@azngen1233 actually the original is in korean and wilber pan made a cover.... LOL the lyrics of the chinese version and korean version also have completely different meanings xD
This song was originally korean but wilber pan made a chinese (mandarin) version
Wilber pan himself is an american born taiwanese singer
The song (not the mv) here is the a korean version (with a bit of english) but there are many versions of this song since it is so popular eg: korean, english, chinese(cantonese)
The subtitles here are in chinese because wilber's version was in chinese, but the korean song has been superimposed over the original mv
@TheBrownCowMoo lol really they speak chinese in korea. Korea has like three languages they can speak most speak korea of course but 2nd most used is chinese
@girlpink0124, the subtitles are Chinese. The actual words are Korean, I would know, I speak Korean, almost fluently. And please no name calling, it's really not necessary. :(
This is like a remix of the english, korean, and chinese version. Originally, this song was produced by freestyle - please tell me why (krn) then there was a chinese version bu de bu ai by wilber pan, then the english version..
Actually the song and the mv doesn't match, the subtitle is Chinese, but it's singing in Korean, the song is a Chinese song originally, maybe cover by some Korean singer with Korean lyrics.
@TheRunescapePlayerz actually It's not. It would be more like old English and modern English. Japanese, Chinese, and Korean can be easily mistaken for those who haven't been taught or learned any of their history.
@Malco119 (shaking head) actually YES, and you already got my point. German, French, America, do seem the same, IF i havnt been taught or learned about their history. not to prolong this argument, we dont know the different in your language just like you dont know the different in ours.
This Chinese Version is more popular simply because of Pan Wei Bo. Wei Bo and the girl here made it more serene. Not to mention this version is way way much better than the other versions... even better than the Korean's. Peace^^
Of course the CHINESE are going to claim this as a ORIGINAL version.
The fact is, this song was originally made by KOREAN group FREESTYLE.
I have 3 Chinese versions, 3 Korean versions, 1 viet version, and a tagalog version. THE ORIGINAL VERSION was always KOREAN.
Chinese version just got popular because there's like 2 billion people in China. That's why Yi Jianlian will be voted into the All-star Game, just you see!
hahaha well lets see. The original was in Korean i cant argue that, but pan wei bo is from taiwan (well actually america) not china. Besides, china doesnt even allow youtube so it didnt get popular from china, it was a good song thats why it chinese version got popular.
Ok, the fact that Yi Jianlian got voted 3rd is probably due to his ethnicity, i believe that, but WTF does it have to do with this song? The fact that China doesnt allow youtube means that OTHER countries liked this song. There are a lot of chinese people i can garuntee that. Hell, im Chinese. Are you saying because im Chinese that i wont recognize that the Korean version was the original? Or that Yi Jianlian got so many votes because he is chinese? I agree with you on both, so why the racism?
Actually no...people in CHINA DO NOT need youtube to hear this song. That's the point. This song did not get popular off just Youtube, you do realize that there are many ways to hear this song other than youtube right?
The fact that many CHINESE people liked this song and then passed it on as it being the "ORIGINAL" is the issue here. It's not racism, it's fact.
Ok i get it. Im chinese. I say the korean one is the original. so WHAT IS THE PROBLEM? I dont care what the other chinese think, not everyone thinks alike. you cant say chinese as a whole when there are people who are chinese that agree that the korean one is the original.
Yeh i know the politics in Taiwan are really crazy right now. Im not really sure if im Taiwanese or not cause only my mom's side has a history of ancestors there, but my dad was born in Taiwan after my grandfather, who was a bodyguard for Chiang Kai-Shek, came over and settled. So can i represent both or none? Also, like i said, not a all Taiwanese people think alike, some consider themselves both Taiwanese and Chinese.
I know, just not enough space type it all. Hes technically from china but he was born in america and moved to taiwan, so the part about him being in china isnt really important anymore lol.
hey,can u send me this song lyrics on word??please..i reali want train sing this song at home..but u send me using WORD not chinese language or English..
Clarifications: (Thumb this up please!)
