Carrie Underwood is Defying Gravity!

[RebaRocks100]

You guys need to chill! This video was just made to show that Carrie Underwood is really defying gravity with everything she's accomplished and what a great person she is, and how far her voice and talents are taking her i her career! Idina Menzel and Carrie Underwood are two AMAZINGLY talented women, but that's not the point! It's just a tribute video, chill! :P

[MiamiFreerunning]

lol duh the caption says carrie underwood IS (IS) Defying Gravity

not

singing defying gravity lol

[AmakiMikashiWWW]

i love Carrie; i can tell this isn't her. Give credit to the actual singer, okay? :)

[ash4evagrl]

@AmakiMikashiWWW I did. It's in the description.

[xSaikusu]

Idina is a god.

[SSBBify]

um.

[tlhusted]

Not at all what I expected. Carrie is a great singer, but absolutely no comparison to Idina Menzel. You need to change the name of this video.

[ChrisGuy1980]

@tlhusted Carrie is the pop godess and Kristen is the opera godess!!!!!

[Alkee61]

That's Idina

The One and Only!!!!!!!!!!!

[Cheezypoofs91]

that doesnt sound like carrie

[Disneylove93]

people who thought this wasnt idina need to listen to her more often

[joyfulCaroline]

It's Idina Menzel who is singing (with Kristin Chenowith).

[hawkeyesproductions5]

Thought is was Carrie... You know, any die-hard fan of this song or the musical would know that is Idina Menzel singing, not Carrie Underwood... What kind of fools do you take us for?

[lynnelynne111]

this is actually a really good video. i like carrie underwood and idina menzel is amazing <3

[killercrystal]

Carrie Underwood is nothing compared to Idina Menzel.

[Leon8701]

@killercrystal That statement is a FAIL! Idina is trying to achieve what Carrie has.... # multiplatnum albums....

[serabi87]

@Leon8701 Album sales don't directly reflect on talent. Carrie has some catchy songs but that's about it. Idina is a fantastic performer, she gives me chills every time. Carrie: Not so much. I get tired of her voice quickly. Just my opinion.

[shinaecox11]

haha i thought that as well iw as like...she is not this good!! Idina is soo good !!!!!!!!

[midnightsolitair1000]

It's only used as a background music... idina Menzel and Kristin Chenoweth sang this song for the musical, Wicked...

[AseAvante]

i am so glad this wasnt ACTUALLY carrie underwood singing defying gravity that is Indina Menzel's song and NO ONE could do it like she could =)

[sighteyed]

@AseAvante i disagree, Mandy Gonzales was pretty amazing when i saw her perform it in wicked...

[thewolf1911]

ok is it just me or does emily osment look just like carrie underwood

[6919mandy]

So misleading...And fail.

[Tubulator101]

I have never seen anything so dumb ......

[TVBProductions]

Ok. i was scurred for a minute. i thought she did a cover too.

[skekso1]

What you did is cheapen what Carrie Underwood does by putting another song on this video. I love Carrie, and I love Wicked, two VERY different things. Carrie is not Wicked, and Wicked is not Carrie. If you consider this your best work, keep going.

[jheuzdumaop]

It doesn't say that Carrie Underwood singing Defying Gravity...It's Carry Underwood IS Defying Gravity.....but the thing is, Carrie Underwood doesn't even fly on that video.....

[bookworm1256]

That is Idina singing not Kiristin. change who you are saying is singing soon!

[erinmmowery]

@bookworm1256 Kristin sang for a second, lol. but yea, 99% Idina

[bookworm1256]

@erinmmowery Yeah it is like Idinas song just like Popular is Kristin's even though Idina sings in it.

[WeirdButNotInsane]

@Gymnasticseverywhere

I really doubt that Carrie can sing those high notes that Glinda has to to do. I see her more as a Nessarose.

[jonathanbolerjack1]

wow i can't believe somepne actually took the time to do this, get a life

[Tiggerer2]

Duh



[vaja95]

Do people really think that this i Carrie Underwood who's singing!? It ISN'T! It's Idina Menzel, the original Elphaba!

[SingJiya]

Boy I was a carrie fan but not now she sound horrible.

[hietkampm]

@SingJiya that IS NOT carrie underwood, its idina menzel

[SingJiya]

@hietkampm Oh go figure, not a very good voice. Justin Bieber is much better.

[joecollinsse]

Would it not make more sense to have... I don't know... a Carrie Underwood song backing a Carrie Underwood fan video?

[martinliao1992]

it seems she's singing opera...lol

[TheyCallMeBird69]

I came here expecting Carrie Underwood to be singing defying gravity.

[20132021]

@TheyCallMeBird69 me too. then when i heard idina's awesome voice i was like omg wtf this isn't carrie underwood. i stayed though. idina's too awesome to leave

[Bella24Forever]

I love this song

I love how put it togther.

[cmdozier]

Why you cover Carrie Underwood with someone else's voice?! Stupid idea. Carrie needs no cover.

