The Click Five------Mary Jane with Eric

[domodiLLeta]

powerful.

[nikkicutiestar]

Kyle is seriously better :)))))) Kyle sounds the same when he's singing live and with the recorded version. Eric is good but... Where is he now? He's not that good of a solo artist

[glensamson]

both versions are great!!!

[TheScarrr]

Eric was singing this song? Wow.. So, honelsty, in this Kyle is much better!

I lone Eric, but it's not his song to sing. xD

[Horsecrazed117]

i didnt know eric preformed this song ever

[HanCour]

Wow. If i had been there i totally wouldve cried.

[click5rox123]

cool song :)

[ChemicallyAlice]

ERIC!! That lovely stud <333

[dazzledazzlezah]

i still like kyle's version better... it's nice though.

[xiaobin90]

I like eric's version

[fluteplayer007]

Eric can sing this song and it sounds good but I still prefer Kyle's version, he just sounds more powerful

[daiyingqingri]

i miss eric !  but i know there is no chance that he come back to tc5. ~~ kyle is amazing too. so both 2 guys i luv !

i do not know why eric leave away fron tc5 and make a new band ?

[fluteplayer007]

He went solo, and tried to pursue acting

[stygianmessiah]

kyle 's version suits this song more.like how eric suits jenny n kidnap my heart.its not whos better.its the kinda song they sing

[Redirah]

yea, his voice suit with the tempo...it sounds more pretty...seriously!!

[triiiish09]

..both versions are great..

..so i think it would be not fair for the both of them if we would compare them by saying who's better than who?..dey r both great in such diffrent & unique ways..

[angel010193]

ok i thought kyle did really good on mary jane until i heard this....eric is better...so so much better.....i miss him too but some ppl make it sound likes hes dead! stop that!!<3

[neverstopinspiringme]

i love eric and kyle... but i think TC5 were a much stronger group back then. as for this song, i like both ways. (:

[fluteplayer007]

If they were a stronger group, than how come in the interviews when they talk about the split, the guys say the band was close to falling apart altogether.

[sawdnbtrb]

omg, i miss eric so damn much now.

[12345Clicked]

Eric's version is waay much better.

[mahrizyah]

I love Eric's version... the notes he hits are really touching...

Maybe it's because his voice resembles someone I know.

But I love eric Now & Forever. I prefer this version.

[abigailscholz]

i miss eric 100% but kyle's kinda cool too...

[nadia497]

Kyle version is better

[bostonmayo]

He didn't come back to sing it. He originally sang it. The video is just from before Eric and TCF parted ways.

[mEntZheriCk]

seeing this makes me miss eric a lot!

and i'll never compare between him and kyle coz both of them are gr8 singers!

[mEntZheriCk]

i miss eric!!!!!!!

[fiioonaaa]

Oh my god that is so gay. Boo Eric.

I love Kyle.

[sNowaNgeL2395]

i dnt like the way he sang it... no offense but.. kyle is REALLY BETTER THAN ERIC... Ö

[VeryFiona]

u know nth so dont compare like you know. dont talk as if u know kyle and eric, comment with brain my dear.

[isabellacullen2]

wow!!! im in sock they are both amazing at singing i cant decide whos better...rock on:)

[ConquistadoresBand]

Such a wonderful song. And a wonderful singer.

ERIC DILL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[coolhazim0]

Boy...I'm glad that I'm not the only one who realised that. It's so true that Eric is so much better. You needn't be a proffesional to realise this because it's obvious. GO ERIC! Haha. Kyle may be better in looks but no way near Eric's voice. But I don't think Kyle's that good looking after all. ;) peace out

[khimmy88]

Stop !!!

You Stupid Girls!!!

How could you say that!!

Eric is sososososososos Better than KYLE

for your information!!!

Watever happends Eric will always be more better than KYLE!!!

I will defend him!!

Hummmpp..,.

Comment me hahahahahah!!

[falloutboydiehard]

i think kyle's version is better,,,but this is funny but still it's good

[yAn0912yan]

OMG. this is suuuch a good version! :D both eric and kyle's version roxx!^^xxxx

[deth101283]

is a nice video

[superyanaa]

i love eric. kyle sings tis better

[janielfanofpbb]

sorry, but,his voice is annoying! i like kyle's version!

[liverpoolroxx]

yea..LOL1!!

[amiesong555]

omg. eric is the best thing thats happened to me.

where can i download this version??

[lejenderi]

Eric is amazing.

[Kylie1354]

I like Kyle's version better.

His singing touched once heart.

[liverpoolroxx]

yea!

[damespencer]

eric is the original singer of this

so what do u mean u like kyle better

cuz i heard him sing catch ur wave n he wasn't thatt good

cuz he can't hit the notes that eric can

but eric could sing songs that kyle sings

so they both are great the way the are no one is better than the other

[polerzer]

If eric sings jenny it will be funny because of his voice So not every songs he can sing

[theclickfive1000]

Me too i like KYLE better

because his voice itz POWERFUL^_^

[telanalynumfansite]

i like kyle better :)

[pacute888]

ahh they both sing it so differently i cant choose who sings it better. i love them both anyway

[cosmicbelt]

THX !!! u're awesome !!! if u can i need help finding the music tho w/ eric singing this song...

[bostonmayo]

It was never on their album. He pretty much just sang Mary Jane, All I Need is You, and By the Way at concerts. Someone might have it though. Good Luck! You're welcome!

[Edgard1203]

I didnt know that eric was the original version of this song

[mrsdanny123]

god this makes me cry, eric was amazing, hes missed muchly hearing this song makes me go all tingly, his voice, words just cant descrivbe him singing this song

[theclickfiversohot]

yeah..

[fatin2391]

i cried watching this video. so sad that eric left. kyle rocks anyways.

[kohtingting]

because eric's voice is SO much higher pitch than kyle's.

KYLE totally rock!!!!!!!!

[hafferden]

gee, i think that kyle sings it much much better. maybe eric's voice just doesn't suit this song.

[laughoutdamnloud]

yeah i agree. Eric's about spunk & all. Kyle is the weep-aound-the-house-because-m­y-girl-left-me kinda person.

[fritziemonilla]

good adjective!! lol

[laughoutdamnloud]

nothing else can describe Kyle.

[nurfbar]

thanks for posting, this is the most clear version of eric's maryjane , so far.

[Jusor1234]

Greatest Song :)