@omairmazhar My only point was, don't label people, especially the Muslim scholars, if you don't have sufficient proof, and especially if they refrain from such labels and are against it themselves. I have said enough regarding the matter, so yes I'm done with this. May Allah (swt) Guide us all, ameen. Peace. : )
Can someone clarify to me if these guys are Salafi? Also Yasir Qadhi? Zakir Naik? And also Abdur Rahman Green? Are they Salafi? Just wish to know, I have no evil intentions. :)
@omairmazhar Is there any place/way where you can actually confirm this? Because there are videos of some of these scholars speaking against Salafis.. that's all.
@omairmazhar, Assalaamu'alaykum, how can you say they are Salafis, when such scholars themselves like Sheikh Yusuf Estes is calling them a deviant sect, and rather talking against it himself, check this video: /watch?v=GeN_hCqddhs
You must have sufficient evidence to back up or prove your claim.
i have seen the video link that u sent me before,yusuf estes only says in this video that he prefers not to CALL himself salafi.he prefers calling himself muslim only without going into other labels...and that is his own opinion. as far his ideology is concerned that he follows, he is salafi 100% and u can take your time to watch his videos on ageedah and other issues to confirm it for yourself or u can waste your time arguing
@omairmazhar Assalaamu'alaykum, I do not intend to argue except it be wrong to not respond to a wrong claim that you made against the scholars, whose lectures I have been listening to for years now; and I find their Aqida concepts similar to all the other major madhaabs like Hanafi, Shafi'i etc. Also Yusuf Estes was not asked if he's a Salafi, but he still talked against the group and obviously he wouldn't do that if he belonged to them. Check these out:
{2}:-->In the BIBLE they wrote : Revelation 4:2-11 (9) And when the living creatures give glory and honour and thanks to Him Who SITS ON THETHRONE, to Him Who lives forever and ever, (10) the twenty-four elders will fall down before Him Who SITS ON THE THRONE, and will worship Him Who lives forever and ever, and will cast their crowns before the throne, saying, For Thou hast maintained my just cause; Thou dost SIT ON THE THRONE judging righteously.Psalms 9:4.
--> But NONE knows their interpretation except Allah, while the ones who are firmly grounded in knowledge say "We believe in it, every single one of it is from our Rabb", but none take heed EXCEPT the people of reason! **
*SURAH IMRAN Verse 7: He is the One Who has sent down to you the Book. In it are ayahs that are MUHAKAMAT {CLEAR}, these are the foundation of the Book, and OTHERS THAT ARE MUTASHABIYAT {UNCLEAR/SYMBOLIC}. So the ones IN WHOSE HEARTS IS A PERVERSION, they go after the mutashabiyat {SYMBOLIC/UNCLEAR} seeking to cause Fitna and seeking to give it their own interpretation.
"Narrated Aisha {Radhiallahu Ta'ala Anha}: Allah's Apostle {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} recited the verse: SURAH IMRAN Verse 7
THEN Allah's Apostle {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} said:"IF you see those who follow thereof that is NOT entirely clear, then THEY ARE THOSE WHOM ALLAH HAS NAMED [AS HAVING DEVIATION (FROM THE TRUTH)] 'SO BEWARE OF THEM'.{Bukhari, Volume 6, Book 60, Number 70
this man isnt a MUSLIM ....he folow the same belive that the juif k fir follow........it was a simple question to answers.....ALLAH EXIST WITHOUT A PLACE,HE CREATED THE PLACES ALLAH IS UNIQUE NOTHING IS LIKE HIM....ALLAH DOESNT NEED ANY OF THIS CREATION AND IS EXEMPT OF ALL DIRECTION.....THIS MAN FOLLOW THE PETROL DOLLAR WITH THE K FIR....HE DOESNT KNOW THE TRUTH.....ALLAHU AKBAR
@coolsilverman1 Yes brother,they are salafi bitches and if i ever saw that cunt of bilal philips,i would not waste a second to behead his ugly head!! They are being supported by zionist and jews,they have petro dollars and they spread their fitnah though sateliite channel and internet,they have invaded us..They are najdi dogs!! i really despise them,i feel pity for their women and fellow students,they are being given free tickets to hell!!
@coolsilverman1 {2}:-->In the BIBLE they wrote : Revelation 4:2-11 (9) And when the living creatures give glory and honour and thanks to Him Who SITS ON THETHRONE, to Him Who lives forever and ever, (10) the twenty-four elders will fall down before Him Who SITS ON THE THRONE, and will worship Him Who lives forever and ever, and will cast their crowns before the throne, saying, For Thou hast maintained my just cause; Thou dost SIT ON THE THRONE judging righteously.Psalms 9:4.
@coolsilverman1 "Narrated Aisha {Radhiallahu Ta'ala Anha}: Allah's Apostle {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} recited the verse: SURAH IMRAN Verse 7
THEN Allah's Apostle {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} said:"IF you see those who follow thereof that is NOT entirely clear, then THEY ARE THOSE WHOM ALLAH HAS NAMED [AS HAVING DEVIATION (FROM THE TRUTH)] 'SO BEWARE OF THEM'.{Bukhari, Volume 6, Book 60, Number 70
@abduuul You are ignorand,may allah guide u,the hadith on slave god is about tauhid and not where allah subhana wa ta'ala is..He rose his hands in the sky like we do after we make salah.If allah is in a place,then u insinuate that allah is limited,above the throne means the exaltedness of our creator on his creations which is heavens and earth and evertything in heaven and earth bows to allah,if allah is in 7th heaven,then?
If anybody ever ask me"WHERE IS YOUR ALLAH, I DONT SEE ANY OF YOUR ALLAH?"HOW CAN YOU WORSHIP OR FEEL SOMETHING THAT U CANNOT SEE?..1stlyI will slap her at her face really hard (appologize later) and I'll ask her..DO YOUL FEEL THE PAIN of MY SLAP JUST NOW?if she say yes..I'll ask her to SHOW ME THE MOLECULE OR ATOM OF YOUR PAIN that u feel..I WANT TO SEE IT...sure she will understand better about where is ALLAH.. :) ALLAH is what we feel, we believe and we submit ourselves to HIM.. wallahu'alam
Salam Brother/Sister. IslamNetwork is a new Islamic based website, which allows you to discuss, debate, and chat about anything related to Islam. It's a great place to learn and guide fellow muslims and non-muslims to a more righteous path. Feel free to join today, thank you.
The true Salafiy, Abu Ja^far at-Tahawiyy said in his book:
"Allah is supremely clear of all boundaries, extremes, sides, organs and instruments. The six directions do not contain Him--these are attributed to all created things."