[mclineohio]

Ash4evagrl is infectious human waste. Please end your time on this planet as soon as possible, you buck toothed, backwoods, genetic fuck up.

[EricaLNord]

WTFFFFF waste of time, thank you for mis-representing something...............

[leecheehee]

U R SO STUPID!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Prickley71394]

people! come on! we all know it's not carrie singing, and the maker never said it was. she just put carrie pictures and videos to idina's/kristin's song from wicked.

[mclineohio]

@Prickley71394 you are as stupid as ash4whatever. Fuck off you ignorant cow.

[Prickley71394]

@mclineohio i'm betting you'd never say that to my face. but whatever.

have a good day, asshole.

p.s. i WOULD say that to your face. GTFO.

[Roguestatus33]

Rachel drom glee sings this song wayyyyyyy better! check it out

[DavidNuuge]

@Roguestatus33 With auto tune yeah sure

[pinklesizzle]

this is not carrie underwood...this is idina menzel!!!

[thatznotcool]

BHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

This isnt her singing. It's from the CD

stupid people

[hattie234]

haha i was about to say 'WOW SHE SOUNDS LIKE IDINA MENZEL !!' Then I thought, oh wait it is Idina :D I love how there's loads of comments saying that this version is crap though HA when actually it is AMAZING and they're only saying its crap because they think its Carrie Underwood who is actually a good artist, people just don't want anyone to be as good as Idina so they're willing to believe even Idina herself (sort of dressed up as Carrie) isn't as good as Idina :D

[crazycreature52]

Carrie is sweet, but Idina is the only GOOD singer!!! Carrie is good, but not as good as Idina

[jul123212]

i love how everyone is saying this version sucks Idina's is better! dude, this is Idina's version... get a clue! bahaha (;

[nailartist4life]

@jul123212 Bahaha, that is so funny xD

[Ahab2008]

Idina Menzel's version is MUCH better! This one is a disgrace!

[petoetjuh]

@Ahab2008 uhhh...it IS Idina Menzel...

[aledu89]

@Ahab2008 hahahahah you are so dumb and deaf!!!!! THIS IS IDINA MENZEL's version!!

you can't say Idina is better when you don't even recognize her own voice

[blisasianhite]

@Ahab2008 dude..THIS IS IDINA...

WOW

[louffylou]

@Ahab2008 LOL FAIL IT IS IDINA

[GIeeky]

@Ahab2008 FAIL FAIL FAIL

[FlutterbaiDestiny]

@Ahab2008 lol wow.

[ScribblesTheNinja]

If Idina went out for American Idol she would win, hands down.

[Sireggyweggy]

read the description idiots, it says its a fan video, she's not actually singing it

[Fayyzz]

Fail. 

[jaimelespoptarts]

WTF???

[thetopsinger101]

...This is Idina Menzel..... 1. I know the song 2. Read the box above...

[TheNolantherolan]

In my opinion, Teal Wicks is the best Elphaba

[815LAFLACA]

i like how you did this video and at the end it look cool when you was walking with the wind.

[yovaspears]

The lea version is cool too

[animated669]

hey everybody! can we please not judge ash4evagrl for doing this? she's just a fan of of Carrie (which by the way is a great singer too.) and she's just doing this for her. Every singer has their own identity/voice/uniqueness and we don't have the right to judge them by that. i think this is a GREAT video cause it enhances the image of both of them (Carrie and Idina). Well, im not trying to be a martyr here, all im saying is, please, stop criticizing this video by ash4evagrl. TNX!

[freedomii6]

This is really stupid. Carrie sings Carrie songs. Idina sings hers. Why would you make this, it's just a dumb idea. Sorry...

[crazyaliuk]

Love this song! Idina Menzel is an incredible singer and I really want to go and see Wicked! Lea Michele version is also amazing. I can't choose which is the best so I guess i'll just carry on listening to both versions

[sammileigh95]

my math teacher looks like Carrie Underwood and it creeps me out

[ladybaba2]

This is Idina Menzel singing the original Broadway cast! What's with the Carrie Underwood crap?

[opticalworld]

hey thats IDina singing.

[tokonoma]

I hear that in season 2 of GLEE, Idina Menzel will play Rachel's birth mom and, coincidentally, the music director of Vocal Adrenaline (the rival Glee Club). I can't wait.

[parisbercy]

kristin cheo is the best. short ... but the best. ;-)

[TescoShampoo]

@parisbercy WTF is wrong with being short?!

[isabelgalan711]

idina menzel is really the best.

[llama4lifex0x0]

i <3 wicked!!!

[beckywixon94]

this song gives me shivers everytime

any version, this song is just incredible

[vniguam]

@beckywixon94

i know right... i watched Wicked... just to see this song...

[biglipstasia]

Wow.

[bastiantotalhappy]

idina menzel is better

[musicalmuffins3]

that IS idina menzel singing

[bastiantotalhappy]

@musicalmuffins3 i know that its idina someone said glee is better but idina the orignial is much better

[Hairsprayxoxoful]

@musicalmuffins3 I know, right!

