This album is IMO her greatest work. I love her past stuff, but this was so different from her. The only reason people didn't like it was because when you think of Madonna, you think upbeat dance music, but American Life wasn't a typical Madonna album. Deserved a grammy nod somewhere.
I saw this live in Las Vegas back on May 30th, 2004...it was a Sunday. AND Madonna blew us the f*ck away!!!! She rocked our asses off, what a great show. Thank you, Madonna, for always giving us your very best. Lots of love from Texas.
LOVE IT HONEY GOD OPEN MY DOOR WITH MADONNA THEN HE OPE IT WITH BRITNEY SPEARS BABY HATERS HATE CAUSE U ALL LOOK LIKE SHIT FANS GO MY CHANNEL U SEE DALE DANCING AT BRITNEY CIRCUS TOUR
Doesnt matter how old she is it matters that she inspires everyone, and to let them enjoy and make them selfs and other people happy. Madonna is a bg role model but still she swears >.< GO MADONNA :D
@rocky362 I totally diagree and feel it was her best. I think it was a good "overall" Madonna tour, while Confessions was more in tune to that specific album.
Madonna has inspired me so much. I wish I could thank her. She has taught me to never let anyone tell u No u cant do something, Do as u feel and say as u feel.
@kbamchrepavian-I think that it is so beautiful how she inspired you! She has done the same for me for so many years but when i heard the song Jump it totally changed my life. I am now doing what i always wanted because of how much that song spoke to me. Don't ever under estimate the power of music!
@zeque7 of coarse. The point was to keep the vocal effects of the cd version which are hard to produce live but she sang live on most of the tracks on this tour.
na take madonna as a serious soul, way back ago she wore a t shirt preach 'it takes 20 dumb animals to make a fur coat but only 1 to wear it' now da lowlife bitch pays dem big bucks to support the enslaving, torturing an skinning alive of gods creatures for her false vanity, check da fur farm vidz on youtube 2 c wot she tinks is acceptable to promote in 21st century, fur an fur trim b da height of lowlife taste, kabbalah, is a joke. check 'ANTI FUR SOCIETY' on google, SEE DA TRUTH 4 YA SELVES
No official DVD has been released yet, but video footage of the show - including this video - can be found in the "I'm going to tell you a secret" documentary DVD.
It's so obvious she's lipsynching here, just like she did with Vogue and Die Another Day during the Reinvention Tour, but that's only because of the demanding choreography and after all it's ok to lipsynch only 3 or 4 songs, when you dance the whole 2-hour show. Sir Elton John should have thought of that before blaming her!
She might have been lipsyncing with this one but shes the absolute BOMB! Im sorry to say but even poor MJ could have learnt a thing or two from Madge. Gym fit, healthy, macro-biotic and drug free. The only thing Madonna is addicted to is music and touring!
Madonna at her absolute best. Proof she is not just business savy but a true artist in which critics fail to see. Hopefully now that she is free of warner she will release material like this. Madonna and Mirwais together were so advanced in their thinking partially while the album bombed. American Life was one of her greatest works in her career.
Le't not overeact here. This performance was very good, but it wasn't born out of genius. She had better performances. Plus a real genius wouldn't have lipsynched this song. Wouldn't have been too hard to sing this song live.
It wasnt until I heard of Madonna that my life completely change. When i bought the american life album i was so into it that i actually reinvented myself. Lost 70 pounds, changed my agttitude. learned only i can make mysaelf happy for who i am. I wish i could actually eet her in person and thank her.
@kbamchrepavian Wow! Congrats on your own reinvention!! I know, I wish I could meet her too. She inspired me so much and gives me so much strengh it's magical! American Life it's a very powerful record. xx
@kbamchrepavian I reinvented myself as well. I too would love the chance to meet her and thank her for all that she does and how much she inspires me, And for all her wonderful wonderful music that has helped me during hard times in my ife.. Even if I was having a bad day I would play some Madonna and feel at ease.
@kbamchrepavian wow! i thought I was the only one!.... my first album was american life and then everything changed..... I was 14 and I also re-invented myself! thank you for sharing your story.
'nobody knows me' is one of my favorites (especially the 'american life' version). Her performance of this song during her Re-Invention Tour is quintessential MADONNA and is a work of art! Can someone get a message to Madonna if she would ever consider a theme
Incredible perfomance,incredible moves and Madonna of course...I can`t understand how can anyone dare to compare with such artist as Mariah or Dion-sorry,but it`s very stupid-it`s impossible to compare-Madonna will always be THE ONE
People! You need to stop comparing artists! Madonna vs. Kylie is an impossible comparison. They're NOTHING like each other. Besides... They are terrific friends - Kylie did her version of 'Vogue' and Madonna carried a t-shirt that said 'Kylie' on it.
