Added: 2 years ago
From: TheMadonnaCN
Views: 346,702
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (578)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • BEAUTIFUL SONG

  • Sometimes I think Madonna lost her creativity because of this song.

  • not caught up in Glee - but i wont bash it either. just a pure dancer from the city right here. and Madonna helps me dance better than anyone.

  • Glee version is much better!

  • All versions by Madonna is Great !! and New York is the BEST city !!!!!!!

  • Other places make me feel like a whale's penis?? How does that work Madonna? Haha jk I love Madonna

  • @JmCamilaRox1 Very funny, but dork means what you want but is usually a belittling saying. It depends on the intention of the speaker if it is serious or playful in meaning. Still I appreciate your sense of humor. Languages are so unpredictable." No, not so," in Mandarin Chinese sounds like the English's "Bullshit". I am not kidding!

  • Comment removed

  • i ADORE how the songs on this masterpiece segue into each other.

  • ok

    how the FUCK could someone dislike the QUEEN OF POP, the most SELLING ARTIST in the world's music ?????!

  • @TheBlard ABBA, The Beatles, Michael Jackson, Led Zeppelin, Queen... For much that I like her, I can't cheat myself and say she's the bestselling artist.

  • @BlondiEmilio She’s actually even above some of them. She’s sold more than ABBA, Led Zeppelin and Queen. The only acts to of sold more are The Beatles, Elvis and MJ (and tbh, none of them will be releasing more music anytime soon.)

  • @somepups

    Elvis has sold more than them and Madonna outsold him years ago.

  • @somepups Exactly! those are the only 3 ones that beat Madonna!!! the only thing is that Madonna keeps making music

  • @BlondiEmilio I can agree with you on that. She the best selling female artist of all time and the fourth overall.

  • @OHSNAPWTF8 Well, Its her song. If you create something, you did it best how much you could so it will look like your song. Becase she created something she sings it best. Because its her. I think glee only gets similar and more Gleefied. Madonna is still madonna and for my opinions its best :)

    No offense..

  • Who the fuck is Glee?! cause everybody talk about that person can anyboby tell me who is she or he?

  • @carmen190995 Stop pretending that you dont know Glee..! I Can tell you are lying..! :D

  • @jajatecachesdereal seriously i don't know who is this person. Singer? Another internet "star" like rebecca black or something?

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I'm going to new york in december with school were going to broadway and everything i cant wait

    (Im british and it will be my first USA trip) it cost 1000 pounds but were saving up :D

  • This song reminds me of "I wanna be your dog" by The Stooges >:-)

  • glee did it better

  • @triptoyourheart123 You are the reason why the next generation of kids will make the world an even WORSE place.

  • FUCK LOS ANGELES

    New York City is MUCH BETTER

  • @lucasnovaes14 LA is boring and everything is far away only good thing is celebrities NYC is amazing its where people go to become something in life 

  • new york is not for little pussies who scream. best line

  • @fauxindigo its Wussies

  • Glee was wayyyy much better

  • f@#@#$ck! Im moving to NEW YORK CITY in 6 hours!!!!!

  • @80Jellybean Welcome to the concrete jungle where you can become a millionaire over night or get shot a stop sign.

  • i like when it says can't play it in your country...... I live in Canada

  • what century are we in again!!!!!!!!!! my gawd, next "you tube" will be burning books

  • it has nothing to do with the audio, it has something to do with the video, what year are we in again!!!!!!!!!!!

  • los angeles i for.. people who sleep!

  • I like Madonna, but I also like glee. I think that glee sung this better.

  • no queda new york es mas genial aunque cada quein tiene su concepto

  • I love both madonna and glees version of this song. Who says you have to like one or the other? You have to appreciate both versions for different reasons because they are very different. I think everyone should stop fighting. =] -3

  • Madonna is the best!

  • the true fans of madge really estimated ''american life'' and ''confessions on a dance floor''!!!

  • If you like the Glee version then go to watch Glee's videos. And if you don't like my attitude then you can F off.

  • lol i loved this song when i was 12 i look at it now and its very bad :(

    i have hard andy and hung up so i like her

  • NYC is the best city in the world!

    Chicago and LA = Booring.

  • @lucasnovaes14 u haven't been to Moscow baby.... MOSCOW, NEVER SLEEPS! :)

  • Comment removed

  • Glee's version sucks .... Glee sucks period though ...

