A little bit flat at parts but even still it was great, its really hard for a guy to sing that cause parts are so high pitched but you got past that, great job :)
Immensely good, you are very talented. Although, I would've liked to maybe hear an arrangement that diverged away from the original. But still veeeeeery good.
AMAZING! AND DA PICTURES IN DA BACKROUND WER GREAT AND REALLY ADEDDED TO IT! Until I read ppl's comments I thought dat was da real fing! I love dat song n u did a great job of it!
i'm not being rude but alot of the notes that u r singing r out of tune and that is the easy notes the high notes r good. overall it is still good u just need to watch those notes. still love it. if i have offended u then be sure to let me no. hay try and listen to the song that wasnt used called Use well the days. any questions on LOTR be sure to ask me I CAN SPEAK ELVISH.
@Blogsterle I'm guessing at male. Skimmed a tad, but didn't see any confirmation from earthonika either way. Listen to the upper range carefully.
@earhonika: Well done! If you are indeed a man, this is very impressive. I had to listen rather carefully as I too was wondering if it was you or Annie singing! *lol* The lack of perfection comments, don't listen to them. Professional singers aren't always perfect either ie; Enya singing May It Be, live. Her voice shakes in all the vids I found.
This is the best into the west cover I've seen. and i don't care what all these people who are telling you your voice sucks say, you're a beast. keep making videos.
this is you singing? i really thought it was annie. usually i criticise songs sung by "unknown" but this is really amazing! you should really think about starting a career with your voice! i would die for a voice like that and i think i'm quite a good singer...
you are correct, reading back, what i wrote sounds incredibly condescending. what i meant to convey by "one who studies" was that i was speaking from a technical point of view. i may study music, but i cant sing for shit - - i wouldn't have the balls to put my stuff out there, so,yea i was just trying to give you an honest opinion, because you are obviously passionate, love the song, and you should stick with what you love doing. high notes were your best!
Hey, This is a very wonderfull song, and you sang it without any sort problems, not so good quality, but still i hear the potential. 1. question, are you a man or a woman. and this is not to be rud, but on the originale, i had to thing. but i no now. its annie lenox. hehe please anwer?
wowza!! when u first started i thought it was annie lennox and then i read the title properly and could only tell the difference by listening very hard.
that's actually pretty good...at some points it seemed a little off and flat...but better than most covers i've seen, you put a lot of feeling into it, and thats what matters, you have to sing with your heart.....good job
Sometimes it's the hardest to hear our own pitch... your expression is lovely - and I'm not trying to be a vocal coach here see if you can sing it slightly sharp and then find the middle point...
Hold onto your memories with your Dad,and know he Loved you enough to sit through this movie with you even though he was sick, believe me,he always knew how much you loved him too! May he rest in Peace.
C.J. OMG!!!!! I like this better than Annie's version NO LIE...Your voice is so calming and relaxing and this is one of my fav. trilogy's of all time, watch it all time, man you did this song so well...Thanks so much for doing this one!
i can sing EXACTLY like cher and u just inspired me to try annie lennox and i am actually a soprano idk how good my voice is, i like it most of the times but im no por or anything
we are singiing this song in chior and thats why i looked it up with lyrics and i found your and i am truly glad i did. i m an Alto (female) and could never truly get my voice right for this song like you did you are an amazing, amazing tenor very very good...nice high notes and i love your voice. the only other words i can say are: Breath Taking.
A little bit flat at parts but even still it was great, its really hard for a guy to sing that cause parts are so high pitched but you got past that, great job :)
MrZENESSENCE 10 months ago
this is by far the best cover version of this song i have ever heard!
JohnNelsonPhotos 1 year ago
Immensely good, you are very talented. Although, I would've liked to maybe hear an arrangement that diverged away from the original. But still veeeeeery good.
johnstupid 1 year ago
AMAZING! AND DA PICTURES IN DA BACKROUND WER GREAT AND REALLY ADEDDED TO IT! Until I read ppl's comments I thought dat was da real fing! I love dat song n u did a great job of it!
