Added: 2 years ago
From: mozpiano2
Views: 17,431
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (68)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This showa you what makesABBA ABBA. Those voices, so unalike, working together to produce that most fantastic sound. Just wonderful.

  • Para aquellos que dudan de las voces de ellas. Muy buena idea, excelente. Porque muchos cantantes se ayudan con los instrumentos y no cantan nada bien. Pero ellas de verdad son el alma de ABBA o lo fueron. Son las que le ponen vida a ésas letras.

  • Neat !

  • This is true LOVE to her Linda.I cryed when I heard and saw that video.That blond angel.....Aaaah...ABBA something special 1

  • Whoaaa!!!! This is just incredibly beautiful! In a way, it's even better than the music version! It's like they are in the same room with you, or something like that. Really really great job you did!!! Do you have more videos like this one? If not, could you please upload more?

  • that a pretty cool video how did you do that?

  • Really great! Thanks for this!

  • It's as if this video was done to prove what great singers they were. No need to do that. We already knew.

  • so beatiful !

  • I agree their voices are wonderful - thanks Monica!

  • Very interesting :)

    5 Stars :)

  • That sounds great! Thanks for doing that for us all....

  • la voce di agnetha è ancora più bella senza la musica beautiful !!!

  • Can you do that trick with whatever song?

    And If You Can How?I know only how to remove voices:(

    Amazing performans by Agnehta ofcourse! I love Her!

    CONTACT

  • w gli abba sempre e comunque siete daccordo ? abba the best forever !!!!!!!

  • bellissima versione buona idea la voce di agnetha è ancora se possibile più valorizzata

  • Frida <3

  • <3 <3 <3

  • Awesome... this vid proves that even though Frida was a mezzo-soprano, she had a huge range and a huge voice and in fact sang the highest note in this song. At 3:00, it's clear Agnetha isn't singing, but Frida (off camera) is.

  • @graficjack It isn't that hard for a singer to do a quick flip to "head voice" which is what Frida is doing and she is singing the harmony in the song. Frida stated herself that Agnetha had a "much higher voice" which is evident in most, if not allof ABBA's recordings. That doesn't mean Frida is incapable of singing in higher registers or Agnetha singing in lower registers.

  • Is the isolated vocal coming from the 5.1 surround mix from the DVD? It would be the Front Centrer channel? I am also wondering if the vocals were actually re-recorded in the studio afterwards because in a live performance you would be hearing more "bleed-through" from the hand mike....

  • @THEmotownboy I saw this when it originally aired and even then I asked myself the same question, was it re-recorded or even pre-recorded. There's something about the the lipsynchronisation (especially with agnetha) that doesn't look right or sound right.

  • I am sure that they re-recorded the vocals in the studio. If these were the live vocals, we would be hearing the band so much louder than what is here. What little we hear sounds like what would be heard from the vocalist's headphone in the recording booth. I believe it has been documented in one of the ABBA timeline books that some lead vocals for the "ABBA The Movie" concert scenes were redone in the studio. The song "I Wonder" comes to mind.

  • Wow =D so great! thank you!

  • One of the best Abba Songs, i love it pretty much and this posting only with the lead vocals is fantastic. thank´s a lot.

  • WOW! This is genius. Whey call this method "oopse"? Anyway, I like both voices but when Frida joins Agnetha, the song becomes even more beautiful. Awesome!

  • OOPS stands for Out of Phase Audio

  • Nice job with the separation. I don't hear any lack of quality in Agnetha's voice. You

    must be dreaming.

  • So amazing! Some people may not like Agnetha's voice in this clip, but Agnetha had to sing it that way. If you hear the official audio you can hear almost the same.

  • Ammazing Job

    The girl voices are brilliantly highlighting .

    Well done  Rudolf

  • booo she cant sing no effence intended

  • this is the best best best...frida's harmony just stellar!

  • Agnetha was just incomparable.

  • OMG, now I know what people were complaining about back in the day...I heard from a lot of European fans saying you could hear how Agnetha's voice was suffering from her smoking habit. Agnetha's voice sounds so whiny and weak here...thank goodness she sounds better now! :-)

    As for Frida...she sounded wonderful, and her harmonies have such a melancholy sound. Perfect for this song!

    Great job stripping the music from the vocals, BTW! Keep these videos coming, please!!

