Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (267)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • linda demais

  • Love the song so beautiful !!

  • So glad Hannah Montana is over with and it does look like she's lip syncing

  • Linda !!

  • miley is Awesome!! :D

  • How can you be so sure that she is lip syncing she has performed this song and some performances were really great.

  • BITCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • shes lypsinching. this is the actual song. fail

  • @sammelina12 no she's not.. havent you ever watched disney channel or something? they always show live performances but with the studio version song playing - so when she performed she was singing but they had switched when on TV - U CAN HEAR HOW THEY CHANGE TO THE LIVE VERSION IN THE END!

  • @MCrocks2 Your right they do the real song over her but why are people like, "omg she's so good" when you cant even hear her?

  • @sammelina12 cuz its still hear voice in the studio... ? And i also think this was extra good fx cuz compared to other versions on youtube the sound here was so so much better and with the violens added - plus her whoahahoh in the end is live and thats sounds really beautiful... BUT mainly on the studio it is still her voice..

  • @MCrocks2 they can edit voices in the studios thats why when people see singers live they're not impressed. and at the end it doesn't look or sound like shes actually singing.

  • @sammelina12 oh god you really did just say that? it doesnt look or sound like shes actually singing? ... geezz .. youre a really obsessed with checking how she looks when she sings or what?? .... IT CERTAINLY DOES sound like she's singing?? its her voice and its not the only time she ends a song like that... oh really they can edit voices??? i really really didnt know that?! i've seen miley live and i think shes BETTER live than studio!

  • @MCrocks2 okay i tried to be nice but your such an idiot. Yes I really just said that because at the end it's still the song they EDITED in the studio. Yes you dipshit they edit their voices and if you knew that, why are you saying that's her real voice? And she sucks. So this is fucking retarted I dont get why I'm arguing with someone over Miley Cyrus, a person with absolutley no talent. Go love Miley and tell someone shit who will actually give a fuck :)

  • @sammelina12 u tried to be nice?-yeah and im an idiot cuz i anwered you with my own opinions and you disagree-thats how it is?.No,her voice is dif.in the end from the studio version.I KNOW THEY EDIT VOICES!?it was irony cuz sure i live in the 17th century?ohgod, yeah i think its really pathetic too that you "argue" with someone over a person you dont "like".hey you decide what you do..i only answered YOUR question.n u know?u stop writing comments on vids of her if u "actually dont give a fuck"? 

  • @MCrocks2 Yeah you were acting like a snotty bitch the entire time. And you've been disagreeing with my opinions. No, her voice is deff. not in the end of the video. And you should really learn how to spell. :)

    I'm arguing because you're really fucking annoying. :)

  • @sammelina12 no i wasnt.. and how would you damn its writing.. i can tell you i smiled while writing the second message.... no i havent - i only told you that this wasnt lipsync.. um yeah. well correct me if im wrong (actually i shortened many of the words cuz there isnt enough room) but im not from an english talking country so i'll just see how you'll do speaking my language (: yeah i am really fucking annoying and thats becuz i have different opinions than you.

  • @MCrocks2 Nå da Danmark har brug for en bedre uddannelsessystem, fordi du er dum. Gå tilbede Miley og gå finde nogen at slås med på youtube. Sikke et liv du skal leve.

  • @sammelina12 haha its funny when you google translate and it just come out all wrong. the grammar really sucks and i wouldnt expect anything else from you since you dont speak my language - i only learn it in school. how good are you at spanish or whatever its pretty much the same. and can i just say.. i know i am good at english and just what do you think is so wrong with my spelling? - i'd like examples. new school system? denmarks got one of the greatest school systems in the world.

  • @MCrocks2 HAHAHAH, woow it took you a LONG time to figure out that I used google. Faill. And no, your English is really not that good. "well i like using it so what?" & "i meant that like 'quitly'" ?

    Canada's education system is WAY better than Denmarks.

  • @sammelina12 um yeah - i was only saying that it's funny cuz you had no idea what it said in danish when using google. (uh that Fail is the thing that really annoyed me in ur first comment).. yeah i see - that is really really bad english.. its awful - but really its youtube no-one takes time to write real nice.. i happen to have a sister who's been in canada for a year - and she liked how your chose your own subjects more in C but the teaching level is not as good in canada as in denmark.

