Why haven't you posted anything new? Ever time I listen to your Holland, 1945 cover it makes me take at the old Martin and submit the finger tips to 3 hours of punishment.
I stumbled upon this video while trying to learn the song for uke. I love the raw energy of the original, but I think you've inspired me to go down this route. It really lets the lyrics come to the front. You've definitely done this song justice! Very delicate and controlled.
Lowering the tempo was a very clever idea, it can be very tricky to sing this song at original speed, you have created here a very classy cover version.
i kinda stumbled across this, and it ended up playing in the background. then when it was over i had to play it again. im not a big fan of covers, but your voice goes wonderfully with this song!
Every cover I've heard of this song sucked (not that the person sucked at playing or singing, they just couldn't top Jeff Mangum), but I was pleasantly surprised with this one. This is the only cover I've seen that I actually enjoyed.
Awesome cover- you have a really soulful voice that brings out the beauty of this song. I have heard so many covers of this song that made it too fast, but you clearly have the confidence and talent to play it at a relaxed pace that makes the listener appreciate all of its intracacies. Great job!
Wow. The whole song is great, but the ending especially makes me shiver. You should really post some more Neutral Milk Hotel. I'd love to hear you sing Oh Comely.
Hey, you did a really great job with this song. Like everyone else said, it was nice to hear you take it and make it into your own. Any chance you wouldn't mind posting the chords you used?
That was great. One BIG suggestion though -- don't say that you're reading the lyrics. This is probably my favorite song of all time, so when i heard you say that, I was like, "so why are you recording it if you don't know the lyrics?" Besides, I wouldn't have noticed you were reading if you hadn't said it. But otherwise, you have a gorgeous voice, and that was a lovely cover. Well done.
i'm a huge neutral milk hotel fan, and i feel like i should hate your cover. however, your voice is amazing and you gave the song a completely different perspective. its very fitting, and i think you did the song the justice that it deserves (considering all of the other covers on youtube are horrendous)
Thanks for making it your own song and not mimicking idiosyncrasies that aren't yours (as so many others do). It really is lovely.
Also, the lilting, country take is nice, but just a tiny bit jarring to me. Since the song's subject matter is very recent-European, I have a hard time imagining a narrator that would be so moved by the events described and yet express them in 19th century Americana.
I think I'll look at any other work you've got posted. There must be real gems!
dunno why you've been given thumbs down... sure magnum was a fantastic musician for writing it in the first place... but to say he was an "awesome singer" is just lying to yourself, whereas this girl has a really good voice and deserves the praise given above.. and this is from someone who usually cant stand an american accent in songs. long story short.. good cover :)
Interesting take on this song - a completely different feel than the original, unlike many covers on youtube that try to be just like NMH and come up short. The original will always be my fav, but you gave it a nice twist.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
rape, definitely rape. sorry girl but some songs you just cant change, you should have left this as it was, ahh your slow voice and the slow gutiar playing is just blasphemy
I couldn't stop listening, oddly enough.
TheShitBed 3 months ago
prepare your mountain top
joemunkey30 3 months ago 3
@joemunkey30 you win a million internets, sir.
asdfadfv32452345 3 months ago
@joemunkey30 LMAO
EnlightenedJHOX 2 months ago
@joemunkey30 Hahahahaha!
scrumjosh 4 weeks ago
99% of the covers on youtube are really bad. This falls into the 1%. Nice take on a great song.
mpbrown27 4 months ago 3
Nice one! Keep it up!
Greetings from Holland 2011 :)
gjkok 5 months ago
i feel like this song was always meant to covered nice and slow. well done, really impressive stuff. you have an awesome voice.
nick1553 5 months ago
this version is really sweet and delicate, and although far away from the original, i like it
GranCarta 6 months ago
your beautiful :)
BleuRibbonMarathon2 8 months ago
very good... it sounds more relaxing coming from a womans voice
MyTeenageyearzz 10 months ago
This is a really hard song to cover, and you did it really well. Keep it up!
