@snake89453 I don't really think she looks like a corpse o.o. But then again I come from a family of pale, black haired people so... xD
I think she looks really pretty. It's nice to see a woman like her, talented, beautiful, and HEALTHY, instead of anorexic or something. I wish I looked like her!
@snake89453 you might be true considering its your opinion but i long to look like her isnt it said when a 13 year old who has depression and is emo longs to look like as you called her a "corpse"? or is that normal?
@ca52998may Your depression might just be hormones if you are only thirteen. Hormones can be pretty evil, believe me. Think positve =D Songs like these are beautiful, but also can have a way of enhancing depression. Hang in there and try your best to keep smiling even when it feels impossible :)
@abbaabbaaaabb probably because it's such a personal song. Like it's a joke because she doesn't really wanna put it out. I wouldn't. The songs intense.
@moogisXmaximus6991 Firstly, there was an official statement that Ben Moody left due to creative differences and in order to make a second album something had to change. Yet, there is some evidence that point out that Ben became abusive and controlling and was omitting negative energy amongst the band especially towards Amy Lee. The songs explains how him being hateful and abusive towars her had made a mental impact her but she learnt to get over it.
@moogisXmaximus6991 Also, the song describes how Ben was stopping form doing what she wanted and being herself and that now without his negativity and his unecessary hatred and agression she'd 'make her own way'. She was fighting
People are saying that this song was written as a joke but Amy Lee, the singer and songwriter of the song, has confirmed herself that it was not a joke and was written very seriously
i know they will... and if you are an ev hater then why do u bother being so pathetic as to view videos of their songs and tell the people who have commented to shut up? someone obviously has no life
the only reason i would ever really learn to play the piano would be to learn all their songs on the piano.....amy lee is like....a poet...except she plays music...all of her songs tell a story...all you gotta do is listen....i love the piano on all her songs.....evanescence forever!
This is THE best video that I've found of someone playing the piano to this song. I don't feel like I need to rush my voice in places, and that's very good!! Thanks for posting! I think I'll be using this often!!! (:
i love this song , im in piano lessons , and my teacher is gonna teach me how to play it and im gonna play it at my concert in may. i cant wait , this song is truly beautiful
omg i so agree....and i really want to go to her next concert and signing if she brings a new album out....bcoz she so inspires me i cant even explain the emotion, i love her....and no im not some crazy fan...i feel a connection like shes been there for me through music
You should correct the description of this video. She said it was a joke several years ago, but by the time the song actually came to light she made it clear that she's quite serious about it. It's pretty obvious listening to a) lyrics b) composition c) her inflection that this song is very much not a joke.
i like the part where it goes " sickened in the sun and you dare tell me you love me, yet u held me down and screamed you wanted me to die, but honey you know, you know id never hurt you that way, your just so pretty in your pain
the lyrics are so well written, one of her best pieces I have to say, and the lyrics you are on about are really, really painful to listen to, I actually felt like crying when I heard them the first time..so much emotion!
I really like that song... it's just so deep... It's something thst I can relate right now. "demanding my response, don't bother breaking the door down" that just gives me the chills...
I love Amy Lee [non sexual way, obvs]. She's so lucky to be that beautiful. And her voice is so terrific, it's almost impossible. I wish I could sing like her. I love this song too, joke or no joke, it's wondrous.
I was just gonna say that! lol. It's true. Amy meant what she said in this song. She wouldn't write a song just for fun. She writes songs to let out all of her problems.
that is actually not "cited" on the evreference (no actual quote available) , what Amy said is cited, if she did it as a joke or did not, who knows. Its still one of my favorites... Effin Ben...
Um, yes it is. Or atleast it was. I know for a fact it is her. And if you don't believe me or everyone else who says you're wrong then I'm not sure how you can call yourself a "supreme Evanescence fan".
OK guys nobody cares if it is amy or not! now im not sure coz maybe its just the white face that gets ppl confused i dont know but can we stop fighting about it...PLEASE its an awesome song and i dont think the picture really matters does it?...
