Msnbc commentator on Dakota Fanning Rape Scene @ Sundance

[Red81181]

@911FalseFlagTerror01 Are you a fucking dumbass. You know what I think? I think you raped someone and your trying to justify it. I bet your a fucking messed up, low life, no job, let's not forget single because we all know you are, loser, with no life. Yes you know it's true. Don't deny it. You'll only embarass yourself even more dipshit.

[sargientcupcake]

Hahahaha!

[RevolutionistHenkel]

i think youtube cannot upload that RAPE SCENE or even SEXUAL SCENES bcoz youtube is a gay!

[911FalseFlagTerror01]

MSLSD interviews a negro child molester film reviewer. Liberalism is danger mental breakdown.

[edamianr]

What the fuck is wrong with this man?

[Googaify]

my dear... he must've lost his job immediately xD lol

[911FalseFlagTerror01]

@Googaify He's a sex offender. Lol.

[11xzxzxz]

I think a quick painless murder is worse than rape that is not violent as murder which will usually devastate the family and friends and maybe a spouse. Rape can be horrible and affect some people for the rest of their lives but others might shake it off in time or not even be very upset. If the threat of violence or violence becomes part of the rape that makes it seem so much worse imo and then I would not be opposed to very long jail terms.

[chemicalbro2007]

was that guy who was being interviewed making funny remarks, even if it's just a film and nothing happened of course, Dakota was just a little girl in the film she was 12 it wasn't funny to make a rude remark about the relation of the film where a child gets raped, that's not right and certainly not funny at all. Even if it's just a film not funny to make a remark like that about a child, really creepy...

[hitokirimasamun]

LOL RORSCACH IS GONNA FUCK HIM UP

[hitokirimasamun]

WHAT THE FUCKER?!!!

[TheRealDeal1515]

LMAO !

That is one perverted bastard XD !

[JBirdman]

lol

[HipHopElectronic]

HAHAHAHAHAHA i remember that shit

[13243546576879809090]

i cant believe wat he says on 0:23

[diddykongfu]

lmao

[fagsaaaa]

WTF? Wesley Morris , she is a little girl. Rapists should be castrated and killed because of all of the torment they put their victims through. Rape and murder are the two worst violent crimes.

[feoka]

i think rape and torture are the worst because torture can last for a loooong fuckin time but murder mostly is swift. and the pain goes away

[monkeymichel]

wtf? is that a plug for murder? yeah, let's hear it for murder.

[kledder2]

@feoka

Rape is overrated. You think it's justice to put someone in jail for many years because someone put a meatstick in you for 5 minutes? There are much worse things then rape.

[911FalseFlagTerror01]

@kledder2 Rape is not a serious crime. You don't die. It's not fatal.

[kledder2]

@911FalseFlagTerror01

Just because it's not fatal doesn't mean it's not a serious crime. Rape is overrated by feminists and some horny politicians made laws for it. Stricter than it should be.

[911FalseFlagTerror01]

@kledder2 The only reason law legitimately exist is for safety. No morals lewgislation. You can't legislate my moral values. Sin taxes don't encourage "moral behavior". Rape is not serious. Oh boo hoo you get raped you're still alive to bitch about it?Abortion is a crime, but rape? Why allow abortion for incest and rape? It's always rape when she doesn't want to get pregnant. Pregnancy is seen as a disease to teen girls abnormal even.

[winchesterboyz89]

@911FalseFlagTerror01 Oh, no it's not a serious crime when some unwanted man takes away a young girls virginity, the one piece of her that men can't understand. You might not die, but people who are wish that they did die. 'Cause being raped isn't just something that can be forgotten, it's a scar that will never ever fade away. You can't see it but its there. It'll seriously fuck someone up for the rest of their lives, it is fatal. It's like a cancer, eating you away from the inside.

[911FalseFlagTerror01]

@winchesterboyz89 Theft of property is not serious. Just sue for money. Feminists invented rape in the 1970s to excuse bad female behavior.

[winchesterboyz89]

@911FalseFlagTerror01 Oh I get it, like being sexually violated shouldn't matter because women obviously don't get physically or psychologically fucked up right by it right? Well you're obviously a man who wouldn't be able to comprehend what that does to a woman, or a man. Ask men how they feel being raped in prison, 'cause they as criminals are using that as an excuse for their bad behavior. My friend was raped, moron, it is a crime, men's dicks aren't all precious and not every woman wants it.

