Added: 4 years ago
From: Rice28m
Views: 36,041
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (321)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the way most people I know use it is to use imovie 08 for compatibility. import files into 08 and save the project, then open the project in HD so that you can import previously incompatible files yet still edit them effectively. Although this is mostly a mute point because 09 and 11 DON'T SUCK.

    but if you're stuck with imovie 08 and HD, there's the solution to using both programs effectively.

  • @hobocamptheater I have iMovie 09 and it's fucking unusable. It DOES suck.

  • @DanneskjoldThePirate oh, well I've used 11 and at least for me, it's freaking awesome. although I've only heard 09 was good and never used it myself. thanks for the correction.

  • YEAH FUCK IMOVIE

  • @glogman at least imovie 08, 09 and 11 are pretty good.

  • In my opinion, the whole "new" concept in imovie different from other vid editing programs and what makes imovie unique SUCKS. It just doesnt work for me, regardless of which version.

  • any IMOVIE after 07 sucks. period.

  • i think imovie 09 was a little better. You can speed up reverse or slow down video. They do have travel maps, backgrounds, green screen effect, and picture in picture. I'm sure imovie 11 would be more better than imovie 08. But not as good as imovie hd.

  • you have a nice voice :)

  • @js07ccg haha i was thinking that! i was expecting an annoyed rant but the whole video sounds really pleasant XD

    I'm using imovie8 myself and i cant even get the upgrade anymore sadly

  • NO slo-mo in 08 sux balls, 09 is the shit

  • My teacher insists on us using imovie to edit our films. It really sucks ass if you want to do advanced editing. I'm used to using Sony Vegas and i got so frustrated I couldn't add the effects in imovie that I wanted to. I thought it was supposed to be easy to use but that doesn't mean dumb it down.

  • I just started with iMovie 08 and it's VERY easy to learn quickly. I think that's a POSITIVE thing for beginners, housewives, young kids and proud dads.

    If you want more control of your timeline, it seems to me the solution is obvious: Start using Final Cut Express.

    Again, I've only used iMovie 08, so I could be totally wrong. Maybe iMovie 06 was great. But I think Apple's trying to make things REAL EASY for non-pros to make a quick movie.

    The pros (or hobbyists) can simply move up.

  • at last iam not the only person who cant slow or speed footage up 08 is shit who ever made it deserves to get shot!!

  • watch my movie - البارحه ماسليت - لبشير شنان - it was don by Imovie - and the others were don by nokia cam , see the difference !

  • ilife came on my macbook.

    I hate the new imovie.

    But on my imac it still has the old imovie, phew.

  • Download link doesn't work. :(

  • you are 100% right

  • Don't dis Apple!

  • i have ilife 09 and imovie 09 is amazing we have ilife 09 at school as well as imovie HD

  • i agree!

  • All the school computers have this crappy program, and the school district will not let anyone install new applications to replace this crappy program. AND WE HAVE TO MAKE A LOT OF PROJECTS FOR MOST OF OUR CREDITS, THIS THING SUCKS ASS!!

  • @ipodtouchuniverse You can do it in 09 or 11 version but not in the 08 version

  • 0:00-0:05 how did u get that black background and then put writing on it before the video started. can u snd me the link to imovie download i been lookin everywhere and i cnt not find it.

  • '08 sucks so FOKN BAD.

  • i hate imovie 08. ick.

  • I've spent days arsing around just in order to find out what I can't do on 08. Far too much time and money spent on making it look slick. I am trying to fight a growing sense of deep and meaningful hatred of apple. They appear to have taken the HD6 download off there page. Unless blind rage has prevented me from seeing straight after too much time day dreaming about kicking the living nanny out of the turd licker that made this software.

  • its true... i've had much problems with imovie because i can't do things i use to do on my old PC on windows movie maker

    so it makes things very hard

  • the new imovie is an absolute fail.

    apple seems to have downgraded it in an effort to make users go out and buy third party apps. (final cut pro. etc)

    really unnecessary.

    and another thing, what happened to appleworks? once again, making suers head to products like microsoft word!

  • Their are video effects in ilife 09, and you can also use a timeline like look, but it is very difficult to figure out. The audio is also very hard to use as you stated.

  • lol YES!!!

    THANK YOU!