@oscar: No, unfortunately there is no dvd of the full show out there. But maybe in future as part of a boxset or something...in BluRay...well wishful thinking.
Yes, there is one. A New York show has been recorded unofficially, the audio quality is acceptable and the video is good too (it was taken from the screens). I used to saw it very often at the street markets here in México. Hope you can find it in your country!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
... and Kylie doesnt treat her fans like shit. Madonna does and the funny thing is - her fans like it. Kylie is interacting all the time with her fans (in a nice way) and you can always see it in her face how much fun she has. For Madonna its pretty much a job and thats all.
Fair enough.Good that you have your own opinion.Now..I don't mean to be mean, but why have you even logged in onto 'cold bitch' site when you don't like her. I have never been on i.e.Kylie's site as have no desire to slam her or anyone in front of her fans. What's the point? Why would I search for artist I dislike?...? It would be just wasting of my time.And I don't waste my time.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I watch her stuff from time to time cos I tried to understand why the people are so crazy about her, the whole madonna hype, the "queen" of pop etc. I just tried to take a look behind all that. I saw clips where Madonna shouts the F word and other nasty things to her fans. I saw a clip where she first ask the people what she should sing now and then she said: Im the queen - nobody tells me what do to etc. Her attitude sucks and Im happy for Guy Richie. Must be terrible being married with her.
and, I have seen a 'cold treating of fans' before and the artist was not Madonna. Madonna interacted with her fans in a lovely way on her London's gig where I was present. And don't say she is cold and it's just a job for her. You don't know her.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
... and I tried to unterstand why people always say Kylie is a cheap copy of Madonna. She isnt! I did not see many things they have in common. Im glad about it.. but hey - thanks for your comments.
I think you should watch some of her stuff like GET STUPID marvaleuos piece of work btw which says so much about her... Can't think of any other artist being as caring as Madonna. And also, you mentioned that her last 2 albums were not very deep. I am actually convinced that her last albums have a lot to do with a life philosophy. So disagree again with you... But, yeah, pleasure is internally mine.
and Kylie doesnt treat her fans like shit. Madonna does and the funny thing is - her fans like it. Kylie is interacting all the time with her fans (in a nice way) and you can always see it in her face how much fun she has. For Madonna its pretty much a job and thats all.
yeah, madonna is more seductive. she's like an empress on war. authoritative. a commander. she is not dapperly, you know, like a pretty nice girl you can handle around. not that she has a voice let's say like shirley bassey or what ever. but she has a royal appearance. she browbeats, and we like it..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
madonna is known for using a LOT of playback in her "live" shows!! i dont care if they MAYBE add some audio stuff for the dvd etc. i can tell you some other songs where she did full or half playback. i expect a bit more from the "queen of pop" how you people call her all the time. glad we have Kylie Minogue - the pop goddess. Great LIVE shows, nice personality, awesome songs, good live singing. Kylie rocks!
Kylie being a nice and lovely person is one thing (which i agree) but the depth of her lyrics and her music on the whole is the other thing...Sorry but she is a mature singer but her music is far too empty and souless, no depth at all. It hurts me listening stuff from Kylie or even Byonce. Its so so empty...very materialistic. But fair enough we all are at the diffrent levels so we all crave for something else. Madonna's music feeds my soul perfectly. She's the living legend and I love her.
Kylie being a nice and lovely person is one thing (which i agree) but the depth of her lyrics and her music on the whole is the other thing...Sorry but she is a mature singer but her music is far too empty and souless, no depth at all. It hurts me listening stuff from Kylie or even Byonce. Its so so empty...very materialistic. But fair enough we all are at the diffrent levels so we all crave for something else. Madonna's music feeds my soul perfectly. She's the living legend and I love her.
Yes I agree with the point that Madonnas lyrics (not from the last 2 albums) are deeper and many times she tried to bring a serious message across but thats why I consider Kylie as more "pop". Kylies music is fun and catchy and thats what real pop music is about. The lyrics are not what Kylies music is about even though some her songs have a generell message. I have to say that Kylie sings with more emotions even her "shallow" songs. Kylie is a good live singer. Madonna sings pretty hard & cold.
you moron, this performance was live! this clip is from the dvd, and on the dvd they never put the audio from the live performance, because there are thousands of prople screaming. you wouldn't hear a thing. they probably added the audio from the rehearsals (maybe, i don't know). have you been to her concerts? it' 100% live.
All right Madonna / best song of the 21st century/ 3rd Millennium / 16,000,000,000TH YEAR! WILL YOU PLEASE MARRY ME?? SIGNED ETERNAL INFINITE ANTI CHRIST CAPTAIN COSMOS ... AT YOUR SERVICE 001000101000...I LOVE YOU MORE THAN THE UNIVERSE ITSELF, I CAN REALLY TOTALLY RELATE TO YOUR SONG, YOUR THE BEST !!!
