I love those paintings at 1:04 but when I went to parilament we rushed through them all and I got shouted at becuase I walked 1 metre away from the tour to look at them.
I'm an American but I love watching Prime Minister's Questions and hearing the stuff Skinner comes up with. I wish American politics were as entertaining.
It commemorates the events of 4 January 1642 when King Charles I tried to enter the House of Commons and the MPs slammed the door on his face.
I think the tradition of slamming the door on the monarch's representative to commemorate 1642 dates back to the early 18th century, but the current door is only about 60 years old as the original was destroyed during the Second World War.
POMPOUS ARROGANT THIEVES MURDERERS...THE BANKRUPT ENGLISH CROWN
WHERE IS THE TAMPOON CHARLES AND HIS WHORE SITTING ON THE TARNISH THRONE? FITTING END TO THE 'EMPIRE' JUST LIKE THIS WORTHLESS USA BUILT ON STOLEN LAND AND SLAVERY.
POMPOUS ARROGANT THIEVES MURDERERS...THE BANKRUPT ENGLISH CROWN
WHERE IS THE TAMPOON CHARLES AND HIS WHORE SITTING ON THE TARNISH THRONE? FITTING END TO THE 'EMPIRE' JUST LIKE THIS WORTHLESS USA BUILT ON STOLEN LAND AND SLAVERY.
@adam4757 I WILL ALSO BRING A ARAB WITH ME ...YOU KNOW WHAT THEY DO. PFFT, A TANDOORI FART IN YOUR WHITE FACE. O HEAR THE COMMONWEALTH TAKING OVER BANKRUPT ENGLAND..KARMA SUCKS.
@pugilistofpower You first Wigger,a wigger is a white nigger. You whites are the biggest parasite/virus on this planet and like all virus need to be exterminated.
Why do weird Evangelical Americans always feel they have to get involved in things that don't involve them? Nobody asked for an arrogant American's opinion.
@rederic2004 I think the first joke after he retires should be something simple like "Nothing from Dennis this year?" If he retires through death (which could happen, as he is very old now) then they should just say "RIP, Dennis Skinner." That's my view on it anyway.
they cant keep the United States out there mouth like a Dick, never have i heard any mention of the UK in ANY U.S ceremony, if they did it would be considered treason and 30 years in jail
@thehulk3010 Whats that? I can hear 5 year old children dying across the Atlantic because billion dollar insurance companies have ripped his family off. The US has nothing to be celebrating in this day and age.
I am marvelled at how The British remember their political past every single year with as such meaningful ceremonies as these. I wish we, in Argentina, did the same with the lame politicians we have in Congress.
@mkeeble1989 I do not know there names etc, but if you are refeering to their function the just hold the Ermine train of the Queen's robes as she walks to parliment
Oh come on, listen most women her age would be sat looking forward to their pureed lunch and an afternoon of staring out of a window at sparrows. We send her all over the world, and she never puts a foot or a word wrong. She is worth very penny and we are lucky to have her, god knows what's going to happen when she has gone. Do them the maths and compare how much money she generates compared to how much money she costs. I have huge respect for her.
As I said, every Presidency in the world is more expensive per capita than the British monarchy. The Queen doesn't get a salary, the money she receives is to pay for her duties as head of state. Also, the monarchy brings in more money through tourism than it takes out through taxes. So abolishing the monarchy wouldn't pay for any new schools or hospitals.
You may not like the monarchy, but about 70% of the British people do.
The Queen only started paying tax in 1993 (i think).
She has a personal fortune of £150m (that the press know of)
France doesnt have a monarchy BUT gets twice as many tourists as we do.
Why should any tax go to funding their castles, mansions, country retreats and staff.
If they really care about their subjects, then they should give that money back and live on their investment portfolio which I hear yields them around £20-30m per annum.
A huge percentage of tourists come to the UK to see those castles and palaces, and to see events related to the monarchy. Most of the money the Royal family gets goes towards the upkeep of those places, all of which are part of our national heritage.
Much of the rest of the money pays for the Queen's duties of head of state.
The Queen is one of the most famous and respect women in the world, and the UK gets a great deal of prestige as a result of having her as head of state.
Open up ALL the buildings that the public pays for - hence more tourist revenue.
The Queen might be respected but the next monarch is Prince Charles and lets just say he'll most likely damage this country's reputation.
I respect the Queen, but it makes me sick to my stomach that we're having to live in a period of "austerity" while the Royal family get the best that money can buy.
As I said, the tax money goes to the upkeep of the Royal residences (which are part of our heritage) and to pay for the duties of the head of state (which would still be needed in a republic).
The monarchy gives the UK prestige, a link to our history and a unifying national figurehead, of which most nations are envious.
There is not guarantee Charles will become King, the Queen seems to be in great health. I think William (son of Diana) will secure the monarchy's future.
Given that men in general, and from what i can see, men in the Windsor family, die earlier than women, its highly possible that Charles will die before the queen, or at the least, only be on the throne for 10-15 years
@Medeasbiggestfan Most nations are not envious. They might find the pomp and ceremony charming and quaint, but ask an American if they'd rather be a monarchy than a republican and the answer would be emphatically 'no'.
@Medeasbiggestfan She is famous and respected now, but was she when she first became Queen? How exactly is her fame important anyway? if we had a President they would be famous by virtue of the important position that they hold and their ability, not because of who their parents are.
She was very famous when she first became Queen, her Coronation was shown throughout the world.
How many people can name the President of Germany? Yet that is a very important office. A British President would not be as famous or as respected as the Queen.
Having a head of state as famous and as respected as Elizabeth II gives the UK great prestige in the world and that is very important to the UK's position in the world.
@otleybey Presidents are kind of boring anyway. Besides, even when you don't count the money they generate through tourism they more than pay for themselves through taxation of crown property, so effectively she pays you 60p a year for the honour of representing you around the world.
