garbage - the trick is to keep breathing

[jeff42416]

shirley has beautiful eyes.wow the scottish.

[evavigo]

oh, the 90s!!

[nwchrista]

Luv this song, dig her vocal tonal qualities...her hair is very cute up like that.

[nwchrista]

Luv this song...her hair is very cute up like that.

[vivjfriday]

great turn of the century nostalgia

[chicharinujilla]

she'll always be my number one!!! thumbs up!!!!

[Hokonopogo]

Wow, she was so young in this video!

[helikestv]

@Hokonopogo 32?

[herbheads]

followed these guys from the beginning, saw at least two shows in Toronto.

This is exceptional footage with some video effects and transitions.

The audio is of a high quality live mix.

Shirley puts out deep, with strong emotion in her singing; phenomenal performance, band was tight.

[infIikkt]

she looks like shes about to cry @ 3:40. thats so hot <3333

[1licious1]

this is garbage literally, rubbish, she sings like shit!!!!!!

someon shut her up please!!!!!!!!

i can't stand this shit!!!!

[benisdown]

@1licious1 funnu how only some one who sucks cock would say shit like that!

[1licious1]

@benisdown ur talkin about your mama right????

[benisdown]

@1licious1 LAME ASS you damn well i was talking about your tranny mom!

[1licious1]

they suck !!!!!!

[benisdown]

@1licious1 if they suck you swallow! you swallowed it!

[1licious1]

@benisdown i might have swallowed it but doesn't change the fact that they suck, bad!!!!!!!!!

[1licious1]

@1licious1 am i not aloud to not like them?????

[benisdown]

@1licious1 ha haaa i knew it you are a FAG!!!

[1licious1]

@benisdown and u a bitch!!!!!

[benisdown]

@1licious1 im no bitch but you admitted that you are a cock smoker! lmfao little faggot in desperate need of attention!

[tartansam]

@benisdown So.... you are 31... and think thats its ok to call someone a "cock smoker" and "faggot", and "i knew you were a FAG"? Not only are your comments offensive to gay people(which I take it your insults are directed to) but its kinda sad at your age to 1.Use language that an ignorant teenager would use and 2. Use a persons sexuality/any old "gay" insult to try and offend someone..I wasn't aware it was the early 1900s.

You have really embarrassed yourself.

[benisdown]

@tartansam hey asshole this other asshole is talking shit about my band! 2). im not sure if your gay or not but im going to asume that you are; if you can take a dick you can take a joke! stop being such a fag!

[Damian609]

@tartansam ...Dude... wtf... nice way to get a following... u wanna argue, u don't do it here.... take it to ur own channel... no room for prejudice of any kind here....period.

[tartansam]

@Damian609 whilst the convo wasnt directed and had nothing to do with you, I will just clarify that you seem to have missed my point- I was saying to the person in question that it wasnt nice to insult people, some of his comments were very offensive, have a another read of it-and you are correct that there is no room for prejudice in here-which was my whole point.

Kind regards :-)

[Damian609]

@tartansam i don't believe i was disagreeing with you... unfortunately, the comment went to you instead of the offender in which case i do apologize (even w/o being able to access ur original post),....if you don't want feed back there are adjustments u can make... it's a public forum... thanks for ur kind regards... back at ya

[icabal1]

Amazing song, this fits my mind so well.

And its great to hear a band play live rather than all the miming you get now

[arogancija]

God how much i love this !!!!!!!!!!!!

[tootapatootaxD]

This only sounds a lot like "Enjoy the silence", yeah but thats just it.

[007AuFinger]

Oh, was the rest of the band there too. What a pure voice, I'm speechless. Frik'n French, they don't appreciate Shirl like we do.

[derelictus]

Shirley looks beautiful here..

[ucenigma]

I went to a CD and poster signing at Tower Records here in Chicago over 10 years ago and still love their music to this day.

[atolm1]

She is such a gifted and underrated vocalist; she has a voice with soul. Love her and the band.

[iamsoification]

la mia extraterrestre preferita

my favorite e.t.

[gregasm]

Absolutely world class style and execution. Much respect and admiration.

[oscartata]

increible mujer

[TechnicalEvaluation]

Beautiful song from my favorite of all their albums.

[cb2000a]

Yep she is good....so is the whole group.

[ParanoidandFine]

@cb2000a agreed! I love Shirley's voice heaps, I think she's talented and unique and the most awesome all-round singer. But it's just as good to realize how capable Butch, Steve and Duke are, and how they've finally enjoyed the success in Garbage that eluded them for a long time before. Their instrument and production skills are as vital as Shirley is to the success of the band. This is the one song/band I want to be listening to as I die, I love it!

[maulser90]

shirley manson!!!! the best voice ever!!! unbelievable

[InsEvolution]

Beautiful song, but I couldn't help but laugh at the guy caughing near the end xD Love the video!

[Finito866]

one of the best female live performers ever.

[tartansam]

love Shirley Manson. She has turned me straight. Well not quite lol. :-)

[folklore]

what an amazing girl..

[babyif19]

I heart her!!!!

