Sadly, it was her brother and Alexander Schmorell that wrote most of the material, and put in most of the work; but it's Sophie that is remembered more. I don't think being a woman is enough to be granted more credit than she deserves, but that's how our society works I guess.
@daFattylover It's not because she's a woman, it's because of her attitude during these interrogations and her process. She was the last who confessed of the arrested and tried to take all the guilt to herself to protect her brother, the others and Christoph Probst, who was a father. It's right, Sophie made lowest effort in the white rose, but she didn't even try to pretend to be innocent or not involved when she was arrested, but was willing to die. I admire her. Btw: I'm german.
@daFattylover I think because she had such a limited inputted and yet still was executed is the reason why her story is so strong from her and the words she speaks will highlight The White Rose so that its never forgotten, all that were in the movement are to be remembered. Even though people see her part being small in the story in hindsight it was bigger then anything for what she said to the judge and to the policeman for she has made people think.
This is a great movie. Impressive and excellently played and directed. However, I do not think that the nazis wasted the time to talk to her or leat her speak up her ideas. I think that all behaved like the judge who convicted all of them without letting them say anything.
@WehrmachtFeldwebel Sadly the real lame hippies hide behind a computer screen. Many of us, knowing the consequences, wouldn't have the guts to do what Miss Scholl, her Brother and assistants did. May they R.I.P.
@AngelBiLove I'm sorry, please explain your comment. To me it would appear that you're implying that "creationists" originated in America? That can't possibly be what you mean...
The 3 "Battle Of Stalingrad" videos in the favorites of your channel are BLOCKED IN GERMANY - for good reasons.
You cannot manipulate me, silly bitch + it´s not your business if i have to put down a beer or not.
Your"answer"is the usual "way" of hidden fascists trying to manipulate other people who don´t want to have anything to do with your silly state of mind+weird hysterical"arguments".
Do me a favor+fuck off, you seem to have enough problems with your own idiotic Hitleristic manias.
Das Sophie Scholl ist ein echter deutscher held, den kampf gegen die unterdrückung der berüchtigten Nazis. Ruhe in frieden Sophie . Gott segne . =) . Lolol Ima German-Norwegian living in Canada, tell me how my German was . Prolly bad ! xD .
You are a narcissistic problem in yourself+trying to impose other persons with silly idle "arguments".
"Good looks"combined with religious demagogy are not everything+this is something you cannot realize.
There are millions of methods of fascists and ideologists to "impress" other people whom they think they are superior to, but in the end always their BARE LIES will "shine" through.
I can see your eyes and i know how they want to manipulate.
Once again: The "apostle" Paul (Book Of Galatians) was mostly a purely hideous dishonest fascist + modeled early Christianity at his own crazy personal totalitarian will + nothing else.
The tragedy of early Christians is that they fell victim to this manipulating totalitarian madman.
And no further comment now, only that Sophie Scholl or her comrades were certainly not adherents of the awfully hating scriptures of "Saint" Paul - an evil demagogue who could have also defended Hitler.
@gfks11 People think that this kind of "bureaucratic" supidities are not happening anymore!!!???!!! Unfortunately when you stand up for your ideas or when you are witness of grave injustice...they can make your life miserable and it can take a very long time to repair the damages!!! I know it by experience!!! Corrupted Power is Hell on earth!!! Kiss!!! Johanne (please excuse my english..i am french)
Ich habe den Film bei den „Deutschen Kulturtagen in der Ukraine“ geguckt. Ich erinnere mich daran, dass ich nach der Filmvorführung gezittert habe... Warum? Weil das kein Film war… Das war das LEBEN.
Man soll das betonen, dass die Weltgeschichte das Leben war/ist. Nicht von irgendwelchen abstrakten Leuten, aber von den realen Leuten. Es gibt keine abstrakten Leute.
---Das Wertvolle ist in kleiner Menge, aber das zählt sehr viel…
was known by his colleagues and enemies alike as a true German soldier and one of the few in the entire war to show respect to his enemies . He was respected by such people as Churchill and Patton . When a plot to assasinate Rommel failed and the assasins were killed he ordered them buried with full military honours . He also refused to deport the Jewish populations in the areas where he commanded, even writing back to Hitler in protest .
