Ok this is probably only the 2nd time I've commented on a fanvid, and I have a watched A LOT. For many different shows/couples. There's lots of fancy vids with crazy kinda of editing, and they're great. But you, you brilliant angel, you just caught the emotions perfect, stitched them together beautifully and made me cry! Thank you for this!
I love that you took clips from even the earliest episodes and just the entire video is amazing. Great job. You don't deserve those 2 dislikes. It's probably the best Doctor/Rose video I've ever seen.
This video really makes me realize why i love Doctor Who so much! My girlfriend is Dutch and she never even heard of Doctor Who before she met me.. Now she bloody loves it!
I'm not sure if you take requests, but if you do, could you make a video for doctor who to the song "Endless Roads" by Jason Munday? If not that's fine but I thought I'd ask just in case.
I think that is the first fan video ever to make me cry. I am sitting here crying like a child and thinking how I need to start back at the beginning of Series 1 again because I miss them so much.
My best friend, a fellow Whovian, sent me this video. I watched it... the song is perfect (I know every word anyway)... to say I cried would be an understatement. Tears are still running down my face. I'm sobbing. Amazing job, you captured the pain of their separation perfectly... :'( ♥
God, I had the sad feeling left in me after watching this. Truly now I want to find a video about them being happily ever after. Though re-watching the last episode of season 4 satisfies this, I crave to know how she and the Doctor lived and how their lives turned out.
@TechGrenade I've made some of those too. I just couldn't resist. Try 'Nobody Sees' and 'Wait for Me' on my original channel. I hope they help, at least a little. ;)
I watched em, truly amazing. I also rewatchted the episode were Rose get's a Doctor of her own. A happy ending and with your videos I have a slight idea of it might be like for them now in this alternate world. I try to think of the happy ending Rose must be having but it does hurt a bit that I won't see her again. It feels like so much more then just 1 season with Rose and the 10th Doctor. Truly I love the story between the two.
after all is said and done...I´ll always treasure the time the doctor had with Marta and I absolutely loved him and Donna, such a winning team! But when it comes down to it all, it´ll always be The Doctor and Rose, cuz they fell inlove!
500 character is not enough to describe how wonderful I feel about this. I could write a 6000 words essay about this. If perfect exists it's right here.
This is probably the best Doctor Who video ever made. I cry every time, but I still watch it over and over and over. Forever crying. You, sir/ma'am, are a god(dess).
I've watched this so many times, its just so heartbreaking yet I love the feeling. Re-fell in love with the song, such a beautiful video. Idek I just love refreshing my shippy-ness by watching the video and listening to the song. Your videos are always so well made!
although the doctor loved rose , now in his 11th incarnation he now feels guilt for losing her but strnding her in the parrael world and taking her normal human life away
This video is unbelievable. Heart-breaking, raw, painful, gorgeous and just - epic. The energy behind it, the cuts to the music, the overlay of the audio in all the right places - the way it ebbs and flows to the words and movement of the music - there are no words. Probably the BEST video I have ever seen in any fandom. Ever. You deserved every award you received and probably some of the ones you didn't receive. Just stunning.
Oh wow this was so perfect! I'm not the verge of tears this is just so...beautiful! Really incredible job. You did an amazing job of showing him missing Rose when she's gone and I love the fade/layover things you did. And the inclusion of the audio was great! And I love you mixed 9 and 10! So so great!
created and this...THIS was GORGEOUS! Twisted me heart right up, but it was done so beautifully. Besides using scenes that many usually don't, the transitions were quite smooth and the whole video was absolutely touching! I have never seen a video that has gotten such a reaction from me and that's saying something because there are a lot of wonderfully creative people here. I could go on and on, but then I'd be quoting a thesaurus for how wonderfully magnificent this video was!
I've been making a few Doctor and Rose videos since the beginning of the year. My sister knows I'm obsessed with them so when she was hearing Evanescence we both turned to each other and said, "Doctor and Rose!" She wanted me to make a video of them with this song (even if she's not an obsessive rabid fan like I am), but I thought it was too depressing (I try not to write/create angst at all costs, but I love reading/watching it). So I thought I'd have a look to see what other people have
This is gorgeous. Absolutely gorgeous. I'm the type who normally just lurks on people's videos (partly, because I share this account with friends), but this was too well done to go without comment. I enjoy watching fanMVs, but almost never do I see something this well done. Excellent song choice, the clips fit the lyrics perfectly, the editing was practically flawless, and the choice and incorporation of dialogue was better than I've ever seen done. Excellent work. ~J (off to cry now...)