  • i dunno why people are hating on Glee... it's not like they stole the song, Madonna gave Glee all the rights to use her songs because she loves the show.

  • blahblahblah al about glee x3

    but dit you here Strify´s version? :3

    hhaha x3

    But Madonna is awesome, i like this one the most ^^

  • Glee's version is way better. Sorry to disappoint you Madonna fans. It definitely has a very Madonna taste in the music, but I don't find it really energetic to show she really loves New York that makes her glad, and unlike other cities. It's almost as if she is dreading that she loves New York. And. Please don't bother critiquing this comment cos I will disregard any comments that come in.

  • This song might not have the best lyrics, but it's super catchy and awesome! :) ^_^

  • haha my friend and i r always mocking glee because we thought this song was theres! we say that the lyrics are so stupid "other citys always make me sad" sounds like a whole bunch of high school kids to us lol i was shocked when i found out its Madonna! lol srrryyy!!!

  • Church of Madonna. start that dance club/studio franchise already. Can't stand the heat? F off, off my street. I think if I have a girl.. I will name her Madonna. Inspiration. Trailblazing for decades. Hey, yeah, chica. Off my street...So glad she came back stateside... Back home. Wherever you roam, you always come back home.

  • WHO THE FUCK IS GLEE ANYWAY???

  • @OneTreeHillFanGr Ginger Cunt!

  • >.< why do people always argue about Glee. I like both versions. People are so immature about it.

  • @thatswhatsheread Also, please remember that Glee's version is actually a mashup of Madonna's song and "New York, New York" from the musical "On the Town".

    Madonna's and Glee's version are both good, and have slightly different atmospheres. Madonna is a little bit more mature and reserved in her version, while Glee's mashup is more energetic, upbeat, and a little bit more eager (as they had just gone to the legendary New York for the first time in their lives).

  • @AlexzPattinson totally agree :)

  • Why is it that all people who slate Glee can't spell?

  • @MrEColi You mean like how you can't spell "hate"? How in God's name did that become "slate"?

  • @james1200 If you had brain cells, you'd know that 'slate' means to disrespect.

  • @MrEColi You name yourself after a bacterial infection and I'm the one with no brain cells? Why don't you go slate yourself!? (There, I used your stupid, made-up word for ten year old.)

  • @james1200 I'm a bacteriologist, Escherichia coli is not a bacterial INFECTION, it is a bacteria which leads to other, well known infections. Again, lack of brain cells on your part. If you search dictionary . com for slate, and look at the 8th definition, you'll realise you are wrong. Also, I'm pretty sure '1200' has no bearing on your life so your name clearly makes less sense than mine.

  • @MrEColi 1200 does mean something to me so wrong again genius!

  • @james1200 I've been wrong about something so far? Oh, sorry. I thought when I was proving you wrong, I was proving myself right? Ah, you DO have brain cells - that's what 1200 means to you. Oh well, only billions less than the average human.

  • i love madonna and also glee and i have to say that glee's version is way better than this

  • Who gives a fuck about Glee's version? Madonna always does it raw and just perfect for my ears.

  • Just chitt --"

  • The resonance in my heartbeat with Madonna brought me here, and i dun giva shit of what Glee is.

  • glee did a version of this??? i saw the new york episode, why cant I remember them singing this....

  • @welaughindoors91 it was a combination if this and new york, new york

  • @welaughindoors91 They did, it was a mash-up of this and 'New York, New York'.

  • a 3 year old could write better than this poor excuse for a song.

  • No i love madonna though but dont be hatin on fing glee

    

  • I love madonna glee and glees version ten times fucking better

  • I hate to be one of those people, but no. Glee didn't bring me here and no, glee's version is not better.

  • GIANNI SPERTI brought me here

  • Madonna darling I love you but Glee's version was better... Sorry...

  • Did Glee do a cover of this? Is it any good? Don't answer, I don't care - Madonna (the original) is good enough for me.

  • thumbs up if glee brought u here i know idid

  • Wir haben das Lied gerade in Englisch, denn wir haen gerade die Thematik New York. Ganz gut, das Lied.

  • I actually didn't know Glee covered this :|

  • glee can never compare with madonna... mostly because glee is retarded

  • i cant believe a woman whos supposed to be some sort of sex symbol/artists just used the word dork in a song...

  • This version is awful? OMG. I don't understand!. This is Madonna's song, her song. Glee sucks.

  • Glee's version is better...

  • @textlover321 definitely not

  • this version is awful. glee.

    and that is taste.