@pardeepsinghk those estates often turn a profit from tourism income and such, actually. All of which goes straight into the treasury, last year or the year before the total was in the region of 20million. They're valuable as a tourist attraction, and the insitution is part of our history.
charles is actually quite popular incase you havnt noticed-hes using his position in EXACTLY the way he should-his charities.
they have brough untold thousands if not millions out of terrible poverty, into work and education. For that alone he has my admiration-having an affair? couldnt give a shit, it happens every day of the week
Mr Tampon can be king as long as he keeps his opinions to himself once king-which is standard practice.
Anyway, he can call himself used Condom man for all i care, as he has more of a social conscience than most of our elected politicians as his chartiers clearly demonstrate-for that alone he will be well regarded
You seem to be assuming British monarchy dictate policy-trhey dont, thats why we allow them to remain-William, Charles it doesnt matter-the elected government dictates policy, the Monarch just does what hes told-thats why we fought a ci-vil war, to force this to be the situation.
As for the authority of the house of Saxe Coburg Gotha-none, because it doesnt exist-it became the house of Windsor 80 odd years ago
Dennis SKinner = Genius! He's the only one who cuts through the pomposity of the State Opening, frankly it looked more ridiculous this year than ever....
This really symbolizes the power of the crown (in Canada, as well). If the Queen wanted to dissolve Parliament or appoint a new Prime Minister, she could. It is the ultimate check on potential abuses by elected governments, such as declaring a dictatorship.
wrong-this power has been devolved to the PM. She is mearly a representative of the soverign power of the state, the government that controls this state withtin the executive under the PM has the power
it may be medieval - but it shows the relationship between the Queen, the House of Lords and the House of Commons.
Black Rod is sent to the Hose of Commons to summon them before the Monarch - the House of Commans slams the door in his face to show the Commons does not heed the whim of the Monarch - he must knock to gain entry and be inivted it. It comes from when King Charles 1st tried to arrest 5 members of Parliment and the door was slammed in his face.
Really? Cuba is nice and such a paradise that the people can't bear being there which is so great that they pack themselves in boats and risk death by drowning to get to Miami! Shame on you sort.propping up that dispicable communist regime,
I think you are talking about many years ago my dear. I have never met such happy people. Their health care system is amazing and the only reason many of them are poor is because of the sugar embargo enforced by the USA you fool.
ou must have been on a Left Wing Guitt Trip, my dear! You probably avoided the absolute destitution of the people as you were probably on a Ethically Cleansed Socialist Tour. Typical socialist you are: ignoring basic facts to cover your perverse left wing idealogy! Sad really! :(
For goodness sake take a chill pill. Just because people want a republic doesnt mean that they are commie reds. By the way what has the colour of my skin got to do with it?
Keep taking your medication mate. What medicine would you take? Socialist syrup? One mouthful fits all. When you get older you will realise the error of your pathetic class-war prejudicial socialist politics-of-envy ways. I pray for you! ;)
Brutual Truth is so funny I can't help winding him up. He is full of anger. He thinks because we believe in republicanism then we are red commie's and God knows what else in his deranged mind. He thinks because I went to Cuba on holiday that I was on an Ethnically Socialist tour. OMG he so makes me laugh, oh and then he assumes Im a black African male. BNP me thinks. He is funny though, keep winding him up and he will come out with more reactionary crap. .
Well London cockney boy, I hope you will put two fingers up to the jock that destroyed pensions; two fingers to the jock that has turned the UK in to a debt-ridden basketcase; two fingers to the jock that has made a mess of immigration; two fingers to the jock that imposed 100 taxes over 11 years. Stupid foolish Republican cockney ignorant uneductaed twat!
And you can fuck off to Cuba or knowing your mentality - North Korea! Go on, off yer ,go we in the UK don't want socialist backward jealous zealots like you! Off you go, comrade brother! By the way ,Black Rod is showing us the the symbol of Parliament;s authority over the monarchy! You are so red and a communist zealot that you don't realise it!
So you think that giving the government royal prerogative powers that are not subject to judicial review or parliamentary scrutiny is a good thing? You think that the royal family are a good deal for the tax payer? I suppose you also think that its great that the House of Lords is unelected.
You're the zealot mate. How on Earth is republicanism and democracy backwards compared to a primitive system that most other countries have managed to get rid of?
You let the cat out of the back there, mate! You are expouting Republicanism. I am not keen on the Royal Family but the vast majority of the UK population are and that is the way it should be. You are are another poisoned Socialist. You think your twisted socialist policies of 'one size fits all is ok' is ok. Well,if you don't like the UK, then fuck off to Cuba, North Korea, Venezuala or to match your mentatlity Zimbabwe! Stupid foolish boy!
You're an intellectual lightweight. Why do you keep talking about North Korea? Idiot. Actually it is not the 'vast' majority, there is a sizable minority who are republicans, and when pressed most people don't hold strong opinion on the matter. When pressed to pick a side on an issue that you don't really understand/don't care much about, you will almost always go with the status quo. Explain to me what socialism has to do with it please - although you probably don't know what it is anyway.
I am called a lightweight by a 19 year old socialist in nappies! LOL. What the fuck is a sizeable minority? A miniority is a minority and a majority is a majority. Your socialist clapped-out Labour party were for 18 years in opposition and guess what! They had to drop the shite of socialist policies that you believe in to get elected. The majoriity rejected socialism! LEAVE THE COUNTRY if you don't like it! Off you go Labour 'yoof'!
Have to agree with you. Our BRUTUAL TRUTH friend sounds a bit deranged. Hes getting himself into a right old state isnt he. He thinks people are still leaving Cuba in boats.
I know, he is a complete raving mad idiot but its good winding him up. You can imagine him walking around rageing at anyone who is not wearing a union jack and bowing to the queen. Otleyboy lets make it a mission to wind up Brutually honest. I mean lets face it he doesnt evan know how to spell!!!! He is so funny.
