Joel Madden and Hilary Duff

[TinkerBelle657]

I am disappointed.... you used a song that Joel wrote for Nicole in a video about his ex girlfriend?!?!?! I love Joel, I love Hilary, but personally,, I am offended as a Good Charlotte fan and a Hilary fan...

[missdreamerluvsbenji]

luv the vid hon just 1 lil prob .46 is not joel its benji color tats joel has blk n whit benj has the color

[escape101fate]

good couple

[xoxgaabby]

is the good charlotte song written about hilary?

[edisonhotties]

:(( joel and hilary is meant for each other!! <3

[Hilaaryy]

And nicole, i'm confuse..

???

[jaynie4ever]

God..I still love them togheter !!

And I LOVE the video !!

Good job ;)

[gabe2pac]

kick ass song

[monicastar14]

beautiful pictures

i love them together

[bigal174]

they were soooo good for eachother

[Miastewart34443]

1. Good Charlotte-Something Else

2. Hilary Duff-Love Just Is

[Miastewart34443]

1. Good Charlotte-Something Else

2. Hilary Duff-Love Just Is

[sweetandsalt]

umm wat the  namne of the song??

[MovieKidX3]

I remember when I first heard that Joel & Hilary were dating I was like: "WTF? Sweet innocent Lizze Maguire is dating punk/rocker Joel Madden? So unlike her!"

[xXxTwilightFanxXx]

4:50---is that nicole? i can't quite tell...

but i've been watching all these nicole/joel vids and i think they were extremely happy and cute together. in 2 1/2 years joel couldn't knock up hilary cuz hilary would never let him. but nicole did---and look at them now? how possibly can he be happy with his decision? hilaryyyyyy and joellll forever yehh?

[rynplyr7]

i love if joel and hilary couple again and be husband and wife forever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[JoelMariMadden]

=´( ..Joel back to Hilary!

[ba7lo0og05]

ey look really cute together!

[ba7lo0og05]

they****

[rmariahr]

never mind

[rmariahr]

what movie is this and I am going to ad you as my friend tell me what movie this is pleaseshe is so pretty and I have been a fan and I mean fan since I dont even know since I was born lllllloooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv­vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv her

[melimaddenxx]

this is not a movie. :)

[sweet4612]

love the song umm hilary wan tjoel bac idk if joel feels the sam bout her it gonna be sad if the baby dies but i gonna be happy when they brek up cuz that baby is keeping the togeather

[bethypiex]

Nicole and Joel aint gnna b for long.

When the baby is born joel is probs gnna lcear off.

They rushed in- n its like joel only knocked nicole off 2 get back and hilary but oh well xx

[shaleena21]

i love this video! its soo good, great job on it ! &hearts;

[THERiVERx3]

i HATE SAYiN THiS BUT i THiNK iT WUD BE GOOD iF THE BABY DiDNT MAKE iT THN iT WUDNT HAVE DiVORCED PARENTS && A DRUGiE MOM ALWAYS iN MAGiZiNES LiKE BRiTTNANY

GO BACK TO HiL JOEL...x3

[melimaddenxx]

come on THERiVERx3.

Hilary broke up with Joel, so i don't see how Joel screwed up his life? and right now both joel and hilary have found significant others and they're both very happy.

i think you should stop thinking about what you want and think about how they feel.

i think nicole has really smartened up because of joel and is now taking things seriously, you are going to have to deal with that.

but thanks for wacthing the video!

[bethypiex]

nw hil n joel shooldnt get back together cs hilary moved on n got a new bf

[THERiVERx3]

OMG i CUD GO ON && ON ABOUT HOW JOEL SCREWED UP HiS LiFE ....&& i MiTE...i MEAN NiCOLE LOOKS LiKE SOME ANEREXEC DRUGiE (WHiCH SHE PROBABLY iS) && HiL WHO PROBABLY HAS NEVER EVEN DRANK OR SMOKED iN HER LiFE && WHO MAKES SUMTHiNG OF HERSELF BESIDES PUTTiNG HER BODY OUT THERE (LiKE NICOLE)&& WHO ALWAYS DOES SUMTHiNG GOOD...GET THiS HAVE U EVER HEARD OF THE SHRiNERS HOSPiTAL FOR KiDS SHE (HiL) ViSiTED THM DURiN CHRiSTMAS...WUD NiCOLE EVER?? NOPE...