I can never say this enough, but you are truly talented. Your videos are amazing and brilliant. This couple is my favorite and will always be in my heart no matter what. Your video, the clips, the timing, the music- impeccable. I loved how you used the Doctor yelling at the Daleks to kill him right when the song gets louder. I love this couple and wish they had stayed on the show together longer. Amazing tribute and the song was perfect haha. In the words on the amazing, 10th Doctor; fantastic,
PS, I'm new to Who fandom, and I came here looking for a good Rose/Doctor vid, and I need look no further, this one is absolutely perfect. The timing, the editing are amazing and capture their relationship with unbelievable accuracy. So heartbreaking. The part of the video where the music swells and he screams "Kill me!" and then we see that bit from Doomsday - wow. I wonder what kind of "man" the Doctor would've become if Pete hadnt popped in and grabbed her. It would have been devastating.
Makes me think about me and my girlfriend... I have been through so much shit and pain and sadness in my life, losing my mum, etc. But i will always use that pain and sadness and compassion to protect and save her from danger no matter what.
God, this video is just perfect. The mix of the song and the audio from the show, the way the clips are put together, the song in general... everything. Heartbreaking, but beautiful and amazing.
that was soo sad i am starting summer vacation with nothing to do never watched doctor who but will since it is on netflix thank for this video made me wanna cry
at 2:55, were you TRYING to kill me?! Starting with how he lost her, showing her missing him, Doctor screaming at the Darlek and then to see when she gets ripped away?? Too much to bear, not to mention the perfectly timed swelling of the music...damn, all I gotta say is..damn.
I still can't get through this video without crying. The video and the song mesh together perfectly, and it fits the pairing perfectly as well. This is one of the best videos I've ever seen on Youtube.
wow. this video makes me fall in actual love with david tennant. He and billie are such great actors, that chemistry will never be matched on doctor who
I will never not love these two with all the love that my wee, one human heart can hold. Brilliant editing as always. Loved it in HD, loved it in non-HD. Just love it.
EPIC. Epically sad, epically awesome... just epic. I can't get through it without crying at least a bit, but it's still amazing, and a truly fantastic video. It breaks my heart, it's so sad, and the song is so perfect for the Doctor and Rose.
I've made a few fan videos of my own for other movies, so I can totally appreciate the time and the heart & soul you put into this one. My 16-year-old daughter introduced me to the series last year and I was hooked. This is such a wonderful tribute to Rose and the Doctor. Thank you so much for sharing this with us! But, goodness...it makes me cry every time I watch it!!
Pretty sure I comment on this every time I watch it. I was at work the other day, and this song came on the radio. Oh shit. I nearly burst into tears.
This is a very beautiful well done tribute to the Love Affair of the Doctor and Rose. Definitely brings tears to ones eyes . . . Thanks so much for posting this on Youtube and in High Def . I totally agree with others who have commented on your videos that you should be the one doing Doctor Who Promos . . .
Oh my goodness. I don't even have to think that this is THE single best fanvid I've ever seen, regardless of fandom. The song (which is in fact overused, usually) is PERFECT for the Doctor and Rose, the editing's brilliant, and it just conveys the importance of the relationship between the Doctor and Rose. Beautifully done.
I really love this vid. It really spoke to me and the scenes you used to convey the imagery from the lyrics was amazing. I think this is the best vid that used this song that I have ever seen.
This is without a doubt one of the best fanvids I've ever seen. The editing is brilliant, the song is perfect, and all of it just makes e want to cry, but it's still beautiful. Just... wow.
This video makes me tear up every time, especially at the part when the Doctor is yelling at the daleks on ;( I miss rose. She should come back for series 6 :)
@DoctorWho852 Yeah, that bit with the Daleks is sheer genius. Also, the dying in battle part, just a bit echoed. The creator of these videos is a legend.
i laughed as soon as amy said "too much the time cannot erased..." never in my life would i would make that connection to her song...wierd at least it stopped me for tearing up
This is amazing. (As has been said many times before). I love the way you used clips from season one. It seems to me that when people make videos about Rose and The Doctor being in love, they only ever use season two clips.
YESSSS!!!!!!!!!! I FOUND IT!!!!!! I FINALlY FOUND IT! I watched this video months ago, and I loved the part with the Doctor screaming at the Daleks (actually, I loved all of it, but, not the point), and I tried to favorite it, and it didn't work, so I lost it. Searching for weeks and months, I FINALLY FOUND IT AGAIN!!! Oh, this day rocks!
