I'm sure there are live recordings of her singing this song without the laughter, but this is the studio recording she decided to put on Countless Times. i think it's great, it shows she doesn't take herself too seriously
hahaha. i find all this god-hating to be funny. if it reminds someone of god, doesn't that mean that their god is dead anyways?... i can relate to that feeling when i was in 6th grade and realized that i no longer believed any of what my catholic upbringing and schooling had taught me. i didn't know where to go. i knew i was still a student, but of whom i did not know and basically began to open myself up to learn from everyone, from all experiences and both the joy and pain of life
We supported Diane at a show in our hometown, what can I say? We were lucky to see her, talk with her, and this song had a profound effect on me. It became an instant favourite song, and I worked out how to play it as soon as I got home. I'm happy to say she's a very nice person too, and I hope to see her again. Matt.
I'm going with the more literal interpretation. A very close mentor has died and all the knowledge seems completely lost and nothing seems worth learning but everything that could have been.
My voice teacher passed away the other night and we were extremely close. I haven't heard this song in years but it was the first to come into my head.
god died and somehow left us.. and yet he lives through and teaches us silently. Life is silent dead and life and it somehow always teaches it with every passing moment/phase.
"God" was never alive in the first place. God is a myth, a figment of man's imagination. Don't defile a real human achievement like the creation of great art with your superstitious nonsense.
while i dont think diane cluck is a christian, she does talk about some type of god (oh lord, nothing but god, nothing but god in the way of itself)-- and we will all have our different interpretations of that. how do you know this guy isn't talking about diane clucks concept of god, too? i understand your intolerance of christianity, but you should have some more respect.
I'm sure there are live recordings of her singing this song without the laughter, but this is the studio recording she decided to put on Countless Times. i think it's great, it shows she doesn't take herself too seriously
frinkianz 1 year ago
@frinkianz i love the laughter in this record - it always makes me smile.
mollythesard 10 months ago
@frinkianz Diane Cluck's 2005 album Countless Times is available on CD or digitally, directly from Diane:
download.dianecluck.info/album/countless-times
There are two versions of this song on the album, sort of.
Thanks for supporting the artist!
lasteverdotorg 2 months ago
Is there a version without her laughing.
stot3 1 year ago
hahaha. i find all this god-hating to be funny. if it reminds someone of god, doesn't that mean that their god is dead anyways?... i can relate to that feeling when i was in 6th grade and realized that i no longer believed any of what my catholic upbringing and schooling had taught me. i didn't know where to go. i knew i was still a student, but of whom i did not know and basically began to open myself up to learn from everyone, from all experiences and both the joy and pain of life
gaiablue24 1 year ago
We supported Diane at a show in our hometown, what can I say? We were lucky to see her, talk with her, and this song had a profound effect on me. It became an instant favourite song, and I worked out how to play it as soon as I got home. I'm happy to say she's a very nice person too, and I hope to see her again. Matt.
AprilMaybeMay 1 year ago
I'm going with the more literal interpretation. A very close mentor has died and all the knowledge seems completely lost and nothing seems worth learning but everything that could have been.
My voice teacher passed away the other night and we were extremely close. I haven't heard this song in years but it was the first to come into my head.
thisisryanblood 2 years ago 4
laura marlings hero,i think she and diane are mine,two beutiful artists.
x
dundeejen 3 years ago
such a beautiful song...
MmaktuBb 3 years ago 2
wow, fantastic, second perhaps only to the live version of peach plum pear by joanna newsom in the amazing stakes!
rcos1 3 years ago
this song makes me think of god.
god died and somehow left us.. and yet he lives through and teaches us silently. Life is silent dead and life and it somehow always teaches it with every passing moment/phase.
mhm!!
watchinggmind 3 years ago
fuck off dick head, with your god bull shit. if diane read that she would prbably vomit all over you
mutdogg 3 years ago
Comment removed
watchinggmind 3 years ago
i seriously doubt she had that in mind when she wrote this.
Music is expression, not praise for imaginary friends.
HeartsBlast 3 years ago
"God" was never alive in the first place. God is a myth, a figment of man's imagination. Don't defile a real human achievement like the creation of great art with your superstitious nonsense.
jc2342 3 years ago 6
@jc2342 You're quite ignorant.
whathelephant1251 1 year ago
while i dont think diane cluck is a christian, she does talk about some type of god (oh lord, nothing but god, nothing but god in the way of itself)-- and we will all have our different interpretations of that. how do you know this guy isn't talking about diane clucks concept of god, too? i understand your intolerance of christianity, but you should have some more respect.
stevensartifacts 2 years ago 13
Wise word Stevens.
redArlo 2 years ago
i want to know if it even possible to dislike her, I seriously am so in love. all her songs, all of herrr.
watchinggmind 3 years ago
i just love this song
daniellalalala 3 years ago
I love Ms. Cluck.
pgblues 3 years ago
adrian!
susannnna 3 years ago
susannnnnnnnnnnnnnnnna!! hello dear
frinkianz 3 years ago
this is one of my favorite songs of all time, i'd say. So beautiful.
kokiriforest 4 years ago
Read my mind exactly kokiri.
gcgx 4 years ago
the song is so beatiful that the video is great as it is. it has nice pictures.
NoSmetana 4 years ago
Thank you soo much.
NICC234 4 years ago
I love this song! I've been hoping someone would make some kind of video for it! Thanks!
VintagePulp 4 years ago