Wrong I am winding you up all the time and you have taken the bait, yer fat blond overweight pie-muncher. Take a look at your own speling - what a retard! Ha Ha! Please keep off the chocolates and crisps and the chronic masturbation. Ha ha, fat boy xxxxxxx
Go to Cuba, its paradise and the only reason its in poverty is because of the US embargo. Lets hope Obama changes that but the people and the country are beaufiful. lol
To me the Queen's Imperial State Crown seems too small. Instead of sitting around her brow, it floats on top of her head. It's a wonder it does not fall off.
I cant see the problem with the current system. The monarchy is an integral part of our identity. Like it or not, its the genesis from which our governement evolved. There is no power wielded by the monarchy anymore, but its still a symbol of our great nation. If we were to scrap it on the basis of progess or equality we would be doing grave damage to the fabric with which our society is woven.
Isn't it inpirational to see our elected members of parliment be summoned to a house of fat, old, senile, over-payed, spinless, putrid, unelected slobs.
Most of the Lords were MP's at one time. Though i feel the upper house should be elected so the Goverment of the Day can't stack it full of thier own supporters.
It's not an imaginary statistic. Do a Google search for BBC "Poll respondents back UK monarchy". The poll from late 2007 shows that 78% of people want to keep the monarchy and only 16% wanted a republic.
The Queen's approval rating has hovered around 75% for the last 50 years.
Younger people have always been less enthusiastic about the royal family, but as they get older they tend to become reassured by the consistency and tradition of the monarchy.
This is certainly the case with my family, several members of which campaigned for a republic during their teenaged years in the 70s, but now support the Queen.
When Gordon Brown went to Washington no one in the US cared about him. Obama cancelled a press conference and most of the people who came to see him address congress werent Senators or Congressmen, but congressional aides who had gone to fill up empty seats.
However, Obama has insisted on meeting the Queen when he comes next month, and when the Queen went to the US in 2007, thousands of people lined the streets to see her. I doubt this would be the case with a British President.
I totally agree with your comments about the US attitude to Browns visit.
Their 'gift' was a disgrace also (Hollywood DVD's) considering Brown gave Obama a pen + a case made from the wood of the last slave ship to dock in Britain!
But... Obama's opinion... or anyone's opinion of the monarchy's positives does not make their position any more reasonable, or logical, or productive or fair.
There are (to me) no positives from still having a hereditary monarchy... it just disgusts me. Why not you?
The Queen has no power but she does have prestige, which helps the UK maintain prestige in the world. Having a non-political head of state can be very useful. For example, if a tyrannical Prime Minister even managed to get to power, the monarch would be the only one who could remove such a PM and call an election. This is what happened in Thailand after the 1981 coup, when the King stepped in to restore democracy. In a sense, the UK's unelected head of state is democracy's last line of defence.
I concur with that completely. The monarch is like our last chance if something awful happens. And I like that traditions, such as this one, are upheld. They remind us of who we are, and what we came from. It lets us know of the brave people of Britain past, and how peace was restored.
it is in the govt's intrest to maintain the mornarchy. Presidents are far more expensive, plus presdential govt are in practice less democratic than parliamentery ones.
Depends - if the president merely replaced the Queen as Head of State, that wouldn't mean an end to a parliamentary system. Just means an elected figure would do the ceremonial stuff. I think Ireland might be run that way. The stuff in this video is really a tradition of role-play, which has its place. Perhaps this could be done as part of theatre for the public - like Shakespeare. Every country has some sort of pageantry or quirks of history to play with - like Morris Dancing!
At times I think that, but watching American traditions shows that a measure of pageantry is, or is used as, a focal point. Congress rising for the President is something we probably wouldn't like in a British context, partly because it might seem like the monarch running Parliament, and partly because we view the PM as supposedly working for us, and not the other way around! Maybe American traditions might seem archaic in 1000yrs. Who knows? The past is always tricky for the present.
Sorry mate, I'm not with you nor are most people. The ceremony in this video should tell you just how powerful the monarchy really is, i.e. not at all.
Brilliant Dennis Skinner highlighting what a joke this whole farce is. I think the best one was in the late 1970s, when the Commons refused Black Rod entry, and sitting was suspended! Shame such rebellion has disappeared as a spineless, supine bunch of careerist politicians are taking over
I hate Skinner! No respect for either tradition or suitable attire whilst in the house.... Typical uneducated and scummy labourite... Who would be on the dole if it wasnt for trade unions..
Skinner is an absolute star and one of the only honest politicians ever. I have a Phd and I respect that man so much. He gave all his salary to the miners strike and has always been there for his constituents. Please do your research before you make comments like this.
Oh you have a Phd from the mickey mouse college of shit degrees!! How special.... you must be right!!! tool... I was giving an opinion.... i happy to hear yours but im afraid you havent convinced me... the mans an outdated fool whos as useless as the shite party he represents!
Absolutely and spot-on Brighty, If he(Skinner) so concerned about his 'people' why the fuck did he walk out on his wife and get a younger woman?t The dirty old fucker! Skinner has the mentality of Hoolley Hoop, here, another socialist in denial! Can't Zanu Labourt get rid of this useless old dinosaur. He is bitter and twisted and stuck in a stupid idealogy!
I think it's great that we in Britain have ancient ceremonies such as these. They are a very important part of our national identity, and I think it's very sad that some people feel that we no longer need a royal family.
I first learned about this ceremony on 60 minutes...very interesting.
ilikemike2436 2 weeks ago
As an American I find this tradition very interesting.
ilikemike2436 2 weeks ago
lol i thought black rod was a person ha
ozipk 1 month ago
I love those paintings at 1:04 but when I went to parilament we rushed through them all and I got shouted at becuase I walked 1 metre away from the tour to look at them.
GCmediacourse 4 months ago
I'm an American but I love watching Prime Minister's Questions and hearing the stuff Skinner comes up with. I wish American politics were as entertaining.
Preston327 6 months ago
Hahahahaha.... Tory moles. What a kidder!
MrOhjames 6 months ago
What a strange custom.
How long has the blackrod staff been hitting that same worn spot?
ffairlane57 8 months ago
@ffairlane57
It commemorates the events of 4 January 1642 when King Charles I tried to enter the House of Commons and the MPs slammed the door on his face.
