I have to join in with a response as well. I loved the winning video. Very clever, well produced and edited. I wish I was film student with piles of fancy gear. Having said that, the video should have been dropped from consideration. It wasn't his best windmill... it was his best short subject film.
Your teacher asks you to write an essay on your summer vacation and you chime in with Dad's story of climbing K2 in 1990. Great adventure but hardly sticking to task assigned.
Exactly. If I had known the criteria for winning was for the best "clever", "funny", Master Editid Short Film, i never would have joined in. This had Nothing to do with Good WINDMILLS. Hello? I suppose it was presumptuous to think this was about doing the best impersonation.
This contest is a fucking joke. masonwoodward should of been first place out of all the winners not some edited short film bullshit with audio overdubbed, thats not the spirit of the who. i cut my thumb open doing windmills for this eat my shit
Dude, your video was 45 seconds so you can't complain of not winning...but I agree about that the runners up were pretty badly picked. But they were picked by people from companies n stuff and not musicians, so that's the way the cookie crumbled.
MrModDog ... Yeah, that sounds right. Upload to account, then post a video response to this page and select your video. You should be good to go in that sense. Then, make sure you fill out the form ... and that's where my question comes in ... I'm wondering if anyone got an e-mail confirmation ...
Ok, I upped my vid to my account first to see the quality was alright, then i went to post a response to this vid and I selected my vid. Is that ok, or do I need to upload the vid WHEN I GO TO POST A RESPONSE. Has anyone reponded with a vid they'd already uploaded and been succesful in seeing it go up here? Thanks
Sure Bill Canell does a good Job but mrsainty goes the whole way. I saw the Who-Dunnit show where he smashed the strat. It was awesome. If anyone deserves to win a guitar it's him!!!!
Check out BILL CANELL aka BC67WHO of Who's Next Tribute band. He is the real deal and does this for real. He is the best I have seen. You must see them live!
keith singing back up - awesome !!!!
GreenhouseEffectGE 5 months ago
Keith = God Forever
Roger = Jon Bon Jovi
Amsterdam74yeah 1 year ago
Fuck they were good!
lofi73 1 year ago
Is Pete doing a little homage to Ian Anderson (who was also on the bill) at 1:56?
bellhorn2b 1 year ago 4
@bellhorn2b I don't know much about Jethro Tull - how is that a homage? is that a move ian anderson does? lol
thebigguyconnor 1 year ago
There is a DVD (bootleg) available. I also read it may get an official release soon.
babyshambler 1 year ago
Absolutely stunning performance and quality! Thanks!
ccrholland 1 year ago
hey this one has a far better quality than the one I own!! is this an officiale release?
epimetero 2 years ago
Yeah...I'd love to have a DVD of this concert!
BritIronRebel 2 years ago
Moon's triplets in between the beat toward the end make all the difference, and help set this band apart.
MrGb1965 2 years ago 2
If I could be anyone else, It would be Pete Townshend.
twoboots4you 2 years ago
GREAT SONG!
DKVillain 2 years ago
was this in boston or somewhere else in massachusetts?
rajbeast 2 years ago
Tanglewood, I understand. Tull warmed up.
MrGb1965 2 years ago
yea they performed a lot of shows in tanglewood in 1970
rajbeast 2 years ago
what do u mean by "tull warmed up"? did jethro tull open for the who?
rajbeast 2 years ago 2
Yes. Pete mentions it in his introduction to "Water", and also says that in the previous year Jefferson Airplane warmed up for them.
MrGb1965 2 years ago
oh nice
rajbeast 2 years ago
were do we find out who all the winners r?
firegeek22 2 years ago
type in the who on google and go on there website
TwoEarsWet 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Mine won. Fuck the judges.
MaxSeidelman 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Total bullshit, mine should have won. No one's ever seen an actual slow motion windmill at 300-600 fps before.
MaxSeidelman 2 years ago
I have to join in with a response as well. I loved the winning video. Very clever, well produced and edited. I wish I was film student with piles of fancy gear. Having said that, the video should have been dropped from consideration. It wasn't his best windmill... it was his best short subject film.
Your teacher asks you to write an essay on your summer vacation and you chime in with Dad's story of climbing K2 in 1990. Great adventure but hardly sticking to task assigned.
What a crock!
swendish 2 years ago 3
Which video was it?
MaxSeidelman 2 years ago
Where is the winner runner-up list?
billdoon111 2 years ago
Exactly. If I had known the criteria for winning was for the best "clever", "funny", Master Editid Short Film, i never would have joined in. This had Nothing to do with Good WINDMILLS. Hello? I suppose it was presumptuous to think this was about doing the best impersonation.
pauljnort 2 years ago 6
why is the grand prize a guitar if its a contest for the best film maker? not musicians?
longliveWHO515 2 years ago
This contest is a fucking joke. masonwoodward should of been first place out of all the winners not some edited short film bullshit with audio overdubbed, thats not the spirit of the who. i cut my thumb open doing windmills for this eat my shit
longliveWHO515 2 years ago
Dude, your video was 45 seconds so you can't complain of not winning...but I agree about that the runners up were pretty badly picked. But they were picked by people from companies n stuff and not musicians, so that's the way the cookie crumbled.
aai005 2 years ago
Comment removed
pauljnort 2 years ago
Mmmmm cookies...
longliveWHO515 2 years ago
sadly, they must have gotten swamped with entries at the end, I dont believe that I will get entered for this one :(
TheDeathmade 2 years ago
I'm quite dissapointed :/ I uploaded my attempt when the competition started, I DEFINETLEY uploaded as a video response, but its not here.