[winchesterboyz89]

@911FalseFlagTerror01 Why don't you go to a woman's survival group, of rape, and tell them that it was just an invention and that it never happened. Rape is a tool for men to establish dominance, it isn't a woman's invention. Why don't you go research that, go get raped and tell me how that goes, first hand experience is the only way for you to really know whether that's the answer to 'your bad behavior'.

[911FalseFlagTerror01]

@winchesterboyz89 If rape was real you would admit that women rape too not just white men. Racism colludig with sexism. Only men rape? A dildo isn't rape? Wome use rape as an excuse to moralize amoral behavior. Kill your kids because you were raped plead insanity and get no time. We all know how women abuse our courts

[911FalseFlagTerror01]

@winchesterboyz89 Women's survivial groups hate the heteropatriarrchy they would never let a man intp their secretive cabal.

[Phych101]

Lol.

[thebigapple3]

Edited and fake.

[pothead0707]

they definitly took that way out...what a crappy way for all of the world to see a person...thats just wrong...i think it sound like a great movie everyone will wanna watch all around...I thought movies were suppost to look real

[CalgarSkull]

They took it out of context I assume, he was talking about the movie in general haha

[lovelydiva06]

lol, that comment was so not right, considering the controversy around the film, im sure the critic guy had more to say other than that but they cut it off making it seem like he was talking about the rape seen and that it wasn't what he expected and imagined it differently in his head, dakota fanning is an amazing young actress her acting is very mature im sure people are just overhyping this rape scene and its not that bad otherwise the studios or her parents wouldn't have allowed it am sure

[chemicalbro2007]

@lovelydiva06 oh yeah i think that what they did, they edited the footage to make that critic guy sounding like he is saying something different lol. I certainly hope that was the case, pretty sick joke to think of it lol...

[nickfortitude]

these hollywood fuckers just can't wait to exploit every sinlge popular teenage girl and fuck them up like they did lohan. Now shes a fake whore

[BoSoxnation1972]

How is Hollywood exploiting Dakota? Because of a rape scene in an INDEPENDANT FILM? LMAO I remember a movie with Jenna Malone about 10 years ago called Bastard Out of Carloina which had a similar rape seen featuring Jenna when she was 10, and Jenna turned out just fine! Lindsey Lohan is a fuckup because she CHOOSES to hang out with the laughing stocks of society like Paris Hilton. For every Lindsey & Brittany, there's a Resse Witherspoon and Dakota Fannings. She'll be just fine!

[Luvzi12]

HAHAHAHA! Love the Soup!

[pwiattitto]

"it was better in my imagination" lol, danm. he'll be branded some time over nothing more than a slip of a tongue.

[AnnerisceRosa]

A seat.

Take one.

[lezzzlie]

Yea there were petitions so it couldn't come out yet. And dakota was wearing a bodysuit the whole time. They just imply a rape, but it doens't acutally show.Her mother and a child welfare agent were on the set the whole time. They're so stupid, she is just acting. ITS HER J-O-B.

[dancer00123]

but isn't dakota 14...

[skin1face]

she filmed it in 2006 when she was 12 but people are so dumb thinking that dakota is always gonna be that little girl they saw in i am sam that they dont want this movie to be released. i want to see it. i love dakota

[BoSoxnation1972]

Did you see Bastard Out of Carolina with Jenna Malone? It was a great movie (my favorite scene is when Jennas uncles beat the fuck out of her mom's boyfriend at a family party)

The movies aren't glorifying the sexualization of kids...infact they are showing the exact opposite of that!

[BeCoolAndLiveLife]

I do remember that. Wasn't she younger too? That was kinda graphic, but I think it showed exactly how terrible it is and made the audience feel the pain the little girl too.

[BoSoxnation1972]

yes Jenna was 10...even younger than Dakota. Unfortunately we live in a world where stuff like that happens, and the fact that people don't talk about it and wanna pretend that it never happens are the ones allowing it to happen by not acknowledging it. The people who complain about scenes like that will never see the film and just wanna throw their 2 cents in. I think that anyone sitting on a ratings board should have to watch any movie they give a rating to. Believe it or not, many don't!

[BeCoolAndLiveLife]

I completely agree with you.

[54spiritedwill54]

The movie Hounddog comes out July 18th, 2008. They will probably cut the rape scene. We will see

[timmmy99]

do you mean July 18th 2009 cause its should be out now

[Dimes329]

its not gonna get cut and I saw it its not that bad or graphic at you, you see nothing... Although it was edited down, from the original shoot, but its not that bad... Ed Norton gettin ass fucked in history X was more graphic then this scene

[khmel123]

poor dakota she always does sad movies

[theDreadMassacre]

is it just me or is this guy really fucking stupid

[Rosaline007]

where can I watch the rape scene???

