There's no denying she's still got an amazing voice, I don't blame her if she lips that note, if she did it live every time it would destroy her voice, look at Whitney, she sang all her high notes live and it shredded up her voice :(
he's telling the truth. There's a lapse in her voice. it's very faint, but noticeable. It's the same backing track used for every live performance. And just so we're clear, it's not the whole song, just the big note. No one can go from barely having a voice to being pitch perfect in one part of the song back to barely a voice, Not even her.
1) If you want a singer who gives 200 shows, concerts, promo gigs a year AND if you wanna hear every time a hard-to-sing-high-note, you have to accept...ACCEPT!! without discussion... that the singer neeeeeds some lip synch parts or whole songs. It's the "fault" of the fans. The fan makes the star! Don't forget...
(2) Celine makes a fantastic job.... Have a look at the concerts of Michael Jackson in the 90's. He used the same vocals from his studio recordings from the albums and performs with an head set, moves his hand to it to hide the non sync mouth of him! (just an example for bad lip synch performances...) Against all my musically professional meaning - I'm still Celine's biggest and really supporting #1 fan...
(3) ....and I travel after "A new day..." the second time over the half planet from Germany to Las Vegas, to see her again doing those baaaaaadly fake performances, pay for the trip more than $ 3,000.... WHY AM I SO CRAZY? Because musically, visually, physically, technically IT'S THE BEST CONCERT A STAR ON EARTH CAN GIVE! ! ! Sorry for my bad bad English, but I'm angry about this discussions, so I have to do that... if my English is right or wrong! Long live quality ;-)
beter doen jullie allemaal normaal ik ben een super grote fan van celine dion en ik en celine en meer mensen die echt fan zijn weten het wel beter dan jullie (dat zingt zei nie zelf. flikker op man dat is wel live en zelf gezongen dus hou er mee op nhaar te beledigen a,u,b
oK. She was sick (and is TERRIBLE ear her like that!) About the playback... sometimes she used to do playback, is true. She is Human. But this video was an official video, so, I believe it is live 100%.
oh guys Listen to me! at that part of her world tour, Celine was sick. Please stop with your echo. I followed the world tour and she had to cancel many of her shows because of that. Instead of saying something without being sure and making fun of one of the biggest singer, ask to a fan. thanks!
oh guys Listen to me! at that part of her world tour, Celine was sick. Please stop with your echo. I followed the world tour and she had to cancel many of her shows because of that. Instead of saying something without being sure and making fun of one of the biggest singer, ask to a fan. thanks!
did you (not) notice that she took the deep breath to dig deep and give it all she could? She was sick, and she shouldnt have been singing period. Any other artist (besides Neil Diamond) would just cancel and move on. But no, because she cant bare to disappoint or cancel, she went on...and did HELL OF A JOB!
the person who posted this wasnt suggesting that she was lip syncing, they were just stupidly pointing out that she missed the que with the BACKUP vocals, BACKUP is when there is someone(or sometimes a prerecorded voice) to backup, or prop up the singers voice, not lip syncing. She gets kudos for doing so well in this performance since she was sick.
What the hell are you talking about, there's nothing in this clip that suggests she's lip synching. And if she is, it's because she had lost a lot of her voice that night. She was sick.
@godessceline there is nothing at all that suggests lip syncing you dip shit! the person who made the video is saying that she messed up her que with the backing vocal track, BACKING as in propping her up and making her voice sound like there is more than one singing basically. its obvious she was singing. and the person who made the video has no life and likes to point out stupid live mistakes
this was replayed in a tv show that celine was on, it was played in front of her, she explained her sore throat etc, do you think her people would let that have been played on national tv if it were her out of sync with the backing track...NO of course not....so hence it is live,!!
If you do not like it is your problem! But do not make up lies about it! You're just jealous of her! Just because she sings better than the other singers that you like! I do not know what kind of fan you are. You're constantly trying to prove that it is a scam! But of course you never will, why those who like it really, is not talking about this stupid fun!
This is all a HOAX! This is rather live. And it does not force the voice to do this because this song is 1 step below the original music, that is, she can sing without straining your voice, and then stop for that kind of crap on youtube!
Isso é tudo uma farsa! Isso sim é ao vivo. E ela não força a voz para fazer isso, pois essa musica esta 1 tom abaixo original da musica, ou seja, ela consegue cantar sem sua voz Forçar, e depois de PARE por essas porcarias no youtube!
you do realize, that she makes the exact same sound when she is in the middle of the "MOOOOOOREEE" part at around 9 seconds in the video...like everyone else says, she was sick. her voice was raspy. shes allowed to have fluctuations in her voice.
