Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (104)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Been listening to this band (Trent's music) since '89.

  • Can someone tell me what chords fink is playing through the MuRF during the second verse? :D

  • Comment removed

  • Did TR seriously do this for the TWILIGHT soundtracks? despicable

  • @theblueroses0 Trent would never whore one of his great songs out to a movie like that because they share similar names, its "despicable" that you would think that.

  • @theblueroses0 just because the song has twilight in the title doesn't mean its related to the shitty movies you fool

  • @TheSystemUpdate Amen. Fuck that piece of shit!

  • @theblueroses0 It's this Twilight because it talks about the "end of the world" and at the end of the world the only thing that still remains it's the sun, so that's why a twilight if you don't get it thas despicable

  • Hey!!, Alessandro actually gave away the keyboard!, that is fuckin' awesome, I envy the lucky bastard who catched it!

  • In this twilight all the glitter vampires die.

  • This is so amazing. Words cannot describe.

  • I wish I could have been who ever was lucky enough to catch Alessandro's keys.

  • Simply amazing.

  • I saw the LitS show in Portland, and this song was simply amazing .... An unusual coda for a NIN career that spawned some of the most powerful currents in metal and industrial electronics .... Here, Trent brings a soft and chordal idea to end the show, and NIN's final complete tour ....

    He'll be back: You can't keep an artist like this quiet ... He needs to write and play his art....

    He will definitely be back; If not with NIN, then something equally powerful and sublime ...

    THANKS Trent ...

  • @TrajanGregory well said, man

  • The ending of this goes much better following In This Twilight than it fits with Zero-Sum. In This Twilight is more of a closing track, and the way they performed the end of it live is sort of like a musical fade-to-black. It's powerful and it's one of the most moving songs I've ever heard personally.

  • Look, the important this is that he's given us 20 years of great music and this (possible) final performance was not some move titled THIS IS IT! Know what I mean?

  • wish i caught that keyboard........

  • That last riff sent chills down my spine. I'm so inspired to learn the piano now. Thank you Trent Reznor!!!

  • it makes me sad that he says this is it but i have a good feeling like the dude below that in some amount of years he'll miss touring and then have a huge meeting of press to say this, i hope this isnt it i really wanted to see him live

  • this made me cry...

  • nin is the only band that sounds better live than in studio. there isnt any voice doctoring in his songs. my favorite band.

  • I wanna get a guitar like robin's......hope they make a decent stock of lefty models though

  • haha agreed, its a jazzmaster btw

  • beautiful. Amazing work as usual chan

  • watching josh leave is sad, hes the man and a hell of a drummer.

  • *I mean telling ME bye.

  • the ending of this song makes me sad. I got to see NIN twice and after hearing that he is only going to do one more tour...i feel like I will never see them again and when they start waving by and zero-sum at the end I feel that its them telling my bye.

  • this next tour isn't his last, he said in the ghosts album that there would in fact be more ghosts music, and if he goes all instrumental on us, it's ok! seriously, ghosts was real great, now the slip was far better, but give the guy a break you know?

    in the end I think he'll do another cd

  • i agree trent wont be done for good hell just take a break kinda like tool does

  • Trent said that he would continue making music under the name Nine Inch Nails, whether its Heavy, or Instrumental, all of Trent's stuff is great..

    He said this tour (09) would be his last tour, but he is still going to continue making kick ass music..

    Long Live Nine Inch Nails.

  • living in new zealand sucks... i was lucky enough to see nin a few days ago but fuck... i mean FUCK! if they tour again in the future im tapping into the life savings and flying to america

  • man new zealand seems like a wicked place to live. So safe cos no one knows about it really lol. Im in canada btw, but better start saving up cos NIN is touring with Janes addiction, tour dates are yet to be decided but they are going to pretty soon. He says its his last tour (doubt it is but even so)!

  • Life without NIN will be a bit less inspired and meaningful.

  • This makes me cry... I cannot imagine there will not be NIN anymore. Please, Trent, say it ain't so......

  • Wow he got a lil choked up there.. I love this song, n this show..

  • Where the fuck does this theory come from?

  • yes, do tell, that's a load of elephant shit there, how are the jonas brothers better than nine inch nails?

    if anything, nin has millions more fans, and I might add competent ones, where the jonas brothers got a buncha little 15 year olds that don't have any real musical taste and beg daddy into bankrupcy to go and see them onstage only to forget it in a week

  • im 15 and i fucking hate jonas brothers. they should fucking quit music.

  • Are they the ones that, when you hear them, you think "oh GOD. What the fuck are they doing?"

  • Yeah and then you barf and want to hammer nails into your ear drums

  • NIN fans are adults. Jonas Brother fans are little adolescent kids that have no taste.

  • what's a Jonas Brother?

    jk

    I know it's some kind of sauce... lol

  • A disturbed, naive preteen mind brainwashed by Disney Channel surely.

