I first heard this song in the late 80's while living in California, far from home. Being terribly homesick this song prompted me to return to my roots in Indiana and to reconcile differences with my ailing father whom I buried a soon after returning. Needless to say, this song means much to me. Thank you Moloney O'Connell & Keane.
This is the sadest song ever written. Its not just about being irish or english or british (whatever) or any of that. Its about the dissolution of the family in the modern economic system. families are torn apart even in america because of the system of things; imho of course. Anyway, I cant imagine anybody with an inkling of human feeling not being moved by this song. the 4 dislikes must be cold hearted republican capitalist pigs.
This song is beyond a song... it's a story about the love of a father for his son, it is about emigration, it is about being poor... it is life itself... it is history and actual as well....
I grew up 10 miles down the road from Kilkelly in Charlestown... and believe me the place is still as miserable and depressing as the song... I won't expect any retaliatory remarks as I don't expect they have the Interweb in Kikelly yet... Sad song though!
@ModernOmen The answer is that no other culture is able to pass down their history in as beautiful or as evocative a way as we are. Whereas some build statues and monuments to celebrate their history, the Irish are renowned for storytelling and their ability to pass on history through the spoken word. If you think that this sounds like whining you should take some time to research why as the history of the irish is an extremely sad and hard one. This is a beautiful song. Éirinn go brách
Hi modern, I guess pain to some sounds like "whinning" to others. Being forced to leave home because of economic concerns is never easy especially when the reason may be the insensitivity of an English government that could have cared less at the time. The old saying, the English never remember, the Irish never forget applies here.
@dratjp many english have had to move elsewhere to because of economic concerns to, its not something that just applies to the irish, even after independence and today even, many irish come to england searching for work ,who do you blame for that
@ModernOmen "The great Gaels of Ireland/Are the men that god made mad/For all their wars were merry/And all their songs were sad' Actually, the Irish write the best songs, and they're not all sad, but sad songs are good too........... poor Modern, got no soul.........
@ModernOmen The answer is that no other culture is able to pass down their history in as beautiful or as evocative a way as we are. Whereas some build statues and monuments to celebrate their history, the Irish are renowned for storytelling and their ability to pass on history through the spoken word. If you think that this sounds like whining you should take some time to research why as the history of the irish is an extremely sad and hard one. This is a beautiful song. Éirinn go brách
this vid tells so many stories. as a nation us irish have suffered our fair share of woe's, to think so many fled our land because of famine and oppression only to be met by discrimination, hatred and bigotry in far off lands. "we are the irish" god bless.................. excellent upload, many thanks.
@coolcork As an American Born Irishman who has deep roots verified to 1563 I can say with no uncertainty that the Irish are the heart and soul of America. We had to fight to leave the motherland and we had to fight to survive in the new land. There isn't a Brit alive, or dead, that can hold a light to the heart of an Irishman. When the Brits stole all the food and let the Irish starve to death, only half of the population, the Irish responded with "give us your worst". Erin go bragh!
@THE88MICK1 BRO LIKE IT OR NOT YOUR AN AMERICAN LMAOF YOU WILL ALWAYS BE AMERICAN NO MATTER HOW HARD YOU TRY! What does your birth certificate say?? Or your passport. Being too proud of your roots is like being proud your neighborer drives a Lamborghini
@THE88MICK1 BRO LIKE IT OR NOT YOUR AN AMERICAN LMAOF YOU WILL ALWAYS BE AMERICAN NO MATTER HOW HARD YOU TRY! What does your birth certificate say?? Or your passport. Being too proud of your roots is like being proud your neighborer drives a Lamborghini.
i agree. this song is just so powerful. not only for the irish in it, but because all immigrants coming to the new world faced similar sorrows. how the times were different back then...
It's such a sad song describing the reality of so many Irish people during and even decades after the famine. Outstanding song combined with a very impressing selection of pictures.
This is the best performance of this song in my opinion. I've gotten teary eyed to this tune so many times - and I'm not the emotional type! Powerful stuff.