"There's too much that time cannot erase." That part hit me in the heart like a silver bullet. Considering what he can do as a timelord, but it's also because he's a timelord that he can't bring himself to rupture the walls of parallel universe to get to Rose. OH MAN. Tears!!! Tears everywhere. Well done on the choice of clips, the editing and the song choice!!!
I don't watch Dr. Who really, just in passing..don't ship The Doctor/Rose...but this video is beautiful, poignant, and moved me to tears. Magnificent job you did there! Oh yeah, I subscribed...You are an artist.
This song is usually totally cliched and WAY overused, but it just works SO well with Rose and the Doctor and this video is just so perfect... it just works, really well. Rose and the Doctor.... it just breaks my heart.... :(
So, I watched this long before I had a youtube account and favourited it... then the whole Doctor Who obsession fizzled out until I started thinking about this video today, so re-watched it (now with a youtube account).
Can I just say... WOW.
I used to watch this before I went to school every morning and as soon as I got home and, even though I over-watched it, it still has STILL managed to have a powerful effect on me.
This is pure brilliance. You got the relationship perfectly.
My favourite bits (apart from all of it :D) have to be 0:59 - 1:04 cos heroic 9 is just so darn perfect, and 3:19 when he reaches up to touch her face *sob*.
Yeah this made me tear up. I've seen Doomsday so much I can actually make it through that without crying now, but this video got me. Amazing work, as always.
Saw the old version an loved that one, love this one just as much if not more. One of my favourite songs and one of my favourite tv programs. Excellently made and brilliantly thought out.
Hmm looks like one person missed the like button when they were rating it
@Trekkie54who this version is Evanescence...I didn't know there were different covers -_-' but I don't listen to Evanescence that much...but I would guess it's a studio version
tears everytime :'( so beautifully done, one of my favourite Doctor/Rose vids
sarahsarah102 6 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
This has been flagged as spam show
This is so beautiful.
The greatest love story ever told. ♥
ownssmyheart 6 days ago
Comment removed
ownssmyheart 6 days ago
I watch this everyday, so god damn beautiful <3
sarahsarah102 1 week ago
2:56-3:00 Gets me every time. Oh god. ='(
maiamire 2 weeks ago
Oh the tears. So beautiful.
TokiKitsune 3 weeks ago
I was brought to tears.
xTeniPurix 3 weeks ago
I won't lie, I teared up quite a bit. Doctor/Rose forever!
UtenaOfRoses 3 weeks ago
from 2:40 on i cried
GlassSlipperTears 1 month ago
Ok this is probably only the 2nd time I've commented on a fanvid, and I have a watched A LOT. For many different shows/couples. There's lots of fancy vids with crazy kinda of editing, and they're great. But you, you brilliant angel, you just caught the emotions perfect, stitched them together beautifully and made me cry! Thank you for this!
gingerfer16 1 month ago 2
I am perfectly honest when I say this, this is the best video I've seen on youtube, ever. Ever. It's just... wow. God I miss Rose and Ten so bad.
sofiianugget 1 month ago
I love that you took clips from even the earliest episodes and just the entire video is amazing. Great job. You don't deserve those 2 dislikes. It's probably the best Doctor/Rose video I've ever seen.
Flik43point8 1 month ago
I miss Rose. :(
Flik43point8 1 month ago
my butt itches....
SamirSuperman786 1 month ago
This video really makes me realize why i love Doctor Who so much! My girlfriend is Dutch and she never even heard of Doctor Who before she met me.. Now she bloody loves it!
oOCaptainCrazyOo 1 month ago
god i love this so much (':
mcr124556 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
I look up this video regularly just to watch it.
starrberstt 2 months ago 2
I'm not sure if you take requests, but if you do, could you make a video for doctor who to the song "Endless Roads" by Jason Munday? If not that's fine but I thought I'd ask just in case.
stargazer1574 2 months ago
I think that is the first fan video ever to make me cry. I am sitting here crying like a child and thinking how I need to start back at the beginning of Series 1 again because I miss them so much.
SatelliteAlice 2 months ago 5
The Doctor is to rose as i am to the girl i want to b with.........so far apart.
jaw4998 2 months ago
gross sobbing ensues
iluvmyhorsie123 2 months ago 2
I was sobbing
wizardmon13 2 months ago 3
Is it alright if I re-Upload this on my Account? It's that good. I'll be sure to give you all the credit for the video.
