@giorgioadams I don't see it if you. think it is because she had her mouth closed. You can achievethat with a closed you mouth while singing and speaker delay. =s
I liked the way she used to dress. She reminded me of a biker chick. Now she's totally different. She dresses all Bohemian with 9'' heels and earrings the size of hubcaps.
I actually don't know what are you talking about...you mean, that this isn't live?Cause i see that at the time 2:48 ...but i think, that Hilary wouldn't sing at playback...but it sounds almost like the official record...but I'm not sure If I understand, what you wanna say...but it is true, that the end of this video is completely out(of tune/flat)
its called back-track? i guess you havent heard of it before. MOST HUGE ARTISTS use it when they perform. it to help the singer when they are too out of breath to sing at some parts.
lollll she lipsyncs!!! A singer is not supposed to be out of breath when they sing they need to be in shape in order to sing in the first place. I understand you're a fan and like her but a fact is a fact no matter how much you denie it
luckytheyorkie you fail all stars has background song in theb ackground if the star forgets her lyrics and you can hear it that she doesent sing at 2:48 but when she sings it goes even louder s oyou fail :), Notice when stars stop singing either they stop the song in background when they tal kto audience or they keep it going :)
and she isnt lip syncing she has back up retards hah
she has a cd that is playing and its her voice and at some parts they cut off the background and she sings some with just herself.i know cuz i sing and its really hard to sound good and walk around and jump around while your singing and she is doin great
only because on her album she uses something called "auto-tune" which is computer software that makes sure a pop singer is never out of tune (it basically alters all her notes to make them perfect) however, in this performance, she falls a bit out of tune at least three times, which -to me at least- is proof enough that it's live.
SHE DOES NOT LIP SYNC!!!!!!! Look as she has finished singing also be convinced!! You simply envy also all!!!She`s singing AWESOME and LIVE!!!! UR ENVY!!!!HATERS this song for U!SHE`s Superb!fantastic!!AWESOM!love her)))
Comment means say what you think...and I think, and it´s the true, that she´s a faker....and thats no even music. Think about that: I can take a CD with a song...click on play and lipsync...than...I am a real artist? im a faker an a fucking shit...and artist is the person who can do it good in a CD or a live performance.
Lip sync, Live performances, There all beautiful. All beautiful songs. :P All songs are beautiful whether there live or not. Quit being haters. :P It is true, Performing live is much prettier ^_^ and much more real, but oh well. A comment means comment, It means adore, it doesnt mean HATE ON IT. Sheesh, :P
lol, you people don't even know what live performance is.
look up "evanescence live" or "flyleaf live" or seether live" or look up any band in the rock category. Basically all rock bands sing live, EVEN if they're tired/sick.
So enough with the bullshit excuses for hilary not singing live "sometimes" (which is most of the time. i can never find her singing live, except for one and it sounded like shit), because REAL musicians do it live every time.
Thats shit !!!! LIP SYNC!!!! fake....NOT MUSIC! If you´re a singer you sing live...if you´re a fucking faker you do this...Go Hilary you´re what makes some music sucks and other kind of music be so great! Punkrock rules! Punkrock is real!
Okay, I am a huge fan of Hilary, but I have to admit, she doesn't actually look very well/tired at this concert. She usually ALWAYS sings 100% live, but I have to admit, she IS lip-syncing in this video. But she doesn't ever lip-sync in her concerts usually - I know, I've been to 2 and watched the rest on youtube and it's always all live.
But there must have been a reason 4 her lip-syncing.
U can tell she is cos at 2:48 she's supposed 2 start miming again but the music starts and she doesn't.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
100% live ?? really?? i have to TRY to find live performances because all she does is lip! at one time i actually liked hilary but got so tired of all the phoney performances.
It's funny when they'll turn it on during the song so she can say/scream something, almost as if to make it look like oh she's talking live she must also be singing live! LOL she needs new management!
I always find it funny how most of the time she'll lipsync the whole song but at the very end they turn on her mic. it's like WHATS THE POINT? ITS THE FREAKEN END! LOL
LOL at 2:45 it looks like she's gonna start but looks at someone to make sure and is like no, and then looks at them again before she actually starts "singing". :)
<3
newintowngirl 6 months ago
you can CLEARLY tell it was sung LIVE and NOT lip sync at the end because she gets a bit off tune. and the band messes up at some small points
MyWolfWarrior 6 months ago
LOVE LOVE LOVE..U ARE PERFECT GIRL!
SuperPartytimes 11 months ago
Can someone please tell me what kind of t shirt she is wearing, is it a band? or is it a fashion thing. i am in love with it.
onlyattention101 11 months ago
@giorgioadams That was the back up singers. Idiot. -___-
CourtXDx3 1 year ago
good times
SHAWNSHAWN01 1 year ago
The name of the song is Wierd!!!!Good song!!!!! I<3 Hilary Duff!!!!!