I think the tradition of slamming the door on the monarch's representative to commemorate 1642 dates back to the early 18th century, but the current door is only about 60 years old as the original was destroyed during the Second World War.
Medeasbiggestfan 8 months ago 6
KLEPTOCRATIC RAPE MACHINE OF THE ESTABLISHMENT AND THE RULING CLASSES ROLLS ON.
R1ag 8 months ago
What does Tory Moles mean? :/
RockerIsabel 8 months ago
You know where you can stick that rod, pal!
densaner77 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
POMPOUS ARROGANT THIEVES MURDERERS...THE BANKRUPT ENGLISH CROWN
WHERE IS THE TAMPOON CHARLES AND HIS WHORE SITTING ON THE TARNISH THRONE? FITTING END TO THE 'EMPIRE' JUST LIKE THIS WORTHLESS USA BUILT ON STOLEN LAND AND SLAVERY.
neilzep 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
POMPOUS ARROGANT THIEVES MURDERERS...THE BANKRUPT ENGLISH CROWN
WHERE IS THE TAMPOON CHARLES AND HIS WHORE SITTING ON THE TARNISH THRONE? FITTING END TO THE 'EMPIRE' JUST LIKE THIS WORTHLESS USA BUILT ON STOLEN LAND AND SLAVERY.
neilzep 10 months ago
Comment removed
neilzep 10 months ago
I WOULD EAT ALOT OF CURRY THE NIGHT BEFORE AND GO IN THERE AND FART MY ASS OFF...TAKE THIS YOU ENGLISH CROWN FROM INDIA.
neilzep 10 months ago
@neilzep People like you would never be allowed in the Palace of Westminster. You can fart as much in the street as you wish though.
adam4757 10 months ago
@adam4757 I WILL ALSO BRING A ARAB WITH ME ...YOU KNOW WHAT THEY DO. PFFT, A TANDOORI FART IN YOUR WHITE FACE. O HEAR THE COMMONWEALTH TAKING OVER BANKRUPT ENGLAND..KARMA SUCKS.
neilzep 10 months ago
@neilzep go and fuck yourself
BADDESTOFTHEMALLUKNO 9 months ago
Comment removed
pugilistofpower 8 months ago
@pugilistofpower You first Wigger,a wigger is a white nigger. You whites are the biggest parasite/virus on this planet and like all virus need to be exterminated.
neilzep 8 months ago
Comment removed
pugilistofpower 8 months ago
@neilzep: Racist.
kanenkitten 4 months ago
@pugilistofpower you first Wigger,a wigger is a white nigger.
neilzep 8 months ago
FUCK all this evil, masonic, occult bullshit. Motherfuckers, God owns you all.
AssSprinkle 11 months ago
@AssSprinkle
Why do weird Evangelical Americans always feel they have to get involved in things that don't involve them? Nobody asked for an arrogant American's opinion.
Myles0Harcourt 11 months ago
@AssSprinkle lolwut?
stinkyglasses 11 months ago
I wonder what the procedure is for replacing Dennis Skinner once he retires?
rederic2004 1 year ago
@rederic2004 I think the first joke after he retires should be something simple like "Nothing from Dennis this year?" If he retires through death (which could happen, as he is very old now) then they should just say "RIP, Dennis Skinner." That's my view on it anyway.
tr1ckydr1v3r 1 year ago
@rederic2004
Hopefully there isn't one.
Myles0Harcourt 11 months ago
You English are so weird....
murrangurk 1 year ago
@murrangurk Yes we are- and proud of it! :)
miahk2 1 year ago
No this isnt 1608, it is 2008......in England
LOL
WestBritWatch 1 year ago
they cant keep the United States out there mouth like a Dick, never have i heard any mention of the UK in ANY U.S ceremony, if they did it would be considered treason and 30 years in jail
thehulk3010 1 year ago
@thehulk3010 Whats that? I can hear 5 year old children dying across the Atlantic because billion dollar insurance companies have ripped his family off. The US has nothing to be celebrating in this day and age.
StudentEntrepreneur 1 year ago
Bloody wankers lol
Deathz0r94 1 year ago
Loved the way Black Rod turned his back to Dennis Skinner and stood right in front of him :)
annenatuurlijk 1 year ago
I am marvelled at how The British remember their political past every single year with as such meaningful ceremonies as these. I wish we, in Argentina, did the same with the lame politicians we have in Congress.
swaingles 1 year ago 3
funny to see that old left winger Jack Straw on his Knees to the Queen.
lndac02 1 year ago
Interesting. Never heard of this ritual before. So much I don't know.
MsTrollHunter 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
who are the three boys in red coats standing to the right of the queen? does anybody know?
mkeeble1989 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
who are the three boys in red coats standing to the right of the queen? does anybody know?
mkeeble1989 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
who are the three boys in red coats standing to the right of the queen? does anybody know?
mkeeble1989 1 year ago
who are the three boys in red coats standing to the right of the queen? does anybody know?
mkeeble1989 1 year ago
@mkeeble1989 I do not know there names etc, but if you are refeering to their function the just hold the Ermine train of the Queen's robes as she walks to parliment
ProfessorEdelstein 1 year ago
Keep the monarch and keep the tradition.
redface626 1 year ago
Dennis Skinner has always had the best quotes when Black Rod was about. This year was no exception "No royal commissions this week".
amiausUSA 1 year ago
what a pompous ceremony
dummyspitter 1 year ago
Haha dennis skinner what a hero
ianruth1 1 year ago
Oh come on, listen most women her age would be sat looking forward to their pureed lunch and an afternoon of staring out of a window at sparrows. We send her all over the world, and she never puts a foot or a word wrong. She is worth very penny and we are lucky to have her, god knows what's going to happen when she has gone. Do them the maths and compare how much money she generates compared to how much money she costs. I have huge respect for her.
vincaful 1 year ago
You have to admit, it is one badass, and highly symbolised, ceremony.
