Added: 2 years ago
From: emiclassics
Views: 415,750
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,056)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I like ben!

    He looks like myson♥♥

  • I wish they will come to Korea

  • Yes all of them are awesome,They look and sound heavenly .

  • Josh <3

  • there is a rather unhealthy obsession with one or two of libera boys over the rest...and a kind of grieving at their moving on...This kind of obsession with certain boys in choirs led to what became known as the 'Castrata' in past times....the castration of talented young boys to preserve the adolescent voice. it was widely practiced in italy and the vatican, much to their shame. think its a lot healthier that tom n Josh moved on!!!!!

  • @paulwhitehead123 *Castrati Thus, we don't repeat history

  • I wish they will come to Bangkok

    this song is touching my soul , feel lonely and sad and power

  • holy crap! josh chills josh! dang he still gives me chills! (that good kind you get when you hear certain music) wow..that voice, those eyes, that..everything. Ive got to meet him!

  • wow!! I love ben's voice!! :DD

  • Powerful music... words will never describe...

  • Comment removed

  • I love that, geat in all !

  • Comment removed

  • the 29 dislikes were mis-clicked - it has to be... i want to believe so... or some people need to see the E.N.T. doctor... ASAP!

  • @JMD20100 LOL who is JUSTIN BIEBER?

  • Comment removed

  • Who earth are the 28 people who disliked this?? - How could anyone dislike it - it's beautiful..

  • OMG, I just heard it, Josh is also singing when Ben is, very softly, you can see it in the video at 1.13-1.14 and if you listen really good you can hear it to.someone asked about that in the making of video but he's right, Josh sings in the chorus with Ben

  • i would create thousand acounts so that i could like this over and over

  • lol i was trying to relax but im like OMG he's cute!

  • I wish they cameto Brazil Too....Love this song...

  • I wish they came to Brazil... =D

  • I recently discoverd Libera and this is absolutly my favorit song. I love Libera's music and they are all great singers who are able to sing eachothers parts but what's wrong with having a favorit singer. I love josh voice cause it's so pure and clear and natural and there's a reason they call him the smile of libera but they are all awesome, still wish I could hear josh live just ones...

  • Chills....that's all I have to say!

  • It's such a same they aren't aible to do this when they grow up anymore :(

  • i miss tom in these boy bands already ....he is soooooo talented and he have a angelic voice ever i heard in my whole life

  • This is wonderful, tenderly sung music. But whenever I listen to Libera on Youtube and plan to write a comment, I'm kind of afraid that it's written above or below some pedophile's... dammit, stupid cliché!!!

  • @FlydraJewel: Do not care, does not matter.

  • LOVE YOU ALL LIBERA SINGERS

    

  • 24 people didn't join in the perfect song of all eternity.

  • @MrGraz38: Meanwhile, there are 28 ignorant ..

  • Josh marry me thanks

  • that kid...holy crap. his eyes make me want to do cannonballs into them. marry me child....you might be a couple years younger tho....ha.

  • This music is like a drug...

  • this kids are very talented! that kind of music must be promoted in society!

  • the best song

  • Justin Bieber no importa comparado con ésto.

  • I love you josh!!!!!!! <3

    I miss you so much.......!

    can't believe you are older than me :')

    i found libera out like a few years ago... but little did i know that im younger than the leading soloists at that time...

    but anyways, josh, tom, liam, sam, joe, ed, ben. I love you all!!

  • Amazing.

  • wow...forgot how good this song is

  • i saw them for the first time at ASAP today,,.. they gave me goose bumps and made me cry...

  • @karlafyae u should see/listen more of their songs... they are indeed amazing.

  • @karlafyae in deed lol ive been tracking them for the last few years i first saw them on the choir comp

  • The Whole CD is awesome!

    Even this song!

    Thamks!

    I discovered Libera in Januwary 11, 2011!

    I love you my angels from heaven!

  • Love mini Ben! There is a 'Nano-Ben' in Libera now xD

  • Wtf? Why have I never heard of these boys before? The note that the second boy who sings hits at 2:35 is stunning. Incredible.

  • OMG who wrote this song?? I want to go to him/her and propose ;-)

  • I agree with u,but the Josh's carisma is something that the others don't have,he just has to stand there and smile.

  • Oh my goodness this song is amazing! One of my favorites! :)

  • Its been amazing watching Josh Liam and Mini Ben grow up! Mini Ben amazes me with his voice! Along with Josh and his voice, not to mention all of their greatly trained facial expressions! What great musicians!!! Love every one of their albums!!!

