Marilyn Horne - a most magnificent mezzo, a truly glorious voice. And Joan Sutherland, a Norma beyond compare. As an opera goer of that long ago 1960's I suffered through another soprano with the initials of MC until I found Joan Sutherland. No comparison, except for the next decades superb soprano Montserrat Caballe.
But, enjoy the legacy of recordings of Horne and Sutherland; they are a treasure.
Now, that's just silly. Why would you even want to compare Flagstad and Sutherland? Different generations, different repertoire. Why don't you give us an aria or a scene that they both sang so that we can compare them on common ground?
Joan Sutherland and Marilyn Horne perform the duet "Oh! Rimembranza" from Norma. Dame Joan introduces this 1987 rebroadcast of "the Concert of the Century" New York City Opera Orchestra Conducted ...
Thankfully...Ms Horne is teaching full time and making sure that Bel Canto doesn't die out...though I don't think there will ever be another singer like her for a long time.
LOVE the way they're singing TOGETHER instead of trying to out-do each other!! Makes the whole thing SO much more beautiful...two excellent performers, two consumate professionals - love this piece!
Horne's voice is so rich and yet petal-soft when needed. Such a large and agile mezzo, with such a beautiful tone and natural placement, she could have made her fortune never singing high C's.
I really don't care whether Horne could or could not take the high C in the passage referred to since her singing is magnificent regardless. The same applies to Sutherland. Insofar as Bellini's music is concerned, they are both peerless.
The "weak" high C was not taken forte, or even mezzo forte. If you saw the entire concert her high C was anything but weak. Also, Sutherland was quoting someone else.....she never referred to it as the concert of the century herself. I
thought it was certainly one of the concerts on the century, a display of vocal mastery that is anything but common-place.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
indeed!!! very rarely Horne sang the high C that so exquisitely G Simionato sang back in mid-fifties. But also Joan;s high C a few moments earlier is unsteady and weak... not their best day!!! abd definetely NOT the concert of the century as Joan calls it in the begining of the clip. Both of them have sung SOOOO much better in other occasions.
What I find amazing about this is the way they sing together. They even manage to co-ordinate their trills perfectly. You have to admire technique like this. And the dresses aint that bad folks!
This particular event had three legendary operatic stars in spectacular form (although Pavarotti is a bit raw for the Puccini). But If it's image you want, visit the Met these days. You'll see plenty of it, and not one great singer. How bad is it? Just wait for next year's LUCIA and NORMA.
Well, she doesn't need anymore, since she's retired since 1990! ;-D
Anyway, her looks were sometimes really weird, but, come on, wasn't most of the fashion in the 70's and 80's awful and weird? At least she was elegant and very polite, what is much rarer than a good image, and that also didn't matter when she had such great things to show (who cares about dresses or looks after listening to her?!)!
I don't find Bonynge all that "flamboyant"... not nearly as much as some other "straight" males in opera. But then too, if you are gay in opera, then you'd be gay in opera.
I was not there but I agree this was the concert of the century. If this is not singing, nothing else is. Love Marilyn Horne, love Joan Sutherland. It is a pity that opera singers don't live more than 200 years and have at least a 150-year career. I guess no one else will sing like these two precious ones.
Unforgetable! God bless the memory of Dame Joan.
Crobertn 1 month ago
Wonderful entertainment by great and consummate singers and performers par excellence! Bravi!
MrAndredekock 5 months ago
Many thanks for this. Luciano, Marilyn and Joan were in my opinion the best cast for Norma by far!!!!
emma41093 1 year ago
what's wrong with Horne's falsh lashes? or do I need bigger glasses?
buggerationable 1 year ago
R.I.P La Stupenda!!!
sebj66 1 year ago
You know it's good when you shut up and watch start to finish with your jaw dropped, and then start to finish again...jaw still dropped.
magicmonkichi 1 year ago
Gee this is nice.
drbarbarabaker 1 year ago
Marilyn Horne - a most magnificent mezzo, a truly glorious voice. And Joan Sutherland, a Norma beyond compare. As an opera goer of that long ago 1960's I suffered through another soprano with the initials of MC until I found Joan Sutherland. No comparison, except for the next decades superb soprano Montserrat Caballe.
But, enjoy the legacy of recordings of Horne and Sutherland; they are a treasure.
bobbieboy54 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Horne is really good!!
Sutherland is crap! Listen to Kristen Flagstad and compare!
If you compare "horseface Sutherland" with Flagstad...
Sutherlands sounds like a bad amateur!!
maxhansendk 2 years ago
Now, that's just silly. Why would you even want to compare Flagstad and Sutherland? Different generations, different repertoire. Why don't you give us an aria or a scene that they both sang so that we can compare them on common ground?
pckermit 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
OH!! Horseface Sutherland is back!
Yiakees!!
maxhansendk 2 years ago
Not just mezzo sopranos...but the greatest singers ever.
baritonebynight 2 years ago
Joan Sutherland and Marilyn Horne perform the duet "Oh! Rimembranza" from Norma. Dame Joan introduces this 1987 rebroadcast of "the Concert of the Century" New York City Opera Orchestra Conducted ...
ac3761G 2 years ago
she is the greatest!