1992Patriciasuper 1 year ago
omg she is liping you can see it @2:44
giorgioadams 1 year ago
@giorgioadams OMG, she is to :(
MsMaddiiee 1 year ago
@giorgioadams YES!!!!!!!!
SHAWNSHAWN01 1 year ago
@giorgioadams I don't see it if you. think it is because she had her mouth closed. You can achievethat with a closed you mouth while singing and speaker delay. =s
kyledylanchang1994 1 year ago
@giorgioadams Please!!!! All USHER RAYMOND LIVE PERFORMANCES THERE IS PLAYBACK & HE LIP SYNCS!!!!!!
13Shotter 7 months ago
Hello all, a what a name at 0.40 plz, Very thx.
ps: I'am French
PtitYZ19 1 year ago
@PtitYZ19 dont you think its weird by hilary duff :))
ockstaar 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Name a song 0:40 plz ! thx
PtitYZ19 1 year ago
Name a song 0:40 plz ! thx
PtitYZ19 1 year ago
@PtitYZ19 Weird ;)
remao 4 months ago
Comment removed
PtitYZ19 1 year ago
I think they're all pre-recorded vocal tracks, but she did sing parts of them :)
HugeFanOfBritney 1 year ago
juicy ass
joshfoxtvworld 1 year ago
whaat is this song called? (:
meglovesPHOTO 1 year ago
@meglovesPHOTO weird.
h44512 1 year ago
What is the name of the song ?
HeiligHeart 1 year ago
please title son ?!!!!!
sapete il titolo di sta canzone??
Robypsychoboy 1 year ago
@Robypsychoboy
il titolo della canzone è weird xD
Soraxever 1 year ago
she is just amazing she is like an angel
TheGjkcity 2 years ago 2
i love hilary!!!! is the best!!
she has A beautiful hair!!
MiSsSpears93 2 years ago
LOL at 2:47 the track starts playing again and you can clearly see her mouth is closed. lip syncer!
the last like at 3:18 is the only live part.
lukeBAM 2 years ago
@lukeBAM she wasn't lip syncing. she had a backing track she sang with. if you listen closely, you can hear two voices. (;
trrrrrent 2 years ago 2
I want so badly to see Hilary Duff live.
dowlingchicks 2 years ago
bring back old hilary!
CriesMaga18 2 years ago 26
she is the rock
I love you Hilary
ella es el rock
te amo Hilary
todoyopoo 2 years ago 2
She is ROCK ! I love you Hilary <3 FOREVER
HollyeHD 2 years ago
I liked the way she used to dress. She reminded me of a biker chick. Now she's totally different. She dresses all Bohemian with 9'' heels and earrings the size of hubcaps.
MacaroniKetchup 2 years ago 3
the live is my dream
HilaryDuffChanel 2 years ago
wat song is she performing
ashleynheartss 2 years ago
Weird from the album Hilary Duff
S0ulm4t3 2 years ago
Best butt in showbiz!
harriganes 2 years ago
same fly video clothe i love that jean and shirt
centon27 2 years ago
I went to her Concert January 6, 2005. I remember that day. She had on a white t-shirt and really tight jeans
DemiLovatoRocks2009 2 years ago
kool girl u rock
rashell20 2 years ago
i Knoow , She used To Be My Wife :-/
Lmfaooo
Fredwarddspyy 2 years ago
I miss this Hilary Duff.. This is the girl I think is awesome, not the new, now shes just like everyone else. -.-
Great concert. <3 Thanks for uploading it. ;D
MollyW 2 years ago 3
it isn't lipsyncing ; cant you tell the difference ? o-o
bAbiiExkUtiES 2 years ago
umm hello that means that she wasnt lip syncing duh.
jjhave 2 years ago
see, that means her voice isnt that good after all...
why in the first place people wanna b singers if they already know they're gonna lip sync in all concerts?? its stupid...
mastura7 2 years ago
this is live.. you can hear her voice crack in the middle once..not in the official record thing
BreeRauch 2 years ago
I lovee uu hilary DUFF ROLE MODEL FOR A LIFE TIMEE
chloew419 2 years ago 2
She rocked in this concert *-* but when was this concert? 'cause now she is not soo into rock as a few years ago :/ can someone tell me please? ^-^
SrtaNitah 2 years ago
Is this the same concert where the video to fly was shot?
TheMonaLisaCloud 2 years ago
Even the person that is in great shape has to catch their breath. Hilary is the best
71elm 2 years ago
HILARY DUFF WE LOVE U !!!!!