MrZENESSENCE 1 year ago
this fuckin song always makes me cry.
xBisexualxAtheistx 1 year ago
This may seem rude or offencive, sorry! But are you a guy or a girl?
The "what can you see on the horizon" is deffinately where you sound best.
XxWrath333Xx 1 year ago
I seriously thought this was the real thing for a moment. Awesome job.
BrianLeexx 1 year ago
Your voice is almost like annie's , beautiful!!
Selllaaahh 1 year ago
What a solid piece of work. Thanks for sharing!
kubarebo 1 year ago
wow!! this sounds exactly like the original!!! but you put your own unique twist on it :) GREAT JOB!
fuzzyfirebunny 1 year ago
beautiful job :)
dorthyrlee 1 year ago
Hello,
Is this Annie Lenox's voice, or your own.
I presume it is Annie's (despite the other comments), but please let me know if not. VERY grateful to hear from you!
Magar6 1 year ago
Hello,
Is this Annie Lenox's voice, or your own.
I presume it is Annie's (despite the other comments), but please let me know if not. VERY grateful to hear from you!
Thanks
Andrew
Magar6 1 year ago
@Magar6 His voice, OBVIOUSLY?
Lanidrac92 1 year ago
thank you for this great job! 5* for you
DarkDamnationDark 2 years ago
Beautiful!
Magar6 2 years ago
i'm not being rude but alot of the notes that u r singing r out of tune and that is the easy notes the high notes r good. overall it is still good u just need to watch those notes. still love it. if i have offended u then be sure to let me no. hay try and listen to the song that wasnt used called Use well the days. any questions on LOTR be sure to ask me I CAN SPEAK ELVISH.
cheesecheesecheesey 2 years ago
Extrememly beautiful. At 3:58 it is amazing.
Magar6 2 years ago
wow
amazing
HarryPotterPower 2 years ago
i listen to this over and over you have such a good voice like american idol worthy i almost like it better flat xD....
Eyelinermadolliss 2 years ago
Its the same thing with a new singer. Do something new. You do have a good voice though.
HelloNurseWink 2 years ago
I could listen to this for hours, utterly amazing!
chizman32 2 years ago
You're amazing. No offense, but are you a woman or a man? Its difficult to tell, but your voice is truly beautiful. True talent.
Blogsterle 2 years ago
@Blogsterle I'm guessing at male. Skimmed a tad, but didn't see any confirmation from earthonika either way. Listen to the upper range carefully.
@earhonika: Well done! If you are indeed a man, this is very impressive. I had to listen rather carefully as I too was wondering if it was you or Annie singing! *lol* The lack of perfection comments, don't listen to them. Professional singers aren't always perfect either ie; Enya singing May It Be, live. Her voice shakes in all the vids I found.
PhoenixBlackthorn 1 year ago
This is the best into the west cover I've seen. and i don't care what all these people who are telling you your voice sucks say, you're a beast. keep making videos.
a147aaron 2 years ago 4
VERY Elvish!
dannyVulture 2 years ago 2
Absolutely amazing!!! You should be very proud of your talent!!! Your higher notes are you best but the entire cover was incredible!! *golf claps*
puppeetoe 2 years ago 4
I liked it, no matter wha the others say :D
very well made =)
greatlotrfan 2 years ago 3
are you kidding??
this is you singing? i really thought it was annie. usually i criticise songs sung by "unknown" but this is really amazing! you should really think about starting a career with your voice! i would die for a voice like that and i think i'm quite a good singer...
(sorry for my english, i'm from germany^^)
lille1012 2 years ago 2
pffffffffffff... please... it's just a bad falsetto.
shamalaga 2 years ago
looks like someone is jealous ;P
i think it's pretty good! not perfekt but much better then most people could make it.
