Should abortion be illegal?

[sjrodovalho]

abortion should be a crime,punished by law,and women that undergo abortion should be esterlised,no more children no more abortion.........it to kill what is human and alive a murder so be it abortion.

[HowardSternn]

@agent0sephiroth I lived in Mex for 8yrs and there are a boatload of Drugs in Mex, there is crime and beheadings every day even though Drugs are illegal. In Mex a Pro-Life Catholic country there are over 500,000 Abortions a year i knew at least 10 young woman who had abortions just 5 blocks from where i used to live. Prohibition never works we have tried it with Alcohol-Drugs Etc. In Argentina another Pro-Life Catholic country there are over 600,000 a year in Brazil there are over a Million.

[WinstonSmith6079]

Yeah, I think they should be tried and punished by the law just like any other murderer, God or no god--"God"'s got nothing to do with it. But too bad you didn't ask me, or then you'd have to stack your cards a little more creatively and a little better than that! LOL

If child-molesters get the big punishment (or should) for such heinousness, then those that kill babies should get that much more, DUH!

[NinjaBunnyPro]

@Femmemoche those conditions u listed tend 2 be common in pregnancy. no, u may not develop every single condition under the sun; u may not even have many problems. true, it may be up 2 the woman carrying the baby, but still, developing things like depression, preeclampsia, etc. r sometimes stuff tht comes with the package. but the thing about getting said conditions & others is tht they eventually/usually go away aftr the baby is born. as ive said, im against, but wont force my beliefs

[NinjaBunnyPro]

im against it, but im not gonna beat the crap out of someone if they want 2 get an abortion. personally, i wouldnt do it. as for others, its their choice. i dont rlly think abortion should be a gov't matter 2 decide on. thats just me.

[Thatsamistery]

Yes I say they should go to jail. Murder is killing, and abortion is killing. They should go to jail AND pay a fine. Of get their tubes tide,.

[sonic10158]

@Femmemoche Slavery is someone being another person's personal property, this has NOTHING to do with anti-abortion. and Abortion affects more than the mother's body, it kills the baby's as well

[sonic10158]

Wow! Columbus MS is my hometown! didn't think I'd see it on Youtube, it's a pretty small place. Ok back to topic, I am against abortion. If you want your child aborted, then put them up for adoption instead. as for if they do it illegally, then they should be punished as if they killed

[Sueezee1]

@sonic10158 says: put them up for adoption instead.

~~~~~~ You mean stop abortion & put a possible one MILLION kids up for adoption each yr?? 80 MILLION in your god damned lifetime?/ Are you insane?

[WinstonSmith6079]

@Sueezee1 Dumb women need to stop being baby-dispensing machines. How about a little personal responsibility, eh? But I guess you won't know much about such a "foreign" concept as RESPONSIBILTY, I'm quite sure.

But regardless of about anything that morons do, it doesn't justify murder. Hey, when you abort YOURSELF, then it will be apparent that you genuinely believe the shit you preach instead of being a psychotic hypocrite. Charity begins at home, ya know.

[Sueezee1]

@WinstonSmith6079 says: Dumb women need to stop being baby-dispensing machines. How about a little personal responsibility, eh

~~~~~~~~~ Youre soooooo right.... thats why there is abortion...for the "dumb" women, and abortion is being responsible. Having unwanted kids isnt!

[Sueezee1]

@WinstonSmith6079 says" t doesn't justify murder.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Oh come on sweetheart, just because pro choice took all the truths to make abortion legal dosent maen you have to lie, does it? Now, admit aboriton isnt murder, thats why there arent 50 million women in prison for the punishable crime, right? Admit it, liar! LOL

[Sueezee1]

@WinstonSmith6079 says: Hey, when you abort YOURSELF,

~~~~~~~~~~~~~ hahahahahah, OMG..there it IS!! The deep, intellectual comment of a probirther... No wonder you nitwits can get nowhere in your fight..Keep up the good work...prochoice thanks for you giving them nothing to fear..LMFAO~~~

[Sueezee1]

@WinstonSmith6079 says: Hey, when you abort YOURSELF,

~~~~~~~~~ With that comment you have proven youre not smart enough or old enough to debate me...BYE!!

[WinstonSmith6079]

@Sueezee1 You're gonna spam me with no less than four replies and then say "bye"? You're an idiot. I think your mother should have "thought" like you, then you wouldn't have given me four replies to my one post. In fact you wouldn't be around at all, and maybe that wouldn't be a bad thing.

"Getting nowhere"? LOL I think you've not been paying attention to the current trends. But whatwith your ADD, I don't think you pay attention to much of anything.

It convienient to murder someone ELSE, eh.

