Yes there's a lot of students in band.. 130 is nothing compared to 300..my mighty raider band has student drum majors and is #1 in the RGV in Texas.. There's no excuse on how bad u r.. But u guys aren't bad :D
@relyt799 Uhmm not a fail...most of the ppl in our band are to stubborn to listen to anyone execpt the director so having a durm major would be a fail.
@thelovelybandgeek that isnt the entire show and usually during the last song of the show (which this was) there isnt much moving execpt to get us to our dance block most of the formation stuff is done during the first two songs. and yes we are a marching band...come out and see us sometime, weve improved alot and have grown to a band of 73 members with most of it being freshman so concidering that fact we are pretty freaking amazingg now!
@phycoticalyphyco Yeah I've seen you every game and TJ's show You need to go back to rock or anything other than smooth or word up. Your Brass is finally there but the songs you guys are playing just don't fit. Don't try to be Creek Jr. Your Edison and the name alone makes you better than Creek.
I'm one of the trombones from that band and I'll let you know that with only 2 upperclassmen and 4 freshmen, we were not in the best form. Plus our director stresses "Balance" so if we actually tried to pull our weight, we got yelled at! It's crap arrangement to, so that didn't help.
Formations were pretty simple and generally stationary for the first part. The low brass could play much louder, and the trumpets were out of tune. A few simple adjustments and you could be really good
We're playing an arrangement of "Into the Jungle" mixed with "Two worlds" from Tarzan. But our band has well over 130 people to choreograph and teach music to, it's difficult
oh wow... they have a horrible sound! wow, they only have 1 tenor?... but yeah, this year our marching band is playing this song and it sounds way better than this...
The choreography in this band was waayyy off. I thought the band players were supposed to be perfect... Plus I agree with blanklsshadow, I really don't think this song was meant for band.
wow well call me picky but there was two things I didnt like about it. the lame introduction of the song, and the well I think the song either wasnt played good or it wasnt ment for band. plus the dance was dumb
WOW, this band sucks , i have noticed several things that went wrong with marching, for one when preparing to march and counting, DO NOT take your toes off the ground, or else your head will move causing unsteady air support
Secondly, why would the band sway , they easily fell off tempo and people were swaying in different directions, they should be stepping 2 small steps left and right- GOD my band director would kill me at a game if i took my toes off the ground
You people have got to seriously give this band some props. This song is hard to play in a band, much less a marching band, where you've played multiple songs already and are tired of marching around so much... I like the visuals, quite possibly the most interesting visuals I've seen from a band that size. Kudos to your band! =D I personally enjoyed this.
If by "off" you mean that the marching doesn't exactly match with the music, it's because the sound is a bit off. It happens sometimes when you upload videos. If that's not what you meant, could you please tell me? I think we're together for the most part.
It wasn't THAT bad. It was written by a college student. This wasn't our best performance either. We had already done a full show just before we did this one (and this was the last song).
go band.
REDneckOHIO740 1 year ago
Yes there's a lot of students in band.. 130 is nothing compared to 300..my mighty raider band has student drum majors and is #1 in the RGV in Texas.. There's no excuse on how bad u r.. But u guys aren't bad :D
dallasstar1313 1 year ago
My my...
Flight3164 1 year ago
btw. Why is there no drum major? Fail.
relyt799 1 year ago
@relyt799 Uhmm not a fail...most of the ppl in our band are to stubborn to listen to anyone execpt the director so having a durm major would be a fail.
phycoticalyphyco 1 year ago
really....like seriously? you call yourself a marching band? nothing against you guys but what kind of show is that?
thelovelybandgeek 1 year ago
@thelovelybandgeek that isnt the entire show and usually during the last song of the show (which this was) there isnt much moving execpt to get us to our dance block most of the formation stuff is done during the first two songs. and yes we are a marching band...come out and see us sometime, weve improved alot and have grown to a band of 73 members with most of it being freshman so concidering that fact we are pretty freaking amazingg now!
phycoticalyphyco 1 year ago
@phycoticalyphyco Yeah but the songs you guys play aren't as nearly as good.
RogueMetal13 1 year ago
@RogueMetal13 Are you kidding me?!?! have you see us lately?!?! Our songs this year were amazingg!!!
phycoticalyphyco 1 year ago
@phycoticalyphyco Yeah I've seen you every game and TJ's show You need to go back to rock or anything other than smooth or word up. Your Brass is finally there but the songs you guys are playing just don't fit. Don't try to be Creek Jr. Your Edison and the name alone makes you better than Creek.
