What about Warren Moon? still the greatest african amercian quaterback of all time. 5 CFL championsips in a row, 70,000+ pro passing yards.That guy can throw a perfect spiral everytime. Half of the Qb's on this list where on Dynasties an all of them had great defences and awesome WR's and Rb's. Just because a QB doesnt win a superbowl doesnt mean their not great it requires a team effort. Tom Brady is great ,but so was Adam Vinateri in all those superbowl wins. All by three points. Team effort.
@boskey10 on the first sb the pats won brady drove them down for the winning field goal with hardly any time and backed up deep. he took his team and put them in the spot to kkick the field goal and he did it with horrible receivers
@TheMW22222 What about when they played Carolina and the Eagles the following years? All won by field goals the point im making is that Brady was very forunate having great speical teams to fall back on. If you dissagree then explain on superbowl XLll facing the gaints he could'nt lead his team down the field when the game was in his hands, after a record breaking 50tds in one season, highest scoring team in nfl history,and undefeated the entire season until that game. Where was he then?
That being said, if I could have 1 QB for one game I would probably take Steve Young. A legitimate double threat. He was athletic and unlike Vick, McNabb, Cunningham,etc. he was very accurate and in the only SB he played in he was unreal.
@HaTeRaDeable I said unlike Vick, McNabb, Cunningham etc. Steve Young was very accurate. Making him a legitimate double threat. I never said McNabb, Vick, Cunningham were not athletic they were just not all that accurate throwing the ball.
Its tough to really decide the top 10 b/c not only are QBs judged on stats but impact should also count for something. They should divide the Qbs into different eras. I mean Otto Graham, Johnny Unitas, Sammy Baugh, Norm Van Brocklin, and Bart Starr were great QBs who played when running was the key to the game and when seasons only consisted of like 12 or 14 games.
U got me until you showed John Elway and montana, dude I know theyy went to super bowls but danny white is better than John elway, but on the other hand montan is better than danny. Troy Aikman is better that Tom Brady. And where is Roger at he is better than Elway and Montana.
Marino #1, Young #2, Elway #3. Montana is so overated, Marino had the arm & vision that no one could match!!!! If Dan got a good defence he'd have more SB rings than everyone.
@redhead5150 I almost agree Montana should be swapped with Marino Joe was that good overated only because of 4 super bowl rings but give Marino Rice and Waters he wins those 4 rings!
There's really no such thing as one single greatest QB of all time. So much of football is just the situation that you happen to fall into. For example, Dan Marino has zero rings and Joe Montana has 4. Yet, Montana had GOBS more talent surrounding him in SF than Marino ever had in Miami. And another guy who really gets forgetten is Warren Moon. This guy's career stats are OFF THE CHARTS. Again though, the QB can only do so much by himself; you have to give him something to work with.
I don't have a huge problem with your list, other than Brett Farve. I think you have him too high, but you do have the right 10 Qb's on the list, just a different order.
Sammy Baugh....he was the original Elvis Presley of QBs, and is easily a top 5 of all time QB.....this is a nice list though.....guys like Baugh and Unitus played in an era where it was far more difficult to complete passes. Are you little children even aware that it was perfectly within the rules prior to the early 1970's to deck a WR way past the line of scrimmage as long as the QB still had the ball? That's right....defensive holding in the secondary was perfectly legal back then....
IDGAF what yall say, Ryan Leaf was the greatest Quarterback of all time. He was put in a position to fail in San Diego. And if he would've had better talent around him he would probably have 5 rings by now. Not to mention he was plagued by injuries, which everyone seems to discredit him for. Here's the real list:
So before you open your mouth, look up the facts, you and everybody else who thinks Namath doesn't deserve the name of an excellent QB. The best is Joe Montana no damn about it.
Oh and Namath beat Johnny Unitas twice, when he was 20 points below as a underdog, AND won against the Giants after SB 3, even though everyone said the Jets were going to get crushed. Instead the Giants got their asses handed to them.
You should change this to "greatest modern QB's" of all time. Otto Grahm and Sammy baugh need to be on the list. Unitas should be 1 or 2. he invented the 3,5, and 7 step drop. He invented timing patterns. Not only did he invent these things, he won championships with them.
where is sammy baugh u sould searh him up he is top 5. and troy aikmen at 9 more like 18 he was great but he played with a great team. john unties should be number he is great besides joe montana his the best of all time send me and email at balester555@gmail.com
yeah bro, favre cant be behind marino and elway, and elway cant be behind marino , favre and montana are 2 best qbs ever. so i think u shoulda put them as 1 and 2 (your pick, your video) then elway then marino.
@kvsfan21 Belickeck filmed all of the teams practices in thoes 3 years that the patriots won. Then he got caught and have they won any since. He won thoes super bowls because Belickeck cheated.
Favre is about the 12th best QB of the last 30 years, much less one of the 10 best of all time. Favre used (and abused) Holmgren's painfully tailored WCO for whatever success Favre had. Sherman's WCO had many elements from Holmgren's well. When Favre followed the system, things went splendidly, when he decided Gunslinging Favreball was needed, bad things happened. This held true for his entire 19 years as a starter, hence why he had a pedestrian 86 QB rating while in a stat enhancing WCO.
Gosh, I guess no one before Johnny U. was any good. They were all well before my time too, but if you don't have Otto Graham or Sammy Baugh on the top 10 list you haven't a frigging clue. For sure I'd dump Peyton Manning and replace him with one of the above. I'd probably also drop Aikman and replace him with Staubach. The only reason Staubach has less rings than Aikman is that he played the Steelers in their prime.
Staubach should have won super bowl XIII when Jackie Smith dropped that Wide open pass in the end zone I am still upset about that. but I wouldnt be able to decide between Aikman or Staubach.
