Added: 3 years ago
From: Robocrat
Views: 52,658
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (260)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Okay, I would like to point out that despite whatever capitalist america tried to teach us about hating everyone else, Communism is not evil. In fact, it is one of the most reasonable and caring forms of economic structuring. I admit, it has not be successful in practice on the large scale, but that's due to human corruption. Almost every successful small scale cultures practiced (many successfully) communism, going back well before Marx. He just put things into words and added his own thoughts.

  • @macgregorcd im glad to see that ppl actualy know that communism is a form of economy and not a type of gevernment lol.

  • @clamshire Thank you, but, and I'm really sorry but this is really bothering me, it's spelled "government." And I wouldn't say people. There isn't that many of us educated people.

  • @macgregorcd lol i have no idea why the hell i said gevernment, that makes no sence at all haha

  • the american flag has red we must be Communist

  • A. there from jersey not a lotta commies in jersey and B. who gives a shit there music is awesome!

  • why isn't there a live version of this song out yet...

  • lol "red is a commie color"  XD

  • what's your prob with commies? :P not that i am one but seriously what's your problem with them? :)

  • who gives a rats ass about communism the only thing that matters in this video is the song

  • Well, this song sums up my life.

  • @Cowguy789 good for you good for you

  • @NobleXStud ???????????

  • red is a cool color and manifesto is a cool word, think i solved the mystery

  • Caring about communism was so 1950s

  • hehe i'am Kristhina... i love this..kkkk

  • The Catch 22 original was such a lovely classic, why did they have to fuck it up?

    Better production... my ass! That annoying hi-hat drowns out the whole song!

    I hate tom for re-recording the Keasby album just to piss off his old bandmates.

  • @loerez That's like, your opinion, man.

  • @loerez your arguement is invalid especially because of fallacious reasoning

  • @loerez We disagree

    But i can tolerate you nevertheless

  • ,, Another life, it could’ve been nice, but Kristina she won’t know what she missed. '';)

  • .... i want to stalk someone now.

  • 3 people were also crossed off of Kalnoky's crush list on January 17, 1998

  • YOUTUBE COMMENTERS ARE TOOLS

    but i still go on youtube bec it's an excellent entertainment channel. a shame.

  • @itskarmabxtch and it's a shame that i too am a tool :/

  • What A Wicked Gang Are We is SO not anti-American. You sheep.

  • umm guys wasnt it catch 22 who orginally sang it, so if anyone is comunist, which i dont believe they are, wouldnt it be the members from catch 22 and yes i know that Tomas Kalnoky was orginally the lead singer of catch 22

  • @daskabro3 Lmao, I know right man, youre like the "furst" one who is making any sense :)

  • I'm confused, when the hell did Americans get so self-centered? Not every damn song in the world is about America -.- Nowhere in those five solos did i hear anything being mentioned about 'Merica.

  • I hope this Kristina chick hears this song xD

  • Turst me guys, they're not commies and they're amazing.  Thats right, I also said turst.

  • @justkicktebuket Please define "turst". p.s. what's wrong with "commies"?

  • @RyanFalls Um, everything?

  • @LeBeastee Communism is actually a really good way to live when it's done right.

  • @RyanFalls Of course, your humongous experience living in a communist world allows you to say that, eh?

  • @RyanFalls Give me one example of when Communism has ever worked.

  • @TheKoeberto I said when it's done right. I didn't say that it was ever done right

  • @TheKoeberto

    hahaha how about one example when Communism was ever actually tried?

  • @Tylerscotsdale Please tell me you're trolling, or like 10 years old? Ever heard of the Cold War? Ever heard of China?

  • @TheKoeberto

    I sure have... have you ever heard of Karl Marx? Or the Communist Manifesto? Or maybe even Das Kapital? No society that emerged from the Cold War even closely resembled a Communist economic system cuz, you know, the whole government thing got in the way of that....

  • @Tylerscotsdale But it was tried...didn't say it succeeded, but you just asked when it was "tried."

    Not trollin', just sayin' watch your arguments against that guy, you blew the door open there.

  • @Tylerscotsdale

    Several times on a small scale, but all notable examples failed.

  • i'm gunna like for the song and pretend that little annotation at the begining never happened, ok?

  • a manifesto is a list of beleifs and a streetlight is symbol for street justice

  • That song isn't "Anit-America" it's realistic and points out the unholy truth that is america

  • this song is fucking beautiful

  • IM SEEING THEM TOMORROW OMG SO EXCITED!!!!!!!!!

  • im gonna go see them live tonight with reel big fish its gonna be badass!

