Annete's vocals skills are way too far from Tarja's, we all know that, but it must be said that she's doing a great job with her own voice n' the boys of the band had made a greater job adapting the old Nightwish songs to her pitch... Nightwish is becoming magical again
you can se the difference even more then in 2008 her voice became cleaner in singing old NW songs :D shesounds soooooooo awsoooomee!!! i wanna see them live >,<
Imho to ask stop comparing cant be done , simply because Tarja was so better and she was defying Nightwish style for years ( imo thats why nightwish are where they are now )...
So , imho, the best thing they should had do was to findan appropriate replacement of Tarja. Same voice and all... Otherwise .. comparing is avoidable. Period
@cookysvidz I can understand Anette better. And the sound quality here isn't that good. If it would have been better, I would have understood Anette better.
im not sure but i have a little suspect that she has to improve her techinque, it seems like she sings with her throat and not with her stomach muscles... if that's right, it's a miracle she continue singing...
OMG that dress doesnt look good on her... and the boots either... I know its all about the music but its a little difficult not to look at her with those clothes...
@cookysvidz I didn't love that dress either but when I say that Anette looks bad is because she doesn't have a body for those clothes... she is not a 20 year old girl you know, and she doesn't look like a 20 year old girl either...
she looks like a 40 year old woman who tries so hard to look younger and totally fails... ugly belly and ulgy tights
@cookysvidz I think Tarja is one of the only people who can pull off a bright yellow dress. But come on - it's the music that matters, not the clothes. If that's the route people want to go down, then I have a number of problems with Marco's shorts and Tuomas's black nail varnish (not in this video, but lots of others) But does that alter my awe of their musical abilities?
@DoJaenin Well, she isn't doing that.... Cause first off, she's doing it with the wrong arm, Secondly, she's not as 'ridgid' as one seemingly should be while doing that... But Anette isn't doing the Hitler-salute...
She's a phenomenal singer. Her pitch is perfect, she just DOES NOT HAVE THAT SOUND that made them so unique. Still love em, still will support them. But it just aint as good.
Anette is a fucking looser si can`t sing just about Tarja sings...but let`s see the truth tarja`s not here and "Nightwish" is falling down wihtout her..
Anette really improved. The last time I saw Nightwish was in Amsterdam when Anette just joined. I was so dissapointed at the time. This was the second performance of Nightwish I saw with Anette and it was so much better. I was actually enthusiastic again in comparising to the performance in Amsterdam.
your question was stupid... i can watch everything i want... is it a free world, right? if someone don't want this, sould be post these videos on his/her personal facebook profile.
i didnt say you couldn't watch whatever you want, i just wondered why you would spend time watching a video you dont like, let alone go and comment on it after watching it. it didn't make sense, that's all. but, if you think my question is stupid, thats fine too. i was just curious.
I just wonder, is there any in the dictionary of music says which voice is for which song? B'coz I see people keep talking Annette had a pop voice. Maybe Susan Boyle should join NW then. Coz she had this a bit of operatic voice. She sang Memories like Simone Simons of Epica. Will Susan Boyle suit NW then? Hmmm.. Her voice might suit but she not a metal singer.
Susan Boyle sings musical tunes and wanted to make it big on Broadway...
You cannot place a certain singer in the boxes of Metal, Pop(which stand for POPular music, which NW is), Jazz... The only thing you can judge a voice on is if it hits the notes it's supposed to or not... Anette does that... And her notes go with the music...
i do like anette i really do, however she does better witth her songs, not Tarja's..like these ones especially the old nightwish ones, she cant sing to well, and i see what Azdleb is talking about with her missing the high notes and what not, becasue she is..Tarja actuially had Vocal training, and it helped her out a lot..Anetter as far as i know dosent have the training that tarja had
And no, I'm not an Annette hater, I just think both her and the band have let the quality just drop since they got over the honeymoon period. Tarja deserved what she got, but I'm really thinking that they are suffering without an adequate replacement. I liked bits of DPP and I can hear the potential, but let's face it Nightwish fans, this isn't a very respectable performane on anyones part.
