I think that voice is so normal, when in your "diet" mix cigarettes, alcohol and you are a rockstar, this shits happens... whatever i love the same liam's voice 1994- ACTUALLY♥
Liam maybe a dick sometimes, so fucking what if he doesnt have the voice of Susan Boyle, he's a god. He is the complete rock and roll star, in the complete rock and roll band.
I think that the problem of LG is not the cigarretes. I'm sure that NG smoke the same, like Keith Richards or other musician. The problem of LG is he doesn't know how to sing. He sings with the throat, and it's no good, but... he's the best singer of the world singing with the throat. He doesn't sing, he shout. This is one of the marks of Oasis. I'm not a real fan now (I was a fan when I was a teenager), and I can see that LG didn't sing ok in this track, but I like so much the performance.
Their voices arent important in Oasis, the tunes are just so epic and they are so coool and rock n roll it doesnt matter, everyone sings along and loves it anyway gtfo haters
i love Oasis, and Noel is my favourite, he is having to cover for Liam big style here, what the hell was up with him ? listen to champagne supernova off the album he souds so young and his voice is pretty awesome and then here he's just completely out of tune and well... awful. call me all you want but man Liam ruined this
liam's voice is still awsome.You cant expect live to be as same as the cd's.Its not meant to be.Man bands like oasis,u2 metallica even after getting 50 60 yrs old they never lose their touch.PURE AWSOMNESS
dont understand why people complain about liams' voice, yeah it's different from the 90's but what do you expect? We should be grateful that atleast somebody is still making great fucking music.
@nikodimitri07 noel smokes way more than liam,it s just a personal thing,i think liam hasn t a strong body like noel or other people do.just think about stevn tyler or dave grohl,they re both chain smokers but they ve never lost their voice...they r just made to resist better than liam
@chsirish5594 not really the cigaretts...i mean that and alcohol does have something to do with it but if thats the case, why does noel just get better as he gets older? i think its the way liam sings, up stretched neck
@chsirish5594 its not the cigarettes, it was his style of singing tracking all the way back to 95 that wore away at his vocal chord coz he started singing from his throat rather than from his chest.
@chsirish5594 No. Its Noel wanting the amps so fucking loads so Liam has to shout instead of sing, which has strained his voice. I accept your apology on behalf of Liam. xoxox
Comment removed
palulisl 2 weeks ago
I am upside down they fall to the top
Kclassable 1 month ago
What a voice!!! ...NOEL
fabiarq13 2 months ago 9
apparently the singing police have shown up to watch all these videos. So nice of them to tell us who is singing out of tune and how awful they sound
dr05guitar 4 months ago
cigarettes and alcohol=bad voice
rainpanos 5 months ago 3
sharrock is loving it!
ozyozkaya 6 months ago
Is not Oasis the greatest band since the Stones, Beatles, Doors, Nirvana, Aerosmith, Led Zepplin and Guns n' Roses?
ADDIDASSSSSSSSSSSSSS 6 months ago 4
@ADDIDASSSSSSSSSSSSSS yes they were!
TheVibeBandTV 6 months ago
@ADDIDASSSSSSSSSSSSSS Good lord, you have good taste.
fatlard5776 6 months ago
thumbs up if you agree with me when i say noel should have taken over lead vocals on oasis song from 2004 onward 's (excluding Liams songs)
NAFIANNA10 7 months ago
Sharrok is amazing!
Throw at 4:05
Catch at 4:10
MrJackous 7 months ago 7
Liam is in tune, but he's struggling really hard to hit the notes.
akara86 8 months ago
@akara86 i think he just dont give a shit
candythebee 2 months ago
FUCKERS Liams not out of tune.. he is in tune but he cant sing . its different to be tuned and to know how to sing. even noel said it...
JohnLlovera 8 months ago
Liam's always out of tune.
78swopester 8 months ago
I actually like it
DannyMadFerIt 9 months ago
Is it me or Noel is trying to cover Liam's voice by singing louder during the chorus...?
reaperDAVEE316 9 months ago
@reaperDAVEE316 Just you, that's the way Noel sings the chorus.
Martingeeo 8 months ago
I think that voice is so normal, when in your "diet" mix cigarettes, alcohol and you are a rockstar, this shits happens... whatever i love the same liam's voice 1994- ACTUALLY♥
StarshipKonk 10 months ago 3
Liam maybe a dick sometimes, so fucking what if he doesnt have the voice of Susan Boyle, he's a god. He is the complete rock and roll star, in the complete rock and roll band.
