Added: 2 years ago
From: haskitt
Views: 61,868
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (204)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • One of THE best drum lines ever and you rocked it out!

  • Outstanding, sir! After watching this, I went to my drums and began to practice some more. I've got a long way to go. Great cover!!

  • @28josh - Cheers and keep rockin'! We've all got a long way to go. :)

  • this is amazing!!!! my cousin led me to this song because i had a rough breakup with my gf yesterday. this song gets me through it. thank you for this!

  • @Wizerslapski - The world is your oyster... recover well! Thanks!

  • thats dope dude!! i wish i could play like that!!

  • terrible job

  • This is probably the best cover I've ever seen. Bravo!

  • You ROCK!This is one of my favorites of Phil Collins he has so many great songs,but you rock on the drums TALENT for music is a gift!Keep Rocking!!!

  • Just love your enthusiasm. Thank you for sharing. Phil Collins is truly an awesome drummer and writer.

  • Awesome cover and tribute to one of the most underappreciated drummers in music.

  • man you rock....jam on m friend

  • I play this on my car to every new person that comes in. I have them watch the video and they are in Awwww!! I'm responsible for about 200 hits on here lol..

  • This is incredible. You've inspired me to finally take lessons. Thanks!

  • You're a beast, man... well done.

  • Man, that rocked! Great playing! Phil would be proud, I'm sure.

  • I'm an old-school traditionalist -- real drums for real drummers lol But man if I could get amazing sounds like that out of an electronic / midi gated / etc. set then dayyyum praise Jesus I done been converted!!! Dude you so seriously kicked major ass on this! Phil C. couldn't have done any better himself.

  • I always open these drum covers of Phil's work expecting very little. Gotta' say I was impressed. Good work.

  • Does anyone know whether there's a drums only version of this anywhere on youtube - I can't find one.

  • This is fantastic. Those toms sound like absolute cannons! Did you gate them at all?

  • Dude... we are not worthy!!! You rock Bro!!!!! I thought watching you, that you were going to whip the heads off. Scott, you are by the best drummer I've seen, that wasn't preforming with a band upon viewing them.

    I hope and pray that Phil is pleased with your tribute, I know I'm sure as hell am !!!!

    God Bless to you and yours, from me and mine.

  • my friend had the same drum set but it doesnt sound this good : D

  • By far the best drum cover of any song. 2 thumbs up

  • Amazing cover, Scott. I linked to here from the VDrums forum, where I believe you've kindly posted the Superior Drummer 2.0 presets for this. A truely iconic track from Phil Collins. The man has a unique drum sound and style, which is instantly recognizable. You've done a man's job, sir !

  • ... AWESOME.... !!!!!

  • Sweeeeeeeet Shiiiiiiiiiiiiiit! Awesome thumping! 

  • I've got a question. All through the beginning of the song you are hitting the pad to the left of your hats with your left hand. Is that just a timekeeping thing, flair, or something you edited out of the final version?

    Freaking amazing cover BTW!

  • @chiefynutz - There's a tom set to that pad... give it a listen on some headphones. I didn't want it to dominate the mix, but in hindsight I definitely could have mixed it louder! The right hand takes over later on on the right floor toms (although in a more linear pattern).

  • @chiefynutz Although you didn't see it much in live concerts with either Phil or Chester, in the orginal studio version, Phil played a floor tom in much the same way that "haskitt" is here. Even though, he's added his own flair, "haskitt" is actually staying quite true the orginal drum patterns.

  • @firstmusic00 It seems he is playing over the top of the original beat, adding his own flair, if I am correct? It makes it that much more impressive IMHO. This is high on my list of drum covers to copycat for sure.

  • @chiefynutz It does sound like he's playing over the original track. But as I said, Phil used a floor tom in much the same way you would a high-hat through much of this piece. Not sure why you didn't see it in concert though. Perhaps it just didn't sound right without the "gated reverb" used in the studio version. Either way, it's an intertesting beat and typical of Phil at the time. I suggest you find the CD ("Hello, I Must Be Going) and listen on a high quality system to check every strike.

  • @chiefynutz Its called hitting the high hat, which you are correct a method of keeping time.

  • nice.. good drumming

  • Scott, that was tight man. You did an amazing job on that. I just got in to drums and I hope one day I can knock something like that out. I have seen Chester and Phil knock that out live countless times, and you did them both proud.

  • One word! EPIC!!