JustAnotherGuy186 1 year ago 2
Abolish the monarchy - use the money to help those struggling.
pardeepsinghk 1 year ago
What would you replace the monarchy with? Who would be the head of state?
The monarchy in the UK only costs about £0.69 per person per year. That's cheaper per capital than every President.
Medeasbiggestfan 1 year ago
A President who we can directly elect - he/she would be much cheaper then he entire Royal family and their various MANSIONS.
How many schools, hospitals etc could we build with those milllions.
I dont want my tax to go to a bunch of inbred, overprivledged, unelected swines.
pardeepsinghk 1 year ago
As I said, every Presidency in the world is more expensive per capita than the British monarchy. The Queen doesn't get a salary, the money she receives is to pay for her duties as head of state. Also, the monarchy brings in more money through tourism than it takes out through taxes. So abolishing the monarchy wouldn't pay for any new schools or hospitals.
You may not like the monarchy, but about 70% of the British people do.
Medeasbiggestfan 1 year ago
The Queen only started paying tax in 1993 (i think).
She has a personal fortune of £150m (that the press know of)
France doesnt have a monarchy BUT gets twice as many tourists as we do.
Why should any tax go to funding their castles, mansions, country retreats and staff.
If they really care about their subjects, then they should give that money back and live on their investment portfolio which I hear yields them around £20-30m per annum.
pardeepsinghk 1 year ago
A huge percentage of tourists come to the UK to see those castles and palaces, and to see events related to the monarchy. Most of the money the Royal family gets goes towards the upkeep of those places, all of which are part of our national heritage.
Much of the rest of the money pays for the Queen's duties of head of state.
The Queen is one of the most famous and respect women in the world, and the UK gets a great deal of prestige as a result of having her as head of state.
Medeasbiggestfan 1 year ago
Open up ALL the buildings that the public pays for - hence more tourist revenue.
The Queen might be respected but the next monarch is Prince Charles and lets just say he'll most likely damage this country's reputation.
I respect the Queen, but it makes me sick to my stomach that we're having to live in a period of "austerity" while the Royal family get the best that money can buy.
pardeepsinghk 1 year ago
As I said, the tax money goes to the upkeep of the Royal residences (which are part of our heritage) and to pay for the duties of the head of state (which would still be needed in a republic).
The monarchy gives the UK prestige, a link to our history and a unifying national figurehead, of which most nations are envious.
There is not guarantee Charles will become King, the Queen seems to be in great health. I think William (son of Diana) will secure the monarchy's future.
Medeasbiggestfan 1 year ago
Given that men in general, and from what i can see, men in the Windsor family, die earlier than women, its highly possible that Charles will die before the queen, or at the least, only be on the throne for 10-15 years
bulked 1 year ago
Then his son william will acceed...you got a problem with that??
histre101 1 year ago
no particualarly, william is a bit dull but nice enough
bulked 1 year ago
@Medeasbiggestfan Most nations are not envious. They might find the pomp and ceremony charming and quaint, but ask an American if they'd rather be a monarchy than a republican and the answer would be emphatically 'no'.
otleybey 1 year ago
@otleybey Are you for real? Are we to ask an American what he thinks and believe this will be of value in determining matters for Britain?
gwhite79 1 year ago
@Medeasbiggestfan She is famous and respected now, but was she when she first became Queen? How exactly is her fame important anyway? if we had a President they would be famous by virtue of the important position that they hold and their ability, not because of who their parents are.
otleybey 1 year ago
@otleybey
She was very famous when she first became Queen, her Coronation was shown throughout the world.
How many people can name the President of Germany? Yet that is a very important office. A British President would not be as famous or as respected as the Queen.
Having a head of state as famous and as respected as Elizabeth II gives the UK great prestige in the world and that is very important to the UK's position in the world.
Medeasbiggestfan 1 year ago
@otleybey Presidents are kind of boring anyway. Besides, even when you don't count the money they generate through tourism they more than pay for themselves through taxation of crown property, so effectively she pays you 60p a year for the honour of representing you around the world.
How many Presidents can you say that about?
vulnerabledonkey 1 year ago 2
@pardeepsinghk those estates often turn a profit from tourism income and such, actually. All of which goes straight into the treasury, last year or the year before the total was in the region of 20million. They're valuable as a tourist attraction, and the insitution is part of our history.
Amosral 1 year ago
tragic for you then that support for the monarchy rarely drops below 70%.
Britain will NEVER be a republic.
bulked 1 year ago
Wait until Charles is King.
pardeepsinghk 1 year ago
charles is actually quite popular incase you havnt noticed-hes using his position in EXACTLY the way he should-his charities.
they have brough untold thousands if not millions out of terrible poverty, into work and education. For that alone he has my admiration-having an affair? couldnt give a shit, it happens every day of the week
bulked 1 year ago
@bulked ... Not sure a self-described aspiring "tampon" should be King of Britain.
But if an Unfaithful Tampon were to be crowned King what sort of policies and changes would likely take place?
And how does that compare with any policies, practices, and changes if William were to become Britain's next King?
Also, what's the authority/basis for the Saxe-Coburg-Gotha family serving as monarchs of Britain, compared to other families?
And what are the Plantagenets doing nowadays?
ProNorden 1 year ago
Mr Tampon can be king as long as he keeps his opinions to himself once king-which is standard practice.
Anyway, he can call himself used Condom man for all i care, as he has more of a social conscience than most of our elected politicians as his chartiers clearly demonstrate-for that alone he will be well regarded
bulked 1 year ago
*charities
bulked 1 year ago
You seem to be assuming British monarchy dictate policy-trhey dont, thats why we allow them to remain-William, Charles it doesnt matter-the elected government dictates policy, the Monarch just does what hes told-thats why we fought a ci-vil war, to force this to be the situation.
As for the authority of the house of Saxe Coburg Gotha-none, because it doesnt exist-it became the house of Windsor 80 odd years ago
bulked 1 year ago
"ci-vil war" i mean civil war
bulked 1 year ago
@pardeepsinghk ... What differences/changes would you expect if Charles were to become King?