LiveForever912 10 months ago 14
Noeeeeeeeel :)
fabiarq13 10 months ago
Noeeel why did u left? :(
DannyMadFerIt 11 months ago
che bello Noel:)
giak2016 11 months ago
Pure Oasis: rhtym, shout, and play it loud.
RubenCamachoZ 1 year ago
I think that the problem of LG is not the cigarretes. I'm sure that NG smoke the same, like Keith Richards or other musician. The problem of LG is he doesn't know how to sing. He sings with the throat, and it's no good, but... he's the best singer of the world singing with the throat. He doesn't sing, he shout. This is one of the marks of Oasis. I'm not a real fan now (I was a fan when I was a teenager), and I can see that LG didn't sing ok in this track, but I like so much the performance.
RubenCamachoZ 1 year ago
@RubenCamachoZ yes but he was way better in the 90's
candythebee 2 months ago
It sounds good to me, what do you expect? It's a rock and roll band not a fucking Pavarotti concert...
Taladroxx89 1 year ago 5
Oh god Liam.......I just don't know what to say about this. Your voice. Not good
LennonPeaceLove92 1 year ago
Their voices arent important in Oasis, the tunes are just so epic and they are so coool and rock n roll it doesnt matter, everyone sings along and loves it anyway gtfo haters
xl2eVoLuTioNz 1 year ago
its good to see liam smile at the end :D
HelterSkelterSOR 1 year ago
dont you just love seconds 0:08 to 0:22
OASIS <3
JaCkKeOgH98 1 year ago
Comment removed
JaCkKeOgH98 1 year ago
critising the singing ability of a rock n roll band ,get the fuck outta here its rock n roll its not supposed to be perfect
Moderatelootz 1 year ago
Noel's voice is even better here than Liam. Liam's voice doesn't blend with Noel when they're together singing live.
KJRA2009 1 year ago 3
liam sounds great here compared to the rest of the tour.
lesassassins 1 year ago
I'd love to grow them sideburns
MartialDriscoll 1 year ago
o dude liam was a great singer the greatest :( but well his fault ! :/
adri1a2n 1 year ago 2
i love Oasis, and Noel is my favourite, he is having to cover for Liam big style here, what the hell was up with him ? listen to champagne supernova off the album he souds so young and his voice is pretty awesome and then here he's just completely out of tune and well... awful. call me all you want but man Liam ruined this
isaacb1996 1 year ago
Nice one Chris Sharrock :) absolutely nailed that !
jacklovesmanutd 1 year ago 2
That one person who disliked this. Fuck you.
Lawriee93 1 year ago 4
Liam sounds fucking fantastic.
dragonnelite 1 year ago
whats the loop at the start before the song kicks in?
anyone know were its from?
Durriboy 1 year ago
@Durriboy it's saying 'rock n fucking roll baby'
penarthliam 1 year ago
Its true, when you're there, the bugger sounds alot different.
GoCubs3425 1 year ago 3
i agree noel had to come in and help him with de chorus
Daroflynnie 1 year ago
@Daroflynnie he always did on this song
125possom 1 year ago
Comment removed
ADREYCOMP 1 year ago
great
leomedvet69 1 year ago
liam's voice is still awsome.You cant expect live to be as same as the cd's.Its not meant to be.Man bands like oasis,u2 metallica even after getting 50 60 yrs old they never lose their touch.PURE AWSOMNESS
vsstrawberry 1 year ago
those complaining about liams voice, need to know, this isnt britney spears lip syncin,
its rock and roll and the mistakes, the attitude the out of key singing is all part of the music,
u want real musicians playing songs or robots who dont make mistakes???
i'd rather this,,,
sunj5976 1 year ago 6
Noel carried liam big time!
Gooasis1 1 year ago 5
Liam kill this good song with this voice
nairemaster 1 year ago 3
the tempo given by chris is waayy too fast! It literally killed the singer... Btw Liam is the best rock'n'roll singer of his generation...
Kwstello 1 year ago
I love Liam and i dont think his voice is bad here or has ever been its just would be nice to hear Noel i mean his voice is so beautiful
unclepic1 1 year ago
dont understand why people complain about liams' voice, yeah it's different from the 90's but what do you expect? We should be grateful that atleast somebody is still making great fucking music.
live forever.