Chocolateshake1234 2 months ago
My best friend, a fellow Whovian, sent me this video. I watched it... the song is perfect (I know every word anyway)... to say I cried would be an understatement. Tears are still running down my face. I'm sobbing. Amazing job, you captured the pain of their separation perfectly... :'( ♥
maggielovesrelientk 3 months ago 3
God, I had the sad feeling left in me after watching this. Truly now I want to find a video about them being happily ever after. Though re-watching the last episode of season 4 satisfies this, I crave to know how she and the Doctor lived and how their lives turned out.
TechGrenade 3 months ago
@TechGrenade I've made some of those too. I just couldn't resist. Try 'Nobody Sees' and 'Wait for Me' on my original channel. I hope they help, at least a little. ;)
seduff 3 months ago
@seduff
I watched em, truly amazing. I also rewatchted the episode were Rose get's a Doctor of her own. A happy ending and with your videos I have a slight idea of it might be like for them now in this alternate world. I try to think of the happy ending Rose must be having but it does hurt a bit that I won't see her again. It feels like so much more then just 1 season with Rose and the 10th Doctor. Truly I love the story between the two.
TechGrenade 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 2
after all is said and done...I´ll always treasure the time the doctor had with Marta and I absolutely loved him and Donna, such a winning team! But when it comes down to it all, it´ll always be The Doctor and Rose, cuz they fell inlove!
Micromusecut 3 months ago
MOST PERFECT FAN VIDEO I'VE EVER SEEN! You really have talent!
keaneing 3 months ago
500 character is not enough to describe how wonderful I feel about this. I could write a 6000 words essay about this. If perfect exists it's right here.
kunaluh 3 months ago 2
This is probably the best Doctor Who video ever made. I cry every time, but I still watch it over and over and over. Forever crying. You, sir/ma'am, are a god(dess).
elizawilliams7 3 months ago
I've watched this so many times, its just so heartbreaking yet I love the feeling. Re-fell in love with the song, such a beautiful video. Idek I just love refreshing my shippy-ness by watching the video and listening to the song. Your videos are always so well made!
LookToTheStars24 4 months ago
This is taking over my life
TheSeventhMurder 4 months ago 4
*DIES*
TheSeventhMurder 4 months ago in playlist TheSeventhMurder's favorites
I'm crying. Ohhhhh god I'm crying.
"They keep on trying to split us up, but they never ever will. Don't you reckon, Doctor?"
FreakBellSeven 4 months ago
This is one of the most perfect things I have ever seen.
SennaAnodyneRaylie47 4 months ago
AHHHH!!!! Poor David!!! Definatly the best Doctor ever!!!!
Emilydaffern4 4 months ago
What's going on at 1:00? What episode is that?
NevillesGran1 4 months ago
@NevillesGran1 It's from season 1 episode 3 - the unquiet dead
Beaslby 4 months ago
My poor shipper heart.
Nervoustruth 4 months ago 2
Fantastic!
MachinationFilms 4 months ago
:'( cried my eye's out... Amazing job on this video, perfect bled of song and effects from actual episodes... :(
AlickRowan 4 months ago
This is just so perfect. That song is really really perfect and asladsksmfefiunhjadioknd I just have a lot of feelings ;___;
QuotesTVD 4 months ago
Cried.
hadiaIAM 4 months ago
How can ANYONE dislike this?!?! Epically beautiful :D
2090792 5 months ago
my roomate is staring at me because im sitting at my computer weeping. great job, its beautifully moving :)
fictionOVERreality 5 months ago
You did a remarkable job. You know how I know? Because I just started crying.
BEAUTIFUL.
NoaA95 5 months ago 3
sdvnkjdbvdskvskdbvksdvbj this wrenches my heart EVERY TIME :'( </3
jEnNiFeRaNiStOnRoCkZ 5 months ago
although the doctor loved rose , now in his 11th incarnation he now feels guilt for losing her but strnding her in the parrael world and taking her normal human life away
doz222 6 months ago in playlist doz222's Favourited Videos
There needs to be a cry reaction.....