Such is the saying of Imam Abu Ja^far who is among the heads of as-Salaf. He explicitly stated that Allah is clear of being contained by the six directions. The six directions are above, below, in front of, behind, right, and left
The true Salafiy, Imam Ahmad Ibn Salamah, Abu Ja^far at-Tahawiyy, who was born in the year 237 after Hijrah, and was one of the Heads of Great Salaf wrote a book called Al-^Aqidah at-Tahawiyyah. He mentioned that the content of his book is an elucidation of the creed of Ahl as-Sunnah wal Jama^ah, which is the creed of Imam Abu Hanifah, who died in the year 150 after al-Hijrah, and his two companions, Imam Abu Yusuf al-Qadi and Imam Muhammad Ibn al-Hasan ash-Shaybaniyy and others.
Imam Abu Hanifah, who is one of the authorities of as-Salaf, said in his book Al-Fiqh al-Absat:
"Allah existed eternally and there was no place. He existed before creating the creation. He existed, and there was no place, creation, or thing; and He is the Creator of everything."
In the explanation of al-Bukhariyy in the chapter on Al-Jihad, Hafidh Ibn Hajar said:
"The fact that the two directions above and below are impossible to be attributes of Allah, does not necessitate that Allah would not be attributed with aboveness, because attributing aboveness to Allah is a matter of status and the impossibility lies in it being physical."
Al-Bayhaqiyy also said: "Some of our companions used as a proof to refute the place to Allah the saying of the Prophet, sallallahu ^alayhi wa sallam : 'You are adh-Dhahir and there is nothing above You, and You are al-Batin and there is nothing underneath You.' Therefore, if there is nothing above Him and nothing underneath Him, He is not in a place."
Imam al-Hafidh al-Bayhaqiyy said in his book, Al-Asma'u was-Sifat, on page 400: ".... What was mentioned towards the end of the hadith is an indication of denying Allah has a place and denying the slave is alike to Allah, wherever he was in proximity or remoteness. Allah, the Exalted, is adh-Dhahir--hence, it is valid to know about Him by proofs. Allah is al-Batin--hence, it is invalid that He would be in a place."
The saying that Allah, ta^ala, exists without a place is the belief and the creed of the Messenger of Allah, sallallahu ^alayhi wa sallam, the Companions and the True Salaf and Khalaf, those who graciously followed them, and it shall be until the Day of Judgment
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i think this fat cunt needs to sit with scholars so that they could teach him. I URGE YOU PEOPLE TO LEARN AND NOT FOLLOW THIS IGNORANT FOOL WHO DOESNT KNOW HOW TO PRONOUNCE ONE WORD OF THE ARABIC LANGUAGE PROPERLY SO HOW DOES HE THINK HE IS ALLOWED TO INTERPERT THINGS AS HE WISHES??!!
@Musty24q ......i guess u need to sit with the scholars first(or maye u dont have to) for straightening your language out...his views are shared by all the famous contemporary scholars of Islaam(now dont ask me their names to officially declare your ignorance....when ppl like u use foul language, it only makes Haqq stand out stronger
@omairmazhar so you diss her for her language structure and use that as a reason to discredit her and belittle her...thats not love and kindness, dont preach with your mouth, but live it,which obv you arent livin out.
@Musty24q I believe you think Allah is everywhere and in everything as you are like Hindus as they believe same concept, so you better sit and think about your concept of Allah swt. and also donot insult our scholars b/c if you are in front of me, I have kicked your Ass very hard
@davidshazusa again i need to intervene for this brother,allah is not everywhere,his capacities are omnipresent but allah himself exist without a place because he existed before a place,time and creations..Allahu Allam!!
Allah said in quran in surat As shurah ayah 11 which means: nothing resembles Allah. The prophet said which means: Allah existed eternaly and NOTHING else existed. Imam 3aliy the cousin of the prophet said which means: Allah existed eternaly without a place and he is as was Eternaly without a place. Allah created everything examples are: the space, time, places, directions, up, down, right, left. Allah is not inneed of his creations.
But if god/allah is outside the creation...where is he in? In some other larger creation? If yes, who created that one and him?
The answer "god is everywhere" is better!
We know universe is only 4% matter. The rest is dark matter and dark energy (called dark because we cannot see them). Scientists now believe that higgs boson "the god particle" is everywhere & it controls, possibly create matter!
Could it be god instead, an "entity" a "force" we cannot see?
@9ior77 ......brother, space came into existence along with creation...God exists outside that space and not inside or within it....u can read Einstein's works on the physics of space n time to know what i m talkin abt.....
To be honest I'm not a believer in any god, but I keep an open mind! We definitely don't exist just by chance.
Higgs boson is called the god particle because it is everywhere, and it gives everything a mass, but itself cannot be detected or isolated (at least so far).
Now lets ask...can the higgs bosson make a rock exist so heavy it cannot move it? Stupid question as without the higgs bosson the rock will have no mass.
@9ior77 in order to understand the concept of God, u can follow this path: please watch : /watch?v=9D1_zBzLlr4 . and /watch?v=OSLs_cgPNXI watch other parts of the vid too.then watch?v=bFe8vQZtbbE .and u can search Youtube for more.now u know 'quran is from God and its preserved from modifications'.now beleve wot quran says abt God.and thus its clear that mohamed is not wrote it.so he is a prophet.so beleve in him.may allah guide us all.
A same Question was asked by the prophet (p.b.u.h) himself mentioned in a sahih hadith,
Mu’awiya b. al-Hakam (may Allah be pleased with him) said:
I had a maid-servant who tended goats by the side of Uhud and Jawwaniya. One day I happened to pass that way and found that a wolf had carried a goat from her flock. I am after all a man from the posterity of Adam. I felt sorry as they (human beings) feel sorry. So I slapped her. [continued..]
From the sahih Hadith (sunnah) we come to know that actually Allah is over His Throne, and ‘by His knowledge’ He is everywhere. In All the verses that people misquote to prove Allah is physically everywhere, the meaning of those verses is, “Allah is everywhere ‘by his knowledge’.”
I came to the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) and felt (this act of mine) as something grievous I said: Messenger of Allah, should I not grant her freedom? He (the Holy Prophet) said: Bring her to me. So I brought her to him. He said to her: where is Allah? She said: He is in the heaven. He said: Who am I? She said: Thou art the Messenger of Allah. He said: Grant her freedom, she is a believing woman. (sahih Muslim, Book #004, Hadith #1094)
Attributing Allah Ta’ala with being confined to the sky, heaven, or above the 7th heaven, sitting on a throne, consisting of organs and limbs, being a mass, governed by space or time, being limited by His creation….etc., leads to unambiguous blasphemy. Allah is The Creator, and He does not resemble the creation in anyway. Nothing is like Him. | AL-FIQH AL-AKBAR Al-Imam Al-A’tham Abu Hanifah (R.A.)