  • Attention Madonna and Glee fans: the song she is playing is called "I Wanna Be Your Dog" by The Stooges and it is many decades old. This is cool though—I'm just saying.

  • what is with the lyrics... so poorly written

  • @everybodypoops11 ...Its techno. Its generally accepted that techno lyrics should make little sense as possible. I have heard worse...believe me

  • I love chicago!:P

  • i love mexico city lol

  • @haterboy19888 hahahaha xD mamasteee!! xD

  • Madonna and Glee are both great, it's so stupid to compare them. Madonna is a solo artist who's been around for decades. Glee is a TV show about a Glee Club who have introduced the younger generation into older styles of music. They do covers as a tribute to the original artist, and they also write some of their own songs. People can like one version better than the other, it's a matter of opinion.

  • @littleliondog my opinion is that most of that autotuned glee shit is disrespectful to the original

    but in a way, it is moving the next generation towards this type of music

    it has its pros and cons lol

  • Glee's version has better energy.

  • @Piguinz it's cuz they mashed it with "New York, New York" from "On The Town"

  • "I love NY" Nobody says the same of any other city. Have you ever heard, I love Budapest? or I love Beijing? or I love Glasgow or Bilbao or Tijuana? I LOVE NEW YORK TOO!!!!

  • i would have liked Glee's version if it wasn't a mashup.

  • she's the best :)))))

  • I never heard Glee's version and I won't hear it cause I do not give a fuck on Glee and their covers! This is a Madonna song and I love ittttttttt, amazing song from a masterpiece (Confessions on a Dance Floor).

  • @xxxTIN0xxx i hope someone forces you to listen to the glee version just to shut shut you up because you are rude as fuck...

  • @xxxTIN0xxx Got that right on the masterpiece comment ..confession on a dance floor is one of my favourite album of all time!

  • @xxxTIN0xxx Glee kicked ass at it. You should really check it out. watch?v=Jk2sDNj60-E

  • I like both this version and the glee version. I think the emotion and feeling behind the two songs are totally different though.

  • If you think Glee's version is way better than this, you're fucking deaf.

  • @thecoolestfreak I don't think so. I like Glee's version better because it has a lot more energy.

  • This is kind of wierd as i only had listened to the glee version :S But i like it ^^

  • new york is a state of mind....don't take this song so literal...its deeper than it seems.

  • i loved N.Y. after i heard this song..

  • glee es una payasada

  • this is so danceable!!

    I love you, Stuart Price *______*

  • Glee is terrible

  • I love both Glee and Madonna and I don't see why people are hating on both. I'm sure everyone at Glee loves Madonna and to quote Madonna "The entire cast was amazing. They're all so talented." ... Also It's a GLEE club of course they cover songs. How many show choirs do you know that write there own material ?

  • I don't understand how you people prefer Glee's version. Madonna wrote and produced this song. NOT Glee. Glee is so un-original now, all they do is cover songs.

  • @stupefyyourmind its the whole point of a show choir you idiot. what are they meant to do, hire simon cowell to gte his team to write them songs? with what budget? seriously ge over yourself, glee is harmless fun who happent o cover alot of songs and do a good job wiht most of them, including this.

  • Without Madonna's version Glee's version wouldn't have happened. Also it's somewhat unfair to compare the two since one is a mashup.

  • This video  watch?v=s6cPx3WD5Ho is the answer to all those who like glee version more than madonna version.

    GO MADONNA!!! O.O

  • I waaaayyyy prefer Glee's version, no offense to Madonna.

    I love Glee!!!

  • LMFAO Glee. No wonder America's failing.

  • This pics is sexy > <!

  • Stop talkin' about glee this is MADONNA'S song And i wanna hear comments bout this song!!! not glee's but anyway i LOVEEEE GLEE!!!

  • the version of madonna is softer than the version of GLEE

  • she wrote a good song, but glee's version just has more... pepp!! =D

  • glad madonna wrote this song otherwise we wouldnt have glee's EPIC version :) sorry i respect madonna but glee's version is way better

  • Glee version is better though I do respect Madonna

  • No fucking Glee did brought me here. My great taste in music brought me here :)

  • @BitchSnookiNicole I'll assume you meant *didn't. So in that case, doesn't that mean that the creators of Glee has a great taste in music too?

  • FFS why the hell is glee covering everything... what kind of dumb shit

  • @ujan0zbas It's a show about a choir covering songs, problem?

