Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (42)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Lol, I remember Dilip Kumar singing this song in Ram Aur Shyam!!

  • Being a fan of madhu nd dilip enjoed the idea of noor jahan singing inthe background while theese 2 superstars r the imaginery presenters.

  • @madhufan1

    Thanks for liking my presentation. I am also fan of Madhu / Dilip like you. Many of my compilations are on this pair. I hope you will enjoy other songs also.

    Thanks and best regards

    Mukhtar

  • Another beautiful upload.Thanks,for sharing.

  • these songs look heavenly. Like either we are alien now or they were aliens. WHICH WORLD THEY BELONGED? GODS?

  • I have great respect for Noor Jehan and when her songs are filmised on Madhubala, both compliment each other. God bless their souls

  • Great song but according to my knowlege this particular version is sung by Surraiya, not noorjehan....there is also same song of same picture which is sung by noorjehan and also pictureized on her......kindly see that version. that version is also marvellous........plz rectify if i m wrong

  • matchless  heavenly voice

  • @saquibhafeez

    Thanks, you are right.

  • mukhtar saheb. your efforts replacing noor jahan to dilip kumar/madhubala is ofcourse admirable. it looks like they were in the film Anmol ghadi instead of Noor jahan/surrendra. your note about crystal voice of her, i 100% agree but only till her songs in intezar, dupatta, gulnar, koel etc. later..... i don't hestitate to say, rest were ''phatta baja'' (not necessary to agree with my views). anyway i fully enjoyed with the vdo that you fit dilip/madhubala.

    regards

  • @Svetka994

    Thank you Svetka ji for coming again to comment on Noor Jahan's unmatchable voice of that era. It is really so intoxicating old wine. pl also listen songs of movie Jugnu on YT for her beautiful voice.

    Best regards

    Mukhtar

  • Mukhtar Bhai, this song brings back distant memories when I used to listen to Noor Jahan Ji melodious singing on radio in India. It is a very touching and emotional song that I believe would only have suited Noor Jahan voice. Also, the dedication you put to create your alternative video to suit the song is greatly admired and appreciated.

    Best Regards...Siraj

  • @chotasagar

    Dear Siraj Sahib,

    Thanks a lot for liking, appreciating and encouraging my efforts. I am really happy and thankful that you have recognized my hard work that goes into creating a befitting video. This marvelous and matchless song of Noor Jahan and the enthralling beauty of Madhubala, complement each other so perfectly that it gave me the impetus to create a video, otherwise original video was also good. Normally I do not create for competition.

    Thanks and best regards

    Mukhtar

  • What a beautiful emotional song , perhaps one of the best songs, sung by Noor Jehan.

    Mukhtar Bhai your superimposition of this touching song on Madhubala and Dilip Kumar looks very natural. Your hard work in selecting and mixing the old clips so thoughtfully can never go waste. Keep it up .

  • @kuckudk

    Dear Sharma ji,

    I am really thankful to you for liking and appreciating my work. This marvelous song in the crystal like voice of Noor Jahan and the captivating beauty of Madhubala, complement each other perfectly. This is the reason I have created video, otherwise original video  was also good. I am obliged for your continuous support .

    Thanks and best regards

    Mukhtar

  • @Svetka994

    I am really happy and thankful to you for adoring and appreciating the videoclip. The voice of Noor Jahan and the simple beauty of Madhubala are icon of Bollywood and will be remembered for ever.

    Thanks and best regards

    Mukhtar

  • Despite lack of definition in some images of Madhubala and Dilip, the close focusing on portraiture of this golden pair, since the beginning, conferred a greater and pleasent visual impact to tihis new version of your video creation, which is , overall, much more dynamic and impressive than the original video clip of Anmolghadi. Thank you.

  • @musafir39

    I love the way you see my compilations. I am thankful for liking the "REDONE" version. The previous version, as you have rightly noted, was less dynamic The lack of definition of the clips was intentional to make them look as flash- back.

    Thanks and best regards

    Mukhtar

  • Thanks dear friend for sharing rare real GEM

    anjaam-e-mohabbat hame maaloom hai lekin,

    Lete hain tere gham mein umeedon ke sahaare..Tanveer Naqvi.

  • Mukhtar Bhai, thanks a lot for spreading joy on Y.T. with your excellent videos/songs.

    Noor Jahan Ji sings brilliantly in her unique,melodious voice with right feelings of Dard.

    Your favorite Madhubala Ji and Dilip Kumar Ji, the handsome pair of Film World are very very soothing to eyes.Madhu Ji the unmatchable Beauty Queen with her brilliant facial expression and beauty looks out of this World.

    I salute you for your very creative,enjoyable video.