0o0doir0o0 2 years ago
Two giants of the vocal art
USABOYMAN 2 years ago 2
We need to bring back this lost art, Bel Canto is real singing with proper clear voices and natural tones.
aminul1984 2 years ago 3
Thankfully...Ms Horne is teaching full time and making sure that Bel Canto doesn't die out...though I don't think there will ever be another singer like her for a long time.
baritonebynight 2 years ago
ROTFLMAO!!!!
Cramnella 2 years ago
This is what we call BELCANTO!
Perfect.
fabouw 2 years ago 5
Se Richard Bonynge nel frattempo dirigesse la Norma e non una Messa da Requiem sarebbe un capolavoro!
michelangelobo 3 years ago 2
I love hearing Joanie talk. So cute!
LaMostraESopra 3 years ago 3
LOVE the way they're singing TOGETHER instead of trying to out-do each other!! Makes the whole thing SO much more beautiful...two excellent performers, two consumate professionals - love this piece!
patssister1960 3 years ago 14
Their voices compliment each others so well.
VirnAlfakyn 3 years ago 3
Horne's voice is so rich and yet petal-soft when needed. Such a large and agile mezzo, with such a beautiful tone and natural placement, she could have made her fortune never singing high C's.
Hako2004 4 years ago 7
True. But, she did have one when she needed it. Her low range was every bit as good though...and in some ways even cooler to hear.
BeauTenor 4 years ago 6
I really don't care whether Horne could or could not take the high C in the passage referred to since her singing is magnificent regardless. The same applies to Sutherland. Insofar as Bellini's music is concerned, they are both peerless.
meltzerboy 4 years ago 12
Does anyone know if this concert is available on DVD, and, if so, where one can buy it?
timsuffolk 4 years ago
amazing. i love these ladies singing together!! :D
<3
xagentzero 4 years ago 4
The "weak" high C was not taken forte, or even mezzo forte. If you saw the entire concert her high C was anything but weak. Also, Sutherland was quoting someone else.....she never referred to it as the concert of the century herself. I
thought it was certainly one of the concerts on the century, a display of vocal mastery that is anything but common-place.
Hako2004 4 years ago
A) They aren't pajamas, they are obviously dresses, and they don't look that bad, just simple.
B) Horne rarely rarely sang high C's - more in the beginning of her career
C) Yes, they aren't in their prime... It's 1980! It's still great singing that we rarely hear!
D) Joan was never "fat." She is a tall woman, around 6 feet, and if she didn't have a few pounds on her, would look like a skeleton!
drdre333 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
indeed!!! very rarely Horne sang the high C that so exquisitely G Simionato sang back in mid-fifties. But also Joan;s high C a few moments earlier is unsteady and weak... not their best day!!! abd definetely NOT the concert of the century as Joan calls it in the begining of the clip. Both of them have sung SOOOO much better in other occasions.
Lohengrin 4 years ago
why doesnt horne sing the high c at about 7:00? Cant she sing it? most adalgisas do it..
twizzle99 4 years ago
What I find amazing about this is the way they sing together. They even manage to co-ordinate their trills perfectly. You have to admire technique like this. And the dresses aint that bad folks!
owenboi66 4 years ago 2
i listened to norma recording,joan,marilyn and pavarotti--lovely voice--bravo to 3 of them! remus
remrom2 4 years ago
She looks so much more feminine when she's speaking..
Fanome 4 years ago
This particular event had three legendary operatic stars in spectacular form (although Pavarotti is a bit raw for the Puccini). But If it's image you want, visit the Met these days. You'll see plenty of it, and not one great singer. How bad is it? Just wait for next year's LUCIA and NORMA.
clearandsunny 4 years ago
Two amazing personalities and wonderfull singers. A real inspiration!
christinegroeneveld 4 years ago
I don't care if she has got her pajamas on, she sings like an angel!!!
Mamasan41 4 years ago
I guess you are right, operaBR.
jaqueline Kennedy and Lady Di couldn´t sing like that.
Each person has its talents and music talent is the most exquisite one.
OperaGhost1990 4 years ago
jajajaja
OperaGhost1990 4 years ago
Joan Sutherland is a great singer, but she needs an image manager.
I know lots of people will be ofended with my comment, but is what I think.
OperaGhost1990 4 years ago
Well, she doesn't need anymore, since she's retired since 1990! ;-D
Anyway, her looks were sometimes really weird, but, come on, wasn't most of the fashion in the 70's and 80's awful and weird? At least she was elegant and very polite, what is much rarer than a good image, and that also didn't matter when she had such great things to show (who cares about dresses or looks after listening to her?!)!
OperaBR 4 years ago
Well, it's puzzling that her rather flamboyant husband couldn't give her fashion tips, wink wink...
ariodante76 4 years ago
I don't find Bonynge all that "flamboyant"... not nearly as much as some other "straight" males in opera. But then too, if you are gay in opera, then you'd be gay in opera.
urgrad03 4 years ago
Sutherland and Horne, are still the best Belcanto singers.
Indeed a pitty that singers have a longer carreer!
But....fot us students, a great study.
Thanx Dame Joan!
X
andreasscholl 4 years ago
I was not there but I agree this was the concert of the century. If this is not singing, nothing else is. Love Marilyn Horne, love Joan Sutherland. It is a pity that opera singers don't live more than 200 years and have at least a 150-year career. I guess no one else will sing like these two precious ones.
zoozooyou 4 years ago