  • I LOVE THIS GROUP!!!

  • 1000th comment......and i love libera! :)))

  • Mini big Ben!

  • Dang this guy sure knows his Libera^^^

  • Ben is stunning.

  • Bardzo fajny utworek -super to jest .

  • Absolutely beautiful. Great job Josh & Ben (mini-Ben)......lol. Perfect.

  • Omg i love it... *-* nice voice and beautiful kids!

  • Omg i love it... *-* nice voice and beautiful kids!

  • How come some 22 guys didn't like it??

  • @lumKyo They've all been sectioned under the Mental Health Act for being criminally insane!

  • thank U soooo much i love them and if they have a concert in korea, i must go there concert. the voice is wonderful ♥♥♥

  • Libera is so AMAZING

  • Comment removed

  • I dont understand why this video doesnt have more views!! O.O Its AMAZING!! <3

  • Hello,

    I'm a fan of Libera.

    I love the live album released in 2007.

    However, I find it too "perfect" too "studio".

    Wouldn't it be time for a second live album, recorded in autumn, released in the same time as the Christmas album?

    Hoping that my comment resonates with you, I invite you to visit my channel.

    See you soon maybe.

    PJS

  • @captainPJSchannel j'attend moi aussi qu'il puisse sortir un jour un autre album live afin de pouvoir juger au mieux des nouevaux chanteurs

  • it is too beautiful..

  • Surreal.

  • I miss tom...:(

  • My sisters went to see Libera when they came to Chicago on July 31 and Josh was, in fact, with the group! So were Liam, Ben, Sam and Alex. What a pleasant surprise for them! My sisters say that all these boys' voices are now a lovely tenor, and that the older boys sang their own song at the concert. I am so jealous of my sisters for being able to hear that :). They say that Ben's tenor voice is very remarkable, and Josh's tenor sounds a lot like Tom Cully's (look up his "Cashmere" on Youtube) :)

  • angels <3

  • i like it

    

  • woooooooooooooooooow

  • Maravilhoso! Divino!

  • That really did take me to heaven! god i felt as if i could touch the sky!!

  • ... heaven's voices ...indeed ...!

  • Comment removed

  • Kav....I KNOW KAV!! :D

  • Angel voices

    

  • Mini Ben!!!

  • mini ben´s voice is amazing:O

  • Is Josh still in Libera???

  • Honestly, it does close the chapter in a negative way. I would never have had searched up Libera if it wasn't for Josh Madine and Tom Cully.

  • @Instinct1H Then you must be too narrow minded to give other boys a chance or a retard that only looks at cute faces.

    I admit they where both great, but I'd never like Libera without the great songs (credit to Robert Prizeman), their wonderful harmonies (credit to the non-soloists) and their sheer enthusiasm (credit to all). There are new boys coming up all the time and older boys leaving all the time, who benefits from making such a huge deal out of it.

  • You two can twist my words as much as you want too, but I was just making a point that for those of us that have followed Libera for the past 5-7 years, we have been 'bowled' over by the impact that boys like Tom, Josh, Ed, Liam, Mini Ben etc have made in the group. They have took them to a level of popularity never seen before and revolutionised the role of a 'libera' boy. I didn't say anything bad about the current boys, I was just acknowledging what was for me a very noteworthy period

  • @dhelianthus I just discovered Libera very recently and indeed, Josh and Tom where the first ones to catch my eye as being especially talented. They have done a great job, that's true, but as I have been watching and comparing a lot of the older and more recent Libera songs, I see that they have been improving all the time. The 'closing of a chapter' sounds a little negative to me.

    Sorry if I didn't understand you correctly.

  • @MrGraz38 It's okay, I should have said the 'closing of that particular chapter' which personally for me time will prove to be a very special one. Technically you could be right, the songs are getting better. That's down to the director/composer/arranger Robert Prizeman and his team, which thankfully remains the one 'fundemental' constant.

  • @dhelianthus Agreed. It was indeed a golden period and I am not sure we will ever see such a talented grooup of soloists again. Josh had a voice from heaven and Tom worked hard to achieve what he did.

  • @dhelianthus totally agree .. really miss the boys;( still often go back to the older videos.

  • does anyone know who wrote this song? I checked Libera's website and itunes but there's no credit as to who composed this. I'm guessing it's Libera's director Robert Prizeman, but I can't find proof.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I miss the talented and beautiful Tom Cully! Libera for ever!!

  • wow thats....thats.....simply.....­breathtaking...

