Added: 4 years ago
From: GregorSamsa1987
Views: 398,266
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (355)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Is Vanessa Carlton still with Andre Berto???

  • Great song : * (:

  • is this a demo version, or single version? this is definately not the album version

  • @XLnotsofunny It's a live version i believe.

  • ONE WORD: BEAUTIFUL

  • I've fallen big time for the simplicity of this and the innocence of her voice. Her record label has really let her down, she needs seriously to be shown to the WORLD. The same as Avril has...stunning, she speaks for a LOT of women here me thinks.

  • That's Stephan Jenkin's house :) LOL!

  • Love this song! <3

  • Love these simple recordings best.  Nothing but her voice and piano...ahh.

  • i love your voice<3

  • If a man proposed to me while playing this song....I would yes.

  • Through her father, she was exposed to classic-rock artists such as Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin

  • Comment removed

  • She is so Amazing < 33

  • she has an amazing voice and extra bonus points for playing the piano! she plays both in the same time, that is very amazing and beautiful! i wish i could do that, but i would probably mess up lol^^

  • loove it.

  • i love this song

  • Dang, this girl can sing! And she plays the piano so beautifuly and it goes so well with her voice. Excellent.

  • Yeah, I'm not really a fan of the studio version....I generally like a less processed, more raw sound- well, not raw exactly, but uncensored, I guess. That said, I liked the studio version of Heroes and Thieves better:) Oh well, can't keep a good woman down

  • a beautifull song! wish i could play the piano like that... but i guese i still need some help for this song ^^''

  • Shes so amazng. I wish i could play and sing like her.

  • (L)

  • AMAZING LOVED IT SOOO MUCH..!

  • This is extremely beautiful. Vanessa is enormously talented, both singing and on the piano. This is so very haunting and lovely. I love it :)

  • you know what? ! i really really want to learn all her songs on the piano!!! ugh!

  • my God, this song is so beautiful it hurts! & this sounds wayyyy better than the studio version.

  • Me and my fiancé I mean lol....

  • Magnieziu or what ever....I must wonder WHAT KIND OF MEN ARE YOU DATING?? don't assume a bad thing will happen and pin it to men. Granted there are some crappy ppl out there, but I have good judgement, we've been together for atleast 4 years. :)

  • My boyfriend just perposed to me (a couple days ago) and this song was on ( my CD) in my car. it's a special song.....I said yes. :)

  • Aww congrats :)

  • aww, grats!

  • that's sweet

  • its proposed *

  • -"Sooner of later you're gonna hate it".

  • gyaa~! congrats!!! wish u the best! hope u´ll hav a wonderful and happy future together! ^^

    btw. this song is soo good!^^

  • @HaruXlunaX Congratulations !

  • @HaruXlunaX aww :)

  • @HaruXlunaX proposed*

  • @HaruXlunaX i hope you too are doing well^^

  • @HaruXlunaX aww!! that's adorable so i am guessing that you guys are married now!?

  • @HaruXlunaX

    I know this comment is old, but I want to say congratulations. I hope you guys are living a happy life together. It certainly started out perfect, didn't it?

  • @HaruXlunaX  awwhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @HaruXlunaX perposed? What the fuck does that word mean?

  • @alexhirschmusic : asked to marry me, you pig. you can ask--but dont be rude you rhinocerous pizzel. typos haooen when you are on an iphone. not that i should be explaining to a back water moron like you. good day sir.

  • this version isn't that loud!!

    the original version is louder and better!

    but, i like this too!

    =)

    <3<3

    T.

  • I prefer this, it's her natural voice.

    Studio's hide the beauty of several artists talents.

  • I think this version is more haunting than the studio, but i like both :]

  • It makes me have good mood.

    Love it~

  • :)))

  • Cette chanson fait réfléchir.. On s'évade quand on l'écoute. J'aime vraiment, bisoux a tous

  • 1:40 sounds like white houses

  • Ti`am luat`o inainte :P

  • This song rocks! Her piano and singing skills are something to treasure.