Allah Ta’ala is not attributed with limits nor ends, because limits, ends, space, place, directions, time, above, below, and everything else are all His creation. He, subhanahu wa Ta’ala, existed eternally when nothing else existed, i.e. no place, no space, no directions, no limits, no above no below, etc.. all those were brought into existence by Allah, who is not in need of them to exist, and existed before their creation without needing them.
@revengeoftheturnip ....ofcouse Allah is All-Hearing, All-Seeing. we affirm that. his Knowlegde encompasses the universe. but He in His essense doesnt. with regards to the Hadith being inauthentic, ur the first person saying this. even famous Sufi scholars have affirmed this Hadith, only adding a different interpretation to it, but no one denied its authenticity,brother
@revengeoftheturnip .....firstly, Allah is in the heavens, whether the heavens are above Saudi or the Fijis, that doesnt count.u wud point UP either way. relative to you, u'd alwez point up. secondly, isnt saying "Allah is literally everywhere" attributing a position to Allah?u've put him in a place(the universe-the creation) and not thinking for second what blunder u've just made.
@CocoaBrownSkinLady Allah is NOT in a physical place, he is exalted above being in a time and/or space. This is a limitation of CREATION, not Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala
@revengeoftheturnip ......well so are u denying the Hadith itself?the slave girl's answer to the Prophet's question was very clear(Allah is fis samaa)...well akhi the speaker ma be ignorant but lets clear up our own belief system first
@revengeoftheturnip ......he is right when he said that its not a legitimate question, coz alot of times the question needs to be straightened out b4 it can b answered.e.g., if i ask u "are u out of jail?" how wud u reply?yes? no? either way u cant answer,so that makes the question illegitimate- and not that he cant answer
Wow according to him Allah has hands and a face. And what possible benefit could a God derive from having body parts? This one of the most stupid videos I've seen. I used to listen to this guy on tv, I'm glad I know the truth about him as well.
Stanley Villavincencio from city of Cebu in Philippines the newest evidence that Jesus is God and he offers his mercy to everyone, and the Lord told Stanley that everybody who refuses his mercy will have to face his judgment and nobody is righteous in front of God, what makes us righteous is Jesus precious blood, and if we are not washed by his blood we are in danger. If we receive Jesus mercy then we are justified before heavenly court, Jesus came on this world to offer his endless mercy.
The views of the salaf (im talking about the actual salaf, not the ones who claim to folllow the salaf) and khalaf are all in the link below...that is if u r searching for the truth for these so called salafis, have misinterpreted the quran and hadith
Know firmly that the scholars of the salaf and khalaf confirmed that Allah exists eternally without a place as everything that exists in a place is a creation...
Before creating place, Allah existed without a place and after creating place Allah exists as he was i.e. without a place
I'm not going to disagree with this as it is logical, and it is logical because also in theoretical physics the "higgs boson" exists without a place and this is why it is called the god particle.
read what imam malek said:al istiwaa is known and way is diffirant,so he doesn't deny that rising over the throne,but denies the way,i wish we can talk more about that Insh'Allah.
It was affirmed about Imam Malik Ibn Anas, may Allah reward his deeds, in what alBayhaqiyy related with a sound chain from the route of ^Abdullah Ibn Wahb, that "We were at Malik's when a man entered and said, "O Aba ^Abdillah, (meaning Imam Malik), ar-Rahmanu ^alal-^arsh istawa, how did He istawa?" Malik looked down dismayed and then lifted his head and said '^alal ^arsh istawa as He attributed to Himself. It is invalid to say how, and how does not apply to Him.
There is no basis for the saying of those who liken Allah to the creation, which they falsely attribute to Imam Malik, that al-istiwa' is known and the how of it is unknown. What they mean by that is that al-istiwa' is sitting but the how of that sitting is unknown.
This saying of theirs is silly , because sitting, no matter how it is would be by organs and parts that fold. Furthermore , that term that they attribute to Imam Malik was not affirmed about him or others.
ok akhy,but doesn't allah have power and huaman beings have power?but power of allah swt is diffirant,plus,al istiwa of allah is diffirant than our own.
(continuing)... (Malik then said) "I see that you are an innovator. Take him out'." Hence, the saying of Imam Malik, ' How does not apply to Him,' means that His istiwa' over His ^arsh is without a how, i.e., it is not with a body, place, shape, or form as sitting, touching, suspending above, and the like.
You don't have to be a scholar to know that 'rising' does not befit Allah. My 11 year old brother knows that. Humans rise, animals rise, and other things rise...'Rising' is a characteristics of created things and does not befit Allah.
read surat taha and other verses where alah swt said He rose <Himself to al arsh,it's very clear,i will give you a book by sheikh ibn othaymyeen about asmaa and sifat.
Mutashabihat verses cannot be taken literally, if they were they would contradict other verses of the Qur'an. Surely the Qur'an does not contradict itself.
yeahnthat's true,but you misue those evidance by our prophet peace be upohim,the hadith i gave you is authentic,yes,allah is over His throne and will be forever
well,actually,asking about place of allah is permissable and even done by our prophet peace be upon him when he asked a maiden about place of allah and said He said above heavens,so he said free her,she is muslim.
The Prophet Muhamamad never said "where is Allah". when the Prophet, sallallahu ^alayhi wa sallam, asked the slave woman the question: "Aynallah?", the scholars said this meant he was asking her about her belief in the status of Allah. She answered: "Fis-sama'" which has the meaning that Allah has the highest status. Furthermore, Imam Malik related the same hadith with a different wording.
In the narration of Imam Malik, the Prophet asked the slave woman if she believed in both parts of the shahadatayn and she said: "yes" to both. So the Prophet said to set her free. It is blasphemous to apply place to Allah. Allah is not in a place as Allah is the One Who created it and does not need it.
imam malik, imam shafi'i, imam malik n imam abu hanifa were very clear on the istawa.....
y do your "scholars" ALWAYS interpret all ahadith by saying that "basically what is meant by or intended by the hadith is that.........." instead of taking it straight on
The Istiwa of Allah is without a 'how' meaning it is not with a body, place, shape, or form as sitting, touching, suspending above, and the like.
You can't take some Hadiths 'straight on'. Because some Hadiths are Mutashabih (have multiple meanings, according to the arabic language.) If you were to take some of them 'straight on' then they would contradict the Qur'an and other Hadiths.
@loonietoonie0123 .....exactly akhi...thanx for making it simple.infact this is the best explanation that our scholars have to offer...i.e, as far as istawa or any other attribute of Allah is concerned, the WHAT is clear. the HOW is unknown. so, we dont ask how, neither do v give a meaning to istawa or deny it altogether.....JazakAllah
@MrYusuf99 ....exactly my point. the istawa is without a "how" . but unlike u, we tend to stop here, but u just went on and explained what "how" is referring to.
