G.E.M. 聽海

[sylviawg624]

哭腔太多

[mirukubaby]

香港人咩都比一餐＝　＝ｇｅｍ唱得超好～

但真係哭腔重得濟

[zoe3661]

@35660978 呀gem普通話不正宗 你知唔知佢細個拍普通話教育電視嫁

[YEETING28]

好好聽;gem you are the best of the best;

[hokaching]

好好聽

[narutoxd118]

雖然G.E.M.唱聽海並唔係唱得最好聽果個~但係我心目中G.­E.M.永遠都係最好嘅歌手~

[620139]

唔錯好好聽 不過個人感覺呼吸聲大左d

[MacchiatoCrow]

@620139 lol

[kevinhylee]

什麼“沒有感情沒有感情”，沒有同樣的感情，當然聽不懂GEM的­感情

[Alan020877]

無果種爆既感覺, 可以聽聽學友同張惠妹唱果種爆既感覺

[kaikai05052010]

@Alan020877 ::  有同感.

[raysunwong]

@YukiWong520 on9

[BSC1211990]

phrasing有啲問題，句與句停頓太多，令成首歌欠連貫！應­以成首歌作expression,而非每個字！發聲放太多喺喉嚨­，應多注意下面嘅support！(Thats y 有啲人覺得佢唱得辛苦) 可能坐喺度唱嘅關係~~~Overall 都不錯=))

[kevinhylee]

@BSC1211990 你可能係唯一一個覺得phrasing有問題的人。每個字每個音­都投放感情才會令音樂變得細緻，當每個音都變得細緻，整首歌便成­了你所謂的expression。用喉嚨是唱流行曲的技巧，如果­你覺她唱歌時沒有“下面嘅support”，那你聽音樂的能力就­有毛病了！

[ONEPIECE201107]

真係好好聽！！



[summerkennykwan]

是咪的問題嗎?

感覺唱得有點辛苦

[mklong135]

高低,真假音轉換;靈活運用咽音。 技巧認真高超 真心 :一)

[cherry36149944]

跟原唱比有意思嗎？雖然確實缺乏一點感情，但是人家2009年的­時候才18歲，前途還無可限量啊！

[AngelSuka]

岩岩聽完啊mag唱歌, 再聽gem gem唱... 哇!!!!!  簡直系地獄與天堂!!! 點講呢,5系話啊mag勁難聽, 只系啊gem gem順耳好多.

[feliciababy13]

我还是喜欢阿妹的版本...=)

[allen102050721]

音樂性非常好~本質音色也不錯~!!

只要對於聲音的掌握度能更加操控可以更加漂亮~!!

和弦的了解性非常好~!!會多加入一些功能和弦~!!!!

整首的掌握感很棒~!!!只要能考慮音色的修飾能更加成功!!!­!!

[drifterworld1]

佢坐係到唱 加埋要彈琴 都可以唱得咁好, 咁好感情 :)

唔知佢企係到唱會點呢?

[redphiveII]

她真的没有出国？很abc

[qwe5294]

正@_@

[meiyoong]

she is one of the few hk singers nowadays who can really sing... way to go GEM!

[JX0101]

不好意思，还是阿妹唱的我比较喜欢听(-_-)

[liaojining]

天分有限，唱得太辛苦。

[cashlover]

點解成首歌咁chord都咁咁低音…

[ChloeXable]

not bad :)



[appleandeddy]

唔中意聽既人唔該ALT+F4，唔好係度小學雞

[littleko1216]

@bbyyyyyyyy 你唔可以咁嫁.頂你!!

[sumyibaby]

@723lion no matter who u r,, i dun think u can sing either:)

[bearbear1231220]

@723lion If you don't like her, dont leave any comment here. If you don't like her, or you think HK people suck, you may leave this page immediately. We don't welcome people who leave bad comment here. By the way, I don't think HK people suck, I think you suck!

[WhoAmi8083]

@723lion Even she cant sing well it doesn't related to all the Hongkies..btw, I'm Malaysian. I support HK entertainment. The world wd b lonely w/out them..Do appreciate.

[tanley517]

@WhoAmi8083

你講乜鳩呀,文化錯到7彩....唔該唔好侮辱英文,BITCH­!

[killmysorrow123]

@723lion 英文爛到咁就咪講英文啦-.-收收皮

[michellesuen78]

@723lion 就算佢唱得吾好聽,都吾等於HK people suck

而且GEM佢唱得好好

[oicq747285250]

你地班友話佢有技巧冇感情- -不過佢已經擺曬感情黎唱lar wor，而技巧就係唱好歌必須ge= =你地自己去ktv唱都係認為自己最有技巧同感情ga lar 同一個道理，唔好批評佢啦 你同fd一齊去ktv咪一樣係咁

[ecarlx306]

感覺上佢太著重技巧~~

[wendycheung888]

我想聽阿妹唱ainy

[TheBillows]

@wendycheung888 yup !

[sugarbrosis]

不錯 但GEM成日哭腔 有d over

[wendycheung888]

@siuchu610 白痴

[handicap2ful]

play technique... but bad outcome

[siuchu610]

@handicap2ful agree

[alantsang319]

話佢唱得比原唱好聽呢樣真系太誇張lol - -

但系講真佢唱功非常唔錯，加多少少感情就更加好~

[zoe6HM]

好好聽！  GEM!!

[TheResever]

好. 好. 好.