  • it really sucks :S

  • Man. iMovie HD doesn't even work on my new MacBook Pro. balls

  • Fuck apple and their stupid piece's so shit they make. I fucking hate them now because of this. I used to be the biggest apple fan until they pulled this shit. Fuck Steve Jobs in his faggot ass.

  • Haha your just jealous!!! haha.

  • Nah, I wouldn't call taking it in the ass something to be jealous over. What I mean is that I hate that Apple fuck over everyone. I deleted iLife 08 and stole HD back by torrenting it.

  • you can split a clip just select an area of 0.1 sec and go up to edit and click split.

  • well at least i got Final Cut Studio with my MAC

  • lucky -.-

  • This new IMOVIE sucks DICK...

    Who the hell said this was a good idea.....

    They should be ashamed of them selves for releasing this trash.....

  • it was a port of WMM for mac

  • okay i have a question. everytime i add a title to IMovie HD, it turns blurry. I don't know how to get it unblurry so can you possibly help me?

  • well theres always torrents for anyone who wants final cut pro fo free lol

  • I just tried using my new imovie on the $2000 mac i just baught.... and its awful.... thought i might have to go back to using my 7 year old mac with the old imovie... glad to find out i can get an older version on new mac! ugh stuuupidnessss

  • so true!!

    imovie hd is much better

  • the new imovie blows

  • I love you.

    <3

  • iMovie '08 seriously sucks in my opinion.

  • boooo 08!

  • final cut express!

  • this video save 2 years of my life i could have wasted looking to speed up something

  • I love Adobe Premiere!

  • Thank you for posting this. I thought I was just stupid or something because I find it hard to do some stuff in iMovie in iLife 8. I think I'm going to go check out that iMovieHD or maybe envest in iLife 9. I've heard iLife 9 works better with VoiceOver anyway. :-)

  • mac is on the right track with ilife 09 they have the same format as 08 but brang back the features and made editing much easier

  • thank you!

  • The iMovie '08 transition is a lot like the Mac OS X transition. Apple wiped the slate clean of any legacy code, causing both advantages and disadvantages when compared to the predecessor. However, over the years, both products regained credibility with successive upgrades.

    It's clear Apple wanted to start clean, and they've redeemed themselves with iMovie '09 in my opinion.

  • so true-.-

    i used both imovies for my latest video because imovie 06 can do the slowmotion effect and imovie 08 can turn the videopicture by 45 degrees:)

    combined, they're fuckin powerful.

    imovie 09 is these two apps in one.

    nice.

  • is imovie freeware with macbook?

  • Yes.

  • how about a circle around something?

  • i have imovie 08 and you can do every thing you said it can't do

  • how do you slow down the video in 08??

    pls tell me if u know it.

  • i do,not know yet but i'll find out

  • can you please explain then how you can reverse a clip on imovie 08?

  • nope!

    hehehehehehe!

  • you can do most of these in the ,09 version.

  • agreed too.

  • I completely agree.

  • ok for my style of editing i like to speed up slow down reverse/overlay/fade that kind of thing imovie 08 has dick all, i might post a video just showing how much it sucks, because all it is for is pretty much just drag a clip add a title and music and thats it, which is pretty low.... anyways i was woundering what a good editing software would be for me, im also new to macs, if you would click on my profile look up the vid motocross riding you will have a better understanding of the editing

  • i like my regular Imovie better...

    i can take out parts of the clips i dont want, i can do better v.o's

    ..

    but Imovie HD Is better in other ways...

    you can speed up, slow down, reverse clips,

    and there are more effects, but the quality of the films through the built-in camera SUCKZ

  • How do i slow down or speed up clips???

    i never knew how.

  • get HD, go to the editing tab, then video fx, and you will find an effect that says "Fast/Slow/Reverse" there you go

  • This is so true that I'm almost crying because I couldn't use a slow effect on my latest film!! *holds back tears*

  • i agree. the new imovie makes me want to shoot myself in the face.

  • No excuse for not having any effects

  • fuck imove 7, its absolutely ridiculous and pointless, it makes so much more sense in the previous versions, wtf!

  • is there any way where i can get youtube videos and put it into imovie?

  • Download the video (search how on YouTube) then drag it into iMovie. There are numerous ways of downloading YouTube videos.

  • my videos come out bad :( look at them :(((

  • Not really a rant but good none the less.

  • Edited with Imovie 08 (ironically), hilarious

  • yes i agree with ViolentDimensions, you can actually change it to black and white, and there ARE hidden effects.