    Thumbs Up.

    With Blessings and Love. Didi,

  • @jasbongy

    Dear Sarla Didi,

    The hard- work I put in creating the videos, is rewarded when I receive such a priceless appreciation from you. Your nice words always brightened my efforts. Such enchanting songs would remain memorable as their creators were really blessed with divine Souls. They remain always fresh despite repeated hearing as they permeate into our souls.

    Thanks a lot and God Bless you

    Mukhtar

  • hi mukhtar bhai adab. u r always best in ur creations. ur vintage is xlnt in all respects. one of the best song of noor jahan superimposed on the amazon buty madhu bala. tho lip movement didnt coincide, i can understand ho difficult it is 2 coincide 2 different versions. but ur efforts r highly praise worthy & u r suxesful in xpressing ur artistic feelings. an xlnt upload.

  • @jagjitisher

    Thank you Jagjit Ji, for your continuous support and liking my presentation. You can understand well, it is a very very difficult task to synchronize complete lips movement as all the clips are borrowed from various other songs. I have to keep the feelings of the song in view also.

    Thanks and best regards

    Mukhtar

  • Wow! What a perfect opening & a perfect closing!

    From the dramatic opening moment of her frantic expression of realizing he's leaving, to "giving up" in an angst-ridden expression as she languishes back to the Piano, in closing!

    Heartrending Song! Captivating Voice "defining" the emotional realism of a woman pleading in anguish to her beloved to care for her feelings & come!

    All done with matching lip synchs & excellent collage of film clips by the creative genius on YT, Mukhtar!

    Bravo!

    12FEB11'

  • @ritupm

    Thank you Ritu Ji, for describing my presentation so beautifully, in your insightful comments. I have created the video on the same perception of “ "defining" the emotional realism of a woman pleading in anguish to her beloved to care for her feelings & come (back to her)!, her frantic expression of realizing he's leaving, to "giving up" in an angst-ridden expression as she languishes back to the Piano, in closing!” Bravooooooo..

    Thanks and best regards

    Mukhtar

  • Beautiful song and beautiful voice Noor jehan Thanks for sharing such A wonderful song!

  • @ShahidAndShahid

    Dear Shaid sahib,

    Thank you very much for liking this really matchless song by NOOR JEHAN.

    Best Regards,

  • Wonder ful job done Mukhtar bhai... very refreshing video work... keep up the good work.. regards .. SS

  • @eddie21y21

    Dear Shiv Shanker Ji,

    Thank you very much for liking and appreciating my presentation .

    Best Regards,

  • Wah bai wonderful production. I have no concern with the technicalities but to say that the taste of the song has increased many time to that of we heard prior to it.. Sound quality and nostalgic clips are worth-praise.

    Shama ko aata ta bas jalwa faroshi ka hunar

    elm o tahqeeq ka fun kismat e parwana tha.

  • @56riazali

    Thank you Riaz sahib for writing so impressively. I love your expression: "Shama ko aata tha bas jalwa faroshi ka hunar".

    I want to disseminate love and harmony through music as the candle spreads its light.

    Thanks and best regards

    Mukhtar

  • Video is very well built. This Noor Jehan song is my favorite. Very Touchy Song indeed. Thx for sharing. You have taken lots of efforts to present this song again.

    Regards,

    Dr. Kamath

  • @nrkamath43211

    Dear Dr. Kamath

    Thanks a lot for liking, appreciating and encouraging my efforts. I am really happy and thankful that you have recognized my hard work that goes into creating a befitting video.

    Best regards

    Mukhtar

  • Maan I love this song.

  • Your presentation you vision so powerful which has made the song a strong presentation , you should be somewhere in film line.

  • Both of your fantastic clips do right to this song,that in the original is on Noor herself who just lies on a sofa,worrying-with that immortal voice of hers!But your first version is (IMO)much more expressive and fetchingly composed than the original;very fluent and natural.The second clip is even more dramatic,its diction even more fitting.The flashbacks tell more about the lovers' story.The first version seems better balanced to me,though.Wonderful and too difficult to choose!no space:)

  • @madhubala2009

    Dear Kiri San,

    I appreciate you knowledgeable comments. This marvelous and unrivalled song of Noor Jahan and the enthralling beauty of Madhubala, complement each other so perfectly that it gave me the impetus to create a video, otherwise original video was also good. Normally I do not create for competition. I am thankful for liking the "REDONE" version. I felt that the previous version lacked dynamism.

    Thanks and best regards

    Mukhtar

  • Madam Noor Jahan has magic in her voice Lata Jee voice has amrait !

  • @AghaZulqarnainPasha

    Dear Pasha sahib,

    Your description of both the legends is great.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more