Added: 3 years ago
From: felixdaman18
Views: 1,026
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (80)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • it truly doesn't matter anymore both games are good you play it hit notes and have a good time truth be told i like the difficultly guitar hero has to offer make me better player while I like rock band b/c of the huge dlc list. so it doesn't matter if you make a video or not. people will still be fans to the games a lot of people play and if you have an opinion then people will always beg to differ.

  • ok, just because it's more popular doesn't mean it's better. That's like saying Chop Suey is SOAD's best song because it's their most popular, no, it all comes down to your own opinion, not a couple of other people you don't know

  • rockband is a great game, but you cannot say that its better only because its more popular.

    even tho, rockband is better, but there are other ways to prove it, like features, gamplay, instrument, the Awesome feeling of being in a band.

    yeah, rb is best, but not because its popular.

  • both games are creative, HOWEVER, RB2 offers more songs and GHWT (i hve the game, and played RB2 at friends house a lot) does not offer much songs compared to RB2. The DLC for RB2 is way more often than in GHWT. And RB2 just is a better party game.

    I own GHWT, but not RB2. I wish I had RB2, and planning on getting LEGO RB for ps3 durin the Holidays :)

  • I've never had any problem with rock band. I've had a thousand and one problem with ghwt. I use the same drums for both. Also, ghwt's graphics, and music selection, (on disc and dlc) are crap. Also, Peace Sells! Megadeth ftw!

  • forgot the other gh's...i agree if you mean just ghwt...if not, i dont agree...and on another note...rockband is better vocals and drums, guitar hero is better for guitar

  • why dont you try this:

    PLAY these games and then see who truely is the better game in YOUR opinion, not OTHERS opinions.

    I honestly think both games are just as good...

  • I played both games you idiot.

  • each game has its pros and cons, ghwt has (BY FAR) the best guitar gameplay, while rock band 2 has (hands down) the best druming, especially with the ions. But i say rockband takes it cuz it has a way better setlist

  • I like both , Rockband 60% , Guitar hero 40% , in my opinion

  • you idiot they are both good. ghwt for music and rock star creating and rb2 for graphics.

  • lol I love Donkey konga lol the original drum gamelolololllolololololol just kidding.

  • you proved that you could use other peoples OPINIONS, i repeat OPINIONS, to back up your own OPINION, and you also proved you have way too much time on your hands, congratulations, YOU LOSE YOUR DIGNITY :D

  • estemenshorn is a cock licking dip shit both of them are awsome

  • god dam some people just have no live especally the person who made this because instead of playing real instruments like me(drums)you argue about 2 awsome family games ill admit ghwt drums do have some problems i had to take it back once but rb2 i had to take it back 3 times

  • make a comparison to RB2 and GH:Metallica,and see....

  • The ONLY problem I have with RB2 is the ridiculous timing window for strumming. If it fixed that then I wouldn't have a preference.

    I honestly do not understand the big battle between these two games. They are both great, and are both BASICALLY the same game. People need to get over it. Seriously.

  • fucking fanboys, get over it. both games are the fucking same. only difference: songs. thats it. god, why the fucking argument

  • I have both games and love the set lists to both. I'm old and like to sing after a few beers with friends or online, so I prefer RB2 because the singer can't talk online in GHWT. It seems to me that GHWT is for the 20 and under club that are heavily into the hard guitar songs while RB2 is more of an older crowd more interested in having fun with the game. They are both worth buying.

  • GHWT ≤ RB2

    RB2 ≫ GHWT

    (ghwt is not greater than rb2. rb2 is much greater than ghwt.)

  • why do people care so much like comeon their both great games their both good they both have guitars drums vocals they like the same thing just different game play they just have different songs and amount of them so rb2 has more songs  but who cares both great games i give them both 10/10

  • i like both games but i just have to say that the rb2 guitar sucks anus so i jus use a gh3 guitar, and also i find rb notes harder to hit -.- idk why. but i still think both games r awsum!