[sjrodovalho]

IT SHOULD BE ILLEGAL AND THE PUNISHMENT IS TO BE STERILISED. NO MORE CHILDREN NO MORE ABORTION

[sonic10158]

@sjrodovalho I remember seeing something on the news where someone got mad because they were sterile after an abortion lol

[IamYou86]

@sjrodovalho Hey! You would fit right in in China! They do that there, you know. They will forcibly kidnap women who have had more than one child and if they can't pay for it then they are taken to a hospital and force fed the abortion pill then forcibly put under and the baby is aborted. Go to china if that is how you feel! You won't find anybody who will argue with you in the slightest.

[NLCA1987]

What is wrong with those protesters? Don't they have the guts to say, "Women who have abortions should have the death penalty."?

[EscapeTheFate101975]

people who are pro choice and who are all "its the womans body" dont give women a choice they only have abortion to turn to but the smarter and better people like me who are pro life actually give choices keeping the baby adoption all that stuff. people who have abortiopns are selfish. i thik the law is so screwd up if i was 2 days pregnant and got murderd the killer would be charged with 2 lives yet a mother can walk in and kill her baby this world i so f***ed up

[IamYou86]

@EscapeTheFate101975 First thing's first....PUNCTUATION!! You have made your comment almost impossible to read. I think what you are saying is that abortion should be illegal. Right? What about the thousands of children that will die tonight and tomorrow night and the next without stopping from starvation? Is it better to let a child live and experience the agony and hopelessness and terror of this world AND THEN die? You have failed to think outside of your tiny area of the world.

[Sueezee1]

@EscapeTheFate101975 says:if i was 2 days pregnant and got murderd the killer would be charged with 2 lives

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ That ONLY because the womans right to HER fetuses fate was taken from her. We assume the woman is going to give birth to her child unless SHE decides differently. Its no one else decision.The murder charge is there for the fetus who COULD have been born, but now cant. Bush jr was the one who deicded to call it murder.. so, consider the ignorant source.

[FallenSparrow]

I know it's against the law. I ask you, what has the law ever done for this place?

[EPR89]

Dear God, please make it rain brain, because you obviously made a mistake when assigning it to them.

[AmboGuy]

Fucking bible bashers. Why don't threy keep thier opinions to themselves - arseholes.

[2010revolutionusa]

Hey to whoever posted this video.... If Abortion is Illegal, then the clinics would be shut down and NO ONE could ABORT... Hello, think with your brain. The clinics would not get the money to exist and would close... then lots more precious babies would be born and adoption clinics would be VERY VERY happy...so would the infertile parents trying to have kids but can't... WAKE UP... Illegal means it wouldn't be allowed or no possibility of it happening EVER.

[le0jay]

@2010revolutionusa You're a dumbass. Making something illegal doesn't make it not happen - drugs, murder and theft are all illegal but still happen. Making abortion illegal would just create illegal clinics and practices, leaving desperate women open to exploitation and unsafe practice. Illegal means 'against the law', it does NOT mean "no possibility of it happening EVER".

[dustygirl122]

@HowardSternn Do you think you could give me a site or url for this claim? Its a really good argument and I thought it would be interesting to read more on. Do you know where the article or statistics or whatever are? Thanks

[HowardSternn]

@dustygirl122 I once lived in MEX a Pro-Life catholic country for 8yrs and i can tell you that there are over 500,000 abortions a year those are not my numbers those are the GOV numbers and i knew a boatload of woman that had them as well. Argentina another Pro-Life catholic country with only 40Million people they also have over 500,000 abortions a year. Brazil another Pro-Life catholic country they have over 1Million a year.

[HowardSternn]

@dustygirl122 There is also less crime in countries where Drugs are legal than in countries where it's illegal like Venezuela, Colombia, Peru, central America and i won't even mention MEX where i once lived because i knew a boatload of Dealers as well and politicians are always caught in bed with them as well. Less Abortions where it's legal than where it's illegal. Less crime where Drugs are legal than where it's illegal.

[sonic10158]

@HowardSternn probably because in those countries they don't count druggies as part of the criminal list.

[dustygirl122]

"Well if it's illegal doctors ought not be able to do it." Am I the only one who cringed at this statement? Great, so when its illegal the doctors won't do it, instead some discount crack dealer with a coat hanger will do it. They'll punish the women by killing or maiming them I guess then, thats why they don't want jail time for them. I think Pro-Life needs to rethink its approach.

[cunninglinguist82]

Xavierz71 said "how much do they pay you to go around attacking people defending babies. you are just as guilty as those that kill the babies, if you are not against them then you are for them."

If he is right, I suppose I am going to hell, because I believe women should make choices about abortion, not the government. You say we are going to hell? No problem. Let God sort us out. But until then, keep your personal and religious feelings separate from women's bodies and our legal system.