1) Chinese Version: Pan Wei Bo - Bu De Bu Ai
2) English Version: Karma K - Forever You and I
3) Korean Version: Freestyle - Please Tell Me Why
To clear this up, THIS ONE IS BY FREESTYLE - PLEASE TELL ME WHY!
ThangMusic 2 months ago 5
The audio is in Korean, the visual is in Chinese, and the lyrics is in Chinese. So the lyrics doesn't fit exactly to the singing portion.
ThangMusic 2 months ago
-.- people the SONG is in korean. the VIDEO is in chinese. OBVIOUSLY this song was added to the vid. i
StrawberryVampy 2 months ago
@thelaughteam ur dumb its korean.
xvietchai 3 months ago 2
TO CLEAR THIS UP I'M CHINESE AND THIS SONG IS CHINESE I UNDERSTAND IT SO OK IT IS CHINESE
TheLaughTeam 3 months ago
เพราะมากครับ ชอบๆๆๆๆๆ
jamsZedSa 5 months ago
dude wtf this is the chinese version video but the song is english and korean. label the song right. kthxbye.
AwemandaR 7 months ago
I dont care what this is...its still nice hahahaha
xeng26 7 months ago
This is the korean version
lBlueHolic 7 months ago
CORRECTION TO MY PREVIOUS COMMENT: this song is originally from
freestyle as ''please tell me why'' and the one from wilber is a cover but totally legal
LordMSDrK 8 months ago
@LordMSDrK no! totally illegal! freestyle sue wilber.
barial76 8 months ago
ok to make it really clear this song is originally from wilber pan and sung in chinese as BU DE BU AI
but this is the english/korean version of that song, the girl sings in english and the guy sings in korean
as simple as that
LordMSDrK 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This song is chinese.
Mrclimber17 8 months ago
Yes yes, it should be labeled English/ Korean.
keijimashta 9 months ago
the guy is speaking korean, dont know about the girl. But thanks for the vid!
TaiLeeify 9 months ago
여전히 멋진 노래!
XiaosiTsai 9 months ago
this is in korean retards LOL..
BassNDrum2424 9 months ago
this is the english and korean version
omfgsjoc 9 months ago
I'm pretty sure this is just the Korean version of the original song.
And I just realised that your tag contains "Naruto vs. Gaara" LOL how is that relevent to this song at the slightest...xD
creamysodarevenge 10 months ago
really nice song:) just found it today lol
majonee15 10 months ago
this was first a nigerian song
Gafienboogie 10 months ago
completely taiwanese song, in taiwanese mandarin :)
mapleric 10 months ago
@mapleric This is Korean
?
theroadsofar 10 months ago
@theroadsofar the original song is idk what this is....if this is even the original singers...
mapleric 10 months ago
@mapleric dumbshit its korean
BassNDrum2424 9 months ago
Chicken killer
robloxpwnmaster3 11 months ago
i dont understand most of it but who cares its awsome!!!!!!!!
idkimrandom555 11 months ago
WHO CARES WHAT LANGUAGE THIS SONG IS?!? ITS STILL SOUNDS GOOD :D !
lildevilxxangel 1 year ago 3
I AM BETTER
dimensionsriss 1 year ago
it's not even translated..
JJZCS 1 year ago
This is not sang by wilber
2229286 1 year ago
Song is in Korean and English but the music video and subtitles are chinese.
prisiv 1 year ago 4
thumbs up if david choi send u here
skippyzheng 1 year ago 21
@skippyzheng haha i'm glad he sended me here because i've been looking for this song for a long time
masterdomike 1 year ago
@skippyzheng did he cover it?
Epiton3 10 months ago
@Epiton3 nah he sent a link that led to this video
skippyzheng 10 months ago
@skippyzheng did david choi do a cover of this? can you send me the link?
rock152 9 months ago
since when wilber pan raps in korean ???is this another cover?
amimax 1 year ago
nice XD
erixxnamjam 1 year ago
LOL ppl this is sang in korean that just has chinese subtitles and a few lines of english in it
charleemaine 1 year ago
i know both chinese and korean let me tell u that the song is korean but th subtitle&mv is chinese....in chinese, it's called 不得不愛
lokchow 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
lokchow 1 year ago
david choi likes this? @.@
festivilicious 1 year ago 13
the song is korean even the mv is chinese
yukiodaikuara 1 year ago
Comment removed
xiolinorchdork 1 year ago
omg i remember this song from somewhere o.o
iEpicLy 1 year ago
WILL PANNNNN! :D
mys3LfNi 1 year ago
IT IS FRIKING CHINESE
WizardzzRule 1 year ago
wooooooo david choi fav this video
ahahaa likes!!
wei bo jia you!!
hyuend 1 year ago 5
Best song ever!!