  • she rocks

  • I do too anyway, but what's wrong with the puppy? Just curious.

  • Her music and lyrics are amazing, something you listen to and makes you think. I love her <3

  • "Awe-inspiring music" it says on Wikipedia gives people goosebumps. Well this song gave me goosebumps. Thanks for the upload!

  • I like some of her songs better when they have not been heavily edited, like i liked the rough versions of Heroes and Thieves, Twilight, and this one better than the album versions, but they are all fantastic :)

  • I like this song... like a lot

  • I love her she is so good at singing and trust me her voice makes u calm down on slow songs!!!!!I wish i could meet her and she's so pretty too.

  • so then request vanessa carlton on the radio if u think she's meant to be known by many peoples! - wanna join me?

  • V is amazing!!! she is really unique and beautifull!!! she write's beautiful music and she is really pretty! :D

  • wow

  • "cargo across the sea" means that you would do anything for thembecause you love them that much. I think. really gd song

  • i love this song

  • ammmmmmaaaaaaaazzzzzzzziiiiiii­nggggggggg! :D

  • Comment removed

  • fuck you.

  • No, I agree. Her songs are easy to play on the piano but what I meant was that I find it hard to sing and play both at the same time. I can do it but not without mistakes. Maybe I just lack more practice

  • nice~!

  • I really like this song

  • can someone explain to me what " cargo across the sea" mean?? cargo is not a verb... and im kinda dumbfounded o.o

  • i dont know but i think the lyrics are supposed to be "to go across the sea" instead of "cargo across the sea".

    im just saying. not sure if this is true or anything. :\

    plus, they kinda sound the same to get easily mixed up.

  • Look up the lyrics on her website. It says "cargo across the sea". I was just checking a few minutes ago because I'm singing this for a show at my school in a few weeks and I wanted to be completely positive. So there you go! :)

  • well thats weird. i have the sheet music and it says "to go across the sea" :\

    oh well.

    like it matters :P

    (;

  • I know, I have the same sheet music, I think. I downloaded it and there were a lot of errors - that's why I went and checked because I was afraid I had learned it wrong or something! Lol, but yeah.. It doesn't really matter! I just wanted to clarify to everyone because a lot of people are confused about the words! :)

  • I love Vanessa Carlton. It's really hard to sing AND play the piano at the same time without making obvious mistakes. This song by her is one of my favorites.

  • HARD to play??? i find all her songs easy to sing and play... i bet a lot would agree with me. but, everyones different. anyways, not trying to sound rude. i always like 2 comment & butt in- haha.

  • love her voice

  • Why do all the plastic artists do so well and artists like Vanessa less so......is everyounes taste in music so bad these days...new artists like Ana Free and Vanessa Carlton are so great .Their songs are meaningful. True musicians

  • like hanna montanna she sucks balls vanessa is way better

  • i really love her and her songs.. have an identity.

  • at first i didn't like this song (which is rare, i love everything Vanessa does) but then when i really started listening to the words and melody, i found it quite beautiful. her lyrics and piano are some of the most beautiful music i've heard in a long time, cuz it acutally means something.

  • thats really funny, cuz this is the only song i DO like by her.

  • awesome song!!!!

  • she is the best singer go vanessa carlton

  • This is one of the beauifulest music I had heard

  • I love her voice! it's so beautiful and meaningful :)

  • is this one live or something? cause i love her, but no offense, she kinda sounds...not that great in this recording. like as if she's pushing it

  • Vanessa and Stephen Jenkins broke up!!! she's with some tool of a guy named Andre Berto! He's a pilot or something! LOL. What a waste

  • Really I have to Google him. Wierd that she is going with a pilot, her dad is a pilot.

  • omg i was just going to say all that lol im going to google search it now too!

  • I think it's amazing - I'd like to see you do better, asshole.

  • i honestly doubt that. your friend probably committed suicide because you kept sending these damn chain messages to her.

  • You're right. I should send this and be weary of little-ghost-children who want to kill me because i refuse to send chain letters.