The ONLY argument EVER given for Marino not being the best ever, is that fact that he never won the SB. That is the ONLY thing the haters and homers have to hang their argument on. ALL the other QBs have multiple flaws that get pointed out. NOT Dan!
fuck no Troy Aikman should be way higher and also the only reason u have peyton manning and jonny unitas higher is cuz ur a colts fan pshh # 9 troy aikman dats stupid and also tom brady is better than those foos too
Whoa! No one in his right mind will criticize Joe Montana as the all-time greatest. Terry Bradshaw should be in the top 5. Troy Aikman shouldn't be listed. Tom Brady is rated too low. Peyton Manning deserves his spot. Dan Marino is over-rated and should be much lower (especially since he couldn't win a Super Bowl). Brett Favre is over-rated. Johnny Unitas shouldn't be listed. Steve Young is over-rated. John Elway is slightly over-rated. And everyone should ask, "where is Roger Staubach"?
@rtmorphine Troy Aikman is like a child hood hero to me. He was the most accurate QB in History and he has won more games than any other QB in 1 decade and his play off pass percentage is the best in history so if you dont think Aikman should be on this you dont know much about football. Bradshaw has a rating of 75 He was SHIT. Elway to me is underated. Johnny Unitas changed the way the game was played. Staubach should be in the top 5 I agree with you on that. Marino is a great QB
@rtmorphine Disagree with Bradshaw.. Sure he has 4 rings but that is because the 70s Steelers were known for their great Steel Curtain Defense.. plus legends on offense like Harris, Webster, Stallworth, and Swann, etc Bradshaw had 212 tds and 210 ints.. not real good when you look into his career..
Disagree with Marino, his run game and defense on the teams he was with was shit. Unitas defiently is on the list. I can agree with Favre, and Young. Elway.. no. Staubach deserves should be on here..
(Part 2 Of 2 Parts): team, we don't know how well he might have performed. When Doug Williams was with Tampa Bay (when every part of their game sucked), I thought Williams was to blame. At the time, I was too young to know any better. However, when he was traded to the Redskins, at a time when they played great on both sides of the ball, he shined and won a Super Bowl. Unfortunately, he was injured in the off-season and never played again. I believe that Bart Starr was much better than Unitas.
@Magic32Rice80 (Part 1 Of 2 Parts): You make some excellent points. A defense that can bust balls is a must. That accounts for a large part of Bradshaw's success, along with the Steelers awesome tandum of Stallworth & Swan. Bradshaw's only win against the L.A. Rams was in the 1980 Super Bowl! I would add that an offensive line that can protect the quarterback is also a must. You are correct that it was all on Marino to do everything. But since we didn't see him play with a better (See Part 2)
100% agree that Bradshaw was way over rated. How can he be one of the greatest all time with a career QB rating of 70.9. The Steelers would have probably won a few more titles if they had a real QB. QB's with better career passer rating: Scott Mitchell, Dave Krieg, Tommy Maddox, Tim Couch, Tony Banks, Quincy Carter, Gus Frerotte, Ties Rex Grossman, beats out Joey Harrington by a point and a half, beats Kordell Stewart by .2. Sad that a man can be in this company and be called one of the greats
Tom Brady is #1 and he is the man, you fuckin fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuckity fuckin mother fucker, cunt dick douche bag whore slut ass hole bitch pussy nigger twat shit fuckin vagina face cum cuzzlin faggot,
@tylerdeiana read his name bro he's a colts fan there dillusional they let them team get in the way of who really is a better QB I agree Brady number 1 montana play with the greatest team ever assembled
@tylerdeiana Let me guess, you weren't on the high school debating team. Brady is good. However, Montana, Staubach, and Bradshaw are 3 of the all-time greatest.
@runtheharlemworld I am a die hard Charger fan and I personally think he is better than Fouts, Brees and Humphries, but you are insane to even consider him top 10
I really like what you tried to do. I would put Bradshaw much higher and Elway much lower. John Elway and Mike Shanahan should still be making monthly payments to Terrell Davis for establihing their reputations. When you get a chance, check out the post season and championship game records of one Bart Starr; he did a whole lot more than hand off to Hornung and Taylor and was The Best big Game Quarterback Of All Time.
Remember people the amount of Super Bowl rings a QB has dose not determine who is the best. That is a myth because its just the easiest thing for people to say without really breaking it down, and we live in a messed up society where sometimes individuals are judged by team performance. How come People are'nt bashing Brady or Manning when they loose in the playoffs or the SB, but oh hes the best when the team wins.
@juko9998 If I had to pick a QB and a team to play in a Super Bowl, I would take Terry Bradshaw and the 70's Steelers over Joe and the 49ers. The difference is Terry was a big straping son of a bitch with balls of steel and would drop bombs on the defense into double coverage on 3 and 10 in super bowls in the 4th qauter, and he would say hee haa. Joe on the other hand did not have that ability or arm strenght, he had to rely on great play makers and Bill Walshes system to look good
@heavymetal92892 yeah ok head banger lol (I love rock n roll to) go watch the highlights again, and watch the Blonde Bomber goin deep multiple times on all the teams they played in the Super Bowls. Its not always about numbers, if a QB is having a bad day but throws a deep pass to set up a score or throws a TD, and one of those TDs break the game open. Deep completions and deep TD passes r the only numbers that mattered in those games and it ripped the heart right out of the defense
@FuckRaiders1 Understand that without Bill Walsh Montana is just an above average QB with not a very strong arm. Walsh's system and the playmakers he had in that system made Joe look really good, not saying hes not top 5, just not top 3
Why do people so consistently overrate Steve Young? He came up small in the biggest games against the Cowboys, while Troy Aikman came up huge. He was a product of the San Francisco system. You could have plugged in any number of quarterbacks into that system and they would have had similar success to Young. Conversely, put Steve Young on the Troy Aikman Cowboys and they would have taken a big drop. Young is pushing the top 20, nothing more.
This list is a travesty if Roger Staubach is not on it. Absolute travesty. Did you see the man play? He was everything you could possibly want in a quarterback. He had a strong, accurate arm, could make all the throws, could scramble with the best of 'em, was tough, consistent, and was at his best when the game was on the line. Not to mention the fact that he was the ultimate leader of men. Roger Staubach was an absolute legend.
You're kidding, right? Steve Young and Brett Favre better than Johnny U? Bradshaw and his FOUR rings only 10th? Ask most any Cowboy fan and they would laugh at Aikman being in the top 10 ahead of a guy named Staubach.