ZeKingBk 1 year ago
I heard that Freestyle sued them for not giving credit =/
anime223 1 year ago
the original is Chinese but people make covers.
azngen1233 1 year ago
@azngen1233 actually the original is in korean and wilber pan made a cover.... LOL the lyrics of the chinese version and korean version also have completely different meanings xD
choybo1 1 year ago
@choybo1 the original is Chinese this is a Korean cover version.
azngen1233 1 year ago
@azngen1233 sorry my dear this is chinese. this is actually mandarin
SusannaQ450 1 year ago
@azngen1233 no... wilbers version is not the original... there ARE covers BUT the original was korean...
choybo1 1 year ago
Comment removed
iG0Tn0NamE 1 year ago
Comment removed
iG0Tn0NamE 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@azngen1233
Title - Y (Please Tell Me Why)
Singer - Freestyle (Korean)
Album released at 2004-07-16
Title - 不得不愛 Bu De Bu Ai (Have To Love)
Singer - Wilber Pan (Taiwanese)
Album released at 2005-07-08
and yes, wilber pan got permission from freestyle to do a taiwanese version of his song.
just like how wheesung got permission to do a korean version of insomnia by craig david.
MrPleasethink 1 year ago
Ok people whether yous believe it or not;-
This song was originally korean but wilber pan made a chinese (mandarin) version
Wilber pan himself is an american born taiwanese singer
The song (not the mv) here is the a korean version (with a bit of english) but there are many versions of this song since it is so popular eg: korean, english, chinese(cantonese)
The subtitles here are in chinese because wilber's version was in chinese, but the korean song has been superimposed over the original mv
Hanaquan 1 year ago
the original song was in mandarin! that's why they have chinese subtitles.
marylovesoreos 1 year ago
why is chinese lyrics doing in a korean song?
TheBrownCowMoo 1 year ago
@TheBrownCowMoo lol really they speak chinese in korea. Korea has like three languages they can speak most speak korea of course but 2nd most used is chinese
MrTimoteo1596 1 year ago
This is obviously Portuguese.
LostFaithChoi 1 year ago
love that guitar sound
androobay 1 year ago
Okay, yeah, that is definitely Korean, with a little English thrown in there.
girlpink0124 1 year ago
@girlpink0124 u dumb shit, its not korean, its mandarin! Chinese
xuxu4life 1 year ago
@xuxu4life hey man no need for negative words man, and besides it IS korean, just the subtitles are mandarin, the song itself is korean
technodavzero 1 year ago
@girlpink0124, the subtitles are Chinese. The actual words are Korean, I would know, I speak Korean, almost fluently. And please no name calling, it's really not necessary. :(
girlpink0124 1 year ago
The singer is speaking Korean but the original song could be from a different country.
JosKiddin 1 year ago
i heard korean, english and japenese? hahaha
justinalim16 1 year ago
There's also a Viet version of this song. Lol.
igotsunao 1 year ago
KOREAN!
MiaoXinGan 1 year ago
It's the KOREAN version of a MANDARIN CHINESE song by a TAIWANESE SINGER, Pan Weibo, OKAY PEOPLE????
avplaya 1 year ago
hmmm... its korean.... not Taiwanese... sounds like a cover
HmOoBYajboi24 1 year ago
The original song is mandarin, or from taiwan, either way, the subs are chinese characters. all the other languages are remixes and covers.
legomaniaccraz 1 year ago
The song is korean, the mv is chinese.
DucksGoMoooooooo 1 year ago
korean
hiitspiggy 1 year ago
This is like a remix of the english, korean, and chinese version. Originally, this song was produced by freestyle - please tell me why (krn) then there was a chinese version bu de bu ai by wilber pan, then the english version..