  • rb2 better guitar ghwt better drums

    ghwt better game play

    rb2 better graphics both great games rb2 9/10 ghwt 9/10

  • Why is this such a big argument?! THERE BOTH THE SAME FUCKING GAME! Get over it! I happen to like both EQUALLY.

  • it's also true that RB2 won every single "best music/rhythm game" award (ex. spike tv video game awards, gamespot, etc.)

  • Man who cares about the reviews, PLAY THE GAME URESELF!!!!

    I have GHWT and its awesome...i cant say if its better thn RB2 because it havent played it. Thats how it goes. No game is better than another, both are going to sell hundreds of copies...

    If youve played both dont go... LOL (game) is the better game by milesz...

  • I've played them both. There both good, but it is just a matter of opinion. Of course its also a matter of opinion when you say the Detroit Lions are the best team in the NFL. And I think we know thats Definitely not true. RB2 has a better set list though. The only way I can See GHWT having a better set list is to those people who like singing strange foreign songs.

  • i'm not saying rock band sucks..but i just like gh better but u can't tell us what game is better it's the opinion of us

  • i have all but 1 question for you !!...have u read the reasons of the ppl who said rock band was better??? because i've been on a couple websites and a lot of ppl had pretty stupid reasons or reasons that weren't vaild EX:

  • guitarhero had higher ratings harmonix which means neversoft should leave the music games to actual MUSICIANS and stict to tony hawk games which also sucks balls

  • I dont like rock band 2 because there arent that many new features.

  • I think it doesnt have any new features because it started out with all the right features.

  • yeh but because of that its basicly the same game with different songs.

    But thats just my opinion.

  • i chose world tour over RB 2 because I can't play rock band worth a crap ( i think it's because I'm not use to the rectangles coming down the highway)

  • same

  • they are both good, but guitar hero gets old kinda fast

  • Guitar Hero is the original

  • Drumania by konami is the original. GH was drumania with a guitar.

  • the makers of guitar hero 1 2 and rock the 80's (Harmonix) Sold Guitar hero to activision, and Harmonix teamed up with MTV games to make rock band

  • on gamer rankings

    RB2 92% GHWT 85.4%

    on gamestats

    RB2 9.3 GHWT 9.4

    Metacritic

    RB2 92 GHWT 85

    Rockband2 has the edge with these ratings but it duznt mean people won't have fun playing it, everybdy played the first rockband before ghwt even came out, and people dont like change even if its for the better... so its obvious people wont like GHWT as much. if GHWT came out before rock band games then ppl wud like GHWT much more so IMO its pretty even.

  • IGN

    Rock Band 2 9.0

    GHWT: 7.9

    for wii

    Rock Band 2 9.0

    GHWT 8.8

  • favorite*

  • say something that makes rb2 better than ghwt :P

    rb2 sucks

  • rb2 has better fretting(note charts)

    rb2 already has over 500 songs

    etc.

  • I'll say it again;

    - can you create your own songs in RB2? NO!

    - can you create your own characters, guitars and drums in RB2? NO!!

    - Is there any REAL characters like Jimi Hendrix or Ozzy Osbourne(GHWT) in RB2?

    NO!!!!

  • -creating songs in ghwt sucks, the sound quality of it is just horrible and they delete any songs that have copyrights, the songs that are made are usually just hard to play and sound like crap

    -You can create characters and you can buy and guitars drums and pick the colors, etc.

    -playing as a special character aint that cool

    because:1.You ain't watching the characters, your watching your notes 2.I wouldn't want to play as a dead guy(Jimi)3.I wouldn't want to play as a 60 year old(Ozzy)

  • okok, sure, but everything you says that is good about rb2 is not facts, its different what people think is good, and whats not. If you say to me that rb2 is better than ghwt, i wont care about it, I'll just keep play my favorie game and there nothing you can do about it ;P

  • and sorry, i ment AcTiVision. But Neversoft has been a part of it to

  • Also, Neversoft/RedOctane was the first company making a music game such as Guitar Hero

    pwned! :P

  • RedOctane made the controllers. Neversoft was making tony hawk games while Harmonix was making gh1 gh2 and gh 80s

    super pwned:P

  • I dont care a shit about that, Im just telling you; rb2 is boring and retarded, ghwt kicks ass

    (your ass :P)

  • dude, this video was made to prove that ghwt isnt as good as rb2

    and i proved it

    you suck

    but i wont block you

    blocking is stupid

  • So pretty much review aggregators are the ultimate source for how good a game is, not personal preference or set list or ANYTHING. My god we live in an era of robots.