  • actually you can change a clip to black and white by going to the little sun in the left top corner and adjust the exposure saturation and the rbg the contrast etc

  • the funniest part is that you actually paid for the ilife package... what a silly idea

  • the new one sucks and the old one isn't great either

  • Yeah I just got this new iMac and this new iMovie sucks. I'm going to download the old one that is much more simple.

  • THANK YOU!!! I have been SO frustrated with iMovie! Then I saw this and now I have the RIGHT version of iMovie! =D Again, THANK YOU!!!

  • check out my video that shows u how to do effects in imovie 08 i am posting it as a response

  • there are some video effects in imovie 08 watch my video about it

  • I like imovie 7 better, because it is easy to use, I agree: imovie hd has more functions, but it is difficult to use, and t's annoying that you have to import the same clip again if you have used a bit of it in your projekt.

  • is this free??

  • imovie comes in ilife, which comes free with every new mac. if you own ilife you can download imovie HD

  • I love apple, but iMovie 08 is only a waste of money... You`re totaly right, it's difficult to make a video in it, iMovie HD is so much better!

  • my black and white tutorial is in the video responses list :). its the 02:45 minutes one.

  • Dude, i love making videos, and my parents bought me a 1500 dollar mac JUST for the freaking video editing program!! And i looked at it, and it's a total duche! I use WMM now and was totally looking forwardt to new features and stuff, i checked it out, and not even a timeline! IT was like stepping into a forign country or something, i was so lost! So, you're saying it IS possible to get the timeline even though you're using the newer software? please reply, i'm in desperate need. Thanks!! :)

  • you don't actually need a timeline,,,

  • well excuse me if that's what i use and apparently a lot of other people too since there are so many freaking complaints about it.

    I can SEE The actual beats with a time line and it helps so much to sync the music with it. Especially with fast music like techno or metal.

  • you wanna know how to put video effects and audio effects on imovie 08?

  • Um. I downloaded the other version, 06, so if that response was to me, then thats okay. I think i can make my way around 06.

  • I know how you feel. I hate iMovie '08. I use FCE as my main video editing software, but I use iMovie '08 on occasion.

  • actually you can put video effects on imovie. select your clip and press v on your keyboard.

  • Imovie '08 stinks!! it is needlessly complicated. Has no effects at all and gives you a headache!! Stinks!!!

  • imovie 08 = worthless

  • Lern2Cinelerra. It's opensource, compressed it tar.gz so you can install through terminal, and it's the free equivalent of finalcut or Vegas. Oh btw, Linux ftw. I may get macbook to take along with me some places, but Linux is my main stuff :3.

  • iMovie ' 08 is great. i put movies together easily and can edit them quickly and efficiently. If your looking for more get Final Cut Express

  • i deal with it lol

  • you're right!! I had my hard drive replaced so I lost my iMovie HD 6 :(( Now I have only iMovie '08 and it sucks!!

    (btw I don't have iLife '08 so I can't get iMovie HD 6 back... that TOTALLY sucks!!)

    :D:D:D

  • i totally agree

  • I don't have a problem with iMovie08. I don't need the time line, it's easy for me to add and edit audio and video, I can add transition effects and slow downs at any time. It's easy for me, I don't why your all having so much trouble, I tried iMove HD and just was like, what the hell, this is like going to windows movie maker again.

  • Thank you MOTHA FUCKER!!!! Gave me my perfect, reliable, and efficient iMovie back to me you son of a bitch! If you are ever passing through my state I'd cook a linguine dish for you straight out of my Godfather's kitchen, and serve it with an imported glass of wine from Italy. I'm subscribing you Sum-una Bitch lol. Grazie pizan.

  • WHy apple why? What the hell is going on with 7.1-7.~?

  • you're right .. im actually using that same iMac HAHAHA

  • Great Man! I agree all you say.. Thank You !

  • hey, i know how to make it black and white in imovie, i have a tutorial but not such a high quality one.

  • geez i thought i was stupid or something not knowing how to find effects on the new one i guess not

  • I get a kick out of this only because you said that you can't do the effects like B&W, etc. Yet there is a video a kid uploaded telling you how to do the effects in 08. To me it just sounds like you are use to the other version and are not willing to learn the 08 version.