@LaCanadaMike I like Bradshaw to sir, he had balls of steel, but had one of the greatest teams of all time and made a lot of mistakes, he deserves the 10 spot, and Aikman was more consistent then Roger dodger.
I agree with most of the list, but I don't think Steve Young was a better QB than Roger Staubach, Bob Griese, Ken Stabler or even Big Ben, and remember Sammy Baugh as well...
@dshstudio54 LMAO! Young was head over shoulders better than Stabler, Griese, and Roethlisberger. I guess you can somewhat make a case for Staubach, and Baugh but I would put SY over those 2 as well.
DONKEY KONG peyton hasn't had a de like brady and peyton doesn't just throw screens oh and it's funny that when brady got hurt and was ou for the season the pats still made the play offs so they don't need brady learn your shit dumb ass and superbowls are team sport to you tard
Marino is the greatest qb of all time he had numbers a realease and everything also he didn't have a de or a run game his team sucked like montana he had recievers and a de and a run game also Tom Brady sucks all he does is throw screen passes and since he lost his defense they can't win in the play offs ALSO when brady got hurt and was out the whole season the patriots still made the play offs so they don't need him top 5 qbs off all time are
@CAJunkie1 you're wrong because marino is the best quarterback not ot have a super bowl ring sure he has all those stats and stuff that you said but when you think about joe montana he led a SUPERB team to 4 superbowl wins
Marino should be higher look at the number's besides not winning a super bowl he had the quickest release and put up remarkable numbers for the talent he had around him.Most Qb's on this list where with teams that had a stellar defence and great wide receivers and runningbacks.Marino didnt have that on a consistent basis like them so of course they won superbowls.
how is Brett Favre better then Young, you got to be kidding me. He is totally confused coming out of retirement and going back. He sucks he only won once in the super bowl while young won once and helped Montana with the other 2.
Not saying Namath was AMAZING but he did more than guarantee he was the first QB to throw over 4000 yards and that was a much harder task back then, especially on a team like the Jets.
@CAJunkie1 Someone is a little mad. In 1972 he led the league in passing yards, touchdowns, yards per attempt (7.0) , adjusted yards per attempt, net yards per attempt, and adjusted net yards per attempt. He also had a very low sack ratting. But I'm guessing QB rating is al that matters to you.
give me one reason why Petyon is higher than Brady Brady has won 3 superbowls with no pro bowlers whatsoever and a horrible reciveing corps while Manning has had Marvin harrsion, Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark, Anthony Gonzalez, Piree Garcon, Austin Collie, Edgerrain James, Joseph Addia, Jeff Saturday throught his career and how does he only have 1 superbowl with those players
and its my opinion, but look who montana had on his team, elway carried his team for 3 years the won 2 super bowls, i know im not changing yalls opinion and unless peyton or brady keep on going, he will always be considered the best.
lol if u exclude montana at #1 u realize the last 3 quarterbacks have more superbowls then the rest of the list combined...im a patriots fan and brady won the offensive player soon to win mvp and belichick won coach of the year...that means nothing to me rings are what matters when it comes to the quarterback position...the list says greatest not most skilled the great quarterbacks win championships end of story...bret farve is awful btw all his records are due to longevity
@MrRugbyfan999 oh really does rodgers have the nfl record for passing yards touchdowns and compleations and have a superbowl and is a 3 time MVP, oh wait he doesn't actually know your football before you open your mouth and sound like an idiot.
@Boomer1719 Rodgers will never be better than favre I can see him winning the superbowl this year but to be better than favre you have to beat all of favres records and still be under his record for intercpeetions and fumbles and be a 3 time MVP which will never happen
@Donkeykong21425 and i completely agree with you, i was laughing at what you said to MrRugbyfan999, im gonna guess you are someone that actually will admit when someone is good whether or not you like them as a person at all, same here. and your right it will probably never happen again.
@Boomer1719 oh yeah sorry bro I thought you were rugbyfan, but yeah since rodgers got injured in the middle of this season that just tells you there's going to be more injuries with him he will be lucky to make it through 10 more years if he wants to keep on scrambling and the guy hasn't even thrown 100 touchdowns yet and he's 27 he's going to have to play until he's 50 to break Favres records, he's a good QB but very few quarterbacks in my opinon are better than Favre.
@Slotten68 how he only threw 5 more touchdowns than Interceptions..... the few who are better than favre are Joe Montana, Tom Brady and argubally Johnny Unitas
UHH HELLO MIKE VICK CHANGED THE WAY QBs ARE MADE.....EVERY YOUNG QB WANTS TO HAVE A LITTLE MIKE VICK IN THEM HE I PERSONALLY THINK HE IS IN THE TOP 5 BUT HE COULD ATLEAST MAKE THE TOP 10 THUMBS UP IF YOU AGREE
song?
Ferrari123planb 2 weeks ago
that is bull shit terry bradshaw won 4 super bowls john elway won 2
ththtguy 1 month ago
MONTANA MANNING BRADY BRADSHAW AIKMAN IN NO PARTICULAR ODER.
Mark53190 3 months ago
What about Warren Moon? still the greatest african amercian quaterback of all time. 5 CFL championsips in a row, 70,000+ pro passing yards.That guy can throw a perfect spiral everytime. Half of the Qb's on this list where on Dynasties an all of them had great defences and awesome WR's and Rb's. Just because a QB doesnt win a superbowl doesnt mean their not great it requires a team effort. Tom Brady is great ,but so was Adam Vinateri in all those superbowl wins. All by three points. Team effort.
boskey10 3 months ago
@boskey10 on the first sb the pats won brady drove them down for the winning field goal with hardly any time and backed up deep. he took his team and put them in the spot to kkick the field goal and he did it with horrible receivers
TheMW22222 2 months ago
@TheMW22222 What about when they played Carolina and the Eagles the following years? All won by field goals the point im making is that Brady was very forunate having great speical teams to fall back on. If you dissagree then explain on superbowl XLll facing the gaints he could'nt lead his team down the field when the game was in his hands, after a record breaking 50tds in one season, highest scoring team in nfl history,and undefeated the entire season until that game. Where was he then?
boskey10 2 months ago
@boskey10 when he had the ball the final time they had less than a mineut left and he put them in field goal range against Carolina and philly
TheMW22222 2 months ago
That being said, if I could have 1 QB for one game I would probably take Steve Young. A legitimate double threat. He was athletic and unlike Vick, McNabb, Cunningham,etc. he was very accurate and in the only SB he played in he was unreal.