To everybody who likes this song I will recoment a swedish swedish movie called "Utvandrerne" in swedish.. Its a two disc movie about the story of poor swedish farmers who decides to go tho America... the film is fantastic:)
I was actually able to hear the writer of this song (Peter Jones) performing this at the Machinst Union training school in Placid Harbor Maryland. The Jone's brothers are very accomplished artists who have dedicated a lot of their efforts on social and labor issues. It was very touching to see this performed by the person who wrote it.
we listened to it english lesson too. it so sad that the father die before he can see his son again. also i cant really believe , the letters are real.
when my history teacher showed me this song, it inspired me to try hard in all my classes besides his, this song is awsome, and i usually only listen to stuff like Notorious BIG
I remember listning to this song for the first time and when it got to the part when their mother dies, I got like; Omg no! Felt like crying at the end, when he dies=(
One of the most beautiful, moving and touching songs i've ever heard !
i am deeply moved by this piece, no matter who sings it. i cannot help but blubber and weep; the sadness of the father and his longing for his son. i heard this for the first time back shortly after it had been written. the piece i heard was accapella. wow! i turned a young friend of mine on to it last year and he learned it in 24 hours and sang it for his mother on her birthday. what joy to hear it again!!!
all my claddagh care o'appreciation for sharing this endearing video & treasured song... i have eclectic irish ancestry with both of my parents & i grew up hearing stories of the tears of immigration... i proudly carry ireland as my cherished surname, john :):):)
i love this song soo much! my ancestors came from Ireland(County Cork)and my family loves pretty much everything irish. thank you for making this video!
As an Irish-American, I thank you for one of the best overall presentations of this song that I have seen.
Those of you complaining about the accuracy of the images need to get a life - listen to the heart in the song! My ancestors came to the US and Canada during the hunger (there was NO famine, just another British attempt at genocide).
The family of 11 started out for Belfast from Keady, Armaugh. 9 made it to the ship - two died from starvation along the way.
i have the hole song off in 1 day because my clss are doing a play bout the famine in Ireland for scor na bpaisti on sunday. i love history about it because its so full of history.and i love reading the books about it too. to those irish people ot there be proud of where ur from. i know im only 10 but who cares i love my country.
seriously quit arguing about this stupid shit. this song is amazing, and unbelieveably sad. this stuff happened so often back then, should make everyone appreciate their lives now and be taken as a lesson.
As an Irishman I dismay at you fucking intolerant wankers ....... irrespective of nationality let everyone have their say. It is a beautyful song that most Irish will understand. Please don't spoil something that rips my heart out. Thanks.
in all fairness to our german friends germany was governed by an austrian. when it created all of the trouble. and this song isn t about politics its about emmigration and if it can strike a chord with the germans then i say vundarbar
I made this comment about Nazis because you talked about emigrations AFTER WW2. I am aware that Germans, like other Europeans, emigrated to the New World long before the Second World War. I am typing, not stereotyping.
You can't compare Germany to Ireland. Ireland was governed by Britain, and the cause of many of its troubles were the result of this. The Germans created their own troubles and other other country's troubles.
I want to know who John was, because I would tell him he is a terrible person for deserting his family. Family is all that people had back then, and we Irish need to remember the hardships that our elders endured for our future. We need to remember our roots and never forget. The English betrayed all of us. Some might call it GENOCIDE; I do.
One of my favorite songs. I first heard it 20-25 years ago, recorded by a MN duo called Smith & Mayer. Ten years ago I had trouble finding a recording of it...Imaging my surprise to find it on YouTube! THANK YOU. I added it to my Favorites.
I first heard this song in the late 80's while living in California, far from home. Being terribly homesick this song prompted me to return to my roots in Indiana and to reconcile differences with my ailing father whom I buried a soon after returning. Needless to say, this song means much to me. Thank you Moloney O'Connell & Keane.
wistopnow 1 day ago
This is the sadest song ever written. Its not just about being irish or english or british (whatever) or any of that. Its about the dissolution of the family in the modern economic system. families are torn apart even in america because of the system of things; imho of course. Anyway, I cant imagine anybody with an inkling of human feeling not being moved by this song. the 4 dislikes must be cold hearted republican capitalist pigs.
wistopnow 1 day ago
So beautiful song! :D
javiismadani 1 month ago
4 stupid, tone deaf, heartless bastards stopped by here!
Scotty1137 3 months ago 7
Хвала
dratjp 7 months ago
Excuse me, I've got something in my eye...