RogueMetal13 1 year ago
@phycoticalyphyco Yeah but the songs you guys play aren't as nearly as good.
RogueMetal13 1 year ago
sick
berlinwood131 2 years ago
is this e house stockton ca
agcz347 2 years ago
great job!!!!!!
Caitlin31422 2 years ago
I'm one of the trombones from that band and I'll let you know that with only 2 upperclassmen and 4 freshmen, we were not in the best form. Plus our director stresses "Balance" so if we actually tried to pull our weight, we got yelled at! It's crap arrangement to, so that didn't help.
RogueMetal13 2 years ago
they r so out of tune
manlyman587 2 years ago
Great job cats :)
xxxabbyrae22xxx 2 years ago
Formations were pretty simple and generally stationary for the first part. The low brass could play much louder, and the trumpets were out of tune. A few simple adjustments and you could be really good
AbbyITMS 2 years ago
Our band is playing a lot of sunshine crap this year. Do they have any helmets.
dragonman478 2 years ago
I don't think many people commenting on this knows quite how hard it is to synchronize well over 40 people (my band has 51)
Its much harder to do than just 4 people like in GnR
I admit, some of their players seemed a bit weak. But not a bad job in general.
relyt799 2 years ago
We're playing an arrangement of "Into the Jungle" mixed with "Two worlds" from Tarzan. But our band has well over 130 people to choreograph and teach music to, it's difficult
AbbyITMS 2 years ago
Wow. They need the low brass to pick it up and the trumpets to play better. and well everything could be better. This sucks.
redneckmaster5000 2 years ago
oh wow... they have a horrible sound! wow, they only have 1 tenor?... but yeah, this year our marching band is playing this song and it sounds way better than this...
DeadlyNinjaDrummer 2 years ago
This year they pulled their shit together or something.
rhall1337 2 years ago
u guys sounded coool. but u guys could of done better like. formations because you guys just stood there at times
MrNumber1punk 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck you all
AlexAck2011 2 years ago
cool!
BlanFan2O 2 years ago
The choreography in this band was waayyy off. I thought the band players were supposed to be perfect... Plus I agree with blanklsshadow, I really don't think this song was meant for band.
imsocool14 2 years ago
Edison Marching Band rocks!!! i love Edison!!!! ") and this song is amazing...but its better live than on here
kith00000 2 years ago
wow well call me picky but there was two things I didnt like about it. the lame introduction of the song, and the well I think the song either wasnt played good or it wasnt ment for band. plus the dance was dumb
blanklsshadow 3 years ago
dont worry. im in marching band. that song wasnt played well at all.
gchstrumpet 2 years ago
wait is this edison from stockton
uchiapeter 3 years ago
No - Richmond, Ohio.
smarty08pantz 3 years ago
Comment removed
rsuch54 3 years ago
Yo, i thought this was the edison high school from New Jersey, cause the feild looks exactly like this one weiiirrrddddd
TehZombehHamster 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What kind of garbage is this??
tpmc14 3 years ago
cute freak show:)=.=
wennan13524 3 years ago
That's insane. You guys played really good. I wish my band could play that but we probably won't.
Vidgamer95 3 years ago
no offense but your guys' cymbals SUCK!!!!!!! For you cymbal players, watch New London's cymbals. you might learn a thing or two
Cymbalbeast22 3 years ago
that was terrible how do you sleep at night or how does your band director even feal im sure helen keller could have tought you guys better
dangeurs 3 years ago
I've got poly ringtones that sound better.
Axlander 3 years ago 2
Yeeeeaaahhh, welll...
There are some songs that aren't good for marching band. This is one of 'em.
Nomad1718 3 years ago 2
xD!!!!!!!
kevintone 3 years ago
Solon Band > Richmond Band
That arrangment sucked...
the64 3 years ago
1:36, someone should have got a mic and started making sex noises (if you have heard the real song, ya know what I mean) XD
tsnaruto 3 years ago
Epic failure, I don't care if this is a marching band. It sucks, period.
igrenade 3 years ago
Wow. OMG. WOW. STOP. SOMEONE TAKE IT OFF YOUTUBE.
ph34rONE3443 3 years ago
wow commenting on your own comment, you go band freaks!
pier2 3 years ago
WOW, this band sucks , i have noticed several things that went wrong with marching, for one when preparing to march and counting, DO NOT take your toes off the ground, or else your head will move causing unsteady air support
thad1121 3 years ago
Secondly, why would the band sway , they easily fell off tempo and people were swaying in different directions, they should be stepping 2 small steps left and right- GOD my band director would kill me at a game if i took my toes off the ground
thad1121 3 years ago
is this thad e class 85?
cashtackle 3 years ago
Not that this is the greatest example, but there many different styles of marching. Don't be so closed minded, it can be done if practiced.