BNS224 4 months ago
@BNS224 vick? un athletic? are you stupid one of the best passing quarter backs and one of the fastest quarter backs of all time
HaTeRaDeable 3 months ago
@HaTeRaDeable I said unlike Vick, McNabb, Cunningham etc. Steve Young was very accurate. Making him a legitimate double threat. I never said McNabb, Vick, Cunningham were not athletic they were just not all that accurate throwing the ball.
BNS224 3 months ago
Its tough to really decide the top 10 b/c not only are QBs judged on stats but impact should also count for something. They should divide the Qbs into different eras. I mean Otto Graham, Johnny Unitas, Sammy Baugh, Norm Van Brocklin, and Bart Starr were great QBs who played when running was the key to the game and when seasons only consisted of like 12 or 14 games.
BNS224 4 months ago
tom brady number 8 ? manning number 7 tom brady should be ahead of steve young and so should manning
MrRyguy92 4 months ago
U got me until you showed John Elway and montana, dude I know theyy went to super bowls but danny white is better than John elway, but on the other hand montan is better than danny. Troy Aikman is better that Tom Brady. And where is Roger at he is better than Elway and Montana.
TheHistoryGuy97 4 months ago
brady is one of the toughest qbs on this list and i think hes #1
67mdoherty 4 months ago
untias should be #1 he made the qb position what it is today
kgreen1232 4 months ago
Where the heck is Bart Starr? C'mon, man!
jaspeterson 5 months ago
Where is Otto Graham! should be top 5! and young 5? more like 8!
bensyd123 5 months ago 2
Where is Otto Graham!should be top 5! and young 5? more like 8!
bensyd123 5 months ago
Marino #1, Young #2, Elway #3. Montana is so overated, Marino had the arm & vision that no one could match!!!! If Dan got a good defence he'd have more SB rings than everyone.
redhead5150 5 months ago
@redhead5150 I almost agree Montana should be swapped with Marino Joe was that good overated only because of 4 super bowl rings but give Marino Rice and Waters he wins those 4 rings!
broarnold1 5 months ago
Fuck Elway and hop off of Dan Marino's dick
Au323 5 months ago
There's really no such thing as one single greatest QB of all time. So much of football is just the situation that you happen to fall into. For example, Dan Marino has zero rings and Joe Montana has 4. Yet, Montana had GOBS more talent surrounding him in SF than Marino ever had in Miami. And another guy who really gets forgetten is Warren Moon. This guy's career stats are OFF THE CHARTS. Again though, the QB can only do so much by himself; you have to give him something to work with.
phillyspartanfan 5 months ago
elway the best he has second most tds if farve didnt stay 2 long and brady best of this generation better then steve young and manning
prettyboyswag317 5 months ago
Bret Favre above Manning, Brady, Aikman, are you fucking high! he should be 10th if that he has the worst stats out of them all!
MarcViper 5 months ago
I don't have a huge problem with your list, other than Brett Farve. I think you have him too high, but you do have the right 10 Qb's on the list, just a different order.
btez31 6 months ago
1. marino
2. unitas
3. montana
4. farve
5. tarkenton
thats my opnion on top 5 and bradshaw shouldn't be on there
de7897 6 months ago
Peyton Manning is not better than tom brady, not opinion known fact
JaKe160100 6 months ago
@JaKe160100 my point exactly
joeycanfly24 6 months ago
Sammy Baugh....he was the original Elvis Presley of QBs, and is easily a top 5 of all time QB.....this is a nice list though.....guys like Baugh and Unitus played in an era where it was far more difficult to complete passes. Are you little children even aware that it was perfectly within the rules prior to the early 1970's to deck a WR way past the line of scrimmage as long as the QB still had the ball? That's right....defensive holding in the secondary was perfectly legal back then....
colderbeer 6 months ago
What about the guy that broke nearly ass of thos QB's records?! DREW BREES!!!!
whodat1994 6 months ago
@whodat1994 Why did you randomly throw the word ass in your comment? lol
ga20065 6 months ago
@ga20065 Haha, my bad. ALL* I have no ideal how that got there.
whodat1994 6 months ago
IDGAF what yall say, Ryan Leaf was the greatest Quarterback of all time. He was put in a position to fail in San Diego. And if he would've had better talent around him he would probably have 5 rings by now. Not to mention he was plagued by injuries, which everyone seems to discredit him for. Here's the real list:
1. Ryan Leaf
2. Tom Brady
3. Joe Montanna
4. Steve Young
5. David Gerrard
ga20065 6 months ago
@ga20065 That's a weird list bruh, IDK about that.
whodat1994 6 months ago
@ga20065 worst list Ever Ryan Leaf seriously and David Gerrard
EazyESJC82288 6 months ago
And he did all of these with one knee...imagine if he had both.
1993majinvegeta 6 months ago
All of the below: Joe Namath
So before you open your mouth, look up the facts, you and everybody else who thinks Namath doesn't deserve the name of an excellent QB. The best is Joe Montana no damn about it.
Oh and Namath beat Johnny Unitas twice, when he was 20 points below as a underdog, AND won against the Giants after SB 3, even though everyone said the Jets were going to get crushed. Instead the Giants got their asses handed to them.
Just guaranteed a victory my ass...
1993majinvegeta 6 months ago
You are the only one who is stupid. Let's take a look:
Passed for 4,000 yds twice
Actually won a SB(unlike Dan Marino)
Revolutionized the NFL to what it is today
Accepted by Don Shula as one of the greatest quarterbacks of his time
Called plays of his own, which more than once succeeded
Lead perhaps the only team that had a chance of beating Miami in 1972, ending their streak.
