Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (25)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • umwerfend

  • It should be noted that it's the Vienna Philharmonic under Claudio Abbado that's accompanying Mme. von Otter in this absolutely-Heavenly song (and this IS a song in all truth!)

  • Comment removed

  • The best I've heard in this song cycle. My fave. The weight of her voice, the expression, the lilt - can't believe I'm attempting to learn these. Ah well - it's just too gorgeous to pass up ;-)

  • This song concludes in some way the culmination of the Western European civilization.

  • great voice to play Berg!

  • I'd like to sing just like her... 

  • Of the 1st three of these "Seven Early Songs" of Berg, this third one truly is WONDERFUL!! Absolutely haunting - had he not gone atonal under his teacher Schoenberg's influence, he really could have extended the life of tonality not a little bit longer yet. Post-Romanticism didn't need to die that quickly or be ridiculed that severely by the likes of Stravínskiy, Schoenberg or whoever was guilty thereof...

  • Definitely the very best rendition of this one of the "Sieben frühe Lieder" by Berg that this writer has ever heard, from all the selections that are at this point available on YouTube!!!

    This is just the perfect voice-quality I could envision for this piece - also a beautiful balance between the voice and the orchestra!!! Compared to this, Renée Fleming most definitely sounds like an "also-ran", while Cheryl Studer - though better than Fleming - still doesn't match von Otter!!

  • [This is not meant to pan Ms. Fleming overall by any means in this song (in itself, her performance is definitely very good!): it's just that Frau Von Otter does things so beautifully in this particular piece as to make it hard for anybody to match!!!]

  • Very good performance!!! I liked the song too! :)

  • Do not miss the splendid renditions of these splendid songs (also taped live) by Cheryl Studer, just uploaded to my channel. Audio only.

  • By the way - the song isn't even transposed down. She's the man!

  • She's the MAN??????????

  • Oh, yeah, she's got the verve and the technique, that's what I mean.

  • @vincecharus She is definitely the man!

  • @vscanzi Please. In PROPER English, it's "She da MAN!!!"

  • Wow! Gorgeous song, gorgeous singing! This is a side of Webern I've never heard before.

  • Oops, that was Berg. Definitely a side of Webern *nobody's* ever heard. :-)

  • It's not Webern man...

  • Well, I caught my mistake within minutes, but it took you a year. :-P

  • perhaps my favorite lieder

  • I love that picture of her

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more