Ducking high notes, vamping on longer ones can't she just stay on the note that was written? Are the rest of the guys in the band blind to this? She looks out of place (and, forgive me, in need of a post tour diet and detox), sounds second rate, and they really could have got someone better; I've heard X Factor auditionees with greater consistency of pitching.
Good perform Annette
Le0carry0n 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I think she really SUCKS!!!
96Chakal96 3 months ago
A lot of song is better with anette ! For example wihmaster I like Tarja´s version but I love love Anette´s version it´s just more epic !
majomanak 3 months ago
Marco is God!!!!! Anette sings so much better this song than Tarja. I love Tarja, but this song sounds so much better with Anette's voice
GrissyPink7y9 5 months ago 5
Anette is so fat *-*
xTeAmoMel 6 months ago
@xTeAmoMel Anette is so hot :p
Aztlankkk 6 months ago
@xTeAmoMel You must need glasses. Your vission seems to be more than a little bit blurry.
Rawrfulchan 6 months ago
@xTeAmoMel thats not fat,thats having godes body
dallowow 5 months ago
the best way to ruin all Nightwish old songs..............
ValeriaOceanSoul 6 months ago 3
She's amazing !!
kl0uny 6 months ago 2
yeah, and there she is. you cannot sing, so show your ass! LOL
noisygrass 7 months ago 2
Tuomas looks like having fun ;D
Excrucius 7 months ago 3
She sounds better than 2008 ;) Anette rules ! <3
JeremySkater666 7 months ago 5
marco's voice <3
LoveXHarmony 7 months ago
what was she thinking when she got dressed that day? looks like she tried to pack 10 pounds of flour in a 5 pound sack
metalwarrior27 7 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
21/ 10/ 05 Hartwall Areena, Helsinki. R.I.P NIGHTWISH
uncharlymas 7 months ago
@uncharlymas You're boring...
MargolottaLady 7 months ago
GORDA TIRA PEDOS LARGA CON LOS POSTRES
themetalmaster1972 8 months ago
Un verdadero Asco PUAAAJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
themetalmaster1972 8 months ago
I do not compar Annette and Tarja ! It is Nightwish, that is all !
Jukkalex 9 months ago 4
ahah, Emppu's got no sustain. :D
ka0ism 10 months ago 2
Annete's vocals skills are way too far from Tarja's, we all know that, but it must be said that she's doing a great job with her own voice n' the boys of the band had made a greater job adapting the old Nightwish songs to her pitch... Nightwish is becoming magical again
Griffope 10 months ago 3
you can se the difference even more then in 2008 her voice became cleaner in singing old NW songs :D shesounds soooooooo awsoooomee!!! i wanna see them live >,<
Nightwish581 11 months ago 2
Is that My Little Pony singer?
heisenmanFC 1 year ago
YO QUIERO VERLOS EN VIVO YAAAAAAAA XD XOXO
IVIWAY99 1 year ago 2
great ,anette rules.
juve605 1 year ago 6
Marco Hietala <3
Konilemel1 1 year ago 3
When did she dye her hair blonde?
maniacgamer9 1 year ago
@maniacgamer9 She didn't dye her hair blonde, she dyed her hair black when she joined Nightwish..;)
TheNightvis 1 year ago
@TheNightvis Ah... well I hope she keeps it that way. She looks way better with black hair lol.
maniacgamer9 1 year ago
Imho to ask stop comparing cant be done , simply because Tarja was so better and she was defying Nightwish style for years ( imo thats why nightwish are where they are now )...
So , imho, the best thing they should had do was to findan appropriate replacement of Tarja. Same voice and all... Otherwise .. comparing is avoidable. Period
Azatis 1 year ago
Jukka <3
XIMERAWOW 1 year ago
Since people have no musical knowledge at all they start to fire about Anette's clothing and look. .-.
moraesfmk 1 year ago
@moraesfmk lol
essentialDemon 1 year ago
wow, she starts learning to sing!! and oh, is that two anettes I see, or is it just one fat blondie?
pulec1 1 year ago
YAY... horrible audio
Colinpatrickcantrell 1 year ago
@Colinpatrickcantrell but that's good enough for a cheap digital camera.