NickHannula 1 year ago
This was adorable, which is crazy for this song. Awesome
rockshow1806 1 year ago
hey you tryin to be my gf for a lil bit and then have a tragic romantic fallout?
phifeNtip 1 year ago
Great cover and what a wonderful voice! Greetings from Holland! :)
ewk71 1 year ago
wow that was amazing. a beautiful voice, with a beautiful girl.
mst3ksanta 1 year ago
You have a great voice and I love this song!
ZomfGJohn 1 year ago
i wanna buy this version
phifeNtip 1 year ago
This is an excellent version of the song, it's very smooth.
GoggleBoy116 1 year ago
sweet cover
doktorkosmos213 1 year ago
Beautiful
lesa9410 1 year ago
That was lovely! Cheers!
Charliesproduct 1 year ago
Why haven't you posted anything new? Ever time I listen to your Holland, 1945 cover it makes me take at the old Martin and submit the finger tips to 3 hours of punishment.
jdogl79 1 year ago
This is actually very pleasant. Good job (:
shak99 1 year ago
Liked.
INDENTIONS IN THE SHEETS!
gloriouspeanut 1 year ago
i love this song and you have a very pretty voice.
pinman 1 year ago
your daddy must be very proud of himself for having such a cute little talented gal like you as a daughter
Psygnus 1 year ago
thumbs up, i especially loved the cocky look in your eyes at the end....NICE
braknar 1 year ago
I stumbled upon this video while trying to learn the song for uke. I love the raw energy of the original, but I think you've inspired me to go down this route. It really lets the lyrics come to the front. You've definitely done this song justice! Very delicate and controlled.
jmartindunc 1 year ago
You sing good
NoFrag0 1 year ago
Oh, how much i love southern women. any chance you'll do another NMH tune? 'Naomi', maybe? I think that one would translate well.
crappybassist96 1 year ago
after listening to this i decided that southern accents are the best of all american accents.
ozzy08 1 year ago
after hearing this i realized that the southern accent is the best of all american accents.
ozzy08 1 year ago
wooooooow
nice
shiv3bmx 1 year ago
Lowering the tempo was a very clever idea, it can be very tricky to sing this song at original speed, you have created here a very classy cover version.
Sandline86 1 year ago
Comment removed
RdSoxFan618 1 year ago
thx..raised in ga, but been in sc for about 6 years
cutemusicmaker 1 year ago
i definitely enjoyed the southern version of this song. very smooth.
snowpoon 1 year ago
thx :)
cutemusicmaker 1 year ago
i kinda stumbled across this, and it ended up playing in the background. then when it was over i had to play it again. im not a big fan of covers, but your voice goes wonderfully with this song!
nintend82 2 years ago
hey, thanx! i appreciate that :)
cutemusicmaker 2 years ago
Holland 1945 is a southern song sang by south folk from Athens, GA. Go Braves, and take the Falcons with you...
MrRolly25 2 years ago
@JimmyHoffa04 hahaha i don't know why, but i'm glad :)
cutemusicmaker 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
poor kid, you really need lots and lots of lessons!
atfatw 2 years ago
i think the lyrics were dead on. really good
IamianaimaI 2 years ago
really good job
bradattax 2 years ago
i like this style, i like your smile...
chasgun 2 years ago
cute cover. sweet voice. nice and smooth.
nikiyadig 2 years ago
you have a southern accent
and those are hot
Supaduck0 2 years ago 10
haha thanx
cutemusicmaker 2 years ago
@Supaduck0 nothing personal, (love the cover) but i have to say southern USA accents are horrible.
steve0619 6 months ago
great job, you should cover some silver jews sometime.
wiggawannabe 2 years ago
Fantastic version - I would pay to download it if it was available.
arover1882 2 years ago
Wonderful rendition
MMMcDermott 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
That was actually pretty good.
lolimtrippingballs 2 years ago
anyone have the chords?
Jakearoo14 2 years ago
C G and D will get you through that one.
lolimtrippingballs 2 years ago
If you ever become a singer, make sure you cover this song on one of your CD's, k? K.
shantizzlerose 2 years ago
Brilliant. 5 stars !