[TheFlashDwade25]

香港人黎講 算係唔錯架喇

[hi97105620]

@TheFlashDwade25 香港人本來就很強



[jovayang]

如果感情能更深一点就是完美了！唱功没话说啊！！

[ronaldhulk]

我觉得他比原唱好听

[zcfge]

GEM有名氣不是沒道理的，真好聽

[FONGCHUNHO80]

加油^^



[ying403jy]

JOEY is better~!

[jenniferyapp]

i think for those who are saying gem's incapable or unemotional, they need to go and watch gem's cover whitney housten's "i have nothing".

[chocomisuhorlick]

她唱得很有自己的味道

[honeytube888]

整首歌聽不出有連貫性或層次,

感覺是務求唱出音而聽不到感情嘅自然流放,

所以不能感動我

[lukeleeee]

呢首歌唱得唔好wo..加油加油~

[sr20jun]

我觉得好有feel wor!重自弹自唱tim!

[uohecc]

her voice can't get very emotional, should just stick to r&b and all that

[dmlforte]

she clearly isn't capable of singing such a big song.

[hoholoney]

唱的技巧好好~

但係感情方面-w-差少少

始終仲細個

[happifruit]

She tried to dress the song up too much. A-mei's original interpretation is very sad and emotional, which I think GEM didn't deliver. The hook is very powerful, but she's holding back.

[Anson6136]

自彈自唱好難，gem真係好西利，而且gem的普通話好正宗，g­em真的是樂壇的人才。

[john198822]

@Anson6136 she's born in shanghai

[35660978]

@Anson6136 gem唱功好是公認的,但普通話並不正宗,淚水唱成淚誰

[kaind1bf3]

唱得吾夠放~.~



[kaind1bf3]

唱得吾夠放~.~



[lingasuet]

啊gem唱得好☆*:.｡. o(≧▽≦)o .｡.:*☆

(=´∀｀)人(´∀｀=)加油

[amandakwok1]

好聽!

[acmilan173]

唱得唔係咁好聽

[Samanisawesome]

she sang sooooooooooooooo beautifully!!!!!

[ritalee616]

3.08 坐系隔離果個男嘅系陳柏宇??-0-

靚仔靚仔

[mirukubaby]

@ritalee616 ｊａｓｏｎ好ｑ︿︿

[thxforshare]

跟原唱差很遠 完全唔好聽

[thxforshare]

gem現在只有唱功  唱歌沒有感情

[MrJusleng]

唱歌根本不用跟别人比较，自己开心就好。。

[Horrible28]

她在高部分用太多假音了。跟阿妹比不了。她的声音不够强。

[Sparklyfire1]

@Horrible28 谁说要跟阿妹比呀？LOL xD

[borischansmart]

GEM 自己彈仲好過"鋼琴王子＂幫佢伴奏！

[marklung]

amazingly hard song to sing especially with piano playing, amazing singer.

[TheIjk27]

gdgd

[christyluvjing]

聽媽xd

[edgar517]

GEM, 太動聽了. 在阿妹的歌中, 唱出了自己. 唱出了感性.

[premium829]

自彈自唱實在不容易,

G.E.M要兼顧彈琴之餘,

仲要唱得咁好,

不得不比個讚你....

[rainlucinda425]

好好聽呀！

[g01324killer]

GEM係高強歌手~~加油呀

[g01324killer]

gem, 唱歌真係好勁, 咽聲假音好正~~

支持妳

[g01324killer]

gem, 唱歌真係好勁, 咽聲假音好正~~

支持妳

[king0228]

不觉得唱出了这首歌的味道~ hmm~

[Gazette2008]

hmm she has a nice tone of voice, but the feeling is not deep enough.

[jollychippy]

good, feeling not bad at her age too...

[hongkongchico168]

giver her a break guys, she's 19 fucking years old. She did pretty well

[sj2000167]

始終年齡太輕，人生沒有太多經歷，唱功不錯，假以時日必成大器。­

[obx325]

隻歌同佢都唔夾.......................­...

[freestyleyik]

都叫唱到,,但唱唔到曹格個種咁令人心痛

[michael1372006]

高潮位反而放輕唱,應該同前半段掉返轉就差唔多

同埋去到"聽~" 連音個到好明顯唔連貫,重要走埋音

[ChristyX1209]

返去唱返where did you go啦

[minamiliu]

@ChristyX1209

[alice2363]

我覺得佢太強了,唱軟的歌軟不下來

[LapSiLap]

got my heart moving

[whitecin45]

好喜歡這首歌,而且GEM唱得蠻好聽呀^O^希望GEM愈唱愈好­聽~support^O^

[mk2man2003]

應該進步不小了吧,很好的潛力.

[celica4438]

感動唔到我囉～

[KIT7732KIT]

好聽 ...

[520TXFS]

哩首歌唔適合佢！！

[cyandbs]

唱不太出悲傷的感覺，可能她本身的聲音很powerful

[yu2000yu]

@cyandbs 佢可以參考張惠妹: 她的聲音同樣很powerful, 不過可以將感情收放自如. GEM唱功唔錯, 不過可能年輕, 佢仲未唱出好多歌嘅感情. 好似I Will Always Love You咁. 如果佢肯努力 (再加運氣--例如唱啲歌hit唔hit到), 前途應該無可限量.

[kwanswhswh]

透氣聲好大。

[gn01953588]

@kwanswhswh 呼吸聲可作感情

[jack1990125]

i love it

it is so touching song

and G.E.M. has done a graet job

good~!!!

[YuSan08]

好聽!

[cheat99]

Beautiful~~~~