Yeah it is actually a picture of her lol, if you got to evanescencewebsite and go to the gallery it is from a 2007 photoshoot, there's one with the full band too.
Dude l don't care if nobody agrees with me. I just know that's not her and l'm 100% sure. I watched so many pics with her and l know that it isn't her so..whatever. And don't call us poop heads just bcuz we have different opinions, everybody think whatever they want !!! So whatever...I think she's beautiful and she has an excelent voice !!!
Yeah, I agree. If u look closely and if u know Amy u'll see that it's not her..she looks a little bit like her, ok maybe a little bit more but there are some differences..it's definetly not her, ppl that don't really know Amy can say that it is her. Anyway...I love the song !!!!
omg im so stupid........the whole time i was thinking wen is she gonna start singing its already been like 3 minutes.....then i realized it was a piano solo....lol
I think that Amy has been a few cruel with Ben. Althought all that he has done to her, I think that we need Ben's version to know what really happened in Evanescence before the breaking.
I don't know, she just looks a bit different if it is her, there are just so many Amy posers out there. But what I don't get is that's not the piano she usually plays.
Well, that piano, if you didn't notice was kinda burned. And she wasn't wearing that in the video. I'm just pretty sure it's not her. 'Cause even I can look like Amy, pretty much anyone can, with all the make up and if you have the right kind of hair. And eyebrows, too. I think it's who ever is playing this, but it looks alot like Amy, if it isn't Amy that is. Maybe I should just E-mail the person who made this. : / Kinda, make things more clear.
even aliens listen to her songs <3 love you Amy
AdamChocoSo 3 months ago
2030 still listening to this song
AdamChocoSo 3 months ago
Amy is very very beauitiful In That pICTURE!!
iloveGaga1029 6 months ago
Beautiful song!Super!
Melania199898 6 months ago
:')*
Saarouss 9 months ago
das ist echt toll und die info´s finde ich auch klasse, man bekommt richtig gänsehaut beim hören, tolles gefühl
1991Amazon 10 months ago
this song means so much to me......
she writes beautiful songs and her piano pieces are deap even without the vocals you can feel it..
she is so beautiful :) xx
fayned50 1 year ago 2
:'(
Tzenaki94 1 year ago
When the picture popped up on my screen my heart skiped a beat.
Is it just me or does she look like a corpse?
snake89453 1 year ago
@snake89453 I don't really think she looks like a corpse o.o. But then again I come from a family of pale, black haired people so... xD
I think she looks really pretty. It's nice to see a woman like her, talented, beautiful, and HEALTHY, instead of anorexic or something. I wish I looked like her!
SakiWatari 1 year ago 5
@SakiWatari yesh! she can be my corpse bride :'D
doomleaf 10 months ago
@snake89453 you might be true considering its your opinion but i long to look like her isnt it said when a 13 year old who has depression and is emo longs to look like as you called her a "corpse"? or is that normal?
ca52998may 7 months ago
@ca52998may Your depression might just be hormones if you are only thirteen. Hormones can be pretty evil, believe me. Think positve =D Songs like these are beautiful, but also can have a way of enhancing depression. Hang in there and try your best to keep smiling even when it feels impossible :)
turquoisesurprise 7 months ago 3
This isng touched my soul like i could feel the pain
animegirl525100 1 year ago
Why should such a sad song be written as a joke?!
abbaabbaaaabb 1 year ago 2
@abbaabbaaaabb probably because it's such a personal song. Like it's a joke because she doesn't really wanna put it out. I wouldn't. The songs intense.
PhantoMPhreeK92 1 year ago
Will you please send me the song?
EBstarrified 1 year ago
this make me cry :'(
JosePxR 1 year ago 3
To say that her songs are beautiful is not enough ...
These songs are much more than that ...
They are all ... Amy Lee is all the better ...