  • lol OWNED.

  • no way =0 !! I Made A Similiar [ idk how to spell ] Song Like This But With Different Lyrics And More Techno-ish lol , Shit , Mabey I Should Screw It lol , Think I Should ?

  • its my favo song from hero and thieves, dont know why but it simply is. the rec version is just so wicked... well she's just wicked, sigh tour plz ;P

  • what does this music means?

  • supposedly about 'reincarnation' and reuniting with your love (in past, present, and future)... I think. I guess it's somewhat complicated, but I admire it anyways.

  • Dieses LIed ist so hamma :):):)

  • Dalai Lama is not a what, its a who...a person that is, a VERY famous person at that.

  • i luuuuuuuuuuuv dis song but cood some 1 tell me wats a dahli lama

  • The Dalai Lama is the spiritual leader of the Buddhist people arround the world. Like a kind of Pope, but than different, you know.

  • can u make a kareoke like this

    sorry bout the first one..

  • can kaareoke with just the piano like thiss

  • she reminds me of michelle branch

  • I know!! She does! I was just watching Michelle Branch's video Breathe... then I realized how similar they are O_O

  • ahah sometimes i get them all mixed up

  • I like this version! Its very clean and neat. Just the piano and vocals. So Beautiful. I wish i could write such beautiful songs like v.

  • weird but i sing this like this whole album everyday when im washing dishes... my sisters are sick of it but suck it VC rules lol

  • great song:D:D

  • love her voice idk why but i listen to her songs wen im sad but they tend to make it worse cuz there so meaningful!...i love herr

  • Vanessa Carlton always has deep meaning to her songs i lvoe her she is just breathtaking and her piano works is BEAUTIFUL

  • Vanessa is my favorite singer ever! she is so awsome and i love her songs. they rock.

  • Vanessa is the best of the best among the females singers today, look at her style of music combination of rock, pop or sometimes alternative which is so perfect to her and she is very talented person rather than the other female singers today!

  • Disregard the other comment about Miley. We have a Miley-crazed fan in the club. *rolls eyes*

    Personally, I think the demo is better than the studio version. Vanessa is so pretty and her voice is probably blessed.

  • with all the songs out there about sex and drugs ,etc. it's easy to forget about poetic, soulful music thats also really great (like this). and i really respect her and what her music is. great job vanessa :)

  • I like this one because it sounds like she is singing to you.

  • @Stephanie44554

    i agree....

    but trouble is now i can't listen to this song without thinking subconsciously that she's in love with me..... :P jks

  • vanessa is way better than some of the shit out today u got poeple like katy perry singing about kissing girls and that makes number one and this song is miles better and it is not evan in the charts

  • Tell me about it. This is music, not that crap that is on the radio. Soulja Boy? LilWayne? Mike Jones? You call that talent?

    America's general taste in music sucks! My friends and I all agree.

  • i do not like hip-hop and rap. some songs i can stand others i just hate. i like people like vanessa here, and real music like rock and alternative. country's ok

  • thats true

  • @Rapmastac1 please introduce me to your friends. we'd hit it off :P  lol

  • I don't mid Katy Perry but yes there are some pretty shite artists that don't deserve to be famous and in the charts.

  • Katy Perry has other songs too and they are pretty good. THey have meaning too. It is also because people ask songs to be on the radio and then it becomes more famous.

  • I love Katy Perry, but I think artists like Vanessa Carlton are so underrated, which angers me because there are so many talented musicians out there who are overlooked. People think of Vanessa as "a one hit wonder" because the only popular song she had was "A Thousand Miles", and then mostly everyone forgot about her and moved on to whatever other hit singles were on the radio.

  • i just heard of her single a thousand miles...

    i have heard that song but i didnt know the name so its just the time that i searched it on youtube and i thought she was very popular because of this song and when i search for her name there were no music videos and live songs unlike other artists.....

  • I agree.

    There are alot of good stars that were from what, just a couple years back?