  • I like this song. That's all I really care about here.

  • Retards, don't you know streetlight manifesto? wtf why would you ever think they're communists. no offense to commies

  • Just because Smanifesto is against America doesn't mean they're communists. Bands like NOFX, Bad Religion, Pennywise, Minor Threat, and so on are all anti-american in a sense; pretty sure none of those bands support communism, although I think smanifesto might be putting red (commy color) so they can show they're trying to demote American society; really not to promote their supposed communist beliefs.

  • @kickenwing30 It could also be that red, black, and white are the best advertising colors and fit perfectly into SM's theme in their music. Also, SM isn't so much anti-American as it is anti-what-has-become-American, in my opinion.

  • am i only one who dosent give a shit if there communist?

  • @whoaholy Are they communist, I always assumed Anarchist...

  • 2011 and the red scare still holds....wut.

  • AAAAAAAAAANNNND replay

  • ... How does this have anything to do with communism?

    What?

    Maybe I don't understand because I'm not American.

  • weather it be communist or not its a kick ass band

  • Comment removed

  • Well... America does have a communist undertone... Ever herd of the welfare system? People all pay taxes to a greater good (government)... I mean, the lines are fairly blurred both ways. Communism is not bad and nor does it bash America. In the 50's+ we were taught to fear the Red Army because, well the cold war. Palmer raids started and up until '94 did the whole 'war' officially stop.

    Point being, don't think as communism as being anti-american nor think that Streetlight as the same.

  • Deep inside we are all communists... We just dont know it, one can search for himself and come back with questions :P

  • 2 minutes of epic solos

  • I love how Communism has become synonimys with anti America.

    But seriously. I am a communist. This song has NO communist undertones what-so-ever. Not a single one.

    Get over it and listen to the music. Life isn't about arguing over who's right, it's about skanking till' you can't skank any more.

  • Actually everytime here this song I imagine Castro chillin' with a cigar jammin' out to this song.

  • doesnt mean they are anty american, they are against politaclly that united states practice just like other people from other countrys(sorry my english)

  • Who gives a shit if Streetlight Manifesto is Communist? It's just about skanking your balls off

  • It's all about the solos at 1:57 and on! :D  Wicked man.

  • Dude, if they were communist they would probably talk about it a bit more, and you drew conclusions by connecting fake dots with invisible lines. Plus, communism is a great government in theory, but in practice it is to easy to corrupt leading to people like Joseph Stalin and Fidel Castro.

  • I get pissed when i hear this song cause im facing the same problem since the last year.

  • actually the girl on the first album cover in red looks like a kgb agent hahaahah

  • This song is the story of my life.

  • @Myeyesplaytricksonme go for it mennn, all what girls want now days is sexx

    COMEE ONNNN

  • streetlight=music. not politicians. shut the fuck up and jam.

  • i jizz everytime i hear this band. just saying.

  • @afavs96 i hate people like you T_T

  • im gonna get a bunch of hate comments but communismusnm or how ever you spell it is good if its true communisum

  • how does this have anything to do with communism?

  • When I see it, I think about running down my street singing their awesome music!

  • I think everyone of us had such a "love" story :-<

    truly sad but beautiful

  • anti american? hahaha you're stupid  with a litle pennis "american jerk"

  • well kristina will never find out what a great guy sh missed on lol

  • "What a Wicked Gang Are We" isn't anti-America...it's talking about how people in general are irresponsible and always try to have others fight their battles for them, instead of manning up and facing their problems themselves. America isn't even mentioned in the song. "So here's to the boys who fight all the wars you will never fight for yourself" is the line that might suggest that, but it's America's own fault for getting that reputation lol. Oh, metaphors, you're so silly.

  • i had lost my cd with all there songs on it T.T" er and i dont feel like rebuying 1

  • Man That Trombone Is Fucking TIGHT!!

  • woah... please, read some books about communism and red and america.

  • why do people always have to argue through comments??? i really dont care if their communists or whatever. its good music. just relax and enjoy

  • @DoMineEyesDeceiveMe yea man i'm totally with you on that. People should relax its good music, ENJOY!!!

    Peace x

  • COMMIES GTFO

  • Every Form of government in the World is flawed and ultimately fail in the end. Communism is self-destructive, dictatorships leads to many revolutions and there are many more. Even our own democray has failed us. It was great when it began, everyone had a say and everything was equal. But our Democracy allows "additions" ( or in other words changes) to the original consitution ultimately contradicting itself. No government is perfect, no way is right.

  • @ReapersSprint We have no democracy, We Have A Republican Government Man

  • these guys cant be commy's... commy's suck at life

  • Everyone stop talking about your shit and listen to the song.

