Added: 3 years ago
From: alexnadim
Views: 280,998
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (491)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • So pretty. I can't stop listening!!! Amy's voice is just so beautiful :)

  • Amy Lee is the lead singer in Evanescence right? I LOVE HER! :D

  • @doubledstar yes, she is! She plays the piano and sings for the band. she is amazingly talented!

  • Love this cover...

  • OMIGOSH I JUST REALIZED THIS IS AMY LEE. I feel stupid, considering I clicked on the video...

  • @CaptainessValentina Thumbs down. :\ Idiot. Why even bother if you should of read it before coming here? DUH.

  • Comment removed

  • @LeBeauPapillon1 That required no reply whatsoever... I wasn't saying anything besides stating my realization that it was Amy Lee singing and I made the connection between her name an Evanescence. It wasn't that I thought it was someone else singing, I just realized that I actually knew who Amy Lee was. PS It's "should have" not "should of" - don't be lazy.

  • @CaptainessValentina Wow. Big woop. I wasn't being lazy, as you can see my grammer is fine.

  • @LeBeauPapillon1 You mean your *Grammar? Good job.

  • @CaptainessValentina Everyone has flaws, jackass. No one is going to be perfect. -__-

  • awesome i now love her lol

  • Wow!

  • Fiona's version rules! Sorry

  • beautiful:D

  • Such a stunning cover!

  • OH MY GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!! THIS IS AMAZING! When the hell did she do this?! ARGH! MUST... HAVE.... THIS ON MY IPOD!!!!!!

  • did anyone notice that jacks bowtie is a bat?

    

  • @MrCubbycake i noticed it when i noticed zero's nose is a pumpkin lol

  • Freaking amazing.

  • okay but a bit nasal...

  • c: i freakn love Nightmare before Christmas .... and all their songs

  • i think evanescence and the nightmare before christmas is like the best thing ever........yeaaahhhhhh :P

  • thumbs up if you love it so much you turned your volume all the way up!

  • I enjoy both versions.

  • I really like this version. It's dark, sinister, and sad at the same time. I really like this version, but the original is also really nice.

  • ques'que Evanescence a à voir avec "Nightmare Before Christmas" ?

  • @louisecostard C'est simple: ''The Nightmare Before Christmas'' est formidable, Amy Lee est formidable... tu vois la connection?

  • Ur fucking stupid dude she has a great voice

  • Check out me singing sally's song! Lilzies- sally's song! :) 

  • Amazing you left me speechless :O

  • At first, Amy Lee, I'm like, shes a good singer..... then I'm like, this sounds like the girl from Evanesense...... then I'm like HOLY CRAP IT IS!!!

  • I want to marry Jack. I dont give two crapz about him being dead and whatever. I want him.

  • <3 

  • nice

  • I HAVE AN IDEA WHY DON'T THEY REAMKE INVADER ZIM CROSSOVER WITH NIGHTMARE BEFORE CRISTMAS EVREONE IS PLAYED BY JOHNNY DEP

  • As a newcommer to both of these songs today (I saw the movie when I was young, but didn't recall the song), I like both Amy's and Fiona's, but I think I prefer Fiona's. Amy's sounds very pretty, but Fiona's has a darker mood. Amy's sounds slightly hopeful, Fiona's sounds completely hopeless, and the later I think is the best way to portray the lyrics.

  • Chloe Boleti singing Sally's Song - Amy Lee (Nightmare Before Christmas) RMX DJ Zeraph

  • I love amy lees voice omg its soo beautiful if I wanted 2sing she would b my biggest role modle :) n I love the song too

  • OMG! I love her voice! =D

    She's amazing!! xx

  • (* I love nightmare before christmas its my favorite movie I also love amy lee she couldn't have done any better shes amazing and has made sally s song even amazinger lol I kno not a word but watevz. . .i<3 Both =D!! (*

  • I live

  • This is pretty badass.

  • Her voice is so unbelievably gorgeous. Is this version on iTunes??

  • Amy Lee + Sally's Song = Me, speechless... again.

  • "And does he notice me feelings for him..?"

    So hauntingly beautiful!

  • So beautiful. *o*

  • By the way, i change my mind. I think I wanna direct it. not tim and marilyn. :P

  • AMY LEE ROCKS!!!! She is SOOO much better then everyone else!!

  • I LOVE THIS this song will be stuck in my head forever

  • I LOVE IT!!!!!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3 <3

  • I do love Amy Lee and her manner of singing... everything sounds beautiful sung with her voice *-*

    And this song... its so sad and so stunningly beautiful!!!!

  • Eh... I prefer the original version to Amy Lee's... don't get me wrong, it's good, but I love the original waaaaaaaay better.

  • I SCREAMED WHEN I SAW THIS!! AAAAGGGHHHH!!!! I LOVE AMY LEE AND I LOVE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS!! <3 <3 <3 <3

  • thumbs up if u like the song,thumbs down if u r gonna be a virgin forever xD

  • @Pitlord1470 TT^TT i cant thumbs it up and dowmn.... i just picked down because that comes first ^_^

  • Amy Lee has always been so talented.

