You are the one who is laying Mr. May Allah forgive you!! Muslim scientists’ contribution is tremendous. Read your history before you open your mouth on a talk show. Don’t miss inform people, Allah doesn’t like this. … Al-Fitnah is worse than killing…(Al-Quran 2:217)
Mr. Nisar is talking of today's world. He might not be 10% right in his argumentation, but this video totally misrepresents his opinions, and is not a suitable answer in my opinion. Muslim scientists, or rather arabic and persian scientists were great, but then they lost interest, and now you've got nothing. NOW matters, and then is from what we should learn. That is what Mr. Nisar is trying to communicate to us in his rather stern manner.
@wanttowatch80 u r right by the way, NOW is what matters, thts true. but Hassan Nisar mostly thinks tht Muslims of the past have also done nothing. thts not da case. u cannot take few examples among a community ad generalize it to describe it as a whole.
@MrUmairmazhar indeed it so, but it has been like this for ages. I believe Mr. Nisar is still 90% right and presents his arguments in a very logical manner. I do admire him, but I also try to stay subjective in what I say, and he is but human, so I can differ with him when he's wrong. 1. when he talks of people of the past, he talks about political games.2. When he talks of ingenious minds, he talks of today. I don't believe he denies the ingenious minds of the past, but that is just my opinion
@wanttowatch80 he mentioned we gave nothing to the world and he is absolutely wrong, Muslims provided base for modern inventions and modern world, We can say all things in a very instructive manner rather than in a tone where he is insulting muslims and history of muslims. Iqbal did it he tried to awake his nation by memorizing them their glorious past whereas hasan nisar is saying we did nothing for mankind and we did nothing for building a modern world
If the theory only prooves the inventions of the camera than the original theory of "live telecast" was in the times of "Mahabharat Times" more than 3000 yrs back (900 BC-1200 BC). When Dhritrashtra was being told the details of the war in his room by someone sitting with him (since Dhritrashtra was a blind man).
[[When Dhritrashtra was being told the details of the war in his room by someone sitting with him]]
thts not how science works dear, to prove the theory u do not have to mentioned stories, u have to demonstrate it to the modern world, then only scientists would accept, otherwise the stories u r talking about would always be considered as myths and legend, as everything is possible in myths.
But whatever u find in Mahabharat does not reach us in any way, as no Hindu could show us inventions such as telephones, broadcast systems etc. in the era of 500 CE to “when these things were actually discovered or invented”
@originaldigger- All above theories were discussed in the ancient Indian litretures in details.
I am not belittling the importance of the above Islamic scholers but just mentioning that what they have thought by medival age had already been thought & may be successfully implemented too in the far ancient India.
Many call him the "father of sergery". infact whole world i repeat whole world calls Charak (300 AD from Gupt dynesty) the Father of sergery, indeed from India.
But the so called scientific inventions in the Mahabharat times, did not pass down to the present age, otherwise we would have been faaaaaaaaar ahead in science today than v r. the ideo tht ancient ppl in pharoanic times and Mahabharat times had more knowledge also indicates tht there had been a clean sweep out of civilizations, otherwise the knowledge would have reached us about how pyramids of Giza were built.
, to prove the theory u do not have to mentioned stories, u have to demonstrate it to the modern world, then only scientists would accept, otherwise the stories u r talking about would always be considered as myths and legend, as everything is possible in myths. But whatever u find in Mahabharat does not reach us in any way, as no Hindu could show us inventions such as telephones, broadcast systems etc. in the era of 500 CE to “when these things were actually discovered or invented”
Furthermore, those things mentioned in Hindu scriptures r disputed by Hindu intellectuals themselves, and they themselves say tht these narrations r not proven through historical records.
Abu qasim is not the father of surgery----bt an indian surgeon Sushruta(present at around 800 BC) (SEARCH WIKI) is father of surgery.it was first of his works which were translated into arabic language during the Abbasid Caliphate (750 AD).
read the comments in replied to "UXIDEEP" and "thegreatashutosh"
[[But the First surgery Took place.Before That]]
it may have. Abu Al Qassim is known as the father of MODERN surgery dear.
[[And abt the Flying machine]]
scientists of today respect Einstein more even tough they know things which even Einstein did not know. Why? Coz he was da first 1 to do research on the things he discovered, and tht too with limited resources.
The point of this video is not to make competitions and show tht other civilizations did nothing. But the point is, to refute tht idea tht Muslims of the past have contributed nothing to modern science.
There was a time, when Greeks were ahead in science, maybe there was a time when Indians were, Egyptians were, some knowledge was passed down, some was not. And similarly a time came when were ahead in science, and now they’re not coz they have gone away from their religious scriptures, and they reason why the Westerners r ahead today is tht they too have gone away from their religious scriptures.