Bhikshu2 10 months ago
@Bountykilla82 are you retarded or something? He said he is an irishman. learn to read
Strobanov 10 months ago
umetnicko delo!!
janknjazovic 11 months ago 2
@janknjazovic hvala
dratjp 11 months ago
@dratjp ne postoji tuznija pesma... Daje smisao zivotu
marersbs93 7 months ago
Ireland, united and free. Ireland unfree shall never be at peace.
wingzero890 1 year ago 2
This song is beyond a song... it's a story about the love of a father for his son, it is about emigration, it is about being poor... it is life itself... it is history and actual as well....
666Alester 1 year ago
I grew up 10 miles down the road from Kilkelly in Charlestown... and believe me the place is still as miserable and depressing as the song... I won't expect any retaliatory remarks as I don't expect they have the Interweb in Kikelly yet... Sad song though!
almuzza 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ModernOmen The answer is that no other culture is able to pass down their history in as beautiful or as evocative a way as we are. Whereas some build statues and monuments to celebrate their history, the Irish are renowned for storytelling and their ability to pass on history through the spoken word. If you think that this sounds like whining you should take some time to research why as the history of the irish is an extremely sad and hard one. This is a beautiful song. Éirinn go brách
rordogSA 1 year ago
What fukin video
princesseibhlin 1 year ago
great song we watched it in school watching it i found it educational and sad
butch820 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Could someone plz answer me is the Irish national past time whinning or is it just every Irish song I've ever heard lol
ModernOmen 1 year ago
@ModernOmen
Hi modern, I guess pain to some sounds like "whinning" to others. Being forced to leave home because of economic concerns is never easy especially when the reason may be the insensitivity of an English government that could have cared less at the time. The old saying, the English never remember, the Irish never forget applies here.
dratjp 1 year ago 17
@dratjp many english have had to move elsewhere to because of economic concerns to, its not something that just applies to the irish, even after independence and today even, many irish come to england searching for work ,who do you blame for that
TheMightOfTheEnglish 3 weeks ago
@dratjp and ps it was the british government ,not the english,
TheMightOfTheEnglish 3 weeks ago
@ModernOmen Lol?
That's rude and insensitive.
DontFeedTheZombies 1 year ago
@ModernOmen "The great Gaels of Ireland/Are the men that god made mad/For all their wars were merry/And all their songs were sad' Actually, the Irish write the best songs, and they're not all sad, but sad songs are good too........... poor Modern, got no soul.........
adrienrain 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
rordogSA 1 year ago
Comment removed
rordogSA 1 year ago
Comment removed
rordogSA 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ModernOmen The answer is that no other culture is able to pass down their history in as beautiful or as evocative a way as we are. Whereas some build statues and monuments to celebrate their history, the Irish are renowned for storytelling and their ability to pass on history through the spoken word. If you think that this sounds like whining you should take some time to research why as the history of the irish is an extremely sad and hard one. This is a beautiful song. Éirinn go brách
rordogSA 1 year ago
@ModernOmen rascist -_-
Strobanov 10 months ago
this vid tells so many stories. as a nation us irish have suffered our fair share of woe's, to think so many fled our land because of famine and oppression only to be met by discrimination, hatred and bigotry in far off lands. "we are the irish" god bless.................. excellent upload, many thanks.
coolcork 1 year ago 10
@coolcork thanks
dratjp 1 year ago
@coolcork As an American Born Irishman who has deep roots verified to 1563 I can say with no uncertainty that the Irish are the heart and soul of America. We had to fight to leave the motherland and we had to fight to survive in the new land. There isn't a Brit alive, or dead, that can hold a light to the heart of an Irishman. When the Brits stole all the food and let the Irish starve to death, only half of the population, the Irish responded with "give us your worst". Erin go bragh!
THE88MICK1 1 year ago
@THE88MICK1 BRO LIKE IT OR NOT YOUR AN AMERICAN LMAOF YOU WILL ALWAYS BE AMERICAN NO MATTER HOW HARD YOU TRY! What does your birth certificate say?? Or your passport. Being too proud of your roots is like being proud your neighborer drives a Lamborghini
Bountykilla82 11 months ago
@THE88MICK1 BRO LIKE IT OR NOT YOUR AN AMERICAN LMAOF YOU WILL ALWAYS BE AMERICAN NO MATTER HOW HARD YOU TRY! What does your birth certificate say?? Or your passport. Being too proud of your roots is like being proud your neighborer drives a Lamborghini.
