Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (537)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i think taeyeon is better.. her voice more stronger

  • She didnt pull the long note. And taeyeon voice was stronger. Nicole looks like she had a longggg night.

  • people stop comparing taeyeon is good and nicole is also great so WTF stop comparing

  • woah...Even Taengoo is mentioned here... <3

  • azunnoj002 taeyeon bad..nicole vocal

  • amazing

  • HER VOICE IS pretty pitchy and strained on the highs ...

  • she go solo or not still SHES A FILIPINA WHOM WE FILIPINOS SHOULD BE PROUD OF!!!!! so back off haters! peace♥

  • Fuck off you asians. she is better than ur little asian girl

  • @jacob123JS nicoles asian as well...

  • would've been better with back-up dancers.. and i agree her voice suits this song... but Taeyeon pulled it better really well and her (Taeyeon) live voice was amazing and clear.. sorry Nicole ♥

  • thumbs up if you come here because you're watching Tae Yeon's

  • She sounds exhausted.

  • i love her and the song shes a good singer but how come wen they sing live it sounds really bad just sayin no i'm not bein rude I LOVE U NICOLE.

  • she was my bias before and now taengoo is.. gotta admit they're both amazing! different style vocals can't be compared!

  • smoke and mirrors

  • I just noticed that most of SNSD's fans are here.

  • sorry to disagree, I'm Taeyeon fan but I'm think Nicole is the best to sing this song. Her voice suits this kinda song better, Nicole has more powerful voice to turn people listening to the song on.

  • @FYIize of course, it's her song , I'm Taeyeon fan too ^^

  • Nicole's voice is so powerful, listen to her ballads " I'll be your love" just blew me away completely. This is not one of her best live perf but still much better than TY's version for me :)

  • Comment removed

  • where are the high notes i love so much about this song ....artists often let me down when they sing live :(((

  • Taeyeon's is better! I'm surprised so many people know Taeyeon :D

  • so low !

  • Nicole is such a beautiful woman.

  • not to ruin this song but look pause at 2:20-2:21 it shows her nip and i would love to suck on that :/

  • your correct

  • She is very beautiful and very talented!!!))))

  • perfeita

    

  • heheh its funny how ppl compare her with Taeyeon,taeyeon might sing well for this song but if you see Nicole she's the only singer,she sing the whole concert with a bits of Melody while SNSD is 9persons which everyone get a chance to get on stage to perform solo and Taeyeon have time to slow down while nicole is not..so see the whole picture

  • @belacanmelatox uh, what? if Nicole slowed down, i would say the song would of sounded better, but TaeYeon sings it in the same speed? well maybe alittle slower,

    your comment is useless because there's nothing in your comment that will make Nicole better then Tae Yeon's voice...

    nice try tho :)

    not trying to offend u.

  • @pokerockman oooo thank You~~ :) nicole still did better than her, im not a fan of nicole also can hear she did better than taeyeon..overall nicole vocal can go R&B, sexy and etc while Taeyeon? eemm same all the way :)

  • @belacanmelatox Actually, Tae Yeon has a very cute voice too, she has a loud + cute voice, if you listen to some of her vocals...

    *damn talking about her sweetens my heart*

  • @pokerockman - What belacanmelatox said is that it's easier for TaeYeon since she's not singing all the time during their concert, she only sings some lines for each songs and then she did her solo. Nicole always sing the full songs alone, that's why she's more tired than TaeYeon during a concert.

    I agree that TaeYeon always sings in the same way, she lacks emotion. Most of the time it looks like she only sings without thinking about the lyrics... She doesn't feel the songs =S

  • @KazuuuX3 I kind of got that later on :P

    any way, if you really want me to, i could go to the MV and do the same...

    and she doesn't have emotion? WUUT... Listen to Gee... *so cute* o.O

    anyway... xD your opinion, my opinion. Finished :)

  • @pokerockman - OK we both have different opinions it's alright. I know Gee is a cute song but you know, all the groups in KPOP have cute songs and they all can sing in a cute way. If you ask me, some SNSD members sing "cute" in a better way than TaeYeon... Now if you talk about real songs that show off vocals, there's like... 10 videos where TaeYeon is good. Other than that I don't like her voice that much. It's always the same and she should work on emotion...