  • lol wtf

  • THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR PUTTING THIS UP! Just like I remembered it.

  • that was by far the best show ever pity I wasn't there

  • BONNAROO!!!!!!

  • My favorite NIN song.

  • What a voice! Amazing....

  • i got to goo the lits when it came to saskatoon it was amazing but he didnt play the encore when he was here thou which sucked cause he would have played this song but guys dont get ur hopes down just yet about trent quiting it says on his website there playin another tour the final tour its gonna be amazing

  • I cried when I saw this. I kind of wished it would have went into Zero Sum. I know Trent isn't done.

  • Sorry, I mean the full version of Zero Sum.

  • robin fink is amazing whats wrong with yo

  • I am crying inside...I sure will miss them.

  • This is the most powerful NIN show ending I ever saw.

  • 3:09 aha

  • Its strange but in the end there's a such a feeling that we wont see NIN again... :'( I hope that wont happen...

  • trent's vocals are amazing in this live version. he hits some notes i've never heard him hit before. great video.

  • wowee! well done! an elegant end with the perfect song. smashing. wish i could get that keyboard!

  • That soulful look as he hits that final note and leaves the stage...breaks my heart every time.

  • epic.

  • wow, Gänsehaut! What a pity Ally and Josh leave NIN :-(

  • That was incredible. Seriously.

    Thanks so much for uploading this, such a brilliant song and such a moment too with Josh Freese leaving and Ally throwing his keyboard into the audience.

    Awesome.

  • He hands it more than he throws it, like "Hey guys, I'm gone this is yours now."

  • Just watched the whole thing.

    Wow!

    It's almost like it was seeing it live. It was really, really sad . . . but really, really, beautiful.

  • I saw this awesome spectacle in July 2008 Mohegan Sun Arena. What beautiful piano keyboard work at the very end.. Trent Reznor is the ultimate musician!

  • i Was There! but This Video Definitly Captures What I Couldnt ! Amazing!

  • words cannot describe this.. it's beyond beautiful

  • that was beautiful. thank you for posting your videos! i'm really glad you were able to make it to Vegas for this amazing show. from where I was sitting...i could basically see nothing of their faces so this is great.

  • This is the reason we need a DVD. Great, great tour.

  • Thank you very much for putting your videos here.

    Cheers!

  • Absolutely beautiful bro.

  • more melancholy and melodic than the original. i prefer.

  • I pretty much teared up the first time I saw Ally throw his keyboard into the audience. Fuck, I regret that I have but one account with which to 5-star and Favourite this video.

  • Thank you, thank you, thank you! Such an awesome end to such an awesome tour, and I really appreciate your work on this. Thank you for bringing it to us, too!

  • Possibly the best video on youtube

  • Stunning!

    great job & thanks for uploading!

    wow

  • wow, just wow. and so sad.

    is it just me, or does ally look like he can't wait to leave the stage/band at 4:55? his arms move like "yay, finally" o.O

  • WOW!!! This tour was so amazing.. and your vids are wonderful. you do capture what ever it is in your vids but they are like really being there unlike lots of vids i have seen or mine.. this tour was so special.. i am so glad to have been able to some of the shows on this tour.......

  • Wow yours is the third version of this I have watched and it was so clear and amazing thank you!!!

    I just sob whenever I think about it. I gotta stop watching this song LOL

  • Glad this came out so well. Too bad about the douchebag with the fro a couple rows ahead of us, but it looks awesome anyway.

  • Great video!

  • Your footage is just amazing. I keep saying that but I mean, really. The shock of how good it is never seems to go away. A HUGE thanks to capturing this and I am so looking forward to this finished DVD.

  • Wow, I've just seen this for the very first time and I'm simply just ... stunned.

    What a way to end a show!

  • I'm pretty much speechless.

    Even though it's the same exact outro... it gets more beautiful every time.

  • thanks for this!

  • super awesome!

  • I loved how the lits concerts end with Trent being the last one on stage with his keyboard, just like how nin started - just Trent and his keyboard.

  • I shed a few tears at this one >.>

  • Gorgeous. Thanks so much for the upload.

  • WOW... Perfect quality, those of you who were there are so lucky. It's so sad to be witnessing the end of an era.

  • Man, the quality of this vid is nuts.

  • Beautiful quality video. Thank you so much for the upload, and I hope this goes on the DVD!

  • I cried.

    I love Robin's facial expressions - it looks like he was trying not to cry also.

    And Trent's face at 5:20 is so peaceful...

  • Comment removed

  • Epic.

    Can't believe someone got Ally's keyboard he used in his final NIN show... lucky bastard.

  • Keep up the AWESOME work! I'm glad you can be part of the ETS project.

    I was wondering if you were going to post a video for ITT ;)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more