Some of it is much more Bach-like than your other one. There are some harmonic differences though there are more harmonic similarities, but the glaring difference is the transition to the relative major and it's less grounded introduction I guess you could say. Good work though
@SecondAgeOfReason Why do you say that some of this is more Bach like? I feel that the rhythmic juxtaposition between the two parts in the other one is much more driving and Bach-like, not to mention that there are no counterpoint errors in the e minor but there are several implied direct fifths in this one. Also, there's "wilder" harmony in this one that Bach wouldn't have used, such as the chord progression in the coda. Thanks for listening by the way
This is just wonderful! Very beautiful melody and I couldn't notice the parallel fifths! Very charming! Congratulations my dear nephew! Your dad and grandparents would be so proud of you! I am!
Some of it is much more Bach-like than your other one. There are some harmonic differences though there are more harmonic similarities, but the glaring difference is the transition to the relative major and it's less grounded introduction I guess you could say. Good work though
SecondAgeOfReason 1 month ago
@SecondAgeOfReason Why do you say that some of this is more Bach like? I feel that the rhythmic juxtaposition between the two parts in the other one is much more driving and Bach-like, not to mention that there are no counterpoint errors in the e minor but there are several implied direct fifths in this one. Also, there's "wilder" harmony in this one that Bach wouldn't have used, such as the chord progression in the coda. Thanks for listening by the way
AbsoluteZ3R0 1 month ago
This is just wonderful! Very beautiful melody and I couldn't notice the parallel fifths! Very charming! Congratulations my dear nephew! Your dad and grandparents would be so proud of you! I am!
iadlaws 2 months ago