There Aren't Two * Any's* Atall .. Its Just Her Taking a Breath .. And plus i dont see the problem Maybe she needed a little help that night ..c'mon her throat was almost closing for goodness sake .. lol
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
So... she lipped big note or she improved it with backing vocals? Ot maybe at some concerts she totally lipped it and at some concerts she sang it along with backing track.
Hmm, can't you people just realize that she still can sing this song? Sing her heart out. I know that she lip syncs some songs, but she didn't lip sync here. She can still do it like she used to, but she doesn't sing it live as often as she used to
yeah, she is singing her heart out... she's also lip-syncing for her life. yeah, she's my fave, but when i'm given footage from a live show and it's painfully obvious that she was lipping, how can it go ignored? I'm not that delusional LOL
You clearly don't know much about the human voice.Of course,if you take the moments when she had trouble with her voice as examples,she doesn't sound as good as before,but at the end of the tour,when she was pretty healthy,her voice sounded clearly stronger than before.The only thing she lost is the teenager-sweetness in her voice.
When the "Anymoooooore" starts, you can hear both Celine and the backing vocals, but then she syncs up with it. It's easier to hear if you're wearing headphone. I will take credit for discovering this on xXCelineDionXx's video when it was first posted. LMAO.
uuum, no, what I hear is two "any"s in the word "anymore"; she isn't in sync with her backing vocal. I'm using headphones, so maybe thats the difference, but I can hear it every time.
@speedorg oh guys Listen to me! at that part of her world tour, Celine was sick. Please stop with your echo. I followed the world tour and she had to cancel many of her shows because of that. Instead of saying something without being sure and making fun of one of the biggest singer, ask to a fan. thanks!
If it were just an echo, we'd here it for more than just one word. She's obviously using backing vocals and the sound mixer goofed for half a second and now it's more obvious. Oh well.
i heard it :D i been tryin to catch when the track kicks in for the big notes for agess, but i couldnt hear when it came in untill i saw this video and realised. btw......this video was taken from the 'star academy show'? and was the concert when she lost her voice....but could still somehow hit that note?? and you hear her singing the very last note of the song at the end and her voice is breaking....lol
Yeah, that's the performance they showed on 'star academy'... so basically they've given us proof that this is lipped or backing vocals are used heavily during the big note, but people still pretend like it's all live. lol.
ild like to see someone else do this on a good day! :/ fail!
gospofunkd 3 months ago
There's no denying she's still got an amazing voice, I don't blame her if she lips that note, if she did it live every time it would destroy her voice, look at Whitney, she sang all her high notes live and it shredded up her voice :(
SammSammmm 3 months ago
only Celine can sing even without a voice...I'm sure you couldn't even sing her worst vocal moments...
iwannab0123 3 months ago
he's telling the truth. There's a lapse in her voice. it's very faint, but noticeable. It's the same backing track used for every live performance. And just so we're clear, it's not the whole song, just the big note. No one can go from barely having a voice to being pitch perfect in one part of the song back to barely a voice, Not even her.
EthMan09 7 months ago
DEAR CRITICS & FANS
1) If you want a singer who gives 200 shows, concerts, promo gigs a year AND if you wanna hear every time a hard-to-sing-high-note, you have to accept...ACCEPT!! without discussion... that the singer neeeeeds some lip synch parts or whole songs. It's the "fault" of the fans. The fan makes the star! Don't forget...
MarqRiosTV 9 months ago
(2) Celine makes a fantastic job.... Have a look at the concerts of Michael Jackson in the 90's. He used the same vocals from his studio recordings from the albums and performs with an head set, moves his hand to it to hide the non sync mouth of him! (just an example for bad lip synch performances...) Against all my musically professional meaning - I'm still Celine's biggest and really supporting #1 fan...