Bountykilla82 11 months ago
Beautiful..Touching...Sad, The Reality of life.
vinnyhoags 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I was crying on this song :'(
d0ma1n92 1 year ago
I was crying on this song :'(
d0ma1n92 1 year ago
@d0ma1n92
tdame34x 1 year ago
this song is beautiful
holey396 1 year ago
I love this song.
Thank god for skype and ryanair or this would be my reality.
rabbitwho 1 year ago
@rabbitwho
tdame34x 1 year ago
Sad but good, extremely good, it gives me the creeps
maesecamara 2 years ago 2
i agree. this song is just so powerful. not only for the irish in it, but because all immigrants coming to the new world faced similar sorrows. how the times were different back then...
pommedupin 2 years ago
I cry when I listen to this song. Every. Single. Time.
pdscotia 2 years ago 2
JAYSUS! Song never gets old,beautiful!
grahammacken 2 years ago
tears all over
lsdvine 2 years ago
Go mbeannaí Dia duit
jmjk63 2 years ago
It's such a sad song describing the reality of so many Irish people during and even decades after the famine. Outstanding song combined with a very impressing selection of pictures.
Thank you very much.
StefanLochner 2 years ago
Heart-wrenching...
mike24gr 2 years ago
sad sad song very good one
steventype1 2 years ago
omq
its the sadest song ive ever heard
im crying every tie i hear it
SuperMarius94 2 years ago 2
This is the best performance of this song in my opinion. I've gotten teary eyed to this tune so many times - and I'm not the emotional type! Powerful stuff.
jfeeney73 2 years ago 2
this is the saddest song i have ever heard. have listened to it hundreds of times, still moves me. seriously powerful.
horsemouth53 2 years ago 2
To everybody who likes this song I will recoment a swedish swedish movie called "Utvandrerne" in swedish.. Its a two disc movie about the story of poor swedish farmers who decides to go tho America... the film is fantastic:)
beaf123 2 years ago 5
A great song but very sad words.The video worked well with the song and kept with the theme..Some great old pic.....
Coirpeach 2 years ago
You should add the artist in the info.
In this case: Moloney, O'Connell & Keane - Kilkelly
floozdolt 2 years ago
you are spot on flooz, my bad
dratjp 2 years ago
Comment removed
floozdolt 2 years ago
good song... but i don´t need it in english class tests -.- xD
MBalxain 2 years ago 2
ah swift 3...
good old times, fucking loving that one
bgtmko 2 years ago
ah, you're right...and you have impeccable taste I might add...
dratjp 2 years ago
I was actually able to hear the writer of this song (Peter Jones) performing this at the Machinst Union training school in Placid Harbor Maryland. The Jone's brothers are very accomplished artists who have dedicated a lot of their efforts on social and labor issues. It was very touching to see this performed by the person who wrote it.
exkeager 2 years ago
we listened to it english lesson too. it so sad that the father die before he can see his son again. also i cant really believe , the letters are real.
finally a song with a real sense in it.:)
annahuuh 2 years ago
We listened to it english lesson too. It's just souch a sad but great song. It makes me cry everytime I hear it.
Norpionxx 2 years ago
We listened to it in english lesson too...
When I here it I feel like crying :(
Its very sad and moving and i like it because of this!
Great song!
dieradc 2 years ago
we listened to it in the english lesson.
it´s great.
Omurumo 2 years ago 5
thnx,
it's a moving song.
dratjp 2 years ago
at first i didn´t understand the lyrics because of my bad english =D but now i understand it... it´s sad - i like it
Omurumo 2 years ago
I heard this song when I was a child. It tore me up then as it does now. I cry every time I hear it.
ohiopeach 2 years ago 3
we listened to this in my n. ireland folklore class the other day, i almost cried. This is such a good song.