[evangriffiths]

the river wat u on about joel had a hard life he didnt want that life as he got older good charlotte r amazing n hilar duff smokes n drinks shes a big gurl now u idiot joel is amazing hes rich n famous dunno how he screwed up his life he has better life den most u twat so shut up

[bethypiex]

Im sure shes had a drink bt not got drunk like wine or sumink

[Larish77]

This is the best video i ever seen

[9sujata]

oh whoevr posted this ur cool! both songs are so so perfect for this!

[melimaddenxx]

haha thanks!

[9sujata]

hey how do i put it on my hi5?

[9sujata]

I miss them as a couple too.....

[hilarysnumba1]

at 3 min. and 36 seconds on the vid, joel's wearing a home made hat, thats my hat that i gave hilary's mother to in 05!i even have the shirt to it!!!!!

[suzanneforever23]

if only she was a little bit older, they would've stayed together still. Nicole does not deserve him, she's a freaking slut!!

[mikekid626]

this song is so freakin true

[LiesenPien]

I miss them as a couple...

[gilmore117]

0:39- Alert the media! It's Benji touching Hilary!!

Hahaha jkjk.

[gilmore117]

3:21- could he get any more innocent?

[melimaddenxx]

haha , true gilmore!

[gilmore117]

3:44- so adorable, no?

[HopelessGCgirl]

hey its me: punkychick815. I guess your right...Hil isn't so bad. *waves white flag* I give up. (but seriously, more then half of my school hates her)

[punkychick815]

To me, Hilary Duff is just a blonde, slut! She acts like she's all innocent when she's not! She probably cheated on Joel when he was 100% honest with her! Hilary Duff probably has fake boobs too! I HATE HER! She thinks she's soo beautiful, but guess what? SHE'S UGLY! (actually a lil more than half of my whole school thinks that too) I hope something really bad happens to Hilary Duff one day, so now she can see how us little people feel!

[gilmore117]

HILARY? Dude, personally, your discribing Nicole.

[pinkpixie553]

I agree w/ punkychick815 hil tries to act like a freakin diva saying "oh my god I hate picture menues" and eww lebanese restaurant. shes such a wanna be primadonna f**king b*t*h good thing he moved on anyone is better than her even nicole.

[punkychick815]

the first song was called "Something Else" By: Good Charlotte

[skaterjorge]

whats the first song?

[gilmore117]

Im confused- whats the deal with gc and avril? I thought they didnt like each other but 1:13 joels with avril

[melimaddenxx]

they never hated eachother :)!

[MadeLevel27chick92]

Really nice...I think all of us(most) wanna see Joel and Hil together

[benjispunkyprincess]

he was way better off with hil. i miss them together.

[XSyntheticxRomanceX]

i really wish they were still together.

[melimaddenxx]

thank you everyone.

[gilmore117]

4:55- Did you add in that pic of Nicole by accident?

[melimaddenxx]

Nope, if you listen to the lyrics hilary says "it don't make sense, what can you do?" so there's a little message in there. lol, because at the time i didn't think him being with nicole made any sense..

[johannaduwa]

OMG, this video is so cute!!

[Okej00]

i miss Jilary, they made such a good couple

[Smileycyrus15]

This was a very good video. You put the pictures to the music perfectly. Can I please get the sights where you got the pictures from both Hilary and Joel? Thanks.

[tushyy6]

i miss jilary to not jochie

[kmygc15]

I MISS JILARY, i hate madchie

[tushyy6]

i loooove this video it's so cute i miss joel and hilary. oww nice video you did a good job. a very nice one i really really love it. this is the best tribute video ive ever seen from anyone but you ya you took the cake.

[xXxtHeXxXdRoXxX]

i <33 joels tatoo - madden :P hes faf!

[HilandHaylsfan]

Love it!!! i miss Jilary