JohnNortek 2 years ago 8
this is the "as one who studies" guy...
you are correct, reading back, what i wrote sounds incredibly condescending. what i meant to convey by "one who studies" was that i was speaking from a technical point of view. i may study music, but i cant sing for shit - - i wouldn't have the balls to put my stuff out there, so,yea i was just trying to give you an honest opinion, because you are obviously passionate, love the song, and you should stick with what you love doing. high notes were your best!
natjhj 2 years ago
I thought he was going to completely fail on the high notes, but you actually did okay..
Simonomon2 2 years ago 4
I wanna cry when I hear this song. It's wierd. No other song hits me like that. (Other than the song at the end of Gran torino...)
Bradiztheman 2 years ago
You have such a fantastic singing voice. I love it so much!!!
foxstar10 2 years ago 2
indeed!!! really good singer! :)))))))
LilouParker 2 years ago
Omg u Have a great voice i thought it was Annie Lennox... great video love it :) ty for posting this song all ways manages to get me crying :(
duomaxwell123 2 years ago
OMG! you are a REALLY GOOD singer!!
RockstarChick898 2 years ago
Omg.. I thought it was the original..
You're really talented.. keep it up ^^
subscribed~~!!!
durianice 2 years ago
wonderfull song!!!!!!!
kynanblender 2 years ago
Hey, This is a very wonderfull song, and you sang it without any sort problems, not so good quality, but still i hear the potential. 1. question, are you a man or a woman. and this is not to be rud, but on the originale, i had to thing. but i no now. its annie lenox. hehe please anwer?
snakeinmyass 2 years ago
wowza!! when u first started i thought it was annie lennox and then i read the title properly and could only tell the difference by listening very hard.
very well done!
Ravagad 2 years ago
This song is so peaceful & beautiful, like a lullaby.
BestEvaGal 2 years ago
This is awesome!!! As one of the biggest fan of LOTR, I think this really cool!
tangle2nite 2 years ago
:D very nice i love your voice, you sang very well
icegoddesslexra 2 years ago 2
You sounded awesome at this part.
"What can you see
On the horizon?
Why do the white gulls call? "
alcaknight 2 years ago 10
you sung that?that was amazing!thanks for putting this up.i'm a boy so i need to know what pitch to do for a show and this really helps!
Joezilla219 2 years ago 2
LOVE it! and i didnt even notice the pitching difference until i read the other comment :P
jamiedonne 2 years ago
one ov theee best songs ever written for one ov thee best films ever made...
2866037 2 years ago 4
awsome love this song!!!!
lajorn 2 years ago 3
Very well done! :)
Immemorials 2 years ago 4
that's actually pretty good...at some points it seemed a little off and flat...but better than most covers i've seen, you put a lot of feeling into it, and thats what matters, you have to sing with your heart.....good job
oozablondie 2 years ago 5
Sometimes it's the hardest to hear our own pitch... your expression is lovely - and I'm not trying to be a vocal coach here see if you can sing it slightly sharp and then find the middle point...
all the best!
NagaBukko 2 years ago
AMAMZING!!!!!!!
BeccaCullen111 2 years ago 2
excellent effort and lovely production ~ you are singing slightly under pitch throughout...
NagaBukko 2 years ago 3
your a little flat
hoggoshowgo 2 years ago
Great :) you sound realy good :)
0sska 2 years ago
sounds amazing
BenRaikes 2 years ago
You covered a song that I really enjoy and I actually like it.
Bravo.
Runeblade279 3 years ago 3
Muito bom, gostei demais, parabéns.
kalashinicov1945 3 years ago
Idc if its a guy or girl, it sounds gr8
puggle7882 3 years ago
can't tell if its a guy or girls voice..but it doesn't matter..it was gr8...when is your the CD coming out?..: )
thatsMYbeef 3 years ago
its a girl her name is annie lenox :D
BeccaCullen111 2 years ago
You sang that amazingly! Well done
beczsmile 3 years ago
You have a great voice, if you hadn't said so, I probably would have thought it was Annie.