21krizchristensen 1 year ago
perfect
Aptemishe 1 year ago
Anette é a coisa mais e já ví e o nightwish é muito melhor com ela!
8rafaviana 1 year ago
This song could have been to a bit more aggressive.... It's too friendly. But it's still not bad.
subwaytosally18642 1 year ago
love the fatty at 1:07 waving his finger like "you tell 'em Marco!" lol.
CrimsonFallen21 1 year ago
makes you child. what? 0:49
filipeabjvt 1 year ago
@filipeabjvt She sings: makes you cry. Hardly understandable.
subwaytosally18642 1 year ago
@subwaytosally18642 because you can understand tarja's every word undoubtedly!
cookysvidz 1 year ago
@cookysvidz I can understand Anette better. And the sound quality here isn't that good. If it would have been better, I would have understood Anette better.
subwaytosally18642 1 year ago
Comment removed
filipeabjvt 1 year ago
Anette is so bad for this song.
dura4ok666 1 year ago
anette is bad for any nightwish song!!
sotosmadys 1 year ago
Comment removed
Determersandihavet 1 year ago
Comment removed
Determersandihavet 1 year ago
Comment removed
Determersandihavet 1 year ago
FAVE SONG!!!! Marco kicks ass in this one ^^ This is when I fell head over heels <3 <3
Not a bad song for Anette, either :D
NIGHTWISH!!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3
supahwicked 1 year ago 3
im not sure but i have a little suspect that she has to improve her techinque, it seems like she sings with her throat and not with her stomach muscles... if that's right, it's a miracle she continue singing...
quetzalcoatl2870 1 year ago
@quetzalcoatl2870 She mixes techniques as she sees fit.
HeartsEyes 1 year ago
wow what camera did you use?
vberg06 1 year ago
Jukka's small drum fill with a huge presence during the silence at 0:13 is fantastic!
Kolo21892 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
-for lifestyle opinion click on ''siposattilaid''!, -eletstilus velemenyert kattints a ''siposattilaid''-ra!
siposattilaid 1 year ago
Comment removed
KlaudiaDeadEvil 1 year ago
the suit that anette has is very sexy <3
TheNightWish691 1 year ago 12
perkele
AsyaThawho 1 year ago
OMG that dress doesnt look good on her... and the boots either... I know its all about the music but its a little difficult not to look at her with those clothes...
ClaudiaDenise 1 year ago
@ClaudiaDenise and tarjas bright yellow dress at end of an era was any better?
cookysvidz 1 year ago 3
@cookysvidz I didn't love that dress either but when I say that Anette looks bad is because she doesn't have a body for those clothes... she is not a 20 year old girl you know, and she doesn't look like a 20 year old girl either...
she looks like a 40 year old woman who tries so hard to look younger and totally fails... ugly belly and ulgy tights
ClaudiaDenise 1 year ago
@cookysvidz I think Tarja is one of the only people who can pull off a bright yellow dress. But come on - it's the music that matters, not the clothes. If that's the route people want to go down, then I have a number of problems with Marco's shorts and Tuomas's black nail varnish (not in this video, but lots of others) But does that alter my awe of their musical abilities?
xxFace4theRadioxx 1 year ago 6
I miss Anette's black hair Dx but blode looks cute on her too :D
NemoNameless0 1 year ago 3
hate her awful style :(
she does not look like a metal singer
chopantura 1 year ago
why does Anette keep making Hitler salutes to the audience in the second half of the video? :(
DoJaenin 1 year ago
@DoJaenin Well, she isn't doing that.... Cause first off, she's doing it with the wrong arm, Secondly, she's not as 'ridgid' as one seemingly should be while doing that... But Anette isn't doing the Hitler-salute...
h06anbjo 1 year ago
mo voz de traveco! ;D
ele acaba abafando ela' no dueto!
Ipicassol 1 year ago
She's a phenomenal singer. Her pitch is perfect, she just DOES NOT HAVE THAT SOUND that made them so unique. Still love em, still will support them. But it just aint as good.
Paultheguitarist 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Anette is a fucking looser si can`t sing just about Tarja sings...but let`s see the truth tarja`s not here and "Nightwish" is falling down wihtout her..