DrBoni7 3 years ago
that shouldve at least had one person on guitar or bass tht was fucking horrible
dudejohnny 3 years ago
dude its supposed to be marching band not show choir
REMOROCKS 3 years ago
i didnt say they needed a singer dumbass
dudejohnny 3 years ago
dumbass show choir isnt just singing...its like drums, guitar,trumpet...all those good instruments
REMOROCKS 3 years ago
whatever makes you happy
dudejohnny 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my ears are bleeding
Laxfreak299 3 years ago
Oh dear. Please stop. Now.
elrevert 3 years ago 8
@elrevert Well, you don't go to this school like I do. So don't say stuff about our band. o-O
HaleyxXxLynn 2 weeks ago
In Rossville, KS, in a basketball game, a band was playing Carry On My Wayward Son. Although, it wasn't on video.
spikedeath27 3 years ago
jesus that sucked stop ruining good songs
racoondude1122 3 years ago
the conducter looks retarded
rileypoole1234 3 years ago
My High School Marching Band used to cover all kinds of shit like that too, ofcourse I wasn't in the band but my friend was!!!
JEZUZ06 3 years ago
lame yall was out of step
wweman1092 3 years ago
Ahh Edison, I miss that place, but then I had to move lol my luck.
The band out there did well though.
{At least in my opinion.}
omega1123 3 years ago
wat city r u guys from????
JTSmith1254 3 years ago
Richmond, Ohio
smarty08pantz 3 years ago
Did you guys perform at the Wayne or Graham Band Fests. I think I remember hearing this song at one of them
rlongmuir 3 years ago
No. We only performeed at our own band show, Tearin' Up the Turf II.
smarty08pantz 3 years ago
awesome dude.... play for our school lol,
pauldawisp 3 years ago 2
these gays suck!!! the original rulez
xCRAZYTERRORISTx 3 years ago
That was NOT GOOD
usernameisgood 3 years ago
the opening SUCKED balls but when the melody came in that was cool the shanananananana knees was sweet though
also your band is small
guyflutist 3 years ago 3
yeah edison is the shit i used to go there
mikev2012 3 years ago
You people have got to seriously give this band some props. This song is hard to play in a band, much less a marching band, where you've played multiple songs already and are tired of marching around so much... I like the visuals, quite possibly the most interesting visuals I've seen from a band that size. Kudos to your band! =D I personally enjoyed this.
Differus 3 years ago
Thank You! I'm glad someone actually has something constructive to say instead of just bashing us for what we did wrong.
smarty08pantz 3 years ago
no offence but im in sevvie band
7 grade band and we kinda sound like this
so id try to get some talent
superblondieman 3 years ago
Its alright the sound is off in the begiinning not by marching but its out of tune
MeowSqueekBark 4 years ago
kinda sux
piojillo3 4 years ago 2
some MAJOR intonation issues in the opening of it
that or some serious wrong notes
sweetxkhaos 4 years ago
Probably just intonation problems. I'm sure we were all tired by this point in the show after 6 straight songs.
smarty08pantz 4 years ago
they are off from the begining.thanks for butchering a great song.
tvdinner4me 4 years ago
If by "off" you mean that the marching doesn't exactly match with the music, it's because the sound is a bit off. It happens sometimes when you upload videos. If that's not what you meant, could you please tell me? I think we're together for the most part.
smarty08pantz 4 years ago
i think he means innacurate... i though it was alright... not the best, but alright...
jacobpotter 3 years ago
I'm not gonna lie, but this sorta sucked. I've seen much better marching band remakes of rock songs
berndawg123 4 years ago 2
It wasn't THAT bad. It was written by a college student. This wasn't our best performance either. We had already done a full show just before we did this one (and this was the last song).
smarty08pantz 4 years ago
i rly hate when marching bands play rock songs...... or at least i hate when i have to do it
littleah95 4 years ago
Awesomeness.
PhoenixFlute 4 years ago