Added: 6 years ago
From: goldshoe888
Views: 147,256
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (157)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Zhang is an awesome talent and an inspiring story. Nice to discover her. I wish her the very best.

  • Damn..... I just wish this was a better recording.....

  • she's a lovely girl with a very nice voice. good singing is good singing in any country.

  • No bad comments from me... the last singer to touch my emotions this strongly was the late great Teresa Teng.

  • awesome sound quality!!!!!

  • The singing is AMAZING ... however the videos audio quality sucks, WTF ??

  • Great voice and great song. Well done.

  • My husband who is working in China heard a song of hers and remarked on her talent. Now we're both listening to her...me on Youtube and him in the restaurants. No YouTube or downloading allowed in China.

  • not rippin on her cause i don't know shit about her...but the guy did a pretty decent job of the high parts that shoulda been done by her....so.......yeah, she okay tho....i guess

  • Spoilt by bad recording. What a shame, but Jane is a great singer with good voice. Its thumbs up for me.

  • i love you JAne Zhang,,i like your voice so much,,,your such a great singer that can line to a Hollywood singers. more successful to come on you...

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Compare her version to charice's, I would prefer charice's

  • @Babievn

    screaming is all charice does , if u think this way , charice is also better than celine dion

  • @nightsucks: If u think charice just scream, so david foster just like those who scream right?

  • @Babievn

    exactly , david foster failed to see the details that Jane can deliver , go and listen to impression of the west lake sang by Jane , composed by kitaro. go listen that first , nominated 52th grammys , is a top classed performance, i doubt charice can sing it

  • Lol the guy killed it ! He's awesome :p

  • its nice but be careful in lyrics specially if you're singing those familiar and giant songs...

  • well she does have an impresive range....but not really good Quality....its madness

  • This guy is Zhao Qi (赵祺) who worked together with Jane Zhang for a bar named "Music House(音乐房子)" in Chengdu.

  • that guy is cute. other than his voice, i find his looks at his age still very appealing. He seems to be the manager of ms. jane or the owner of the band.

  • I can't believe you said this guy is cute! He looks like a pig

  • hahahahaha! seaweed9999, you must be one of the guy's friends and you are making fun of him. anyway, I have my own standard which could be totally contrasting with yours. The guys is really cute.

  • i think they sound amazing for not speaking english as their first language! they sound way better than me!

  • Yeap, I agree. It's just phenomenal how they're able to sing a foreign song with such minimal accent. But, then, who cares. This isn't a show of who can master enunciation or use of diction. This is for those who enjoy fine music. I'm flat out impressed by these two very talented performers.

  • Now Jane's English Much better than that~!

  • ohhh man! the old guy's voice is amazingggggg! omg....wowwowowoww....

  • who knows the chinese name of that guy?

  • the guy has a strong voice

  • they are both are good!

  • Jane Zhang is an undeniably very great singer. The guy is good too, no matter what anyone may think.

  • He's not that good, but he's not that bad either.

  • Comment removed

  • Look who's talking. I didn't say she wanted to be EITHER, that's just my opinion, you stupid fucking retard. I didn't say anything bad about Jane so why do you care so much.

  • Comment removed

  • That's you alright. You can't even spell my name right and it's right in front of you! Retard! Just because I don't live in China doesn't mean I'm completely oblivious about the things that are happening there. Geez, I'm Chinese myself, if you haven't noticed.

  • Comment removed

  • Guess you don't know how to spell "forlorn" either. Whatever. I'm not coming back here just to reply some idiot who keeps removing his comments. He's just that insecure with himself.

    Have a nice day. :)

  • She's no Mariah Carey or Michael Jackson, but I must admit she did pretty good covering this. :)

  • the audio horribly under-reps her talent

  • Jane Zhang actually has an incredible voice with absolutely amazing range & versatility!! It's just that this video has bad sound quality, which makes her voice sound crappy, but in reality, she is a really good singer, she can literally sing anything, and make it sound good. Search up some of her other videos on youtube.

  • People should just stop comparing it and try to enjoy the song -_-

  • @ UALJYC017, maybe you just can't handle other people singing the song. Or maybe it's the fact that they're Asian that you don't like. I bet if Jane was American then you wouldn't have a problem with it. Jane's voice is wonderful, that other guy is questionable though. Music is universal & every artist is entitled to "cover" another artists song, especially if they're inspired by that artist. You might just be shocked that an "Asian" is defying some stereotype

  • The way i see it, singing popular songs will make people notice her. Its not wrong at all. Those songs have usually good melodies , good lyrics and widely accepted. Those are classics and by proving u can sing the classics well... you are considered a potentially good singer. Then you will probably go another stage by singing your own style, own music... I believe she has made that transition. She has her own songs now.. they are pretty good. Of ocurse also, she's pretty !!