She was and is the symbol of a true Germany . A free and prosperous Germany reborn from the ashes of the defeat and despair of WW1 and WW2 . She and many other honourable Germans like her showed the rest of the world that not all of Germany was nazi . She will forever be remembered as a beacon of light to all mankind and as a defender against the immoral and atrocious acts that were taking place all around her . She's one of my favorites alongside the leader of the Afrika Korp Erwin Rommel who
Sadly, it was her brother and Alexander Schmorell that wrote most of the material, and put in most of the work; but it's Sophie that is remembered more. I don't think being a woman is enough to be granted more credit than she deserves, but that's how our society works I guess.
daFattylover 4 weeks ago
@daFattylover It's not because she's a woman, it's because of her attitude during these interrogations and her process. She was the last who confessed of the arrested and tried to take all the guilt to herself to protect her brother, the others and Christoph Probst, who was a father. It's right, Sophie made lowest effort in the white rose, but she didn't even try to pretend to be innocent or not involved when she was arrested, but was willing to die. I admire her. Btw: I'm german.
TheScylla666 2 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
@daFattylover I think because she had such a limited inputted and yet still was executed is the reason why her story is so strong from her and the words she speaks will highlight The White Rose so that its never forgotten, all that were in the movement are to be remembered. Even though people see her part being small in the story in hindsight it was bigger then anything for what she said to the judge and to the policeman for she has made people think.
cherrytopx 2 weeks ago
This is a great movie. Impressive and excellently played and directed. However, I do not think that the nazis wasted the time to talk to her or leat her speak up her ideas. I think that all behaved like the judge who convicted all of them without letting them say anything.
AliciaDupres 1 month ago
Where the fuck is that bitch who said Sophie is a lame hippie? Guess what? Your the ones the lame hippie.
WehrmachtFeldwebel 1 month ago
@WehrmachtFeldwebel Sadly the real lame hippies hide behind a computer screen. Many of us, knowing the consequences, wouldn't have the guts to do what Miss Scholl, her Brother and assistants did. May they R.I.P.
Broadsword255 1 week ago
Damals waren alles gegen die " vorschrift"
AugendesAbgrunds 1 month ago
the document of istory l..bologna
crvlnz44 2 months ago
Lüge!
fall0rn 3 months ago
See, america? Back when there were moronic extremist thinkers like your creationists, people sat down and talked.
AngelBiLove 6 months ago
@AngelBiLove I'm sorry, please explain your comment. To me it would appear that you're implying that "creationists" originated in America? That can't possibly be what you mean...
uber418 6 months ago 4
human ignorance is baffling.
cmon lets see how many angry ignorant people react to this comment cuz they disagree :3
AngelBiLove 6 months ago
AMAZING scene!
Theyoats 6 months ago 2
@anebt: RE: "Please put down your beer."
Please put down your nazi arrogance of a silly stupid bitch.
MrSKINFLICK 7 months ago
@anebt:
The 3 "Battle Of Stalingrad" videos in the favorites of your channel are BLOCKED IN GERMANY - for good reasons.
You cannot manipulate me, silly bitch + it´s not your business if i have to put down a beer or not.
Your"answer"is the usual "way" of hidden fascists trying to manipulate other people who don´t want to have anything to do with your silly state of mind+weird hysterical"arguments".
Do me a favor+fuck off, you seem to have enough problems with your own idiotic Hitleristic manias.
MrSKINFLICK 7 months ago
@anebt:
You are a Nazi, fuck away from Sophie Scholl videos, you stupid Nazi. GET OUT !
MrSKINFLICK 7 months ago
How can you change the world? With my Heart and Soul,
let Liberty Ring throught the world!
asther113 7 months ago
Her name will live forever! What a brave and wonderful girl she was. May the world never forget Sophie Scholl!
LeMightySabre 8 months ago
I watched the movie about 4 years ago... SO moving, touching and sad!!!
I cried at the end, when she was executed. It was really heart breaking.
I still ask myself how come the German people, majority of them followed a monster like Hitler and supported the nazis. It's unbelievable.
ofri75 9 months ago
@anebt "Have you become my enemy for being a tool?" Me
tok291 9 months ago
Das ist gut . =) .
scottweise18 9 months ago
Das Sophie Scholl ist ein echter deutscher held, den kampf gegen die unterdrückung der berüchtigten Nazis. Ruhe in frieden Sophie . Gott segne . =) . Lolol Ima German-Norwegian living in Canada, tell me how my German was . Prolly bad ! xD .
scottweise18 9 months ago
She is my hero !
sonofasaylor 9 months ago
Comment removed
8Jjon 10 months ago
Comment removed
8Jjon 10 months ago
Comment removed
8Jjon 10 months ago
Comment removed
8Jjon 10 months ago
Comment removed
8Jjon 10 months ago
Comment removed
8Jjon 10 months ago
4:13
kdoh1159 10 months ago
Comment removed
kdoh1159 10 months ago
eines der besten deutschen Filme über die Hitlerzeit. Hier wird gezeigt wie es wirklich war. Der Film is Gut, Hitler war scheiße...