    Now all you hear about is Miley Cyrus,JB, etc.

  • Well, thank you so much for putting this demo version here. I knew Put your hands on me for a long time before release of it as a single and I thought,..hmh, why she didn´t release it. And then here it was :D

  • ok who cares rite now miley and vanessa are both singers good singers so shut up about it and enjoy the awesomeness of this song, got it?

  • ohk i what does this have to do with being a lesbian, huh? i cant find nothing in there about that, yeah

  • This is now one of my favorite Vanessa Carlton songs.

    __

    Miley is not even close to Vanessa. Why? They are two different artists. It doesn't matter if you think one is better that doesn't make Vanessa or Miley better.

  • she makes me cry, she's so good.

  • you're so cute

    she really is good.

  • did u just say i'm...cute?

  • omg.. miley sucks stop comparing here to vanessa!!

  • i heart this song!!!

  • For those of you who keep asking "Why are people comparing Miley and Vanessa?"

    So, Why?

    Ok. If you look closely at This Song (Normal Version) At around :50 Seconds into the Song, The Beat and sound is Exactly Identical to one of Hannah Montana's Song "Bone Thugz".

  • ohhhhhhhhh

  • Stop talking about Miley here. She is a stupid whore and is now where near comparable to vanessa carlton. Keep that slut out of vanessa videos.

  • word XD

  • that's so strange, it really does.

  • @KidMugen91

    lol...the "z" on the end of "thugz" makes it look soo tacky. then again, so is hannah montana... so it suits perfectly.

  • Personally I think Miley should grow up and showcase real, pure talent. I mean, sure, she sort of deserves her success and fame, but I hate her songs. It's like she wants to try too hard and blow everyone away with over-the-top music. I prefer a simple, great voice that has aptitude. I like this version and the studio-edited one, because you can tell they only apply some background music and a few instruments to liven it up. Vanessa's singing doesn't change.

  • that's so mean. she IS still a young girl. since when was being young & not completely grown up a fault?

    and there's no point in bashing music. music is personal. bashing music is like bashing people for feeling what they feel.

    i love vanessa's music.liiike. i don't know why, it just hits me the right way.

  • I totally love Vanessa carlton's music! They have their own uniqueness and isn't so annoying like some songs! But why are people argueing about miley cirus and Vanessa? But Vanessa is a lot better, i'm sorry Miley fans, but i just like Vanesssa better!

  • Uhhh eww Miley Cyrus shouldn't even be compared to Vanessa Carlton ... Miley has a disgustingly loud voice and sounds like a boy and she lip syncs in every concert...

  • Exactly.I like her songs that are written,but,I mean seriously!All she does is screams as loud as she can,and she thinks she can sing.I mean,no offense to Miley lovers.This comment is only for Miley haters.

  • ...Which is me. Miley Cyrus is so ovverrated, when I can sing better than her.

  • right.

  • exactly. personally, i prefer vanessa to miley, but you're right. they're totally different; you can't compare them! vanessa is more of a song-writer, miley's a belter. they're both good in their own ways and so long as you respect both of them as artists it doesn't really matter who likes who better.

  • WTF YO?!

    Vanessa blows miley the whorebag off the stage fer sure!!!!

    Vanessa plays music about real life,

    miley sings about crap she wishes would happen..

    so, yeah, vanessa wins by like 1,000,000,000 to 0

  • this sounds different from the actual song.. try to download it in limewire.. it seems this is a live performnce?..

  • no i think this version came out before the actual one with the drums and all that. its not a live performance.

    i personally like this one better.

  • when you here Miley you can kind of tell that they do things to her voice to make it sound more, well, techno. For instance, her song "See you again". Her voice sounds totally diffrent. No ones voice can sound like that. I think that she might have a good base for singing but they edit and add. With Vanessa it's all pure nothing done to it, you can tell

  • Vanessa is a beautiful, gifted musician, and is definitely among my top favorites!

    Why are you discussing MILEY in front of a totally uncomparable, outstanding REAL singer?!