Emmily1003 1 year ago 2
it' s just that lovely!
InLoveWithCookies 1 year ago
whow ! i love this song
ladycroft004 1 year ago
Can I PLEASE have a copy of this cover e-mailed to me?
am27lonely 1 year ago
good to know that a new album is coming out :D !!!
Mirmidon87 2 years ago 2
hey i never got the full story bout ben moody and her some1 tell me basically wat happened here.
moogisXmaximus6991 2 years ago
@moogisXmaximus6991 Firstly, there was an official statement that Ben Moody left due to creative differences and in order to make a second album something had to change. Yet, there is some evidence that point out that Ben became abusive and controlling and was omitting negative energy amongst the band especially towards Amy Lee. The songs explains how him being hateful and abusive towars her had made a mental impact her but she learnt to get over it.
TheLegendOfZelda100 1 year ago
@moogisXmaximus6991 Also, the song describes how Ben was stopping form doing what she wanted and being herself and that now without his negativity and his unecessary hatred and agression she'd 'make her own way'. She was fighting
TheLegendOfZelda100 1 year ago
@moogisXmaximus6991 She was fighting for her own rights as an indiviual person and her own form of creativity. Hopefully, this answers your question.
TheLegendOfZelda100 1 year ago
i friggin love this song!!!!
AlphaNuke 2 years ago
did you do this cover? it is awesome!
gothgal2119 2 years ago
Evanescence 4ever. Emy lee красавица.
SiNiBoLL 2 years ago 2
LA MEJORRRR!!!!!!!!!! que BUENA que esta!!!!!
TheCaseto 2 years ago
Beautiful, I love singing this, can' t wait for the new album!
fruitloop008 2 years ago 3
this is so beautiful!!!!
its so sad :( i hope ben moody has a guilty conscience.
Its been sed that after the fallen tour, moody invited amy to a movie, but she didnt show up...
just thought id share that random peice of knowledge...
frediscute17 2 years ago
Very Good!
I(L)EVANESCENCE
EvanImmortal03 2 years ago
love u amy
AmyLeeGreatestFan 2 years ago
I miss evanescence I want they to make a new album
RIGHT NOW!
dens158 2 years ago
theyre in the proces of making one
its released in 2010
imyourhell1 2 years ago 7
YAY!!!!!!!
xxXcrayonsrockXxx 2 years ago
it wasnt written as a joke. amy confirmed that herself on evthreads
helxig 2 years ago
wat?
NyaIsPower1 2 years ago
People are saying that this song was written as a joke but Amy Lee, the singer and songwriter of the song, has confirmed herself that it was not a joke and was written very seriously
helxig 2 years ago 5
uhhhh......shut up! evanescence will be releasing their new album in december 2009!!!!!
(Evanescence hater :@)
bijkj01 2 years ago
i know they will... and if you are an ev hater then why do u bother being so pathetic as to view videos of their songs and tell the people who have commented to shut up? someone obviously has no life
helxig 2 years ago
oh i didnt read what you said properly. no they arent releasing their new album in 2009 its april 2010 i think
helxig 2 years ago 2
@bijkj01 no they wont they will next year sometime
Paramoreluvr125 2 years ago
I believe you should shut up. Evanescence won't release their new album before 2010.
GothicAngel600 2 years ago
lol now it is 2010
bookworm6795 2 years ago
Yeah, we're seven days into 2010, and your point is? I never promised that it would come early 2010 only that it would come within the year.
GothicAngel600 2 years ago
ik I just got bored and decided to point that out...sorry....
bookworm6795 2 years ago
@GothicAngel600
Well it is coming out in 2010, why wont you check some different Evanescence websites, like Evanescence AL
It has the most recent news of Evanescence, and there recording for the new album next month
H2OJustAddWaterFan2 2 years ago
i saw that too on evthreads!!!
eli0h 2 years ago
Comment removed
helxig 2 years ago
i agree i freaken love evanescence im a total die hard fan
GO EVANESCENCE YOU HAVE HELP ME THROUGH SOME TOUGH TIMES WITH YOUR MUSIC
hidb2007 2 years ago 5
amen to that!! ^^
emovampireroses 2 years ago
does anyone know what the chords are in this song? or where i can find the scores for free ofcause.
