Book Eight...Another Harry Potter Song

[TheCONNORCO]

I didn't think the epilogue was crap...

[24hoursayear]

Charlie?

[Alassieth]

Anyone still looking for a "Book eight" I would recommend I Saw My Lady Weep by Worldmaker on fanfiction net which looks at Harry's life after Deathly Hallows (finished fic) and also Our Obligations by the same author which focuses on the kids (which unfortunately is not finished and hasn't been updated for a while).

[kristinemarcotte]

I wonder if we can get JK Rowling to respond to this like we got Helen Hunt... Just an idea.

[KatetheMotorMouth]

I love going through old videos and seeing songs that you've been listening to for a while. If I wasn't in a public place, I would be belting this, man :P.

[iluvmanugalx]

hagrids dad and hagrids mum ...

donkey and the dragon...

both had babys

i dont want to think of any more

[ExterminateObliviate]

Harry Potter and the Paper Towns would be pretty interesting actually. It could be set in their "8th year", and I think Luna would be Margo...

[StyxAnStones]

Or Harry Potter and Harry Potter and Harry Potter and the Cloning Spell

[BeatrixNemesis]

Sometimes I just start grinning like an idiot because John and Hank exist.

[RoloFilms]

Send this guy a bouquet already! 

[MeghhanTron]

harry potter and the nights who say NI would be amazing.... :D

[theJJcomedycrew]

Thumbs up if Hank should read Rock On by Dray!

[hb2578]

am I the only one to kinda liked the epilogue?

[fairbank95]

I have a 13 chapter book written if anyone wants it, send me an email at j.blast.w@gmail.com

[fairbank95]

Harry Potter in your pants

[rachinapotter]

@fairbank95 I'd like Harry POtter in my pants

[TheQueenSydney]

people who arn't nerdfighters would be so confused at the beginning or very ammused

[LilyTheAnnoyance]

Back in the days when their faces were way too close to the camera. ^^

[merksmirs]

CHAAAARLLLIIIIIIE!

Sorry had to point it out <3

also I am very frustrated because I missed the very short period of time you had to sign up for pottermore and now I can't anymore and I'm frustrated

[james2700james]

Why does he mean by pants

[rachinapotter]

@james2700james nerdy website that'd been hacked.

[briannapast]

<3

[MrNemBooks]

Thus : Pottermore.

[MissPurple222]

Oh my gosh. Sirius Black IS Aragorn. Actually.

[theonewhoreadsalot]

I'm just going to mention that I know when Hank says "I really think there's an unwritten story there" that he means an unwritten Harry Potter related story; but I'm going to point out that, even though it's implied that way, there are, overall, many MANY unwritten stories in this world. I just hope my stories never become part of that category.

[cloebaby97]

The girl at 0:14 says nose ADORABLY.

[ExterminateObliviate]

Harry Potter and The Fault in Our Stars?

Personally, I would reaaaaaaaally like JK to do a series about the Marauders!

[SammyCronin]

@ExterminateObliviate Merlin, that's what I've been hoping for for a really, really long time... She must do that now! I need her to write about Prongs and Lily (she needs a Marauder nickname) for my own mental health. Oh, and Padfoot and Moony, of course, but she can just slaughter Peter (he doesn't deserve a Marauder nickname). Peter killed James and Lily. I loathe him.

[merksmirs]

@ExterminateObliviate I'm sorry I really don't have anything to say about your comment but your username is amazing just had to say it. It connects the two most amazing things ever with each other

[mindofmetaphors]

Harry Potter and the Beatles!

[Soulintune5]

Truth, Voldie needs to have had a kid personally I think it needs to be a girl, she would be so much worse (can you imagine? Voldie's daughter going through puberty, she would be everyone's worst nightmare!) than a boy. :p JK please write book 8

[RandomnessSHQ]

I wanna know what happened to the Dursleys; like that's gotta be a hilarious story xD

[sethwerewolf]

i understand why jk rowling didn't continue after the seventh book, but the epilouge was kind of crap.