@omairmazhar What do u mean straight on???? :S in suratul imran ayah 7, Allah says that there are mu7kam ayat and mutashabihat in which the mu7kam have one literal meaning and the mutashabihat can have many....
its funny u say that because if u take suratul hadid, verse 4 literally it would mean allah is literally everywhere and this goes against YOUR beliefs....u see how the so called salafis take what they like and leave out what they dont like...so dont talk about 'straight on'
@omairmazhar Do you understand how stupid that sounds? So instead of taking the meaning that befits Allaah's majesty you choose to take the first derogatory meaning that comes to your mind?
@darktee .....brother we dont choose choose words that befit Allah according to wat v THINK is befitting....but v describe Him accorging to how He describes Himself in the Quran.....y dont u go n read the Quran and the Prophet's sunnah for yourself to find out...by the way, i visited your channel and i've gotta say u have ALL the authority to tell how stupid everyone else is when they talk Islam
The Prophet Muhammad, sall Allahu alayhi wa salam said:" Allah existed Eternally and nothing else existed." Eternally meaning without a beginning. Having a beginning would entail being a creation and Allah is the Creator, and not the creation. This saying of the Prophet means there was nothing with Allah; no space, no light, no darkness, no time, no place, no time, no change, no directions, absolutely nothing.
And after creating 'place' and the creations, Allah did not change. Change is a sign of development and needing others, and the one who needs something is not God. Allah is not in a place and does not need anything.
assalamualaikum brother.... a straight answer to your question is that Allah interacts with His Prophets (peace be upon them) ... Allah has sent Prophets and Messengers in every ummah (group of people) to make the message of monotheism(one God) clear... Islam is no old religion..its the same religion which noah,ibrahim,jesus,and moses (peace be upon them) preached...
cos Allah says there is a sign in nature for those who ponder over it.... Quraan is also full of signs for those who want to know the truth.... Allah interacted with His Prophets the way He wished.. sometimes through angels, in dreams, or talked directly (in case of moses)..
and Prophet Muhammed peace be upon him was the last of messengers by Allah..so islam is the religion for mankind now
Ibn Abbas, a famous companion of the Prophet Muhammad, sall Allahu alayhi wa salam said: Ponder over the creations, but do not attempt to ponder the Dhaat(Reality) of Allah.
@Khamzat89 ....to say that Allah is everywhere (meaing within his creation) is to assign him a location/position.....we salafis believe he is in the heavens(meaning He is beyond His creation)
@RizaHUD ...no brother....that group is better called Brelwis....and they exist only in the Indo-Pak subcontinent...and they sing qawalis and other non sense on television
This has been flagged as spam show
@omairmazhar My only point was, don't label people, especially the Muslim scholars, if you don't have sufficient proof, and especially if they refrain from such labels and are against it themselves. I have said enough regarding the matter, so yes I'm done with this. May Allah (swt) Guide us all, ameen. Peace. : )
thespeedyeagle 1 month ago
Comment removed
thespeedyeagle 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Can someone clarify to me if these guys are Salafi? Also Yasir Qadhi? Zakir Naik? And also Abdur Rahman Green? Are they Salafi? Just wish to know, I have no evil intentions. :)
Peace upon all Muslims. :)
<3
InkDries 1 month ago
@InkDries ....yes theyre salafi :)
omairmazhar 1 month ago
@omairmazhar Is there any place/way where you can actually confirm this? Because there are videos of some of these scholars speaking against Salafis.. that's all.
InkDries 1 month ago
Comment removed
thespeedyeagle 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@omairmazhar, Assalaamu'alaykum, how can you say they are Salafis, when such scholars themselves like Sheikh Yusuf Estes is calling them a deviant sect, and rather talking against it himself, check this video: /watch?v=GeN_hCqddhs
You must have sufficient evidence to back up or prove your claim.
thespeedyeagle 1 month ago
@thespeedyeagle ...walekum salaam warahmatAllaah
i have seen the video link that u sent me before,yusuf estes only says in this video that he prefers not to CALL himself salafi.he prefers calling himself muslim only without going into other labels...and that is his own opinion. as far his ideology is concerned that he follows, he is salafi 100% and u can take your time to watch his videos on ageedah and other issues to confirm it for yourself or u can waste your time arguing
omairmazhar 1 month ago
@omairmazhar Assalaamu'alaykum, I do not intend to argue except it be wrong to not respond to a wrong claim that you made against the scholars, whose lectures I have been listening to for years now; and I find their Aqida concepts similar to all the other major madhaabs like Hanafi, Shafi'i etc. Also Yusuf Estes was not asked if he's a Salafi, but he still talked against the group and obviously he wouldn't do that if he belonged to them. Check these out:
/watch?v=us-02KdlRAE
/watch?v=Szzn9lFg9n0
thespeedyeagle 1 month ago
Comment removed
InkDries 1 month ago
Can someone explain what's wrong with the Ashari and Maturidi believe from Salafi point of view? The asharis and Maturidis hold the following:
[1] Affirming what Allah has affirmed, such as istiwa' or His Hand or Eyes, not more not less
[2] Negating what Allah has decisively negated, which is any similitude whatsoever between the Creator and creation
[3] Consigning the specific meaning and details to Allah Most High
Whats different with the Salafis as I fail to see them?
azrinsani 2 months ago
{2}:-->In the BIBLE they wrote : Revelation 4:2-11 (9) And when the living creatures give glory and honour and thanks to Him Who SITS ON THETHRONE, to Him Who lives forever and ever, (10) the twenty-four elders will fall down before Him Who SITS ON THE THRONE, and will worship Him Who lives forever and ever, and will cast their crowns before the throne, saying, For Thou hast maintained my just cause; Thou dost SIT ON THE THRONE judging righteously.Psalms 9:4.
AfwaunMuMeen 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
¸.·´¸.·*´¨) ¸.·*¨)
(¸.·´ (¸.·~ஜ۩۞۩ஜWHERE DOES THE SALAFIS/WAHABIS BELIEF ALLAH SITS ON THE THRONE COME FROM?ஜ۩۞۩ஜ
They wrote: God reigns over the nations, God SITS ON HIS holy THRONE. Psalms 47:8
...I saw the Lord SITTING ON A THRONE, lofty and exalted, with the train of His robe filling the temple. Isaiah 6:1
AfwaunMuMeen 2 months ago
--> But NONE knows their interpretation except Allah, while the ones who are firmly grounded in knowledge say "We believe in it, every single one of it is from our Rabb", but none take heed EXCEPT the people of reason! **
AfwaunMuMeen 2 months ago
*SURAH IMRAN Verse 7: He is the One Who has sent down to you the Book. In it are ayahs that are MUHAKAMAT {CLEAR}, these are the foundation of the Book, and OTHERS THAT ARE MUTASHABIYAT {UNCLEAR/SYMBOLIC}. So the ones IN WHOSE HEARTS IS A PERVERSION, they go after the mutashabiyat {SYMBOLIC/UNCLEAR} seeking to cause Fitna and seeking to give it their own interpretation.