MrFrosty 2 years ago
you look and sound really at ease playing this song- unlike Jeff Mangum. Beautiful- do you have this song properly recorded?
heyutang 2 years ago
Every cover I've heard of this song sucked (not that the person sucked at playing or singing, they just couldn't top Jeff Mangum), but I was pleasantly surprised with this one. This is the only cover I've seen that I actually enjoyed.
You have an amazing voice :)
yeslauren 2 years ago
best cover of this song :)
dowhat93 2 years ago 2
Effing brilliant.
SpasticChariot 2 years ago
Awesome cover- you have a really soulful voice that brings out the beauty of this song. I have heard so many covers of this song that made it too fast, but you clearly have the confidence and talent to play it at a relaxed pace that makes the listener appreciate all of its intracacies. Great job!
dhb2114 2 years ago
You made that your own...not easy to do with Mangum tunes...lovely indeed...
JGSturgeonmaster 2 years ago
well done :)
hhhodes 2 years ago
a little goosebumps around 1.28
shadyreefer69 2 years ago
An amazing cover. :)
ladyerlynne 2 years ago
That was awesome!
LoFiLime 2 years ago
Wow. Beautiful both you and your voice. I love it.
jfactory1986979 2 years ago
Wow. The whole song is great, but the ending especially makes me shiver. You should really post some more Neutral Milk Hotel. I'd love to hear you sing Oh Comely.
schmabbisch 2 years ago
i LIKE!
themusicthief 2 years ago
Great job. Totally charming.
mattbebe 2 years ago
thanx so much :)
cutemusicmaker 2 years ago
So cool because it doesn´t sound like an imitation, like a lot of other youtube vids. 5 stars :)
arthurspooner60 2 years ago
great rendition
i love it
nice job
fezman3000 2 years ago
Wow, what a wonderful version of this song... I've wanted to hear it acoustic for so long. Thanks so much for sharing your beautiful voice.
johntudor85 2 years ago
I agree! This is a beautiful song and you just do it so much justice! Gorgeous!
waubese 2 years ago
nice
jeremy6992 2 years ago
beautiful!! I always wanted to hear a softer version.
Shurekien 2 years ago
gr8!
gabsdrake 2 years ago
Gosh, This is the most creative, soft, lovely cover of this song ive ever heard. It sounded amazing :)
Huffah007 2 years ago
you have a beautiful voice
tonygoldmen 2 years ago
amazing
TomSchmitzyes 2 years ago
Second best version I've ever heard...and your Southern accent is a bonus.
colujomes 3 years ago
Hey, you did a really great job with this song. Like everyone else said, it was nice to hear you take it and make it into your own. Any chance you wouldn't mind posting the chords you used?
checkerchic89 3 years ago 2
Hottie
r7069c 3 years ago
I approve
ruthg10 3 years ago
not usually a fan of fan cover videos, but this was fantastic. different and similar in all the right ways. beautiful voice. great job.
xmadcowx 3 years ago 2
Yeah, even if you're reading the lyrics, never say you're reading the lyrics..
paintingtasters 3 years ago 2
sometimes you have to because there's always that one poster who says" ZOMG IT'S OBVIOUS YOU'RE READING THE LYRICS!!!"
Shurekien 2 years ago
You have such a beautiful voice =) xx
bethieeee 3 years ago
awsome cover! I'd like to have this version on my itunes! any chance?
lauraxg 3 years ago
I really liked the last part.
neiladri 3 years ago
i like how you made it feel kinda folksy. good cover.
elscorcho19 3 years ago
That was great. One BIG suggestion though -- don't say that you're reading the lyrics. This is probably my favorite song of all time, so when i heard you say that, I was like, "so why are you recording it if you don't know the lyrics?" Besides, I wouldn't have noticed you were reading if you hadn't said it. But otherwise, you have a gorgeous voice, and that was a lovely cover. Well done.
yowza138 3 years ago 5
his stephanie you have a beautiful voice
Xiansiempre 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
don't quit your day job
princefarai 3 years ago
didnae like it
Dolebob 3 years ago
you should post more videos! i enjoy every one of them.
schismtomynism 3 years ago
your ok.