QueenofNarnia29 2 years ago
when my history teacher showed me this song, it inspired me to try hard in all my classes besides his, this song is awsome, and i usually only listen to stuff like Notorious BIG
cosbyfan1 3 years ago 13
gracias
dratjp 3 years ago
I remember listning to this song for the first time and when it got to the part when their mother dies, I got like; Omg no! Felt like crying at the end, when he dies=(
One of the most beautiful, moving and touching songs i've ever heard !
magnusolav123 3 years ago 9
Mick Moloney sings :)
His my hero!
DUCATIROOLS 3 years ago
Robbie O'Connell is the singer, Mick Moloney accompanies.
jratt2 3 years ago 2
This is one of the most depressing irish songs I've ever heard.
wingzero890 3 years ago 3
very nice song... we sang it in our english lessons :)
beautiful idea to make a song from a family history
OceanReflectsTheSun 3 years ago 2
we did too (:
great song.. we sing it every day.. well in other lessons too xD
Quaellchen 3 years ago 3
touching...
icep12 3 years ago 3
A great song.
Does anyone know the chords to 'The boys from county mayo'?
dubbyajay 3 years ago
i love this song, but this song by robbi O´Connel is a bit better
melanze110 3 years ago
wonderful. Thanks you ever so for the video post.
Tinymoezzy 3 years ago 4
my pleasure. thanx
dratjp 3 years ago
Beautiful
cjthetim 3 years ago 4
the most beautifully sad song i have ever heard and because i am travelling myself it makes think of home everytime i listen to it.Genius!!!!!!!!1
hughodaly 3 years ago 7
does anyone know what the first chord of the song is?
all i know is it's on E
02jstock 3 years ago
it starts with Am twice followed by F 2x G 2x then back to Am
good place to get the chords is to "google" "Kilkelly Guitar Chords"
dratjp 3 years ago
na you can play it on your guitar it definitely starts on E, i just don't know what variant
i saw this in a pub in ireland about a week ago and he did it with a chord shape i've never seen, but using E as the root
02jstock 3 years ago
i am deeply moved by this piece, no matter who sings it. i cannot help but blubber and weep; the sadness of the father and his longing for his son. i heard this for the first time back shortly after it had been written. the piece i heard was accapella. wow! i turned a young friend of mine on to it last year and he learned it in 24 hours and sang it for his mother on her birthday. what joy to hear it again!!!
nosowisewoman 3 years ago 3
im not irish but its a pretty deep story. i can aprecciate it
biscut420 3 years ago 4
if you got a drop of Irish blood in you this song should hit you like a ton of bricks
paratrooper321fa 3 years ago 7
every time i hear this song i cry....it makes me feel sad and depressed.....
i always think about if it would be the same for me if i go away from my family.......i just dont hope so.....
i really like your presentation of the song.....great job
yankumi2 3 years ago
great vid!
Faithiana 3 years ago 3
we heard that song with our english teacher.
a friend of mine and myself sang it all the time during our exchange with belgium.. god, that was fun, although the text is so sad
:DD
dasyoshi 3 years ago
very sad song
xmoorserx 3 years ago
Great job!
Thank you.
chord97 3 years ago
all my claddagh care o'appreciation for sharing this endearing video & treasured song... i have eclectic irish ancestry with both of my parents & i grew up hearing stories of the tears of immigration... i proudly carry ireland as my cherished surname, john :):):)
you'll NEVER walk alone!!! :):):)
IrelandCladdagh 3 years ago 4
many thanx
dratjp 3 years ago
i love this song soo much! my ancestors came from Ireland(County Cork)and my family loves pretty much everything irish. thank you for making this video!
Ec4694 3 years ago 2
As an Irish-American, I thank you for one of the best overall presentations of this song that I have seen.
Those of you complaining about the accuracy of the images need to get a life - listen to the heart in the song! My ancestors came to the US and Canada during the hunger (there was NO famine, just another British attempt at genocide).
The family of 11 started out for Belfast from Keady, Armaugh. 9 made it to the ship - two died from starvation along the way.
The 6 brothers never returned.
foxeye93720 3 years ago 4
hello to the people who listened to this song.
i have the hole song off in 1 day because my clss are doing a play bout the famine in Ireland for scor na bpaisti on sunday. i love history about it because its so full of history.and i love reading the books about it too. to those irish people ot there be proud of where ur from. i know im only 10 but who cares i love my country.
jessiejess3333 3 years ago 3
btw would u mind telling me where u got all of these photos?