WHEELSBRANUM 3 years ago 2
i have to sing this song 4 chorus!!!its okay.......but..........IT ROCKS BUTT
sorriana45 3 years ago
I love you Dad, never forget you, this is for you!
candyshopgirl71 3 years ago 5
Hold onto your memories with your Dad,and know he Loved you enough to sit through this movie with you even though he was sick, believe me,he always knew how much you loved him too! May he rest in Peace.
rljames54 3 years ago
Awe...Thanks for that, you are so sweet! Love ya!
XSTaTICPROCeSS71 3 years ago
C.J. OMG!!!!! I like this better than Annie's version NO LIE...Your voice is so calming and relaxing and this is one of my fav. trilogy's of all time, watch it all time, man you did this song so well...Thanks so much for doing this one!
candyshopgirl71 3 years ago 2
I agree with you! You said it best,what more can I say? *****
rljames54 3 years ago
i can sing EXACTLY like cher and u just inspired me to try annie lennox and i am actually a soprano idk how good my voice is, i like it most of the times but im no por or anything
linguini12345 3 years ago
I am one of the biggest Lord of The Rings fan ever and i am really touched by your piece of art!
POPDIVA20 3 years ago
we are singiing this song in chior and thats why i looked it up with lyrics and i found your and i am truly glad i did. i m an Alto (female) and could never truly get my voice right for this song like you did you are an amazing, amazing tenor very very good...nice high notes and i love your voice. the only other words i can say are: Breath Taking.
DomainOfPeace 3 years ago
i am run out of words,i could only say...............awesome
hardtohaveaname 3 years ago
Stunning.
You sing this so good.
: ) <3 I could sure learn a thing or to from you.
Any tips on singing ?
GoldElement18 3 years ago
That's a very kind of you to say...I guess the best advice is to connect with the meaning of the song...Sing from your heart...
earthonika 3 years ago
Why thank you.
: )
GoldElement18 3 years ago
Lord of the rings is my favourite movie ever made! and this song is beautiful! =)
KakaTehPinguin 3 years ago
Thank you for the upload.
black0rose 3 years ago
beautiful...sooo tear-jerking...^^
MaximA014 3 years ago
nice
irgndwer 3 years ago
thank u my friend..this is a very special vid 4 me..
davidof619902 3 years ago
This is really beautiful, thank you.
loveknot3 3 years ago 4
great job man god bless you
estell35 3 years ago 2
Much appreciated...Thank you...
earthonika 3 years ago
beautiful. this is one of my favourite songs to sing from LOTR, and I am attempting to teach myself the piano part(with little success so far...)
ScottishLady11 3 years ago
wow, amazing tenor-ness
I'm a bass... a LOW bass so I'm doing it like an octave or 2 below but seriously that's amazing
fatman987234 3 years ago
My favourite part of the song it's at 1:29 :]
dgcrew 3 years ago
Gorgeous! Beautiful voice and emotion.
StereoSpace 3 years ago
Nearly like the original!
ToFKPaan 3 years ago 2
WOW it's really u singing?!
NinjaMatt27 3 years ago
wow, thats awesome, your voice is amazing!
ToFKPaan 3 years ago
Thanx...I'm glad you enjoyed it...
earthonika 3 years ago
Really good.
Cerb 3 years ago
WOW.
You're awesome.
You have a beautiful voice, and you definitely have the right voice for the song. :D
xdieromanticx928 3 years ago
bravissimo
PIOSSA 3 years ago
I agree! Your voice is great for this song!
keepinlow 3 years ago
You have such a magical voice! Perfectly suited for this song. Thank you for sharing your talents here on youtube. :)
firefly4tori 3 years ago 4
Absolutley Beautiful! This is one of my favorite movies,Thank You for the post!
rljames54 3 years ago 4