236Cloud 1 year ago
lol anette is such a dork XD but shes amazing
nixichixi85 1 year ago
Esta tia no tiene ni idea de cantar, escuchado con esta voz parece basura.
BvBratovich 1 year ago
She has her own style, I think it's time to stop comparing Anette from Tarja.
katinkorn 1 year ago 63
Gawd, she's so damn hot
unorthodox41 1 year ago
After sacked phantom of opera band have lost this something special. Atmospehere of night and voice of Tarja singing metal it was something amazing.
Anette is singing very well but it's not making the same effect (of course it's impossible).
Florek777 1 year ago
I so wanted to be here...
140BeatsPerMinute 1 year ago
:o
EN PARTICULAR, ME GUSTA MÁS LA VERSIÓN DE ANNETTE DE ESTÁ CANCIÓN. :D
VERY GOOD!
MUIILEROLERO 1 year ago
anette make a bad performance o_o
NightingaleFreak 2 years ago
Why bad ? She's singing very well.
Florek777 1 year ago 4
her belting has more nuance to it now
IsheebesIover18 2 years ago
I just see comments about anette and tarja..... humm what about Marcos?! HE IS FUCKING AWESOME!!!
linnahmoon 2 years ago 86
Nobody is commenting him because he's not the one f..ing the song
Venom1225 2 years ago
@Venom1225
i like anette a lot, and i do not agree, but...
i can stop laughing!!!
maurillion 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
angelsdoweep 5 months ago
@linnahmoon Tarja always get most of the attention,,,so Tuomas fired her. xD
angelsdoweep 5 months ago 5
anette used to be the perfect nightwish singer
but....
i dont know
her singing gets better and better
but she's just not metal anymore :(
wolffe93 2 years ago
but she never was...oô
oceansoul02 2 years ago
She used to have a nice image for Nightwish. She used to struggle a lot with her live vocals.
I seriously don't know why she decided to shange her public image and appearance to this...
My opinion is I don't like most of it.
But she has improved her singing.
EilennaElonen 2 years ago
yeah thats exactly what i was saying
wolffe93 2 years ago
yeah, you right man :(
Motakujo 2 years ago
Ha ha, I love how Tuomas is over there singing along.
Yes, Anette has a infectious stage presence XD
AfraidYoureNext 2 years ago 2
i love how she is improving ,, she sings better and better again ^^
SaharaNw 2 years ago 2
Anette really improved. The last time I saw Nightwish was in Amsterdam when Anette just joined. I was so dissapointed at the time. This was the second performance of Nightwish I saw with Anette and it was so much better. I was actually enthusiastic again in comparising to the performance in Amsterdam.
ForrestSpirit 2 years ago 4
Because Tarja has the Nightwish voice, and that's why she is going to Graspop this year :)
BlackManon 2 years ago
i like this version with anette...but ...tarja is the one...
fakulobos 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I found they sucked ... oh yeah I was there, they changed a lot and I think they were rather better before...
849738 2 years ago
no.
oamadeife 2 years ago
i thougth they were the most dissapointing band i've ever been to
Umnes 2 years ago
When I saw her live in 2008 at Montreal, she didn't screamed her parts that much, her singing was really good on the chorus, very soft and beautiful.
Rayaelle 2 years ago
Other than a little awkward dancing in my opinion, she's really not as bad as people keep complaining about. And I really do love those boots.
Sakuragal212 2 years ago 3
high heels to the world =D
thavador 2 years ago
Wow, this sounds really good, didn't think she'd be able to pull it off ^^
dustd3mon 2 years ago
Why do some people moan about the singing? This was a good performance, I saw them in London in spring 09 and their performance was awesome!
Spectre500 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
in by by beautiful video she looks awsome
hear she little fatt
sory for my english
predatorvrb 2 years ago
im in uk and love to go to this festival
pikeybot 2 years ago
Comment removed
noemlih09 2 years ago
Comment removed
noemlih09 2 years ago
ide tap dat azz! mm hhmm
thatmetalguy85 2 years ago
esta cancion si q le sale bien,,, me alegro....
annette es buena también,,!!!! :)
TheNightTouch 2 years ago
Sry but Tarja had much more power at all if she was singing!!