  • I LOVE IT! <3 (L)

  • Fiona Apple has to be jealous

  • personally I like amy lee's and then katethegreat19's version =)

  • @jnzettle Then go listen to Fiona and shut the fuck up.

  • @jnzettle I like them both ...but amy lee is more angelic and Fiona version sounds more folky ...but I think there both good.

  • this video is absolutely amazing... got a shiver all over... thumbs up for amy lee!!!

  • PERFECT NOW!!!

  • i can see fiona apple doing this song too

  • I seriuosly like this version better

  • i like both versions of the song

  • this song is so pretty....in a creepy way(not stalker creepy. halloween creepy)

    even though it is kinda sad...still love it though!

  • Both Amy Lee and The Nightmare Before Christmas are fantastic! :) x

  • Both Amy Lee and The Nightmare Befoe Christmas are fantastic! :) x

  • BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!! AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =D

  • Meh, it was okay, I guess. The instrumental was pretty neat how they mixed it at the end. But Her voice didn't hold the right sound. She wouldn't be able to replace Catherine. No Cathering O'Hara was not the best singer, which was half the point, the song was written for her. If any cover was better it was Fiona's. Who added her own twist with her voice, and something very dark, which I lovd. But there's no replacement for the original.

  • Goth's national anthem!!!!!Whohooooo!!!!!!I love this song and this singer.Hauntingly beautiful and scary good!!!!I love all of her songs including Haunting!

  • I dont reely lyk amy lees music.....but this is absolutley amazing!

    No words can explain the beauty of this cover!

  • OMG!!!!! she's AWSOME!!!!!

  • She's an amazing Sally :P She sings this really well! :D

  • She's an amazing artist! And why is this movie so amazing???

  • Anyone that says Amy Lee aint a good singer can blow it out their ass, shes the best singer ever

  • Both Amy Lee and Catherine O'Hara did wonders to this song :)

    O'Hara---the original Sally---sang the song beautifully, and her high-pitched voice gave Sally a very unique, almost authentic personality. It really portrayed the character's feelings.Plus, how can you ever hate the original anything...?

    As for Amy Lee, I think that she did an exceptional job with the song.Her voice having such strong emotion, the somewhat lower key really gave the song a certain depth.

    A great job to them both :)

  • To Evanescence, and a bit to poppy with the whiny sound she has.

  • One of my favourite movies <3 and my favourite singer <3 Amy Lee is magic...

  • i think fiona apples version is too deep and coarse for this song. sally is a tiny little thing and amy's voice depicts the voice of some tiny with a little, high pitched voice like sally o'hara depicted it. personal opinion dont kill me for it 0.o

  • Amy Lee--You are a goddess. ♥ You are even more amazing for redoing this song. You did perfectly. :)

  • i personally think.... tht Tim Burton and Marilyn Manson shud team up and remake this movie! and have a complete new cast!

    Jack Skellington= Johnny Depp

    Sally=Amy Lee

    Oogie Boogie=Rob Zombie

    Dr. Finklestein= King Diamond

    Lock=Jonathan Davis

    Shock= Lita Ford

    Barrell=Munky

    Santa Claus= Meatloaf

    Narrator=Alice Cooper

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx where does Marilyn Manson come in though?

    But I think that if Tim Burton really wanted to, he could get a cast of real actors, and the movie would be a success

  • @nmaster13 Manson could be the scriptwriter while Burton is director. PLUS! he (MAnsoN) could have some of his music in there!

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx OMG! That would be a kick ass cast!

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx no

    no noi no. They shouldn't re cast this, at all, it was perfect the way it was. Why change perfection?

    Except for Meat Loaf being Santa Claus

    that'd be hilarious

  • @jmaheroux perfection is meant to be changed to intrest some1 who saw it a different way in their eyes.... i see this movie with an amazing cast so thts how my remake will be

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx ahhhhh. Okay fair enough, not Johnny Depp though, he's been done to death, and not Amy-Lee, maybe like Helena Bonham Carter or something, Emma Watson? Meatloaf as santa claus would be awwwwwwwesome. though xD. i disagree about the perfection thing, but I guess itWOULD be kind of fun to see. but Danny Elfman was good for Jack's singing voice. =/

  • @jmaheroux well of course no one can replace the originals! i agree on helena bonham carter! i love her to pieces! she is so brilliant! meatloaf can pull it off so well! hes already like santa claus but wit a more sarcastic attitude lol i just like johnny depp tho and can see him doing the part cause he for some reason reminds me of jack

  • @jmaheroux Meat Loaf as Santa would be cool, awesome in fact

  • @torchwood11 that wud be amazing lol :)

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx i couldnt agree more with your cast

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx: Evil Movie lol

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx man,that would be sooo awesome: DD

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx No way. Tim Burton chose a perfect cast. That is why the movie is so awesome.

  • @DaveSpectacular no shit? im not trying to make the movie better im just doing it my own way. i love and respect tim burton im not gonna try to upstage him.

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx I wasn't trying to offend you. I was just saying that I don't agree. Like you said, Tim Burton and Marliyn should. That would deffo be cool.