@nairrajarun Sorry brother but you are unable to understand Hassan Nisar at all. Muslims has given nothing to this world in 500 years. (Please check and give any inventions which WORLD is using today). Hasan Nisar said @0:07 "sadian hogaeen hain ..... " he never said that Muslims hasn't contributed at all but he was saying that for a very long time Muslims hasn't contributed towards science in such a manner that today world is benefiting from their invention.
Muslims contribution to the world is Killing, Jihad, and Islamic Terrorism.
Muslims never invented anything they copied or stole ancient science and mathmatics from Hindus and but damb Europeans thought some of it came from Arabs who traded with Indians and Europeans so tranfer from Indians to European took place place through Arabs but Arabs never invented anything.
Than came Islam and Arabs were only interested in spreading Islam by Killing millions of people in India and Europe.
i think what matters most is present, dont just feel too proud of the past. the west have best brain in today world
therajoou 3 months ago
but all bad discussions what are you today look your self don't look yours past
sanjaybsr 4 months ago
You are the one who is laying Mr. May Allah forgive you!! Muslim scientists’ contribution is tremendous. Read your history before you open your mouth on a talk show. Don’t miss inform people, Allah doesn’t like this. … Al-Fitnah is worse than killing…(Al-Quran 2:217)
ik2019 5 months ago
name of the movie please?
hueblue1 5 months ago
@hueblue1
i think 1000 inventions
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
thek hi to keh raha tha hasan nisar
agar atom bomb chaley ga to 10000000 people marain gey is chiz par hum hero hain
by killing the people in ratio % 1000000 or ther is one of u got any courage to press the butten to kill 100000 people in seconds
rainandmemories 5 months ago
@rainandmemories
tht is also a point to taken into consideration, but the point im discussing here, is tht Muslims of the past have achieved many things.
keeping tht in mind, we also accept tht today we r backward coz of our laziness
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
Mr. Nisar is talking of today's world. He might not be 10% right in his argumentation, but this video totally misrepresents his opinions, and is not a suitable answer in my opinion. Muslim scientists, or rather arabic and persian scientists were great, but then they lost interest, and now you've got nothing. NOW matters, and then is from what we should learn. That is what Mr. Nisar is trying to communicate to us in his rather stern manner.
wanttowatch80 5 months ago
@wanttowatch80 u r right by the way, NOW is what matters, thts true. but Hassan Nisar mostly thinks tht Muslims of the past have also done nothing. thts not da case. u cannot take few examples among a community ad generalize it to describe it as a whole.
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@wanttowatch80
so in the past, what was dominant in us was prosperity i think, but today u may say tht decline is more dominant
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@MrUmairmazhar indeed it so, but it has been like this for ages. I believe Mr. Nisar is still 90% right and presents his arguments in a very logical manner. I do admire him, but I also try to stay subjective in what I say, and he is but human, so I can differ with him when he's wrong. 1. when he talks of people of the past, he talks about political games.2. When he talks of ingenious minds, he talks of today. I don't believe he denies the ingenious minds of the past, but that is just my opinion
wanttowatch80 5 months ago
@wanttowatch80 he mentioned we gave nothing to the world and he is absolutely wrong, Muslims provided base for modern inventions and modern world, We can say all things in a very instructive manner rather than in a tone where he is insulting muslims and history of muslims. Iqbal did it he tried to awake his nation by memorizing them their glorious past whereas hasan nisar is saying we did nothing for mankind and we did nothing for building a modern world
TheButshikan 5 months ago
If the theory only prooves the inventions of the camera than the original theory of "live telecast" was in the times of "Mahabharat Times" more than 3000 yrs back (900 BC-1200 BC). When Dhritrashtra was being told the details of the war in his room by someone sitting with him (since Dhritrashtra was a blind man).
UKXIDEEP 5 months ago
@UKXIDEEP
[[When Dhritrashtra was being told the details of the war in his room by someone sitting with him]]
thts not how science works dear, to prove the theory u do not have to mentioned stories, u have to demonstrate it to the modern world, then only scientists would accept, otherwise the stories u r talking about would always be considered as myths and legend, as everything is possible in myths.
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@UKXIDEEP
But whatever u find in Mahabharat does not reach us in any way, as no Hindu could show us inventions such as telephones, broadcast systems etc. in the era of 500 CE to “when these things were actually discovered or invented”
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
fyi Hassan Nisar never rejected the scientific contributions of Muslim Civilization, he just says that Rulers had enslaved masses!
usamax007 5 months ago
Exaggeration in a most vulgar way!
dhawan56 6 months ago
@dhawan56
yeah, now it seems exageration, obviously. wht do ya hav 2 say abt this exageration watch?v=1nzdkaDqv1Y
MrUmairmazhar 6 months ago
Still not comparable !
originaldigger 6 months ago
@originaldigger- All above theories were discussed in the ancient Indian litretures in details.