  • We're really proud of Zhang, i think some people were giving some bad comment because of lack of knowledge.  May be is a good ideal to send someone from the West to challenge Mandarin songs since they're not unhappy that Zhang was singing their American songs...I would also like to see how good they could perform...

  • I said songs/COVERS.

  • her voice.... ah it gives me shivers!

    and i so badly want her hair xDD

  • Why do you care so much? o_O Those are classic songs, tons of people sing them. It's like in American Idol, where you pick a song to sing. This is no different; it's Chinese Idol. So don't get too worked up about this.

  • u daft prick, its a michael jackson song u moron.

  • 我不敢相信这么多人踩张靓颖,你们知道为舌么她和这么多大牌写歌­大师合作过吗?

    不怕货比货,只怕你不识货

  • u better write english coz not many ppl here in youtube understand simplified chinese....

    ~from hong kong

  • 台狗ajoe收啦  係又踩唔係又踩

  • ...well, the guy's pretty good! He's got soul!

  • She has a great voice, now time for her to go make her own musics now. I want to hear something more original. Getting tired of listening to old music she's trying to remake or something.

  • She already has 3 albums and 2-3 eps out, plus, she has done dozens of amazing movie theme songs, so she has A LOT of "her own songs".

  • Nice voice,but,the best feeling of this song who sing this song is,the original,jackson 5,micheal jackson.

  • 「海豚音」也被稱之為「咽音」。 真音是聲帶全面振動(摸著喉結振動明顯);假聲是聲帶邊緣振動(­ 摸著喉結振動較小);海豚音是聲帶沒振動(摸不到振動)。

    海豚音是區別於真音、假聲的第三種音

  • 感謝ajoe999將靚穎與mariah carey相提并論,當然現在靚穎還有一段距離,不過她會不斷努­力的,多謝您

  • 她高音部分的表現 差mariah carey差多了 大家可以和原唱比較看看

  • 人靚声响亮唱功了得

  • she is not win the competition, cos it is chinese competition, people not accepted this western voice very much.. but she is the one who did best after the competition.

  • 她高音不行 很硬撐

  • 高音是可以撑出来的吗,又来了个装内行的!

  • 哈哈,同意,高音是不能硬來的

    硬來只會破音

    大家只要看到ajoe999在jane post出現,一定是說什麼 高音不行的垃圾評論,其實他是不會分音頻的noob, 咽音都到了f3 還說人家上不到高音

  • 這個ajoe999出了名專反jane的

    人家明明唱高音跟吃飯沒分別,他硬要說她上不到

    看到ajoe999 nub 的評論全都是:高音不行

    我看到真的笑了出來

    有空去看jane唱天下無雙,亞洲沒一個歌手比她唱更好,lov­ing you唱到連外國人都讚

  • re:ajoe999

    高音是不能硬來的,硬來只會破音,不懂別裝內行,大家看到耶會笑­xdddddd

  • 高音怎麼不能硬撐 所謂音沒那麼高硬來就是硬撐 而且她高音不好聽

  • 外國人都讚不絕口,你憑"你自己的濫耳朵"去否定張?

    我便信外國人耳朵拉,人家聽的是英文歌,會的的是英文,哪跟你這 個連真假音都不會分的傻b討論?

  • 你pose幾段高音硬撐來看看,不會唱歌別裝內行

    台灣音樂節目常有人玩高音,硬撐只有2個後果

    一) 破音

    二)像尖叫,跟原本key相差很遠

    ajoe999我勸你回老家多聽marich歌,別愈說愈錯拉

  • i actually disagree. i love

    her voice more than mariah

    carey's. its not all raspy and stuff.

    lol =]

  • 1:46-1:47...little mistake in singing the word "Protect"...but overall great performance

  • She has a good voice, but she's not comparable to Mariah.

  • I'm in love with this girl lol...Great voice..5 octaves...Mariah Carey gonna have a run for her money. If she is in America, she'll be rich by just doing what she loves to do and that is singing.

  • Comment removed

  • i'll say the same thing i said before somewhere else. why did she not win the super girl competition? how did butches like zhou bi chang and the other girl, forget her name, win?

  • i like her sexy body her voice her face her hair and attitude. enuf said. i want to marry her.

  • WHO SING?PLISSS

    WHAT SONG?PLISSS

  • I'll be there-Jackson Five

  • 人靚,声响亮,唱功了得0

  • WHO SING?PLISS

  • 那男的在搞破壞哦 女聲那麼好聽

  • Beautiful song!!

  • she is far beautiful than i thought

    can't help like her

  • Amazing voice.

    if you dont watch you can barely tell she is chinese with almost no accent.

