Brooke White - "I'm A Believer" - Idol Final 5- 04/29/2008

[cheryblosen]

this was her biggest mistake! she couldve made final 4 if she chose a better song!

[btqy]

I love this song. When song by others.

[MrHankkey93]

don't sing a song that is famously known for it's male voice, it will just plain sound weird to most people

[42feenix]

i love that song too she was ok

[healthhavencom]

love that song

love her version

love her

[nyynygnyknyr1]

This is somewhat frightening.

[darrellkaiser11285]

The only hot thing about her is her candy pants. Also, she smiles more than The Joker!

[Scrubs9393]

pff >.>

[6969Narayan]

I can't hate this girl any more!!!! SUCKS! Saw her on idol yesterday and threw up in my hair......

[MrCaberto]

she should stick with the piano, this was thumbs down

[darealest006]

this was horrible.  I agree with Simon, this was a nightmare.........

[PopPrincess984]

i love how she plays the piano or the guitar (even though i barely watched american idol this season, its liek something new thats pretty cool :)

[mcmahoma]

she doesnt have a strong voice....wasnt my favorite

[shiningstar2652]

luv this song!

[Animehindu69]

U GO BROOKE!!!

[so102995]

she did a great job here she rocks

[Christiannorden]

I was laughing at Brooke when she was eliminated xD

- The person leaving us tonight is... Brooke...

-yep... yep! *sob*

HAHHAHAHAHA, couldn't help it, she should've gotten eliminated before top 100.000

[so102995]

dude how can u not like brooke she was like the best person on the show and let me guess u like christy lee right?

[Christiannorden]

No, I don't like Kristy lee

[osahju914]

i liked both...

[dcrocksmyworld1]

@so102995 DAVID COOK was the bast person (obviously)

[cmulwee001]

An update on a previous comment of mine. Her pre- 'Idol' CD 'Songs From The Attic'is NOT so great. Except for the opening track, 'Free'

the rest of the disk is nothing but slow songs, enough put anyone to sleep. Who needs that? I just turned my copy in{to a place called CD WAREHOUSE} and got money for it.

Hopefully, if she makes another disk, there'll be a better balance of fast and slow songs.

[osahju914]

same as teh aerosmith album... and another indie album my friend made

[lordhornet]

Terrible noise. How can anyone compare this with Neil Diamond= chalk and cheese.

[riotdotcom]

That is one of Brooke's worst performances along with "You Must Love Me". I think this her only uptempo performance.

[animallover1897]

I like this song=]

[meex45]

dude the words are are all wrog instead she used bullshit sorry monkees

[osahju914]

!the words were right

[meex45]

no instead of "she" she used you

[osahju914]

She's not a lesbian...

[meex45]

i dont care...

[osahju914]

i meant she changed the words to avoid professing love to a woman, lol...

[jamesm907]

I hate Brook White, she sucks and she makes me physically sick to my stomach. As a signed singer, i can honestly say that Brook White has to deep of a voice that she thinks is talent. She shud just stop singing.

[osahju914]

deep voiced woman are godo!

[qg6ff]

i just love watching paula dance lol

[darealest006]

This is classic karaoke! c'mon people. I close my eyes and i'm at a bowling alley listening to an asian person murder this song!

[cmulwee001]

Brooke is adorable. I LOVE her! I have her "Song From The Attic" CD. She has one of the purest voices I've ever heard.

[rainydayx17]

the shiny pants need to go!

[emereld42]

this song needs to be belted, not whispered, this was a awful choice for her

[bladerunnerb26354]

Yuck!

[kimahulimage]

God, this performance was a joke.

[rueter43]

She should have won 4 sure.

[cbgbs93]

that sucked

[DetectiveHolmes12345]

I love Brooke, however, this was her worst this comp. She tried to hard on it. And she is much better with the slower songs.

[CheeseburgerEdddy]

this was a nightmare

[doubleDdog09]

this wasnt her best, but i disagree with what simon said [not shown in this clip] that brooke was a "nightmare". i think simon was just being harsh, but the way he said it was still hilarious! it was even funnier than paula's mess-up!

[osahju914]

a carole king-ish rock

[kmarshall222]

she takes no risks ever. I swear she has a range of one octave. So glad she's off.

[pokecritic95]

this is way better than the original.what's wrong with it?i've watched 10 other performances of this song and i say that this is the best one.what's wrong?you all deaf?

[Blondesrmorexfun]

i love how she is totally massacring the song and she still has this huge cheese smile on her face. it's great.

[upiter38]

shes awesome!

[soccerndaseylover]

terrible. what the heck was that?

usually i love brooke, but that was terrible.

[chickforGod16]

brooke is awsome!!! i don't think it was fair i mean for the girls. Neil dimond songs were written for a low voice! not a girls. so at least she pulled it off!! so sad she is gone!!

[saramuzzammil]

the end was really good. and someon guys, she aint that bad...it's just that comparitavely, she wasn't upto the mark infront of archie cook and catsro..syesha or brooke...one ov em had to go...

[Bucho13]

YIKES! That was bad,she makes every song waay to honky tonk. Country is fine but hers is the cheesy country.

[osahju914]

she isnt country, she is rock!

[cilij]

What kind of song choice was this? it showed off her worst range ever....umm....she needs to go...i prefer carly over her!

[jgrigsby79]

OMG - this is hands down the worst performance I've heard all season!  Truth be told - I think the whole night was weak...wonder if they all are nervous as it's narrowed down to the top 5?

[alisafari82]

Carly Smithson goes and she is still out there. now thats what i call a phenomena!!!!!

[Sarttimi]

your telling me this girl is better then carly smithson?hahah thats hilarious!HOW THE HELL IS SHE STILL ON AND NOT CARLY?

[walmartcarretapusher]

Brooke is one of those grossly cheesy and corny singers who you hate but always hear on the radio. She's a Sheryl Crowe....blah.

[meather]

Poor thing, I was really rooting for her, but she just topped out a few weeks ago. Yeah, its time for her to go. I feel terrible sayin it, but yeah........

[catecreative]

She was so good at the beginning...

Now? She's so bad!

[ashley11201985]

ugh she needs to go. plese get her off the show.

[scototy]

FIRST!