More interceptions that TDs yes, but he didn't win an SB only thanks to his defense(why is Terry better)
1993majinvegeta 6 months ago
1 montana
2 brady / manning
4 elway
5 favre
eblsymk 6 months ago
This is my top five:
1.) Joe Montana
2.) John Elway
3.) Peyton Manning
4.) Dan Marino
5.) Steve Young
Beale64 6 months ago
You should change this to "greatest modern QB's" of all time. Otto Grahm and Sammy baugh need to be on the list. Unitas should be 1 or 2. he invented the 3,5, and 7 step drop. He invented timing patterns. Not only did he invent these things, he won championships with them.
mdf3962 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
where is sammy baugh u sould searh him up he is top 5. and troy aikmen at 9 more like 18 he was great but he played with a great team. john unties should be number he is great besides joe montana his the best of all time send me and email at balester555@gmail.com
walkerniqaill 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Switch Manning out with Young and your list will be ok.
andreykashin1988 6 months ago
yeah bro, favre cant be behind marino and elway, and elway cant be behind marino , favre and montana are 2 best qbs ever. so i think u shoulda put them as 1 and 2 (your pick, your video) then elway then marino.
Craigster45 6 months ago
Farve at 4? Elway at 2? common
RandyMossfan111 6 months ago
tom brady is the est qb in the world who else can say they won 3 superbowls in the first 4 years of there career
kvsfan21 7 months ago
@kvsfan21 Belickeck filmed all of the teams practices in thoes 3 years that the patriots won. Then he got caught and have they won any since. He won thoes super bowls because Belickeck cheated.
EazyESJC82288 7 months ago
who is steve young?
RyanBlade100 7 months ago
If Favre didn't slip up near the end of his career, he's be top 2...
Behind Marino
madman25ish 7 months ago
Favre is about the 12th best QB of the last 30 years, much less one of the 10 best of all time. Favre used (and abused) Holmgren's painfully tailored WCO for whatever success Favre had. Sherman's WCO had many elements from Holmgren's well. When Favre followed the system, things went splendidly, when he decided Gunslinging Favreball was needed, bad things happened. This held true for his entire 19 years as a starter, hence why he had a pedestrian 86 QB rating while in a stat enhancing WCO.
toolkien 7 months ago
Gosh, I guess no one before Johnny U. was any good. They were all well before my time too, but if you don't have Otto Graham or Sammy Baugh on the top 10 list you haven't a frigging clue. For sure I'd dump Peyton Manning and replace him with one of the above. I'd probably also drop Aikman and replace him with Staubach. The only reason Staubach has less rings than Aikman is that he played the Steelers in their prime.
mrskyman58 7 months ago
@mrskyman58 Aikman was a very good QB.
Staubach should have won super bowl XIII when Jackie Smith dropped that Wide open pass in the end zone I am still upset about that. but I wouldnt be able to decide between Aikman or Staubach.
EazyESJC82288 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The ONLY argument EVER given for Marino not being the best ever, is that fact that he never won the SB. That is the ONLY thing the haters and homers have to hang their argument on. ALL the other QBs have multiple flaws that get pointed out. NOT Dan!
So, yeah....he IS the best
filthyswit 7 months ago
fuck no Troy Aikman should be way higher and also the only reason u have peyton manning and jonny unitas higher is cuz ur a colts fan pshh # 9 troy aikman dats stupid and also tom brady is better than those foos too
IZZY24fan1 7 months ago
Two greatest of all time: 1. Roger Staubach.....2. Troy Aikman
Andreas748 7 months ago 2
@Andreas748 yea rright Cowboys overrated
DavidOwenWard 6 months ago
@Andreas748
The cowboys fans are like cub fans. Every year they say theyre gonna win, and they end up blowing a hobos left testicle.
Halo3Arbiter 5 months ago
@Andreas748 joe montanna tom brady
bakonman12 4 months ago
Comment removed
rtmorphine 7 months ago
Whoa! No one in his right mind will criticize Joe Montana as the all-time greatest. Terry Bradshaw should be in the top 5. Troy Aikman shouldn't be listed. Tom Brady is rated too low. Peyton Manning deserves his spot. Dan Marino is over-rated and should be much lower (especially since he couldn't win a Super Bowl). Brett Favre is over-rated. Johnny Unitas shouldn't be listed. Steve Young is over-rated. John Elway is slightly over-rated. And everyone should ask, "where is Roger Staubach"?
rtmorphine 7 months ago
Comment removed
EazyESJC82288 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@rtmorphine Troy Aikman is like a child hood hero to me. He was the most accurate QB in History and he has won more games than any other QB in 1 decade and his play off pass percentage is the best in history so if you dont think Aikman should be on this you dont know much about football. Bradshaw has a rating of 75 He was SHIT. Elway to me is underated. Johnny Unitas changed the way the game was played. Staubach should be in the top 5 I agree with you on that. Marino is a great QB
EazyESJC82288 7 months ago
@rtmorphine Disagree with Bradshaw.. Sure he has 4 rings but that is because the 70s Steelers were known for their great Steel Curtain Defense.. plus legends on offense like Harris, Webster, Stallworth, and Swann, etc Bradshaw had 212 tds and 210 ints.. not real good when you look into his career..
Disagree with Marino, his run game and defense on the teams he was with was shit. Unitas defiently is on the list. I can agree with Favre, and Young. Elway.. no. Staubach deserves should be on here..