  • het mooiste jongens koor allertijden , heel relaxing en zalige muziek

  • SIMPLEMENTE ANGELICALES.. LAS MAS DULCES VOCES DE ALICIENTE MELODIAS..

  • my libera favorite song. i looooooooovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvveeee­e snif snif ^^

  • It seems a shame to know that in all there comments spark controversy,,,, and the ego ....

    Rather should sentirce proud to hear angelic voices,,,, sing songs to sing it in particular so I see it ..

  • i usually don't like this kind of music, but when they are singing, it's just SO beautiful! i love their voices and this song! omg!

  • WAIIIIIIIITTTTTTTTT at 2:11, is that ED Day?!?!! OMG I soo miss him! Please tell me if it's him! I havent been seeing him much in recent concerts or videos.. =__=

  • Comment removed

  • Real angels .... O_O

  • common how can you dislike this video! its beautifull!

  • Sure I can agree to that Tom,Josh,Mini Ben and Liam were the ones leading when I started to listen to Libera. But I did back track and found many "old" stars I liked like Liam O´kane and Co. But I think the new members like Stefan, Ralph and Kavana, James and Co are just as great and talented as the old gang. They woulden´t be in Libera otherwise. Ralp and co did an awesome job on Song of Life.

    Libera will always be Libera:D

  • @Lethnion i strongly agree with you

  • Only two great soloist left......I hope the younger boys will follow their path and to those former members your songs and concerts will remain in our hearts god bless and more power LIBERA!

  • I think it's so hu-lari-OUS how people, particularly the American audience, equates good singing talent, to how hot someone looks. I mean...take The Voice. All the judges AND the audience shoudl have their backs turned to all of the contestants as they perform, and only after they've all been judged, can everyone turn around. I think they'd ALL be surprised at who they chose! Actually...it's kinda sad...kida hypocrytical!

  • @dm100971 I'm sorry to tell you that in America we are trained by our entertainment to be as shallow as possible. Our definitions of what is beautiful are not well thought out and we are completely out of touch with who is talented or what talent actually is. If you have a pretty face and can produce sex appeal, that's good enough for most American audiences. It's atrocious!

  • who are the two leads?

  • @LoveYamachan Josh Madine and Ben Philip

  • @LoveYamachan Josh (the darker skinned boy who sings the slightly lower part and starts and ends the song and sings during the i am..parts ) and Tom (lighter skin, shorter hair who sings the slightly higher parts after Josh's beginning part)

  • @4FabBEATLES Actually, its Josh and Ben

  • @13shenmy1 oh, my bad. I mixed up Ben and Tom. It's Josh & Benn doing the solos then. is it  the boy they call "mini Ben" ?

  • @4FabBEATLES YUP! but he's not so 'Mini' anymore!

  • @13shenmy1 wow- 'mini' Ben has grown so much in a few years- he used to be one of the youngest of the group

  • Undoubtedly the best track among the many pearls those little angels.

  • I'd say that only when Liam and Ben will have left Libera, but you are definitely right that Tom's and Josh's retirement have yet left some emptiness that has not been compensated with new upcoming prodigies (although it would be a mistake not to consider all of the members big talents).

  • Time is off of the album "Peace" (as it says above), and in my opinion everything on it is smash hit.. (That said, I think that of every Libera song and CD). Go Libera!

  • Comment removed

  • I saw an angel searching I asked him what are you searching he said some angels jumped out of heaven to sing to the humans and asked me if I knew where they were I said I didnt kno that time but now I kno :) where they are They are in a group called Libera ;D

  • wow ! great .. music , when u hear it .. you'll be relaxing all the time that you heard this song .. and they voices such like an angel .. and give hope , lights and peace who heard that .. a amazing voice of a child ( a little soprano ) ..

    and y justin bieber mentioned to this music ?!! hmmp !! (",)

  • The boys must come to Germany!!! They are so amazing !!!. LIBERA - You are the Best !!! Really !

    MiLu

  • relaxing, beautiful, sweet,  Thank You

  • @meyko05 what kind of ass are you?? I don't even know what to say in response to that ignorant comment

  • @sassychick2002 he/she not worth your comment .. just ignore him =/

  • @meyko05 Your skin color has nothing to do with your voice. That "black one" was selected to be in one of the best boys' choirs I've ever heard, I'm sure he is amazing. I'm a teenage girl in a chamber choir and that's one of the reasons why I love this type of music; it's all about the voice, not about stupid "trends", stereotypes or "techniques". Props to this young boy for singing something other than rap. I'm also of 100% British heritage, so please keep your ignorant comments to yourself.