I LOVE YOUR STYLES AND HOW YOU'VE RECREATED YOURSELF OVER THE YEARS! ARE YOU MARRIED OR SINGLE OR BOTH? I'M HEAD OVER HEELS FOR U MADONNA! YAHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO1
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ok kylie isnt dancing like madonna but i really prefer the natural moves during a song and kylie has it. im not a huge fan of choreography... and like i said: playback on a live tour is a NO GO. its ok when the madonna fans accept it. paying lots of money of her tickets and seeing her doing playback in more than 1 song. i had the chance to see madonna live for free and I said NO.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
yes she has that electronic stuff in some songs but I still think this is full playback. same like - die another day - this "live" tour was full of playback songs...thats why elton john and many more were complaining. even madonna said she used playback in some songs for this tour. whatever the reason are. for me its not acceptable.
Sorry, but I missly spammed you... where did she say it? Can you put a link?
And I usually say these times: Tori Amos isn't lipsynching, but playing completely different setlist each time. Of course her dancing "skills" are terrible, she says :D.
Do u really think that there is someone in this world who can do such a great show without playbacking sometimes?? And if you look at other female pop-artists, she doesn't even playback half as much as them.
... playback on a live tour!! thats a huge NO GO!!! I dont care about the dancing! kylie never does playback on her live tours. she dances and sings very well!!
allright, Kylie and dancing?? R U KIDDIN ME?? I really likes kylie, im a big kylie fan, but she only dances when she's not singnin. (exlcuding confide in my at homecoming)
this is not playback. on her tour she sung live, but the clip is from the dvd, where they add a different audio, not that from the real show, becuse there are thousands of people screaming.
I´m sure someone else will buy the ticket just to listen to her acting "live", and of course every concert will be sold out and she will sell millions of CD´s and make enormous amounts of cash, but still she is lipsinging
Madonna is Real Queen
madyerotica 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Real music fans know that Madonna is the queen of pop & music in general. Fuck gaga & her retarded fans.
ITSTHRILLERTIME 1 month ago
THE ONLY QUEEN.. FOREVER
OSKARMADY1 1 month ago
"And I've realized, how many times I've diiiiied" *beat CLAP beat beat* ...FUKN LUUUUV IIIIIIIIIT
domytube 2 months ago
I know you Madonna....very talentued video...thanks
winston1319 3 months ago
Just love it
GArbedg 3 months ago 3
God?
123456789derts 4 months ago
Nobody fuckers!!!..
ICONVIP 7 months ago 3
With just walk. Madonna has style and power
pablodela41 8 months ago 17
@pablodela41 hell yeah see does, just here presence commands respect and attention !!!
beer87music 1 month ago
@beer87music oh yeah. Queen of music
pablodela41 1 month ago
she is amazing.
d3blh01 9 months ago 3
This album is IMO her greatest work. I love her past stuff, but this was so different from her. The only reason people didn't like it was because when you think of Madonna, you think upbeat dance music, but American Life wasn't a typical Madonna album. Deserved a grammy nod somewhere.
mikeparez 9 months ago 4
I saw this live in Las Vegas back on May 30th, 2004...it was a Sunday. AND Madonna blew us the f*ck away!!!! She rocked our asses off, what a great show. Thank you, Madonna, for always giving us your very best. Lots of love from Texas.
cl0ser2g0d 9 months ago
My Love planetary artist, I love You //;)
toshiba6079 9 months ago
is the whole concert on the "i'm going to tell you a secret" dvd? this has to be my favorite tour from her next to "blonde ambition"
Plumpy14 11 months ago
WTF IS GAGA!?? O.o ... o wait Madonna and her dancers did said to what group "IT" belongs at the very beginning :)
germanga89 11 months ago
Can't say she changed me at all but what I can say is that I appreciate the artistry in her music.
moodyblue1964 11 months ago
LOVE IT HONEY GOD OPEN MY DOOR WITH MADONNA THEN HE OPE IT WITH BRITNEY SPEARS BABY HATERS HATE CAUSE U ALL LOOK LIKE SHIT FANS GO MY CHANNEL U SEE DALE DANCING AT BRITNEY CIRCUS TOUR
spearsdoesitbetter 1 year ago
"Sorry Ass Mother Fuckers" Madonna Forever..
plugtop0000 1 year ago
can somebody say me what she said in the begging of the video...did she say " serbia suck" or i understud wrong xD
pls tell
TheMadonnaPOPqueen 1 year ago
@TheMadonnaPOPqueen No, they actually said "sorry-ass motherf___ers!" :)
MrPetiiii 1 year ago
@MrPetiiii oh...i'm better now xD
thanks and madonna rules !!!!