  • Absolutely amazing man. A month ago i got my first drumset, A roland full mesh TD-6XT & DW3000 Double Kick, and have finally started in on a dream ive had for a long time. I also recently got superior drummer and came across your presets for this song that you posted in a forum, how i found the video, and am in awe. Ive yet to download the presets yet but look forward to doing it. One question though, I think all i have so far is Avatar, kit from hell, pop/rock, and cocktail. That enough?

  • @VisionCrys Thanks so much... I think that's plenty to start off with, although for a lot of these presets I used a couple different expansions. This one uses mostly metal foundry.

  • Absolutely amazing man. A month ago i got my first drumset, A roland full mesh TD-6XT & DW3000 Double Kick, and have finally started in on a dream ive had for a long time. I also recently got superior drummer and came across your presets for this song that you posted in a forum, how i found the video, and am in awe. Ive yet to download the presets yet but look forward to doing it. One question though, I think all i have so far is Avatar, kit from hell, pop/rock, and cocktail. That enough?

  • Great Job. Love this Song. Nice Performance.

  • Dude I have a love for music that is very strong, and I have to say that you did more then bring justice to this song....you just brought this song back to life. I am jaw dropped, you did an amazing job!

  • Pretty Sick man, was thinking of covering this myself and came acrossed this video...the drums sound great too, kinda changed my view on electronic kits as well. Great Job !

  • Great work!!

    

  • How much do you bought that drum ?

  • @coolsebas14 - it's a TD-4 kit with a bunch of added used pieces... I'm not using the module, but rather a laptop with samples on there. Altogether it's a bit of an expensive kit!

  • @coolsebas14 - A lot! But not as much as it could be... I skimped a bit on some of the actual pads. The samples and laptop/interface/software were the most expensive parts.

  • Awesome..I love this Song and you did it JUSTICE..Great Scott Thank you

  • Very nice job!

  • Damn!

  • fuck dude!! that's bad ass fucking crazy!! freaking love it!!

  • what's the name of your band? you should be in one. people would pay to see you play. I would. even if you just did a phil tribute band. like running a marathon. animal says "eat drums..."

  • WOW! That is all.

  • WOW!!! That was fucking fantastic! I could watch this over and over...you are trully a great drummer....keep it up!

  • wowwww...all i can say is FANSTASTIC!!! You are very talented drummer Scott!

  • awesome!!!! never heard somebody play it that good (sorry for my bad english I'm from germany) ,,... what plugin are you using? sounds a bit like addictive drums...?! anyways this song is awesome, fits right into my mood...

  • You sorted it out well very nice enjoyed every beat!!

  • From your lips to God's Ears about Phil Collin's spinal surgery. Damn your GOOD! You drum, from what I can tell is eerily precise, right on target your beats are here. DAMN YOUR GOOD DUDE!! God Bless YOU!

  • GRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­ANDE ! ! !

    Like in Ferrari says to Fernando alonso when he wins a race.

    Great great performer.

    Thanks for this incredible greatness drop.

    A great hug from Spain.

    :)

  • ANYBODY WHO CAN PLAY " THE DRUM

    PART " TO THIS SONG ; IS WITHOUT

    QUESTION, AN EXCELLENT DRUMMER !!! "

    I USE TO PRACTICE THIS SONG, WHEN I

    WAS A KID !!! AND STILL, TO THIS DAY, IT IS

    A VERY DIFFICULT SONG TO PLAY !!!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Astonishing, you actually made this track better than the original - how is that possible? Great stuff!

  • You just blew me the fuck away. You are awesome. :) Thank you!!!!

  • SUPERB!

  • Fantastic!!!

  • Phil IS drumming again.  For the new album "Going Back" he talks about how they used gaffing tape to help him hold the sticks.

  • I can;t keep my left hand like that

  • dude U Fu**en Rock man....I listen to your VID a shit load of times, ...its awesome how U can keep the beat tight. thanks homy....I hope U make it BIG

  • Top notch man! Great tribute! This song is great.

  • that is some brill playin

  • was it hard to learn to hit the drumz?Good job

  • i like it very much

  • AWESOME...!! Scott...I'm seriously impressed, dude!!! Slick setup. Gotta love that Superior Drummer. You stayed true to the song, at the same time adding some of your own tasty fills... a master at your craft.

    I invite you to check out a few of our recordings... search YouTube for "suttercain666"

  • Hey Scott, your spin on this awesome tune kicks hiney!

  • Thanks Scott to make me happy every time I hear your drumming - from Hungary

  • Killer!!!

  • nice drum kit, cool cover!

  • Sick!! I can't stop watching it.

  • sickkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk­kkkkkkkkk!! Can't get enough of it.