Rocknroro1995 3 years ago
While your voice is no where near as powerful as Magnum's (whose is?!, I have to admit this is a beautiful cover!
PrinceforPeace 3 years ago
Interesting take. I think I like it.
asburytheo 3 years ago
i like it
DerKenobo 3 years ago
Great cover of Naanteen Forty Faaave.
GuitarChix69 3 years ago 2
I love the accent. Brilliant cover. Just so awesome.
inthefiveonenine 3 years ago
very very good
jamsd3 3 years ago
Great song, pretty girl, an excecelent cover.
htredlih 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You played it wrong. What's with people playing these songs wrong? They're so easy to play and the tabs are easy to find online.
punktematrix 3 years ago
..it's called a COVER, moron. have a nice day :)
cutemusicmaker 3 years ago
for someone who's supposedly a punk enthusiast, i'm surprised you're such a fan of maintaining the norm.
schismtomynism 3 years ago
This song gives the original no justice. Try a frente song, it would fit your voice!
melodel2 3 years ago
you just made me cry.
DannyWeinkauf 3 years ago
...hopefully not a "you eff'd my fav song up" cry...
cutemusicmaker 3 years ago
no ... it was a "the sadest song of all times just became a little more sad" - cry ...
good work there ...
DannyWeinkauf 3 years ago
oh my god, i'm in love with you. your voice is beautiful. lovely cover!
voodooriptide 3 years ago
my god...that's absolutely beautiful
JP9405 3 years ago
wonderful, wonderful cover of this heartbreaking song.
cahillion 3 years ago
I dig your digs...In other words, I like your song. Cahill, I say: yes. Excuse me miss, what is your name?
aguythatisasa 3 years ago
Fantastic x
glen279 3 years ago
wow, i think most covers are lame, but this ones awesome
493jake 3 years ago
Put a feminine touch to this song.
Awesome sweet voice.
I enjoyed, Thanks !
Lucem2 3 years ago
ps- i can't stop watching your video.
schismtomynism 3 years ago
i'm a huge neutral milk hotel fan, and i feel like i should hate your cover. however, your voice is amazing and you gave the song a completely different perspective. its very fitting, and i think you did the song the justice that it deserves (considering all of the other covers on youtube are horrendous)
schismtomynism 3 years ago
your good at preforming with a guitar, and your also very pretty
derf234 3 years ago
great cover
joshuaradin123456 3 years ago
great acoustic version...but i gotta feva, and the only cure is more trumpet!
jhickma 3 years ago
thats really good, i love your speaking voice. you'd be a perfect girlfriend......maybe
humanshieldchorus 3 years ago
wow you made this great song into a great ballad good job:D
regengy 3 years ago
good job! and she's cute
tellallyourfriends 3 years ago
eh, dont like how soft it is... ruins it
ZooYorkSniper 3 years ago
to each his own :) thanx for the comment!
cutemusicmaker 3 years ago
You sing beautifully, CuteMusicMaker and you play well.Great.
Ashdonis 3 years ago
you really make this song your own. well done
Whittzkrieg 3 years ago
I love this. your wonderful!
northernohiomike 3 years ago
beautiful!
Bassguy623 3 years ago
Honestly, this is amazing.
You really made it your own. <3
uniski 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i'd do you.
butlerKNOWSall 3 years ago
You're best cover so far. I think your voice goes very nice with this song.
marshallq 3 years ago
Very pretty. I really wanted you to hit that last high note though! When you nail that last note it's like an out of body experience or something.
SalesDudeMcBoob 3 years ago
Terrific cover!
Gizzmo 3 years ago
would sound a little more natural if you learned all of the lyrics. still i like this as much as the orignal
liquidpyramid 3 years ago
that was really beautiful!
xxBitzaxx 3 years ago
love it. great accent.
jannonymous 3 years ago 2
Very relaxing, thanks :)
Neuropelisis 3 years ago
you mean "great cover"
typos are a bitch.
i like your take on this song.