    That's all ^^"

  • @KazuuuX3 Still... she does have a different song with a little bit of emotion right?

    btw i like/agree with your opinion :P

    and yeh i guess your right, k-pop = CUTE CENTRAL *TaeYeon in charge tho xD*

    Nice Talking to you too :D

  • @pokerockman - Oh so you agree with me :P Cool. She sings with emotion sometimes, like when she sings "If" or when she does covers on radio (like I Have A Lover) but other than that I'm not a fan of her voice and she's not that great to me haha~~

    Yeah it was nice talking to you XD

  • @KazuuuX3 : lol. how much emotion do you want taeyeon to exude? do you want her to pour her entire heart out and overdo it? the emotion she expresses is just enough to make her performance entertaining. at least a lot of Koreans love her singing. there's a reason why she's popular among not only in the kpop industry but in the professional music industry in korea too. how would you know if she doesn't "feel" the song?lol. only the singer would truly know.

  • @Lecmar91 - I have the right to have my own opinion, right? I just think TaeYeon doesn't feel the song when she sings, that's MY opinion. It's like, she's singing, sometimes she can hit the high notes, but about emotions? I have like... 10/15 videos where she sings with emotion. Other than that, she just "sings" without delivering the right emotion. and believe me, it's something important. You can love a singer when you listen to a song, but when it's LIVE they need to sing it the right way.

  • @KazuuuX3 : lol you determine 'emotion' by the numbers of videos? lol just lol. "right" emotion? since when was there a "right" emotion?? rofl. and have you truly heard her sing live to judge her? okay then. you're right, it's YOUR opinion. just a typical subjective opinion.... oh well, at least korean music professionals and the majority think otherwise ^^. happy new years eve to you~

  • @Lecmar91 - Oh please. When did I determine emotion by the number of videos? I said that I saw her singing a lot of covers & only some of them are great. Professionals think she's good because when she sings in the right way, SHE IS REALLY GOOD but that doesn't mean she always sings well. Sometimes she cracks her voice, she lipsyncs, she sings without emotion & there's no need to be professional to see it. Professionals judge her based on her good performances, obviously.

    Happy new year to you!

  • @KazuuuX3 : just because she has a few bad performances doesn't mean she is any less of an awesome singer/performer. although consistency is key, when you're constantly busy such as her or snsd, her performance prowess decreases. ever since they debuted, she(along w/ the other members) would put in ALL their effort. these days, w/ promotions in Japan, Korea and all over Asia, what do you expect from her? that's why professionals judge her based on when she gives it her all.

  • @KazuuuX3 : it's not fair to hold it against her because as busy as she and snsd is, it's extremely difficult to put in all their effort. i notice that you're a wonderful. i can apply to sunye and yenny the accusations you made w/ taeyeon. they've had performances too where they crack or didn't do too well. i've seen MR removed videos and i'm not impressed. I still think they're good singers but they have their flaws. is it fair to judge them based on their flaws? no.

  • @Lecmar91 - (1st comment) First of all I never said SunYe or YeEun are perfect singers. But when they sing ballads there's emotion. It's not about schedule, WG have concerts everywhere but when they sing ballads it's always great. Of course it's stupid to judge them by MR Removed of performances of Tell Me, So Hot... these are "cute" songs and they aren't even singing (for real). It's like Gee or Oh!. Now I'm talking about ballads only... I think you just don't know the difference...

  • @KazuuuX3 : a person's schedule has to be factored in when talking about how well they do. and for taeyeon, who had a busy itinerary, she is NOT a robot who can sing 'emotionally' on default. and the fact that it was a DUET, didn't help either. we all know that taeyeon tries to focus on getting the lyrics and pitches right when singing a duet. when she sang a studio cover of "because you loved me" w/ seohyun, she had to turn the other way around just so she can focus.