[MacTempleton]

l'acide

[sephirothhatescloud]

excellent song from my childhood. I wish more people would listen to thi over stupid girl

[PilotoMAF]

I love her voice!

[dbzlover27]

shirley manson i love you! garbage ruuuulez! :)

[glowingliketheocean]

they sound so good live. not a lot of disparity from the studio version.

[Zenon2006]

great song

[ThisIsNotMyIdea]

just beautiful ...

[andrea111292]

This song is truely amazing...

Didn't make it to the charts ..but still it's one of their very best . And I noticed it's the favourite song of many people too :)

[marknaki123]

the trick is to keep breathing is personally my favorite garbage song. i dont know why, it just stands out for me. its perfect.

[scwomanchangeling2]

cute Hair!

[fsandoval60]

Absolutely love this song. Played it 20 times in a row one day.

[SpecialVersion09]

The Trick Is To Write Songs As So Damn Good As Garbage Do...

[zodiacgirl3]

my favorite song from Garbage....

[sayheytome]

it is wrong to copyright videos on youtube. there are bands and songs i never heard of. how do they expect you to buy the video or music if you never see or hear of it? copyright claimers need some brains or drink a beer to think about this!

[LauriVilleCrow]

VERY VERY WELL SAID!!

Especially the part of "..need some brains.."

I TOTALLY AGREE with you.

[ShenmueAtheist]

great vid, although it pisses me off that they took off the original music vid for this song.

[marknaki123]

hey if you cant find the original music video, andrea111292 uploaded it onto youtube

[andrea111292]

Hey! I'm famous! :)

Anyway , yes , it's true , I uploaded it on youtube and they're not gonna remove it , stupid copyrights claimers fuckers!

[edy18620]

i know.

[thamig87]

Best live performance of them on youtube...sound quality really really good

[neoskosmos01]

amazing song...

[conicall]

great. what a hairstyle ! : D

[Mjollnir4001]

Garbage is a great band:I love their music.

Is there a woman alive cooler than Shirley Manson?

[clockorange16]

Hmm, maybe only one!!!!

[maiagey]

who?

[fivecougarsoz]

3 words ... beautiful, beautiful, beautiful

[LiLitH2pOiNt0]

.. mi himno personaaaal.! ^^

wuaa.!

eiios son simplemente

geniaaales.!

[SonicadeMusic]

Great live performance of an amazing song.

[nullnpo]

i like...

[rocka80]

I LOVEEE Shirley;)

[invirused]

the band was great..and she is beautiful

[soacker25]

Incredible live performance, with a few differernt nuances, that makes it even more exciting....the trick is to keep dreaming...

thanks for the upload :*

[annawantstorock]

I saw Garbage in concert back when I was in high school. I was in the 2nd row, and it was one of the BEST concerts I have ever been to. I wish they would tour again!! That concert will always be one of my top bestmoments in my life!!

[rhezzz]

garbage!!!!!!!! Shirley!! MY GOD.......WE HAVE OUR OWN FALLEN ANGEL.....:) Love u Shirley.

[marixalilith]

shes a porcelain doll....i adore her

[botneva]

This song is one of my favourites. Shirley looks beautiful here (as usual).

[ontologic7]

that girl can fucking sing. it's nice to see real talent. bjork go yell and squeel some where else.

[gabyrivera]

shirley shirley shirley... her voice, the music, the lyrics... are just perfect!!!

[KeaneQueen11981]

This song is very personal for me. It almost makes me cry

[millienyc]

Shirley looks and sounds so ethereal. Thank you for posting this!

[ontologic7]

garbage rocks. Shirley rocked in Angelfish as well and before that. She is an awesome musical force. This song is about surviving an emotional abuse relationship. much like her music intensity i'm pretty sure it spills into her personal life as well.Were all human. Shirley just looks better doing it!! lol

[angelirlanda]

esta cancion me trae muy buenos recuerdos............

[gat1982]

que buena cancion...

[gpx44]

Excllent live performance, Shirley

the band. Great song.

[DOCspoof]

i absolutely love this song. my favorite one actually. its the first song i ever heard from garbage and now im hooked. they shouldve made a remix of this song too on Absolute Garbage.

[ovoomusic]

Beautiful version.

Thank you for posting!

[mooky9669]

I wore this cd out...one of the best ever...I love this song and Shirley is amazing!!

[DakotaMCX50]

garbage rules....

[otep4president]

an amazing poet...

[kubagryniewicz]

jest grubo.

[JohnLennon100]

GReat Song Great Performance

[IMDLEGEND]

I love this song, this is the main why I purchased the album again (I lost the first copy I had when it first came out).  Its so hypnotic!

[tzorf]

One of my fav Garbage songs!!

Wanna see them live bad!!

[dvorak18]

Such a great song. too bad it wasnt included in their best hits compilation.

[luckymincer]

you are so right...we were robbed

[zrhop]

she looks like a goddess with the voice of an angel.

[udavidovic]

Absolutely the best Garbage track ever. Shirley is awesome.