SteviesLastTry 3 years ago
seriously quit arguing about this stupid shit. this song is amazing, and unbelieveably sad. this stuff happened so often back then, should make everyone appreciate their lives now and be taken as a lesson.
SteviesLastTry 3 years ago 2
I live in Kilkelly, this is a great song and the video is good but wrong!
The scenery is not from Kilkelly at all.
I don't much like this version either.
yummyburgers 3 years ago
sigh...everyone is a critic
dratjp 3 years ago
Check out the other video, it actually shows the town!
Its a nice tribute but they could have used the real town in the vid! C'mon?!
yummyburgers 3 years ago
As an Irishman I dismay at you fucking intolerant wankers ....... irrespective of nationality let everyone have their say. It is a beautyful song that most Irish will understand. Please don't spoil something that rips my heart out. Thanks.
ironpaddy 3 years ago 2
Great song so touching. Alright with the German thing already
rocfour20 4 years ago
i like that song
we had herad it in the english lesson a few days ago and it's not going out of my mind
our teacher gives us the text and at the end i nearly cried when i hear it yet
a sad beautiful song
very good
thx for downloading it
(sorry for my english i'm german)
NovaSeha 4 years ago
in all fairness to our german friends germany was governed by an austrian. when it created all of the trouble. and this song isn t about politics its about emmigration and if it can strike a chord with the germans then i say vundarbar
brrrrny 4 years ago
this song is GREAT!
ice9222 4 years ago
i am not irish
i am geman but in germany there have been many of these emingrations after ww2 too.
very sad and touching
stalkingopfer111 4 years ago
Where did they go to then? South America? That's where all the Nazi war criminals went.
rumpraisin 4 years ago
Comment removed
WolfArden44 4 years ago
I made this comment about Nazis because you talked about emigrations AFTER WW2. I am aware that Germans, like other Europeans, emigrated to the New World long before the Second World War. I am typing, not stereotyping.
rumpraisin 4 years ago
i am german too and pls don't try to tell me that any germans are nazis! it is not like that and you should know that!
ice9222 4 years ago
Your English is quite good (much better than my German)but maybe you misunderstand me. I never said all Germans are Nazis.
rumpraisin 4 years ago
ok sry if i misunderstood you...
ice9222 4 years ago
You can't compare Germany to Ireland. Ireland was governed by Britain, and the cause of many of its troubles were the result of this. The Germans created their own troubles and other other country's troubles.
rumpraisin 4 years ago
I want to know who John was, because I would tell him he is a terrible person for deserting his family. Family is all that people had back then, and we Irish need to remember the hardships that our elders endured for our future. We need to remember our roots and never forget. The English betrayed all of us. Some might call it GENOCIDE; I do.
ddhmi88 4 years ago
a) You're American, not Irish.
b) Who the hell are you to judge him.
c) The English never did anything to you.
AKAlex47 4 years ago
this is a beautiful song - i love it
emeraldrocks71 4 years ago 2
I have loved this song for years. Thanks so much for making this very touching video to it.
silvertonguedbard 4 years ago 2
The is singer is Robbie O'Connell. I think he sings the definitive version of this song.
jratt2 4 years ago
very moving
den22thecoast2 4 years ago 4
Comment removed
WolfArden44 4 years ago 2
Have you got an ass of a face?
rumpraisin 4 years ago
Very touching it sure got me crying. I can
relate to the years apart from family.
cinsere22 4 years ago 3
Very touching.
Luftwaffels 4 years ago 2
Comment removed
WolfArden44 4 years ago 2
I love this song!
Aerianh 4 years ago 2
One of my favorite songs. I first heard it 20-25 years ago, recorded by a MN duo called Smith & Mayer. Ten years ago I had trouble finding a recording of it...Imaging my surprise to find it on YouTube! THANK YOU. I added it to my Favorites.
NewBoi1980 4 years ago 2
oh i love this song!!
Ec4694 4 years ago
well done ! a top tune;like the montage.
clarao1 4 years ago
nice!!!
aaronkelley 4 years ago
Touching song and great pictures. Very nice job!
loitzi81 4 years ago
so do i
FoLKiEeEe 4 years ago
very nice, I love this song
jgibbings 4 years ago