AfwaunMuMeen 2 months ago
"Narrated Aisha {Radhiallahu Ta'ala Anha}: Allah's Apostle {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} recited the verse: SURAH IMRAN Verse 7
THEN Allah's Apostle {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} said:"IF you see those who follow thereof that is NOT entirely clear, then THEY ARE THOSE WHOM ALLAH HAS NAMED [AS HAVING DEVIATION (FROM THE TRUTH)] 'SO BEWARE OF THEM'.{Bukhari, Volume 6, Book 60, Number 70
AfwaunMuMeen 2 months ago
this man isnt a MUSLIM ....he folow the same belive that the juif k fir follow........it was a simple question to answers.....ALLAH EXIST WITHOUT A PLACE,HE CREATED THE PLACES ALLAH IS UNIQUE NOTHING IS LIKE HIM....ALLAH DOESNT NEED ANY OF THIS CREATION AND IS EXEMPT OF ALL DIRECTION.....THIS MAN FOLLOW THE PETROL DOLLAR WITH THE K FIR....HE DOESNT KNOW THE TRUTH.....ALLAHU AKBAR
coolsilverman1 2 months ago
@coolsilverman1 Yes brother,they are salafi bitches and if i ever saw that cunt of bilal philips,i would not waste a second to behead his ugly head!! They are being supported by zionist and jews,they have petro dollars and they spread their fitnah though sateliite channel and internet,they have invaded us..They are najdi dogs!! i really despise them,i feel pity for their women and fellow students,they are being given free tickets to hell!!
AhlusSunnahWahJammat 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@coolsilverman1 ¸.·´¸.·*´¨) ¸.·*¨)
(¸.·´ (¸.·~ஜ۩۞۩ஜWHERE DOES THE SALAFIS/WAHABIS BELIEF ALLAH SITS ON THE THRONE COME FROM?ஜ۩۞۩ஜ
They wrote: God reigns over the nations, God SITS ON HIS holy THRONE. Psalms 47:8
...I saw the Lord SITTING ON A THRONE, lofty and exalted, with the train of His robe filling the temple. Isaiah 6:1
AfwaunMuMeen 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@coolsilverman1 {2}:-->In the BIBLE they wrote : Revelation 4:2-11 (9) And when the living creatures give glory and honour and thanks to Him Who SITS ON THETHRONE, to Him Who lives forever and ever, (10) the twenty-four elders will fall down before Him Who SITS ON THE THRONE, and will worship Him Who lives forever and ever, and will cast their crowns before the throne, saying, For Thou hast maintained my just cause; Thou dost SIT ON THE THRONE judging righteously.Psalms 9:4.
AfwaunMuMeen 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@coolsilverman1 "Narrated Aisha {Radhiallahu Ta'ala Anha}: Allah's Apostle {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} recited the verse: SURAH IMRAN Verse 7
THEN Allah's Apostle {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} said:"IF you see those who follow thereof that is NOT entirely clear, then THEY ARE THOSE WHOM ALLAH HAS NAMED [AS HAVING DEVIATION (FROM THE TRUTH)] 'SO BEWARE OF THEM'.{Bukhari, Volume 6, Book 60, Number 70
AfwaunMuMeen 2 months ago
here sat 2 salafi bitches!!!
AhlusSunnahWahJammat 3 months ago
@AhlusSunnahWahJammat .....well your language says alot about u....fear Allaah and His Last Day.....
omairmazhar 3 months ago 2
@revengeoftheturnip well when i ask u habashis what the quranic verse in surat al-rahman means.
u say that istawa doesnt have a litteral meaning. instead u say he means " risen " like in status,
that means that he did not have that status before so thats also a change. an attribute of the human lol..
how about the hadith of the slavegirl then?
how about all the other verses of the quran that refers to allah being above all things
when allah said that he ascends jesus ?
abduuul 3 months ago
@abduuul You are ignorand,may allah guide u,the hadith on slave god is about tauhid and not where allah subhana wa ta'ala is..He rose his hands in the sky like we do after we make salah.If allah is in a place,then u insinuate that allah is limited,above the throne means the exaltedness of our creator on his creations which is heavens and earth and evertything in heaven and earth bows to allah,if allah is in 7th heaven,then?
AhlusSunnahWahJammat 2 months ago
@abduuul this means allah wields unlimited power over the heavens and the earth.Throne is Cosmos!!
AhlusSunnahWahJammat 2 months ago
If anybody ever ask me"WHERE IS YOUR ALLAH, I DONT SEE ANY OF YOUR ALLAH?"HOW CAN YOU WORSHIP OR FEEL SOMETHING THAT U CANNOT SEE?..1stlyI will slap her at her face really hard (appologize later) and I'll ask her..DO YOUL FEEL THE PAIN of MY SLAP JUST NOW?if she say yes..I'll ask her to SHOW ME THE MOLECULE OR ATOM OF YOUR PAIN that u feel..I WANT TO SEE IT...sure she will understand better about where is ALLAH.. :) ALLAH is what we feel, we believe and we submit ourselves to HIM.. wallahu'alam
idah359 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Salam Brother/Sister. IslamNetwork is a new Islamic based website, which allows you to discuss, debate, and chat about anything related to Islam. It's a great place to learn and guide fellow muslims and non-muslims to a more righteous path. Feel free to join today, thank you.
________
W W W. I S L A M N E T W O R K .IN
IslamNetworking 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The true Salafiy, Abu Ja^far at-Tahawiyy said in his book:
"Allah is supremely clear of all boundaries, extremes, sides, organs and instruments. The six directions do not contain Him--these are attributed to all created things."
Such is the saying of Imam Abu Ja^far who is among the heads of as-Salaf. He explicitly stated that Allah is clear of being contained by the six directions. The six directions are above, below, in front of, behind, right, and left
Mu7ammadi 8 months ago
The true Salafiy, Imam Ahmad Ibn Salamah, Abu Ja^far at-Tahawiyy, who was born in the year 237 after Hijrah, and was one of the Heads of Great Salaf wrote a book called Al-^Aqidah at-Tahawiyyah. He mentioned that the content of his book is an elucidation of the creed of Ahl as-Sunnah wal Jama^ah, which is the creed of Imam Abu Hanifah, who died in the year 150 after al-Hijrah, and his two companions, Imam Abu Yusuf al-Qadi and Imam Muhammad Ibn al-Hasan ash-Shaybaniyy and others.
Mu7ammadi 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Imam Abu Hanifah, who is one of the authorities of as-Salaf, said in his book Al-Fiqh al-Absat:
"Allah existed eternally and there was no place. He existed before creating the creation. He existed, and there was no place, creation, or thing; and He is the Creator of everything."