[andywinch80]

I agree with you SO MUCH..........

this is my fave garbage track off all time !

[andywinch80]

My favourite GARBAGE track off all time !

I love this band, I love this tune !

What talent it takes to write something as powerfull as this, great stuff !

This album will ALWAYS be one of my favourites.

[XquisiteVx]

She's amazing live. Props to them for being so fucking awesome. Love Garbage!

[warwitus]

Been a fan since 95! saw them and no doubt live back in 2000 they were great! Shirley you're breathtaking!

[Ezniter]

MUJER MARAVILLOSA!!!

TE AMOOOOOO SHIRLEY!!!!

Nada como haberla visto en vivo... ojala regresen a mexico... es un millon de veces mas bella en persona X3~~~~~~~~~~

[boladao923]

meu deus do ceu

q mulher é essa?!

a shyrl é d+

linda

[romatzer]

Mi dios ??? Que mujes es esa? Shirly es la mas linda, muito bonita Eso dijistes?

[greshadj]

Wow,after so many years i feel like im listen it for the first time,Shirley is the best and my name is Mirko,Best singer ever....and im bigest fan!!!

[poohaironu2]

I love this song..

[pumucklinka]

anyone saw her without make up? but anyway I love Garbage and Shirley is a great singer.

[themlo]

yes she gets all shy without make up i saw it in one of the support videos...

[DEFkon001]

yes! Shirley did a number of shots for a magazine (CK?) that featured her without any makeup. She does look very different but i think i actually prefer her natural look. you might also be able to sample some quick clips of her without makeup on the "thank you for the uhh support" documentary, which has lots of behind the scenes stuff.

[andrea111292]

Yes also in the scene with ferrero rocher.She's too funny

[infectedmonkeybite]

I love this version, and love Shirley.

Is she hot or what!

[musicgirl999]

Well you know she's only like 43 right now, right?

[silenzioradio]

Now? 41

[musicgirl999]

no. shes 43

[flegsiboy]

41 actually.and so fucking what. that may seem ancient to a fucking kid like you but it's barely middle age.

[N00D13]

yea she's 41 now, but in this show she would have still been in her 30's, but she's always had the heart of an intelligent n mature 18 yr old

[bubblewarped]

really? 41? she doesn't look like it. she's just like in her 20s and never grows old.. which is nice! I hope garbage makes another album =)

[N00D13]

garbage might make another album in the not-so-near future, but this year, may 27th shirley's releasing a solo album, and dayum im excited!!

[bubblewarped]

a solo album? i hope she still rocks, unlike gwen who became a popstar.. I wonder if there are any previews to her upcoming album?

[greenrangr125]

i'm pretty sure it's no longer being released that soon due to problems with her record company thinking it's too ''noir''

[cannylad]

smokin mate ,just smokin

[benolly22]

just brilliant

[maapapu]

eres mi idolo shirley

[Alfarc83]

LOVE THIS SONG

[melphis]

how can i access the webpage? user name and password?

[Brady2511]

I don't like this live perfomance. I absolutely love how the low notes in the studio version when she sings the "Lately I'm not the only one" part, and here she sings it so different...

[rufuswashere]

Most underrated band in history.

What a song, and what a performance.

[poohaironu2]

so true.

[hynl]

Future wife.

Lots of love and hopes and dreams.

M>L>A>

[337ttyl]

....Breathtaking.

[lomba98]

she is the best!!

[cuitlapanton]

I won´t be the one who´s going to let you down,

maybe we get what we want this time around......

[milkyabbi]

el mejor disco de estos grandes carajos es y sera version 2.0, definitivamente, no hay otro disco mas arrecho en la historia de garbage, para mi, es y sera version 2.0, y esta cancion es muy buena

[alexdos316]

she's an amazing performer,i mean just look at her...great son great vocals,great girl....go shirley

[MikeKakashi18]

i love this song shes such a good singer

[devilishMortisha]

i love this song and i love shirley manson. she looks so hot in this vid - no stupid blonde hairs...version 2.0 was awesome - i miss the time

[senecaslucius]

Yep I second that ... the 2.0 era was terrific but now ... it is a real pity. They are/were good and really have/had potential. 2.0 was amazing, BeautifulGarbage... was OK ...

[Outrack]

Is it just me, or does she seem to lack the kind of raw emotion she had back in the 2.0 era? Not just with this song, but virtually everything since the Beautiful album has lacked impact...

[kawaiihimistu]

awesome!!

[bimbz72]

This is good....no....really good!!

[cuitlapanton]

lately I´m no the only one. Thanks

[BiruteB]

ok, I'll try...

[BiruteB]

ok, I'll try..

[BiruteB]

do u have "Sara meets Shirley (interview) vid? I see, it's not on youtube, but I can't upload it on 'Tube 'cos it's too long or smth like this.. :/

[DuckyBG]

now i don't have it :(

but maybe you can upload it in 2 parts (or m ore?)

like i did with the rockpalast concert ?

[DuckyBG]

this is one of my favourite garbage videos!

i've seen a shorter version befor but the longer, the better :P (is that good english?)