TheMadonnaPOPqueen 1 year ago
The end is so magical
MrKremlin 1 year ago
shes so amazing x_x a nice production !!
MrKremlin 1 year ago
Doesnt matter how old she is it matters that she inspires everyone, and to let them enjoy and make them selfs and other people happy. Madonna is a bg role model but still she swears >.< GO MADONNA :D
MrHimey 1 year ago
THERE IS ONLY ONE...AND SHE IS MADONNA
JOELIFIQUEISION 1 year ago
THERE IS ONLY ONE....AND SHE IS MADONNA
JOELIFIQUEISION 1 year ago
Q U E E N O F P O P
baroondiwand 1 year ago
i didnt like the RIT it seemed forced and rushed madonna didnt really sing live and the staging was weird the Confessions Tour was awsome
rocky362 1 year ago
@rocky362 I totally diagree and feel it was her best. I think it was a good "overall" Madonna tour, while Confessions was more in tune to that specific album.
BrandonLori 1 year ago
@rocky362 On most of the reinvention tour clips i've seen online, she definitely does sing live on most of the songs.
MrBurritoSupreme 1 year ago
I WORSHIP HER!!!
Nemiah 1 year ago
I LOVE the end!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! wow wow wow!!!
kokapejote 1 year ago
Awesome! Madonna is the greatest live performer in existence! X
RichardPears 1 year ago 2
INSPIRATION
slivasiul 1 year ago
i\I like her 80's music best.
But most of her stuff is more than decent. She's good.
selemawit14 1 year ago
this performance has one of the best choreography ive ever seen in a show.
ricky8541 1 year ago 2
This is my song. She's awesome.
selemawit14 1 year ago 3
:)LINDA
madonacicone 1 year ago
"I... I sleep much better at night. I feel closer to the light. Now I'm gonna try. To improve my life..."
alfaceandrice 1 year ago
Madonna has inspired me so much. I wish I could thank her. She has taught me to never let anyone tell u No u cant do something, Do as u feel and say as u feel.
abe1289 1 year ago
yo estube en ese concierto,fue IMPRESIONANTE!! como todo lo q nos ofrece madonna.
elijacko 1 year ago
magnificaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
musicainferno 1 year ago
Awesome song:)
sweetsugar191 1 year ago
Do you want her to sing or to dance?????
Dont be stupids, she cant do both.
SHE IS THE BEST
pablorubiolugo 1 year ago 3
@kbamchrepavian-I think that it is so beautiful how she inspired you! She has done the same for me for so many years but when i heard the song Jump it totally changed my life. I am now doing what i always wanted because of how much that song spoke to me. Don't ever under estimate the power of music!
solansdaddy 1 year ago
ABSOLUTELY LIPSYNGING!
zeque7 1 year ago
@zeque7 of coarse. The point was to keep the vocal effects of the cd version which are hard to produce live but she sang live on most of the tracks on this tour.
MrBurritoSupreme 1 year ago
always I´m right .. this song is madonna
NoConfidential4U 1 year ago
c vrai personne ne la connait :-) à mon plus grand regret moi non plus :-( fais pas partie de ses intimes hi hi
paranaguaboy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
na take madonna as a serious soul, way back ago she wore a t shirt preach 'it takes 20 dumb animals to make a fur coat but only 1 to wear it' now da lowlife bitch pays dem big bucks to support the enslaving, torturing an skinning alive of gods creatures for her false vanity, check da fur farm vidz on youtube 2 c wot she tinks is acceptable to promote in 21st century, fur an fur trim b da height of lowlife taste, kabbalah, is a joke. check 'ANTI FUR SOCIETY' on google, SEE DA TRUTH 4 YA SELVES
misstowerofpower 2 years ago
when an artist dont need too much of production in a performance, you know that he's gdefinitely great.
betto1305 2 years ago
No official DVD has been released yet, but video footage of the show - including this video - can be found in the "I'm going to tell you a secret" documentary DVD.
MrBstranger 2 years ago
this tour is on DVD?
AnastaciaBoy 2 years ago
It's so obvious she's lipsynching here, just like she did with Vogue and Die Another Day during the Reinvention Tour, but that's only because of the demanding choreography and after all it's ok to lipsynch only 3 or 4 songs, when you dance the whole 2-hour show. Sir Elton John should have thought of that before blaming her!
MrBstranger 2 years ago 4
@MrBstranger BUT IN ''DIE ANOTHER DAY'' SHE WASN'T LIPSYNCHING :D
RikardoVeintidos 2 years ago
I love too much this video. It shows that Madonna is a great artist, she has a complete show: a mix between plays and songs!
joannessouza 2 years ago
She might have been lipsyncing with this one but shes the absolute BOMB! Im sorry to say but even poor MJ could have learnt a thing or two from Madge. Gym fit, healthy, macro-biotic and drug free. The only thing Madonna is addicted to is music and touring!