KcKelLi 1 year ago
wow david choi favourited this? o.O i rmb listening to this song few years ago
Olivievie 1 year ago 5
its korean
potatoman08 1 year ago
Actually the song and the mv doesn't match, the subtitle is Chinese, but it's singing in Korean, the song is a Chinese song originally, maybe cover by some Korean singer with Korean lyrics.
MrMattLiu 1 year ago
Screw it! let's just enjoy the TAIWANESE song that this person posted K? :D
IJustEpicFailed 1 year ago 42
@IJustEpicFailed But..the language is Korean.. :O
WonderfulMrShyne 1 year ago
@IJustEpicFailed its not taiwanese... its korean and yes you did just epic failed LOL
choybo1 1 year ago 3
@IJustEpicFailed This song is chinese.
Mrclimber17 8 months ago
@IJustEpicFailed fuck up. this song is chinese
afterth0ughts 8 months ago
i heard at the end of an mmv i just cant help searchin it up
zob114able 1 year ago
sounds better in chinese
fatmanswimming 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Will Pan's Bu De Bu Ai was released on 01 Feburary 2006
Freestyle's Y(Please tell me why) was released on 13 July 2004
Who did COPY this song?
dsm5259 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
tis song sucks!!!!
darkterrous 1 year ago
why does everybody hate on peops who cover songs?
peops cover songs, bcs they think the song is great o=
LiivingMyLife 1 year ago
love this song!!!
MyBobalina 1 year ago
cette chancon n'est pas chinoise, original est coreenne, "Y"
bellemonique328 1 year ago
this is such a swweeet song =D
woahCxDuel 1 year ago
this is korean???
wow they made a lot of languages...
i like the chinese!!! korean!!! and english!!!
LOLzItzMEteehee 1 year ago
i dont find any difference in Korean chinease or japanease srry
Slayer1571 1 year ago
@Slayer1571 thats like i saying i dont find anything different in GERMAN, FRENCH, and AMERICAN.
TheRunescapePlayerz 1 year ago 16
@TheRunescapePlayerz actually It's not. It would be more like old English and modern English. Japanese, Chinese, and Korean can be easily mistaken for those who haven't been taught or learned any of their history.
Malco119 1 year ago
@Malco119 (shaking head) actually YES, and you already got my point. German, French, America, do seem the same, IF i havnt been taught or learned about their history. not to prolong this argument, we dont know the different in your language just like you dont know the different in ours.
TheRunescapePlayerz 1 year ago
@TheRunescapePlayerz
Man. German and English languages are completely different
Malco119 1 year ago
@Malco119 so is korean/chinese and japanese
TheRunescapePlayerz 1 year ago
nice video
woahCxDuel 1 year ago
ITS KOREAN .
jhaicaMelody 1 year ago
this version is korean not english @.@
princesscandy2595 1 year ago
it's korean.
narutofreak94 1 year ago
This Song Original Language Is Chinese, Theres Been A Shit Load Of Remixs Of It, Like Thai, Korean And English
MangaPlusAnime 1 year ago
awsome ;3
pancakehuntachibi 1 year ago
@Mojoheart the song is orignally from korean group "freestyle". Theres been many remakes of it.
freakingsagwa 1 year ago
@freakingsagwa no the songs origin is chinese
MangaPlusAnime 1 year ago
@MangaPlusAnime Lol trust me the original is korean. This singer remade MANY korean songs
freakingsagwa 1 year ago
this is english and korean
PAIGERINES 1 year ago
i dont think this is full english is full English and Korean
jiawenrebecca 1 year ago
Comment removed
annlaurenz 1 year ago
thanks for the upload and taking the time to write out the lyrics really appreciate it ^^
tngpremox2 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
chinese, taiwan..
stop copy !!
bsh5024 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
chinese, taiwan..
stop copy !! pleses!!!
bsh5024 1 year ago
it's really confusing having...english....and korean together...w/ chinese subtitles for those people who understand all three(like me.....)
kellyyunrocks 1 year ago
the guy is speaking korean.
i am korean so i know what he is saying.
the written subtitles are not korean however.