SilvaAdrianiel 6 months ago
THAT IS SO SAD!
writermercia 6 months ago
*bawls like a baby*
beautiful
UltimateCybress 6 months ago
Normally I feel this song is over-used but you definitely justified it. Heartbreaking.
janekrahe 6 months ago
I can't watch this without tearing up. Gosh, how are you even real?
pirategirl102 6 months ago
This video is unbelievable. Heart-breaking, raw, painful, gorgeous and just - epic. The energy behind it, the cuts to the music, the overlay of the audio in all the right places - the way it ebbs and flows to the words and movement of the music - there are no words. Probably the BEST video I have ever seen in any fandom. Ever. You deserved every award you received and probably some of the ones you didn't receive. Just stunning.
skallywalla 6 months ago 25
I truly do feel his anger and pain... I have suffered so much similar..
ShroudedFury 6 months ago
Well done on the video.
DarthReven83 7 months ago
Oh wow this was so perfect! I'm not the verge of tears this is just so...beautiful! Really incredible job. You did an amazing job of showing him missing Rose when she's gone and I love the fade/layover things you did. And the inclusion of the audio was great! And I love you mixed 9 and 10! So so great!
loveGG3 7 months ago
created and this...THIS was GORGEOUS! Twisted me heart right up, but it was done so beautifully. Besides using scenes that many usually don't, the transitions were quite smooth and the whole video was absolutely touching! I have never seen a video that has gotten such a reaction from me and that's saying something because there are a lot of wonderfully creative people here. I could go on and on, but then I'd be quoting a thesaurus for how wonderfully magnificent this video was!
chibitsukihoshi 7 months ago 2
I've been making a few Doctor and Rose videos since the beginning of the year. My sister knows I'm obsessed with them so when she was hearing Evanescence we both turned to each other and said, "Doctor and Rose!" She wanted me to make a video of them with this song (even if she's not an obsessive rabid fan like I am), but I thought it was too depressing (I try not to write/create angst at all costs, but I love reading/watching it). So I thought I'd have a look to see what other people have
chibitsukihoshi 7 months ago
This will always be my fav version...
ShroudedFury 7 months ago
@xxBeccaFlectcher thx
wolfking94 7 months ago
which episode is the one where he is saying to kill him
wolfking94 7 months ago
@wolfking94 It's from Evoloution of the Daleks.
xxBeccaFletcher 7 months ago
jeez my eyes water to this all the time it really touches my heart
AustralianPhenomena 7 months ago
Torn my heart to pieces.
Brilliant!
jialgri 7 months ago
Comment removed
weareMJandR 7 months ago
This is gorgeous. Absolutely gorgeous. I'm the type who normally just lurks on people's videos (partly, because I share this account with friends), but this was too well done to go without comment. I enjoy watching fanMVs, but almost never do I see something this well done. Excellent song choice, the clips fit the lyrics perfectly, the editing was practically flawless, and the choice and incorporation of dialogue was better than I've ever seen done. Excellent work. ~J (off to cry now...)
weareMJandR 7 months ago
I can never say this enough, but you are truly talented. Your videos are amazing and brilliant. This couple is my favorite and will always be in my heart no matter what. Your video, the clips, the timing, the music- impeccable. I loved how you used the Doctor yelling at the Daleks to kill him right when the song gets louder. I love this couple and wish they had stayed on the show together longer. Amazing tribute and the song was perfect haha. In the words on the amazing, 10th Doctor; fantastic,
immortaletternity 7 months ago
PS, I'm new to Who fandom, and I came here looking for a good Rose/Doctor vid, and I need look no further, this one is absolutely perfect. The timing, the editing are amazing and capture their relationship with unbelievable accuracy. So heartbreaking. The part of the video where the music swells and he screams "Kill me!" and then we see that bit from Doomsday - wow. I wonder what kind of "man" the Doctor would've become if Pete hadnt popped in and grabbed her. It would have been devastating.
ThisIsMyBoomStick 8 months ago
Wow, this is stunning and perfect! Trying not to cry...
ThisIsMyBoomStick 8 months ago
@ThisIsMyBoomStick me too!!
TheTardisDreamer 8 months ago
anything to do with the Doctor and Rose which is by Seduff will be good
barberalex1 8 months ago
I'm crying right now...this is so emotionally and beautifully done! Brilliant job!!
KobayashiMaru89 8 months ago 2
Makes me think about me and my girlfriend... I have been through so much shit and pain and sadness in my life, losing my mum, etc. But i will always use that pain and sadness and compassion to protect and save her from danger no matter what.
CJCartoons 8 months ago 2
God, this video is just perfect. The mix of the song and the audio from the show, the way the clips are put together, the song in general... everything. Heartbreaking, but beautiful and amazing.