MarqRiosTV 9 months ago
(3) ....and I travel after "A new day..." the second time over the half planet from Germany to Las Vegas, to see her again doing those baaaaaadly fake performances, pay for the trip more than $ 3,000.... WHY AM I SO CRAZY? Because musically, visually, physically, technically IT'S THE BEST CONCERT A STAR ON EARTH CAN GIVE! ! ! Sorry for my bad bad English, but I'm angry about this discussions, so I have to do that... if my English is right or wrong! Long live quality ;-)
MarqRiosTV 9 months ago
there nothing wrong with the video. there is not backing vocals. u idiot
saheelshah1 9 months ago
beter doen jullie allemaal normaal ik ben een super grote fan van celine dion en ik en celine en meer mensen die echt fan zijn weten het wel beter dan jullie (dat zingt zei nie zelf. flikker op man dat is wel live en zelf gezongen dus hou er mee op nhaar te beledigen a,u,b
TheRowdy40 11 months ago
oK. She was sick (and is TERRIBLE ear her like that!) About the playback... sometimes she used to do playback, is true. She is Human. But this video was an official video, so, I believe it is live 100%.
justeddme 1 year ago
Celine Dion, the greatest singer in the world.
But this was lip singing!
Proof: youtube.com/watch?v=_eymmDf6TZc&feature=related
That's a little burn to yah all!
You can hear it over and over again.. it's the same! But still amazing..
LiquidGold93 1 year ago
???
mateush990 1 year ago
I don't understand!!! What do you want you say?
rubendiamante 1 year ago
oh guys Listen to me! at that part of her world tour, Celine was sick. Please stop with your echo. I followed the world tour and she had to cancel many of her shows because of that. Instead of saying something without being sure and making fun of one of the biggest singer, ask to a fan. thanks!
nielsou 1 year ago 2
oh guys Listen to me! at that part of her world tour, Celine was sick. Please stop with your echo. I followed the world tour and she had to cancel many of her shows because of that. Instead of saying something without being sure and making fun of one of the biggest singer, ask to a fan. thanks!
nielsou 1 year ago
Poor! 1*
Gudulpif 2 years ago
I can't hear that... :/
but it doesn't matter, she was really sick that night.
Googaify 2 years ago 2
did you (not) notice that she took the deep breath to dig deep and give it all she could? She was sick, and she shouldnt have been singing period. Any other artist (besides Neil Diamond) would just cancel and move on. But no, because she cant bare to disappoint or cancel, she went on...and did HELL OF A JOB!
Celinefanatic07 2 years ago 2
this is is the sick phoenix song
Gaara321456 2 years ago
the person who posted this wasnt suggesting that she was lip syncing, they were just stupidly pointing out that she missed the que with the BACKUP vocals, BACKUP is when there is someone(or sometimes a prerecorded voice) to backup, or prop up the singers voice, not lip syncing. She gets kudos for doing so well in this performance since she was sick.
EthMan09 2 years ago 3
Normally when ratings are disabled you know the video contains some traces of bullshit. Can you not hear the lapse in her voice at 0:08 and 0:09
PsuedoSenator 2 years ago 3
she was sick asshole
steeephaniadion 2 years ago
What are you talking about? SHE WAS SICK! She had lost her voice!
piernaslargass 2 years ago 2
What the hell are you talking about, there's nothing in this clip that suggests she's lip synching. And if she is, it's because she had lost a lot of her voice that night. She was sick.
godessceline 2 years ago 2
@godessceline there is nothing at all that suggests lip syncing you dip shit! the person who made the video is saying that she messed up her que with the backing vocal track, BACKING as in propping her up and making her voice sound like there is more than one singing basically. its obvious she was singing. and the person who made the video has no life and likes to point out stupid live mistakes
EthMan09 2 years ago 3
"Dip shit"? Wow, how eloquent. You need something to help you relax, I heard herbal tea is good for stress and mood swings. Mwah. x
godessceline 2 years ago
this was replayed in a tv show that celine was on, it was played in front of her, she explained her sore throat etc, do you think her people would let that have been played on national tv if it were her out of sync with the backing track...NO of course not....so hence it is live,!!
jakeydog1987 2 years ago 2
She often sings the 'any' live even thoug it'spart of the playback note just incase it doesn't start!
ShuttleDiscovery 2 years ago
Comment removed
zzzooooo 2 years ago
If you do not like it is your problem! But do not make up lies about it! You're just jealous of her! Just because she sings better than the other singers that you like! I do not know what kind of fan you are. You're constantly trying to prove that it is a scam! But of course you never will, why those who like it really, is not talking about this stupid fun!
CelineDionBRA 2 years ago
This is all a HOAX! This is rather live. And it does not force the voice to do this because this song is 1 step below the original music, that is, she can sing without straining your voice, and then stop for that kind of crap on youtube!