911aaron 1 year ago
Oh and the korean version (this one) is the original. chinese version copied this.
i love the chinese version thuogh ^^
911aaron 1 year ago
ans :
Girl:English
Boy:Korean
ANS2:i know because i learn korean and cantonese
AiZaiShotz 1 year ago
I think it's chinese, because those 'characters' are in Chinese.
And I understand chinese :)
CarmenDegoDeng 1 year ago
@CarmenDegoDeng its korean and english, this is the video to the chinese version
myssvang 1 year ago
@CarmenDegoDeng No the song is in Korean but it originally in Chinese
MangaPlusAnime 1 year ago
it's not cantonese, it's korean..........
original chinese song title-不得不爱 by Wilber Pan 潘玮柏
MusicOFcGame 1 year ago
original song = korean "tell me why"
music video = mandarin "bu de bu ai"
someone just did an audio swap.... gg
TypeR89 1 year ago
@TypeR89 No, original is Chinese
MangaPlusAnime 1 year ago
@TypeR89 original is chinese
MangaPlusAnime 1 year ago
@MangaPlusAnime its not.. the end
TypeR89 1 year ago
that's Korean !
YamK36 1 year ago
It's cantonese(chinese) lol i study mandarin (chinese)and its very similar... so ya its chinese
BucknoodlesExtreme 1 year ago
I love this!!!!!
joannieyyyy 1 year ago
*.*
thaofeatmaja 1 year ago
lindooooooooooooooooo<33333333333
gatobrija 1 year ago
The original song is CHINESE, this version is KOREAN.
kamakazi2o6 2 years ago
lol dumbass
MrSparkys 2 years ago
lol troll/no life/white boy
kamakazi2o6 2 years ago
@kamakazi2o6 The orignial is korean. Will pan remade many korean songs. look it up on youtube
freakingsagwa 1 year ago
this is korean
JohnJohnnz 2 years ago
I first saw him on Miss No Good and thought he is SO HANDSOME. And now that I've heard his voice? Ughhh... *melt
imagiholic 2 years ago
@imagilholic :
HAha. I k R. But he still cute/Hott ! <3 Lol.
iiDorkYneSs 2 years ago
this is please tell me why... not bu de bu ai. they are different
musician8591 2 years ago
I thought 'Please tell me why' is 'Bu de Bu Ai'?
HatenSuffering 2 years ago
i love this song n u i dont care if u taiwaneses
Vietnamese N chinese is the best gang ☻♥♦◘♣♠•○ :þ
supdog12cool 2 years ago
This Chinese Version is more popular simply because of Pan Wei Bo. Wei Bo and the girl here made it more serene. Not to mention this version is way way much better than the other versions... even better than the Korean's. Peace^^
Henjch 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wonderful *-*
Zergikun 2 years ago
wonderful *-*
Zergikun 2 years ago
Of course the CHINESE are going to claim this as a ORIGINAL version.
The fact is, this song was originally made by KOREAN group FREESTYLE.
I have 3 Chinese versions, 3 Korean versions, 1 viet version, and a tagalog version. THE ORIGINAL VERSION was always KOREAN.
Chinese version just got popular because there's like 2 billion people in China. That's why Yi Jianlian will be voted into the All-star Game, just you see!
Filipinos4Islanders 2 years ago
im sry but ppl like u only show ur dumbness
av3ragetomb0y 2 years ago
Can you please tell me who sang the Korean version and also the Vietnam version ?, thanks.
SHUNFAT 2 years ago
hahaha well lets see. The original was in Korean i cant argue that, but pan wei bo is from taiwan (well actually america) not china. Besides, china doesnt even allow youtube so it didnt get popular from china, it was a good song thats why it chinese version got popular.
flapplewapple 2 years ago
People in China don't need Youtube to hear this song you know....
and it's a fact that there is a large population of Chinese, not only in China, but worldwide.
is it a coincidence that Yi Jianlian got so many votes for the All-Star game? He was 3rd AMONG Fowards in 08-09 season! 3rd!! mwhahaha
Filipinos4Islanders 2 years ago
Ok, the fact that Yi Jianlian got voted 3rd is probably due to his ethnicity, i believe that, but WTF does it have to do with this song? The fact that China doesnt allow youtube means that OTHER countries liked this song. There are a lot of chinese people i can garuntee that. Hell, im Chinese. Are you saying because im Chinese that i wont recognize that the Korean version was the original? Or that Yi Jianlian got so many votes because he is chinese? I agree with you on both, so why the racism?
flapplewapple 2 years ago
Actually no...people in CHINA DO NOT need youtube to hear this song. That's the point. This song did not get popular off just Youtube, you do realize that there are many ways to hear this song other than youtube right?