Magic32Rice80 7 months ago 2
(Part 2 Of 2 Parts): team, we don't know how well he might have performed. When Doug Williams was with Tampa Bay (when every part of their game sucked), I thought Williams was to blame. At the time, I was too young to know any better. However, when he was traded to the Redskins, at a time when they played great on both sides of the ball, he shined and won a Super Bowl. Unfortunately, he was injured in the off-season and never played again. I believe that Bart Starr was much better than Unitas.
rtmorphine 7 months ago
@Magic32Rice80 (Part 1 Of 2 Parts): You make some excellent points. A defense that can bust balls is a must. That accounts for a large part of Bradshaw's success, along with the Steelers awesome tandum of Stallworth & Swan. Bradshaw's only win against the L.A. Rams was in the 1980 Super Bowl! I would add that an offensive line that can protect the quarterback is also a must. You are correct that it was all on Marino to do everything. But since we didn't see him play with a better (See Part 2)
rtmorphine 7 months ago
@rtmorphine Bradshaw has one of the lowest ratings a super bowl winning Qb has ever had
EazyESJC82288 7 months ago
100% agree that Bradshaw was way over rated. How can he be one of the greatest all time with a career QB rating of 70.9. The Steelers would have probably won a few more titles if they had a real QB. QB's with better career passer rating: Scott Mitchell, Dave Krieg, Tommy Maddox, Tim Couch, Tony Banks, Quincy Carter, Gus Frerotte, Ties Rex Grossman, beats out Joey Harrington by a point and a half, beats Kordell Stewart by .2. Sad that a man can be in this company and be called one of the greats
theGUNNman 6 months ago
Tom Brady is #1 and he is the man, you fuckin fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuckity fuckin mother fucker, cunt dick douche bag whore slut ass hole bitch pussy nigger twat shit fuckin vagina face cum cuzzlin faggot,
tylerdeiana 7 months ago
@tylerdeiana read his name bro he's a colts fan there dillusional they let them team get in the way of who really is a better QB I agree Brady number 1 montana play with the greatest team ever assembled
TheJewballer 7 months ago
@tylerdeiana Let me guess, you weren't on the high school debating team. Brady is good. However, Montana, Staubach, and Bradshaw are 3 of the all-time greatest.
rtmorphine 7 months ago
not a bad list just swich Aikman and Young and Montana and Elway and it will be exactly what I think also you should have put Staubach on
EazyESJC82288 7 months ago
@EazyESJC82288 Who won the games when Montana and Elway went head-to-head?
rtmorphine 7 months ago
@rtmorphine Montanas team won the games
EazyESJC82288 7 months ago
good list
143tank 7 months ago
Fran Tarkenton. jussayin
chaosmyr 8 months ago
brett favre and dan marino should switch and so should john elway and peyton manning :) and you should move both brett and dan back some
waxer32123 8 months ago
@waxer32123 that is complete BULL SHIT Elway is better than Manning
EazyESJC82288 7 months ago
brett favre and dan marino should switch and so should john elway and peyton manning :)
waxer32123 8 months ago
i dont agree steve ahead of peyton he should be like 3rd and i agree with cunnidvd unitas at 2nd but #1 is a tough choice
52ColtsFan24 8 months ago
you got it wrong. no way Johnny U is any lower than 3. Number 2 in my opinion. He was the man.
cunnidvd 8 months ago
where the hell is staubach? he should be the number 2 selection!
22steve5150 8 months ago
@22steve5150 yeah !! there isn't Stauback !
elsupertakito 8 months ago
marino should be #1 imo with peyton#2
dolphinzrwj1 8 months ago
Not bad, but wheres Staubach?
pinapplefart35 8 months ago
This is so Bad... Where Is Bart Starr- Packers 5 NFLChampionships
A QB LEADs his Team to Titles Otto Graham Browns , Arnie Herber - Packers 4 titles , Sid Luckman- Bears 4 Rings ..
John Brodie deserves to be in the Hall Of Fame .
calforman 8 months ago
Where is Roger staubach,Bart starr,Bob griese, and Fran tarkenton?
sarahschofield13 9 months ago
i would not put favre before brady or manning
18baseballfreak18 9 months ago
Aikman was not better than Staubach.
AAHemlock 9 months ago
watch my top 5 video it has highlights and a great list
peytonmanningfan7 9 months ago
@runtheharlemworld I am a die hard Charger fan and I personally think he is better than Fouts, Brees and Humphries, but you are insane to even consider him top 10
bscdude17 9 months ago
where the fuck is PHILLIP RIVERS? AT LEAST TOP 5!!!!
runtheharlemworld 9 months ago
I really like what you tried to do. I would put Bradshaw much higher and Elway much lower. John Elway and Mike Shanahan should still be making monthly payments to Terrell Davis for establihing their reputations. When you get a chance, check out the post season and championship game records of one Bart Starr; he did a whole lot more than hand off to Hornung and Taylor and was The Best big Game Quarterback Of All Time.
marcillestlkg 9 months ago
Terry Bradshaw got four superbowl but he is number 10?? and Peyton manning won one but he is 7th??? you suck ass at this dude
Halo2sleker 10 months ago
I loved the list but maybe Peyton manning and Brady shoud a little higher also I liked how you put John elway as 2 instead of 5
XxMickMuffinXX 10 months ago
Remember people the amount of Super Bowl rings a QB has dose not determine who is the best. That is a myth because its just the easiest thing for people to say without really breaking it down, and we live in a messed up society where sometimes individuals are judged by team performance. How come People are'nt bashing Brady or Manning when they loose in the playoffs or the SB, but oh hes the best when the team wins.
MrCjp37 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
are you on drugs?
atocoro2010 10 months ago
I like how Brett Favre is #4!
bscdude17 10 months ago
Good list.
biggpete100 10 months ago
This list is pretty accurate except Elway is #1 and Montanna is #5 Young was better
MrCjp37 10 months ago
@MrCjp37 wow Montana is better than every fukin qb out there
juko9998 10 months ago
@juko9998 If I had to pick a QB and a team to play in a Super Bowl, I would take Terry Bradshaw and the 70's Steelers over Joe and the 49ers. The difference is Terry was a big straping son of a bitch with balls of steel and would drop bombs on the defense into double coverage on 3 and 10 in super bowls in the 4th qauter, and he would say hee haa. Joe on the other hand did not have that ability or arm strenght, he had to rely on great play makers and Bill Walshes system to look good
MrCjp37 10 months ago
@MrCjp37 bradshaw didnt do shit pittsburghs defense won them every sb they won terry has no numbers
heavymetal92892 10 months ago
@heavymetal92892 yeah ok head banger lol (I love rock n roll to) go watch the highlights again, and watch the Blonde Bomber goin deep multiple times on all the teams they played in the Super Bowls. Its not always about numbers, if a QB is having a bad day but throws a deep pass to set up a score or throws a TD, and one of those TDs break the game open. Deep completions and deep TD passes r the only numbers that mattered in those games and it ripped the heart right out of the defense
MrCjp37 10 months ago
Joe Montana is and always will be the best
FuckRaiders1 10 months ago
@FuckRaiders1 Understand that without Bill Walsh Montana is just an above average QB with not a very strong arm. Walsh's system and the playmakers he had in that system made Joe look really good, not saying hes not top 5, just not top 3
MrCjp37 10 months ago
Why do people so consistently overrate Steve Young? He came up small in the biggest games against the Cowboys, while Troy Aikman came up huge. He was a product of the San Francisco system. You could have plugged in any number of quarterbacks into that system and they would have had similar success to Young. Conversely, put Steve Young on the Troy Aikman Cowboys and they would have taken a big drop. Young is pushing the top 20, nothing more.