  • ABBA Acapela

  • OH . woooow , amazing <333

  • je reste sans voix! c'est magique!

  • Without words - stunning, amazing! Nothing lft to say...

  • Breathtaking! Nobody in pop music come close to these two singers. Thank you so much for posting!

  • casi lloro....casi muero....realmente una belleza.....

  • Agnetha & Frida are the magic of ABBA. Brilliant!

  • Wow!! This sounds soooo great!! Now you can clearly hear which part was sung by Frida! She did a very good job singing together with Agnetha in this beautiful song. Please, share some more of these live recordings with us?!

  • Simply - I want more;DDD

  • i never thought i'd live to hear abba a capella in a entire song! thanks for posting this centre channel! how did u do it? what software was used to extract an individual channel?

  • Wow, this is very cool to see... Thanks for posting, and please, MORE!!!!

  • This is just the center channel from the 5.1 mix found on the DVD on the Complete Studio Recordings from 2005!

    And it's NOT in stereo.

    But it's nonetheless amazing!

  • Well of course :) but who did think to upload the vocal channel before?

  • Nobody though of it, of course!

    But I think more people have discovered it, just that none has upload it to youtube before!

  • To be honest, I'm surprised no has done this before me! But its still great to hear Aggie and Frida like this! I love it!

  • Haha, genius!

  • how did you manage to get just the centre channel?

  • I extracted the audio to Audacity, and worked with the mutitracks from there.

  • what a beautiful touch. this song so hurts and reminds me of my lost daughter. to hear this acapela is fantastic

  • amazing just acapella. Great pure voice.

  • Thank you very much for all these wonderful ABBA videos and edits!!

  • You should do more of this!! This one is great!!! It's good to see how they sang without the music.

  • Wow!! What amazing experiment! How possible?? Love the 2 voices together in the "breakfast table" bit!

  • Incredible! Thanks so much!!

    More songs please! ; )

  • Rudolf you are amazing how you can take a performance like this and just extract the lead vocals from it and make it sound so beautiful! I sure don't know how you do the things you do but I sure like it, I will tell you that! I will put this one to my favorites and play it a lot, I just love it so much! Great work my friend!

    -Dallas

  • This song is sooo beautiful, Rudolf!!!

    thanks a lot for posting.

    Oh, and i agree with RenaultTwingo.

    If you do it again with Dancing Queen, would be awesome!!! ;)

    thanks again, your friend Larissa.

  • A wonderful piece of technical wizardry but undoes all the work that was put into creating a beautiful record-love it as an experiment though

  • Incredible! I won't add to the requests list, but just imagine if this *could* somehow be done with Just Like That!

  • Get thee back to thy computer NOW and start cranking out more!!

    Chiquitita, Dancing Queen, Fernando, and One Man One Woman would be excellent places to start........:D

    Many many many thanks for posting-

  • I'm sorry, but I don't like this much. Yes the voices are stunning, but to me ABBA is the whole sound, the blend of music and vocals, and all the little bits in the background. ..It sounds odd..sorry..

  • AMAZING!!! More, More, More!

  • Mozpiano - you're incredible! Thanks for this!!!

  • Thank you Rudolf, this is just incredible. When Frida joined it, it brought me to tears. I love it that after all this time, there are still things that can jolt me into loving ABBA all over again - and the admiration just keeps growing and growing.

    Stripped bare, their voices together are so beautiful. They are so clear it's like they are sitting on my desk singing to me.

    You've made my day, thanks

  • Fantastic work , great to hear

    Didn't think this was possible!

  • This is quite incredible. At first, I thought this was impossible; surely it can't be Agnetha, but a very good soundalike.

    Half way through the first verse, I recognised all the nuances. By the time Frida had joined to create their unique sound, I realised the impossible had been achieved!

    If you could replicate this technique for another song (in particular, Dancing Queen) you would make a lot of people very happy! Thank you.

  • this is amazing mozpiano2! any chance of a few (or a lot!) more of these????

  • Congratulations to your software for managing to nearly complete the impossible - see the Beatles Anomalies List/Extras article on Out Of Phase for details on why this is theoretically impossible. I say nearly, because this algorithm obviously overemphasises the vocal range - it doesn't do the opposite of OOPS or we'd hear lead gtr solo too. There is also some delay beween the original and processed signal, obvious esp at "the feeling that I'm losing her..."

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more