Mu7ammadi 8 months ago
In the explanation of al-Bukhariyy in the chapter on Al-Jihad, Hafidh Ibn Hajar said:
"The fact that the two directions above and below are impossible to be attributes of Allah, does not necessitate that Allah would not be attributed with aboveness, because attributing aboveness to Allah is a matter of status and the impossibility lies in it being physical."
Mu7ammadi 8 months ago
Al-Bayhaqiyy also said: "Some of our companions used as a proof to refute the place to Allah the saying of the Prophet, sallallahu ^alayhi wa sallam : 'You are adh-Dhahir and there is nothing above You, and You are al-Batin and there is nothing underneath You.' Therefore, if there is nothing above Him and nothing underneath Him, He is not in a place."
Mu7ammadi 8 months ago
Imam al-Hafidh al-Bayhaqiyy said in his book, Al-Asma'u was-Sifat, on page 400: ".... What was mentioned towards the end of the hadith is an indication of denying Allah has a place and denying the slave is alike to Allah, wherever he was in proximity or remoteness. Allah, the Exalted, is adh-Dhahir--hence, it is valid to know about Him by proofs. Allah is al-Batin--hence, it is invalid that He would be in a place."
Mu7ammadi 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The saying that Allah, ta^ala, exists without a place is the belief and the creed of the Messenger of Allah, sallallahu ^alayhi wa sallam, the Companions and the True Salaf and Khalaf, those who graciously followed them, and it shall be until the Day of Judgment
Mu7ammadi 8 months ago
2:03 lol whatever the ....i thought he was going to say ("or whatever the crap this was")
MrYahya0101 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think this fat cunt needs to sit with scholars so that they could teach him. I URGE YOU PEOPLE TO LEARN AND NOT FOLLOW THIS IGNORANT FOOL WHO DOESNT KNOW HOW TO PRONOUNCE ONE WORD OF THE ARABIC LANGUAGE PROPERLY SO HOW DOES HE THINK HE IS ALLOWED TO INTERPERT THINGS AS HE WISHES??!!
Musty24q 11 months ago
@Musty24q ......i guess u need to sit with the scholars first(or maye u dont have to) for straightening your language out...his views are shared by all the famous contemporary scholars of Islaam(now dont ask me their names to officially declare your ignorance....when ppl like u use foul language, it only makes Haqq stand out stronger
omairmazhar 11 months ago 7
@omairmazhar so you diss her for her language structure and use that as a reason to discredit her and belittle her...thats not love and kindness, dont preach with your mouth, but live it,which obv you arent livin out.
Goodtimes1333 5 months ago
@Musty24q I believe you think Allah is everywhere and in everything as you are like Hindus as they believe same concept, so you better sit and think about your concept of Allah swt. and also donot insult our scholars b/c if you are in front of me, I have kicked your Ass very hard
davidshazusa 5 months ago
@davidshazusa again i need to intervene for this brother,allah is not everywhere,his capacities are omnipresent but allah himself exist without a place because he existed before a place,time and creations..Allahu Allam!!
AhlusSunnahWahJammat 2 months ago
@Musty24q
Watch your self Musty! be carefull before you swear
mrAsim7 4 months ago
Allah said in quran in surat As shurah ayah 11 which means: nothing resembles Allah. The prophet said which means: Allah existed eternaly and NOTHING else existed. Imam 3aliy the cousin of the prophet said which means: Allah existed eternaly without a place and he is as was Eternaly without a place. Allah created everything examples are: the space, time, places, directions, up, down, right, left. Allah is not inneed of his creations.
Musty24q 11 months ago
This sure was a smart answer!
But if god/allah is outside the creation...where is he in? In some other larger creation? If yes, who created that one and him?
The answer "god is everywhere" is better!
We know universe is only 4% matter. The rest is dark matter and dark energy (called dark because we cannot see them). Scientists now believe that higgs boson "the god particle" is everywhere & it controls, possibly create matter!
Could it be god instead, an "entity" a "force" we cannot see?
9ior77 1 year ago
@9ior77 ......brother, space came into existence along with creation...God exists outside that space and not inside or within it....u can read Einstein's works on the physics of space n time to know what i m talkin abt.....
omairmazhar 11 months ago 3
@omairmazhar alhamdulillah!
leeorifleman 9 months ago
@omairmazhar
To be honest I'm not a believer in any god, but I keep an open mind! We definitely don't exist just by chance.
Higgs boson is called the god particle because it is everywhere, and it gives everything a mass, but itself cannot be detected or isolated (at least so far).
Now lets ask...can the higgs bosson make a rock exist so heavy it cannot move it? Stupid question as without the higgs bosson the rock will have no mass.
Very interesting.. no?
9ior77 7 months ago
@9ior77 in order to understand the concept of God, u can follow this path: please watch : /watch?v=9D1_zBzLlr4 . and /watch?v=OSLs_cgPNXI watch other parts of the vid too.then watch?v=bFe8vQZtbbE .and u can search Youtube for more.now u know 'quran is from God and its preserved from modifications'.now beleve wot quran says abt God.and thus its clear that mohamed is not wrote it.so he is a prophet.so beleve in him.may allah guide us all.
shamimuhammed 7 months ago in playlist Beleifs:Tawheed(Monotheism),Prophets,Destiny,Judgement etc
@9ior77
A same Question was asked by the prophet (p.b.u.h) himself mentioned in a sahih hadith,
Mu’awiya b. al-Hakam (may Allah be pleased with him) said:
I had a maid-servant who tended goats by the side of Uhud and Jawwaniya. One day I happened to pass that way and found that a wolf had carried a goat from her flock. I am after all a man from the posterity of Adam. I felt sorry as they (human beings) feel sorry. So I slapped her. [continued..]
MuhammadFarhanAhmad 1 month ago
Comment removed
MuhammadFarhanAhmad 1 month ago
From the sahih Hadith (sunnah) we come to know that actually Allah is over His Throne, and ‘by His knowledge’ He is everywhere. In All the verses that people misquote to prove Allah is physically everywhere, the meaning of those verses is, “Allah is everywhere ‘by his knowledge’.”
MuhammadFarhanAhmad 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
[continued..]
I came to the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) and felt (this act of mine) as something grievous I said: Messenger of Allah, should I not grant her freedom? He (the Holy Prophet) said: Bring her to me. So I brought her to him. He said to her: where is Allah? She said: He is in the heaven. He said: Who am I? She said: Thou art the Messenger of Allah. He said: Grant her freedom, she is a believing woman. (sahih Muslim, Book #004, Hadith #1094)
MuhammadFarhanAhmad 1 month ago
3.18 should be "walam yakullahu kufuwan ahad"
badriadib 1 year ago
The Prophet (Alayhis salaam) said in a Saheeh (authentic) hadith , "When Allah created his creation , he rose above his throne".