[JAMBO4358]

Are My Pants back up yet?

[HariSlate]

@JAMBO4358 Well, My Pants isn't used any more, but I don't think Your Pants are back up.

[rachinapotter]

@HariSlate Your Pants are back up now. The Russian Hackers failed at takng them down all the way. Happy Dance

[jmaster1324]

harry potter and the paper towns really?

[SkullJokeBrook]

Just wait, three more years and you will have Pottermore.

[Master0fspaceandtime]

Hank, thanks for putting up an X-Wing book :D

[the0turtle0is0carl]

for how much money she could make by writhing another book i think it mean and also maybe even a crime not to write more. harry potter had so many untold stories and it was just too amazing to end now.

[AlwaysPotter]

@the0turtle0is0carl i think that may be why she isnt writing them. She never wrote for the money, she wrote because she loved it, the money was just a bonus, As for the untold stories, there will always be untold stories, and you need to know when to stop, She left it at the perfect time, and although if she were to write another, I will be one of the first to start crying of joy, but her decision to keep it at 7 is one to respect, not to challenge. The only JKR is guilty of, is being perfect.

[the0turtle0is0carl]

@AlwaysPotter well said

[mysss29]

Sirius in Middle Earth. He DID find go to some exotic places....

[katlovesbtr]

wow he talks REALLY fast

[ddc32997]

*Voldemort

*love potion

*incapable?

[ddc32997]

But but but

oldemort COULDNT have a son.

Because he was concieved under a ove potion he was incapeable of love.

Even though Bellatrix loved him.

According to JKR that is.

[JAMBO4358]

@ddc32997 He could of had a son. It just wouldn't have had anything to do with love. Unless being conceived under a love potion renders you infertile

[snowpixie15]

@ddc32997 I'm sure he could still have sex....

[natdot2804]

Harry Potter 8: the Tales Left Untold

[pompapartygal]

Hey, this is what fanfictions are for :)

[graybutcolorful]

@pompapartygal I know! Who needs another book, when nerdfightastic people can just write it for them?

[TheGosbubblan]

But the epilouge wasn't crap... and it would so suck if voldemort had a son :P

[TheGosbubblan]

I would siriusly do ANYTHING for a book eight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I would love to hear more about the marauders. Dumbledore/Grindelwald would be awesome but it would feel very weird... And I don't really want to accept that there is a "next generation" because to me Harry is still that little eleven year old boy who lives under the stairs..

But I have always loves the marauders, and snape and lily ofc <3

[3HeartsWereBreaking]

The add at the side is a Harry Potter one!

[ddoglvr96]

hank, this song gave a whole lot of people fanfiction ideas

[Naraic7]

i want book 8!!!!!!!! i know it is not the same thing but hpff (harry potter fan fiction) has heped me deal with there only being 7 short books!

[rainabraina]

This was uploaded on my birthday! (So was Accio Deathly Hallows!)

[123456789robbie]

0:13 i love the way she says "nose"

[Ziphorax]

anybody else think when he says "book eight" it sounds a little bit like "be gay"

love this song though :P

[BenGriffithsReviews]

The guitar sounds like the beginning of the song "Substitute" by The Who. I like it.

[zahir13]

I quite liked the epilogue. Don't know why people hate it. But yeah, I'd love her to tell the story of the next generation--Rose Weasley, Skorpius Malfoy, Albus Potter, etc.

[morganlizzie23]

as nerimon put it. Harry Potter and the Anal Fist...

[potterlife1]

We all want a book 8-582 and maybe even more than that. But that would be over doing Harry and that could turn out bad.

[BenGriffithsReviews]

@potterlife1 Yeah, like Star Wars.

[potterlife1]

@BenGriffithsReviews

exzactly. I use to love starwars and i still do but they overdid it and now i don't like it as much.

[potterlife1]

The epilouge was crap!

[BenGriffithsReviews]

@potterlife1 What, the prequels?

