Added: 3 years ago
From: FadeToBlack2404
Views: 89,695
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (369)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Anyone expecting a live show to sound exactly like the recorded version is stupid. No ones perfect, you're going to fuck something up, your voice is going to give out at times. Its just going to happen.

    Phils doing an amazing job considering he also screams more than anyone else i listen to.

  • Pause at 3:24 ><

  • @TheMetalWaffle Haha 

  • Im an avid singer and I agree. he sounded like shit but if you think it's so easy singing 5 nights staright of this shit? Go be a rock star yourself \m/

  • Rickara's right as a vocalist my self(who does scream) it does takes it toll on us but I just don't u fx. It's just not right

  • Phil sounded awesome when I saw him. ATR foever

  • 1:57 wrong note. but to all you people talking about his vocals, sound quality on this vid is fine, listen to it... has anyone not noticed its sped up? And scream/singing daily takes its effects. hell, any vocalist (that doesn't use fx) would know that. Ever seen a deathmetal vocalist lose his voice... thats a bad show, but you have to think of the hell they put their voice through... try yelling as loud as you can but controling the pitch for a full 2 minutes... yea, harder than ya think.

  • Sick ass hell

  • Great guard there (whatever you call him) headbanging to ATR. This proves how AWESOME their music is.

  • He sounds out of breath and exhausted.

  • this song is awesome, but it dosent sound that good live..

  • i get he does this all the time so his voice might be worn out but that is SHITTY vocals.

  • haha hes a fuckin redneck

  • phil cant sing but he can scream live....

  • This was before or whenever Phil started taking vocal lessons to improve his singing voice. Thats why this is a bad performance. PLUS this was one of the very first times they played that song.

  • hey everyone check out the video we made with this song. it was for a comp at our school to see who could make the best video and we thought what better than all that remains. check it out, thanks

  • metal not that pop punk hardcore shit... saw these guys and trivium a while back it was a sick show.

  • mate id give anythin to see these guys live

  • its too bad phil cant sing live.

  • 2:56 nice iPhone!:p

  • y dnt ppl like bmth dnt get me wrong atr's the shit but pray for plagues is one of my fav songs

  • y do ppl h8 atr they are fuckin amazing!! two weeks chiron, this calling not alone and vicous betrails are fuckin unreal songs and phil likes halo what more cud u want lol

  • right i love bmth my favorite band and atr is my 2nd fav ^.^

  • The tune is awesome, but they are kinda bad...what's wrong?

  • @InterwebzSurfah It's one of the first times they play this song live. Cut them some slack. Check one of the newer performances. They are pretty amazing. The quality of the video also sucks penis.

  • hell yes

  • hahahahahahah BMTH hahahaha what a fucking joke, youd like him to suck your dick, cause you a faggit who listens to BMTH

  • man, your 100% correct BMTH sucks so bad

  • @Linkruto sounded great when I saw them.

  • BMTH is good,

    But ATR is better.

  • loooooooooool

  • Hey I know this place. Im from Long Island and ive been at that Colliseum before. Damn it I cant believe I missed an All That Remains concert.

    And on a side note. BMTH area bunch of faggot douche bags whose fan base include faggot scene kids and skaters

  • guittars!!! help him with headbanging

  • omg im seeing them live next fucking wednesday!!!!!!!!!! can't fucking wait!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • dude they are amazing live. just make sure your ready to mosh. i did it was crazy. wall of deathed too. crazy night

  • 3:25 lol

  • The vocals aren't that great in this vid which surprised me because i saw them in Ottawa when they came with Disturbed and he was flawless. Ah well ATR Rocks Face!

  • i hear ya, probebly sounds kinda shitty cause the recording

  • how can you like something so great yet like something like that?!

  • ur jelous i love BMTH better :P

  • are you kidding?..bring me the horizon sucks..

  • u suck soo fuck u u piece of shit :D if u got a prob with BMTH u can suck meh dick

  • ill pass on your offer retard

  • @leeea7x agree

  • @leeea7x

    agreed

  • honesltly atr just isnt right for warped tour

  • they had killswitch engage also which took my suprise... big step from blink 182 lol

  • nope not at all

    but yet again nothing nowadays is right for warped....warped tour used to be the place where you could see true punk bands now all you get is stupid scene bands

    im glad i saw all that remains at the mayhem this year!! :)

  • He has no vocals..