PatryIbanez 2 years ago 12
wats this song called i like it :)
gamerbot101 2 years ago
iTS CALLED WEIRD :D
coopgirl8 2 years ago 4
Hilary rocks!!
Come to Kingston! :)
LOVE LOVE YOU HIL
BrandiAshlee 2 years ago 4
I actually don't know what are you talking about...you mean, that this isn't live?Cause i see that at the time 2:48 ...but i think, that Hilary wouldn't sing at playback...but it sounds almost like the official record...but I'm not sure If I understand, what you wanna say...but it is true, that the end of this video is completely out(of tune/flat)
piper002 2 years ago
was this in st.johns?
ZAPPiGossip 3 years ago
Hilary Duff is the best singer that is in the world...!!!
She is sooo great and nce and sweet to her fan, childeren they have no maney or parents..!!
I love her...!!!
Hilary you rock...!!!
hilarydelaine12 3 years ago
that's my hilary duff!!
she's awesome and that stupid miley cyrus is stealing all her fans.i am so sad about it!
but i love u hilary!!
do u guies too???
hilaryduffisthebestp 3 years ago 4
Hilary can rock!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AlexandraDuff 3 years ago 3
this was the day she rode her "fly" videocliP! :O
mariajeje 3 years ago
that's my girl ;)
i love hilary, she never dissapoints.
cherries9595 3 years ago
Of course im aware of singers using back-tracks.
How can she be out of breath after the instrumental part ?
Huge singers use back-track and playback as well, but actually i dont even care
I LOVE HER ;) (i didnt mean to bother anyone)
Mileyanze 3 years ago
y does anyone care if shes lip syncing is anyone not seeing how hot she looks here.... I really wanna fuk he in the ass in this vid
watsss 3 years ago
Then have a look at 2:48 where she misses the second she has to start to sing again.. .
its rather obvious and i am being sorry to say that cos i love her but there you can see she lipsyncs.. .
Mileyanze 3 years ago
its called back-track? i guess you havent heard of it before. MOST HUGE ARTISTS use it when they perform. it to help the singer when they are too out of breath to sing at some parts.
born2887 3 years ago
lollll she lipsyncs!!! A singer is not supposed to be out of breath when they sing they need to be in shape in order to sing in the first place. I understand you're a fan and like her but a fact is a fact no matter how much you denie it
Blaeize 3 years ago
Did she loose a hair at 1:22 ??
Seems so, sths dropping and looks like a hair xD
Mileyanze 3 years ago
HiLaRy DuFf RoCkS!!!!!
Copy&paste if you agree!!!!!!
MileyDemiSelena11 3 years ago
weird is it called
NathyH 3 years ago
thanks :-)
AlexllMontana 3 years ago
wats d name of the song????
atomickitty01 3 years ago
YEah! whats the name of the song!
AlexllMontana 3 years ago
name of d song is weird
atomickitty01 3 years ago
thanks :-)
AlexllMontana 3 years ago
luckytheyorkie you fail all stars has background song in theb ackground if the star forgets her lyrics and you can hear it that she doesent sing at 2:48 but when she sings it goes even louder s oyou fail :), Notice when stars stop singing either they stop the song in background when they tal kto audience or they keep it going :)
BladeAndSoul 3 years ago
H I L ' S T H E B E S T ! ! ! !
inmyperfectworld 3 years ago
this is where they shot the fly video
and she isnt lip syncing she has back up retards hah
she has a cd that is playing and its her voice and at some parts they cut off the background and she sings some with just herself.i know cuz i sing and its really hard to sound good and walk around and jump around while your singing and she is doin great
fuck off!!!
mikespikekite 3 years ago
what's the name of this song?
beautifulbillkaulitz 3 years ago
I love Hilary Duff, but she's lip synching. =[
Watch closely at 2:48
LuckytheYorkie 3 years ago
I doubt she's lipsynching,
only because on her album she uses something called "auto-tune" which is computer software that makes sure a pop singer is never out of tune (it basically alters all her notes to make them perfect) however, in this performance, she falls a bit out of tune at least three times, which -to me at least- is proof enough that it's live.
outfitmadeofawesome 3 years ago 2
SHE DOES NOT LIP SYNC!!!!!!! Look as she has finished singing also be convinced!! You simply envy also all!!!She`s singing AWESOME and LIVE!!!! UR ENVY!!!!HATERS this song for U!SHE`s Superb!fantastic!!AWESOM!love her)))
lizzie1liza 3 years ago
i'm her huge fan, but this is lipsync... watch at 2.48...
Hilandro 3 years ago
Hilary's fantastic!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AlexandraDuff 3 years ago 3
I lovee Her Hairr! &+ wher can i get tickets from??