  • Epic instrumental Part.

  • ur description is perfect

  • They are not communists, they are just against capitalism

  • Wow, people actually discussing something in a formal manner on a youtube video, thats new.

  • if you want anti america listen to a little band called ANTI-FLAG you idiot

  • Places where politics should not be discussed:

    Bad sitcoms

    Late night television

    Youtube Videos

    Places where politics invariably get discussed:

    Bad sitcoms

    Late night television

    Youtube Videos

    Enjoy the music, stop arguing.

  • @acemarksman9 I'm completely agree.

  • watever people says bout diz band, ,i think they still do their best in each songs, ,they dont give their fanz shitz. .

  • For educational purposes from Merriam-Websters: Main Entry: 1man·i·fes·to

    Pronunciation: \ˌma-nə-ˈfes-(ˌ)tō\

    Function: noun

    Inflected Form(s): plural man·i·fes·tos or man·i·fes·toes

    Etymology: Italian, denunciation, manifest, from manifestare to manifest, from Latin, from manifestus

    Date: 1620

    : a written statement declaring publicly the intentions, motives, or views of its issuer

  • republican country, or democratic country its always changing and i really dont give a shit. its all the same to me. who gives a fuck? and why bring up such topics in such a good song?

  • lol. It's not spelled the same, but this is my name.

  • SCrew Communism!! that will never work!! America is the best country in the world!! USA USA USA

  • I don't think streetlight is anti-government

    i think they're more down the lines of anti- humanity.

  • i like puppy dogs!

  • the solos in this are good, but i still think the Catch 22 ones are better.

  • i love how this song is more about stalking than communism. "from class to class i followed her" :D

  • Contrary to popular the belief, this song appears to be about a teenager who is shy about talking to a girl he is in love with and not about a communist government.

    Just felt I should clear that up. :P

  • lol if i could thumbs up this comment more than once i would

  • @chinnygan obviously man lmao

  • @chinnygan what, no way! (jk dog)

  • @chinnygan OMG NO WAY!

  • @chinnygan I see what you did THAR

  • @chinnygan i would honestly wonder who came up with the notion that this is about communism... then again, this song's basis wouldn't make sense to a lot of people who never had trouble with girls when they were younger...

  • Comment removed

  • What do you have against communists?

  • maybe you should discuss the music and how fucking great it is rather than the political affiliations of the band.

  • :P they aren't communists. It seems to me you're just over thinking the name. its like asking if the band Linkin Park really likes going to a park called linkin. its just a word, man·i·fes·to [man-uh-fes-toh] Show IPA

    noun,plural-toes.

    a public declaration of intentions, opinions, objectives, or motives, as one issued by a government, sovereign, or organization.

  • fuck you they aint communists what if i made a band called trashcan manifesto and made my first album red does that make me a communist? no it makes manifesto a cool word and red a cool color

  • You think because their first album is red and that they have the word Manifesto in their name that they're communist? If they were, their songs would DEFINITELY have more messages there, not just one kind of anti-American song

  • @andyottito

    I know; I put that in there because in some of the earlier comments, people were debating about the stability of communism.

  • i hope they're communists like me

  • I like Streetlight better than Catch. But the Catch version of this record sounds better,

  • watch wrong whit americans and communism Obama tries to make a change in america and some idiots call him a comunist

  • @graskovits

    Who said anything about America being communist?

  • @graskovits

    We're more like a puppet state.

  • @Robocrat And the only one who can turn this around is Ron Paul.

  • saying we get manipulated ay? I like how you put it. haha

  • he is a communist

  • @graskovits English please.

  • @graskovits nice spelling, how about this............ u are what is wrong with americans............. obama sucks another drone for pres hooray. oh wait but hes black that must mean hes different!!!!!!!!!

  • @graskovits what wrong with your spelling? but yeah i see your point...

  • @graskovits what wrong with your spelling? but yeah i see your point...

    

  • @graskovits 1. i have no idea what you are saying

    2. many of us are as dumb as half a sack of potatoes, most of us dont even know what communism is

  • @graskovits Socialist not communist, they call him a socialist.

  • meh i dont they r communist, they r just in life philosofy and everywhere you look you can find anti american stuff

  • @KeybladeOO lol to you sir it kinda does

  • this sounds like it should be in spanish! lol

  • reminds me of a girl called jenny... from Dallas now in austin....ughh...fuck/...