I am not belittling the importance of the above Islamic scholers but just mentioning that what they have thought by medival age had already been thought & may be successfully implemented too in the far ancient India.
Many call him the "father of sergery". infact whole world i repeat whole world calls Charak (300 AD from Gupt dynesty) the Father of sergery, indeed from India.
UKXIDEEP 5 months ago
@UKXIDEEP
But the so called scientific inventions in the Mahabharat times, did not pass down to the present age, otherwise we would have been faaaaaaaaar ahead in science today than v r. the ideo tht ancient ppl in pharoanic times and Mahabharat times had more knowledge also indicates tht there had been a clean sweep out of civilizations, otherwise the knowledge would have reached us about how pyramids of Giza were built.
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@UKXIDEEP
, to prove the theory u do not have to mentioned stories, u have to demonstrate it to the modern world, then only scientists would accept, otherwise the stories u r talking about would always be considered as myths and legend, as everything is possible in myths. But whatever u find in Mahabharat does not reach us in any way, as no Hindu could show us inventions such as telephones, broadcast systems etc. in the era of 500 CE to “when these things were actually discovered or invented”
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@UKXIDEEP
Furthermore, those things mentioned in Hindu scriptures r disputed by Hindu intellectuals themselves, and they themselves say tht these narrations r not proven through historical records.
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
Abu qasim is not the father of surgery----bt an indian surgeon Sushruta(present at around 800 BC) (SEARCH WIKI) is father of surgery.it was first of his works which were translated into arabic language during the Abbasid Caliphate (750 AD).
thegreatashutosh 6 months ago
@thegreatashutosh
Sushutra may have done discoveries in surgery.
Abu Al Qassim is known as the “Father of MODERN surgery”
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@MrUmairmazhar yeah u r right bro!
thegreatashutosh 5 months ago
Brother If i tell u that.many things In this video is irrelevant.
Like The 1 abt flight and other is Abt the Surgeon
IF U Do Sum detail research On them U will Understand.
Abu al-Qasim Khalaf ibn al-Abbas Al-Zahrawi Was A GR8 surgeon at the Medival time.But the First surgery Took place.Before That.
And abt the Flying machine
search for the Name "Shivkar Bapuji Talpade"
And then search From were he Got the Idea Of Making Unmanned air Plane.
IF U CAN...Aceept it reject it.its ur choice :)
nairrajarun 6 months ago
@nairrajarun
read the comments in replied to "UXIDEEP" and "thegreatashutosh"
[[But the First surgery Took place.Before That]]
it may have. Abu Al Qassim is known as the father of MODERN surgery dear.
[[And abt the Flying machine]]
scientists of today respect Einstein more even tough they know things which even Einstein did not know. Why? Coz he was da first 1 to do research on the things he discovered, and tht too with limited resources.
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@nairrajarun
Think u got my point.
The point of this video is not to make competitions and show tht other civilizations did nothing. But the point is, to refute tht idea tht Muslims of the past have contributed nothing to modern science.
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@nairrajarun
There was a time, when Greeks were ahead in science, maybe there was a time when Indians were, Egyptians were, some knowledge was passed down, some was not. And similarly a time came when were ahead in science, and now they’re not coz they have gone away from their religious scriptures, and they reason why the Westerners r ahead today is tht they too have gone away from their religious scriptures.
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@nairrajarun Sorry brother but you are unable to understand Hassan Nisar at all. Muslims has given nothing to this world in 500 years. (Please check and give any inventions which WORLD is using today). Hasan Nisar said @0:07 "sadian hogaeen hain ..... " he never said that Muslims hasn't contributed at all but he was saying that for a very long time Muslims hasn't contributed towards science in such a manner that today world is benefiting from their invention.
questsal 2 months ago
Muslims contribution to the world is Killing, Jihad, and Islamic Terrorism.
Muslims never invented anything they copied or stole ancient science and mathmatics from Hindus and but damb Europeans thought some of it came from Arabs who traded with Indians and Europeans so tranfer from Indians to European took place place through Arabs but Arabs never invented anything.
Than came Islam and Arabs were only interested in spreading Islam by Killing millions of people in India and Europe.
htgajjar 6 months ago
@htgajjar
[[stole ancient science and mathmatics from Hindus]]
find nywhere tht Hindus as a whole were more advanced in science b4 Arabs?
1 or 2 here n there, but plz don’t generalize.
[[Killing millions of people in India and Europe]]
how on earth they left out ur forefathers alive, from whose lineage u r born.
As though ancient India never has battles or fights. Ever read Mahabharat???
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago
@htgajjar
My dear, don’t blame any religion 4 what the ppl of tht religion do. The authority is with the scriptures of the religion.
MrUmairmazhar 5 months ago