Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (30)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • All three are good but different in style. Like them all. Maria is from a different era incredible in her own right. But this song was written for a character fifteen years old. So it sounds better coming from a young girl. But my favorite version of this was done by Carmen Monarcha with Andre Rieu in Tuscany. Carmen is probably tops with this aria. But I have Jackie's cd and probably downloaded every thing she has done. Love her voice, very warm and inviting. With more technical training wow.

  • BRIGHTMAN WINS SHE IS REALY INTO IT!! SHE FEELS THE PASION LIKE I DO!!! I AM AN OPERA SUNGER TO O!!!

  • Man.........Brightman really takes a back seat here to both singers.

  • THE TITLE OF THE VIDEO SAYS IT ALL.............."JACKIE EVANCHO SINGS LIKE AN ANGEL AND SHOWS SARAH BRIGHTMAN AND MARIA CALLAS HOW"

  • Jackie is a very good lip singer. There is no way a kid that young is singing.

  • @CanadaUK01 moron hater she is singing for real

  • @CanadaUK01 But she is. :-) Plus, many children are simply gifted with something. Then again, many doubters out there who simply won't believe. Oh well.

  • Then you better stick to listening to Rap, country twang or bluegrass. For you absolutely do not have the ear to listen to classical music. That was an ignorant comment you made...don't let your friends know that you're that "uninformed".

  • Outsung? Oh nonsense, anybody who compares opera singers does not understand, each performer is unique and special in voice, personality and qualities

  • @jgray110

    YES.....OUTSUNG!!!

  • @jgray110 With all due respect, neither one of them are "opera singers"

  • Sure the adults are better but have trained longer with professionals for many years. What is really amazing to me is how people are already comparing this lovely young 10 yr old girl to some of the greatest opera female voices ever. That is pretty good company for such a young girl. People that do this to prove she is not as good to me are really giving her such a big compliment just to compare her to these other two.

  • @BBBYpsi

    get with the program.......Jackie is ALL THAT.

  • @lanainfla Are you that dumb I was complimenting Jackie & sticking up for her here. I was at the same time saying how pitiful the people that were criticizing her are.

  • @BBBYpsi

    are you?  I REPLIED ON THE WRONG COMMENT. TAKE A CHILL PILL FART FACE..

  • @lanainfla Fart face? LOL oh my you just hurt my feelings

  • @BBBYpsi

    I wasn't trying to hurt your feelings........just making an obvious observation is all. And, I thought it was very classy when considering how much of a stunade you are.

  • Oh,... you can't disrespect legends like Sarah Brightman even if you are a Jackie fan (which i am). Someday there will be another girl as talented as Jackie and you'd want them to respect her,...so let's keep it a little real eh?

  • @spinedoc4U

    I'm real.......and truthful. Jackie outsung Sarah....period.

  • @spinedoc4U I have seven Brightman albums. She was my favorite "pop soprano" for many years - until Hayley Westenra came along. I havent heard Sarah sing recently and found her performance distressing. She was clearly in vocal trouble from the time she began to sing. Her vibrato was wobbly and she was pitchy. She sounded for all the world like Callas did at 50. Jackie on the other hand was better than I had ever heard her. Sarah may have better days, but Jackie was better that night.

  • JACKIE'S VOICE IS SO MUCH MORE PLEASING AND UNIQUE

  • @lanainfla You are so right. I feel the same way. I think she outsung Sarah on AGT and that's why Sarah said save your voice so people woudn't stop listening and admiring her.

  • @Idolheaded

    EXACTLY!!! So glad you said that. You could feel it in her voice with her weak praise of such an amazing young singer. Jackie is one of a kind and ready for prime time!

  • Maria Callas, one of the yardsticks by which we measure sopranos. Sarah Brightman, the successful singer we see today. Jackie Evancho, the soprano we get to watch develop from childhood prodigy to stardom. Nice video, thank you for putting it together.

  • lmao.. i like how people are getting all butt hurt over this video.. sounds like jealousy to me.....

  • little girl at 10 being compared to masters.

  • How silly. Callas, who was probably the best known operatic soprano in the last century, and Sarah Brightman, the best selling soprano of all time compared with this little girl? She has talent, but the song is transposed for her, and she has no technique. Remember how Charlotte Church sang heavy repertoire before she was old enough or had enough technique to handle it? Now she can't sing.

  • @operaroxmysox Church can sing just fine. She moved into British pop and decided that she doesnt like touring

  • oh please dont use Maria Callas with them... Maria Callas who is Master of Master

  • now thats how u do it properly.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more