  • Cracking cover!! Seriously impressive!

  • MY brother is suffering from a spinal cord injury called Nerapolthy!He's disabled and the STATE of Calf. Has taken away his Disablity and is throwing him into the streets to live!He was United State Marine!.Go ahead thow are Vets.,into the streets !thats they way we treat our own people!I don't care NO MORE! The State of Calf. has smead his reputionl all over the place!So they don't have to pay him Benefit!This country!better stand up and fight for the rights of it people!

  • MY children have been taken from me from the dept of Social Service Dept/of SanBERNArdino County of Calf!For no Reason!I m a GOODMother and I've never hurt my children and my children love me and I love them!And I don't care what there bullshit excuses are for there lack of organization and there abuse of my children and my family!No More excuses !I DON"T CARE ANYMORE!I DON"T CARE ANYMORE!

  • can you tell me how do you did to reord that on your mac, I have a macbook pro and a td4 kit.. thanks a lot

  • Fuckin awesome! It looks like you have two Roland kits put together, I been thinkin of adding a second one to expand my kit as well!

  • I always smile when I hear stupid people say Phil is "simple" drummer. Complete rubbish!

  • Great Cross-sticking. That was awesome!!

  • Nailed it, sounds amazing .

  • Phil and Chester would be proud!

  • i enjoyed it from 0:00-5:18, keep up the good work scott, maybe you could teach me how to play this, i love the beat to this and to the "In the air tonight", it almost sounds like something" kitaro" tries to do. No offense to Kitaro.

  • wow!

  • That is one of the best drum cover i have seen, But scott has a long way to be as good as the MASTER Mr phil collins. that was very good scott most enjoyable.

  • Great sound and you got the lick down exactly. It is sad news that he can't play anymore. A great tribute.

  • Wow Scott you very good , I like watching you play, and it was nice what you wrote about Phil Collins too!!!

  • Still the "BEST" cover I have ever seen....still watching...

  • Awesome, especially after the 4 min. mark!

  • perfect drumming! one of my more popular songs by Phil. So much emotion. keep it up!

  • Pwnage

  • for you know who....you care, but just relax...love ya!!

  • damn, now that is true talent, I'm sorry we will miss it, but I'll keep this video in my specials

  • My gosh! That was terrific!! No finer tribute could be payed. Good on ya Scott!

  • I love this song.. great cover man, awesome drumming

  • DAYUM. You do work!

    That is AMAZING!

  • Wow!

  • very good.

  • Scott, as a wanna be air drummer  this is great stuff!

  • Most people don't ever hear the passion and skill Phil (and Chester) brought to drumming; you captured that - well done.

  • That was awesome..Nicely done.

  • And to leave it with you tonight.. one of my all time fav's...

  • great job!! must have been fun playing it, the drum sounds sound just like the original tune.

  • dude, i always wished i could play more than air drums.....i love watching your moves and trying to figure just what the heck your doing. great video!

  • Simply AMAZING!!!!

  • Wow man I wish I had you in my band in high school!!! That was amazing!!! I would not have joined the Army and still would have a band!! keep up the great drumming!!

  • cool dude!!!!

  • Scott you rock, I can't wait to show this upload to my 10 year old son. You are amazing. Thank you sir.

  • Still watching my friend....

  • great performance with new drumming partition ,great energy BRAVO  (my english doesn't enable me to express what i want to say about the drumplay but great)

  • dude you rock!! wish i could do this. plus i love this song too .

  • epic win. good work my friend.

  • Dear Scott, every Friday, before I leave my work for weekend, I enjoy your video, your ultimative genious drumming. Enjoy Scott's drumming is the highlight of my week. Thanks for making me happy. God bless you. Sandro

  • @sandrolaura - Well that certainly puts a nice ending to my American Tax week! Thanks, I'm glad you enjoy it!

  • @sandrolaura tHIS IS THE  A VERY GOOG INTERPRETATIONS

  • I'am a huge Genesis and Phil Collins fan and i really really wanna thank you ! You rock ! That was awesome

  • Brilliant playing, fantastic talent !! Just send you a message :)

  • Brilliant playing, great talent !!!! Just send you a message :)

  • AWESOME! You did a fantastic cover of Phil's drumming. I have always liked this song and Phll Collins musical talent and genius in general. Great job! I used to play, but broke my neck in a diving accident 30 years ago and have often thought of trying to rig some kind of system up to work for a quad (i.e. Def Leopard). Anyway, thoroughly enjoyed your video!

  • Awesome!

  • Wow! I really had tears in my eyes while hearing this. That was incredible!