Gordo80 2 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
I love this song!
DevinHolliger 2 years ago 2
This song is so soulful, this is how you make electronica soulful, powerful lyrics, love it Madge!!!
atgny 2 years ago 3
Now i can really understand that song
mediasansnom 2 years ago
Madonna at her absolute best. Proof she is not just business savy but a true artist in which critics fail to see. Hopefully now that she is free of warner she will release material like this. Madonna and Mirwais together were so advanced in their thinking partially while the album bombed. American Life was one of her greatest works in her career.
veradodawg 2 years ago 6
..that "someone to admire" part is so brilliant. it's my favorite part.
thisrainykitten 2 years ago 18
Love it. Love her.
BluerumorLisAnna 2 years ago 9
Incredible, inspiring, innovative.
leewhite1988 2 years ago 12
woooow! the song is actualy not that strong but she blew us away with this performance. It's so strong and genius.
leander1991 2 years ago 8
Absolute genius, pure art, phenomenal..words can't describe how amazing this performance is.
SuperHollywoods 2 years ago 7
I so agree with you I could watch this for a million years and still be amazed and inspired by it
vinilla 2 years ago 6
Yeah, I could, too, I thought I was the only one who watched this over and over and even when I am sad it kind of cheers me up.
thisrainykitten 2 years ago 4
me too! it's full of energy. I watch it whenever I feel down and tired ^^
linhNeo 2 years ago 4
This is a performance born out of complete genius. It is absolutely amazing and such a piece of art!
SuperHollywoods 2 years ago 5
Le't not overeact here. This performance was very good, but it wasn't born out of genius. She had better performances. Plus a real genius wouldn't have lipsynched this song. Wouldn't have been too hard to sing this song live.
treg1980 2 years ago 4
i love the lyrics to this song, btw is she lipzinching or did they made her voice sound electronic.
ricky8541 2 years ago 2
Nope, she was lipsinching.
treg1980 2 years ago 2
won't let a stranger give me a SOCIAL DISEASE
tchetjelly 2 years ago 6
"Why should I care what the world thinks of me" thats it M, keep doing your thing! Dont listen to the haters, baby. :)
mlccharlottex 2 years ago 4
Madonna es una reina del pop es la mejor indiscutible.
juanpis1991 2 years ago
Everybody knows her and love her :)
makepeaceful 2 years ago
OMG Madonna is the best I love her so much!
BlueWaterloo 2 years ago 10
It wasnt until I heard of Madonna that my life completely change. When i bought the american life album i was so into it that i actually reinvented myself. Lost 70 pounds, changed my agttitude. learned only i can make mysaelf happy for who i am. I wish i could actually eet her in person and thank her.
kbamchrepavian 2 years ago 98
American life is impecable
pablorubiolugo 1 year ago 3
@kbamchrepavian hahah i love it!! everybody re-inventionyourself!!!
god blessss madonna !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
france love madonna
TheJasonciccone 1 year ago
@kbamchrepavian Wow! Congrats on your own reinvention!! I know, I wish I could meet her too. She inspired me so much and gives me so much strengh it's magical! American Life it's a very powerful record. xx
lambgd 1 year ago
dumb
ha BORING
sickstunner 1 year ago
@kbamchrepavian I reinvented myself as well. I too would love the chance to meet her and thank her for all that she does and how much she inspires me, And for all her wonderful wonderful music that has helped me during hard times in my ife.. Even if I was having a bad day I would play some Madonna and feel at ease.
abe1289 1 year ago
@kbamchrepavian wow! i thought I was the only one!.... my first album was american life and then everything changed..... I was 14 and I also re-invented myself! thank you for sharing your story.
dumbasaboxofhair 11 months ago
@kbamchrepavian Thats very nice. IM so happy Madonna was the lady who made you change.
madonnabiggestfan 11 months ago
'nobody knows me' is one of my favorites (especially the 'american life' version). Her performance of this song during her Re-Invention Tour is quintessential MADONNA and is a work of art! Can someone get a message to Madonna if she would ever consider a theme
'Planetary Healing'
for a future tour?
Love you Madonna,
In Light & Love,
Kavika
kavika121 2 years ago
Nobody knows her...
She's an enigma-
The world's most talented enigma.
ogosh25 2 years ago 10
and perfect it...
luciannopoa1 2 years ago
Even thoguh her voice is electronically changed it is still somehow RAW! The lyrics r just genious! and the perfromance amazing.
kbamch92 2 years ago 6
Queen of Pop! Great as always! No doubt about that!
