weak - the singer's vocals carry no emotion at all, and whatever alexthemod1 says, Ian Curtis was an excellent vocalist, whether or not he cared to be
i certainly hope they picked up this recording in the middle, considering that the intro, which ran more than half the original length of the song, is most of what made this song a classic post-punk dirge
very disappointed, why cover a song if you can't make it better than or at least equal to the original in some way - cheap applause i guess
la verdad es algo intangible la descomposicion de la rola esta por de mas..... de verdad lcd sound sistem dejen de tocar esta rola no lo digo en mala sangre ni nada por el estilo solo lo digo como un buen fan de joy..... saludos a la banda
...and i'm not a purist or anything but the JD's original is much better, it's played in a lower key and has much better rythym and a rawness to it that's lacking in this cover. Love LCD though. Keep it up!
-----> amgk11, I'm jewish and I fucking love Joy Division. The name is horrible if you go deep into it, but the fact is that although they were a post-punk band, they didn't have any bad feelings, prejudices or resentment towards anyone, so far as I know. It's a punk name for a punk band, what do you think the Sex Pistols were doing? Just listen to the music
OMFG I absolutely hate nin, let alone their shit version of dead souls; but I like this, it keeps the punk warsaw feeling. Of course ivor45 has a point.
@alexthemod1 Prince wrote all his own songs, produced all his own albums, and played alot of the instruments. Jackson wrote alot of his songs including Don't Stop 'til You Get Enough, Beat It and Billie Jean.
I fucking hate that anymore at every show I go to someone has to sing along at the top of their lungs. Keep that shit in the shower you assholes. Either that or go squeal between videos on TRL. SHUT THE FUCK UP and let me watch the artist I came to see.
this song needs its intro tho... it builds it up so well
goonerballs 9 months ago
the horrors sometimes covered this aswell when they toured strange house
wreck93 1 year ago 2
weak - the singer's vocals carry no emotion at all, and whatever alexthemod1 says, Ian Curtis was an excellent vocalist, whether or not he cared to be
i certainly hope they picked up this recording in the middle, considering that the intro, which ran more than half the original length of the song, is most of what made this song a classic post-punk dirge
very disappointed, why cover a song if you can't make it better than or at least equal to the original in some way - cheap applause i guess
MultiNickDanger 1 year ago
@MultiNickDanger The sooner people get there heads out of their a-holes the better.
Just except that other people enjoy different music.
chinesespiders 5 months ago
this is a terrible cover- this should never be sung by anyone other than ian curtis
Jibbulo 1 year ago
la verdad es algo intangible la descomposicion de la rola esta por de mas..... de verdad lcd sound sistem dejen de tocar esta rola no lo digo en mala sangre ni nada por el estilo solo lo digo como un buen fan de joy..... saludos a la banda
aliengendro1 1 year ago
this is fucking rad
unfamous13 1 year ago
You're a wanker !!
Zelda36J 1 year ago
nice cover
...and i'm not a purist or anything but the JD's original is much better, it's played in a lower key and has much better rythym and a rawness to it that's lacking in this cover. Love LCD though. Keep it up!
LloydinMelbourne 1 year ago
@LloydinMelbourne no shit the original is better
spanky46758 1 year ago
really sweet cover, digging it
nightfall91 2 years ago 3
Hey I thought this was GREAT! props to lcd....
whoever said it sounded like shite is a little insecure me thinks...
rainallday 2 years ago 3
respect to the lcd
th0mas422 2 years ago
awful
alistahr 3 years ago 3
people hating on a shitty recording, go figure.
kwizzeh 3 years ago
LCD Soundsystem is cool band but this sounds like shit
DyllamDop 3 years ago 4
Worthless! Total disrespect to JD and all true JD fans.
RosalitaComeOut 3 years ago
ahahahaha youre retarded
MrPharmacist32 3 years ago
Yeah both version are great. Speaking about disrespect is stupid.
imaswinginlad 3 years ago
disrespect?joy division ? nazi camp?respect?nihilism?suicide?hate?no sense?what?
amgk11 3 years ago
Comment removed
bassmanUSSR 2 years ago
-----> amgk11, I'm jewish and I fucking love Joy Division. The name is horrible if you go deep into it, but the fact is that although they were a post-punk band, they didn't have any bad feelings, prejudices or resentment towards anyone, so far as I know. It's a punk name for a punk band, what do you think the Sex Pistols were doing? Just listen to the music
bassmanUSSR 2 years ago
i agree with ivor45
only nin the rest is crap
elBOBAnme 3 years ago
OMFG I absolutely hate nin, let alone their shit version of dead souls; but I like this, it keeps the punk warsaw feeling. Of course ivor45 has a point.
farswept 3 years ago
I hate it when bands cover joy division songs. No one can do them justice.
Ivor45 3 years ago
Crap. Wishes it were crap, it'd be an improvement.
adamv242 3 years ago
I think that this is a decent cover.
ASSDipsy 3 years ago
Crappy Shitty fucked up version
markez2012 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What an embarrassment to Joy Division music, LCD sound ussually great on their own songs.
mcleese 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LCD is an embarrassment to American music.
BennyLruce 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why all the new fucking bands play cover of joydivision!!!in special ofthis song is so poor!HEY IAN IS DEAD!!! LEAVE REST IN PEACE!!!
ecstasys 4 years ago
No pies lost.
jacoboram 4 years ago 2
He's even worse at singing than Ian Curtis.
LCD dont suit this kind of music though they are good.
4N3Y 4 years ago
ian curtis never intended to be a 'good' singer. good singing is for popstars.
alexthemod1 4 years ago 25
@alexthemod1 That's not a bad thing. Stevie Wonder, Prince and Michael Jackson where all good singers and pop stars, yet they made awesome music.
michael918273645 1 year ago
@michael918273645 Oops... kinda made it sound like Stevie Wonder and Prince are dead.
michael918273645 1 year ago
@michael918273645 besides stevie wonder, the other two didnt write their own songs.
alexthemod1 1 year ago
@alexthemod1 Prince wrote all his own songs, produced all his own albums, and played alot of the instruments. Jackson wrote alot of his songs including Don't Stop 'til You Get Enough, Beat It and Billie Jean.
michael918273645 1 year ago
THIS IS AMAZING!! Im going to watch this man at the hollywood bowl with one of the greatest bands ever, if not the best, THE ARCADE FIRE!!
andreandeahhh 4 years ago
ah, this is a good one :) apparently the horrors are goign to release an ep of covers and 'no love lost' will be one of them (apparnetly)
quellehorreur 4 years ago
Section 25 have also been doing this song in their recent live shows !....The circle is complete.
stakka79 4 years ago
wish that cunt would shut the fuck up...
bestyleeds 4 years ago
a message to dude who sings along and yells "joy division" at the end - shut the fuck up.
danomyte1 4 years ago 2
I fucking hate that anymore at every show I go to someone has to sing along at the top of their lungs. Keep that shit in the shower you assholes. Either that or go squeal between videos on TRL. SHUT THE FUCK UP and let me watch the artist I came to see.
tobywoo 4 years ago
JOY DIVISION!!!
elfeo11 4 years ago 7
I was there! They rocked.
brooklyntype 4 years ago