First time I watched the Wall, I was 9 years old, it was in 1988. My father was a sailor and he brought the tape secretly on the ship through the border of USSR. He could be jailed by that time. For freedom of speech and for freedom of thoughts you need to pay whatever the price. Unfortunately USA and UK not the same as it was. Now GAGA is ruling the world....( Great music. Thanks.
You know, I've heard a lot of people say that "rock is junk, whilst classic music is forever". In my view, it's just a matter of being in the right timeframe. If Roger Waters & Dave Gilmour had been contemporaries of Beethoven or Tchaikovsky, they would be hailed as genius, on par with the composers of Ode to Joy or Capriccio Italien. Comfortably Numb is a masterpiece, and therefore defeats time itself. A great song, performed perfectly. It's shame PF is no more. I miss them big time.
@rolandbrookscooke The problem is pop music. This money-driven product for the tasteless devalues modern music with huge artistic significance such as the Floyd.
I saw Crosby,Stills & Nash last summer and this was playing over the PA before they came out.I got a real shiver down my spine during the solo part.Absolutely beautiful.
i had the cd but now it seems its gone missing, been searching for this song online ever since...thanks a lot for the post! perfect cross between classical and rock
Stunning. I thought this was well orchestrated by Pink Floyd; this version doesn't diminish the original while at the same time giving a new emotional feel to the song. It blew me away. Thanks much.
This is brilliant! I found this CD in my basement, but it was all scratched up. And this song is completely f***ed up. So I'm glad I found this on youtube!
wow man, finally, thank you. I was looking for that for a while now. I bought that original CD more than 12 years ago but lost it. I was waiting for someone to upload it to youtube. I hate PF covers, usually, but the philarmonic just gives it a new look smell and touch. Absolutley beatiful.
You know you succeed in the game, when you got an orchestra playing covers for you songs. Simply Superb. Congrats.
LordLehmann1 3 months ago
2:16-2:57 is my favorite part...and then it takes off from there! I think Comfortably Numb lends itself to a symphonic version pretty well.
pnut7805 3 months ago
First time I watched the Wall, I was 9 years old, it was in 1988. My father was a sailor and he brought the tape secretly on the ship through the border of USSR. He could be jailed by that time. For freedom of speech and for freedom of thoughts you need to pay whatever the price. Unfortunately USA and UK not the same as it was. Now GAGA is ruling the world....( Great music. Thanks.
russiansarecoming 5 months ago
This is so going to my favorites <3
komoriaimi 6 months ago in playlist Pink Floyd Symph
NICE a another clasic great,great . long life david
hidegmarius 6 months ago
NICE a another clasic great,great
hidegmarius 6 months ago
Thank you HumbleAntagonist. It's a masterpiece
arval6 6 months ago
perfect! love it
GarRcio 7 months ago
It is so fucking unfuckable! Eargasm!
vixenius 7 months ago
You know, I've heard a lot of people say that "rock is junk, whilst classic music is forever". In my view, it's just a matter of being in the right timeframe. If Roger Waters & Dave Gilmour had been contemporaries of Beethoven or Tchaikovsky, they would be hailed as genius, on par with the composers of Ode to Joy or Capriccio Italien. Comfortably Numb is a masterpiece, and therefore defeats time itself. A great song, performed perfectly. It's shame PF is no more. I miss them big time.
rolandbrookscooke 7 months ago 3
@rolandbrookscooke The problem is pop music. This money-driven product for the tasteless devalues modern music with huge artistic significance such as the Floyd.
Selecta88 4 months ago in playlist Symphonic Pink Floyd :Us and Them
Very good playing, not really good "interpretation"...
It misses the feeling of the original part, and there is no ending solo!!!
Sorry, but I was a little bit disapointed...
bramilan 7 months ago
0 dislikes. Just like it should be.
thenumbaonerocka 8 months ago
Simply amazing. I believe this arrangement may cure cancer.
16Engine22Truck 9 months ago 2
@16Engine22Truck If anything can, it will surely be music like this
PabloMGP 7 months ago
they should've had a massive choir taking care of the vocals.
symphonicsage 9 months ago
this is so beautiful. i hate it so fucking much. why you might ask? i hate it because it ends!!
EVILFR3ND 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WHO LIKES PINK FLOYD?
I JUST STARTED A CHANNEL. CHECK MY VERSION OF THIS SOLO, SEARCH
COMFORTABLY NUMB SOLO GUITARISTIFIED!
I WANT OTHER PEOPLES FEEDBACK!
[THUMBS ME UP SO OTHER CAN SEE PLEASE!]
THIS IS RECENT SO CHECK IT OUT!
I will be doing more solos and covers soon Subscribe if you liked it!