Also , Allah says " Ar rahmana ala arshal istawa" The Most Gracious rose above his throne (in a manner that suites his majesty).
muslimallday 1 year ago 2
Attributing Allah Ta’ala with being confined to the sky, heaven, or above the 7th heaven, sitting on a throne, consisting of organs and limbs, being a mass, governed by space or time, being limited by His creation….etc., leads to unambiguous blasphemy. Allah is The Creator, and He does not resemble the creation in anyway. Nothing is like Him. | AL-FIQH AL-AKBAR Al-Imam Al-A’tham Abu Hanifah (R.A.)
ibnfarooq11 1 year ago
Allah Ta’ala is not attributed with limits nor ends, because limits, ends, space, place, directions, time, above, below, and everything else are all His creation. He, subhanahu wa Ta’ala, existed eternally when nothing else existed, i.e. no place, no space, no directions, no limits, no above no below, etc.. all those were brought into existence by Allah, who is not in need of them to exist, and existed before their creation without needing them.
ibnfarooq11 1 year ago
@revengeoftheturnip ....ofcouse Allah is All-Hearing, All-Seeing. we affirm that. his Knowlegde encompasses the universe. but He in His essense doesnt. with regards to the Hadith being inauthentic, ur the first person saying this. even famous Sufi scholars have affirmed this Hadith, only adding a different interpretation to it, but no one denied its authenticity,brother
omairmazhar 1 year ago
@revengeoftheturnip .....firstly, Allah is in the heavens, whether the heavens are above Saudi or the Fijis, that doesnt count.u wud point UP either way. relative to you, u'd alwez point up. secondly, isnt saying "Allah is literally everywhere" attributing a position to Allah?u've put him in a place(the universe-the creation) and not thinking for second what blunder u've just made.
omairmazhar 1 year ago
@omairmazhar /watch?v=ikvD2fO--bg
CocoaBrownSkinLady 1 year ago
@CocoaBrownSkinLady Allah is NOT in a physical place, he is exalted above being in a time and/or space. This is a limitation of CREATION, not Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala
CocoaBrownSkinLady 1 year ago
@revengeoftheturnip ......well so are u denying the Hadith itself?the slave girl's answer to the Prophet's question was very clear(Allah is fis samaa)...well akhi the speaker ma be ignorant but lets clear up our own belief system first
omairmazhar 1 year ago
@revengeoftheturnip ......he is right when he said that its not a legitimate question, coz alot of times the question needs to be straightened out b4 it can b answered.e.g., if i ask u "are u out of jail?" how wud u reply?yes? no? either way u cant answer,so that makes the question illegitimate- and not that he cant answer
omairmazhar 1 year ago
Wow according to him Allah has hands and a face. And what possible benefit could a God derive from having body parts? This one of the most stupid videos I've seen. I used to listen to this guy on tv, I'm glad I know the truth about him as well.
darktee 1 year ago
@darktee .....read the Quran n u'll know what hez talkin about, not some silly sufi guy
omairmazhar 1 year ago
Is he serious? Allah is up in the sky, how childish. No difference between them and the other pagans......
Qum2Najaf 1 year ago
Stanley Villavincencio from city of Cebu in Philippines the newest evidence that Jesus is God and he offers his mercy to everyone, and the Lord told Stanley that everybody who refuses his mercy will have to face his judgment and nobody is righteous in front of God, what makes us righteous is Jesus precious blood, and if we are not washed by his blood we are in danger. If we receive Jesus mercy then we are justified before heavenly court, Jesus came on this world to offer his endless mercy.
austriaheute 1 year ago
looool he is so funny :)
Nuha38317 1 year ago
the video isnt coming up but just type in Allah exists without a place and find a guy named elhabesi
lebrocky 1 year ago
The views of the salaf (im talking about the actual salaf, not the ones who claim to folllow the salaf) and khalaf are all in the link below...that is if u r searching for the truth for these so called salafis, have misinterpreted the quran and hadith
lebrocky 1 year ago
Know firmly that the scholars of the salaf and khalaf confirmed that Allah exists eternally without a place as everything that exists in a place is a creation...
Before creating place, Allah existed without a place and after creating place Allah exists as he was i.e. without a place
lebrocky 1 year ago 14
@lebrocky
"Allah/God exists without a place".
I'm not going to disagree with this as it is logical, and it is logical because also in theoretical physics the "higgs boson" exists without a place and this is why it is called the god particle.
9ior77 7 months ago
the word istawa has many meanings and we should take the befitting meaning to Allah, read the Arabic to english dictionarys brothers .
captainenp 2 years ago
read what imam malek said:al istiwaa is known and way is diffirant,so he doesn't deny that rising over the throne,but denies the way,i wish we can talk more about that Insh'Allah.
kharbashe 2 years ago
It was affirmed about Imam Malik Ibn Anas, may Allah reward his deeds, in what alBayhaqiyy related with a sound chain from the route of ^Abdullah Ibn Wahb, that "We were at Malik's when a man entered and said, "O Aba ^Abdillah, (meaning Imam Malik), ar-Rahmanu ^alal-^arsh istawa, how did He istawa?" Malik looked down dismayed and then lifted his head and said '^alal ^arsh istawa as He attributed to Himself. It is invalid to say how, and how does not apply to Him.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
There is no basis for the saying of those who liken Allah to the creation, which they falsely attribute to Imam Malik, that al-istiwa' is known and the how of it is unknown. What they mean by that is that al-istiwa' is sitting but the how of that sitting is unknown.
This saying of theirs is silly , because sitting, no matter how it is would be by organs and parts that fold. Furthermore , that term that they attribute to Imam Malik was not affirmed about him or others.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
ok akhy,but doesn't allah have power and huaman beings have power?but power of allah swt is diffirant,plus,al istiwa of allah is diffirant than our own.
kharbashe 2 years ago 2
Rising is a physical doing and necessitates a body; that doesn't befit Allah, because Allah is not a body nor is He composed of anything.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
(continuing)... (Malik then said) "I see that you are an innovator. Take him out'." Hence, the saying of Imam Malik, ' How does not apply to Him,' means that His istiwa' over His ^arsh is without a how, i.e., it is not with a body, place, shape, or form as sitting, touching, suspending above, and the like.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
it isn't contradicted one,but a perfect evidance akhy,all scholars are talking about that.
kharbashe 2 years ago
You don't have to be a scholar to know that 'rising' does not befit Allah. My 11 year old brother knows that. Humans rise, animals rise, and other things rise...'Rising' is a characteristics of created things and does not befit Allah.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
so,we must be approv what allah swt approved for himself and denied what alllah denied.
kharbashe 2 years ago 2
read surat taha and other verses where alah swt said He rose <Himself to al arsh,it's very clear,i will give you a book by sheikh ibn othaymyeen about asmaa and sifat.
kharbashe 2 years ago
Mutashabihat verses cannot be taken literally, if they were they would contradict other verses of the Qur'an. Surely the Qur'an does not contradict itself.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
yeahnthat's true,but you misue those evidance by our prophet peace be upohim,the hadith i gave you is authentic,yes,allah is over His throne and will be forever
kharbashe 2 years ago
Allah does not need any of the creations, whether it be the Throne, the largest creation, or an ant. The Prophet never said "Where is Allah".