HabboFan8 3 years ago
Comment means say what you think...and I think, and it´s the true, that she´s a faker....and thats no even music. Think about that: I can take a CD with a song...click on play and lipsync...than...I am a real artist? im a faker an a fucking shit...and artist is the person who can do it good in a CD or a live performance.
Rubo41 3 years ago
what's the name of this song? i totally love her as an artist wow !
beautifulbillkaulitz 3 years ago 2
weird it' the first song
hilarydufffanclub01 3 years ago
1KillerGirl1 3 years ago 2
SHE DOES NOT LIP SYNC!!!
Duffstar94 3 years ago 3
ya!! i would always sing alive
Duffstar94 3 years ago
lol, you people don't even know what live performance is.
look up "evanescence live" or "flyleaf live" or seether live" or look up any band in the rock category. Basically all rock bands sing live, EVEN if they're tired/sick.
So enough with the bullshit excuses for hilary not singing live "sometimes" (which is most of the time. i can never find her singing live, except for one and it sounded like shit), because REAL musicians do it live every time.
frenzicffion 3 years ago
I agree.
shadymansoncyrus101 3 years ago
awesome wow how much r the tickets 4 her concerts? i wanna go! lmao! she is so awesome oh does any 1 know when her new cd is comming out!??!?
jonasbros101 3 years ago 2
No more than $60 or $70. However, in places like Las Vegas, they were $100 (for the Dignity Tour)
alexd123456 3 years ago
Thats shit !!!! LIP SYNC!!!! fake....NOT MUSIC! If you´re a singer you sing live...if you´re a fucking faker you do this...Go Hilary you´re what makes some music sucks and other kind of music be so great! Punkrock rules! Punkrock is real!
Rubo41 3 years ago
fake... not music? then you just really don't know what music is all about ... anyways
beautifulbillkaulitz 3 years ago
is that lipsync?
even if it is true, i like her
we sometimes exhaust even not celebrity
the clebrity feel thoroughly tired than us
she drives me crazy. thats it
thats the star
i dont care the lipping
I don't care what they say about us anyway.
I don't care about that.
I don't care about that.
emisuzukiemi 3 years ago
wats d title of this song?
B5D729 3 years ago
¨weird¨ by hD!..
iZahOlly15 3 years ago
lipping
Gillie4eva 3 years ago
even i accede wid u dat she's lip-syncing in this concert
luvduffsisters 3 years ago
m also a huge... fan of hilary.yup ur rite xhilaryxduffxfanz..this ws da concert fimed for da music video of 'Fly' in Massachettus
luvduffsisters 3 years ago
Okay, I am a huge fan of Hilary, but I have to admit, she doesn't actually look very well/tired at this concert. She usually ALWAYS sings 100% live, but I have to admit, she IS lip-syncing in this video. But she doesn't ever lip-sync in her concerts usually - I know, I've been to 2 and watched the rest on youtube and it's always all live.
But there must have been a reason 4 her lip-syncing.
U can tell she is cos at 2:48 she's supposed 2 start miming again but the music starts and she doesn't.
xhilaryxduffxfanx 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
100% live ?? really?? i have to TRY to find live performances because all she does is lip! at one time i actually liked hilary but got so tired of all the phoney performances.
lipsyncpolice 3 years ago
OH
MY
GOD
Is this the concert that was filmed for the actual music video of 'Fly'? OMG!
xhilaryxduffxfanx 3 years ago 2
lol
Blondiiful 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lpsync , Lipsync, poor Hil
Denielys 3 years ago
ppl r leaving mean comments!
hilary duff rox and she is singing sooo great =]]
hilaryxxduffxx4life 4 years ago
lol i like hilary, her songs are relly cool, especially so yesterday! i kno its old but i luvv it! :)
Blondiiful 4 years ago
yaa me 2 =]
hilaryxxduffxx4life 4 years ago
It's funny when they'll turn it on during the song so she can say/scream something, almost as if to make it look like oh she's talking live she must also be singing live! LOL she needs new management!
SoImAnticonformity 4 years ago
lol :) yea
Blondiiful 4 years ago
I always find it funny how most of the time she'll lipsync the whole song but at the very end they turn on her mic. it's like WHATS THE POINT? ITS THE FREAKEN END! LOL
SoImAnticonformity 4 years ago
LOL :)
Blondiiful 4 years ago
it's funny after the bridge she doesn't know when to start so she puts her back to the audience and waits til the pre recorded track starts! LOL :)
SoImAnticonformity 4 years ago
yea lol
Blondiiful 4 years ago
LOL at 2:45 it looks like she's gonna start but looks at someone to make sure and is like no, and then looks at them again before she actually starts "singing". :)
SoImAnticonformity 4 years ago 2
I LOVE HERRR
mellow122 4 years ago