PigPenguin91 8 months ago 54
I'm crying. :')
KatzePiano 8 months ago in playlist Doctor Who 2
ohmigod from 2:53 to 3:20 I nearly died because of goosebumps.
godessshannon 8 months ago
Okay, honestly, I'm sitting here sobbing. I haven't watched doomsday yet because I know that I'm going to be depressed after I watch it. ;n;
Awesome video.
IntrepidInkweaver 8 months ago
why must you rip my heart out with your sad video!!!!
PPandJF 8 months ago
I love it your vid made me cry, fav' <3
CrazyBitchair 8 months ago
Comment removed
godessshannon 8 months ago
A very beautiful video Seduff. Thank you for making it.
AngelicaConstantine 8 months ago
This is a beautiful brilliant video…sooo sad…the clips matched the music perfectly and just wow…I am crying…yup….but sooo good nonetheless
bandgeekweirdo 8 months ago
that was soo sad i am starting summer vacation with nothing to do never watched doctor who but will since it is on netflix thank for this video made me wanna cry
babyangel1317 9 months ago
brilliant video, was already crying at 0:36. amazing
fskater007 9 months ago
I promised myself that no matter what , I wasn't going to cry during this.
I started off pretty well , but right around the 3:30 mark I burst out in tears .
This is beautiful , Doctor and Rose ♥
kourtniiRAWR 9 months ago
at 2:55, were you TRYING to kill me?! Starting with how he lost her, showing her missing him, Doctor screaming at the Darlek and then to see when she gets ripped away?? Too much to bear, not to mention the perfectly timed swelling of the music...damn, all I gotta say is..damn.
jetlaginwis 9 months ago
@jetlaginwis definately the best part. Completely heart-wrenching!!!!
Perinlyn 9 months ago in playlist Seduff Videos
There are no words on this planet to describe the beauty,and in the same time the sorrow, of this video... great job :)
Lucy1996Cro 9 months ago
I still can't get through this video without crying. The video and the song mesh together perfectly, and it fits the pairing perfectly as well. This is one of the best videos I've ever seen on Youtube.
PigPenguin91 9 months ago
wow. this video makes me fall in actual love with david tennant. He and billie are such great actors, that chemistry will never be matched on doctor who
salsaru85 9 months ago
I will never not love these two with all the love that my wee, one human heart can hold. Brilliant editing as always. Loved it in HD, loved it in non-HD. Just love it.
RedHeadLuvGoddess 9 months ago
where is 3:34 from? i know it's tooth and claw but which scene is it?
sarareadsalot 9 months ago
@sarareadsalot i think its a deleted scene
spirit0423 9 months ago
I'm still watching this video after all this time. Thanks Seduff!
icepikoftime 9 months ago
I've seen this so many times and it still gives me goose bumps... Fabulous wonderful job... The Doctor and Rose forever!
shayleencb 10 months ago
Ugh...I love your videos. This one finally broke me and I cried. Well done. Well done indeed.
carbuncle22 10 months ago
AMAZING
TheAdcorn 10 months ago
This is AMAZING!
TheAdcorn 10 months ago
EPIC. Epically sad, epically awesome... just epic. I can't get through it without crying at least a bit, but it's still amazing, and a truly fantastic video. It breaks my heart, it's so sad, and the song is so perfect for the Doctor and Rose.
PigPenguin91 10 months ago
Anyone else notice the small spit bubble in Tennants mouth at 0:21-0:23. LOL.
ChaosTheory0 10 months ago
at 3:00 when he screams " Kill me just do it!!" and it echoes and the more heavy music kicks in THAT is just so hauntingly epic, shit!
Micromusecut 10 months ago 54
@Micromusecut that bit always gets me!
12793lexilou 5 months ago
How is it even possible to make such an incredible video??? I even had goosebumps on my nipples for gods sake!
Micromusecut 10 months ago
I've made a few fan videos of my own for other movies, so I can totally appreciate the time and the heart & soul you put into this one. My 16-year-old daughter introduced me to the series last year and I was hooked. This is such a wonderful tribute to Rose and the Doctor. Thank you so much for sharing this with us! But, goodness...it makes me cry every time I watch it!!
Jenflower74 10 months ago
I just love all of your videos. I'm your greatest fan. ;-)
This is the best video I have ever seen! I love how the pictures fit with the music, the way you put it all together. I watched it a thousand times.