cladiaBenitez00 10 months ago
This list is a travesty if Roger Staubach is not on it. Absolute travesty. Did you see the man play? He was everything you could possibly want in a quarterback. He had a strong, accurate arm, could make all the throws, could scramble with the best of 'em, was tough, consistent, and was at his best when the game was on the line. Not to mention the fact that he was the ultimate leader of men. Roger Staubach was an absolute legend.
cladiaBenitez00 10 months ago
were is drew brees he beat payton manning in the super bowl he should he was the second qb in nfl history
lovegirl211000 10 months ago
tom brady should be first
laxlover76 10 months ago
Maybe its cause I am a Cowboys fan but... Roger Staubach? The first comeback captain.
BrolyPowerslave 10 months ago
your only mistake was putting brett favre and dan marino in front of steve young.. GO NINERS
dirtydozenbitch2 11 months ago
@dirtydozenbitch2 Oh stop whining, you have Joe Montana as number one.
Dugganworks 10 months ago
You're kidding, right? Steve Young and Brett Favre better than Johnny U? Bradshaw and his FOUR rings only 10th? Ask most any Cowboy fan and they would laugh at Aikman being in the top 10 ahead of a guy named Staubach.
LaCanadaMike 11 months ago
@LaCanadaMike I like Bradshaw to sir, he had balls of steel, but had one of the greatest teams of all time and made a lot of mistakes, he deserves the 10 spot, and Aikman was more consistent then Roger dodger.
MrCjp37 10 months ago
I would've liked to have seen Dan Fouts on this list.
lagnaf007 11 months ago
You suck tom brady is the best and you know it
squbbydoo 11 months ago
@squbbydoo Easily the most overrated on this list.
lagnaf007 11 months ago
I agree with most of the list, but I don't think Steve Young was a better QB than Roger Staubach, Bob Griese, Ken Stabler or even Big Ben, and remember Sammy Baugh as well...
dshstudio54 11 months ago
@dshstudio54 LMAO! Young was head over shoulders better than Stabler, Griese, and Roethlisberger. I guess you can somewhat make a case for Staubach, and Baugh but I would put SY over those 2 as well.
Magic32Rice80 11 months ago
Marion= greatest release ever
Damn who knows what could happened f he went to the steelers
Evanthegreat98 11 months ago
@Evanthegreat98 Or any team that was interested in putting a good team together.
lagnaf007 11 months ago
How about Otto Graham - should probably brush up on Pro Football History.
jkfoxworth17 11 months ago
nice but steve young wasnt as good as p.manning .Wheres sammy baugh
DonQuiRomo 11 months ago
otto graham,, sammy baugh?
eDUBqb12 11 months ago
no joe namath? wtf
bobopedic127 11 months ago
@bobopedic127
Why should Namath be there. He was a bit above average...
TheOtherView 11 months ago
Joe Montana is number 1. You got that one correct.
wosfedbackup 11 months ago
Why is Troy Aikman so low?
TheIceMask 11 months ago
DONKEY KONG peyton hasn't had a de like brady and peyton doesn't just throw screens oh and it's funny that when brady got hurt and was ou for the season the pats still made the play offs so they don't need brady learn your shit dumb ass and superbowls are team sport to you tard
CAJunkie1 11 months ago
Marino is the greatest qb of all time he had numbers a realease and everything also he didn't have a de or a run game his team sucked like montana he had recievers and a de and a run game also Tom Brady sucks all he does is throw screen passes and since he lost his defense they can't win in the play offs ALSO when brady got hurt and was out the whole season the patriots still made the play offs so they don't need him top 5 qbs off all time are
5.Unitas
4.Elway
3.Farve
2.Manning
1.Marino
CAJunkie1 11 months ago
@CAJunkie1 you're wrong because marino is the best quarterback not ot have a super bowl ring sure he has all those stats and stuff that you said but when you think about joe montana he led a SUPERB team to 4 superbowl wins
jsfr1209 11 months ago
Marino should be higher look at the number's besides not winning a super bowl he had the quickest release and put up remarkable numbers for the talent he had around him.Most Qb's on this list where with teams that had a stellar defence and great wide receivers and runningbacks.Marino didnt have that on a consistent basis like them so of course they won superbowls.
boskey10 11 months ago
how is Brett Favre better then Young, you got to be kidding me. He is totally confused coming out of retirement and going back. He sucks he only won once in the super bowl while young won once and helped Montana with the other 2.
UltimateNinja007 11 months ago
Not a bad list but u need to add Staubach
EazyESjc187 11 months ago
sorry about writing on other commment wasent paying atention his name says colts fan and jonny u is only 6 on nfl network
theSgtTatortot 11 months ago
your namr sys colts fan and Jonny U is only number 6
theSgtTatortot 11 months ago
Replace Bradsaw with Roger Staubach and Elway was drafted to the Colts but was such a baby he wouldnt go so remove him completely then the list is ok
WID7 11 months ago
@WID7 Fuck you! Elway wanted to play for a team he thought was capable of getting a winning season.