Can somebody upload it please???

[khmel123]

u can not put it on utube it's too violent

[Rosaline007]

Why not???

The rape scene of Jenifer Aniston was allowed to be put here. Then why the rape scene of her can't????

[TMitose]

The movie isn't going to be released until september.

[DiabloDave363]

has chris hanson ever talked to u?

[Rosaline007]

Who is he???

[Dakota4Ever4]

@Rosaline007 dont watch it dude ,

[sketchman724]

0_o

[Lisa13245]

OOOO

[SWV8]

A few years, I saw Hide and Seek and at one point said "man, dakota fanning's one dicked up little kid!" because she was so messed up in the movie. Then this movie came out I made a joke, and i pretty much said the same thing except this time i thought wow, now dakota fanning is one seriously dicked up little kid....literally!

[sweetnsexy4u]

until you have lived it or known someone who has been abused as a child you might never see past child porn in thsoe scenes but forgive me if i'm still hoping that people will open their eyes before it happens to them or their own kids, I might be too passionate about this but everybody should do all that they can in order to stop these attrocities, which is one the of things this movie is trying to do, trying to make a difference, make a statement, a point...

[sweetnsexy4u]

in a world were internet, television and movies are the only way to communicate with everyone, the only way to point something out, i think we dont really have a choice, we need to do something about this, you will find that the kids younger than 1 yrs are 41.9% of all the child abused every year,The National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System reported an estimated 1,460 child fatalities in 2005..go read about baby brianna and tell me frankly that you are not disgusted

[zoom1234567]

child porn is child porn no way to twist around it . somebody needs to go down for the making of this film. simulated fake sexual contact of a minor with or without nudity constitutes child porn. looks like somebody didnt read the books before they made this movie

[sweetnsexy4u]

the intentions of the mdirectors of this film was probably not to promote child porn...as an actres myself i'm am fully aware of each role that I play, they all have an history either it be a prostitute or a rich brat kid, let me tell you that nowadays the only ones that can make a difference in this world of computer and television interconnectivity are the directors, actors and all of those who stands up and say something on television or big screen

[sweetnsexy4u]

all of this to say that even if she was too young in your opinion to chose to do this role, she was fully aware of what she was getting into and this movie is not an independant one and it has to respond to certain protocoles meaning that someone higher than them had to approve of everything that constitutes this movie, script, scenes actors, everything, so this rule book that you mentionned well they didn't disobey any rules in the making of this movie.

[sweetnsexy4u]

this movie has a meaning like every other movies that are made, maybe on the exception all of the blockbusters movies, this is not about child porn or breaking laws it's about opening the eyes of a generation that will soon be old enough to lead contries, go to war and make their own decisions in their life, it's now or never to make them see what is right and what is wrong and CHILD ABUSE IS WRONG...

[sweetnsexy4u]

and if the only way, they can understand that concept, is by making a movie about it then let's make thousands of movie every year about that, let's make movies and televisions show and documentaries about child abuse and the more realistic the scenes are the more the people on this earth will realize how disgusting this is and how horrible we are, the humans are the only ones to this, you will never see animals abuse their progenitures, they would die for them and some us kill their own kids..

[technopatheticx3]

o-o

[LU2087]

Movies like this challenge what is accepted in our society.. I think it makes for a great film to "go to far"...notice how all the popular films always have controversy. Job well done.

And I read somewhere a quote from Dakota Fanning that the rape scene was not really the focus of the film or what it was about. I haven't seen the movie, but Dakota Fanning is a wonderful young actress and she is very mature for her age.

[fatnazicowdicktater]

so let me get this str8. they actually had a 12 year old girl play rape in a movie??? wow. the film makers and parents apparently have a price for responsibility

[sweetnsexy4u]

on the contrairy you have it all wrong, she agreed to do this movie, fully knowing about the rape scene and for the intentions of making the movie industry move past all those blockbuster movies, this film was made in order to show on the big screen to millions of viewers that children still gets abused and raped in this century, it's a message and i think that she made a good choice in giving her name, which is kinda famous, to stop child abuse

[zoom1234567]

on the contrairy sweetnsexy to undermind laws is not a good thing because it opens the door for anyone to make a film with nothing but simulated sexual acts of a minor , the point being she was to young to aprove of the roll , you better hope somebody dont callange the law of simulated sexual acts of a minor and win , because soon you will see nothing but movies with 12 year old girl actors in rolls of such nature and the whole movie will be the same thing over and over.