    Beautiful voice and beautiful face to go with it!!!!!

    bettern than most NA singers by far!!!

  • guz bum..... you blew d roof...nice rendetion..I admire you miss Jane Zhang ..I love u babe....

  • Jane eres fenomenal, maravillosa, cuanto te admiro, desde venezuela con cariño

  • She is the most beautiful singer that i ever see in my entire life.CONGRATULATIONS! and many hugs from Brazil

  • 100/100 for her

  • ok, she does hide her accent quite well in this song (as opposed to the "what's up" fiasco....). And she does a good job here.

  • She can definitely compete with the ppl on America Idol, shes amazingggggg. She sings some songs better than the original singer in my opinion. GOOO UUU!!

  • she sounds like Mariah !!!

  • I'd literally die for her. Seriously.

  • With a voice like that, she could tear the roof off. Excellent work.

  • The man ruined it..

  • Nope he didn't entirely ruin it... she saved it. He did good... but of course she's vocally superior to anything I've ever heard out of China (but we all know how ignorant the rest of the world has been about China since forever)

  • Excellent!! Voice we love you jane!!! We LOVE YOU!!!!! hehehe.... : ) :D

    PLZ Rate My Video!!! i did a jane´s  video too!!

    /watch?v=fDa4CthJlFY

  • she makes me have goosebumps!! she's great!!

  • She is comparable to Mariah Carey if not better

  • Is she that good? I think not. She cannot be better than Mariah, Both are good in what they do. But I if you notice, she copies the covers of most divas and sound- pitch and add-ons. No No, Simon won't be pleased.

  • Actually, Simon was more than pleased with her, he even left his phone number for her so that they can "keep in touch", and this girls got plenty of style.

  • She will be able with singers in America Idol contest anytime

  • WOoow Blooddy betterr then Marey carey , shes awsome :|

  • SHES AMAZING !!!

    she should be more famous LOL

  • This girl is so talented...it's SCARY...WoW.....She is amazing. Go baby go....! Love to hear her let - rip...!

  • So touching..when singers sing by heart,

    like Jane Z. She is great.

  • what isthe thing singers always had in their ears when are singing¿

  • when you stand on stage and speak with the mic, the speaker will be so loud that you can't hear your own voice inside your body, and that's very scary scene to be in. And by putting something in the ear, it allows the singer to be able to listen to their voice within their body, it also helps them to adjust volume. That's y you will see singers wear ear plug or have a hand to cover one of their ear if they don't have one

  • wowies alot of haters i must say..but um to that guy or girl hyseik or whatever its spelled maybe your just jealous cause you can't do it so no need to leave bad comments if you really don't like it then don't watch it..don't make a fool of yourself stupid!

  • ooo...a lot of jealousy....I love this girl's voice... SHE'S GREAT!!! let me say it again... SHE'S GRRRRREEEAAATTT!!!!!!

  • I'm shocked by her vocal!1 she is really talented!!

  • great voice.. too bad the frog is annoying...

  • Great voice! Love the way she sings. She must enjoy it a lot.

  • At this monent i'm with a litter sadness

    the Lyrics from her mouth was wrong .

    I always love Mariah carey

  • now you know maria was not the original singer of this song...t

  • her accent can be improved however she has a great voice!!! so does the guy wicked voice!!! itsd all about the voice, she'll improve over time

  • those of u giving negative comments.. why do u guys watch her performance if u don't like her english or her voice.. u guys are ridiculous..

  • that's easy!just wanna compare the so-called "dolphin voice" to the real dolphin voice..she's pathetic...u know what real voice is only after listening to the best..it's just sad seeing her ruining all mariah's best songs...

  • She's not pathetic she has more talent than American popstars right now. She's better than Kelly Clarkson, Beyonce, Ciara etc, she just has to find her own sound. She's better looking than Mariah, and Mariah can't sing in CHINESE so really, she's amazing.

  • that is talent?give me a break!you dun really know english!her own sound?i bet you are trying to say her own style!maybe..Mariah cant sing Chinese, so what?she can sing spanish; how about this whatever her name is?what's her total sales for whatever albums she has released?she is better looking?maybe i'll say younger looking; if she is not...damn pathetic.....sad...

  • WHAT!! I've been speaking english for 22 years you ignorant, simple-minded, blubbering idiot.

    I know what Mariah sounds like, I OWN her greatest hits cd, and I've been listening to her since I was a kid, and after all that I'm telling you that Jane's really good. How the **** can you compare total albums sold from someone who is just starting a career to someone who is already at the tail-end of it?

  • If her english pronounciation is her only flaw, then that's very easy to fix. Besides, if she's a CHINESE girl why the hell would you want her to sound exactly like a white woman, it wouldn't be natural.