  • Ok, so if E.T.(piece of crap game for atari 2600) was rated 1.0, you would say it's good? review aggregators are one of the best ways to find if a game is good since it takes many reviews from professional reviewers and compiles it into one score.

  • Those professional reviewers cannot decide what I think is fun. I dont like rb2, I like the guitar hero games. the fretting, the characters and the guitar hero feeling.

    You can go play your rb2 instead of making videos such as these.

  • No, but I wouldn't automatically say that a game with a rating 1.1 (pretty much difference in rating between GHWT and RB@ on a lot of aggregators is 5-10%) is better than ET because it got 10% higher score.

  • who cares about reviews? i mean, they are helpful, but to realy know if a game is good in your opinion YOU HAVE TO PLAY IT and see if YOU like it yourself

  • Oh there are no more professional game reviewers. Maybe 15 years ago, but now all you get is smartasses who are using mags and websites as a stepladder. I wouldnt give these guys much credit. You would do a better job.

  • What is making RB2 better than GHWT!?!??!! - can you create your own songs in RB2? NO!

     - can you create your own characters, guitars and drums in RB2? NO!! - Is there any REAL characters like Jimi Hendrix or Ozzy Osbourne(GHWT) in RB2?

    NO!!!!

  • gh world tour is still funner and cooler to play!!!!

  • the only thing im dissapointed about for GHWT is that is doesn have DRAGONFORCE =(

    that was just awesome in GH3

    I hope I can download their packs on marketplace!!

  • So you have just basically told the people who like Guitar Hero World Tour more that they are wrong to do so, and that their preference doesn't count.

    Well done, douchebag

  • No, I'm telling the RB2 haters and ghwt fanboys that they were wrong.

  • dony you think people who play GH WT(me)

    like it better cuz it has songs that they like more then the song in RB2??

    so the ratings think RB2 is better.

    but dont you think people playing GHWT wont have time rating is cuz they are busy playing the game??

  • WOW if GH's instruments are better how they get broken, plus RB2 for the Wii will have everything the PS3 and X360 versions have. PLUS GHWT'S SETLIST is very bad and dissapointing plus the DRUMS suck ass RB2 may not have changed but it's still good Aleast RB has Megadeth, Avenged Sevenfold, Foo Fighters, OH and AC FUCKING DC!!!

  • umm who cares? its a video game i personal prefer Guitar hero but thats just because im used to it and i dont like the sqaure notes in RB but who cares just get the one you like more

  • it doesn't matter what anybody says its what you think is the best game

  • i think rb2 is a little better than ghwt, but this video doesn't justify anything. u can't show different reviews as ur proof that one thing is better than the other, it's based on personal preference and u need to play both games to decide which one you like better.

  • its just a matter of opinion, some ppl love ghwt some hate it and others love rb2 and others hate it. personally i havent played rockband 1, 2 or ghwt but i will get ghwt wen it comes out in australia (12th november) and i wont be getting rockband 2 for another year cause rockband 1 just came out here today -.-

  • I have them both and in my opinion Ghwt is a little funner than Rb2. They're both awesome though.

  • the songs peace sells!

  • Rock Band 2 brings nothing new to the table it is the same as Rock Band 1

    GHWT has better songs,better instruments,music studio,ranking system,and character creator.

    You my friend are just a fanboy and you need to learn how good GHWT is.

  • I'm a fanboy? I just proved to you with this video that RB2 is better than GHWT.

  • It doesent matter what the critics think its if it is fun! RB2 has nothing and it didnt change anything but GHWT Has OZZY OSBOURNE (i think thats his name) and you can create your own songs! the drum set even has cymbals so GHWT IS BETTER THAN RB2 WHOO HOO YAY!!!!