Nattehuen 2 years ago
AMAZING job! :)
daSONNE1 2 years ago 3
the only reason i would ever really learn to play the piano would be to learn all their songs on the piano.....amy lee is like....a poet...except she plays music...all of her songs tell a story...all you gotta do is listen....i love the piano on all her songs.....evanescence forever!
xoxoxoxoHardygirl22 2 years ago 16
is this in a different key from the original
because i can sing with the original, but somehow i can't hit some of thew notes in this one???? Maybe i'm crazy...
ShunnedByZoi 2 years ago
sounds like the same key to me. maybe its because the quality isnt that great
ISHEEBESI 2 years ago
WOW I SANG THIS SONG WITH THIS TRACK, WITH NO LYRICS AND NO STOPPING =D Love dis song! xxx
Boredom97 2 years ago 2
yesss yesss yessssss.ssssssss pianooooooo <3
NoisyMiranda 2 years ago 4
Evanescence
Evanescenc
Evanescen
Evanesce
Evanesc
Evane
Evan
Eva
Ev
E
aloneatsunset19 2 years ago
I LOVE EVANESCENCE
ROCK ON
aloneatsunset19 2 years ago 3
can u send me this version of that song?
or do you know where i can find it?
Xristina21amy 2 years ago 2
nice and sad melody<333
I LOVE EVANESCENCE
I LOVE EVANESCENCE
I LOVE EVANESCENCE
I LOVE EVANESCENCE
I LOVE EVANESCENCE
Xristina21amy 2 years ago 2
This song is wonderful!
Lovedreamerin 2 years ago
Amazing, i really enjoyed it! :D thanks for posting, this is one of my favorite Evanescence songs. :)
BehindLacrymosa 2 years ago
This is THE best video that I've found of someone playing the piano to this song. I don't feel like I need to rush my voice in places, and that's very good!! Thanks for posting! I think I'll be using this often!!! (:
5/5 and favoriting!!!
Heidikins017 2 years ago 2
i love this song , im in piano lessons , and my teacher is gonna teach me how to play it and im gonna play it at my concert in may. i cant wait , this song is truly beautiful
TwilightLoverxox 2 years ago
this is so beautiful- i can't even find the words to describe how amazing this song is. amy lee is truly amazing.
daydreamer5814 3 years ago 4
omg i so agree....and i really want to go to her next concert and signing if she brings a new album out....bcoz she so inspires me i cant even explain the emotion, i love her....and no im not some crazy fan...i feel a connection like shes been there for me through music
kentman37 3 years ago 4
i cried for so many reasons
kentman37 3 years ago 2
You should correct the description of this video. She said it was a joke several years ago, but by the time the song actually came to light she made it clear that she's quite serious about it. It's pretty obvious listening to a) lyrics b) composition c) her inflection that this song is very much not a joke.
retailisthedevil 3 years ago
i like the part where it goes " sickened in the sun and you dare tell me you love me, yet u held me down and screamed you wanted me to die, but honey you know, you know id never hurt you that way, your just so pretty in your pain
HappyEmoPimpette666 3 years ago 4
me 2 :)
StraightIntoDark 3 years ago 2
ME 3!!!!!!!!!!!lol
hyperchic7277 3 years ago 4
the lyrics are so well written, one of her best pieces I have to say, and the lyrics you are on about are really, really painful to listen to, I actually felt like crying when I heard them the first time..so much emotion!
puremagicben 3 years ago 8
i agree
kentman37 3 years ago
i just luurrve it all
kentman37 3 years ago 3
I really like that song... it's just so deep... It's something thst I can relate right now. "demanding my response, don't bother breaking the door down" that just gives me the chills...
iluvlink12 3 years ago
I'm going to sing this song on my talent show, its so beautiful don't you guys think?