The fact that many CHINESE people liked this song and then passed it on as it being the "ORIGINAL" is the issue here. It's not racism, it's fact.
Filipinos4Islanders 2 years ago
Ok i get it. Im chinese. I say the korean one is the original. so WHAT IS THE PROBLEM? I dont care what the other chinese think, not everyone thinks alike. you cant say chinese as a whole when there are people who are chinese that agree that the korean one is the original.
flapplewapple 2 years ago
hahahah not everyone thinks alike? Tell that to TAIWANESE people!
They will get butt-hurt if u call them Chinese! I am not CHINESE! I am Taiwanese! mwhahahah
even tho their country is known as the "REPUBLIC OF CHINA" mwhhaha
Filipinos4Islanders 2 years ago
Yeh i know the politics in Taiwan are really crazy right now. Im not really sure if im Taiwanese or not cause only my mom's side has a history of ancestors there, but my dad was born in Taiwan after my grandfather, who was a bodyguard for Chiang Kai-Shek, came over and settled. So can i represent both or none? Also, like i said, not a all Taiwanese people think alike, some consider themselves both Taiwanese and Chinese.
flapplewapple 2 years ago
wilbers parents were born in china
moved to USA
gave birth to will
moved to taiwan
holds dual citizenship
remirap 2 years ago
I know, just not enough space type it all. Hes technically from china but he was born in america and moved to taiwan, so the part about him being in china isnt really important anymore lol.
flapplewapple 2 years ago
< < hate those who claim he sued
remirap 2 years ago
sued what?
flapplewapple 2 years ago
i meant "he got sued"
remirap 2 years ago
Oh really?
flapplewapple 2 years ago
yeah koreans keep saying he got sued
but he didnt
since no news in tw/china reported it
remirap 2 years ago
Oh... well I dont really get the point of everyone making a big deal out of this song... hahaha that includes sueing.
flapplewapple 2 years ago
Being a Chinese myself, I assure you that this is Korean, used with the mandarin video.
Under the Description, the first set of lyrics are in Korean, and the second set of lyrics are in Chinese HanyuPinyin.
yuxiang16 2 years ago
This video is korean. Except the video is used with the korean version o.o
afklord 2 years ago
the original song is mandarin.
Beccy1369 2 years ago
You're wrong, the original song was korean.
The chinese version was just remade and translated. *Rolls eyes* Get your facts right.
whitebloss0m 2 years ago
It's Korean:)
xproud2bapnayx 2 years ago
some part!
but other parts are chinese n english
ziOmilOd 2 years ago
ahh!!! i cant seem to find the whole english subtitled one!! no where to be found... argh
darladala 2 years ago
hey,can u send me this song lyrics on word??please..i reali want train sing this song at home..but u send me using WORD not chinese language or English..
xXKuzaiXx 2 years ago
RAWR IT SOUNDS KOREAN SO MUCH D=<
lolalsolol 2 years ago
Comment removed
iDramaholic 2 years ago
yeah some of its korean
iDramaholic 2 years ago
ARE you sure.. i do have to admit... some of it does sound like korean.. but i think it's madarin??? right?
kagomevangel 2 years ago
Amazing song.
Forrank 2 years ago
i loved this song scince i was little n i still do
ultracrazy2 2 years ago
chinese ! taiwan !
stop copy
hanRyuWave 2 years ago 8
Wilber Pan! YEAH!!!!!!!!!!! I Love YOU so.
Dreamzgirl82 2 years ago
@hanRyuWave including viets!
sweatdroplets 1 year ago