  • GHWT's setlist isnt much of an improvement either

    there are insanely hard songs that make you wanna kill yourself

    then there are the really slow and horrible songs that make you wanna gouge your eyes out

    statistacilly rock band is a better game and you sir are just a guitar hero fanboy

    and need to see how good rock band 2 is

  • GHWT didn't really bring anything new, lots of it's songs were on rb1 and 2(dlc also) and ghot. instruments were already on rock band(the ghwt drums have problems), rb1 and 2 have character creator, we already have ranking systems(leaderboards) the guitar touchpad is basically a crappy ripoff of rb's solo buttons, only new thing that ghwt actually bring is the music studio which has crappy samples and no vocals. RB2 gives challenges everyday and has a drum trainer.

  • You haven't proved to me or anyone else that RB2 is better then GHWT,by the way most of rock bands songs were songs from gh3 so GHWT has every right to have afew songs from rock band.

  • only a few of rb's songs are from gh3

  • What's also embarrassing is that GH3 actually looks better than GHWT. GHWT's user interface looks like crap. The purple hammer-on thing doesn't even work well

  • yo momma

  • look I have both and I will say this. rb2 has better songs and dlc. gh:wt has better instruments. plus the music studio is fun to mess around with. Theyre both great games so just play and have fun.

  • The music studio has horrible samples. GHWT doesn't have better instruments, just look at the comment I directed to FengZhaoLan(Too lazy to say it again)

  • Ok, for all you haters out there, this is completely ridiculous. Both RB2 and GHWT are great games. Obviously we know that their is differences in the games. RB2 has more DLC content and GHWT has better built software. Instead of complaining of who is better, just play the games. BTW the reason RB2 has more DLC content its because it is owned by MTV Studios and the why GHWT has better software is because they have a better contract with Sony. Just get over these petty fights.

  • GHWT has crap software, haven't you heard about the problem with the cymbals(You had to to switch the cymbals places because they were not working) the guitar touch thing doesnt even work well(even jameslikecoulter complained about it) RB2's mic works better than GHWT's, GHWT's samples in the music creator are low quality. Better software, eh? NO.

  • felixdaman18. thank you. honestly, i fuckin.. god damnit! so many idiots on the internet, i been owning faggots who think GHWT is better for the past week man. rb2 is so obviously a better game. like i never had a problem with ghwt although i have think i could publish a book about all the things that suck about the game, it was the GH3 boners who started talking about how GHWT is waay better than rb2 fuckin BEFORE the game even came out. guess what, games out, and sucks shit. WE WON,BRO. WE WON

  • RB2 is way better. and go felix xD id add other stuff to go with my oppinion but i dont wana piss to many ppl off

  • thanks for making this vid. I hope it will get a better rating soon, when everyone opens up their eyes and see that GHWT is best on paper, while RB2 delivers the joy.

  • check the wii version of RB and GHWT...

    IGN:

    RB 7.9

    GHWT 8.8

  • That's RB1 for wii

    Idiot. RB2 ain't out for wii yet.

  • GHWT is the FIRST 4-player music(i mean guitar, bass, drums and vocals) game of the Guitar Hero series and RB1 too, NOOB.

  • You're the noob.

    I was saying that RB's score that you were comparing to GHWT's is RB1's score. You can't compare RB1 to GHWT since it has a one year difference.

  • ... and that its wii. the wii version was made many months after rock band was already out for xbox and playstion. in wii rock band they took out world tour you just play career and quickplay, there is no online play, no character creator, no dlc. it's basically the game without all the fun stuff. i'm surprised it got nearly an 8.0 that's impressive.

  • Why are you posting the WII review? It came out for ps2 also, does that count? The only reason they got shit reviews is not because of the game, its because of the system. they took so much shit out of the wii version and ps2 that is normally in Xbox360 and the PS3. I'm not trying to bash on the wii but it doesn't have the same power as the 360 or ps3. if they had ghwt on your cellphone i'm sure it would be terrible lol.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more