HappyEmoPimpette666 3 years ago 2
go for it and go where the wind takes you! ^.^ jus promise you'll upload it on youtube
iluvlink12 3 years ago
I'M SPEECHLES...- BEAUTIFUL MELODY AND IT'S SO DEEP, JUST THE MELODY MAKES YOU FALL IN LOVE! I'm so crying!! AMY LOVE YOU!
Evnightlerd 3 years ago 3
I love Amy Lee [non sexual way, obvs]. She's so lucky to be that beautiful. And her voice is so terrific, it's almost impossible. I wish I could sing like her. I love this song too, joke or no joke, it's wondrous.
Angelyssa
Devilyssa13 3 years ago 2
this is one of Amy's best songs...
very deep...
bellabelliboo 3 years ago 55
And photoshop does wonders, ha cheek bones or not ha, Just try the smudge and lighten tools
isaacdubaron 3 years ago
she always writes songs if she is threaten or how she feels this one is sad cause whats his face hurt her feelings lol
kagome6996 3 years ago 4
wow shes beuatiful rite ther
Akisaku19 3 years ago 29
@Akisaku19 She's always beautiful :)
VioletteOlivia55 1 year ago
<3Amy Lee
LoveYourHate619 3 years ago 10
Beautiful
spokenfears666 3 years ago 7
Красивая песня...
Margorritta 3 years ago
okay, if you look on the official website's pictures and compare u can clearly see that is the same Amy
finalfantasyfan13 3 years ago 10
This is one of my favorite songs! Oh, and this is definitely amy! You can't call yourself a fan if you don't even recognise her face!!!
king1091 3 years ago
This song was NOT written as a joke. -.-
"Contrary to popular belief, Amy Lee did not write this song as a joke."
-The Evanescence Referance
Evanescence91607 3 years ago 7
I was just gonna say that! lol. It's true. Amy meant what she said in this song. She wouldn't write a song just for fun. She writes songs to let out all of her problems.
wikipedia103 3 years ago 4
exactly!!
evanescentgothfairy 3 years ago 5
that is actually not "cited" on the evreference (no actual quote available) , what Amy said is cited, if she did it as a joke or did not, who knows. Its still one of my favorites... Effin Ben...
isaacdubaron 3 years ago
i love amy lynn lee
and i love to sing
thnx
thegothicprincess142 3 years ago 2
... yeah it's amy
thefallenopendoor 3 years ago
I love this song!
thcalmeida26 3 years ago
Yeah that picture is Amy Lee. It's from a photoshoot. It's even on the bands main webstie...
JamieDiana06 3 years ago
Umm..no it´s not, I´ve just checked it...check it again .
RockFa1ry 3 years ago
Um, yes it is. Or atleast it was. I know for a fact it is her. And if you don't believe me or everyone else who says you're wrong then I'm not sure how you can call yourself a "supreme Evanescence fan".
JamieDiana06 3 years ago
this is amy
ghostofyourdream 3 years ago
OK guys nobody cares if it is amy or not! now im not sure coz maybe its just the white face that gets ppl confused i dont know but can we stop fighting about it...PLEASE its an awesome song and i dont think the picture really matters does it?...
now stop fighting and enjoy the song thnx
TokioHotelTash 3 years ago
I´m not fighting...that was the sub, it´t just that it looks different..anyway..sorry, yeah the song it´s great, they are awesome !!!!
RockFa1ry 3 years ago
Yeah it is actually a picture of her lol, if you got to evanescencewebsite and go to the gallery it is from a 2007 photoshoot, there's one with the full band too.
puremagicben 3 years ago
where did you get this pic?