  • i totally agree

    and thank you for the link for imovie hd! i downloaded it to make more complex films, and feel like i'm going from imovie to final cut or something haha

  • I totally agree, it is made for speed and not for quality as it was before!

  • I agree. Thanks for letting me know that HD is available for download. I was about to despair.

  • you can change it to black and white just go to video adjustments which u must go to the clip and click the sunny icon and put the saturation at the lowest.

  • uhh ull get used to 1movie 08 eventually, even if it can't do all the same things it can do new thigns as well, though your write precise down to seconds editing for music makes it very difficult especially when attempting to sync music to video speech it drives me nuts

  • iMovie '08 is such a disappointment. Placing music is simply frustrating, no effects is SHIT, how can they possibly call this an 'upgrade'. i have started using WMM because for the first time in a long time, it is much better and easier to use than iMovie. Shame on you apple for destroying such a good program. RIP iMovie.

  • hahaha vila edits on this shit!

    good wee vid tho

    i enjoyed it

  • i have an old macbook with the last i movie... I IS MUCH BETTER!!!! I MOVIE 08 SUCKS BALLS!!!!!!!!!

  • oh my god i JUST got a macbook pro and i thought i was screwed! it has imovie and im getting final cut pro from my friend but i was just speechless and i thought i was dumb because i couldnt use it. i thought there WAS a timeline and i just couldnt find it and ive been editing things for a while. i used an old version of imovie a long time ago on somebody elses computer and it wasnt that bad i couldnt believe how they could downgrade something so bad. no timeline is crap

  • Oh good so i'm not the only one who couldn't use Imovie 08.

  • damn it! My parents got a MAC and if iMovie sucks, im screwed! I love making AMVs and have been using WMM for years now, and i've come to love it...wth am i gonna do now? -.- this blows.

  • the old imovie was amazing brilliant software.

    the new version sucks it is too simplified.

    you can get the old one somehow its way better than WMM

  • Yes, it's a Mac only application.

  • They did it for business reasons. Make more money if you have to pay for the features. Plus the typical consumer does not want alot of control.

  • Aiiigh!  They turned it into Windows Movie Maker! Oh, the humanity!

  • can you download the previous versions of iMovie?

  • Yeah.

  • oh ok well that good

  • THANK YOU. I just got a new Macbook and was SO excited 2 b able to use iMovie. I had been using Windows Movie Maker previously, and gee whiz I thought THAT was shitty. First off, iMovie doesn't support AVI or MPEG files, and WMM DOES. So strike 1, iMovie! Strike 2, I opened it up and find myself completely stumped. WHERE IS THE TIMELINE?! This shit is so user friendly that I can't even fricken figure it out n I've used FCP for about a year now @ school! I guess it's back to Windows Movie Maker..

  • oh my god exactly the same thing happened to me! i just got my macbook today and i was so so so pumped to try out imovie cos i couldnt stand windows movie maker anymore.. turns out windows movie maker is freaking better than imovie! wtf...

  • COMBINE THE TWO..please apple do it. I'd really appreciate it. It'd make my editing SOOOO much better and eliminate me having to decide what I want to sacrifice in my video.

  • i just bought leopard and it came with 08 and 6 HD. HD just wasnt in the dock; i had to search for it

  • i think so

  • thanks yea I Movie 08 is kinda plain im gonna download the older one i miss all the effects and editing u could do etc

  • hey everybody!! do you know how is the song called?? where can i get it?? please pm... thx!

  • i absolutely hate this program i'm really pissed

    i'm editing a movie as we speak and i'm very frustrated

    no video editing at all, only color changing

    fading on music is bull

    it's ridiculous that they consider this an upgrade

  • Imovie 08' has some pretty good Ideas but i hope in the next iLife apple will combine ideas from both IM 06's and IM 08'

  • I couldn't agree more.

    I too upgraded to imovie 08, and was quite dissatisfied to discover that you can no longer use simple effects on clips, that i could in an "older" version.

  • thaaanks!! now I know why I can't make my videos slow or faster

  • im new to the mac and imovie is soo hard for me to use. i cant even make a slide show of pictures on it. if anyone knows how to please help me

  • I AM SO GLAD I FOUND THIS VIDEO!!! I HATE IMOVIE 08!!!!!

    im downloading the old version again, i loved it.

