Gustaw Messar (1/2): "Stein, Stein" - in Yiddish

[LAJARIFKA]

Heartbreaking

[teviah]

Seier a shien kol, un a gur shiene music oich.

Wer is der singer fun dos lied?

[hamadah4]

Haunting and beautiful. Thank you for sharing all these forgotten songs/treaures with us!!!

[teymani]

very touching , i had my wife translate this for me ,my wife speak yidish ,her family sufferd during the war most died there ,i am yemmeni jew , only when you become close to someone who been through the horrors you feel the real pain. not to say that all jew dont share that pain , but it realy hurts you when your love one hurts.

[jurek46pink]

And that's true love.

[evrei909]

Di problem iz az dize idishe lider zainen tzu langzam un keiner hot nisht kein geduld zei heren tzum ende. Zei zoln gezungen veren vi a polka tzu machen zei meer populer!

[Turkenich]

Ich wünsche, dass ich mehr davon verstehen könnte, aber mir fehlen leider das Hebräische und das Polnische, um die Bedeutung völig davon zu begreifen. Und das Lied ist leider auch mir zu langsam.

[albertdiner]

Very interesting. And also the painting of the

rebbe and the yeshiva Bachurim ( Yeshiva boys)

learning.

[barbcard]

Ach, so sad. But also a haunting melody. And I'm beginning to learn about what kspmO1 calls that "fructiferous" cultural collocation.

[dzheger]

Sensitively sung beautiful sad song of an unloved orphan speaking longingly to a tombstone of his mother. "Stone, stone, you were my mother once, with a heart and a soul. By God's punishment I never got to know you..." Thanks J.

[genia106]

Thank you for this and translation and all the others.

[jurek46pink]

Now I understand this haunting tone, penetrating and so true !

[kspm01]

Another lovely example of that fructiferous coexistence of cultures!

[jurek46pink]

To tell you the truth I am now discovering things on my shelves and in my drawers (kitchen cupboard for instance...) that I did not know I had.

Thank you for listenning, Messar's renditions and recordings are rarities and hardly anybody knows him today.