  • This made me cry.

  • Beautiful! Thank you!

  • marvelous voice.

  • goosebumps 

  • Merci pour le partage !

  • 22 people misunderstood for dis-i-like

  • This is an amazing song. The music and boy's vocals really set the mood but the lyrics are just as amazing.Wow! Music can have such power to move us like this.

  • spare us your ignorance and don't even mention justin bieber in comparison to this category of music. PLEASE.

  • @FMLdoodez who is justin bieber?

  • @zawiebieber thats the spirit ;)

    wait...... "zawieBIEBER"? lol

  • @zawiebieber a wanna be singer

  • I can't believe how much mini-Ben's voice has matured! It's absolutely beautiful. Of course, Josh sounds amazing as ever. This song is def. one of my new Libera favorites! <3

  • @Lacota117 sb

  • @Sunchao0510 Rude Much

    

  • @Lacota117 Just like you.

  • @Sunchao0510 How Was i rude. they are classical singers, hes a pop singer. they are not on the same level. Thats what i meant.I Have nothing against JB.

    But Josh is Still Wayyy Better!!!!

  • For anyone worrying about Josh's leaving - no, he was in in Epsom a few weeks ago, but that doesn't mean he has left forever. It's possible, but durring the concert Liam made a speech saying how some of the older boys were at home studying for big exams. It's be a shame if he was really gone, but it's likely that he'll stay around to help, like Tom does. :)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • this is amazing!!!!!!! GOOD JOB GUYS!

  • hauntingly beautiful

  • I wish people wrote more music like this - lyrics and music. I know we need fun, frivolous music and that's fine but there's something deep and profound about music like this that really makes you consider what is important and touches you right in the soul. It's just awesome.

  • I'm SO SAD ur leaving JOSH!!!

  • @dancergurlluvsya Josh left the group??

  • @LuxuryDigitalAgenci Sadly he's not been included in the latest rehearsal photos so it does seem that way. I wonder if he will help out with sound or stage management like Tom does?

  • I LOVE U JOSH!!!! -3

  • my best libera song

  • josh has grown quite a bit hasn't he? i don't really keep up to date with libera, so the last time ive seen them josh was like, 9 or something :S

  • Josh is awesome than other singers lyk Jonas Brothers and JB

  • Where was Libera's concert last night? So sad to know that Josh is leaving. It's okay, Ben, Sam and the other younger boys are still around. Libera will always be Libera!

  • Josh's retirement from Libera following his non-appearance in last nights concert has officially closed the chapter on libera's 'Golden Era' Thankyou to the 2005-2010 libera boys

  • @dhelianthus The Golden Era of Libera, in my eyes, was 1997-2002, led by Liam, Adam, and Steven.

  • @dhelianthus in truth, Libera will always be golden xD We will all miss Josh :( But there is still Ben and Liam not to mention some promising newcomers (Stefan for example!)

  • @dhelianthus I think you're being a little harsh- sure the 2005-2010 boys were amazing, but they were not the only talented ones out there, the choir is still fantastic as they've demonstrated in all their performances since the "Golden Era" boys have left. New boys are stepping up and singing beautifully, and I'm sure that when they get older people will be saying the same thing about them. Don't get me wrong, I loved Tom, Josh, Ed and the others, but they were not Libera, only a part of it.

  • @ebobone Exactly. I think especially Tom had a awesome voice, but he and the others moved on like they should and I think people who are mourning that as if Libera has died now should ask themselves why a 16 year old boy can handle this better then them.

    Libera is eternal youth and the voices of new talents will continue to improve the magic. Until now, that worked well, as I think that Libera has mostly improved over the years.

  • @dhelianthus I agree! He was one of my favorites! I was "in love" with that kid (in a good way), great voice!

  • HOW ON EARTH CAN YOU COMPARE justin bieber to JOSHUA NATHAN MADINE??? i mean really? what has gotten to people nowadays? are you really comparing that bieber guy to every single guy you can hear singing? GET A LIFE!! SERIOUSLY!!

  • When I listen to these beautiful words, it is so hard on my heart. My partner committed suicide, and I'm crying for three months. Therefore, all comments "nagative" are nonsense. The boys sing beautifully. Do not judge, do not criticize, condemn not

  • josh.. T______T.. where is tom.. the best duet tom and josh.. gimme my tom! ahahha

  • My heart belongs to Libera. Who created thischoir?

  • @helenl2010 Robert Prizeman...

  • @helenl2010 Robert Prizman, I believe.