Everytime I watch it, I cry. :-( Sorry for my english, I am from Germany ;-)
BBM05 11 months ago
Best.Video.Ever.
secretsecrets476 11 months ago
Pretty sure I comment on this every time I watch it. I was at work the other day, and this song came on the radio. Oh shit. I nearly burst into tears.
Thoroughbred17 11 months ago
This is a very beautiful well done tribute to the Love Affair of the Doctor and Rose. Definitely brings tears to ones eyes . . . Thanks so much for posting this on Youtube and in High Def . I totally agree with others who have commented on your videos that you should be the one doing Doctor Who Promos . . .
bfranke63 11 months ago
Completely beautiful. I loved it :)
LouisaGlasson 11 months ago
Oh my goodness. I don't even have to think that this is THE single best fanvid I've ever seen, regardless of fandom. The song (which is in fact overused, usually) is PERFECT for the Doctor and Rose, the editing's brilliant, and it just conveys the importance of the relationship between the Doctor and Rose. Beautifully done.
And yes, it made me start crying XD
writerserenyty 11 months ago
I really love this vid. It really spoke to me and the scenes you used to convey the imagery from the lyrics was amazing. I think this is the best vid that used this song that I have ever seen.
1ucky02 11 months ago
Really good, I enjoy your vids alot
TheJonnie15 11 months ago
This is without a doubt one of the best fanvids I've ever seen. The editing is brilliant, the song is perfect, and all of it just makes e want to cry, but it's still beautiful. Just... wow.
PigPenguin91 1 year ago
this is amazing! good job !
Amiii264 1 year ago
I was doing okay until the very end and then...tears.
"Who are you two?"
"Oh, the stuff of legend." How true...sigh =)
SallyT88 1 year ago
woah im in tears. that was brilliant.
aplaceforusbabe 1 year ago
Watching this always makes me cry. It provokes so much emotion. Thanks so much for making it.
LadyDivane 1 year ago
omg i remember commenting on this vid like a year and a bit ago, its still amazing and it still makes me weep like a lil girl xx
shockwaves10 1 year ago
Oh, I mean, it's not like I'm about to start sobbing or anything.
mollielie 1 year ago
OMG.... That was beautiful, made me cry!
shy522 1 year ago
what episode is 1:19?
Xspuffylover4everX 1 year ago
thanks alot! yu made me cry :'( jk i loved it but it really did me make me cry:)
LindseyLove299 1 year ago
I was planning on making my own Rose/Doctor video, but I don't need to now. This was perfect. Thank you!
Jenflower74 1 year ago
At 2.55 I started to sob. (: Amazing work!
Sahahalino 1 year ago 2
@Sahahalino right?
LindseyLove299 1 year ago
@LindseyLove299 What?
Sahahalino 1 year ago
Amazing!! very well done! :)
laurajones240 1 year ago
Brilliant editing, especially at 3:17 when the Doctor is reaching for the wall, but it looks like he's touching her face...
maryliz98 1 year ago
Ok, I have not cried over the Doctor and Rose in AGES, but now when I watched this, I cried absolute buckets!!! :'(
DreamingxInsanity 1 year ago
Does anybody know where I can find the clip from around 2.56?
DoctorWho852 1 year ago
@DoctorWho852 That's from Series Three. Err, Daleks in Mahattan, I believe. It's a two parter. It's in one of those.
Thoroughbred17 1 year ago
This video makes me tear up every time, especially at the part when the Doctor is yelling at the daleks on ;( I miss rose. She should come back for series 6 :)
DoctorWho852 1 year ago
@DoctorWho852 Yeah, that bit with the Daleks is sheer genius. Also, the dying in battle part, just a bit echoed. The creator of these videos is a legend.
Thoroughbred17 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
DoctorWho852 1 year ago
Comment removed
DoctorWho852 1 year ago
i laughed as soon as amy said "too much the time cannot erased..." never in my life would i would make that connection to her song...wierd at least it stopped me for tearing up
TheVelma16 1 year ago
Miss Rose :(
LetsGoFcukingMental 1 year ago 2
Wow.... <3 You CONTINUE to amaze me... Truly moving.
gijis02 1 year ago
i am in tears.
Alice13KissKiss 1 year ago
This is amazing. (As has been said many times before). I love the way you used clips from season one. It seems to me that when people make videos about Rose and The Doctor being in love, they only ever use season two clips.
So yeah. Once again. Amazing.