Pauvredia 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I dont like maddona even a litle , i only like a few of her songs.
OverpowerLoL1 2 years ago
She's incredible. Masterful editing job too.
WrigleyRue 2 years ago 7
One of the best performances i've EVER seen, She is the Queen, no doubt.
judasmartinez 2 years ago 7
great performance but she is nto singing....
LiviaOravska 2 years ago
so what? she lyp sincs only 4 songs on this concert. everything else is live. she respects her audience.
whateverdv 2 years ago
I love this song and performance!! xx
cyberaga20 2 years ago 5
this is a fucking great performance.
kuykee 2 years ago 13
OMG! AMEN right?? was soo happy I'd see it live!!
strobe155 2 years ago
Brillant.. member this very well in Slaine Castle.. Fab tune :)
plugtop0000 2 years ago
so simple, so perfect¡¡¡
excelent coreografy, camon madonna¡¡¡¡
buu britney
retronano 2 years ago 6
buu britney?
cambiodenick 2 years ago 4
Nobody knows me. -relV
relV6 2 years ago 2
It´s so wonderful
no doubt the re-invention tour
is one of the bests!!
tamay1794 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"Live" means that she was alive on stage, miming to her CD, right?
niconico00 3 years ago
lol, yes, actually she lypsinches in 3 songs from this tour... but to be fair she danced her ass off in those songs so it's ok.
FighterMoody 2 years ago 7
What songs were they. Im guessing its this one, and vogue, but whats the other one?
-Madge ftw
Crazycatperson66 2 years ago
die another day is the other one.
FighterMoody 2 years ago
"Live" means like a performers there performing live, in front of a live crowd. Doing whatever they do, even if it's blowing bubbles... lolz.
<3
Rawbie 2 years ago 8
WOOOW!! Madonna is the best!
Chamo333 3 years ago 29
Incredible perfomance,incredible moves and Madonna of course...I can`t understand how can anyone dare to compare with such artist as Mariah or Dion-sorry,but it`s very stupid-it`s impossible to compare-Madonna will always be THE ONE
loganutis 3 years ago 16
agree
Mariah and Celine sucks
Madonna is the queen!
davidvonbarany 2 years ago 27
right on.
theyre alright but minimal compared
to the Queen.
PunkLatino 2 years ago 3
@davidvonbarany just are diferent... madonna is cool but never could sing like Mariah or Celine
EvoShomar 3 months ago
@davidvonbarany
Madonna, Mariah and Celine are all fantastic and great!!!! Nowadays music industry is about autotune and fake music: Kesha, Rihanna, Britney, etc.
Don't hate Celine or Mariah! They were great. They made quality music! But nowadays...
ziggzaggboy 3 months ago
Fucking awesome!
BrandonLori 3 years ago 7
love the graphics ...and Madonna!!!!!!
demco27 3 years ago 7
She's a gorgeous, brilliant, and very very talented artist and business woman.
king5cobra5 3 years ago 5
"it's so hard to find someone to admire"
BUT we can admire her
madonna 4ever
vogueconfessions 3 years ago 9
TOTALLY!!
zh95 3 years ago
fucking fantastic!!!!
I LOVE THIS song!!! It's soo much better on the tour than on the American Life album.. so much more PUNCH!!!
She looks SO hot !!! and FIERCE!!
LOVE YOU SO MUCH MADONNA!!!
PLEEEEASEE COME TO AUSTRALIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!!
christianlinardon 3 years ago 4
and what if it's not live???
this is a show!!!
and it's fantastic
nobody of the "modern" performers can do a show like this
and she did it without dancers( it's just gorgeous)
vogueconfessions 3 years ago 3
She ´s definitly best in this show and music businness,
tonkanao160 3 years ago
It doesn't matter what people think of madonna...shes the queen bee!!!! the best!!!
lagrimasxdexoro 3 years ago 2
madonna is great, luv her!!!!
kevinbycanon 3 years ago
bow down to the queen...
anatotallycrazy 3 years ago 3
People! You need to stop comparing artists! Madonna vs. Kylie is an impossible comparison. They're NOTHING like each other. Besides... They are terrific friends - Kylie did her version of 'Vogue' and Madonna carried a t-shirt that said 'Kylie' on it.
madonnaforever123 3 years ago 6
the one and only queen of pop beyond compare.........lav ya madge
stormsignal09 3 years ago
does anyone knows if there's a dvd of the show??, i mean besides of im going to tell you a secret.. a dvd with the full concert??
oscar210590 3 years ago
@oscar: No, unfortunately there is no dvd of the full show out there. But maybe in future as part of a boxset or something...in BluRay...well wishful thinking.