  • @MCrocks2 yeah. okay then. And then your sister must've gone to a shit school because Canada's education system is the best in the world. And stop trying to bring Canada down because your mad with me. That's really really lame, and shallow. And why don't we stop emailing each other? I don't have for fighting with people who don't even live on the same continent as me.

  • @sammelina12 see know you're doing it again - its was only cuz u said C is way better than dk - i didnt mean to 'bring canada down'.. its just it is actually that way, like the chinese are on a higher level than many many.. its just the way it is actually. yeah there is no point. (:

  • @MCrocks2 Okay what are you talking about ? We're talking about two totally different things, and I even just researched it Canada has a better education system than Denmark. So what? Just drop it.

  • @sammelina12 wow that must've been funny. I know it for sure that the TEACHING LEVEL is more advanced in DK.. but yeah .. I'll drop it mama

  • @MCrocks2 HAHAHHAHA no. Canada has a better education system than Denmark, but yeah, drop it.

  • @MCrocks2 and your saying im making it all your fault when your blaming it all on me? Someone is a hypocrit.

  • @sammelina12 noo noo you got it all wrong - when i say you started it, i mean when you said you dont get why you do - and i meant that you alone are responsible for that-i didnt mean you started this weird thing we've got going on. and u know what?i know you're the one in an english talking country - but i know im great at english(:n its youtube and i only write blah blah casually and its nothing serious.and you dont know me but well funny enough i do-u cant say im not n then change what i know.

  • @MCrocks2 Actually Canada is a bi-langual country, and the two main languges are English and French. So it's not JUST an english speaking country. And good for you for knowing yourself, now go tell someone who cares. :)

  • @sammelina12 yeah I know. i wud ask what is your point in that? but yeah whatever.. Dont have to - everyone who cares already knows. (:

  • @MCrocks2 Good for them.

  • @sammelina12 yeah (:

  • @sammelina12 and what from what i get from your 'danish' message.. i dont mean to fight, you're a really taking something you kinda begun (i mean just read the messages) and making it seem like its all my fault.

  • @sammelina12 and it sure is funny how you seem to know excactly what miley looks like when she sings and how the end is studio version in the climb.. when you "DONT GIVE A FUCK" .. youre were the thta started commenting on mileys vids even though you dont like her and then go and act like you would never do something like that .. by writing you dont why you are doing it .. you did start it.....

  • @MCrocks2 I know what she looks like because I used to like her and watch her videos you idiot! Like use your brain! And your like a little kid with the quotation marks and the YOU STARTED IT. Grow. Up. If someone doesn't like Miley Cyrus, dont comment acting like a know-it-all. Because you started it.

  • @sammelina12 used to - shes probably grown up since... and does it really matter? its not like there is a code of how to look when you sing.. well i like using it so what? look at your first comment.. that fail in the end got me a little annoyed so i anwered with BIG LETTERS IN THE END, but the second i meant that like 'quitly' but you wouldnt know cuz this is writing. what did i start can i just ask? when i said you started i was talking about u not getting y you argued about miley - then dont.

  • @MCrocks2 kay you really dont get it. I dont care about this anymore, cuz it's really retarted. I just stated my opinion, and maybe you shouldn't have written in big letters if you knew that I might not have understood it. And don't think you have a part in what I do, with that whole "then dont" thing. :)

  • @sammelina12 i do get that you dont wanna do all this shit and i feel the same way, believe it or not. actually the big letters was becuz i put capslock on with that TV thing and then forgot turn in off? i dont, and neither should you

  • @MCrocks2 okayy then.

  • @sammelina12 HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH nope.

  • @MCrocks2 oui.

  • miley has an amazing voice who agrees with me

  • he is a wonderful singer

  • @kayssidie100 is she

  • Miley Is AWESOME

  • just about everyone on youtube that sung this song can sing it better then her even thoe she wrote it lol hahah that must suck cuz even people that cant sing can do it better then her hahah !

  • 1.take a deep breath

    2.think of somthing that u like

    3. press f10 5 times

    4.post thins on 5 youtube videos

    5. check ur back round 12 seconds ago

  • I hope you all know thats her voice..

  • Comment removed

  • @stardollteam

    It's called lipsync..

  • @stardollteam not very observant haha!