MR1188 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
terrible cover
SkaKid5 3 years ago
i love your accent, good job
Jolfawnzo1 3 years ago
Simply lovely.
GossamerReverb 3 years ago
hey girl ,that was beautifulll, its a great song
yzaddicted 3 years ago
Mostly praise.
Thanks for making it your own song and not mimicking idiosyncrasies that aren't yours (as so many others do). It really is lovely.
Also, the lilting, country take is nice, but just a tiny bit jarring to me. Since the song's subject matter is very recent-European, I have a hard time imagining a narrator that would be so moved by the events described and yet express them in 19th century Americana.
I think I'll look at any other work you've got posted. There must be real gems!
kitchenlattice 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I love your voice, unapologetic. Better than Mangun's own live versions.
tristanlaing 3 years ago
dunno why you've been given thumbs down... sure magnum was a fantastic musician for writing it in the first place... but to say he was an "awesome singer" is just lying to yourself, whereas this girl has a really good voice and deserves the praise given above.. and this is from someone who usually cant stand an american accent in songs. long story short.. good cover :)
wimbotkang 3 years ago
And its almost a lullaby (its after midnight).
wexy56 3 years ago
Beautiful.
wexy56 3 years ago
Interesting take on this song - a completely different feel than the original, unlike many covers on youtube that try to be just like NMH and come up short. The original will always be my fav, but you gave it a nice twist.
gte836j 3 years ago 3
Wow. By slowing down the tempo and making it acoustic it's suddenly a country love song.
kavorka91 3 years ago
I loved it. 5*
preppy890 3 years ago
Wow, your voice is great, great cover overall.
streetlight3989 3 years ago
This is the only NMH cover on YouTube that I can even stand...and it's great!
gokinsmen 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
rape, definitely rape. sorry girl but some songs you just cant change, you should have left this as it was, ahh your slow voice and the slow gutiar playing is just blasphemy
7RaulGonzales 3 years ago
I would pay five bucks to see that. Seriously, awesome.
varsityfilm 3 years ago
I was checking out Neutral Milk Hotel stuff and came across this video - it is AWESOME!
Keep it up!
m0bi 3 years ago
This is pretty good. Well done!
madstimm 3 years ago
This is beautiful! I like that you did it your own way, it added a unique twist to an already great song
lavieboheme1 3 years ago
That was very beautiful, you and the song lol.
Nichtmara19 3 years ago 2
This is really cool. I ripped the audio off this video and put it on a mix cd for my friend.
kevinhorn 3 years ago 2
haha that's cool and i'm totally flattered!
cutemusicmaker 3 years ago
this is a really lovely cover!
megaphonethis 3 years ago 2
woooooooow, your voice is amazing. the music too. :P
julianalangaro 3 years ago
That was really beautiful..even if it wasn't Jeff.
stellarxosky 3 years ago
pretty cool. surprisingly i liked the country twist to a NMH song
PhillyFlyers8 3 years ago 3
hi, u sang really sweet like an angel from the northern star shining on us.
noobzrule 3 years ago
creepy
xjonnychaosx 3 years ago
the only one who is creepy is u jonny
noobzrule 3 years ago
ace job. you earn many, many stars. stars that were yours to begin with, so what matters an opinion? keep up the great work.
supergwats 3 years ago
oh my god. you are so beautiful. this is great. don't stop singing. ever!
kolipoky10 3 years ago
Wow... Unique interpretation. I like it.
akrlic 3 years ago
i liked it. any NMH fans are cool with me.
hreskofreight4 4 years ago
wow
nice job
Wingbladeproductions 4 years ago
i'm hard to please when it comes to NMH covers, but this is really good. good job.
thekakihara 4 years ago
i think most NMH fans are pretty hard to please when it comes to covers. so the success of this one says a lot :)
thefallinggirl 3 years ago 2
This is my favorite NMH song. You did a great job with it.
RoboPimp3000 4 years ago
this is great! I love what you did with it.
haley727 4 years ago