ProNorden 1 year ago
None, because he will be King of Britain therefore a figure head with no power
bulked 1 year ago
@pardeepsinghk actually your totally wrong-the US presidency, the French presidency-every major present, costs billions-the monarch costs peanuts
bulked 1 year ago
@pardeepsinghk its a shame you brits have no pride in your traditions. GOD SAVE THE QUEEN!!
charlesdcw1990 1 year ago 2
yes, because 69 pence a year will pull us out of poverty.
Presidents cost more than monarchy, so you will LOSE money that you want spent on the poor
bulked 1 year ago
Also Dennis says after Black Rod's retort, "We didn't rehearse it did we?!" Hilarious!
burnsybaby1987 2 years ago 2
LOL a great man - the only version I ever wanted to watch the opening of Parliament.
NeoFalcon69 2 years ago
Dennis SKinner = Genius! He's the only one who cuts through the pomposity of the State Opening, frankly it looked more ridiculous this year than ever....
Nosmos 2 years ago 9
@Nosmos, If it is so ridiculous I am surprised you watch it so often!
maxi1crawf 1 year ago
@Nosmos
Don't watch it then.
Myles0Harcourt 11 months ago
@Nosmos Skinner's a cunt...I'll be glad when he's dead.
cuntylishus 9 months ago
Ohyewildthong...And you my friend are a fucking twat. Skinner's the only honest MP in the building.
RipTheRam 2 years ago
parliament before State
3NUNS 2 years ago 2
I like this video because it shows the job of the Black Rod quite well.
ecoomber 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Skinner = moron
Ohyewildthong 2 years ago
The queen has hardly any power anymore
lowestoftbus 2 years ago 2
whers the door slam bit????/ wth
TheYasserRonaldoShow 2 years ago
1:25
Medeasbiggestfan 2 years ago
honourable house?
DMEB 2 years ago
reserve power is all theoretical, it would result in civil war!!! So no, the crown doesnt have any real power at all.
siobhanbligh 2 years ago
well put
bulked 2 years ago
This really symbolizes the power of the crown (in Canada, as well). If the Queen wanted to dissolve Parliament or appoint a new Prime Minister, she could. It is the ultimate check on potential abuses by elected governments, such as declaring a dictatorship.
fishhead06 2 years ago
wrong-this power has been devolved to the PM. She is mearly a representative of the soverign power of the state, the government that controls this state withtin the executive under the PM has the power
siobhanbligh 2 years ago
You might want to check the article "Reserve power" on Wikipedia - the crown, in fact, wields considerable power.
fishhead06 2 years ago
The door sounds crunchy
IrishLincoln 2 years ago
Fantastic i love Britain. Watching Cameron and Brown is like watching two school children who have been forced to get on by a teacher.
lowestoftbus 2 years ago
Ummm, what the hell are Torey Moles..?
CMLaneLV 2 years ago
it may be medieval - but it shows the relationship between the Queen, the House of Lords and the House of Commons.
Black Rod is sent to the Hose of Commons to summon them before the Monarch - the House of Commans slams the door in his face to show the Commons does not heed the whim of the Monarch - he must knock to gain entry and be inivted it. It comes from when King Charles 1st tried to arrest 5 members of Parliment and the door was slammed in his face.
Its all symbolic ;O
BritCam89 2 years ago 24
@BritCam89 I think it would be a better symbol if they all walked up and flipped off the queen and then liquidated her billions.
fenderstratguy 6 months ago
this is so medieval!!
knight7fox2 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that Dennis Skinner is a Knob lol
huricane868 2 years ago
I thought this was going to be funny, a man getting smacked in the face by a door. =[
kaineshutler 2 years ago
This Brutualtruth man who can't even spell needs a serious mental health assessment. He is so full of hatred.
hoolley 2 years ago
Comment removed
theskilled99 2 years ago
I have great respect for Skinner. I suspect a lot of MPs share his feelings, but haven't the guts to stand up and speak their mind.
Georgiahulse 2 years ago
What did Dennis Skinner say during the 1998 Opening of Parliament? If anyone knows I would be very pleased!
Nosmos 2 years ago
Ha Ha! You are so funny. Just a walking ball of rage. I bet you walk down the street screaming at people who brush into you by accident.
By the way, I'm not a cockney.
IJBLondon 2 years ago
Only at jealous socialists like you! Off to Cuba, Comrade Cockney!
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
Have just returned from Cuba. One of the most beaufiful places I have ever been too. The Carribean, the sand, the sea, the music. Wonderful
hoolley 2 years ago
Really? Cuba is nice and such a paradise that the people can't bear being there which is so great that they pack themselves in boats and risk death by drowning to get to Miami! Shame on you sort.propping up that dispicable communist regime,
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
I think you are talking about many years ago my dear. I have never met such happy people. Their health care system is amazing and the only reason many of them are poor is because of the sugar embargo enforced by the USA you fool.
hoolley 2 years ago
ou must have been on a Left Wing Guitt Trip, my dear! You probably avoided the absolute destitution of the people as you were probably on a Ethically Cleansed Socialist Tour. Typical socialist you are: ignoring basic facts to cover your perverse left wing idealogy! Sad really! :(
Are you a black African? Case closed!
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
For goodness sake take a chill pill. Just because people want a republic doesnt mean that they are commie reds. By the way what has the colour of my skin got to do with it?
Keep on taking your medication.
hoolley 2 years ago
Keep taking your medication mate. What medicine would you take? Socialist syrup? One mouthful fits all. When you get older you will realise the error of your pathetic class-war prejudicial socialist politics-of-envy ways. I pray for you! ;)
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
White, blonde hair blue eyes actually. You tosser.
hoolley 2 years ago
Brutual Truth is so funny I can't help winding him up. He is full of anger. He thinks because we believe in republicanism then we are red commie's and God knows what else in his deranged mind. He thinks because I went to Cuba on holiday that I was on an Ethnically Socialist tour. OMG he so makes me laugh, oh and then he assumes Im a black African male. BNP me thinks. He is funny though, keep winding him up and he will come out with more reactionary crap. .
hoolley 2 years ago
Did you notice how Cameron bowed when entetrng the Lordss and that fat drunk pyscho Jock of a Brown didn't bow- apart from his deformed side jaw!