[xavierz71]

how much do they pay you to go around attacking people defending babies. you are just as guilty as those that kill the babies, if you are not against them then you are for them. why do you not ask if it right to kill an innocent human being for any reason???? but no you want to try to confuse people get them to say something from there heart. so you can say they are religious freaks, or fanatics. you people are evil, and hell is never full.

[ChannelATA]

great video. check this one out too "legal abortion: essential for a free society"

[williemetoyer23]

sounds like a lie

[NostalgicMemory01]

nice video. most people say things like abortion are immoral but why do protesters(most) stand in front of clinics shouting their opinions. to me that's just taking advatage of women who are feeling a little vulnerable since that's a hard decision to make. i don't get why protestors quote the bible against abortion but not anything else. god views all those sins the same. why don't they stand in front of divorce courts or go to prisons and protest? it juss shows how hypocritical many ppl can be.

[williemetoyer23]

if you kill an inecint child it is not the same as stealing something like a pencil  abortion is evil in of its self

[NostalgicMemory01]

@williemetoyer23 during the stages than you can have an abortion, the "baby" can't feel any pain, technical it's still part of the mother not a separate organism. ppl steal a lot more than juss "pencils" (i kno u don't literally mean pencils) but what about murderers or ppl who wanna get divorced. why don't protestors for the bible also go there and protest? in god's eyes it's all the same...

[williemetoyer23]

but abortion is murder and it is the killing of inecints getting a divorce is not the same as killing a child i hope you are not serious

[NostalgicMemory01]

@williemetoyer23 with the whole divorce thing... im talking about people who are actively against abortion because of the bible. if they're doing it for the bible then they should do all the things the bible is against. god is against divorces so he's not gunna say ok you got divorced but you didn't get an abortion so your not dat bad. both divorcees and abortionists are getting the same punishment... so women shouldn't have the right to abort a baby?

[williemetoyer23]

life is a first principle if thier is no dignity twards life then you can't argue other problems

[NostalgicMemory01]

@williemetoyer23 you can't force a woman to do something with her body. if she was raped and wants to abort her rapists baby- legally, so their isn't any pain towards the fetus, she should have that right.

[williemetoyer23]

I understand that to be a difficult situation but idon't think you have the right to kill anyone for convience

[NostalgicMemory01]

@williemetoyer23 true point

[ninjazachy06]

Hahaha. 5 stars :)

[pubuman]

I dont get it... why can't they just say, yes - I mean if they view abortion as murder, why do they think the punishment should be any different from the punishment handed out to murder? Their stance is inconsistent and almost borderline hypocritical... but then, that's the religious nutters for you!

[angelic6465]

If you are really pro-life than you should be taking a stance to help women prevent unwanted pregnancies by providing them with easier access to birth control. What about the 500,000 unwanted children in the foster care system in the us? If you really are pro-life you should be pro-child, too. Be willing to help take care of the ones that are already here and need a parent, adopt a child, adopt 2, just do something about it rather than trying to tell others what to do. Take some responsibility!

[BRT3108]

this makes me ashamed to live in mississippi. silly little simple redneck folks saying simple little redneck things.

"they will be punished if they do it infront of god"

okay? and what if you don't believe in god?

you go to double hell for killing and not believing huh? i bet so...

fucking idiots.

[graveswill]

Ppl in favor of abortion are hypocrites.

Sure they can say yes to abortions CAUSE THEY ARE FUCKING ALIVE! They aren't' in danger of being killed.

They are alive cause their mothers said no to abortion! And those same ppl want to take the chance of living to others!?

[vicmackey2008]

"Sure they can say yes to abortions CAUSE THEY ARE FUCKING ALIVE!"

No man, that's not the case. We just want all those babies to go to heaven, and not have to take the chance of becomning sinners, and going to hell. Thanks to us, the baby population in heaven is going up, and the angels couldn't be happier. I bet Jesus whishes Mary had an abortion. That way he wpuldn't have to be tortured to death, and worshipped by crazy delusional assholes like you! HAHAHAHAHA!

[frootofaloom]

so you hate christians

[afsdoiadfjsoipjdofis]

Well I wish I had a better user name but apparently every single word of any language on Earth has been taken.

But as I said in response to a similar video, the poster assumes for all forms of murder a person is punished. Wrong. It isn't true for attempted suicides, and the law still says that's murder. In both cases the people need help.

The most pathetic thing for the poster in this is I'm also a sidewalk counselor. Word to the poster--quit while you're ahead.