DagIN 3 years ago
Yes, there is one. A New York show has been recorded unofficially, the audio quality is acceptable and the video is good too (it was taken from the screens). I used to saw it very often at the street markets here in México. Hope you can find it in your country!
villanueva64 3 years ago
If ya guys hated her so much..
why do ya open this video.. DUMB ASS
jlonash 3 years ago
Yehaaaa
jlonash 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I used to love Madonna's music but now...
This is not music! It's just computer generated toons, an egoist woman's tool to self-expression.
larvinc 3 years ago
WOWISTHEWORLDNOW:
You think that for madonna this is just a job?
It's obvious you know nothing about her.
She only cares about sharing light
relV6 3 years ago
who fuckin cares abt kylie she is not aNything here in North america she is too girlly gal i like more chanllengin like madge
AFGRULZ26 3 years ago 2
Fucking EPIC!
itone 3 years ago 2
me encanta ese video
thebeasthideme 3 years ago 2
Is she not just the sexiest thing on the planet?!
alanphysio 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no.....
brazilianaffair 3 years ago
yes =)
Hrmad 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
... and Kylie doesnt treat her fans like shit. Madonna does and the funny thing is - her fans like it. Kylie is interacting all the time with her fans (in a nice way) and you can always see it in her face how much fun she has. For Madonna its pretty much a job and thats all.
Melancholio74 3 years ago
Fair enough.Good that you have your own opinion.Now..I don't mean to be mean, but why have you even logged in onto 'cold bitch' site when you don't like her. I have never been on i.e.Kylie's site as have no desire to slam her or anyone in front of her fans. What's the point? Why would I search for artist I dislike?...? It would be just wasting of my time.And I don't waste my time.
ipraythatsth 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I watch her stuff from time to time cos I tried to understand why the people are so crazy about her, the whole madonna hype, the "queen" of pop etc. I just tried to take a look behind all that. I saw clips where Madonna shouts the F word and other nasty things to her fans. I saw a clip where she first ask the people what she should sing now and then she said: Im the queen - nobody tells me what do to etc. Her attitude sucks and Im happy for Guy Richie. Must be terrible being married with her.
Melancholio74 3 years ago
and, I have seen a 'cold treating of fans' before and the artist was not Madonna. Madonna interacted with her fans in a lovely way on her London's gig where I was present. And don't say she is cold and it's just a job for her. You don't know her.
ipraythatsth 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
... and I tried to unterstand why people always say Kylie is a cheap copy of Madonna. She isnt! I did not see many things they have in common. Im glad about it.. but hey - thanks for your comments.
Melancholio74 3 years ago
I think you should watch some of her stuff like GET STUPID marvaleuos piece of work btw which says so much about her... Can't think of any other artist being as caring as Madonna. And also, you mentioned that her last 2 albums were not very deep. I am actually convinced that her last albums have a lot to do with a life philosophy. So disagree again with you... But, yeah, pleasure is internally mine.
ipraythatsth 3 years ago
and Kylie doesnt treat her fans like shit. Madonna does and the funny thing is - her fans like it. Kylie is interacting all the time with her fans (in a nice way) and you can always see it in her face how much fun she has. For Madonna its pretty much a job and thats all.
( are you an idiot?)
WOWISTHEWORLDNOW 3 years ago
they are totally different
I like Kylie also but she only writes about 50% of her songs, while Madonna writes 80-90% of them
I mean they have the basic idea for their songs
and Kylie is charming, but Madonna is ... a bit more serious
and I don't think she is treating us in a bad way
but if you want to see someone treating her fans in a very-very good way, then be a Tori Amos fan :)
she'll do Can't Get You Out of My Head piano solo for you :D
davidvonbarany 2 years ago 6
yeah, madonna is more seductive. she's like an empress on war. authoritative. a commander. she is not dapperly, you know, like a pretty nice girl you can handle around. not that she has a voice let's say like shirley bassey or what ever. but she has a royal appearance. she browbeats, and we like it..
carryall69 2 years ago 4
P L A Y B A C K
ErmoReno90 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
madonna is known for using a LOT of playback in her "live" shows!! i dont care if they MAYBE add some audio stuff for the dvd etc. i can tell you some other songs where she did full or half playback. i expect a bit more from the "queen of pop" how you people call her all the time. glad we have Kylie Minogue - the pop goddess. Great LIVE shows, nice personality, awesome songs, good live singing. Kylie rocks!