  • @Lecmar91 - (2nd comment) You say there are few bad performance of TaeYeon. Honestly, she doesn't sing ballads all the time, only some of them are great. I think the best thing to do is to give you an example so you'll understand what I mean...

    TaeYeon singing A Goose's Dream - watch?v=q_BV_n_bsAc

    SoHyang singing A Goose's Dream - watch?v=q7WMIHUBG8A

    You have to understand the lyrics too so you'll feel the emotions better ;)

    No offense, I love TaeYeon's voice when she's doing good covers<333

  • @KazuuuX3 : taeyeon does well on ballads, that's why she's requested to sing for OSTs by many in the industry because of her smooth and versatile voice. but she's had her moments where she doesn't give it her all which can be attributed to several factors such as snsd activities and her general schedule, just like any other idol in the industry who are busy people. and in terms of taeyeon singing "hush hush," she probably doesn't even know what she's singing since it's in english.

  • @Lecmar91 - All idols have their schedules, and they all are different. Some people can still sing even when they have a big schedule. Maybe TaeYeon can't. All I tried to say, it's that TaeYeon is NOT the best singer of the world like some Sones said. The best singer has to be the BEST. Nobody cares about schedule or the fact that she needs to focus on the song. If she can't be the best then she's not. It doesn't mean she's not great... PS: Mariah Carey is not a robot, she can sing, that's all.

  • @pokerockman owh i see an obsessive fan, cute voice? anyone can do that especially baby..hahah okay im chow~~ atleast someone else get what i meant

  • @belacanmelatox uh... not OBSESSIVE... but just that i love her :P

    come on, listen to Gee... its so CUTE...

    and no, come on... you know what i mean by CUTE voice... not baby cute...

    its *sexy,cute*

    and what do you mean? you mean bye? thats chao btw :P

  • @belacanmelatox Not OBSESSIVE but... just a fan that loves her :)

    and come on... have you not listened to Gee? that was SO CUTE!!!.

    Plus, you know what i mean by cute voice right? *sexy cute* :)

    and i am guessing your saying bye with chow? its chao, isn't it? xD

    anyway... chao.

  • @pokerockman ohh,i know its CHAO,but i like CHOW betterr, nway yeah nice to talk to you

  • You can convert this to an mp3 at instantmp3s..com

  • i think she's very tired......her sound already tired......=(

  • 2:43 "that's for you baby!"-- no,it wasn't. she was literally exhausted!

  • @kok1able lol, true

  • hey, nicole is the first one to sing this, so she must be the best to sing it too! :) besides she has to dance so much, and i guess u all know how hard pcd's dance moves r!! im suprised she can still sing like this! look how she move on the stage while singing, tae cant do that!!! just face the fact that taeyeon has a long way too be a real singer like nicole!!! nicole's so amazing!! ♥

  • I think she should do a solo career...I watched the Pussy cat dolls videos and she is the only one that actually sings...Maybe cuz the other ones cant sing lol

  • i still love her. its hard to sing several songs  you know. :))

  • if she was on like x factor she probably get through with this performance but i love her.

  • Her throats must've hurt after this performance. Nicole you're awesome ! I love you ~ <3

  • WHy didn't she do the High Note ??

    Taeyeon's version of Hush Hush is better,

  • @Cookykey where i can find this version?

  • @littlelinkinquar write snsd taeyeon hush hush ^^

  • @Cookykey Talk about anti climatic

  • fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!!!!!!!!!!­!!!

  • jadore cette chanson

  • i think she is a little bit tired:) but nice song:)

  • Brazilans fans wants Doll Domination World tour Dvd!!!

  • i know the all the teayeon talk is annoying but you guys have to admit she was much better and teayeon also danced to lots of songs bcz it was a concert so in my opinion teayeon was better.

  • stop it with the taeyeon and taeyeon and stop criticizing Nicole. She is the original singer and not taeyeon and thats the fact. Furthermore she's tired after dancing and singing several songs. We have no right to compare her to someone else. I can see her effort.