[SEF6519]

hm... i wonder~

should it be illegal to beat off? =)_

it is killing millions and millions of "lives".

jeez, this ain't called pro-life xP

its fucking anti-human rights -_-'

ppl making it their business about what a woman should do with HER OWN FUCKING VAGINA! -____-'

damn, we're starting to look like those countries that treat women like public property =P

[graveswill]

There is a BIG difference between a womans body and a baby's body. If the baby could talk, he/she would probably say:

"GET THOSE SCISSORS OUT OF MY FACE! DON'T YOU DARE CUT MY ARM OFF! I WANT TO LIVE DAMN IT" and so on.

And as I said before, we who are already a live because our mothers said no to abortion have no right to kill a child.

[korriban129]

If you want to look at it from a biological perspective, at the moment of conception the cells that originate from the egg have a completely different genetic makeup than the mother. This means that this grouping of cells is a completely different entity. You are failing to properly frame this debate by starting with a faulty premise. This grouping of genetically DIFFERENT cells will eventually grow into a human being. What justification is there in terminating that human life.

[yohanancohen]

Anyone educated person who is pro-choice would not argue that the fetus does not have the potential to be born as a human being.

The argument is that the unwanted fetus is in violation of the woman's rights.

The current legal ruling is that the rights of the woman supersede the rights of the fetus.

[flyingscience]

Hypocrites - you laugh at them , but dont know the answer yourself! No one answered my Q, for over 1 week!!!!

[arbuckle1029]

Looks like nobody likes you, flyingscience. Go to hell.

[flyingscience]

Arbuckle - Becoming a murderer is not accepted for any other acts of irresponsibility .Motherhood is the greatest responsibility in a woman's life.

[arbuckle1029]

Oh, I see. You're one of those people who thinks that women are only good for procreation and looking after the children while her husband is off at work.

[flyingscience]

Arbuckle - Pro death murderers cringe every time they are reminded that they choose to kill for convenience sake .Unpopular reminder.

[arbuckle1029]

A fetus shouldn't be held on the same level as you or I. Really, am I pro-death, or a murderer, if I eat a steak? Or even a salad?

[korriban129]

Why not? I am simply curious as to your reasoning. Is it because they are not fully physically developed? Is it the fact that they do not yet possess a satisfactory cognitive ability? Is it because it cannot yet survive outside of the mother's body? And what is this level the you attempt to define. Are you trying to define what it means to be human? If so I would appreciate a clear definition.

[UnconditionalJustice]

The most accepted, and psychologically developed, definition for being 'human' is the ability to cognitively use language and be capable of empathy...neither of which a fetus is capable of.

[flyingscience]

In other countries where abortion is illegal how are the women punished? How many years in prison is typical?

[flyingscience]

Don't like homework -kill teacher

Don't like overtime -kill boss.

Don't like diapers - kill baby .

Its your right to kill unplanned babies-not!

[flyingscience]

Irresponsible pet owners -jailed.

Irresponsible car drivers -jailed.

Irresponsible CEO- jailed !

Irresponsible mothers- jailed!No different.

[bp358]

Jesus is PRO-LIFE! He created every person and only He has the power to say when a life should end.

[arbuckle1029]

If Jesus is Pro-Life, why are there miscarriages?

After all, miscarriages are natural abortions. Or is it all part of God's mysterious plan?

[flyingscience]

BP -Watch the video "Gods death toll " The number that god killed is over 2 million.God is obviously pro death penalty.

[ajpmathwiz]

The women who have abortions are often acting under duress, but the abortionist never is. Thus, the abortionist should be punished without mercy.

[jives004]

In the end though, abortion will probably never ever be illegal, want to know why. Any feminist advocates shield your eyes cause the people in office couldn't give two shits about your rights. It's about MONEY, NOT YOU... people think doctors jump on the chance to perform and abortion because they love killing shit, no they love the fat pay check they get from it, and as long as there is lobbyist, there will be abortion. So please take your self righteous its my body bullshit and shove it.

[CassandraCarter]

Average cost of an abortion: $500.

Average cost of a delivery: $5000.

If they're doing it for the fat checks and profit, then they're DOIN IT WRONG. Fact is, most clinics are staffed by volunteers.

[jives004]

ok i'll answer your question cause i'm not afraid to say it. The way i see it, if abortion is made illegal, it would be a matter of its premise. If it is considered illegal cause it is murder, then yes they should go to jail for murdering someone like everyone else. Don't try and sugar coat it by saying your criminalizing mothers. I think we all have seen a mother drown her children, so she shouldn't go to jail because she is a mom... please come up with a better cover for your poor arguement

[thrillhouse900]

way to watch that other video and do the exact same thing, creative.

[felisd]

Well, why not? It would be interesting to see what the responses are for a larger cross-section of anti-abortion demonstrators than just those few in the first vid. And to get the opinions of a few men.

Seems to prove though that they don't really think about the women who would have abortions at all though, doesn't it?

[thrillhouse900]

nothing the other video didn't prove.

[HarvBand]

AMAZING that these people haven't thought this one out.