  • Yea vocals weren't great here although I've seen him do better live as far as screams are concerned but his actual singing is never good he should stick to screaming =)

  • On the album's his singing is godly, live not so much.

  • in a vid it's almost every time worst, go see them live, then you will say something else;)

  • i think hes got good vocals.

    it didnt sound bad to me

  • i was there his voice sounded better this is poor quality video it sounds alot better in person

  • poor quality would be shitty audio and video.. i think this sounds pretty clear to me... maybe just poor vocals? hmmm....

  • im just saying i was there and he sounded a lot better

  • @FadeToBlack2404 hmm or its just ur opinion against idk the couple of thousands of all that remains fans... hmm

  • @FadeToBlack2404 Or shitty recoding which in this case it is

  • @lumaric01 , I REALLY don't understand your logic. Because the recording quality is poor.. the singer sounds off-key and exhausted? You can hear his voice, can't you? He clearly sounded like shit that day.

  • @lumaric01 No, Phil Labonte sounds like shit at every live show. If you listen to his tracks on CD's, he's got about 3 different vocal tracks recorded so he doesn't sound like shit.

  • i remember when i watch this video almost a year ago before overcame came out. I was so stoked. Can't wait until a new all that remains album

  • i think his vocals arent as good because they just came out with that song, they play it live perfect now. its awesome!

    Give him a break, it was a new song at the time, Good footage by the way!

    i have some videos of them playing live also. Check it out

  • It would help a lot if someone else could help the poor bastard out on vocals, since he's stuck screaming and singing everything. I give him credit, that's a HEAP of effort. I'll bet Phil is just about dead at the end of a set.

  • this man does a lot of screaming in his concerts for a long time... give it a break... no one can scream perfect

  • wow horrible vocals..

  • this is a good song but, They need to work in screaming. thats why his voice is weak in this, he screams alot and then trys to sing clean.

  • I FUCKING LOVE THIS SONG!!!!!!!

  • week vocals

  • You should learn how to spell the word you're actually trying to use to insult the singer before just throwing it out there.

    Just in case you can't figure it out weak not "week" . This guy is screamin his ass off every other night, so naturally he is gonna have shows where his vocals don't sound perfect.

  • Haha what's up with the asian chicks at the end? Since when did asians like metal!

  • im asain but not a chick these guys rock

  • matt heafy from trivium is half japanese

  • ahahaha

  • songs ok i mean his voice is awkward for the song hehe sorry but overall good band. most give that part credit :P

  • his voice sounds kinda strained clean

  • lol love when girls crowd surf if u knw what i mena (=

  • Grab their ass ^_^

  • Is that all you grab? O:

  • they are so fucking awesome, i'm so proud to say they're from my town and my area. fuck yeah. anyway, it was a good video besides all the annoying people coming over you, lol, and lmao look at the girls face as soon as it ends on the left side hahah wow hot.

  • the ENTIRE TIME i was standing where i was it was non stop crowd surfers, i could barely watch lol

  • lol that person in front of you with his/her camera.. lol.. that sucks xD oh well, great song, and cheerz for sharing :)

  • Phils probably drunk or baked (or both)

  • Ok, heard these guys and heard Unearth live and well, Unearth is amazing, these guys rockt too, but..., if you get a chance to see Unearth, go see it, it will blow your face off!!!

  • videos quality on youtube is always a load of shit, he* doesn't suck live hes one of the most talented live performers there is.

  • corey doesn't suck live o.0 tard.

  • Crazy asian at the end.

  • ATR sucks live because they have little desire to finish quickly so he gone bad :(

    All That Remains RULES

  • get your fucking finger out of the camera assface cunt

  • i saw him live and he screamed perfectly fine, his voice must of been hurting in this video

  • Phil is the man.. love this song live and on the cd!!!!

  • cory taylor?? suck live?? lmao wtf are you talking about.

    slipknot was best live haha

    but this is just a hard song to sing,

    beings its not screaming of singing,

    its pretty much borderline

    it this type of singing deff puts a strain on your voice

  • does anybody realize he does this EVERYDAY. his voice gives out at times

    cut him some slack

  • they r one of the few bands i know of that actually sound good live

  • He can actually, I just think this was a bad day.