MrJimmyWade 2 years ago
yeah man!!! same here.
Whats going on????
I've uploaded my video as a video response to this one on july 19th and its not there either...wtf?
patohdz 2 years ago
I've enter a video in THEWHOWINDMILLCONTEST, but with no sound, I was playing Can't Explain.
alastairjr40 2 years ago
When do we find do out who won?
firegeek22 2 years ago
The 15th of July, I think..I'm wondering when they are going to put up the rest of the videos....
MattEllenberger 2 years ago
Oh alright thanks they should come up in a couple of days.
firegeek22 2 years ago
LONG LIVE ROCK!Good luck everybody
ohio1968javelin 2 years ago
MrModDog ... Yeah, that sounds right. Upload to account, then post a video response to this page and select your video. You should be good to go in that sense. Then, make sure you fill out the form ... and that's where my question comes in ... I'm wondering if anyone got an e-mail confirmation ...
guitarJam5 2 years ago
ok thanks very much for your reply, is that what you did and your video has shown up as a response? Hope you get your comfirmation
MrModDog 2 years ago
Ok, I upped my vid to my account first to see the quality was alright, then i went to post a response to this vid and I selected my vid. Is that ok, or do I need to upload the vid WHEN I GO TO POST A RESPONSE. Has anyone reponded with a vid they'd already uploaded and been succesful in seeing it go up here? Thanks
MrModDog 2 years ago
Hey, did anyone get an e-mail response that their video and filled out form were accepted/received?
guitarJam5 2 years ago
brilliant
IANDANDY 2 years ago
just got to be patient guys :)
Hady1994 2 years ago
Yeah, looks like it's going to be a tough wait ... I'm re-learning a couple of Who songs to pass the time ...
guitarJam5 2 years ago
what? a week later for the results?!?! I'm on pins and needles already! :)
TheWhoRocksMySocks 2 years ago 2
I think I fogot to add the tag THEWHOWINDMILLCONTEST
Does anyone know how to find out if i did or not?? as i cant see my sad effort anywhere in the section of subscribers??
Help
clivestubbs 2 years ago
It might take awhile before it's all updated Calm down, have a brandy, and wait.
Mantrasolo 2 years ago
Sure Bill Canell does a good Job but mrsainty goes the whole way. I saw the Who-Dunnit show where he smashed the strat. It was awesome. If anyone deserves to win a guitar it's him!!!!
holdsm 2 years ago
Check out BILL CANELL aka BC67WHO of Who's Next Tribute band. He is the real deal and does this for real. He is the best I have seen. You must see them live!
LIGHTintheHALLS 2 years ago
Comment removed
Anticrombie918 2 years ago
Comment removed
Anticrombie918 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheWhoRocksMySocks 2 years ago
I hope, also I hope they come sign on soon, i want mine approved.
firegeek22 2 years ago 2
Don't complain about the limited number of entries. The less, the better! - I so want that autographed guitar....
MichelleWiggins 2 years ago 3
same and we pretty much all got it made, they r giving 26 prizes out. There r only like 11 video responses, becasue some were uploaded twice.
firegeek22 2 years ago
yeah but think about it most people will upload their videos at the last minutes so their will probably be many more
foolintherain03 2 years ago
I love the WHOOOOOOOOOOO
MichelleWiggins 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheWhoRocksMySocks 2 years ago 2
I entered my video about one hour ago. Would love to see other entries
alanweinkrantz 2 years ago
just done mine. where do you go to see others?
delbut2 2 years ago
Hey how long did it take for ur id to get in the video responses?
firegeek22 2 years ago
Just done mine. Where do we go to see others?
delbut2 2 years ago
i don't think they're going to approve the video responses right away because i already entered mine.
JimiTheWho 2 years ago 2
Well its been about 5 days now and I don't see urs now mate? I entered mine around 4:30 today.
firegeek22 2 years ago
Pete, what guitar was that?
It looks alot like the one I have.
Androminate 2 years ago
I know I am not Pete, but I can answer your question, it's a Gibson SG
firegeek22 2 years ago
he's the reason i got an SG. not angus like most people think
Anticrombie918 2 years ago
Nice man. I might get a black one, but I am looking for a strat right now so, thats y I entered this contest. and it's a free guitar, I mean come on.
firegeek22 2 years ago
Same here.
Mantrasolo 2 years ago
Doesn't anyone wan't to win a Fender signed by Pete?
Androminate 2 years ago
i think most people who are entering are over 30 or 40, they probably have no clue as how to work youtube :(
BrickUnit 2 years ago
good point lol
DrummerTheWho 2 years ago
I know I was like wtf, there is only 13 entries, 14 including mine now.
firegeek22 2 years ago
I was just about ask the same thing. What gives?
jacytoon 2 years ago
Why is Roger wearing high heels? That's ridiculous! Really good quality video. Is this on the new DVD?
thankyoupourlavideo 2 years ago
why not?, look what KISS wore
RamonesMusic 2 years ago
There is a difference between The who and KISS though. KISS were all about the atmosphere and The Who r about the music more.
firegeek22 2 years ago