  • Badass great job on a badass song!

  • HOLY SHIT

  • i can watch tis all frigg'n day. love the song . and this dude rocks

  • That rendition should get you laid several times.

  • Awesome!!

    Thanks for the post!

  • I always hated electronic drums vs acoustic ( the sound and feel ) But, i watched and listened to your video and, I have to say this...GREAT JOB and,GREAT SOUND!!.

  • I am Sndro from Germany. Oh my god, you are a real genious, for me it sounds better than from Phil or Chester. In other Clip you played Guitar also very well. I give you 11 points out of 10 !!! In that league you are playing, you must come from England, right?

    Where can I buy a ticket to see you live ??

  • Wow.. Really good...!

    Looks like good practice for the left hand..

    Does the pattern switch form left to right during the first part of the song?..

  • This has go to be the best cover i have ever heard,100 stars!

  • Very Impressive!

  • i think im in love

  • this is the song i want to cover next wih all instruments...

  • listened now a few times and wanted to tell you:

    THIS IS GREAT DRUMMING!

  • awesome job my friend

  • Now I want to learn drums! Great Drumming!!!

  • Nicely done. Phil and Chester actually play it a bit different live. But I like the fact that you stayed more true to the studio version.

  • great drum!

  • Holy shit, that was incredible. Great job, big thumbs up!

  • Holy Balls!!! I just cant stop watching this...

  • Dude...now I have to practice even harder...NICEJOB!

  • that was fantastic

  • dude - you SO ROCK!!!  This is the sikest rendtion i've ever heard!!! Kick ass!!! :D

  • sweet !! nice job

  • Whoa... AWESOME I love how angry this song is, and the power you added with your take on the drums. Always been one of my favorite Phil tunes. Fantastic job man.

  • You Rock my friend, thank you :)

  • Scott you rock. What kind of drum set up is that? Sorry not a musician here. Nice fill at 3:09-3:10 and 3:23-3:24!! Keep up the good work!!

  • Hey discjockey, They're all roland pads, and I'm using two Vdrum modules... a Td-4 and a Td-3 into Superior Drummer on my macbook pro. Stay tuned in the next week or so for some acoustic drum videos! Thanks for watching!

  • how about "why doesnt anybody stay together anymore" by collins ...would love to see that one

  • You more than do it justice. Sounds fantastic. Keep posting

  • Still watching, my friend....

  • I'm an Phil fan from way back in the days when Genesis was prog rock 70s up until Abacab -- Brand X too. Your drums sound excellent on this. I sent you a PM, you've got to share this preset! You did a great job with it. Kudos.

  • Hey, I'll get you the preset this weekend... thanks for the compliments! I love the metal foundry, but it does take some work to get the sounds you want.

  • Awesome job man. You are dead-on, tight as nails. Really sweet tone you have dialed up on Metal Foundry too. Would you care to share those settings as a preset. I just bought Metal Foundry myself, and I don't have a huge use for the Metal Presets either, but one like you have is perfect. Let me/us know what kit pieces you used, or again, if you could share this as a preset that would be incredible.

  • Yep... had a couple requests for the preset. I'm going to dig it up this weekend. Thanks for the compliments!

  • Absolutely fabulous !! Do you want to play music with me ..... In france

  • Sure, can you buy the plane ticket? :)

  • Great cover man!!!!...love this song, and play around on some drums myself occasionally ....hang in there buddy!!!!!!

  • pretty effin good!!! love the improv.

  • Scott, that´s absolutely fantastic! Thanx a lot!

  • how are you liking the metal foundry software man?, this is really good cover by the way five stars for you

  • Thanks man! Metal Foundry is awesome but a little finicky... it's so much more raw than the other toontrack libraries so it takes a little more time to get a "mix" on any kits I make, and the preset kits are a little too metal for most of the projects I do. So, the reason that it's a pain make it ultimately much more versatile because you form it to what you want to do.

  • Dude you phucking rock! That was so much more animated and from the heart than many if not most of the other covers I've seen! Nice!!

  • that shits right onn

  • very nice job I love the drums you are awesome

  • Haskitt, I listen to this version at least once a day.....Thank You!!!

  • That's awesome, thank YOU!

  • I used to play drums to this, but not nearly as good as that! It's all feel, and that was awesome! I'm really sad about Phil Collins not being able to play the drums anymore...he was so MUSICAL the way he played.

  • how do you have that many pads with the td-4?

  • I'm using a TD-4 and a TD-3, both going into a motu fastlane 2 channel midi interface. The two extra pads are plugged into the TD-3.