CelineDionBRA 2 years ago
Isso é tudo uma farsa! Isso sim é ao vivo. E ela não força a voz para fazer isso, pois essa musica esta 1 tom abaixo original da musica, ou seja, ela consegue cantar sem sua voz Forçar, e depois de PARE por essas porcarias no youtube!
CelineDionBRA 2 years ago
her big note was not live..
mirko301 2 years ago
it's live....and she was sick that night, she was losing her voice...
Arnott1990 2 years ago 13
you do realize, that she makes the exact same sound when she is in the middle of the "MOOOOOOREEE" part at around 9 seconds in the video...like everyone else says, she was sick. her voice was raspy. shes allowed to have fluctuations in her voice.
jfong252 2 years ago
Comment removed
Gudulpif 2 years ago
First of all: That night,she had trouble with her low voice.
Second: People want so bad to see that it's out of synch that they really think they actually see it.
catchita 2 years ago
it's live
carolinebernardo34 2 years ago 14
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the very fake celine dion
petergriffin9901 2 years ago
There Aren't Two * Any's* Atall .. Its Just Her Taking a Breath .. And plus i dont see the problem Maybe she needed a little help that night ..c'mon her throat was almost closing for goodness sake .. lol
brodyntay 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
So... she lipped big note or she improved it with backing vocals? Ot maybe at some concerts she totally lipped it and at some concerts she sang it along with backing track.
Seresu1 2 years ago
I'm not sure that i get the point ?
what is wrong with this performance ?
She was sick and her voice isn't at her best ... but what's the point ?
hilaryduffe03 2 years ago 6
Hmm, can't you people just realize that she still can sing this song? Sing her heart out. I know that she lip syncs some songs, but she didn't lip sync here. She can still do it like she used to, but she doesn't sing it live as often as she used to
SeveralMimi 3 years ago
yeah, she is singing her heart out... she's also lip-syncing for her life. yeah, she's my fave, but when i'm given footage from a live show and it's painfully obvious that she was lipping, how can it go ignored? I'm not that delusional LOL
roberry82 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
even the parts she sings live sound weaker and bad compared to her old voice
petergriffin9901 2 years ago
You clearly don't know much about the human voice.Of course,if you take the moments when she had trouble with her voice as examples,she doesn't sound as good as before,but at the end of the tour,when she was pretty healthy,her voice sounded clearly stronger than before.The only thing she lost is the teenager-sweetness in her voice.
catchita 2 years ago
Wait. I still don't understand how it's not in sync with the backing vocal. :/
Explain please.
Racedude621 3 years ago 5
When the "Anymoooooore" starts, you can hear both Celine and the backing vocals, but then she syncs up with it. It's easier to hear if you're wearing headphone. I will take credit for discovering this on xXCelineDionXx's video when it was first posted. LMAO.
roberry82 3 years ago
what are you talking about?
this is tottally live, maybe you heard the breath she took before the start, or something echo...
Undercover990 3 years ago
uuum, no, what I hear is two "any"s in the word "anymore"; she isn't in sync with her backing vocal. I'm using headphones, so maybe thats the difference, but I can hear it every time.
roberry82 3 years ago 2
it's just an echo.
Undercover990 3 years ago
No, it's not an acho. Undercover990 is right.
speedorg 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@speedorg oh guys Listen to me! at that part of her world tour, Celine was sick. Please stop with your echo. I followed the world tour and she had to cancel many of her shows because of that. Instead of saying something without being sure and making fun of one of the biggest singer, ask to a fan. thanks!
nielsou 1 year ago
If it were just an echo, we'd here it for more than just one word. She's obviously using backing vocals and the sound mixer goofed for half a second and now it's more obvious. Oh well.
roberry82 3 years ago
i heard it :D i been tryin to catch when the track kicks in for the big notes for agess, but i couldnt hear when it came in untill i saw this video and realised. btw......this video was taken from the 'star academy show'? and was the concert when she lost her voice....but could still somehow hit that note?? and you hear her singing the very last note of the song at the end and her voice is breaking....lol
JamieCleaton1 2 years ago
Yeah, that's the performance they showed on 'star academy'... so basically they've given us proof that this is lipped or backing vocals are used heavily during the big note, but people still pretend like it's all live. lol.
roberry82 2 years ago
Yeah...but the biggest proof it's live is this:
When you look at live performances of ABM...they are all DIFFERENT, very different. But now they are EXACTLY the same 131 times....
Racedude621 2 years ago