Guitaristified 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
simply awesome
alexandraviann 11 months ago
simply awsome
alexandraviann 11 months ago
Has anyone heard their version of The Sex Pistols' Anarchy in the UK arranged for celeste, harp and strings? It's looovely.
fremsley001 11 months ago
this is pure magic...
geenezeta 1 year ago
this is pure magic...
geenezeta 1 year ago
more then beautiful..
RedIlija 1 year ago
more then beautiful..
RedIlija 1 year ago
@Tam1297 please answer!!!
santiagodebellavista 1 year ago
beautiful...
stephenkwok26 1 year ago
amazing thank you... xxx
malc2480 1 year ago
Yes I am !
MrOknoprob 1 year ago
I saw Crosby,Stills & Nash last summer and this was playing over the PA before they came out.I got a real shiver down my spine during the solo part.Absolutely beautiful.
Thanks for posting.
TheFutureadvocate 1 year ago
Amazing piece and i like the tracing of the album cover it looks really neat!
ECHO1NINER 1 year ago
My dad got this cd as an anniversary gift to mom who is a big pink floyd fan. I listened to it so much as a kid
1DarkPunk 1 year ago
Thanks for the DVD quality. Makes for a nice MP3 download directly from YT. Sweet.
Lolleka 1 year ago
Humanity is pretty awesome sometimes
IamPersonMan 1 year ago 6
Extremely impressive orchestral performance of one of the greatest Floyd songs. Thumbs up.
styleisaweapon 1 year ago
fantasticoooooo!
valeriolisci 1 year ago
They didn't even attempt the second solo. Dissapointing. Their version of "Time"'s awesome thougb.
TheGerkuman 1 year ago
absolutely amazing!
countryingirl1 2 years ago
very nice
DouchOfTheYear2009 2 years ago
OOOOYYYYY !!!!!!
kimolesen 2 years ago
this is just amazing !
arrapaa1 2 years ago
Superb! I'm a huge fan of classic rock and classical / symphony music, so this is a perfect combination!
LomtickofToast 2 years ago
Pretty good, but how can you not have the outro solo in this?
mjp407 2 years ago
i have this album and it blows me away
every time i play it all true floyd fans
need this in their collections
clockworkorange72 2 years ago
you dont need to be a floyd fan to have the wall in your collection, the second you claim to like music you need to have the wall and dsotm at least
idoknowit 2 years ago
I would love to hear Gilmour's vocals over this. This is amazing.
SimpleSingularity 2 years ago 32
@SimpleSingularity
HOLY SHIT
YOU'RE A GENIUS
I'M ON IT
lamfp 1 year ago
i had the cd but now it seems its gone missing, been searching for this song online ever since...thanks a lot for the post! perfect cross between classical and rock
fosquel 2 years ago
Divine
RameshKannanKumar 2 years ago
OH wow, Thanks so much for posting it.
Kirnus 2 years ago
Beautiful...Sheer Eligance, and wonder.
moondawger5 2 years ago
Pure genius.
Psychoo122 2 years ago
sublime awsome, thats its perfect!!!!!!! i go to cry
densoss 2 years ago
Comment removed
florescadena 2 years ago
nice version of a song that will never be equaled, of course it´s the london phillarmonic orchestra...
Thank you for uploading this!!
P/D: i´m sorry if i´ve got any spelling error, my english is not that good, thanks!
35882542 2 years ago 11
You're welcome.
And you English is fine :)
HumbleAntagonist 2 years ago 3
@35882542 you spell better than most english speakers. ;)
xsnokex 1 year ago
Stunning. I thought this was well orchestrated by Pink Floyd; this version doesn't diminish the original while at the same time giving a new emotional feel to the song. It blew me away. Thanks much.
wutevr63 2 years ago 5
its sad its missing the climatic gilmour solo but otherwise quite moving
Mysterypianoman666 2 years ago
It is a great version. I have this album and another track on it that sounds good is Breathe.
panga3a 2 years ago 2
This is terrific. Thanks so much, HumbleAntagonist, for posting this. A true gem, fusing two fantastic genres together.
Obelix5150 2 years ago 15
I'm glad you liked it :)
HumbleAntagonist 2 years ago 3
This is brilliant! I found this CD in my basement, but it was all scratched up. And this song is completely f***ed up. So I'm glad I found this on youtube!
darkmachete 2 years ago 6
I'm glad to've been of help!
HumbleAntagonist 2 years ago 3
FAR OUT!
Thanks for Posting!
verybadsuzy 2 years ago 5
Thanks for watching and commenting :) my pleasure!!
HumbleAntagonist 2 years ago
wow man, finally, thank you. I was looking for that for a while now. I bought that original CD more than 12 years ago but lost it. I was waiting for someone to upload it to youtube. I hate PF covers, usually, but the philarmonic just gives it a new look smell and touch. Absolutley beatiful.
farchielad 3 years ago 5
It's music. You know, sound.
NOOBLMAO 2 years ago
y love this music quiero el disco y no lo consigo
Padredelcaraguay 3 years ago 5