[dhani17]

the glee version is better

[SoFunKYxoxo]

wow she sucks compared to glees superior talents:)

[TristanandIsolt]

This is not Carrie Underwood it is Idina Menzel the original artist of this song. If you think she sucks compared to Kris Colfer or even Lea Michelle you are just a gleek who is too biased to even listen. I love Glee but you have to recognize the facts.

[twilightwit]

@TrisandandIsolt

...

it's chis colfer. LOL. not kris.

[TristanandIsolt]

Whatever, and I wasn't even sure whether it was Lea Michelle or Leah Michelle. When I start worrying about just how they like to spell their names I will start worrying about myself.

[twilightwit]

@Trisanandlsolt

dude chill i didn't mean any offense by it.

[TristanandIsolt]

No offense taken. Just having some fun.

[mitchohh]

I'm sure in the context of the show, Ms. Menzel works better. Lea Michelle sang the song incredibly well. I think if someone were to just compare the songs, the majority would choose Lea's version.

[TristanandIsolt]

I doubt that the typical listener would think Lea's version was better but I do love Lea Michelle. Somebody said that this version sucks and that was really messed up. As far as the best vocal performance I have heard on this, with no consideration to the acting elements, was Mary Carewe. Listen to that one if you want to hear a great vocal performance and let me know what you think.

[vniguam]

@mitchohh

i prefer Chris Coflers version to Lea's...

[SoFunKYxoxo]

Oh it is?! My god i thought it WAS...LOl. anyways. No i'm not a gleek, but i think, in my opinion, they sing it with more feeling. I listened. (okay...i am a gleek) But still I like theirs better. Man you take your stuff seriously...Losen up!! haha jk.

[VictoriaAckles]

great video:)

[kaytee94]

Okay please don't ever put an idina/kristen song to ... Carrie Underwood. Its just... annoying and Wicked is better :p

[attackthesky]

what the fuck this is not carrie underwood you got idina fuck up

[TwoBitBecca]

This song is pure genus!!

Wicked was my first and by far my favorite musical ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Yeahitszimmer]

0:53 she looks like bridget from the girlsnextdoor.

[jprocker0494]

Its Idina, its just showing how awesome carrie is. showing that shes good enough to defy gravity :p

[ultracrazy2]

srry but i dont get it is this by carrie or idina???? im lik hella confused now

somebody plz help me pretty plz????????

[ShanesSpace]

Its Idina, just showing how Carrie "defies gravity" by doing like... good deeds and putting up with fans. lol

[nickj1706]

what the hell?!?! this is like a great song don't fuck it!

[correctedsun]

it is. I only listen to the songs without watching the actual video, and it's identical to the original. . .

[strongerxgirl12]

TO EVERYONE,

this is the original music, it says so so in the description.

[jad0900]

yeahh this is the originall

[jjchee]

erm... everyone I think the music is the original idina menzel one dubbed onto a self-made carrie underwood video

so everyone who's saying that carrie underwood's spoiled the original clearly doesn't know how the original sounds like cos this is it.

[smileypat77]

and in case you are an overall wicked fan, my high school did a music video adaptation of "Popular" a few years ago that screened pretty well. You can find it on my youtube channel.

[bradleyjames4evahot]

OMG! wtf? this song is about friggin friendship! not about her taking pics for cameras?! original is WAY better and glee also! :)

[OnTheRoadWithAndre]

Wow, she RUINED a great song....If you want to see someone do an AMAZING job on it, search out "Brian May Kerry Ellis Defying Gravity Royal Performance"....it blows this lame version away...

[Rabbyadam]

... what? this is the original version, stupid.

[OnTheRoadWithAndre]

Oh? ..... Well, then she ruined the ORIGINAL version of it, stupid....

[kaylielikestosing]

no, she didn't ruin the ORIGINAL,,, because this isn't carrie underwood signing. this is Idina singing with pictures of carrie underwood. (which is a DUMB idea)

ehh, who's stupid?

[xFeatherheartx]

@kaylielikestosing everyone lol ^^

[actressqtxoxo]

@kaylielikestosing lol :]

[mclineohio]

@kaylielikestosing Thanks mate

[SheSister]

moran... this is the original -.-'

[superphillies18]

ok video. good song but not for carrie.

every one add me as a friend please!!

[deepice24]

Lol, I think it's actually kind of a random song to pick really...

[wickedsimprifygleek]

i don't get this video. are you trying to say that carrie underwood is singing this?? cause its of course idinaa (:

[h193013]

4:04 is she pregnant

[anniecrazy95]

i dont think so

[h193013]

are you sure

[anniecrazy95]

pretty sure haha

[daniboy018]

@ChocoboEmperor omg somebody isn't being ridiculous on here Amazing...Thank You Seriously

I got to see Marcie Dodd perform this In Kansas it was amazing. I'm not saying she is better just that she is as good as Idina. there are parts that I like about Idina and then there were parts I like about Marcie so there.