    She has a lot of potential, her range is amazing. I don't think she's trying to say she's better than Mariah, she's just trying to show people what she can do. It's not a cover song, its just a performance.

  • wxc85, you are wasting your time answering that idiot. Obviously hysick is depressed, lonely, ugly, and sexually frustrated otherwise he/she wouldn't get upset at a singer in another country. Mariah doesn't speak Spanish. Jane sings in Chinese, French, Spanish, Japanese, and English. And her Spanish pronunciation perfect. I know this because entiendo espanol y me gusta su voz mucho. So leave hysick alone if she needs to put people down to make itself feels better then let him/her.

  • I guess so....

    It just sucks that there's a double standard. It pisses me off more than anything when asian ppl tend to put down our own race, simply b/c their english may not be perfect.

    And this idiot learns a few words and immediately rips on a good singer for difficulties in her 2nd/3rd/4th language.

    But I have witnessed white folks try to attempt to learn chinese, and fail miserably, but we don't give them hell for it.

  • It's not hard to say someone is good if they've already become famous, any fool could realize that. But it would take fool not to realize a good new talent when it slaps you in the face.

    Go look at her other vids on youtube. The one where she sings the opening to Condor Heroes is particularly good, and considering ur from Malaysia you should be proud of Asian talent.

  • Hysick, why are you so angry at a singer that you don't even know? There is a reason for your actions. Are you psychological ill or just stupid? Whatever you are suffering form there is help available for you. Go to your local mental health center and see a psychiatrist immediately. Also ask for something for your low self-esteem condition.

  • It's not hard to say someone is good if they've already become famous, any fool could realize that. But it would take fool not to realize a good new talent when it slaps you in the face.

    Go look at her other vids on youtube. The one where she sings the opening to Condor Heroes is particularly good, and considering ur from Malaysia you should be proud of Asian talent.

  • It's not hard to say someone is good if they've already become famous, any fool could realize that. But it would take fool not to realize a good new talent when it slaps you in the face.

    Go look at her other vids on youtube. The one where she sings the opening to Condor Heroes is particularly good, and considering ur from Malaysia you should be proud of Asian talent.

  • that guy kinda got a black dood voice

  • You got Rick-Roll'd! :D

  • who cares about her english..it's music man, love it or leave it.

  • Lyrics isn't right. She mixed up with other parts.

    Her english sucked. So badly.

  • Lyrics isn't right is NOT her fault, obviously you never even sing at all.  If you been in karaoke bar, you will notice MANY TIMES the lyrics are completely wrong and if you follow the on screen Lyrics. you will be WAY OFF THE ORIGINAL (since most videos are filmed by people live in other countries). She may be just following whatever is on the screen (or so called teleprompter?)

  • Couldn't help to fall in love her music!

  • is she the regine velasquez of china? well they're good anyhow.

  • Naw its not wack, wack is something that happens to you while getting whipped for not doing your work slave cotton pickin mother fucker!

  • I still think she has an amazing voice anyway

    I like her !

  • jane zhang not that good if she do duet. that guy suks LOL

  • CLose your eyes and listen. Sounds like Christina/Mariah. She has pipes

  • http://eladies.sina.com.cn/z/s­upergirl/2005/0606/4255.html

    if anyone wants to know more about her, you can visit this website. There are a lot of videos of her.

  • I agreed to takwingforever.

    I am Chinese and she is also from China Mainland.

    She is also a university student who studies English.

    So you should listen to more of her before you made comments on her

  • She is the best christina aguilera copy, I like when she sing I turn to you, she sing very very good and her falsetto amazing ^^.

    I am in Hong Kong ^^ and I watch the new chinese idol, Other girl very good like jane. ^^

  • i have to sadly disagree with all of you because if you listen to the original, she pretty much on key to Mariah's key. She's maybe only 15% flat, thats about it, BUT I MEAN DAMN!! for Chinese, this girl got pipes...so give credit. Like to see you do better ^_~

    <3 timmy

  • well, actually, it wasn't so bad...however, the beginning was horrible, the guy killed some parts, and she was off at times.

  • have to agree with nlee035

    she sounds the same in every damn song and nothing of herself! like Simon said: No "it" factor! no wonder she is third place.

  • This ain't American idol, Simon can shove "it" where the sun don't shine.

  • american idol sucks

  • Shut up your shit mouth, Cunard32, your idiot, I just listen her different song, very talent and well sung, she was born in China, and reach this level, lots credit for her, do not be jealous, grow up!!!

  • where she from tawian

  • Obviously not one of her best performance.. but you should also blame the video quality..

  • You totally butchered the word, "manage".

    But yes, this video is not one of her best.

  • Powerful performance, one of Jane's best!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more