[sweetnsexy4u]

and as for the parents it might not have been easy for them to let their 13 yrs old girl do this movie, but she probably convinced them to see this as a simple movie role that unfortunately reflects the daily life of kids all around the world, don't be close minded, it was certainly not a party for the parents to watch the rape scenes at the premiere, if they even were able to, stop seeing epic movies and go see an american crime, that ought to show you that movies have a purpose

[daritykane7]

if she is 12 and making a rape scene that shows how good and actress she is not a lot of 12 yr olds could do that let alone adults

[missdecemberplaymate]

LOL

[145gfgh]

what a load of moaners these are hope they dont cut it as it helps show the movie to the full effect.

[charmedrox07]

gfhhkgf;sjdgfsgbd'fgsdfgbsdjk

[fanning23x]

The movie Hounddog comes out July 18th, 2008. They will probably cut the rape scene. We will see

[magicseeker008]

Can somebody please message me with the transcript of this video??!!?!

I dont have the stupid speakers for a few days and I really wanna hear what he said O.O...

Thankssss!

[mysixstrings]

oh come on people the guy's words were taken out of context he didn't meant it in a bad way, maybe he heard all the talks about how nasty and dirty the rape scene was, so with that image in his head, he was watching the movie,and mentally preparing himself to see the depiction of a little girl being brutally raped based on all the media bullshit but instead he saw that there wasn't any serious problems

[UdoShan]

As a few observant people have pointed out (thank you,roaminggator) the comment that the critic made was about the WHOLE MOVIE, not the rape scene!

Jesus, people, pay attention...

[chronusvaltiel]

So THAT'S what Pyramid Head looks like under the mask.

[nintendaholic]

what is in that wierdo's imagination?

[Markymark419]

wow u sick ass....she is only 12

[Houminid]

perve

[UltraVioletGem]

Who raped her? Her mother's bf or something? Why did he do it? Was he drunk? What happened afterwards?

[NamanIV]

Lol 00:26

[DenmiSama]

O_O Was he fired?

[jackieliem2007]

I love Dakota Fanning so much

and I want rape her !

[ThroneTV]

he thought it was gonna be more brutal then what you see because the way critics talk about it they act like the guy is brutally takking it and they say he doesn't...

[skateboardpunkgirl]

I remeber this one.WOW,I love Joel always funny!

[ARNULFOZAMORA]

The rape mentality does not come alone. vikings lived on the same islands as the inuit indians but quickly extincted themselves with a rape/pillage culture. Inuits still inhabit the same islands, the difference?The Inuit indians executed rapists and respected the environment. Its more important than ever to make rape a capitol offence. Killing sex offenders is a great deterent to our rape/pilage/exploit culture. respect women, children,the earth. write to congress execute rapists!

[ARNULFOZAMORA]

the mentality of rape does not come alone.The vikings who inhabited the same islands as the inuit quickly extincted themselves with their rape and pillage culture. Americans are like vikings of the past. Sexual predators are becoming more and more socialy exceptable because of the internet, thats why its so important to make rape a capitol offence. Killing sex offenders would be a great deterent to our current pro extinction mind sets.

[mka800]

So irrelevant to this video, you had to post it twice. It does make sense, though.

[arumanti]

unforgiven

good dakotas cute nude

[opitz74]

better in your imagination? I can't help but laugh at that idiot

[klamydia0508]

hahahahahaahaah!!!!!!!!!!!!! LMAO!!

[iamscoutstfu]

ROFFLMMFAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

[lafond1H]

UNFORGIVABLE

[orangepencilonlaptop]

that's nasty that a 12yr old gets raped.. in a movie. just the thought of it.. is gross? even though it's just a movie.

ew. people are nasty.

[Sammartin16]

SICK PERVERTT!!!!

[crustymethaddict]

hahaha

[josephdaw]

rofllmfao

[arumanti]

ohhh good i like watch dakota rape is sexy babe i want lunch canibal hanibal lecter is love of dakotas love omg god bon a petit a nose of dakota sexy sexy sexy ohhh ..............................­................and hes very cute

[ralphcifaretto1]

Hahaha ! Fuck Sake !!!!

[Zetnov]

MEGA-LOL

[marshmallowygoodness]

oh my god, irriducibil828. THATS WHAT THEY SAID HUNDREDS OF YEARS AGO AND IT GOT MILLIONS OF INNOCENT BLACK PEOPLE EXECUTED. i hope you were kidding.