Ahrrem 3 years ago
Dude l don't care if nobody agrees with me. I just know that's not her and l'm 100% sure. I watched so many pics with her and l know that it isn't her so..whatever. And don't call us poop heads just bcuz we have different opinions, everybody think whatever they want !!! So whatever...I think she's beautiful and she has an excelent voice !!!
RockFa1ry 3 years ago
this is my favorite song from her well not my top favorite from her but its up there! teehee! i ♥ evanescence!
heartalone101 3 years ago
Yeah, this is Amy Lee.
But, I love this song!
(:
xXDeadDolly 3 years ago
that effing is amy-lee u poop heads :P
EmoVampireGirl666 3 years ago
Yeah, I agree. If u look closely and if u know Amy u'll see that it's not her..she looks a little bit like her, ok maybe a little bit more but there are some differences..it's definetly not her, ppl that don't really know Amy can say that it is her. Anyway...I love the song !!!!
RockFa1ry 3 years ago
Lol you not amy lee
xBuBleGummyx 3 years ago
omg im so stupid........the whole time i was thinking wen is she gonna start singing its already been like 3 minutes.....then i realized it was a piano solo....lol
kristyn360 3 years ago 9
Haha yes it like very much on the real piano indead.
MarryWitch94 3 years ago
I think that Amy has been a few cruel with Ben. Althought all that he has done to her, I think that we need Ben's version to know what really happened in Evanescence before the breaking.
damadellaberinto 3 years ago 5
I know everybody hates this question, but does anybody have th mp3 for this song? ^_^;
AnimeGirl978 3 years ago 2
OMG
its Amy!!!
DUUH
LiaNight 3 years ago
uh no that's amy i would know her anywhere
baddogg516 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's not amy, the cheek bones are totally different, and have you seen the nose?
You're fucking stupid..
TheCatIsDry 3 years ago
Look on pictures she has the same nose. And i know here dress from a photoshoot. You're stupid!
MarryWitch94 3 years ago
I don't know, she just looks a bit different if it is her, there are just so many Amy posers out there. But what I don't get is that's not the piano she usually plays.
TheCatIsDry 3 years ago 2
But she likes very much and she use the piano in the clip Good enough(i thought).
MarryWitch94 3 years ago
Well, that piano, if you didn't notice was kinda burned. And she wasn't wearing that in the video. I'm just pretty sure it's not her. 'Cause even I can look like Amy, pretty much anyone can, with all the make up and if you have the right kind of hair. And eyebrows, too. I think it's who ever is playing this, but it looks alot like Amy, if it isn't Amy that is. Maybe I should just E-mail the person who made this. : / Kinda, make things more clear.
TheCatIsDry 3 years ago
it is amy u ween hole. if your any kind of evanescence fan you would know..
somekindafish 3 years ago
baeutiful
rockerchick4god 4 years ago
AWESOME! its so good!
vincentkurtkazune 4 years ago
relax, me tranquiliza, buena cancion..
miguelRaton85 4 years ago
awesome!!!!!!!
rockprsesi 4 years ago
is there anyway i can get a copy of this? huhuh i need it :(
nelokarmela 4 years ago
ImmortalxBitch:
Hello?! Thats amy! any dumbass an see that
jjeisc 4 years ago 3
It's fun to sing along with ^.^
LetxGoxOfxMe 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This isn't real amy...xD It's only a model that looks like Amy, the girl on the pic is to skinny and has different face a little...
ImmortalxBitch 4 years ago
...That's Amy. o_o
AnimeGirl978 3 years ago 2
I need this pic ;(
ImmortalxBitch 4 years ago
OMG where did you find this pic!!!!
i love it
SmokinAce 4 years ago
perfeitooooo
monykstwell 4 years ago
lol i thought it was a video and amy was just sitting v still.
took an embarrasing amount of time to realise otherwise =[
TheBlondeGrudge 4 years ago 4
Whoa, I didnt know it was a joke, thanks for uploading this version! :]
xSatansxAngelx 4 years ago
this was really written as a joke?
irishbitch29 4 years ago