  • wow this is SO not better than the glee version! GO GLEE!!!!!! VOTE THUMBS UP IF U AGREE!

  • @1gleekafied i'd thought people would whore for money,not thumbs

    guess i was wrong...

  • @1gleekafied omg, you stupid.. madonna is the law

  • Guys music is music no matter whether it's a cover or the original…just enjoy the sound, they're all great :o)

  • I love this song.

  • I love the beat!!

  • I love New york , and I lovee this song ... but I think even if I will live there , my heart will still be crazy and not want to listen to me loool , I can dance , I can jump, I can shop, I can drive... but I can't take him off my mind lol , no matter how everyone says stop thinking, I can't ... lool

  • ..good song...Everything is Madonna do

    ...I think...Good job....

  • come on people... gosh, its about new york, its gonna be good either way...

  • i love Madonna but for this song i would prefer Glee version. s:

  • @MaRbeeLLaCaVaZooS so when she is ....and then glee....there has to be.something better that you can say....well not true...your eyes are on tellivision...i am so wrong...music only matters when it becomes part of a t.v. show...thank you for that...as a fan of music i now become a student of t.v. shows...but you are right...who did the best flintstones..b 52s?or???

  • @Simon4642 Truly it is right but on the basis of people who like music a little more encouragement as I do, but in regard to the letter & the legend that is Madonna, singing songs she is successful, but in this occasion I as a person & as viewers prefer a little more rhythm & not so "off"

    That is my opinion only

  • SHUT UP AND ENJOY THE MUSIC!!!!

  • BUT I also think this original is more...sexy and I think this represents the sexiness of New York whereas Glee's represents the excitement for going for the first time.

    That's what I think.

  • Lady Gaga's MARRY THE NIGHT is more powerful than this. ;)

  • @IFulliI but it doesn't mean is any better or any worse.

    both songs are REALLY good pop/dance tracks concerning one's love for NYC. one's explicit and one's implicit. both are extremely wonderful in their own rights.

  • @IFulliI I'm a Gaga fan, and Marry The Night is good, but your comment is fuckin' pointless. We don't care which song is more powerful, they're both awesome. Although I prefer the live version of I Love New York, it IS more powerful.

  • Remember Newbie Gleebie's,

    You would not even have an opinion to talk about the existance of this song and it's horrible rehash by "Glee" if it had not been written by one of the most talented artist of our time: Madonna. You can bow and give thanks to her now.....um Hello!

  • I hate the glee version. It sounds too campy and kids boppy

  • Muy buena cancion (:

  • Madonna can't beat Glee in her own song. The Glee version is a lot better !!!

  • @Ricardoglee2000 I agree 

  • This version is brilliant but sorry the Glee version just made me more...excited and it made me feel like how I felt when I went to New York. I dunno...it was a mashup so its a different anyway.

  • Glee sucks. It shamed Madonna, Lady Gaga, & Britney Spears. People who think that songs from Glee are better than the real songs have no idea what music sounds like!

  • @LADYGAGAISQUEENOFPOP since when was knowing 'what music sounds like' being one track minded, and labelling any cover as bad ? - that's not loving music

  • @LADYGAGAISQUEENOFPOP You are so fucking right. I'm damn sick of people telling me that they prefer the fucking Glee version whenever I listen to my music. o__O

  • I love both the original and the new Glee version - Madonna rocks my socks but sometimes her later stuff is kind of like "house background music in a 90's RomCom when the girl misunderstands the guy and turns in a huff to leave the bar where the song just finishes with a synthetic symbol crash"... I just like the harmonies and backbeat from glee as a bigger "partying" type song... No worries, Queen of Pop, you my lady and you still captured my city perfect!

  • needs to be faster

  • I'm a big Madonna fan, but I have to admit that Glee's song was like happier, not saying is better, just it is more vibrant, maybe because it was a mash-up. Anyways, without Madonna Glee wouldn't have made the cover, so yeah.

  • Glee Version is better(; 

  • Glee's version is more, i dont know happy .-. But I like Madonna.

  • I am a big glee fan... but this version is better for me than Glee's version

  • Wow. I hated the Glee version. This is so much better.

  • LADY GAGA + GLEE = MAINSTREAM BULLSHIT.

    Fuck my generation

  • hallo to GLEE fans...without this song...there won't be GLEE!

  • @patdrox22 I am sure there will be glee without this song :D

  • @patdrox22 Glee is the best show in the World, do you ever seen glee?