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
well,actually,asking about place of allah is permissable and even done by our prophet peace be upon him when he asked a maiden about place of allah and said He said above heavens,so he said free her,she is muslim.
kharbashe 2 years ago
The Prophet Muhamamad never said "where is Allah". when the Prophet, sallallahu ^alayhi wa sallam, asked the slave woman the question: "Aynallah?", the scholars said this meant he was asking her about her belief in the status of Allah. She answered: "Fis-sama'" which has the meaning that Allah has the highest status. Furthermore, Imam Malik related the same hadith with a different wording.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
In the narration of Imam Malik, the Prophet asked the slave woman if she believed in both parts of the shahadatayn and she said: "yes" to both. So the Prophet said to set her free. It is blasphemous to apply place to Allah. Allah is not in a place as Allah is the One Who created it and does not need it.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
therefore wat ur saying is that all imams of ahle sunnah committed blasphemy.....astaghfirAllah
man....your "scholars" are definitely knowledgeable
omairmazhar 2 years ago
which "scholars" brother?
imam malik, imam shafi'i, imam malik n imam abu hanifa were very clear on the istawa.....
y do your "scholars" ALWAYS interpret all ahadith by saying that "basically what is meant by or intended by the hadith is that.........." instead of taking it straight on
omairmazhar 2 years ago
The Istiwa of Allah is without a 'how' meaning it is not with a body, place, shape, or form as sitting, touching, suspending above, and the like.
You can't take some Hadiths 'straight on'. Because some Hadiths are Mutashabih (have multiple meanings, according to the arabic language.) If you were to take some of them 'straight on' then they would contradict the Qur'an and other Hadiths.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
@MrYusuf99 I think you and omairmazhar are saying the exact same thing. Allah is Istawa alal Arsh. How? Allah never told us how so we don't ask how.
loonietoonie0123 1 year ago
@loonietoonie0123 .....exactly akhi...thanx for making it simple.infact this is the best explanation that our scholars have to offer...i.e, as far as istawa or any other attribute of Allah is concerned, the WHAT is clear. the HOW is unknown. so, we dont ask how, neither do v give a meaning to istawa or deny it altogether.....JazakAllah
omairmazhar 1 year ago
@MrYusuf99 ....exactly my point. the istawa is without a "how" . but unlike u, we tend to stop here, but u just went on and explained what "how" is referring to.
omairmazhar 1 year ago
@omairmazhar What do u mean straight on???? :S in suratul imran ayah 7, Allah says that there are mu7kam ayat and mutashabihat in which the mu7kam have one literal meaning and the mutashabihat can have many....
its funny u say that because if u take suratul hadid, verse 4 literally it would mean allah is literally everywhere and this goes against YOUR beliefs....u see how the so called salafis take what they like and leave out what they dont like...so dont talk about 'straight on'
lebrocky 1 year ago
@omairmazhar Do you understand how stupid that sounds? So instead of taking the meaning that befits Allaah's majesty you choose to take the first derogatory meaning that comes to your mind?
darktee 1 year ago
@darktee .....brother we dont choose choose words that befit Allah according to wat v THINK is befitting....but v describe Him accorging to how He describes Himself in the Quran.....y dont u go n read the Quran and the Prophet's sunnah for yourself to find out...by the way, i visited your channel and i've gotta say u have ALL the authority to tell how stupid everyone else is when they talk Islam
omairmazhar 1 year ago
The Prophet Muhammad, sall Allahu alayhi wa salam said:" Allah existed Eternally and nothing else existed." Eternally meaning without a beginning. Having a beginning would entail being a creation and Allah is the Creator, and not the creation. This saying of the Prophet means there was nothing with Allah; no space, no light, no darkness, no time, no place, no time, no change, no directions, absolutely nothing.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
And after creating 'place' and the creations, Allah did not change. Change is a sign of development and needing others, and the one who needs something is not God. Allah is not in a place and does not need anything.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
Question
Who does god interact with his creation
Is or was there a physical link/
Can we learn of god through his "works" his creation??
6079smythw 2 years ago
assalamualaikum brother.... a straight answer to your question is that Allah interacts with His Prophets (peace be upon them) ... Allah has sent Prophets and Messengers in every ummah (group of people) to make the message of monotheism(one God) clear... Islam is no old religion..its the same religion which noah,ibrahim,jesus,and moses (peace be upon them) preached...
sahilshaikh87 2 years ago
surely in the creation is a purpose and if you ponder over the creation you will definately get close to Allah..
sahilshaikh87 2 years ago
cos Allah says there is a sign in nature for those who ponder over it.... Quraan is also full of signs for those who want to know the truth.... Allah interacted with His Prophets the way He wished.. sometimes through angels, in dreams, or talked directly (in case of moses)..
and Prophet Muhammed peace be upon him was the last of messengers by Allah..so islam is the religion for mankind now
sahilshaikh87 2 years ago
And is god reflected in his creations (nature)?
can we learn about god through his creations?
6079smythw 2 years ago
Surah Ash-Shura, ayah 11 means :There is absolutely NOTHING like Allah WHATSOEVER.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
Ibn Abbas, a famous companion of the Prophet Muhammad, sall Allahu alayhi wa salam said: Ponder over the creations, but do not attempt to ponder the Dhaat(Reality) of Allah.
MrYusuf99 2 years ago
Allahijaziek
Assanni87 2 years ago
i love this
ummmaymuna 2 years ago
ALLAH IS EVERYWHERE! ALLAH AKBAR!
Khamzat89 2 years ago
Im not muslim and I know this is not correct
Allah cannot be part of his creation
6079smythw 2 years ago
@Khamzat89 ....to say that Allah is everywhere (meaing within his creation) is to assign him a location/position.....we salafis believe he is in the heavens(meaning He is beyond His creation)
omairmazhar 1 year ago
God exists without a place
palo4lyf 2 years ago 13
@palo4lyf
omairmazhar 1 year ago
Astagfhirullah. The small number of Muslims he refers to at the start of the video are the Ahlus Sunnah wal Jamaah.
RizaHUD 2 years ago
@RizaHUD ...no brother....that group is better called Brelwis....and they exist only in the Indo-Pak subcontinent...and they sing qawalis and other non sense on television
omairmazhar 1 year ago
sweet
NocriZle 3 years ago