  • WISH I HAD MILEY'S TOES IN MY MOUTH :P

  • I like her dress

  • She isn't lipsyncing. Sang it live and then they put the track over top of it. At the end is her real singing though. You can tell by the slight difference in tone of her voice.

  • lip sync definatly

  • GO IMILLRY !! Woo woo!!

  • love her dress and i loved the movie

  • i love miley, but she is definitely not singing here. it sounds like the recorded version.

  • Hello. check out my new music youtube channel. Listen to "the climb" and others. Thanks for your time. Be well.

    Jesse. Y2JesseMartin

  • I WOULD SUCK THE SWEAT OFF HER FEET

  • watch?v=WMxEwUTDNoQ

    watch miley singing Climb live

  • miley's awesomee x however she is lip syncing in this. its exactly the same as the cd version, although the end is differnt.

    This is the first time for ages i have seen her lip sync.

    She always sings live, so good on her! unlike britney who never sings live. britney is awesome aswell x

  • lip singing!

  • lip syncing

  • Miley you are so awsome!!! You are my rol model.

  • dont hate on her sluts cus miley is my girl nomatter wat ppl say she is my role model so just shut up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • she is lip singing!

  • she is soo lip syncing

  • No she isn't it would be really obvious and plus that song would be really hard to lip sych because first all the ending isn't like that and her lips would be off the music duuuuuuuuuuuuuuuh stupid bitches

  • no, it really is lip syncing.

    what are you some little kid that just doesnt want to here her slutty idol sucks ass?

  • the climb one of my favorite song :)

  • LOL your only hatin on miley because she can sing and you obviously can't :). she's an amzaing vocalist, and gorgeous. can't wait till 27th december going to see her live at the M E N areana in manc :) xx

  • i love miley no matter what people may say. =)

  • u suck.... miley is the sweetest person with the biggest voice ever... i would like to see you sing better than her.... :)

  • I love her so much <3

  • all of u are hater cuz all of u want to be a kind like miley but all of u cant cuz u are so little behind her!

  • How about you guys grow up and stop hating on Miley do you know how rude and hurtful your being towards her commenting on her singing just coz shes famous doesnt mean it doesntt bother her. shes human too, she hurts jus like you.

  • She wasn't lipsincing after they shot that clip they just put the studio version over the live version and took that last part to make it seem like it was live

    People its Disney what do you expect?

  • No es en directo.

  • hey dumbasses... the audio is off from the video... it's what you can expect from a craptacular upload like this one... however... having heard the radio edit and this... they are not the same... her vocal solo at the end is different... her style at quieter moments is different... and for someone who can't stand this girl... i'm sorry... but this is one of the most well written songs of the last year, lyrically and composition wise... it's got it. period.

  • jjust becuase people lip sing doesent mean they cant sing thats there real voice so stop taking the piss out of people who are lipsyncing

  • she is so lip syncing

  • lol then she must be vaery good at lip syncing

  • Hahaha i was just thinking the same thing, but to afraid to write it as a comment

  • perhaps... But it's really her voice!!! Listen to other sons if you don't believe it.

  • i think so too.

  • i L.O.V.E it its my favoret song keep on rocken ps love the movie

  • AI QUE ROMANTICOOOOOOOOO

  • best song of the next three years maybe even longer than that!!!

  • uhm why does this say live? it is SO NOT!

  • This is my favourite song now...

    I don't like Miley very much,but this song is amazing!!!!

  • This song is brilliant!

  • wow shes good, but i hope u realize shes lipsynching in this video, if u listened to her other live concerts she sounds ALOT differant and i mean ALOT !

  • haha yes this is so playback :D

    You can even see it when you look at her lips, curse she looks different when she sings live I think ^^ Eyes closed and so on^^

  • wow pple haten on miley...she juz does wat she do best

  • i love love love miley, but that sounds just like the music video, so that says, that she was lipsynging in this video .. xP

  • I love Miley!

    but that was soo lipsynch ..:/

  • she sucks - - big time

  • stop hating on miley cuz seriously no matter how you hate her the reality is she's famous and your not so seriously you and everybody else that think she sucks are just making her life better so just stop...and do you honestly think that she cares what people like you,no cuz she has said that before that doesn't care what people that hate her think so just stop cuz she is living her life happy just acting and making music and no offense but you need to get a life too and stophating on her.