  • sad day..... :(

  • i accidently gave u a thumbs down. and i was gonna give you a thumbs up cause of your bad memory lol and im probably gonna get thumbs down for backin u up but idc

  • In my opinion they just talk about problems with the gov't so its not just completely ANTI-American just like to say there opinions and a great band

  • they talk about a lot of different problems with society in general, like the album somewhere in the between is sort of anti established religion, and a few of the songs off of everything goes numb are anti-suicide. I'd say the most prevalent theme in Tomas's lyrics is existentialism. He mentions Camus in "Here's To Life", and songs like "Somewhere in the Between," "If and when we rise again," and "Down, Down, Down to Mephisto's Cafe" all have a lot of existentialist concepts in the lyrics

  • I don't think there's any problem with being communist

  • Love the solos

  • tom wentto college and left catch after he started a new band and just madean album with songs HE wrote

  • when she walked by her hair would dance a secret tango only i could understand....never heard my emotions about a girl described so perfectly lol

  • @burgler09

    Fuck you.

  • Stupid the first time? Oh please.

  • as to the remarks on the oppening...WTF MATE? i just don't see the connection.

  • in response to your opening comments on the video. here are my beliefs:

    1. Communist Manifesto = Streetlight Manifesto? Nah. the word manifesto is derived from to manifest or to reveal. the book was written to reveal the aspects of communism, the name streetlight manifesto is just a cool name.

    2. Red album = Communism? Maybe, but i mean come on, red is just a really cool color. i could understand though why you could use it to support your other two ideas... but idoubt it.

  • 3. Streetlight = Anti-American? i wouldn't say that, just that they disagree with alot of the policies of the american government, and alot of their songs talk about problems with just the world in general from the past.

    I'm not trying to say you are stupid for thinking these things, i'm just saying thomas Kalnoky is a musical genious, and alot of his music has to do more with problems in the world in general, rather than just america.

  • @shs1superfan you are so right... just because a band doesn't want corporate america sticking their dirty hands in the pockets of artist to make themselves rich does NOT make them anything but true believers in the AMERICAN DREAM!!

  • 4 Kristina Behrs on facebook ... I wonder which one is this Kirstina? :O

  • hey kalnocky wrote this song alone

  • Doesn't sound stupid at all the first time. You shouldn't be so insecure, bud. =)

  • But this isnt a red album....

  • yo i heard this gay ass band cover this the other day, catch 22, man, they don't even know how to play the honrs LOL

  • hey dumbass, CATCH 22 wrote the song, Sm covered this entire album after tom left catch22, get your facts straight before you go downplaying other bands music

  • tomas kalnoky, the current lead singer of streetlight, the person who started both catch and streetlight wrote this song, you're the one who needs to get his facts straight, not to mention this version is waaaaayy better.

  • Comment removed

  • No, Catch 22 didn't write shit. Kalnoky wrote the WHOLE album. He wasn't kicked out he left. You have almost everything wrong.

  • Thomas Kalnoky wrote the entire Keasby Nights album, which was originally preformed by Catch 22. Thomas left Catch 22 for personal reasons, then formed Streetlight Manifesto, then he re recorded Keasby Nights completely because he thought the original wasn't good enough.

    Please do research before assuming you know everything.

  • uhhh someone already said that, and i just said what i heard, soon after i posted the comment i found out for myself...

  • catch 22 plays this song on so many levels better

    it just sounds better and cleaner

    you have a bad ear i guess

  • actually on the recording quality i agree this was all done home made instead of in a recording studio with a label, but the instruments are played way better.

  • idk to me its like

    this version sounds too clean, and the hell no's and stuff dont sound good, i mean i love both bands but streetlight didnt do this one good at all

  • @AsianPuhssy

    So you didnt notice that the singer from catch 22 has the exact same voice as the singer from streetlight,

    Coincidence? i dont think so

  • maybe he should look up the lead singer of each band......

    suprizingly its Thomas Kalnoky...... for both bands! :O

  • i hate this song it totally applies like perfectly for me

  • thats supper :)

  • just fuckin enjoy the song for what it is

    youll ruin the song

  • manifesto: a public declaration of principles, policies, or intentions especially of a political nature

  • I love this song it is sooooo wonderful!! <3

  • Hey Robo, you do know not only commies hate America...i hate American government has well... actually most punk bands hate the American government cause most punk bands have some what of an anarchists view on politics. Also a Manifesto is a book of theories on the topic in mind, for Instance the Marxist Manifesto is a manifesto of Marx's thories. same for ANY manifesto. Red is also a color of violence which most of there songs include.

  • I rest my case.

  • @jimgreen198

    I think he was saying they arent communist.

  • Catch 22 do this song way better but it was nice attempt.....I absoutely adore this song!!!