[derekjtg]

i just watched this 10 minutes ago!

[zamb0nio]

ibslc

[roxychick333]

u r a sick person Shanemac88 as if anyone would

[corngrinder1]

hey fuck you Irriducibili828, you white racist!

[valericool]

ur such a stupid filthy racist, it doesnt matter if its someone black or white, there r also many white men that are fucking rapers!

so stop being a racist u asshole

[Aistulf]

Yep, another case of the Tee aN Bee!

[valericool]

ew ur sick u fuckin pedophile

u should go arrested

[Superapplefrog]

Shanemac88 anyone who rapes a 12-year-old (or anyone else) needs their head testing. Why the fuck would you wanna destroy a person's life like that and cause them to commit suicide?

[ric112]

as if they're being serious. lighten up.

[Superapplefrog]

Oh right so laughing at rape victims is funny now is it? Let me know when your sense of humour is less twisted

[iammont]

you're a stuck up piece of shit

[Superapplefrog]

Right. I'm a stuck up piece of shit because I actually have feelings for other humans and don't think laughing at abuse is funny? So I suppose if I ever actually HELP a victim of abuse, I'm REALLY far up my own arse? What drugs are you taking?

[iammont]

oh, right, youre british.

move along people, nothing to see here.

[Superapplefrog]

Oh great idea - start on the racist crap because, like most North Americans on youtube, you have nothing to say that's worth reading

[ThroneTV]

you have .

[coolc101]

That wasn't funny!!!!! The subject matter is absoulety nothing to joke about!!!!!!!!!!

[flyckorna]

What is truly disappointing is that Dakota is playing yet another role as the victim. Don't these people realize that society is teaching young girls that they are victims by showing this role to them over and over again. To empower girls we need to show them having pleasurable sex and happy relationships.

[Paniked68]

I'm not sure I entirely agree with your remarks, but I will say that Dakota Fanning's constant screaming nearly ruined "War of the Worlds." I was hoping her character would be killed, just so her inane, cowardly screaming would finally end.

[maratt123]

I Agree lol!

[majorvoltage]

I agree. But on the other hand, showing them being abused raises awareness of it, because unfortunately it does happen.

[majorvoltage]

I am encouraged by the fact that despite the outrage, Dakota was able to go ahead and make this movie because it's what SHE wanted to do. In that respect, she's a great role model for kids everywhere. I'm hoping that strong children like Dakota will lead to the next great social revolution; child liberation.

[MyndigJAg]

amen to that!

[majorvoltage]

Hey you're from Sweden! Have you heard of Amy Diamond? Her song "big guns" is an inspiration.

[smokerdalejash]

mmmm dakota's little ass

[freedermkk]

where did u see it?

[ThroneTV]

They showed it in Calorado 2006 I believe around Halloween and then they showed it in 2007 around spring... it was not that bad that rape sence passed and then it's like ok still a good movie ..

[exmore07]

oooooh foot in mouth

[potcfanatic]

LOL Shame on that man...

[luvinyou69]

gay!!

[helen3333]

that guy is suck!!! :<

[roaminggator]

I don't really see what is so funny. They basically cut off his words and took them out of context. They asked him about the movie...not specifically the rape scene. He said he was disappointed in the movie and it was better in his imagination, in other words, in his expectations about the movie. Just another poor attempt by the media to create something that is not there.

[rarenature]

The Soup took an excerpt from him commentary. Actually the critic was disgusted about the film portraying the rape, rather than a scene just alluding to the rape and leaving it to the viewers imagination. Similar to a scene when someone gets stabbed and they don't show the actual knife insertion, but show blood splatter on the floor.

[rarenature]

The Soup took an excerpt from him commentary. Actually the critic was disgusted about the film portraying the rape, rather than a scene just alluding to the rape and leaving it to the viewers imagination. Similar to a scene when someone gets stabbed and they don't show the actual knife insertion, but show blood splatter on the floor.

[SirLuchieus]

that guy is sick

[ThroneTV]

lol... he said he wanted it to be more hardcore in his mind lol ehhh what the hell is he thinking .. but seriously thought the movie is not that bad

[ronismonis]

haha saw this on the soup. and ppl im pretty sure they edited his opinion from a different part. ITS CALLED EDITING. but he might have actually said that haha. what a tool

[ThroneTV]

they did. that man did not say that because it would have been all on TV all on the news

[Pikahound]

how nasty..

[UrbanMyersIsNumber1]

"It wasn't wat I pictured in my head"

Ha wat a pedo