TheJediNinja 1 year ago
YESSSS!!!!!!!!!! I FOUND IT!!!!!! I FINALlY FOUND IT! I watched this video months ago, and I loved the part with the Doctor screaming at the Daleks (actually, I loved all of it, but, not the point), and I tried to favorite it, and it didn't work, so I lost it. Searching for weeks and months, I FINALLY FOUND IT AGAIN!!! Oh, this day rocks!
Thoroughbred17 1 year ago 2
Here Without You by 3 Doors Down. Someone needs to do it, and u seduff would be amazing :) I would love to but i don't have clips :(
stargazer1574 1 year ago
"There's too much that time cannot erase." That part hit me in the heart like a silver bullet. Considering what he can do as a timelord, but it's also because he's a timelord that he can't bring himself to rupture the walls of parallel universe to get to Rose. OH MAN. Tears!!! Tears everywhere. Well done on the choice of clips, the editing and the song choice!!!
borntobewilder13 1 year ago
I don't watch Dr. Who really, just in passing..don't ship The Doctor/Rose...but this video is beautiful, poignant, and moved me to tears. Magnificent job you did there! Oh yeah, I subscribed...You are an artist.
Plushgoddess 1 year ago
One person accidentally hit the dislike button.
RayzokReview 1 year ago
This is perfectly beautiful.
surykat101 1 year ago
so... beautiful... T.T
motownazn 1 year ago
BRILLIANT.
hb818283 1 year ago
This song is usually totally cliched and WAY overused, but it just works SO well with Rose and the Doctor and this video is just so perfect... it just works, really well. Rose and the Doctor.... it just breaks my heart.... :(
flyingpigs1197 1 year ago 62
So, I watched this long before I had a youtube account and favourited it... then the whole Doctor Who obsession fizzled out until I started thinking about this video today, so re-watched it (now with a youtube account).
Can I just say... WOW.
I used to watch this before I went to school every morning and as soon as I got home and, even though I over-watched it, it still has STILL managed to have a powerful effect on me.
This is pure brilliance. You got the relationship perfectly.
makeshertick 1 year ago 2
just think if that darlick did kill him then he never would have seen rose agine
faithjoy123 1 year ago
@faithjoy123 Dalek* Again*
hessian1235 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@hessian1235 thank you i have bad grammar
faithjoy123 1 year ago
@faithjoy123 *dalek
kctimelady1 1 year ago
2:56 threw 3:00 is so sad
faithjoy123 1 year ago
My favourite bits (apart from all of it :D) have to be 0:59 - 1:04 cos heroic 9 is just so darn perfect, and 3:19 when he reaches up to touch her face *sob*.
MusicMadSuperAwesome 1 year ago
I cry everytime I watch this vid, even if it's just a tear, just like when Rose had to leave in Doomsday :'( But brilliant vid :)
TheDoctorDances63 1 year ago
This made me cry, and I didn't cry during the episode...wow...so beautiful and yet so sad...great work. Great great work. Keep 'em coming seduff...
CowboyHobo 1 year ago
So sad... but at the same time, very beautiful. You did an amazing job. The clips fitted the music perfectly.
MayonakaNoRyuu 1 year ago
@jupitertronic wow, I still can't make it through that episode without wailing ;)
icedmuffinsyum94 1 year ago 32
That still makes my heart hurt. Beautiful.
KittyNightfox 1 year ago
Beautiful work. I love this video!!
NicolettaDelavega 1 year ago
Yeah this made me tear up. I've seen Doomsday so much I can actually make it through that without crying now, but this video got me. Amazing work, as always.
jupitertronic 1 year ago 3
I cry every time. Beautiful piece of work, and a powerful tribute as always.
JugglinJuggaloJuggla 1 year ago
could you tell me where scenes , 0:30, 1:24-4:35, 2:19, 2:30-2:47, please. thanks
by the way love the video, i nearly teared up.
junglegirl247 1 year ago
Saw the old version an loved that one, love this one just as much if not more. One of my favourite songs and one of my favourite tv programs. Excellently made and brilliantly thought out.
Hmm looks like one person missed the like button when they were rating it
Houndofhellia 1 year ago
Who sang this version, and also what version of My Immortal is this?
Trekkie54who 1 year ago
@Trekkie54who this version is Evanescence...I didn't know there were different covers -_-' but I don't listen to Evanescence that much...but I would guess it's a studio version
Kimmuryiel 1 year ago
What version of "My Immortal" is this, i can't seem to find it anywhere could you say what one this please
Trekkie54who 1 year ago
@Trekkie54who I'm pretty sure it's just the regular version. I own both ve