[eretrece]

@potterlife1 Finally someone sees this the way I do. I hated the epilogue from the moment I read it, but my best friend thought it was great. But it was crap! That is definetely my favourite line from the song.

[potterlife1]

@eretrece

It's my favorie line too. Everyone knows Joe could have done way better! Hank is cute.

[browneyednerd112358]

Everyone is entitled to their opinions. And my opinion is that the epilogue is NOT crap. What does Harry want throughout the entire series? A normal life. That's what he gets and frankly, that's what he deserves after all he's been through.

That said, this song is excellent and I would LOVE to read Dumbledore's life story.

[BenGriffithsReviews]

@browneyednerd112358 The epilogue was just a bit too short.

[OffensivePi]

How does Accio Deathly Hallows have over a million views, and this only over two-hundred thousand? Makes no sense.

[imACrAzYinsanePERSON]

What is this shite about the epilouge being really bad? why would it be? It tied up all the lose ends told us that yes those that survived went on to live happy and full lives. What did you hoseatly expect? A cliff hanger? Some hint that there would be another story? And how can anyone but J.K.Rowling say how HER story was supposed to go?Sshe CREATED the world, it's a product of her imagination as such the end could only come from her and only her.

So deal with it.

[TheGummyBearOverLord]

Harry Potter and The Nerdfighters. A book about when Harry took a wron turn and ended up in a class room full of nerds who then proceded to critize and praise him.

[mark4851]

i always did wonder about Hagrids parents

[217982]

hey, at least we have fanfiction.

[ImperialGeorge]

@TheButlerDude

It includes a photo montage, thus is allowed to be longer than 4 minutes.

[DesmondtheRhino]

Harry Potter and the Knights Who Say Ni sounds awesomly epic

[GONEmypurpleflapjack]

@DesmondtheRhino We'd need a lot of shrubberies though. Maybe Nevil could help?

[kellybellymofuckaah]

I am all for the one abou the Knights who say Nee :)

[graybutcolorful]

Hank should write Book Eight! And John can beta it and it shall be put on fanfiction for the world to enjoy!

[BrawlMasterROB]

What is wrong with Charlie's voice at the beginning? Puberty hit him like a brick apparently.

[Diaaakhana]

@BrawlMasterROB He was trying to speak with an american accent, and his microphone was crap back then.

[jalfcat]

there defo should b a book 8 and also I want J.K Rowl;ing to say that she lied when she killed off Snape and Fred and Dobby and Hedwig coz we all know she did :)

[bbmonkey14]

I actually really liked the epilogue.....

[Meahacha]

Just signed up for Pottermore, listening to this. Seems appropriate.

[Stevie4924]

xDD Sirius is in middle earth?

[fortheluvofme]

Omg was that charlie?

[devonriley415]

LOL!!!!

"I think that there's probably a good chance that Dumbledore and Grindelwald batted lefty!"

[funnypets456]

i want j. k . rowling to say that the epilouge was crap cuz we all know it was crap....lolz priceless

[dinaarumor]

Harry Potter and the Knights who says Ni, that's a book I definitely would read!!

[26Staples]

@dinaarumor Harry Potter and The Knights Who Until Recently Said Ni :P

[dinaarumor]

@26Staples Ah, my humblest apology. But I'm sure both books would be worth reading ;)

[ThatSpanishKid]

Me too man, me too.

[JackDukes1993]

Same chords as New Math by Bo burnham?? :P

[kovyiscool]

@JackDukes1993 haha you have some keen ears

[24MandaPanda96]

Harry Potter and the Knights who say "Ni" =D

[bfkennedy]

Sirius isn't in middle earth! He's in Narnia :3

[36gregross]

Jk Rowling did write a harry potter prequel about James Potters adventure with Sirius black there's a wikipedia link and page

[JAMBO4358]

@36gregross Could you please please please reply with a link!?!?!?! Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeease

[MarlonOwnsYourCake]

Cried. Also. I think snape is harry's real dad.