But she is new so i thing it's just fair to give her a chance.
Nefas40000 2 years ago 3
agreed. It's the same with the Anette fans who bash Tarja. It's like, okay, now you sound just like the people insult Anette. :P
jooleah74 2 years ago
no tengo nada contra annette de hecho ya asumi que es la vocalista de nw xD pero debo decir que esa ropa no la favorece para nada x.x
noemlih09 2 years ago
I thank God that tarja is history!
irvrub 2 years ago
Comment removed
jooleah74 2 years ago
i miss tarja!!!!
Collins794 2 years ago 3
who doesn't? ):
Monrosefreak91094 2 years ago
if you miss her so bad, why watch a video with anette?? its so sillyyyy! :)
jooleah74 2 years ago
Panasonic Lumix TZ7 rulez !
LKSPriester 2 years ago
She is horrible.... in look, in voice, in charisma... just horrible...
Tizianachip 2 years ago
then why are you watching nightwish videos with her, silly?! :D
jooleah74 2 years ago
silly a tua madre, stronzo : )
Tizianachip 2 years ago
ohhhh shit, i just got insulted. lawlz.
way to actually respond to my questionnnn. xD
jooleah74 2 years ago
your question was stupid... i can watch everything i want... is it a free world, right? if someone don't want this, sould be post these videos on his/her personal facebook profile.
are u happy now? i answered.
Tizianachip 2 years ago
i didnt say you couldn't watch whatever you want, i just wondered why you would spend time watching a video you dont like, let alone go and comment on it after watching it. it didn't make sense, that's all. but, if you think my question is stupid, thats fine too. i was just curious.
jooleah74 2 years ago
well, i was corius too to watching this live, because Nightwish is one of my favourite group.
i support them, but i don't like annette... i think that this makes sense.
Tizianachip 2 years ago
congrats to anette which can ruin this song!
skr0xy 2 years ago
that statement has awkward wording. xP
jooleah74 2 years ago 2
wait i was watching a vid earlyer that said "Night wish says goodbye"... did they break up and get back together or something?
NationZane 2 years ago
First, Nightwish is ONE word, not two.
Second, in 2005, they had their singer (Tarja) leave the band. In 2007, they introduced their new singer, Anette, of whom is in this video. :)
jooleah74 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Anette was introduced as NWs new singer in 2006... Right after the album was completed....
h06anbjo 2 years ago
Actually, h06anbjo, NW's new singer was introduced in 2007. And, the album wasn't finished recording until February esque.
Check wikipedia's Dark Passion Play (Album) article and go under recording. :)
jooleah74 2 years ago
I was thinking something totally different... AA let go of Anette back then and she sent her auditiontape in... I got a little a head of myself...
h06anbjo 2 years ago
Atleast Marco still is awsome! but if you combine him with Tarja its legendary now you have 1 awsome singer and 1... ehm singer who is ok
heavenshell7 2 years ago 3
gOOD! :D
MUIILEROLERO 2 years ago
lol how can u think those clothes look bad... i think they looks rly nice at least better then tarjas big yellow dress :P
emil9412 2 years ago 4
Nice pop band :) lol
UptheIronsandRide 2 years ago
if you think this is pop
you don't understand about music =) lol
soraelegido 2 years ago 5
And you don't understand sarkasm.
With Tarja they sounded like metal band, now they sound like beach boys.
In the end i don't give a f..k
UptheIronsandRide 2 years ago
How the heck can Nightwish sound like the beach boys?
KingdomofReign 2 years ago
you're lawlzy. :D
if you dont give a fuck, then why watch this video, let alone comment?
oh i'm sure you don't give a fuck....
;)
jooleah74 2 years ago
doubt it.
WhooFlungPoo 2 years ago
Enough Hottfull Comments!