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx that is an amazing idea :D

  • @emoskullbunnyxx thanks =D

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx

    Not a bad idea, but I don't think Johnny Depp would be best as Jack... Frankly, Johnny is great in every role, but I like the current actor for him, and the singer for him too, it's just so fitting.

    As for the rest of them, I totally agree.

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx

    Fucking Brilliant!!

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx OH YES :D That would be amazing.

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx  That's wicked cool! Love the cast choices!

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx .....OMG EPIC CAST!!!

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx you are an effing genius

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx that sounds like a great remake!

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx EPICSAUCE !!!! lol rawkz

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx i know right i was thinking the samething lol

    

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx Narrator=MORGAN FREEMAN

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx love this idea...but it would still have to be made in stop motion for me to watch it ;)

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx but this movie is a classic you cant remake it that would horriable:(

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx

    that would be fantastic for musical purposes, particularly Amy Lee. Johnny Depp isn't too bad in Sweeney Todd either vocally. It is something that could be done, but I don't think they should remake it to replace the original. That just can't be done lol, xx

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx hell ya i would watch it

  • @xXxSaintHydexXx Maryilyn manson=Jack Skellington 

  • @MrAbaham ur on crack. xD

  • i love evanescence!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • It doesn't SCREAM Sally, Amy is way too harsh for her(in MY OPINION) , BUT HOT DAMN this version is AMAZING! It does capture the emotions that needed to be portrayed phenomenally!!! Superb job well don Miss Lee!

  • this one should be the original....its more sally :]

  • I like how he included the song and the lyrics for us at the end

  • my hairs are standing in places that I can't even say!

    amy ftw!

  • waaayy better than the original, more emotion and amy lee has a voice like velvet

  • I love this movie and this song is just amazing(:<3

  • Both versions are good... fiona's is sadder still I think, its her voice and style, Amy lee is a totally different vibe.. its not the broken lonely sadness.

  • amy does so good on this song...the emotion in her voice makes it 10 times better

  • Amy's version captures Sally much better than Fiona's does. Her voice and the emotion in it screams 'Sally.'

  • Yeah. I've always loved Amy's voice and this song just captures it so well. I'd actually like to see Sally's voice acting be done by Amy too, but thats just my opinion. :)

  • COOL ;*

  • This song song was good already in the way that it was written. The lyrics are strong, but Amy Lee makes it so true. It's haunting. She has a voice that sends shivers down my spine, and this song imparticular really does that to me. It's incredible.

  • i like her voice and the song but this is just my opinion i think i like the fiona apple version more ps i dont wanna start anything its just a opinion but this song and her voice is beautiful when amy lee also sings it :)

  • love it!!! XD

  • LOVE IT!!! :))) <3 <3

  • I've Always Loved this Song. :)

    Its Amazingly Beautiful :)

    Amy Lee Is A Great Singer.

  • Amy Lee makes this song soooo hauntingly beautiful !

  • @thankGodforDavidG

    I agree. So gothic...

  • @thankGodforDavidG she has a talent to make things sound tragic and haunting but also like a lullaby that can put u to sleep

  • THIS SONG IS SO AWESOME

  • I love Sally and Amy, the perfect mixture <3

  • I so agree

  • this is the best song in the movie

  • I'm SO glad she covered this. Now to only hear a duet with her and Elfman. Man, that would be magical.

  • i luv this! i kinda prefer sally's version, but this is second best! i don't like fiona apple, not enough emotion...

  • Sally's version is better

  • maybe sally's version fits better with better with the movie, but there are more emotions in amy's version

  • Amy lees voice is so beautiful.

  • I love this song....=^.^= greetings from Bolivia...

  • beautiful!!!!

  • This is awesome. Whoever said she sounds like a whale better shut up. Amy Lee is a really good singer. So shut up.

  • @bfflmnopz4evuh GOOD?!?! You mean AMAZING, right? It's ok xD I corrected you. No biggie.

  • @bfflmnopz4evuh Haha, if this is whale singing, I wish I could sing whale!

  • Danny Elfman is a genius

  • haunting

  • I love this song,for a claymation film it's pretty deep song & this version is awesome.

  • this is beautiful.^^

  • She has the greatest voice... it gave me the chills :)

  • Nice art & tune !

  • absolutely beautiful song i love amy lees voice she is fantastic

  • Comment removed

  • THIS SONG IS GR8

  • she did an awesome job doing this song!!! it's one of 3 of my favorite covers on the album Nightmare Revisited.

  • My favorite cover of this song.... I don't care for Apple's cover, it just awful to my ears.... Amy Lee is a great and those who don't agree well they can just jump in a lake.... plus no one is more suited to the concept of Sally other than Amy.

  • this one gives me chills. :]

  • Hast Du es satt, zu arbeiten? Mit dem coolem Bonus Code: FILM bei fulltiltpoker com kannst Geld verdienen, ohne dein Eigenes zu riskieren! Einfach ein Konto eröffnen, Promo Code Refferal Cod FILM angeben und bis zu $600 Startguthaben kassieren.

  • no she dosnt!:o

  • LoL its called txt talk something your too stupid to understand

    BTW I have seen her with my own two eyes live and she is AMAZING!

    Id like to see you sing better...