  • macs suck cuz theres no sony vegas or camtasia wtf? how can i showu match camtasia and how the hell can imovie rival sonyvegas

    no effects wtf? lol

    mac is stupid workers

  • i cannot agree more however i feel that ur video is not nearly aggresive enough

    the old imovie was excellent, comprehensive and spawned and entire era of movie makers

    this new system is the only one that will support my brand new HD camera.

    they took out effect, audio placement sucks the timeline is altogether gone it is not designed for movies it was designed for slide shows now i am forced to shoot my movies in low def and edit using the comprehensive version or i can spend a grand on finalcut

  • mmmmmmmmmmmm

  • You just answed my question on my i cant speed up or down my videos.

    Damn apple is not my friend no more!

    love the video!

  • U R MY HERO

    thanks for the link

  • Why all the hating on iMovie 08, never had a problem with it, and yes I had iMovie 06 HD, have not felt the need to go back. Probably because I am using Final Cut Pro, but whatever, upgrade to Final Cut Express you won't be sorry, well you would be sorry if you didn't know how to use it, actually I do use iMovie 08 frequently set parameters, quick edits, and make it .XML file and fine tune in Final Cut, never had an issue, but that's just me...

  • How the hell do i use iMovie 08???

  • EW I HATE IMOVIE '08

  • can i download any imovie to a dell inspiron 1420 with windows vista?

  • No. Get a mac.

  • Did u just take snapshots of the screen or did u use iShowU, or any other program that lets u tape wats on the screen. i totaly agree. i was going to do my first you-tube video the other day, and when i went onto iMovie to edit it, well, lets just say a few minutes later i was thinking about throwing the keyboard out the window and shoving the mouse up someones ass. i agree with u 100%

  • I think theres two kinds of people: people who understand that imovie08 is gods gift to mankind, and Neanderthals...

  • can u use isight on imovie 08

  • imovie 08 really does suck

  • i have ALOT of videos saved on iphoto

    but when i try to use them in imovie, none of them show up

    and then

    when i try to import directly into imovie from a digital camera

    an i click import from camera and try to chose a different one then the camera that comes with the mac, i cant

    so basicallly i just can use videos in imovie and idk why

    CAN SOME ONE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE HELP ME

  • Search "iMovie HD Download" and you should see a download for this GOOD version at the Apple site.

  • totally agree... iMovie 08 is Apple's Vista... sucks balls!!! I thought Apple was a better company with "more intelligent" consumers than microsoft. Now it seems they both suck.. Please OSS masters make an OSS video editor!

  • agreed

  • Uhhhhhh, so many complaining people. imovie 08 does not really suck, I personally like it. imovie 06 is not as easy to use, and although it has visual effects, i like 08 more

  • We concur with you

  • it's both good and bad, i use it acctually a lot more than i expected, i use FCP to make the main movies, some really really small movies i'll use this version or the 08 one. Also apple does know it and they did it for a reason, Final Cut Express. if you make a great program that does the same thing than a greater program, why not make the first a bit less to market the second more, does that make sence, i'm not sure if i explained it well

  • I own a mac due and loved imovie for a second, until I wanted to add a crazy transition. At first i was wow awesome i am gonna add a really nice looking crazy transition! Then i could not add any of them and haven't figured out how to. What is sad i went to school for video! The 08 sounds bad and I will not buy! I see this happen all the time in pc world, i thought mac was better than this! Oh yeah Apple, you really need a save for Youtube feature then you would on your way!

  • i use the old version of iMovie, iMOvie 08 sucks!

  • edited with imovie 08, ironically,lulz.

  • SCREW iMOVIE 08.

    THEY SHOULD RENAME THIS PROGRAM IT'S NOT iMOVIE ANYMORE!

    They should name this crappy app.

    "ALL I DO IS TRIM MY CLIPS"

  • Hi. Im new to macs, but after discovering imovie i've born a new interest.

    I'm frustrated with imovie '08 as well.

    Slow motion and other effects really matter, and i'm very dissapointed in mac.

  • just download imovie HD. it rules

  • can u have both the old n tha new 1?

  • yes

  • ilife 06 rules! :D

  • i hate my imovie! it stinks! it is soooooo hard to use!!!!

  • Could be worse.  Could be Movie Maker.

  • Consider yourself lucky. I bought iLife not looking at the fine print about iMovie'08 not being compatible with Power PC macs. Burned.

    Apple really dropped down a few notches with me. Now I'm glad didn't waste time w/ '08.