PErsonally... everytime i see this band I get soo excited because i can really feel nightwish's music! YAY!
shadowparkour 2 years ago
Tarja, I miss you!!! NOT!
man this band sounds soo much healthier without that pompous diva singing.
nice uh... boots! lol
SpudAlmighty 2 years ago
let's not get into insulting Tarja now. There's enough Anette-bashing. Let' not be like those Tarja-oholics. :D
jooleah74 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WHY THE FUCK does she ALLWAYS need to act as a whore!
Metalorb 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
because she is one...
TinaTennant 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They sucked at Graspop ..
No offence ..
cheating9 2 years ago
Yeah man Annete is sooo HOT
aturbulence 2 years ago 6
I hate annette but she looks hot in this one haha, mamasita! yeah!
escoriadelinfierno 2 years ago
that was one hypocritical sentence.....
silly you. :D
jooleah74 2 years ago
without tarja nightwish never would gonna be the same, impossible... what pretends nightwish with a pop female singer, thats makes me laught
snwXcore 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she is so hot:)
lordigreekfan19 2 years ago
shes awesome!
straightedger9 2 years ago
haha.
this sounds great.
anette is getting better and better.
i like her very much.
but she is not Tarja :(
miss her so fucking much.
love tarja <3
NightwishSteffi15 2 years ago 22
No, she's not Tarja. Would you really want her to be, anyway?
jooleah74 2 years ago
lol I had a nice chat with Annette after her performance, I actually got her phone number XD
xinesxxx 2 years ago 5
cool video, thanks for uploading!
HoherLordAkkarin 2 years ago
Tarja was definately better.
zaneruler 2 years ago
i agree... and nice name :D
NationZane 2 years ago
this song amazing yes tarja gone but its still the same band regardless..
yes the sound or the vocals not the best in this clip just enjoy its nightwish ffs..
pikeybot 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Love this version...HATE THE DRESS O_O
piketchup 2 years ago
nossa como ela está gostosa nesse show!
KetiPower 2 years ago
Fuck This Just Reminds Me How Truly Amazing Nightwish Are. Tuomas Is Easily One Of The Best Songwriters Ever.
5 Stars...
pkunderlord 2 years ago 2
I just wonder, is there any in the dictionary of music says which voice is for which song? B'coz I see people keep talking Annette had a pop voice. Maybe Susan Boyle should join NW then. Coz she had this a bit of operatic voice. She sang Memories like Simone Simons of Epica. Will Susan Boyle suit NW then? Hmmm.. Her voice might suit but she not a metal singer.
marcmm03 2 years ago 2
Susan Boyle sings musical tunes and wanted to make it big on Broadway...
You cannot place a certain singer in the boxes of Metal, Pop(which stand for POPular music, which NW is), Jazz... The only thing you can judge a voice on is if it hits the notes it's supposed to or not... Anette does that... And her notes go with the music...
h06anbjo 2 years ago 2
OMG! Anette's dresses are really really crazy!:-) But Marco is my god!:-)
rousse21 2 years ago
i do like anette i really do, however she does better witth her songs, not Tarja's..like these ones especially the old nightwish ones, she cant sing to well, and i see what Azdleb is talking about with her missing the high notes and what not, becasue she is..Tarja actuially had Vocal training, and it helped her out a lot..Anetter as far as i know dosent have the training that tarja had
she did do the song pretty well tho..i liked it
Hyugaftw3 2 years ago
And no, I'm not an Annette hater, I just think both her and the band have let the quality just drop since they got over the honeymoon period. Tarja deserved what she got, but I'm really thinking that they are suffering without an adequate replacement. I liked bits of DPP and I can hear the potential, but let's face it Nightwish fans, this isn't a very respectable performane on anyones part.
Adzleb 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Is it me, or is she out of tune 50% of the time?
Ducking high notes, vamping on longer ones can't she just stay on the note that was written? Are the rest of the guys in the band blind to this? She looks out of place (and, forgive me, in need of a post tour diet and detox), sounds second rate, and they really could have got someone better; I've heard X Factor auditionees with greater consistency of pitching.
Adzleb 2 years ago
i really like this vid it looks like they are just up there having fun nightwish forever
tntsam 2 years ago 7
One of these days Toumas is gonna do his headbop too far and smash his noggin on the keyboard xD
LadyVailen 2 years ago 2