    I saw them live a few months ago and he was sooooo much better at this song

  • yoo wtf? i think hes singin awesome at this show. why is everyone bitchin? And hes probably the best vocalist in metal at the moment w/ vocal range.

  • Oh he does have great vocals. But it doesn't seem like he did so well in this video is all I'm saying

    I've seen them live two times, and he was awesome both times

  • practice makes perfect

    they played this song when they were still working on it

  • u cant just say they suck just cuz of one performance, u gotta watch other ones too, this goes for any band

    look up not alone from their live dvd then tell me they cant sing

  • Some singers just lose it after a couple performances dude. It doesn't matter if one performance is a bit shady. Its what you put into the music that counts. Take Corey Taylor for instance. He gets winded quite easily, but no one gets mad because they know hes giving it his all.

  • dude totally agree with you., i saw slipkntoa t newcastle a few months back in december corey made himself vomit anfter screaming get this...no other signer would do that unless they really CARE abotu the music they play.. liek corey or phill labonte in this case

  • That's dedication.

  • i agree with andwegiveup, look at other performances of him live, he actually sounds better live, but he sounds like complete shit in this video

  • Can i see you scream almost every day for thousands of people and still sound perfect?

  • godddddd

  • how big are these crowds?

  • wait this was at Nassau Coliseum!! i live 5 mins away! damn why didn't i know this. :(

  • nice my bro played at warped tour, hes the singer for Amity

  • LOL i love the random kid that yells "NO!" at 0:09 XD

  • That security guard is rocking out

  • I was supposed to see them on this tour in san diego but was too fucked up to find the entrance. I saw rise against tho

  • i love all that remains but i cant believe they played on a faggot tour

  • they were the only good band there, i seriously cannoy name another thats not gay

  • computer enhancement when it comes to the cd...wish live was better for sure

  • not sure its computers, i think it more to with him taken a break between takes and being more relaxed in the studio, but yeh better live would be good

  • I love his signing , live or on tape , for me it sounds good , i don't think he needs singing lessons , what ever , f'kin great song !

  • lol the asian

  • Last second...haha!

    ASIAN!!!

  • Wow! I love these guys, have never seen them live though.. What a dissapointment :(

  • i know dude, i went to go see them touring w/ In Flames november 25th, but i guess something was wrong w/ the singers voice so they didnt play, i guess i didnt miss out on much. In Flames ftw :D

  • the singer is pretty shit live but they still sound awesome

  • good point

  • he definitely needs some singing lessons to control his singing... he does have a nice voice on the records but doesn't have enough air to sing it live... that's why end of his words and screams happen....

  • he already goes to singing lessons... you go try and sing a song like this live after screaming a bunch of other songs.... obviously you dont know what your talking about

  • obviously... but it's all about practice :D

  • whoaaaaaa no offense but that guys BLOWSSS live. the actual song is sweet, but that guys sucks live

  • 1st of all, take an English class or something and 2nd of all, ATR is fantastic live!

  • hhahahahahah take an english class?? HHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHA ok then..........

  • yeah the guitarists are, but not the singer

  • guy* whoopssss :D

  • i saw them last November this video doesn't do them justice

  • I think Phil sounds good hear, sure a little tired and out of breath, but he still sounds good.

  • Lol, either Oli or mike really screwed up the chord at 1:58, hehe.

  • Why the fuck were these guys a warped tour?..they should have been at fucking mayhemfest!

  • i know, wut the hell!

    man all that remains is badass but they sound that good live

  • ya they should be main stage not gayforce i hope they r there this year

  • prtty good band but live hes not that good. i still LUV them live though

  • dude how many croud surfers were there?

  • how many would you think there to be at the warped tour?