EazyESjc187 11 months ago
Not saying Namath was AMAZING but he did more than guarantee he was the first QB to throw over 4000 yards and that was a much harder task back then, especially on a team like the Jets.
atchman25 11 months ago
@atchman25 please nameth suckedhis completion % was 50.1 he threw 220 picks and only 173 tds HE BLEW DICK JUST LIKE YOU
CAJunkie1 11 months ago
@CAJunkie1 Someone is a little mad. In 1972 he led the league in passing yards, touchdowns, yards per attempt (7.0) , adjusted yards per attempt, net yards per attempt, and adjusted net yards per attempt. He also had a very low sack ratting. But I'm guessing QB rating is al that matters to you.
atchman25 11 months ago
give me one reason why Petyon is higher than Brady Brady has won 3 superbowls with no pro bowlers whatsoever and a horrible reciveing corps while Manning has had Marvin harrsion, Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark, Anthony Gonzalez, Piree Garcon, Austin Collie, Edgerrain James, Joseph Addia, Jeff Saturday throught his career and how does he only have 1 superbowl with those players
Donkeykong21425 11 months ago
are u fucking dum john elway in front of dam marino
frag12son 11 months ago
Pretty good list, bad song though.
aznluvr7 11 months ago
wtf !! sonny jurgensun/roger staubauch/ bart starr/joe namath/ are not on this list they are much better than brady /manning/young/elway
dafan5997 11 months ago
@dafan5997 hahaha! Really?? Namath better than Elway. child please! Namath is the most overated qb out of the eight you just mentioned.
sandman4435 11 months ago
and its my opinion, but look who montana had on his team, elway carried his team for 3 years the won 2 super bowls, i know im not changing yalls opinion and unless peyton or brady keep on going, he will always be considered the best.
Boomer1719 11 months ago
I agree with your list completely except I believe Farve and Young should switch spots.
synyster215 11 months ago
marino and favre should switch spots
ddvbaseball 11 months ago
lol if u exclude montana at #1 u realize the last 3 quarterbacks have more superbowls then the rest of the list combined...im a patriots fan and brady won the offensive player soon to win mvp and belichick won coach of the year...that means nothing to me rings are what matters when it comes to the quarterback position...the list says greatest not most skilled the great quarterbacks win championships end of story...bret farve is awful btw all his records are due to longevity
edreedisfilthy 11 months ago
#1 tom brady
cwhredsox 11 months ago
Well, I would have included Roger Staubach of the 70s - 80s Cowboys, and removed Manning, but that is just me. Excellent job though...just the same.
cheswv1 11 months ago
Tom Brady is the best QB on there so don't be hating on him.
garyice21 11 months ago
brett favre #4 you've got to be kidding rogers is 10x better than him
MrRugbyfan999 1 year ago
@MrRugbyfan999 oh really does rodgers have the nfl record for passing yards touchdowns and compleations and have a superbowl and is a 3 time MVP, oh wait he doesn't actually know your football before you open your mouth and sound like an idiot.
Donkeykong21425 11 months ago
@Donkeykong21425 because he's like 40 once rogers gets that old he will have broken them all
MrRugbyfan999 11 months ago
@MrRugbyfan999 not really he didn't even make it into the pro bowl this year.
Donkeykong21425 11 months ago
@Donkeykong21425 hahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Boomer1719 11 months ago
@Boomer1719 Rodgers will never be better than favre I can see him winning the superbowl this year but to be better than favre you have to beat all of favres records and still be under his record for intercpeetions and fumbles and be a 3 time MVP which will never happen
Donkeykong21425 11 months ago
@Donkeykong21425 and i completely agree with you, i was laughing at what you said to MrRugbyfan999, im gonna guess you are someone that actually will admit when someone is good whether or not you like them as a person at all, same here. and your right it will probably never happen again.
Boomer1719 9 months ago
@Boomer1719 oh yeah sorry bro I thought you were rugbyfan, but yeah since rodgers got injured in the middle of this season that just tells you there's going to be more injuries with him he will be lucky to make it through 10 more years if he wants to keep on scrambling and the guy hasn't even thrown 100 touchdowns yet and he's 27 he's going to have to play until he's 50 to break Favres records, he's a good QB but very few quarterbacks in my opinon are better than Favre.
Donkeykong21425 9 months ago
@Donkeykong21425 Very few are better than Favre...Stan Humphries was one of those who was
Slotten68 9 months ago
@Slotten68 how he only threw 5 more touchdowns than Interceptions..... the few who are better than favre are Joe Montana, Tom Brady and argubally Johnny Unitas
Donkeykong21425 9 months ago
@Donkeykong21425 and Rick Mirer
Slotten68 9 months ago
@Slotten68 do you seriously watch football?
Donkeykong21425 9 months ago
@Donkeykong21425 I don't know, do you watch it? Maybe you would respect the Mirer Effect
Slotten68 9 months ago
@Boomer1719 Rick Mirer was the best of all time, no questions asked
Slotten68 9 months ago
@Slotten68 no dude ive seen him play he is good, but he aint the best.
Boomer1719 9 months ago
@Slotten68 Hey man I'm a huge Notre Dame fan but come on.
tc5150 5 months ago
@MrRugbyfan999 can you prove that, and he might do it, but right now Favre is better. deal with it.
Boomer1719 11 months ago
john elway 1!!!
bowserjrfan101 1 year ago
UHH HELLO MIKE VICK CHANGED THE WAY QBs ARE MADE.....EVERY YOUNG QB WANTS TO HAVE A LITTLE MIKE VICK IN THEM HE I PERSONALLY THINK HE IS IN THE TOP 5 BUT HE COULD ATLEAST MAKE THE TOP 10 THUMBS UP IF YOU AGREE
rodney1236 1 year ago
@rodney1236 so is tim tebow :)
bowserjrfan101 1 year ago
if theres one game u gotta win and u can take any of em. you would be a fool not to take montana. the greatist of all time.
tetchyorangutan 1 year ago
joe namath =)
sk8skiboard3 1 year ago
Joe Montana! Best QB of all time. no one comes close to him
Radioactive767 1 year ago
Elway should be #1
MrRogger1993 1 year ago
marino should be ranked # 1 who agrees
TheDavonebess15 1 year ago