McKingstarr 10 months ago
Great respect for such bravery.....
jeanmaurice1 10 months ago 2
@anebt wow. great quote. thanks for sharing.
uber418 10 months ago
@uber418:
"Thanks" for your silly "gratitude" to a stupid Nazi "commenting" on Sophie Scholl.
If you can´t understand who Sophie Scholl+her comrades were, then remove the video, if you think it is appropriate to give compliments to a Nazi here.
Check his channel+get smart !
How silly can America get to mix up each+everything ?
The so-called apostle Paul, which he cites, was a demagogue+hater like Hitler.
Arrogant "Christian" fundamentalist Americans who abuse the Scholls - shame on you !
MrSKINFLICK 7 months ago
@MrSKINFLICK You are ridiculously confused, my friend.
uber418 7 months ago 2
@uber418:
No, i am not confused, you are confused.
You are a narcissistic problem in yourself+trying to impose other persons with silly idle "arguments".
"Good looks"combined with religious demagogy are not everything+this is something you cannot realize.
There are millions of methods of fascists and ideologists to "impress" other people whom they think they are superior to, but in the end always their BARE LIES will "shine" through.
I can see your eyes and i know how they want to manipulate.
MrSKINFLICK 7 months ago
@uber418:
Once again: The "apostle" Paul (Book Of Galatians) was mostly a purely hideous dishonest fascist + modeled early Christianity at his own crazy personal totalitarian will + nothing else.
The tragedy of early Christians is that they fell victim to this manipulating totalitarian madman.
And no further comment now, only that Sophie Scholl or her comrades were certainly not adherents of the awfully hating scriptures of "Saint" Paul - an evil demagogue who could have also defended Hitler.
MrSKINFLICK 7 months ago
This movie tries to make Communists appear as real freedom-lovers. In fact, the judge who sentenced the Scholls to death was a former Communist.
ecnalubma696969 10 months ago
Very impressing scene, i as half jewish just mustt admire her!!!!
gfks11 10 months ago
@gfks11 People think that this kind of "bureaucratic" supidities are not happening anymore!!!???!!! Unfortunately when you stand up for your ideas or when you are witness of grave injustice...they can make your life miserable and it can take a very long time to repair the damages!!! I know it by experience!!! Corrupted Power is Hell on earth!!! Kiss!!! Johanne (please excuse my english..i am french)
Arcjo1 10 months ago
Have a close look an the books xD
Some kind of continuity fail ;)
NDesignation 10 months ago
Ich habe den Film bei den „Deutschen Kulturtagen in der Ukraine“ geguckt. Ich erinnere mich daran, dass ich nach der Filmvorführung gezittert habe... Warum? Weil das kein Film war… Das war das LEBEN.
Man soll das betonen, dass die Weltgeschichte das Leben war/ist. Nicht von irgendwelchen abstrakten Leuten, aber von den realen Leuten. Es gibt keine abstrakten Leute.
---Das Wertvolle ist in kleiner Menge, aber das zählt sehr viel…
Herzlichen Dank für das Video.
xxKateryna 11 months ago
@xxKateryna bitte :) und danke für deine Worte
uber418 11 months ago
Iam proud to call myself a German . :) .
scottweise18 1 year ago
The war in Africa was known as the Krieg ohne Hass or War without Hate .
scottweise18 1 year ago
was known by his colleagues and enemies alike as a true German soldier and one of the few in the entire war to show respect to his enemies . He was respected by such people as Churchill and Patton . When a plot to assasinate Rommel failed and the assasins were killed he ordered them buried with full military honours . He also refused to deport the Jewish populations in the areas where he commanded, even writing back to Hitler in protest .
scottweise18 1 year ago
She was and is the symbol of a true Germany . A free and prosperous Germany reborn from the ashes of the defeat and despair of WW1 and WW2 . She and many other honourable Germans like her showed the rest of the world that not all of Germany was nazi . She will forever be remembered as a beacon of light to all mankind and as a defender against the immoral and atrocious acts that were taking place all around her . She's one of my favorites alongside the leader of the Afrika Korp Erwin Rommel who
scottweise18 1 year ago
I was doing a project on Sophie Scholl for history. This video gave me so much information and it helped me...thanks to you I got an A!
Great Upload! Thanks!!!
CaRZndHipP0z 1 year ago
@CaRZndHipP0z glad to hear it helped!
uber418 1 year ago
Excellent. I really needed to see this scene. Thanks for uploading. :D
grEEnTEar 1 year ago
@grEEnTEar sure thing! hope it was helpful.
uber418 1 year ago