Melancholio74 3 years ago
Kylie being a nice and lovely person is one thing (which i agree) but the depth of her lyrics and her music on the whole is the other thing...Sorry but she is a mature singer but her music is far too empty and souless, no depth at all. It hurts me listening stuff from Kylie or even Byonce. Its so so empty...very materialistic. But fair enough we all are at the diffrent levels so we all crave for something else. Madonna's music feeds my soul perfectly. She's the living legend and I love her.
ipraythatsth 3 years ago
Kylie being a nice and lovely person is one thing (which i agree) but the depth of her lyrics and her music on the whole is the other thing...Sorry but she is a mature singer but her music is far too empty and souless, no depth at all. It hurts me listening stuff from Kylie or even Byonce. Its so so empty...very materialistic. But fair enough we all are at the diffrent levels so we all crave for something else. Madonna's music feeds my soul perfectly. She's the living legend and I love her.
ipraythatsth 3 years ago
Yes I agree with the point that Madonnas lyrics (not from the last 2 albums) are deeper and many times she tried to bring a serious message across but thats why I consider Kylie as more "pop". Kylies music is fun and catchy and thats what real pop music is about. The lyrics are not what Kylies music is about even though some her songs have a generell message. I have to say that Kylie sings with more emotions even her "shallow" songs. Kylie is a good live singer. Madonna sings pretty hard & cold.
Melancholio74 3 years ago
who cares if this is live.. this perfomance is amazing
aleal31 3 years ago 4
Brillant. love this video.
plugtop0000 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Madonna mimed through the whole 'live ' performance,,,, what a fake
jetstreme 3 years ago
you moron, this performance was live! this clip is from the dvd, and on the dvd they never put the audio from the live performance, because there are thousands of prople screaming. you wouldn't hear a thing. they probably added the audio from the rehearsals (maybe, i don't know). have you been to her concerts? it' 100% live.
NikitaRomania 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Isn't this song a copy of Marilyn Manson's The Nobodies?
umadoshikakko 3 years ago
All right Madonna / best song of the 21st century/ 3rd Millennium / 16,000,000,000TH YEAR! WILL YOU PLEASE MARRY ME?? SIGNED ETERNAL INFINITE ANTI CHRIST CAPTAIN COSMOS ... AT YOUR SERVICE 001000101000...I LOVE YOU MORE THAN THE UNIVERSE ITSELF, I CAN REALLY TOTALLY RELATE TO YOUR SONG, YOUR THE BEST !!!
I LOVE YOUR STYLES AND HOW YOU'VE RECREATED YOURSELF OVER THE YEARS! ARE YOU MARRIED OR SINGLE OR BOTH? I'M HEAD OVER HEELS FOR U MADONNA! YAHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO1
borislueck 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ok kylie isnt dancing like madonna but i really prefer the natural moves during a song and kylie has it. im not a huge fan of choreography... and like i said: playback on a live tour is a NO GO. its ok when the madonna fans accept it. paying lots of money of her tickets and seeing her doing playback in more than 1 song. i had the chance to see madonna live for free and I said NO.
Melancholio74 3 years ago
I don`t want no lies
I don`t watch T.V.
I don`t waste my time
Don`t read a magazine
JtothaLO4ever 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yes she has that electronic stuff in some songs but I still think this is full playback. same like - die another day - this "live" tour was full of playback songs...thats why elton john and many more were complaining. even madonna said she used playback in some songs for this tour. whatever the reason are. for me its not acceptable.
Melancholio74 3 years ago
Sorry, but I missly spammed you... where did she say it? Can you put a link?
And I usually say these times: Tori Amos isn't lipsynching, but playing completely different setlist each time. Of course her dancing "skills" are terrible, she says :D.
davidvonbarany 3 years ago
Do u really think that there is someone in this world who can do such a great show without playbacking sometimes?? And if you look at other female pop-artists, she doesn't even playback half as much as them.
luluvisch 3 years ago
... playback on a live tour!! thats a huge NO GO!!! I dont care about the dancing! kylie never does playback on her live tours. she dances and sings very well!!
Melancholio74 3 years ago
allright, Kylie and dancing?? R U KIDDIN ME?? I really likes kylie, im a big kylie fan, but she only dances when she's not singnin. (exlcuding confide in my at homecoming)
luluvisch 3 years ago
this is not playback. on her tour she sung live, but the clip is from the dvd, where they add a different audio, not that from the real show, becuse there are thousands of people screaming.
NikitaRomania 3 years ago 4
doing some songs full playback on a live tour is poor. queen of pop? queen of playback? LOL... madonna cant live with the F word? why?
Melancholio74 3 years ago
it is not playback
she is having electronic sound enchanment things
why she has one for this song is a wonder... on the album she has for the Mother and Father
davidvonbarany 3 years ago
OMG amo Madonna hace uno shows grandiosos prefiero verlas asi super cool con espectaculo que verla desafinar como otras artitas
fearswhithin 3 years ago
I´m sure someone else will buy the ticket just to listen to her acting "live", and of course every concert will be sold out and she will sell millions of CD´s and make enormous amounts of cash, but still she is lipsinging
sahuarokid 3 years ago