[MattChurch42690]

@MarlonOwnsYourCake But he looks just like James. 3:

[MattChurch42690]

@MarlonOwnsYourCake That would be epic as fuck though. :)

[musickanna]

>.< ok I'll do it Thumbs up if your watching this after you've seen the final Harry Potter movie. (I usually don't like those but I couldn't help my self.)

[ALLCAPSfan98726]

@musickanna I listened to this while waiting to watch it at midnight.

[retc]

BEST. SONG. EVER!!!!!!!!!!

[pinkheartsunglasses]

0:02 Was that Charlie??

[sheleftmalfoy]

@pinkheartsunglasses Charlie made a video singing Accio deathly hallows dressed as Hank.

[pinkheartsunglasses]

@sheleftmalfoy Haha thanks! Just watched it

[SilverEstuary]

i LOVED the epilogue...

[I4gotmyMANTRA]

What I *really* want is for her to publish a book of short stories about the Potterverse.

Maybe one about Godric Gryffindoor, Salazar Slytherine, Rowena Ravenclaw and Helga Hufflepuff. And definitely one about Dumbledore and Grindewald. Maybe a short-but-adorable one about Hogwarts when Harry's kids are there.

[ThePockyMonster]

@I4gotmyMANTRA one about the Marauders and Lily at Hogwarts also!

[SatanisaBeaverShark]

@I4gotmyMANTRA She could tell us how the Marauders met, discovered that Remus is a werewolf, and became animagi. That would be awesome.

[mysss29]

@I4gotmyMANTRA YES. Short stories would be awesome at this stage.

[13cmwright99]

i want a book 9 too...and maybe 14?

[MattChurch42690]

@13cmwright99 41* :D

[ninjabanana29]

Anyone else wallowing in their post Potter depression by listening to songs about Harry Potter and watching A Very Potter Musical? :x

[graybutcolorful]

@ninjabanana29 it's the first thing i did after I got done crying

[iwontbenormal]

@ninjabanana29 OMG I'm still doing the exact same thing! My life is over.

[Bosoxgalaxy]

@ninjabanana29 AAAAH! I Accidently clicked the thumbs down!!! Sorry!

[ninjabanana29]

@Bosoxgalaxy Haha, it's cool. I do that all the time.

[AnnieReadsGood]

@ninjabanana29 Always... :')

[OffensivePi]

@ninjabanana29 That is EXACTLY how I spend my days.

[gotwitbeyondmeasure]

I don't want a book eight, I NEED a book eight.

[effeweewetoob]

"And I think Sirius is in Middle-earth." You have no idea how much this puts me at peace with Sirius's death. Not only does the thought just make me giggle incessantly, it also gives me solace about death of my second favorite character.

[SpyViolette]

The epilogue WAS crap.

[MattChurch42690]

@SpyViolette Personally I wouldn't call it crap...I wouldn't say it's as great as I wished it were though.

[xadele95]

@24nerdfighter I've read that online too but JK Rowling has never said that in an interview, and those rumours have been out for ages. I really wouldn't get your hopes up unless she confirms that, which I doubt.

[prauper358]

@24nerdfighter I DONT LIKE LIES...IS THIS TRUE???

[24nerdfighter]

@prauper358

My local news said it was true and they said jkr said so too

[prauper358]

@24nerdfighter is there a youtube video for her saying that this is true?? if there is would you please give me the name

[24nerdfighter]

@prauper358

Probably somewhere but idk where

[randomeese]

@24nerdfighter right..conviently on the day the world is suppose to end?

[24nerdfighter]

@randomeese

I googled it. And thats what it said. If you dont believe me google it yourself.

[randomeese]

@24nerdfighter you can't trust everything you find on the internet. with that logic i could tell you to google 'jk rowling is dead' and if you find at least one page that says it's true, then it's true. it's probably just a rumour, i didn't see anything on her offical site, and it would say something there.

[K8LEN]

If Voldemort had a son... oh shit.

[alislycat]

Harry Potter and the Nerd Fighters. That one. YES.