  • i was there and nicole was tryin herr best she was tired from al the dancing she had done before this song:)

  • I love it that Taeyeon performed Nicole's song better (excuse me, PCD's song). It just shows you how hard of a worker Taengoo is. And Nicole needs to work on her vocal endurance. She strains to sing the higher melodies and it's a bad judgement to sing songs that are already out of your comfort range. Like Train's "Hey Soul Sister," I saw a performance of that song and he sounded awful because it was too high to sing. (Artists) need to be smarter when they pick the ranges of their songs.

  • Nicole is more beautiful sings very bad!

  • I adore Nicole, but her voice sounds forced here.

    Taeyeon's version of this song was much better.

  • i love taeyeon's live version of this song...

    it's more lively...

    but hse's definitely great. i just stopped liking her, when she done soloing.

  • @istill0luvhim i think Taeyeon is really better than her..

  • @nklongyut Same... Tae Yeon has a better voice :D

    no offense to Nicole fans.

  • @pokerockman Im not a fan of any of these girls but I love kpop, can you all stop with all this comparissions, its seriously getting annoying, if you love to much an artist go and praise her in her videos and stop comparing about who is better than other, thank you and Taeyeon isnt better than nicole,,, they are really different to compare lol

  • @TonksLunaHermy08 Not comparing, i am just praising both of the artists :)

  • nicoLee is awesome..."!

  • i think she's inerestic!!

  • see if you can STILL sing well after singing SEVERAL songs in a concert!!!! she's still good even tho she's losing her voice...you can tell when she talks...i admire her courage to sing even tho she's tired.

  • Awfull

  • @NunaLeal i know eeeek

  • PCD>>>♥ I love You Nicole....

  • shes loosing her voice at this point 1:48..and so goes the rest of it..shes using her voice to the limit..she needs some rest..to reach that high note back in no time..but she didnt gave up..still she perform..good for her...please understand shes a human too...if you do what she does every day youll know...

  • lol mdr

  • love nicole scherzinger !! go go go..

  • If She couldn't reach all the notes, she shouldn't ve owned this song.....

  • She doesnt even sound that good 1.30-1.40 :O

  • сучка только и умеет трахатся а петь нихуя неумеет !!!

  • fuck you nicole how the hell you been there by yourself where are the other girls ????bitch

  • She looks Beyond

  • não gostei

  • taeyeon's version is way better

  • @azianoj002 lol! props to you for bringing up taeyeon's name... and i do love taeyeon's version too.. who knew kid leader could be so sexy right? :D

  • Where The Fuck Are The Other Girls..? Their Called The "Pussycat Dolls" No..?. She Did Pretty Damn Good Beinq'Out There Alone Aye:).

    Luuve You Nicole!.<3.

  • this is not so great for me...but i still love her :)

  • my voice and her voice are same in that song!!!

  • I prefer fuul song but she is very good

  • ))))))))

  • its cool..................

  • for me too! but i like her too!

  • This is so good for a filipina

  • i don't know why in the world she went up there by herself. it's not fair to the other girls. it's the pussycat dolls tour, not nicole. besides for this song all the dolls were in the video. don't get me wrong im not critizising nicole or anything but like i said, it's not fair

  • quii merda ... achei que ela cantava bem ao vivo :/ so presta no playback de merda

  • A LIVING LEGEND!!!

  • I am not criticizing nicole, I really like I just think if her voice is in bad condition she should rest it instead of singing more. Perhaps if she had rested it this would sound a lot better, But still I don't think its that bad:)

  • @Joaz321456987

    HER VOICE SOUNDS ALWAYS BEAUTIFUL!!!

    mb; u need 2 clean yo holes.

  • отстой полный , петь не хера не может эта сучка!!!

  • @clizma4ka ur a bitch, fuken russian, shut the fuck yo bitches ass up!!!

  • @clizma4ka ne pisdi!!!

  • f ure not a singer then u will never know how hard it is to sing wit such pitch and dancing at the same time...its live thats y.....nicole still did it well and maybe u guys are used to her her sing with back ups....yeah she ran out of voice her voice is not in good condition but still shes great!!!