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
Yes!
324wilson 2 years ago
Are you saying it is a good thing for a party leader to be subservient to the Lords? I'd vote for anyone who stuck two fingers up as they walked in.
IJBLondon 2 years ago
Well London cockney boy, I hope you will put two fingers up to the jock that destroyed pensions; two fingers to the jock that has turned the UK in to a debt-ridden basketcase; two fingers to the jock that has made a mess of immigration; two fingers to the jock that imposed 100 taxes over 11 years. Stupid foolish Republican cockney ignorant uneductaed twat!
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
The monarchy makes a mockery of our democracy. The House of Lords is a disgrace. Bugger off back to Ascot you Tory.
otleybey 2 years ago
And you can fuck off to Cuba or knowing your mentality - North Korea! Go on, off yer ,go we in the UK don't want socialist backward jealous zealots like you! Off you go, comrade brother! By the way ,Black Rod is showing us the the symbol of Parliament;s authority over the monarchy! You are so red and a communist zealot that you don't realise it!
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
So you think that giving the government royal prerogative powers that are not subject to judicial review or parliamentary scrutiny is a good thing? You think that the royal family are a good deal for the tax payer? I suppose you also think that its great that the House of Lords is unelected.
You're the zealot mate. How on Earth is republicanism and democracy backwards compared to a primitive system that most other countries have managed to get rid of?
otleybey 2 years ago
You let the cat out of the back there, mate! You are expouting Republicanism. I am not keen on the Royal Family but the vast majority of the UK population are and that is the way it should be. You are are another poisoned Socialist. You think your twisted socialist policies of 'one size fits all is ok' is ok. Well,if you don't like the UK, then fuck off to Cuba, North Korea, Venezuala or to match your mentatlity Zimbabwe! Stupid foolish boy!
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
You're an intellectual lightweight. Why do you keep talking about North Korea? Idiot. Actually it is not the 'vast' majority, there is a sizable minority who are republicans, and when pressed most people don't hold strong opinion on the matter. When pressed to pick a side on an issue that you don't really understand/don't care much about, you will almost always go with the status quo. Explain to me what socialism has to do with it please - although you probably don't know what it is anyway.
otleybey 2 years ago
I am called a lightweight by a 19 year old socialist in nappies! LOL. What the fuck is a sizeable minority? A miniority is a minority and a majority is a majority. Your socialist clapped-out Labour party were for 18 years in opposition and guess what! They had to drop the shite of socialist policies that you believe in to get elected. The majoriity rejected socialism! LEAVE THE COUNTRY if you don't like it! Off you go Labour 'yoof'!
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
Have to agree with you. Our BRUTUAL TRUTH friend sounds a bit deranged. Hes getting himself into a right old state isnt he. He thinks people are still leaving Cuba in boats.
hoolley 2 years ago
they are
andrewshd 2 years ago
I know, he is a complete raving mad idiot but its good winding him up. You can imagine him walking around rageing at anyone who is not wearing a union jack and bowing to the queen. Otleyboy lets make it a mission to wind up Brutually honest. I mean lets face it he doesnt evan know how to spell!!!! He is so funny.
hoolley 2 years ago
Wrong I am winding you up all the time and you have taken the bait, yer fat blond overweight pie-muncher. Take a look at your own speling - what a retard! Ha Ha! Please keep off the chocolates and crisps and the chronic masturbation. Ha ha, fat boy xxxxxxx
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago
Why does he think that because your a republican that you are a communist zealot and a red? Hes so funny old Brutual Truth.
hoolley 2 years ago
Go to Cuba, its paradise and the only reason its in poverty is because of the US embargo. Lets hope Obama changes that but the people and the country are beaufiful. lol
hoolley 2 years ago
I think I know what Dennis Skinner should go with this year!!!! "Has she put the palace on expenses?!"
Nosmos 2 years ago
Can't wait to see what Dennis says this year!!!!
burnsybaby1987 2 years ago 3
To me the Queen's Imperial State Crown seems too small. Instead of sitting around her brow, it floats on top of her head. It's a wonder it does not fall off.
mc0558 2 years ago 2
I cant see the problem with the current system. The monarchy is an integral part of our identity. Like it or not, its the genesis from which our governement evolved. There is no power wielded by the monarchy anymore, but its still a symbol of our great nation. If we were to scrap it on the basis of progess or equality we would be doing grave damage to the fabric with which our society is woven.
E1senheim 2 years ago
Isn't it inpirational to see our elected members of parliment be summoned to a house of fat, old, senile, over-payed, spinless, putrid, unelected slobs.
redplague 2 years ago 2
Most of the Lords were MP's at one time. Though i feel the upper house should be elected so the Goverment of the Day can't stack it full of thier own supporters.
juzt156 2 years ago
I want to abolish the monarchy...
who's with me?
saelaird 2 years ago 2
Not Tory Boy Brighty....He is probably as I speak polishing his collection of Majesty magazine
mickygin 2 years ago
Not me, not about 70% of the British people either.
Medeasbiggestfan 2 years ago
how do you know that?
nice imaginary statistic there!
saelaird 2 years ago
It's not an imaginary statistic. Do a Google search for BBC "Poll respondents back UK monarchy". The poll from late 2007 shows that 78% of people want to keep the monarchy and only 16% wanted a republic.
The Queen's approval rating has hovered around 75% for the last 50 years.
Medeasbiggestfan 2 years ago
I understand polls are important, but you can't take the findings of a poll as absolute!
Maybe I'm young and associate with younger people (most of whom in my experience are anti-monarchy)
Once the older generations die out, and times get tougher for the lower and middle classes, that 'approval rating' will plummet.
I certainly hope it does.
saelaird 2 years ago
Younger people have always been less enthusiastic about the royal family, but as they get older they tend to become reassured by the consistency and tradition of the monarchy.