[nicsnort]

Dear Hank,

That is what Fanfiction is for: explaning everything the author doesn't...and also making pairings that never should happen (ex. Snape/Trelawney or anything that includes Harry's non-existint twin Sister).

From,

Agrees but can settle

[nslprojectify]

It should be a collection of short stories covering all those topics. Which would fit well with harry potter and the forgotten tales

[ledra4321]

Harry Potter and the Nerdfighters? I take that as a challenge.

It was a dark and story night when a baby named Tom Riddle was left on the steps of the Evil Baby Orphanage...

[prauper358]

And Hank I think a (serious) title for book eight would be Harry Potter and the Forgotton Tales

[prauper358]

Who would be the mother of He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named's son...Dolores Umbridge??? haha

[oddrey52]

@prauper358 *shudder*

[prauper358]

@oddrey52 NO SERIOUSLY!!! or he could have had an affair with Narcissa

[teamorangeapple]

@prauper358 Totally Bellatrix. Voldy was drunk one night and.... 

[MattChurch42690]

@prauper358 No...but that's his daughter's name. Lol jk.

[artfanatsymanic]

lol I think Serius Black in in Middle Earth! he's not dead lol! I'd buy into that. anything to have him back! btw I looove all the nerdy referneces : ) but it is nerd fighters after all

[halfbloodprincess67]

Haha sirius went to middle earth

[egirleagle]

does pottermore coun't as book 8????

[sacar96]

i liked the epilogue :(

[elanor2006]

@sacar96 me too i liked the epilogue, i don't understand why everyone is so upset about it.

[sacar96]

@elanor2006 its probably just bitter harry/hermione shippers :P jk

[elanor2006]

@sacar96 yeah, probably :))

[testingmywings]

I know it probably won't be, but I really really wish the Pottermore announcement would be a book 8. We shall know what it is in 2 days!!!

[StarKidKlein]

I was reading a interview of team starkid and they said that they wanted to make a third HP musical Soooooo it's not over yet.....

[aaauut]

@StarKidKlein How are they gonna do that? Haven't any of them graduated yet? Darren Criss is probably too busy with Glee as well... :(

[PUPPYLUVE44]

@aaauut There is an interview with Starkid Productions where they talk about their plan to make the threequel. just look it up. And Many of them had graduated before they did the first one. (Matt and Nick Lang had) They didnt all have to be in school to do it.

[StarKidKlein]

Not just a book eight but a A Very Potter Threequel

[puppyluveromg]

im still waiting for the announcement...

[Stixer111]

We will always have crappy fan-fictions to look forward to.... no, it's not the same is it? :(

[AcaaraUchiha101]

No. Sirius is in Narnia.

Orin one of the countless other worlds in the wood between the worlds.

[graybutcolorful]

I think this is my favorite Hank Harry Potter song. Or the newest one, with the books.

[xSobhan]

Is he knocking on his guitar throughout the song?

[ALLCAPSfan98726]

When I first started watching you guys videos I was watching them with my sister(Who is a nerdfighter)And I wanted to watch this one because in the thumpnail it had a star wars book and I was a big star wars fan.But she said no and I now I know why.

[Nerdfighterian]

Hank, I request permission to send these songs (the Harry Potter Songs) to J.K. Rowling. Personally, I believe, she must hear these. Who knows it may trigger some inspiration for book 8.

[iwanttomakeplaylists]

97 people liked the epilogue :D

[vloggingstudents]

did anyone see charlie at the beginning of the video

[ALLCAPSfan98726]

@vloggingstudents I did!

[HunniBee23]

I wonder if JKR has seen AVPM/S....if so a book about a certain talking lion headmaster and a half-elf boy who cannot use the potty and who ends up on mars would be brilliant! :)

[blackbutterfly013]

gasp!! you didn't put lauren from 5AG in that montage!!! :P

[tayvlogz]

the epilogue really was crap, so disappointing, she claims she wrote it when she was writing the sorcerers stone but who knows?