  • yea shes good , at fuck:))

  • STOP INSULTING HER!!

  • exactly she'z gr8t, very gd at singing acting nd a gr8t role model to me nd to others

  • totally LIPSYNCH :|

  • I know /:

  • Actually they put the real audio to the video, she wasnt lipsynching, the real videos are on youtuve.

  • she's lipsyncing omg if you can hear that she's lipsyncing then you need to get your ears checked...

  • it sounds like shes lipsycing its exacly the same as the the real version anyways ...

  • shes damn good. but she sings not live. ^^

  • She is lip syncing. This is the exact same as the studio version. Compare the 2. There the same.

  • is she lipsinching????

    i think she might be...

    idk tho

  • HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE

    miley. ew.

  • I would smell her feet

    I would kiss her feet

    I would suck her feet

  • FRANKMANNACO700 that's disgusting

  • you are just a fucking hater

  • hater?, i'm not her fan, but i dont hate her... i just think u are disgusting... why do u wanna suck her "feet"

  • lol I want to suck her feet cause her feet are quite lovely and very arousing. I once drank my piss for her and her feet :P

    I also would like to suck her armpits if I could ;)

  • omg. that's the worst n most disgusting thing i've ever heard....

  • n pathetic btw

  • and you're a fag btw

  • fuck you hater

    lmao

  • i love miley cyrus/hannah montana therethe best and i dont care what you guys think ill always be a fan of her no matter what!!!so back off the rude comments ppl!!

  • hahaha!!!. you are so right!! i also like miley a.k.a. hannah! hehehe..

  • shes perfect !!

  • shes lipsyncing huh

  • yeah it's so obvouious

  • i love this song.. but she has to lip syncing because none of her other live performances sound like this.

  • She isnt lip syncing...disney overlaps the performance with the studio version when it is shown on tv for better quality...on the night she was not lip syncing.

  • Tht sounds like the 1 frrom the soundtrackkk she is lipsinkinggg nott good

    xox

  • she isnt stupid, when they make a video on disney they over lap it with the real studio soundtrack of it for better sound they cna sing dickstick, she isnt lipsycin there

  • you guys are just jealous because i bet you suck at singing. so you say that every singer sucks. exept forr the ones who really lip sync. Haha on you stupid people!!

  • ur awsome i wana havemy life with ya CHLOE BIG FAN MCACAS4E

  • dude. how can celebs not expect everyone to know they're lipsyncing, like huh. it sounds EXACTLY like the CD. i wonder

  • She is definitely lip-singing.

    It's absolutely identical to the CD.

    You can tell she's not singing just by looking at her lips.

    And the cut to 'it's all about the climb' is quite rough. Only the last note is real.

  • if the last note was real there would be no way that she was lip syncing. so shut your face

  • Someone said that if the last note is real than there is 'no way that she is lipsinging'. But of course they're going to make her sing the last note - so that when she talks there isn't contrast.

    GROW A BRAIN!

  • NOT LIVE.

  • doesnt sound live

  • PLAYBACKKKKKKKKKKK

  • shes BAD at making songs

  • u fricken poo eggs.

  • She's Not Lip Syncing Gee'z Is It A CRIME That SHe's GOOD!

  • lol she wasnt lip singing you dumbys even though i dont like her i love this song and i know she wasnt lip singing

  • SHES THAT GOOD EH!

  • you're the one who's dumb or deaf listen again

  • Comment removed

  • yeah the live version is different than the movie, she is just lip syncing.

  • not live

  • my fave song

  • i love this song. but she is so lip syncing. oh well.

  • you puted the music on the video just admit it

  • ps in the movie when she sings the song they dubb it with her singing it live with the recording so thats why it sounds soo cool in the movie

  • where is she singing this in this version of the video?

  • She's lip syncing. Because this song she's singing "live" sound EXACT same as the one form the movie and CDs And if you hear her other videos she sings live really bad in this song. So she's not really singing this live.

  • Comment removed

  • Sounds Like You've Put The Music Over The Top Of The Video

  • she is not lip singing......shes the best.....2nd to beyonce

  • ur horrible\ bitch

  • Not Fuck Hr

    FUCK UUUUUUUUU!!!

    shez ad bst and y do u comment if u dnt lyk pple den dont comment u asshol!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i love this video