This is certainly the case with my family, several members of which campaigned for a republic during their teenaged years in the 70s, but now support the Queen.
Medeasbiggestfan 2 years ago
But those family members have presumably grown-up in a cushy 1980's and 1990's economic environment!
It will be harder for my generation I think, and people will dislike the position and wealth of the monarchy.
I just hope all country's will eventually see the pointlessness and backwardness of monarchy.
saelaird 2 years ago
When Gordon Brown went to Washington no one in the US cared about him. Obama cancelled a press conference and most of the people who came to see him address congress werent Senators or Congressmen, but congressional aides who had gone to fill up empty seats.
However, Obama has insisted on meeting the Queen when he comes next month, and when the Queen went to the US in 2007, thousands of people lined the streets to see her. I doubt this would be the case with a British President.
Medeasbiggestfan 2 years ago
I totally agree with your comments about the US attitude to Browns visit.
Their 'gift' was a disgrace also (Hollywood DVD's) considering Brown gave Obama a pen + a case made from the wood of the last slave ship to dock in Britain!
But... Obama's opinion... or anyone's opinion of the monarchy's positives does not make their position any more reasonable, or logical, or productive or fair.
There are (to me) no positives from still having a hereditary monarchy... it just disgusts me. Why not you?
saelaird 2 years ago
The Queen has no power but she does have prestige, which helps the UK maintain prestige in the world. Having a non-political head of state can be very useful. For example, if a tyrannical Prime Minister even managed to get to power, the monarch would be the only one who could remove such a PM and call an election. This is what happened in Thailand after the 1981 coup, when the King stepped in to restore democracy. In a sense, the UK's unelected head of state is democracy's last line of defence.
Medeasbiggestfan 2 years ago
I concur with that completely. The monarch is like our last chance if something awful happens. And I like that traditions, such as this one, are upheld. They remind us of who we are, and what we came from. It lets us know of the brave people of Britain past, and how peace was restored.
I conclusion, Britain is great =D
GlobalInk 2 years ago 3
its all vanity! since when did tradition come before reason and equality?
AnarchistInTheUK 2 years ago
You are so right.
hoolley 2 years ago
It disgusts me watching this ridiculous outdated ritual. When will they ever come into this century and get rid of the monarchy.
hoolley 2 years ago
it is in the govt's intrest to maintain the mornarchy. Presidents are far more expensive, plus presdential govt are in practice less democratic than parliamentery ones.
juzt156 2 years ago 2
Depends - if the president merely replaced the Queen as Head of State, that wouldn't mean an end to a parliamentary system. Just means an elected figure would do the ceremonial stuff. I think Ireland might be run that way. The stuff in this video is really a tradition of role-play, which has its place. Perhaps this could be done as part of theatre for the public - like Shakespeare. Every country has some sort of pageantry or quirks of history to play with - like Morris Dancing!
curlyceltic 2 years ago
At times I think that, but watching American traditions shows that a measure of pageantry is, or is used as, a focal point. Congress rising for the President is something we probably wouldn't like in a British context, partly because it might seem like the monarch running Parliament, and partly because we view the PM as supposedly working for us, and not the other way around! Maybe American traditions might seem archaic in 1000yrs. Who knows? The past is always tricky for the present.
curlyceltic 2 years ago
You are right. Who did they poll? Statistics can be so wrong. They know what they are doing when they want the answer that they want.
hoolley 2 years ago
Sorry mate, I'm not with you nor are most people. The ceremony in this video should tell you just how powerful the monarchy really is, i.e. not at all.
SuperTrekNerd 2 years ago
Well if you're ok with hereditary inheritance of power, position and influence, thats fine.
I think you should earn it.
saelaird 2 years ago
Brilliant Dennis Skinner highlighting what a joke this whole farce is. I think the best one was in the late 1970s, when the Commons refused Black Rod entry, and sitting was suspended! Shame such rebellion has disappeared as a spineless, supine bunch of careerist politicians are taking over
emmetalk21 2 years ago 6
Lol. My favourite one was "Did she bring Camilla with her?"...
lelvish1 2 years ago
He also said as blackrod entered at height if a famous lager commercial, "I bet he drinks carling black label" lol
MrJpalance 2 years ago
Im with you as is most of the country.
hoolley 2 years ago
I hate Skinner! No respect for either tradition or suitable attire whilst in the house.... Typical uneducated and scummy labourite... Who would be on the dole if it wasnt for trade unions..
brighty0808 2 years ago 4
Skinner is an absolute star and one of the only honest politicians ever. I have a Phd and I respect that man so much. He gave all his salary to the miners strike and has always been there for his constituents. Please do your research before you make comments like this.
hoolley 2 years ago 3
Oh you have a Phd from the mickey mouse college of shit degrees!! How special.... you must be right!!! tool... I was giving an opinion.... i happy to hear yours but im afraid you havent convinced me... the mans an outdated fool whos as useless as the shite party he represents!
brighty0808 2 years ago
Absolutely and spot-on Brighty, If he(Skinner) so concerned about his 'people' why the fuck did he walk out on his wife and get a younger woman?t The dirty old fucker! Skinner has the mentality of Hoolley Hoop, here, another socialist in denial! Can't Zanu Labourt get rid of this useless old dinosaur. He is bitter and twisted and stuck in a stupid idealogy!
BRUTUALTRUTH 2 years ago 5
All this ceremony with the door slamming and knocking and stuff just seems a bit silly now.
TRWolf 2 years ago
It's symbolism.
Cheshirecat55 2 years ago
I think its about time Black Rod got his revenge on Skinner for all those times hes interupted his duties.
kanenkitten 2 years ago
I love watching these traditions, its so nice to see that they have preserved such an old tradition!
jtkalehua 3 years ago 5
I think it's great that we in Britain have ancient ceremonies such as these. They are a very important part of our national identity, and I think it's very sad that some people feel that we no longer need a royal family.
God save the queen.
calmac91 3 years ago 8