  • not only did she do a lot of moving and dancing, but if you look closely, they had fans blowing in her face WHILE she was singing. if that much air goes down your pipes, it gets so dry and makes it hard to sing

  • so true

  • SHIT!

  • shouldve lip synched

  • Leona should cover this song, sorry, at least she'd be able to sing it well.

  • apesar de a nicole n ter estado mt bem a musica continua linda....

  • muito ruim ao vivo.....como ja disseram p ai sem as outras atras mais sem graça ainda....só p vender disco mesmo.....

  • Caramba hein Nicole, sem as outras dançando atrás você fica muito sem graça =/

    e esse live aí ficou terrível kkk

  • essa mina elém de ser mó gata

    canta pra karaio.......

    nicole é d+

  • I thing my voice is better :D

    She can´t sing the part in I will survive - from 3:30 to 3:40 and also from 3:48 to 3:55 =/

  • wow she's realy bad live and it kinda sad that she is always the one who's be in the pica but whatever i mean she's still a pcd

  • Weak voice @ live. Poor.

  • Comment removed

  • 1:49 lol still a good song tho ..

  • go nicole...

    proud to be a filipino!!!

  • @MrSongbird73 i thought she was Egyptian?

  • no

    she is russian hawai and philipine

  • she got the words wrong

  • she was like trying too hard ...lol

  • Where are the other's?

  • Where do you think they are? She always dominates them, though it's kinda sad!

  • God she cant sing for shit, im a dude and i could do it better... The song is good but not her... LISTEN TO RIN ON THE ROX SING THIS SONG... ITS AMAZING

  • nada contra, so nao gostei...

  • something is terribly wrong...THERS NO PCD?! BUT A PCD SONG?!-_-

  • Canta muito!

  • She sounds sick.

  • horibleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

  • terrible!!!!!!!!! :|

  • ufffffff.uzas

  • MALAYSIAN SINGER JACLYN VICTOR IS THE BEST. jaclyn victor is asia's best singer.

  • watch this out..

    malaysian singer sing this song live!!

    "Jaclyn Victor - hush hush [Konsert Jom Heboh Bukit Jalil 2009]"

  • Das Live zu singen ist schon sehr schwer... Aber erschwerend dazu ist noch das sie nicht das Stimmenvolumen daszu hat den Song zu singen! Aber ansonsten bis auf die Stimme... gut gemacht!

  • wow....

    that wose ...

    crap

  • ouch.

  • tragedy...

  • OMG.. she sounds so bad in the beginning.. 1:47 wtf

    But after 3:18 it starts getting better,

  • Que Merda é essa ??

    Ela canta muuito , mas infelizmente elaa tha podre nese vídeeo '

  • PUSSYCAT

  • Chatinho mesmo. E cadê as outras Pussycat Dolls? Nicole sempre querendo ser a única...

  • afss as outras tb cantam a  musica solo delas -.-'

  • Chatiiiiiiiinhoo!!!!!!! ZZZZZZZZZ!!!!!!

  • молодчинка!!!!!! супер!!!!

  • Muiiiiiiiiiito bom!!!!!

    Ela canta d +++++++

  • that was good ;]

  • shauihsaihasiuhsaiuhsai q lixo

  • Que merda de texto é esse?

    Merda de brasileiro

  • look at those tits

  • go half FILIPINA.....love u gurl..............

  • SHES SO HAWT :)

  • She`d better sung the ballad (CD) version of this song cos she was performing it alone without other girls dancing.

  • ужасно,я расстроена в ней

  • Acho que ela precisa de mais afinação e treina o diafragma em! iuhaeiuhaeiuhaeiuhaeuihaeuihae

  • this is singing!!

    she was sick during the tour....

  • Ao vivo não tem o mesmo brilho da versão studio... que pena...

  • Ar they on live xx

  • THE BEST !

    THAT'S WHY SHES THE QUEEN !

  • uó mesmo

  • u can tell her voice is course thats why its off.....

    when she talks to the crowd how her voice is strained....

  • horrible! this is not SINGING!

  • OMG! I Hate how he sing that song!?!