OneFootInTheRave93 1 year ago
Ouch Liam is out of tune big time! =(
Zinkpind 1 year ago 40
@Zinkpind Not out of tune at all!! He's still the boss!!
arnyno03 1 year ago
@Zinkpind gotta disagree, he's still got it imo, when you're there he sounds mega!! Always top boy!!!
arnyno03 1 year ago
@Zinkpind He was out of tune whole ig but anyway i luv him
96Dano 1 year ago
@Zinkpind Why don't you try singing for 2 and a half hours
SuperCrazyWizard 5 months ago
liam tiene personalidad es mi idolo
maroon5alan 1 year ago
@maroon5alan awebo, yo traigo el corte tipo the beatles con el toke de oasis
miguellatico 1 year ago
oesis es el mejor de todos los putos grupos
MrLisdi 2 years ago
great gig!
96Dano 2 years ago 4
liam and his fucking cigarettes. love noel !!!!! hope to hear'em again.
nikodimitri07 2 years ago 8
@nikodimitri07 noel smokes way more than liam,it s just a personal thing,i think liam hasn t a strong body like noel or other people do.just think about stevn tyler or dave grohl,they re both chain smokers but they ve never lost their voice...they r just made to resist better than liam
MrPeterGroove 1 year ago
liam can't do the high notes on this one
TheChristopherw1993 2 years ago
Amoo esta cancion... Tenia que ser de Noel.. DON´T BELIVE THE TRUTH Lejos Uno de los mejores discos del mundo
FLORENCIA4569 2 years ago
it's too fast.. live in manchester 2005 was much better...
still luv the song
rapperzondernaam 2 years ago
Hail Hail Oasis
Continuity09 2 years ago
fuckin fuckin fuckin great
giankithesoul 2 years ago 6
It's amazing how Noel's vocal range hasn't been shot like Liam's.
Great performance!
KOTRA1307 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
liam ruins the whole song
Liamgallager96 2 years ago
i agree.. :/
matiasc55 2 years ago
ooh yeeeaah!
Liamforever83 2 years ago
heyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy lyla
kooldude4389 2 years ago
People who say he cant sing anymore are insane! :)
Azza593 2 years ago 4
Then u must be tone deaf. I freakin love Oasis but it's all Liam's fault he can't sing anymore. All those cigarettes
chsirish5594 2 years ago 39
its nowt to do with fags, noel smoked his fair share so did Macca and he can still sing
tp199fan 2 years ago
needs to get that hairball out his throat
grannysgod 2 years ago
@chsirish5594 not really the cigaretts...i mean that and alcohol does have something to do with it but if thats the case, why does noel just get better as he gets older? i think its the way liam sings, up stretched neck
JudLufc 1 year ago
@chsirish5594 its not the cigarettes, it was his style of singing tracking all the way back to 95 that wore away at his vocal chord coz he started singing from his throat rather than from his chest.
tozza7157 1 year ago
@chsirish5594 anymore? now he fuckin can! he has better voice in Beady Eye than ever in Oasis!
DannyMadFerIt 1 year ago 3
@chsirish5594 Do you still think that Liam can't sing anymore?!?!??!?!
liamourkidgallagher 10 months ago
@chsirish5594 No. Its Noel wanting the amps so fucking loads so Liam has to shout instead of sing, which has strained his voice. I accept your apology on behalf of Liam. xoxox
N1ck64 5 months ago 2
Respond to this video... *loud o.O
N1ck64 5 months ago
@chsirish5594 You're kidding right? He sounds Great here!
Sgtpepper212 5 months ago 4
@Sgtpepper212 i'm with you
ges335ch 4 months ago
@Sgtpepper212 brain cancer?
GrayfoXaX 4 months ago
@GrayfoXaX Brain cancer? Your clever.
Sgtpepper212 4 months ago
@Sgtpepper212 Yeah! His voice is great here! Especially during "Morning Glory" ;)
DannyMadFerIt 3 months ago
His voice was a trillion times better this year! XD I saw them last month they UN-FUCKING-BELIEVABLE!!
chrissme92 2 years ago 6
Other than Manchester,City Of Manc Stadium in 2005,,THIS has got to be THE finest version of Lyla i've had the pleasure of seeing and hearing!
alty567 2 years ago
watch the live at BBC one in 2005 fucking awesome version
md47bot 2 years ago 2