  • AHHHH HIS SHIRTLESSNESS DISTRACTED ME FROM THE SONG MUAHAHHAAH. LOL

    I like the new song. ;]*watched it twice*

  • the video ends with asian chicks face lol

  • ok thats fair, but if you listen to the recorded song, the vocals have singing over screaming. phil is the only vocalist which makes it kinda impossible to do live. atr, respect (Y)

  • Great live, but the china kinda sounds like shit =/ Otherwise awesome

  • some people dont like concerts because the voice is off or some other excuse. but the truth is, the way ur seeing it is how they recorded it, they just edit the recordings, ur seeing the band the way they practiced since the begining

  • damn that was a crazy ass show

  • this sounds nothing like the album version. even the solo sounds tweeked. im not going to lie i like this. when you see people you see them for what they sound like on a cd

  • you know you're badass when you can run around on a stage without a shirt and still look good

  • finisher ur shot. ATR is rediculous live, yeah ok phils voice sounds a bit shaky in this video but ive seen them live and i have so much respect because they sound just as good or better then the recordings, live. Dream Theater have been around much longer and have soo much experience. ATR is amazing live and phils voice is rediculousssssss. also the new cd features different kinds of vocals phil might not be to used to.

  • People who criticize his voice need to get off it. Its hard to be in that position touring from night to night wearing your pipes out, especially when everyone expects you to go 100% each time. You try screaming that song perfect every single time you go out to a different town. Until then.. until you've actually experienced that, you can't say shit.

  • Yo, trevallica- Ever see a Dream Theater DVD? They are amazing live. I have seen the ATR DVD. I was dissapointed. Touring is just another "hardship" that comes along with being in a band, but if you can't play- you can't play. I don't understand why everyone gives their singer so much slack. I love ATR, but I'm sorry... The guy sucks. There are things the studio can do that you can't do on your own, and people should realize that before buying a ATR ticket. Hell, I wouldn't see

    them.

  • oh! and toured with 36 crazyfists :)....they were pretty sweet too. could've showed a little more support though here in texas though!...but oh well, i love 36. been a fan since bitterness the star.

  • man, i didn't even get a chance to see ATR when they came down to houston, tx touring with in flames and gojira. phil blew his voice out supposedly...this song and 'overcome' would've been awesome live!! the guitar work, drums, vocals on the album is fuckin' kick ass!!

  • its hard to scream and sing at the same time. try it for yourself. at the same time though, try singing and screaming through 8 songs non stop, and try to look good for the fans. I just can't think of how much vocal damage screamers will aqcuire after singing for such a long time

  • i saw them at the warped tour too

  • Have you heard his screams live?!

  • hahahaha and wow is Phil's singing voice HORRIBLE live

  • so many fuckin vids with SHAKY cameras.

  • It's a mosh pit!

  • before people say anything about phils singing remember they werent really used to playing this song live cause this one of there first times playing and when band plays a new songs like this before the cd comes out it wont sound that good untill they really get it down

  • o shit hes a really great singer but this is not good at all

  • CHINESE PEOPLE!!!!!

  • was this on long island?

  • Things to remember:

    1. this was one of the first few live shows they played in over 4 months; his voice was not in proper shape.

    2. His voice sounds like he stressed it too much previously, as would be expected if you hadn't been on the road in 4 months.

    3. His vocals were FAR too over-layered on the new album; his real singing voice does not sound like that.

    4. Listen to Whispers (I Hear You), the man can sing very well.

  • wow, not his best singing live, but cut him some slack guys, he's probably exhausted like hell, as much as he runs around the stage..... lol, still extremely good run though

  • he can sing fine

  • he definitely CAN sing, but remember bro, he is probably exhausted! its very hard to sign when exhausted, but its quite easy to scream...so remember...he can sing, but here he does a little off only bcuz he is probably EXHAUSTED (he is even sweating badly)

  • FUCK YOU BRO!

  • screaming isnt easy but neither is singer screaming is really hard, i had a fight about this with a kid in my class. he said rapping is harder than screaming and screaming is just a bunhc of idios... lmao.

  • his singing is kinda weird

  • and why is this?

    do you even know the dude well enough?

    do you think he sucks balls just because he likes all that remains?

    Maybe you suck because you are being a jerk off for no apparent reason.

    Dude, being an a**hole will not get you friends.

  • the guitars sound great, the vocals suck balls. I missed them play down the street from my house a few months ago and I was super disappointed. Now, not so much. I sing better than this in my car.